Saturday, February 25, 2012

Rasmussen: PA is a virtual tie

In contrast with another poll, Rasmussen finds the State of Pennsylvania to be a virtual tie (O +1) in a match-up between Obama and Romney:
Mitt Romney runs neck-and-neck with President Obama in the key electoral state of Pennsylvania, but Rick Santorum, a former U.S. senator from the Keystone State, trails the incumbent by six points. Most voters in the state disapprove of the job the president is doing. 

New Rasmussen Reports data shows that if Romney is the Republican presidential nominee, Obama leads 45% to 44%.
This Pennsylvania survey of 438 Likely Voters was conducted February 8-23, 2012 by Rasmussen Reports. The margin of sampling error is +/- 4.5 percentage points with a 95% level of confidence.
The very recent Franklin and Marshall poll of PA (592 RV, ±4.0%, 2/14 - 2/20) showed Obama ahead by eight points against both Romney and Santorum. 
Romney (41/33) 
Santorum (45/37)

The absence of Rasmussen's weasel-wording regarding "undecideds" and those who "prefer some other candidate" is revealing in this current poll. If Obama is ahead in a swing state, Rasmussen feels compelled to point out that it could be a tie - providing that everything goes in the Republicans' favour. 

For a conservative narrative that seems to rely heavily on the idea that "anybody" could beat Obama, conservatives seem oddly eager right now to simply settle for a tie.

PPP's average of four polls shows basically what Rasmussen found, with the latest poll (11/22/11) showing a 45/45 tie with Romney. 

If PPP is - as conservatives love to assert - some kind of unreliable, far-Left, propaganda machine, isn't it interesting that their numbers correlate to Rasmussen's? And isn't it also interesting that PPP can obtain such similar numbers without the use of a highly-secret "likely voter" screen?

The Republicans must win PA just to stay alive. If Obama wins it, he will almost certainly gain enough electoral votes to win re-election. In fact, he would gain enough EV to compensate for losing Iowa. Yet, this crucial State is a virtual toss-up - or could possibly already be in Obama's favour, depending on the pollster.

 -------------------------
Pollster ratings from fivethirtyeight.com, based on 2010 elections: 

  
 

Friday, February 24, 2012

Rasmussen polls MT for some reason

Of all the States to poll, Rasmussen has now chosen Montana. Obama is down by 7% to Romney,  and behind by four to Santorum.
The latest Rasmussen Reports statewide survey of Likely Voters in Montana shows former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney leading the president 48% to 41%. Seven percent (7%) prefer some other candidate in the race, while four percent (4%) are undecided. (To see survey question wording, click here.)
Former Pennsylvania Senator Rick Santorum picks up 45% of the vote to Obama’s 41%. Nine percent (9%) prefer some other candidate, and four percent (4%) remain undecided.
The survey of 500 Likely Voters in Montana was conducted on February 22, 2012 by Rasmussen Reports. The margin of sampling error is +/- 4.5 percentage points with a 95% level of confidence.
 Montana has only 3 electoral votes (EV). While Obama only lost the State by 3% in 2008, PPP polled MT in 2011 and found that it's not competitive any more. It's hardly a "must win" State for either Party. 

It's interesting that the usual conservative whinge isn't applied here. If one added the "undecideds" and the MoE, Obama could potentially tie or win. This would be desperate spin, of course, but that's essentially what conservatives are saying about the polling in PA and VA.

Ras Trax 2/23, Obama leads in VA and PA

Rasmussen gives Obama another eight-point lead over Santorum, and ten points over Romney nationally.
In a potential Election 2012 matchups, the president leads Rick Santorum 48% to 41%. If Mitt Romney is the Republican nominee, the president leads 49% to 39%.
And Rasmussen tries to spin down the lead for Obama in Virginia:
The latest Rasmussen Reports statewide telephone survey of Likely Virginia Voters shows Obama drawing 49% support to Romney's 43%. Five percent (5%) prefer some other candidate in the race, while three percent (3%) are undecided. (To see survey question wording, click here.)
 
With Santorum as the Republican nominee, Obama holds a 51% to 43% lead. Five percent (5%) like some other candidate, and two percent (2%) are undecided.

The survey of 500 Likely Voters in Virginia was conducted on February 21, 2012 by Rasmussen Reports. The margin of sampling error is +/- 4.5 percentage points with a 95% level of confidence.
 That would be a 6% lead over Romney, and Rasmussen is already pointing out the number of "undecideds" as an indication that the race is still kind of even. VA is one of the States that has enough EVs to put Obama over 270 (which means he wins) according to the current polling. It's a "must win" State for Republicans, and this idea that Obama's unpopularity will swing undecided voters is odd for a President who is already taking a slim majority of "likely voters".

Also, Franklin and Marshall polled PA (592 RV, ±4.0%, 2/14 - 2/20), and tried to spin down Obama's lead there:
President Obama continues to lead all of his potential Republican challengers
in Pennsylvania. Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum are the President’s strongest challengers at the moment, but both trail President Obama by about eight points.
The president’s lead over Rick Santorum is smaller than it was in January. Newt Gingrich and Ron Paul both trail the president by double digits. President Obama’s job performance and hard re-elect ratings show slight improvements in the state since January.
 Obama has gained 5 points of support since 8/11, and the number of those who "Don't Know" has dropped by 9% since then. Romney has gained 3% in that period. And this is when Obama hasn't even started campaigning yet. It comes down to 41 / 33 / 18 against Romney.

Santorum would seem to be familiar to voters in PA, yet 20% responded "Don't Know" back in 8/11 in a match-up with Obama and Santorum. Obama lead by 6 points back then. 

In these current numbers, there's a big drop in those "undecideds" down to 12%. Both have gained 6%. As Santorum has risen on the national scene, one has to wonder if maybe this is his ceiling in the State. And now Obama has a nice margin of eight points in a key State: 45 / 37 / 12 against Santorum.

PA is another one of those "must win" States for Republicans. If Obama wins Pennsylvania, he basically is ensured re-election. Republicans are left to rely on "undecideds" and the margin of error in a crucial race.

Thursday, February 23, 2012

Marist poll confirms PPP Michigan survey

A new NBC/Marist poll of Michigan (1546 RV, ±2.5% MoE, 2/19 - 2/20) shows strong leads for Obama over the Republican candidates. This confirms what PPP found less than two weeks earlier. 

Here are some of the highlights from the NBC/Marist poll: 
  • In a match-up with Romney, Obama prevails by 18 points (51 / 33 / 15). Notice that this margin is larger than the percentage of "undecideds" plus the MoE.
  • Independents break in Obama's favour by nine (43 / 34 / 23) against Romney.
  • Obama wins white voters narrowly by 4%, and voters over the age of 60 by 22%, in a Romney match-up.
  • The presidential job approval breaks 51 / 38 / 11. Whites break even 43 / 44. 
  • Paul loses to Obama by 22% in a match-up. 
  • A Santorum/Obama match-up results in Obama winning by 26%, with white voters going for Obama by 14%, and the 60+ age demographic falling Obama's way by 27%. 
  • In the Republican primary, Santorum wins 48% of the evangelical likely voters.
 -------------------------
Pollster ratings from fivethirtyeight.com, based on 2010 elections:


 

 

Gallup: Republican candidates are more unpopular than Obama

An interesting survey release from Gallup today: "Obama's Favorable Rating Higher Than GOP Candidates".

These ratings are from a Feb. 16-19 USA Today/Gallup poll and reflect a political landscape in which no more than half of Americans give any of these presidential contenders a positive rating.
 We often hear (e.g. Selzer) that Obama has lower favourable ratings than other Presidents at this stage of the election cycle. It's interesting to see that this year's Republican candidates are also much more unpopular than other years:
GOP Contenders Less Favorably Positioned Than in Previous Elections
This year's Republican presidential campaign has unfolded in a different fashion than previous years in which non-incumbent Republicans have run for their party's nomination. By February 2008 and February 2000, for example, the eventual GOP nominee was pretty well known. This year, the nominee won't be settled until after February. Perhaps as a result of these different timelines, none of the four Republican presidential contenders currently has an image as positive as those of previous non-incumbent GOP candidates in February of the election year. John McCain's national favorable rating was 56% in February 2008, George W. Bush's was 58% in 2000, and Bob Dole's was 49% in 1996.
Historical Favorability of Republican Presidential Candidates

The current Republican candidates are, at best, 17 points below the last Republican candidate -- who lost.

Sunday, February 19, 2012

Selzer: Obama loses Iowa...really

A shocking new poll from top-rated pollster Selzer & Co. shows President Obama losing Iowa. 

The poll (611 LV, MoE ±4%, 2/12 - 2/15) shows Ron Paul in the lead. Yes, Ron Paul. 

I have a very hard time believing this poll, though Selzer is a pollster with a good track record. Let's look at the results:
Paul / Obama:  49/42 
Santorum / Obama:  48/44 
Romney / Obama:  46/44 
The poll points to Obama's negative approval rating of 46/48 as some kind of supporting evidence. That's pretty much in line with the national numbers, though, and nobody is putting Obama that far back in the national match-ups. Certainly, no one else is showing Paul with any kind of lead anywhere, however slender. I also think that the author's description of Iowa as a "swing state" that is "critical to Obama’s re-election" is quite an over-statement.
No president has been re-elected with a national approval rating under 49 percent, according to Gallup polling dating to 1964. It’s a watershed mark, and about 8½ months from the election, Gallup national polling Saturday had Obama at 46 percent — underwater.
The Hawkeye State has been awash in GOP messages, and, perhaps as a consequence, it’s in a Republican mood.
We have over a year's worth of PPP polling, both nationally and in multiple States, showing remarkably contrary results to Selzer's poll. Pew Research just put Obama eight points ahead of Romney nationally. Even Rasmussen is regularly showing Obama with leads of anywhere from 4 to 8 points. Fox news showed Obama with a five-point lead over Romney. 

What really stands out here is Ann Selzer's pointed insistence that Gallup's favourabilty numbers for Obama are below 49% - which means that Obama loses, in her mind. Further, she points to the large amount of campaign ads from the Republican caucus as a major factor in her position that Obama will lose. So she isn't even pretending that this is some kind of recent development. The Iowa caucus occurred over a month before she took her survey. Selzer is essentially contending that Iowa has gone from a nearly 10-point lead for Obama to becoming a red State in just four years. And she is finding an enormous rise in voters breaking for Paul, though Paul lost the Republican caucus -- third place.

Selzer's reliance on right track / wrong track results is also questionable. Other pollsters have indicated that these lousy figures are more of a reflection of dissatisfaction with the Republican obstructionism and wingnut posing than an indictment of Obama.

On top of that, Selzer seems to be strongly implying here that Obama will lose nationally. What else can be made from her historical comparison and the importance of Gallup's magical 49% mark?

Rasmussen showed Florida breaking 47/43 in Obama's favour. Did FL not see an enormous amount of Republican campaign ads in their Republican primary? This survey also was a sample of "likely voters", so Selzer can't hide behind that. If Gallup's favourables are such a determining factor, wouldn't Florida be showing up as a sold red State? It didn't break in Obama's favour by almost ten points in 2008, like Iowa did. It broke 51/49 in Obama's favour.

There's also Ohio. Nobody is showing Republicans with a huge lead in that true "swing State", and Gallup is still below 49% for Obama in job approval. Virginia is a State that went for Obama by 6 points in 2008, and Quinnipiac showed Obama with a 4-point lead over Romney in February. But Gallup is under 49%! How can this be, if Gallup's 49% mark is so absolutely reliable of an indicator?

Nothing about her narrative is supported by any polling other than her own single poll. This idea of hers that Obama's job approval is the key is fatally flawed, because Republicans are viewed even less favourably than the President is. Even the "very favorable" and "mostly favorable" numbers that she published don't show a huge advantage for Republicans. Obama's "very favorable" 19% beats all of the Republicans except Santorum, which is a tie. Obama's "mostly favorable" figure of 27% is not substantially different from the other candidates' 30-32%.

Instead, Selzer finds Republican candidates are simply not hated as much as Obama in Iowa. Her entire narrative seems to be built on disliked Republican candidates getting more votes than an even more-disliked Obama.

And she is selling a narrative. The entire article reads like a Republican campaign ad. Her tone is one that presents this narrative as something completely obvious, rather than as a pollster publishing outlier numbers that many would be inclined to be sceptical of. I was almost surprised to find an absence of polling on Obama's birth certificate; it would have fitted right in.

Ann Selzer is sticking her neck out in a big way here. She is seeing an electorate that is far, far more concerned about "fiscal issues" than any other pollster. Maybe she is using a flaky "likely voter" screen that excludes Democrats. I consider it highly doubtful that Iowa is some kind of unique island of public opinion where Ron Paul is seen nearly a dozen points higher than in similar States. That means that, if Selzer is correct, we should see this dramatic flip in many other States. But we aren't.

Minnesota, for example, is Iowa's next-door neighbour. Odd, then, that two pollsters have found Obama comfortably ahead in three polls. Minnesota just went through a Republican caucus campaign, and SUSA didn't find this very strange dramatic shift to the Right.

The 2012 election could be the one that makes Selzer the laughing-stock of the polling world, much like Rasmussen in 2010. Rasmussen also saw a much more "fiscal issue" election and a much stronger Tea Party influence than other pollsters. He ended up with an 8-point bias in the Republican direction. 

Selzer has set up a narrative (importance of Gallup favourables, predominance of fiscal issues, Paul cross-over support, rage over the economy, etc.) that runs directly contrary to all other pollsters. She has also boxed herself in to an incredibly tight corner, because her narrative allows no "things changed" moments. The economy will not dramatically improve by the election. The country will still have staggering debt. Republicans will still be running campaign ads criticising the President. Gas prices will still be high. Obama will probably not be above 49% in Gallup's polling. Yet, these are the things she has staked her unique narrative on. If Iowa doesn't go "red" in November, Selzer is left looking like a fool. She can't even hide behind the margin of error, except in the case of Romney, and even then only in a close race.

For contrast, let's look at PPP's Iowa poll in October. 
“Obama’s unpopular in Iowa but he appears to be in position to win the state next year anyway,” said Dean Debnam, President of Public Policy Polling. “Extended exposure to the Republican field of candidates doesn’t seem to have Democrats and independents in Iowa pining to vote for the GOP next fall.”
PPP surveyed 749 Iowa voters from October 7th to 10th. The margin of error for the survey is +/-3.6%.
                              PresidentGraph
 Q1 Do you approve or disapprove of President
Barack Obama’s job performance?
Approve .......................................................... 43%
Disapprove...................................................... 52%
Not sure .......................................................... 5%

Q7 Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion
of Mitt Romney?
Favorable........................................................ 34%
Unfavorable .................................................... 52%
Not sure .......................................................... 15%

Q11 If the candidates for President next year were
Democrat Barack Obama and Republican Ron
Paul, who would you vote for?
Barack Obama................................................ 47%
Ron Paul ......................................................... 40%
Undecided....................................................... 13%

Q13 If the candidates for President next year were
Democrat Barack Obama and Republican Mitt
Romney, who would you vote for?
Barack Obama................................................ 46%
Mitt Romney.................................................... 42%
Undecided....................................................... 12%

Q14 Who did you vote for President in 2008?
John McCain................................................... 41%
Barack Obama................................................ 48%
Someone Else/Don't Remember..................... 11%

Q5 Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion
of Ron Paul?
Favorable........................................................ 27%
Unfavorable .................................................... 55%
Not sure .......................................................... 19%
  • PPP shows a lower job approval rating than Gallup did at the time. Yet Obama prevails by four points over Romney, and beats Paul by seven.
  • PPP's sample shows a more Republican lean than in the actual 2008 election results, with McCain polling about 3 points better than he actually did. Any idea that the sample was skewed pro-Democrat should be dismissed by that fact.
  • No big support for Paul was noted. In fact, Paul was underwater 2-1. Weird, huh?
  • Gosh, Romney is even less popular than the 'despised' Obama. Go figure.
  • PPP didn't find this weird phenomena of Republican campaign ads turning Iowa into a "red" State.
  • Paul showed about the same "cross-over support" as most of the other Republican candidates.
Okay, a four-point lead for Obama isn't some kind solid edge, but it's pretty different than what Selzer is seeing. Both polls are land-line-only. Is Selzer really going to point to her "likely voter" screen as the defining difference?

I'm strongly inclined to think that Selzer is way off base here. She seems to have "gone wingnut", or perhaps seeks to get more business polling for Republicans. It's hard to see this as something other than an ideologically-motivated push-back on the mass of polls showing Obama doing well, but she is kind of restricted to pushing back in Iowa. She has put her reputation on the line, and embraced a faded 2010-style mindset that really no longer seems relevant. She seems to have tapped into a wacky sample, but failed to have the sense to evaluate it.


I will definitely follow up on this as more polling is done of Iowa, and I expect to be merciless on Selzer in November if these numbers of hers aren't backed up by the election results. 


How can she get out of this corner she has painted herself into? 

If Ron Paul isn't on the ballot, she can claim that her voters were dis-enchanted or discouraged. But this is a sample of likely voters. Either they are likely to vote, or they aren't. Either way, she would have a hard time trying to sell the idea that a whole lot of Ron Paul voters went over to Obama. Because he's so disliked in these survey results. And because everything else (Gallup, right/wrong track, debt, etc.) will still be there.


If it's a real close race (like a recount) and Santorum is the candidate, she can claim margin of error. This would sound a bit pathetic coming from someone with Selzer's reputation, though. Even a narrow two-point victory for Obama would discredit her.


If Romney is the candidate, and Obama wins by any more than two points, she will look stupid and biased. People will point to this poll for the next eight years whenever her name comes up. 


The big problem for Selzer in November will be this wingnut narrative she has presented as obvious and self-evident. As I've said, all of these things that she points to now will very likely still be there in November. Even if Obama loses Iowa, but wins nationally, Selzer will look like a fool because of this narrative that sounds like Gingrich on a bender. As goes the Republican Party, so goes Selzer.

Saturday, February 18, 2012

China border troubles continue

China has been making recent public remarks about the state of negotiations with India over the disputed border.
From The Hindu:
A month after India and China held the fifteenth round of border talks, a commentary in a Chinese newspaper has questioned India's claims on Kashmir and asserted that the only dispute was over the status of Arunachal Pradesh.
An article in the Communist Party-run Jiefang Daily, or Liberation Daily newspaper said the disputed western section of the border — including the Aksai Chin region which is now under China's control — was not part of the dispute, underscoring how far apart both countries' positions remained even after 15 rounds of negotiations.
The commentary said: “The Indian side believes that the border dispute between China and India covers not only the eastern region of 90,000 sq km but also the western region of 30,000 sq km and the western region is India's too. This wrong argument, which totally disregards the history, still has supporters in India.”
The article, written by an India scholar in the Shanghai Institute of International Studies, Wu Yongnian, was the first Chinese reaction to last month's border talks, and it underscored a hardening in China's position over the western section over recent years, analysts and officials said.
In New Delhi last month, National Security Adviser Shivshankar Menon and Chinese State Councillor Dai Bingguo, the two Special Representatives, discussed a framework for the settlement of disputes in all three sectors — western, middle and eastern. This was in keeping with the 2005 agreement on Political Parameters and Guiding Principles, which marked the ending of the first of three stages of negotiations.
According to Article III of the agreement, the boundary settlement would be “final, covering all sectors of the India-China boundary.”
 China appears to want to split up the various border disputes, and the talks are not going well, despite public shows of optimism.

The Times of India quotes China Daily:
"The first issue is the China-India border negotiation. China and India have held 15 meetings of special representatives for the border issue.
"Although the meetings have made many positive achievements, it is still far away from reaching a fair, just and reasonable agreement," the write up in the opinion page said.
The main barrier still comes from the Indian side as Indian media insist that the border line between China and India should be based on the " McMahon Line" left by British colonists, it said also India believes that the border dispute between the two countries covers not only the eastern region of 90,000 square km but also 30,000 sq km in the western region.
"This wrong argument, which totally disregards the history, still has supporters in India," it said.
Yet another reason that delaying the agreement was India's multi-party political system as well its society which is extremely complicated, it said.
"Various Indian political parties have different understandings on the China-India border issue, and therefore, it is hard for them to reach an agreement on the issue," it said.
It seems obvious that, in a democracy such as India, you are not going to have the consensus of opinion that you find in China.
 China has made 'concessions' with Tajikistan, Kazakhstan, and Kyrgyzstan in border talks previously. But there seems to be a pattern of China making huge (and unreasonable) demands, while settling for far less:
In the 1990s, China began negotiating settlements with these countries. Border agreements with Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan were reached in 1996 and 1998 respectively. Border talks with Tajikistan were delayed by the civil war there. However, talks gathered momentum in the late 1990s and an agreement was reached in 2002. It was this agreement that was ratified recently.

Analysts have drawn attention to the territorial concessions that China extended to resolve its many disputes. Of its 23 territorial disputes active since 1949, China offered "substantial compromises" in 17, usually agreeing "to accept less than half of the territory being disputed," M Taylor Fravel, associate professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, pointed out in the article "Regime Insecurity and International Cooperation: Explaining China's Compromises in Territorial Disputes," published in the journal International Security.

However, there is more to it than meets the eye. The territorial concessions that China is believed to have made are not quite as substantial as they appear to be. Srikanth Kondapalli, a China expert at the Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi pointed out that China's strategy of stepping up territorial claims and then settling for less has enabled it to appear to be making a major territorial concession to reach a border resolution agreement. In several disputes, "whether China actually gave up territory or made a substantial concession is a debatable question," he told Asia Times Online.
 Chinese media has built up an anti-Indian sentiment, and the media is completely State-controlled. I outlined some of this in a previous post. Much of it is jingoistic, inclined toward "teaching India a lesson". 

India, for its part, has also stirred up resentments in the media over the border conflict.
The shame of a lost border war left a long tradition of anti-Chinese slant in Indian newspapers, to the point where it doesn’t even seem like an aberration. But for some years now, the tone of a large section of the media has turned decidedly strident, a condition the country’s leading Outlook magazine once diagnosed as "Sinositis". Where once the China reportage gave the impression that for some in the media the war never quite ended, now one gets the sense that the infected are, in fact, itching for another round. Brace yourself for more malignant stuff this year, which marks the 50th anniversary of the war.

Many of the China-bashing stories doing the rounds in Indian papers are a mixture of reflexive phobia, envy, anxiety and great-game bluster, with headlines such as Wary of China moves, India, US & Japan plan talks; As China looms, US tells India to lead Asia; etc. Some are products of the occasional public spats on issues such as territorial rights, and are appropriately combative (Manmohan to Wen: Back off on South China Sea). And, when they are not openly hawkish and baying for blood (With China in mind, India tests new-generation Agni missile with high 'kill efficiency', screams a November headline), they are passive aggressive at the minimum, often betraying a degree of inferiority complex. The subheading to another November story headlined East Asia meet to have China tilt read INDIA STAND: Can't check them, will wait and watch. And that's not even an editorial!

Then there are the Chinese "incursions" stories - the most potent, and the fountainhead, of all Sinoscare media motifs in India. These stories, liberally peppered with alarmist words like "aggression", "transgression", "encroachment", and the like, follow a familiar pattern. "Sources", mostly unnamed, tell a paper or a TV channel how Chinese forces have been intruding into Indian territory; a comparison with similar intrusions in previous years establish how the Chinese menace is rising; followed by accounts of Chinese military build-up.
 The "McMahon line" is the only recognised border, and China has acceded to it in the case of Myanmar (its ally). In the cases of India and Bhutan, however, it is considered unreasonable: 

The Sino-Indian border dispute arose out of the Chinese occupation of Tibet. China's refusal to grant internal autonomy to Tibet has kept the pot boiling in Tibet and the Chinese view Indian asylum to the Dalai Lama with suspicion. This, despite the fact that India has accepted Tibet as part of China.

The Chinese have kept the border 'unsettled' so as to keep it as a ready excuse to intervene in the affairs of the Indian subcontinent. But there is a larger Chinese design at work here. 

It showed this intent in 1965 though not during the 1971 Indo-Pakistan conflict due to the erstwhile Soviet Union checkmating it on the Amur-Ussuri border.

Initially, the dispute was over the Aksai Chin area and the Chinese strategic road passing through it connecting Sinkiang with Tibet, a military necessity. Its claims over Arunachal Pradesh, initially at least, were seen as a bargaining chip.

It is noteworthy that the McMahon Line -- that China refuses to accept in Arunachal Pradesh -- has been accepted as the boundary with Myanmar. This clearly shows Chinese duplicity.
 When China talks about "securing Tibet", it means something very different than what the rest of the world considers to be "Tibet". They define Arunachal Pradesh as "South Tibet", and even include Bhutan as part of "Tibet".

Burma and Bhutan establish dipomatic ties...finally

From Bernama:
YANGON, Feb 15 (Bernama) -- Myanmar has established diplomatic ties with two more countries -- Malawi and Bhutan at ambassadorial level in the start of 2012, according to official sources from Nay Pyi Taw Wednesday.

Two joint communiques on the establishment were respectively signed between Myanmar's Ambassador and the High Commissioner of Malawi in New Delhi on Jan 30 and between Permanent Representative of Myanmar to the United Nations and his Bhutan counterpart in New York on Feb 1, Xinhua news agency reported.

The diplomatic establishment with Malawi and Bhutan has brought the total number of countries in the world with which Myanmar has such links to 105 and 106 since it regained independence in 1948.
Burma (now called Myanmar) and Bhutan are neighbours, and finally have diplomatic relations. 
Myanmar is strongly supported by China, who threatens to annex Bhutan.

Bolivia blames Chile for stalled coastal acces negotiations

From The Santiago Times:
Bolivian Deputy Foreign Minister Juan Carlos Alurralde expressed harsh sentiments toward Chilean President Sebastián Piñera on Wednesday, comparing him unfavorably to former President Michelle Bachelet. The same day, American actor Sean Penn called for Chile to show more “solidarity” toward its Andean neighbor while meeting with the Bolivian President Evo Morales.
-------
The main dispute between Chile and Bolivia has its origins in the 1879 war of the Pacific in which Bolivia lost its coastal territory to Chile, making it a landlocked country. Desperate for access to the sea, Morales made renegotiating maritime access with Chile a cornerstone of his foreign policy.

In 2006, Morales and Bachelet agreed on a 13-point working plan to determine bilateral policy between the two countries. One point was the Bolivian petition for access to the Pacific Ocean.

Shortly after his election in 2010, Piñera created a bilateral body to address this maritime demand, but the body last met in February 2011. Then in March 2011, Morales announced his intention to bring the dispute to the UN’s International Court of Justice (ICJ) at The Hague, due to the absence of “useful, feasible, and practical” solutions from the negotiations with Chile.
 After Bachelet left office, these negotiations stalled, with both sides waiting for the other to make the first move. Bachelet was seen as more sympathetic to the more-leftist Morales, but the office of President is term-limited in Chile. Piñera has little incentive to make Morales look good by moving these talks forward, and both sides see this as an issue of nationalism. Bolivia needs little more than a strip of land to construct a highway and rail line. Morales, for his part, stands little chance of prevailing in the ICJ over a war that was fought more than 130 years ago.

Ras Trax 2/18, Rasmussen polls the obvious

Today's Rasmussen daily tracker continues Scotty's furtive slide away from his 1/28/11 poll showing Obama losing to a generic Republican by six points. In fact, Obama now leads by eight points in Rasmussen's whimsical polling.
In a potential Election 2012 matchup, the president posts a 49% to 41% lead over Romney.  If Santorum is the Republican nominee, the president leads 48% to 40%.
That's a lead that is outside of the MoE. How does Rasmussen's "likely voter" survey show the President's approval? Let's see: 
Overall, 50% of voters say they at least somewhat approve of the president's job performance. Forty-nine percent (49%) at least somewhat disapprove. 
Of that 49% who disapprove, 40% is "strong disapproval". If this is a "likely voter" sample, why does "strong approval" matter? Obama clearly attracts 21% of likely voters over his 28% "strong approval" rating. Are Rasmussen's "likely voters" likely to vote or aren't they? 

Meanwhile, we continue to see the two Republican front-runners stuck with nothing more than Rasmussen's partisan angry base of 40% "strong disapproval" for Obama. Apparently, 9% of the "likely voters" in the country dislike Obama, but not enough to actually vote for one of the Republican candidates. That really says something about Rasmussen's narrative, doesn't it?

Once again, we see the Republican candidates stuck with numbers that are only 5 or 6% higher than Rasmussen's Party self-identification for Republicans. Meanwhile, Obama draws 15% more likely voters than the percentage that identify as Democrats in Rasmussen-land. 

But Rasmussen tells us that 46% of likely voters consider the Democratic Party agenda to be "extreme". It's very odd that the Republican candidates can't seem to pick up at least that 46%, isn't it? How could such an "extreme" candidate as Obama get 50% job approval if 46% consider him to be "extreme"? Something isn't adding up in Scotty's narrative machine.

In State polling, Rasmussen bravely sticks his neck out and tells the world that California just might go for Obama after all:
President Obama leads both Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum by more than 20 points in California, as nearly six-out-of-10 voters approve of the way he's handling his job.
 That's a big surprise, isn't it? I'm starting to think that Utah might go Republican, too. Of course, I'll hold off judgement until Rasmussen polls that State. Of all the States to poll, why CA?

PPP: "Obama Leading Republicans Big in Michigan"

Conservatives can't seem to help themselves when it comes to misinterpreting polling results. It's far too common for them to point to primary polling as an indication of a general election outcome.

In spite of the recent 'excitement' over Santorum's rise in the primary polling for Michigan, Public Policy Polling just released new survey results that show Obama winning the State handily. (560 RV, +/- 4.14% MoE, 2/10-2/12)

                    PresidentGraph
President Obama leads all Republican challengers in Michigan by double digits, while Republicans are suffering from high unfavorability ratings among voters. Obama leads Mitt Romney by 16 points (54-38), leads Newt Gingrich by 22 points (56-34), leads Rick Santorum by 11 points (50-39) and leads Ron Paul by 18 points (52-34). Last July, we found that Obama led Romney by just 5 points (47-42).
Obama’s job approval rating in Michigan stands at 52% approval and 44% disapproval, an improvement from last July when Obama was at 50/46. 53% of voters say that Barack Obama’s leadership has been “good for Michigan’s economy” while 41% think it’s been
bad.
Republican presidential candidates are suffering from horrific favorability ratings in Michigan – less than one-third of voters have favorable opinions of Mitt Romney (29/58), Newt Gingrich (21/66) or Ron Paul (31/54). Only Rick Santorum is liked by more than one-third of voters and disliked by less than half of voters (40/47).
While the Republican narrative is that Obama is some kind of hated figure, and "anybody" could beat him, we see that he is much more liked than any of the Republican candidates.

If the most liked Republican (Santorum) only has 40% of Michigan registered voters indicating a favourable opinion of him, what does that say about the "hated" Obama showing 52% approval? Doesn't it mean that Republicans are more "hated" than Obama? How does this support the idea that the electorate would vote for "anybody but Obama"? More importantly, how does this support the idea that voters won't turn out for the more popular Obama, but they will show up to vote for the less popular Republican?

Previously, I did a preliminary assessment of the likely electoral vote totals from States that Obama led in polling. Michigan has 17 EV, and they look even more likely to go to Obama than they did when that post was written. Obama has more than doubled his lead over the past seven months in the State. 

This poll also undermines the Republican narrative that a bad economy will hurt Obama. We have a bad economy right now, and Obama is running away with a State that was hard hit in the downturn. A slight majority of registered voters are even saying that Obama has been “good for Michigan’s economy”. Isn't it weird how the number of those disapproving of Obama's impact on the Michigan economy seems to be right around the number of those voting for and (approving of) Republican candidates? 
It also seems to dovetail with Rasmussen's perpetual 40% that "Strongly Disapprove" of Obama.

You could look at these numbers and say that Obama has a solid 40% of Michigan voters firmly against him. 

I'd concede that readily. But that number has not grown over the past seven months, while the number supporting Obama against Romney has grown... by 7 points. Obama is even over the putatively magical 50% mark when matched up with Romney in Michigan. 

Seven months ago, conservatives were pointing to the President's 5-point lead in Michigan and saying that it was within the MoE, and that it would come down as the general electorate saw more of Romney in the primary campaigns. Well, the race is no longer within the MoE, and those numbers for Romney have slightly declined, while Obama's have gone up. Are we surprised that conservatives are wrong? They are living in a bubble world in which it is still 2010. 

Let's examine the cross-tabs in this survey:
  • Santorum, the 'most popular' Republican candidate, only gets a 67% favourable opinion among those who voted for McCain in 2008. That's the Republican base, folks. 
  • In a match-up with Obama, Santorum only draws 78% of McCain voters, while Obama draws 82% of those who voted for him in 2008. And Santorum is the one who does the best in this metric.
  • Moderates break more than 3-1 against Romney, and 60/21 against Santorum. There's that "extreme" agenda showing up again. 
  • Santorum breaks positively 17 / 68 / 15 against Obama among those who self-identify as "somewhat conservative", and Santorum does the best of all the Republicans in this metric as well. Only 68% of a crucial Republican base demographic that is 21% of the electorate? Does that sound like enthusiasm?
  • Obama wins women voters by a full 30% over Romney (61/31), while Santorum "only" loses women voters by 25 points. Romney breaks even with men, while Santorum carries them by a mere 5%. With males turning out to be a crucial base demographic for Republicans, this breakdown is not encouraging.
  • Romney breaks strongly negative in favourable opinion with Independents (32/52), while Santorum breaks even (43/44). In match-ups with Obama, however, Obama wins Independents by 12 over Romney and six over Santorum. Favourable opinions do not seem to have a strong bearing on the match-up results here.
  • Obama wins white voters by 7 points over Romney (wow!) in a match-up, while whites essentially break even with Santorum (45/43, O+2). That's another crucial Republican base demographic.
  • In favourable opinion, Romney loses voters aged 65+ by 23 points (34/57), with Santorum settling for an even break at 44/42. Match-ups are different once again, though. Voters aged 65+ go for Obama over Romney by 7 points, with Santorum narrowly losing them by 4. Another crucial Republican demographic fails to line up with the Party.
  • Obama strongly prevails in match-ups with the 18-29 age demographic. He beats both Santorum and Romney by at least 2-1. Romney loses these voters 66/26, and Santorum loses them 60/30. Ron Paul, with his much flaunted "youth vote appeal" loses this age group 62/26 over Obama.
 With Republican candidates showing relatively poorly with their own base in these match-ups, it really shows the inherent weakness in trying to run a scare campaign against Obama. We've already had at least four years (including the 2008 campaign) of virtually non-stop fear-mongering by the Right against the President. How will more of the same turn the tide? Republicans have a solid base of 40% right now, and they can't win with that. Making that solid 40% even more solid isn't going to do them any good. 

At least in Michigan, it seems clear that Obama isn't despised, he isn't scary, and he isn't a "failed President". These are the points most likely to be hammered on in the Republican primary, and they seem to only resonate with that 40% Republican base.

 -------------------------
Pollster ratings from fivethirtyeight.com, based on 2010 elections:


  
 

Ras Trax 2/17, doubles down on Catholic poll

Another day, another Rasmussen tracker showing Obama ahead - but within the margin of error (MoE). Plenty of room for Ras to wiggle around, just the way he likes it.
In a potential Election 2012 matchup, the president posts a 48% to 42% lead over former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney.  If former U.S. Senator Rick Santorum is the Republican nominee, the president leads 47% to 41%.
A six-point lead for Obama over either Republican front-runner looks good, but the MoE is 3 points on either side: take 3 points off Obama and add three points to Romney / Santorum, and you get an even break. Of course, this would mean that Rasmussen's sampling, "likely voter" screen, and 'random' panel are heavily skewed toward Republicans. Nobody that still believes in Rasmussen would care about that, though. And, by keeping the level of "undecideds" well above the MoE and the lead, Rasmussen allows plenty of room for his "things changed" moments.

But if we compare apples-to-apples, this tracker shows how flimsy the Republican narrative really is. Let's look at Rasmussen's own party ID (PID) breakdown:
Currently, the baseline targets for the adult population are 34.7% Republicans, 33.6% Democrats, and 31.8% unaffiliated. Likely voter samples typically show a slightly larger advantage for the Republicans.
Okay, Ras doesn't say how large the "slightly larger advantage" is for Republicans is in his LV screen. Let's assume 2%, which is probably generous.

Romney's 42% subtracted from Rasmussen's figures for self-identified Republicans (adjusted for his LV screen) is 5.3%. That means that Romney is currently drawing a bit over 5% outside of his Party.

Obama's 48% subtracted from Rasmussen's 33.6% figure for self-identified Democrats is 14.4%. Remember, these are Rasmussen's "likely voters", so (if you take Rasmussen seriously) you can't say that those Obama supporters won't turn out. That means that Obama is more likely (right now) to win over Independents.

Obama also is drawing 48% job performance approval, strongly suggesting that his support in the match-up is firm. Again, these are "likely voters", so you can't claim that those who only "somewhat approve" of Obama won't turn out.

Romney's 42% contrasts with Rasmussen's 52% disapproval of Obama. This means that 10% of those who disapprove of Obama aren't currently willing to commit to the Republicans. In fact, Romney's 42% split is not much larger than the 40% that Rasmussen shows as "Strong Disapproval" of Obama.

For a Party that seems to be relying on a national mood of "Anybody But Obama", this doesn't look very good. Likely voters that disapprove of Obama aren't moving toward "anybody" but him. If Obama's "Strong Approval" is at 26%, what does it say when he draws 48% in a match-up? Obama draws 22% outside of his strong supporters, and Romney draws only 2% outside of Obama's strongest detractors.

Again, these are "likely voters". Doesn't his show how meaningless the entire "Strong" approval/disapproval really is? You can't say that only 26% of voters will actually turn out for Obama, and simultaneously say that 48% of likely voters will break for him. Either the value of "Strong Approval" is highly over-rated, or Rasmussen's "likely voter" screen needs to filter out 20%+ more people.

These extrapolations all involve Rasmussen's own numbers. They seem to indict the premise that Rasmussen's "likely voter" screen is built on: that Democrats won't vote. And it shows that Obama's solid base is 8 points higher than the Republicans' solid base. This does not support a narrative of an unpopular President that only draws his most ardent supporters to the polls.

In further Rasmussen stupidity, Scotty has doubled down on his previous survey results indicating that that the "religious freedom" (contraception) issue will cost Obama Catholic support.
In his 2/14 poll, Rasmussen says this:
A new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey finds that 59% of likely Catholic voters nationwide at least somewhat disapprove of the president’s job performance, while 40% at least somewhat approve. But the passion’s on the side of those who don’t like the job he’s doing: 44% Strongly Disapprove versus 19% who Strongly Approve.
Okay, so we see the "strong" approve / disapprove issue being pulled out again. But we are already dealing with "likely voters" here. Who cares about "the passion"? You can't vote with an exclamation point.

But how does this poll show that the White House position on the birth control controversy has cost Obama votes with Catholics? Rasmussen himself concludes:
While the president’s overall job approval ratings have improved over the past couple of months, they have remained steady among Catholics.
"Remained steady"? So did Catholic support drop off? No. 
But further:
Fifty-four percent (54%) of Catholics voted for Obama in November 2008. However, Republican hopeful Mitt Romney currently leads the president among Catholic voters by a 52% to 35% margin.
So can an issue that only appeared two weeks ago (at best) be ascribed to a drop over nearly four years? And Romney leaves 7% of those "disapproving" Catholics on the table in a match-up with Obama (59-52). Hell, Obama's even drawing 16% above his "strong approval" in a match-up (35-19). Even if you take this poll seriously, it doesn't show any drop in support due to the recent controversy.

And should we even take this poll seriously? Other pollsters dramatically differ with Rasmussen on the issue:
  • Gallup: "An average of 46% of Catholics approved of the job Obama was doing as president last week, compared with 49% the prior week, a change within the margin of sampling error."
  • CBS/NYT:  "The number is similar among self-professed Catholics surveyed: 61 percent said they support the Obama administration's rule, while 32 percent oppose it"
  • PPP:  "We did an over sample of almost 400 Catholics and found that they support the benefit overall, 53-44, and oppose an exception for Catholic hospitals and universities, 53-45. The Bishops really are not speaking for Catholics as a whole on this issue."
Want more dumb from Rasmussen? Look at this:
Sixty-one percent (61%) of Evangelical Christians and 52% of other Protestants also at least somewhat disapprove of the job Obama is doing in the White House.
 Wow, the Republican base doesn't like Obama! Shocking news. This is the usual desperate spin from the Right that we saw in 2008: Republicans won't vote for Obama, so he can't win. And, at the time of this survey, Rasmussen showed 50% (likely voters, mind you) at least "somewhat approving" of Obama. That kind of puts the "faith gap" numbers into perspective.
This faith gap was evident in December, well before the current dispute between the Obama Administration and religious leaders. Yet while the president’s overall job approval ratings have gone up slightly in recent weeks as perceptions of the economy have begun to improve, there’s been little or no change in attitude among religious groups. 
So the people who disliked him before still don't like him, and that somehow is supposed to mean that this new position is going to cost Obama votes? At best, it shows that the Republican base is more resistant to the improvement in Obama's "favourables" than the general electorate. Big deal.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Ras Trax 2/14, PPP national

Today's journey into the world of Rasmussen brings us the hint of old Scotty's "things changed" narrative. He seems to be insinuating that Romney's negative campaigning in FL is the "event" that "changed" the race. In Rasmussen's (fixed and bogus) polling, Romney was tied before FL. Now he is seven points down on Obama. Santorum, in yet another dizzying shift, is down nine in a match-up with Obama. Weird how Santorum was a point ahead of the President (in Rasmussen's fixed figures) when it was convenient to boost Santorum's "electability" narrative. It's also strange how Romney showed a six-point lead in December (in Rasmussen's fixed figures), but now is behind by seven in the same match-up against the President.
In a potential Election 2012 matchup, the president posts a 49% to 42% lead over former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney.  The numbers are very similar if former U.S. Senator Rick Santorum is the Republican nominee. In that case, the president leads 49% to 41%. Among unaffiliated voters, the president leads Romney by 10 and Santorum by 16.
One week before the Florida primary, Romney and Obama were tied. In the week leading up to that event, Romney fell behind by margins ranging from two to six points. The GOP hopeful has fallen further behind since that time. Over the past week, he has trailed the president by margins ranging from four to ten points (see tracking history for all candidates).
Overall, 51% of voters say they at least somewhat approve of the president's job performance. Forty-seven percent (47%) at least somewhat disapprove. 
Also, Obama is back above 50% in approval, which is also strange. Rasmussen just told us that 50% of likely voters were pissed off at Obama over the Catholic / birth control issue.
Gallup just released a poll that says even Catholics themselves aren't that upset about the issue: 

              

gallup poll
PRINCETON, NJ -- Catholics' views of President Obama were little changed during a week in which the administration battled publicly with Catholic leaders over whether church-affiliated employers should have to pay for contraception as part of their employees' health plans. An average of 46% of Catholics approved of the job Obama was doing as president last week, compared with 49% the prior week, a change within the margin of sampling error.
And the latest CBS/NYT poll fails to back up old Scotty Rasmussen:


61 percent think religious employers should be required to cover contraception, 31 say
                          
The number is similar among self-professed Catholics surveyed: 61 percent said they support the Obama administration's rule, while 32 percent oppose it.
Sounds like a losing issue for Republicans. PPP also polled the issue, and didn't find Rasmussen's 50% opposed. Oh, yeah: "likely voters". Sure. 

Also in polling, PPP released their new national survey. (1200 RV, 2/9-2/12, MoE +/- 2.8%)
Romney trails 49-42, down two points from 49-44 last month. Santorum has improved three points on the margin from a 50-42 deficit to only 49-44 now. President Obama has inched up three points versus Ron Paul (from 47-42 to 49-41), and five over Newt Gingrich (from 49-42 to 52-40). Obama leads Paul by one, Santorum by four, Romney by nine, and Gingrich by 19 points with independents. Santorum is the strongest of the Republicans with the GOP, but still loses 12% of them to Obama, while Obama cedes only 8-11% of his party versus any opponent.
Q13 Do you think the economy is improving, getting
worse, or staying about the same?
Improving........................................................ 41%
Getting worse.................................................. 31%
Staying about the same .................................. 27%
Not sure .......................................................... 1%
  •  In a match-up with Obama, Santorum loses females 53/40 and breaks even with men 46/48. Romney is pretty much the same, but Obama edges out men 46/43 in that case.
  • Gender seems to make no difference on the question about the economy improving.
  • Ron Paul wins the white vote 48/40/12 in a match-up with Obama. Romney wins them 50/41/9. Santorum does best with whites: 52/41/ 7. That's getting into interesting territory with Santorum. If he pulls half of the undecided whites, he moves up to nearly 55%. This is what McCain got, but it's still higher than I would like to see.
  • Paul loses the 18-29 demographic to Obama 56/35/10. Even if he wins all of the undecideds, he loses that age group. So much for the Paul "youth vote" narrative. Romney does even worse with the demographic: 59/29/13. And Santorum is dismal at 63/29/8.
  • In a match-up with Obama, Santorum wins the 65+ age demographic by eight: 42/50/8. Romney does a bit worse at 43/46/11.
We can only wonder if Santorum's numbers will go down as voters become more familiar with him. 
Q4 Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion
of Rick Santorum?
Favorable........................................................ 39%
Unfavorable .................................................... 46%
Not sure .......................................................... 15%