Tuesday, January 31, 2012

China stonewalling Bhutan on border talks

This has been a kind of one-sided negotiation. Now the Chinese are building permanent structures on Bhutanese territory, but it's just for soldiers, so don't worry.
From Kuensel Online:

Many talks, little progress

Opposition leader suggests need for the government to change its strategy
Bhutan-China Border An issue dating more than 50 years, which, despite 19 rounds of talks, yielded little in return.

This was the feeling among some Parliament members, following foreign minister in-charge Khandu Wangchuk’s update to the house on the issue of Bhutan-China border.
Lyonpo Khandu Wangchuk informed the members that, with regards to the boundary to the south, the government was able to not just discuss in great detail the boundary issues with the neighbour to the south, but they had it settled. He said, however, the same could not be said about the progress vis-a-vis the boundary discussions with the neighbour to the north.
He said the boundary talks with the Chinese government began since 1984, and the country was still pushing towards reaching a decision.

“It’s been 28 years since serious discussions began,” he said. “We’ve had about 19 discussions so far, the last being held in the beginning of 2010 at Thimphu.”
Lyonpo Khandu Wangchuk was responding to the question the Haa parliamentarian Ugyen Tenzin raised, on how the government was progressing in the border discussion with China.
Ugyen Tenzin said the earlier temporary tents Chinese border security pitched during winters, which they bundled up in summers, is being replaced with permanent houses being built along the borders.
“This is a major cause of concern for the people of not just Haa but of the nation,” he said, adding the other issue was of the pastureland at Bjagana being taken into their boundary.
Lyonpo Khandu Wangchuk said the government was just as deeply concerned, and was constantly investigating the northern boundary issue.
Having learnt about the permanent houses being built along the borders, he informed the members that, on October 11,  2011, the Bhutanese government wrote a letter to the Chinese ambassador at Delhi about it and the subsequent concerns it generated in the Bhutanese government.
“In the letter we said the action was in violation of the Guiding Principles agreed on between the two governments in 1998,” he said, adding that an agreement on The Maintenance of Peace and Tranquillity in the Bhutan-China Border Areas was also signed in 1998.
Within 11 days, on October 12, 2011, he said the Chinese government replied, saying they had conducted an investigation into the issue.
“They said,” Lyonpo informed the members, “the permanent houses were built for the border security personnel, so they would be saved the trouble of having to  pitch camps and pack them every year.”
One crucial aspect contained in the letter, he said, was that the Chinese government committed to respect and work in accordance with the agreements drawn between the two nations.
On November 15 and 16 last year the expert survey team from the two nations met to resolve differences over border land of Doklam, Charithang, Sinchulumpa and Dramana.
Despite several discussions, he said they could not reach an agreement, following which the two sides decided to continue the discussion in 2012 at Bangkok, Thailand.
Wangduephodrang Parliament representative Passang Thrinlee said the minister’s update on the Bhutan-China border contained both elements of concern and comfort.

“We hope the Chinese government will consider the plight of a small nation in relation to its boundary,” he said. “We pray they help speed up resolving the boundary issues.”
Opposition leader Tshering Tobgay said although the government had done a fair bit on its part to resolve the border dispute with China, it was time they considered changing the strategy to negotiate.
That the government has 19 rounds of peaceful discussions, drew up guiding principles, while the dialogues dragged on, and people of the two nations continuing to maintain the peace on either sides, he said, were comforting then.
“Today, that is not enough,” he said. “My earnest request to the government is to think up an alternative strategy.”
Lyonpo Khandu Wangchuk welcomed any alternative strategy  members of the Parliament might have in mind, and said the agreements that existed between the two nations, at the moment, served the purpose when the issue remained unresolved.
“There were issues of roads being built along the border between the two nations in the past,” he said, adding that, when the government reminded them it was in breach of the existing agreement between the two nations, they stopped immediately. “They even settled any misunderstandings between peoples of the two nations.”
By Samten Wangchuk

Monday, January 30, 2012

More good news from Rasmussen

Rasmussen doesn't really allow links to his survey results. The link just goes to a page where the old polling results are replaced by more current data, so I can't link to the current Generic Congressional Ballot (GCB) results. You'll have to trust me, or go to Pollster.

But here is the text that I am allowed to see, since I am a non-subscriber:

Monday, January 30, 2012
For the first time in roughly two-and-a-half years, Democrats lead Republicans on the Generic Congressional Ballot, this time for the week ending Sunday, Jan. 29.
A new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey finds that 41% of Likely U.S. Voters would vote for the Democrat in their district’s congressional race if the election were held today, while 40% would choose the Republican instead.
Date   Dem   GOP
01-29-12   41%   40%
01-22-12   39%   42%
01-15-12   38%   44%
01-08-12   38%   44%
12-30-11   38%   43%
12-22-11   40%   43%
12-18-11   40%   43%
12-11-11   39%   42%
12-04-11   38%   43%
Notice that, since December, Rasmussen has showed at least a three-point lead for Republicans on the GCB. There was a tie in early November, but otherwise his surveys have showed Republicans favoured to win House races. The freshman Republicans who entered the House in 2010 by riding the Tea Party are not popular.

Also, Gallup is showing the Obama / Romney match-up to be a tie.
1/27-28/12; 907 registered voters, 4% margin of error

National
2012 President
48% Obama (D), 48% Romney (R)
53% Obama (D), 41% Gingrich (R)
49% Obama (D), 46% Paul (R)
51% Obama (D), 43% Santorum (R)

A tie at this point from Gallup is actually pretty good, because a lot of pollsters are showing Obama with a lead. Voters (outside of the Republican base) aren't liking what they are seeing in the Republican primaries. This has been a bad introduction to Romney for most people. It's still early and a lot can happen, but most of the things that could go wrong are on the Republican side.

The next PPP national (DKos/SEIU) poll should be interesting.

Sunday, January 29, 2012

Minnesota's 8th CD now a "tossup"

Charlie Cook changed the status of MN-8 from "Lean Republican" to "Tossup" in his latest ratings.

This means trouble for freshman Tea Party Rep. Chip Cravaack. Already in a D+3 district, and only winning election by 1% (48/47) - 4400 votes, he was not a favourite for re-election. He's accomplished nothing for his district, and spent most of his time in NH when not in DC.

Given the latest polling by PPP in MN that shows strong "buyer's remorse" over electing Republicans to the State Legislature, I don't see a strong "incumbent advantage" for Cravaack. His strong backing of Bachmann hasn't won over Independents, as the same polling shows that Bachmann is very unpopular outside of her narrow 16% "very conservative" base and gerrymandered district.

His big issue, aside from rabid anti-choice positions, was the Clean Water Act, and most particularly H.R 5088. This was the legislation introduced by Oberstar that Cravaack railed against. Cravaack can claim a small victory by tying it up in committee, but that was merely a holding action. That fight is over, and he can't claim to have done anything for the economy by voting the Party line on legislation that had no chance of passing the Senate. His votes were completely rubber-stamp in line with instructions from the Party, so it's hard to say that he's representing his constituents. A vote for Cravaack is essentially a vote for Boehner, because that's who tells Cravaack how to vote.

Meanwhile, Cook rates Democrat Tim Walz's seat as "Likely Democratic", though it's R+1. He held on to his seat against Randy Demmer, in spite of high wingnut hopes, and won by 5% in a great Republican year. Now Allen Quist and Mike Parry will battle over the chance to take on Walz in 2012. It will probably be Parry, who is the typical angry, crazy Tea Party-inspired kind of guy that the electorate is tired of. Quist is a really boring Religious Right bozo who embraced the Tea Party late in the game, and who is notable for failing to win his bid for Governor many years ago. If Quist wins, he'd be one of the few cases of the MN GOP recycling a loser, and he's probably only being considered because the MN Republican Party has been taken completely over by the evangelicals.

There hasn't been a dramatic shift to the Left in Minnesota, as much as there's been a massive and broad-based shudder of revulsion over what the Republicans have turned themselves into. And nothing right now is looking like they are backing away from their image of enraged, hateful, over-the-top, completely interchangeable nuts who all say the exact same thing.

Saturday, January 28, 2012

New MN polling is bad news for the wingnuts

New polling is out by PPP on Minnesota. They last polled the State in June.
Quick summary: Gov. Dayton is popular, Democrats lead by 9 on the GLB, and the SSM Amendment is close.
Gingrich leads the (non-binding) Republican caucus, and loses to Obama by 15. Romney loses to Obama by 10 points. Bachmann and Pawlenty are not popular at all, with Bachmann seeing particularly bad statewide numbers. Klobuchar is a lock for re-election.

Just how bad are Bachmann's numbers? PPP's Tom Jensen reports:

Voters hold an unfavorable opinion of Michele Bachmann by a 34-57 margin, including a 29-59 rating among Independents. 57% of Minnesota voters also say Bachmann should not run for reelection to the House of Representatives while just 37% think she should. 59% of Independents and even 20% of Republicans say Bachmann should not run for reelection.

 So it's bad, then.
Bachmann wins strong approval (85%) from those voters who consider themselves "very conservative", but they are only 16% of the electorate. Those who say they are "somewhat conservative" favour her with a less-impressive 56% support. Pretty weak for your "base". This "somewhat conservative" category holds 22% of the electorate. That's a total of 38% of the electorate with any kind of significant appeal for her. Moderates break highly unfavourably against her by more than 4-to-1. In other words, she has no appeal outside of that narrow conservative demographic.
This doesn't say anything about her chances of holding on to her House seat. The re-districting is still up in the air. Currently, Bachmann is living in the potential new district that includes St.Paul, and she has no hope of winning there. If the re-districting gives her her old district back, then her chances look good. But that district would be an isolated pocket of concentrated wingnuts that Bachmann could have trouble appealing to as time goes by.

One thing is sure: she has no hope outside of that district or in the State as a whole. Moderates, by more than 3-to-1, say she should not run for re-election. 22% of Minnesotans who voted for McCain in 2008 also do not want her to run again. Even worse, a majority of all age demographics say the same thing. And 59% of Independent voters don't want her to run for the House a fourth time, either.
Basically, the State of Minnesota is really tired of her.

The days when wingnuts could pretend that Bachmann is some kind of insurgent truth-teller who would "blow the minds" of the "urban liberals" are GONE. She is a punchline, not an evangelist for the conservative cause in Minnesota. She's done nothing for her district. And, from the St. Cloud Times:

Bachmann missed almost 59 percent of House roll-call votes in the third quarter of 2011, and more than 91 percent of votes in the fourth quarter.

At some point, the MN GOP will realise that she is not the best face for their cause, that she is a liability, and a very expensive candidate that sucks up donations that could be better spent elsewhere. Right now, though, the MN GOP is in the thrall of the evangelical Religious Right, and Bachmann is their poster child.

For the DFL, it is probably wiser not to contest her strongly, and focus instead on regaining the 8th CD from Cravaak, and defending Walz from a very "insider" challenge. Let Bachmann be the face of the MN GOP, and remind MN voters constantly of what the alternative to the DFL is.

As far as Pawlenty:

Q9 Would you support Tim Pawlenty for statewide
office in the future, or not?
Would support Pawlenty for statewide office .. 39%
Would not........................................................ 51%
Not sure .......................................................... 10%
That "would not" figure includes 50% of the 65+ age demographic, 15% of Republicans, 52% of women, 56% of moderates, and 52% of Independents. He only wins about 2/3 of that conservative 38% on this question, which is not strong when looking at your base. Remember, Pawlenty primarily won office by portraying himself as a moderate who down-played his evangelical beliefs. As the Tea Party rose, he transformed himself into a strong 10th Amendment advocate, a vitriolic hater of Obama, and an unquestioning pawn of the Religious Right. Look where it got him. Only 68% of "very conservative" MN voters want him to run for statewide office.

Rasmussen struggling with their narrative

Rasmussen's Presidential approval ratings are slipping away from the wingnut narrative.

In December, Rasmussen was able to regularly scrounge up around 45% "strong disapproval" for Obama. In January, though they are struggling to find 40% "strong disapproval". December began with 43% SD, and steadily moved up to a peak of 49% just before Christmas. That's also when Rasmussen chose to do their match-ups, showing Obama down six(!). This result was a glaring outlier among pollster, but it was their last chance to get some ridiculous numbers out there before moving into 2012 - when "things changed".

And a president who struggled to get 1/5 "strong approval" in December now is moving into 1/4 SA. And only a bare majority of 51% now disapprove of Obama (1/28) in Rasmussen's crazy, skewed, right-wing sampling world.

This entire "strong approval / strong disapproval" thing was implemented by Rasmussen when Obama took office. Previously, this category didn't matter to Rasmussen. But when Obama took over from Bush, it was suddenly very important how intensely people disliked Obama. It's part of his whole "Democrats don't really vote" narrative, which influences his "likely voter" screen. It's weird how, two years before an election, Rasmussen can determine who is "likely" to turn out. Even at eight months out (now), it would be considered too unreliable to employ LV screens by most pollsters. By manipulating this LV screen and his "panel" of hand-picked internet voters, he can pretty much come up with any numbers he wishes to. But he's accurate! Sure, except for 2010, and only when you get within 40 days of an election. Outside of that 40-day window, he's free to publish results that are contrary to everyone else. Once inside the 40-day window, "things change" and the wingnuts are left to despair that their hero pollster has been "taken in by the liberal media".

On 12/28/11 Rasmussen released a poll that I will hold him to: Romney defeats Obama 45/39.  +6R

On 1/4/12, Rasmussen says it's a tie: 42/42.

On 1/10/12, Rasmussen gives Obama a 3-point lead: 41/44.  +3D

Now, a 3-point lead is simply Rasmussen hedging his bets. That's within the margin of error, so he can easily shift it back to appease wingnuts. But the slow erosion of "strong disapproval", and the slow growth of the "strong approval" numbers show that Rasmussen is unwilling to go too far out on a limb for the Republicans right now. And that should make Republicans nervous.

After more than four years (including the 2008 election campaign) of constantly painting Obama as dangerous / inept / too powerful / too weak, only a bare majority actually disapproves of Obama in Rasmussen's sampling. It still hasn't dawned on the wingnuts that Obama isn't hated and that their "magic words" (socialist, Muslim, worst President, etc.) aren't working anymore. But the most right-wing national pollster in America is figuring that out, because his reputation was already damaged in 2010 and he needs to be taken seriously. Otherwise, his speaker's fees dry up.

UPDATE 1/30/12:
Rasmussen now shows Obama with a bare majority favourable: 51% approve, 47 disapprove.
The 37% "strong disapproval" is more in line with June '11.


Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Polling summary 1/25/12

This is a summary of some interesting recent polls. I may reference these in separate posts in the future.

National presidential polling:

CBS/NYT 1/12-17/12; 1,154 adults, 3% margin of error 1,021 registered voters, 3% margin of error

50% Obama (D), 39% Gingrich (R)
45% Obama (D), 45% Romney (R)
46% Obama (D), 42% Paul (R)
49% Obama (D), 38% Santorum (R)

Rasmussen  1/15-16/12; 1,000 likely voters, 3% margin of error

47% Obama (D), 38% Gingrich (R)

PPP 1/13-16/12; 700 registered voters, 3.7% margin of error

49% Obama (D), 42% Gingrich (R)
47% Obama (D), 42% Paul (R)
51% Obama (D), 40% Perry (R)
49% Obama (D), 44% Romney (R)
50% Obama (D), 42% Santorum (R)

Rasmussen  1/11-12/12; 1,000 likely voters, 3% margin of error

43% Obama (D), 37% Paul (R)

Other polling:

PPP (1/19) 1000 Registered Voters, MoE 3.1%, January 19, 2012 - January 22, 2012.

Republicans approve of Congressional Republicans 49/38.
Democrats approve of Congressional Democrats 62/25. 
White voters are negative on the Republicans 37/50 for the Generic Congressional Ballot (GCB).
65+ aged voters break 45/45 on the GCB.
61% of registered voters say that "Mitt Romney will say anything he has to to get elected".
44% of Republicans agree, as do 57% of Independents.
81% of registered voters think that "Making $370,000 in a year is a lot of money".
85% of white voters agree, as do 77% of Republicans and Independents.

PPP MN Republican caucus: 303 likely Republican voters, MoE 5.6%, 1/21-22

Gingrich    36%
Romney    18%
Santorum  17%
Paul          13%

Tea Party caucus voters have an unfavourable opinion of Paul: 35/48
Gingrich is the Tea Party favourite at 44% support.
43% of the Republican likely caucus voters consider themselves to be "very conservative".
32% of the Republican likely caucus voters consider themselves to be Tea Party members.
Paul is favourable in the broad category of age 18-45, breaking 44/33.
64% of the likely caucus voters are over 45.

 -------------------------
Pollster ratings from fivethirtyeight.com, based on 2010 elections: 

 


Saturday, January 14, 2012

Rasmussen sees a different world

First, the composite Party ID of all pollsters:

Independent: 41.5%
Republicans: 25.8%
Democrat: 30.3%

Next, the view from Rasmussen:

Independent: 30.4%
Republicans: 35.5%
Democrat: 34.2%

Now, all pollsters except Rasmussen:

Independent: 41.4%
Republicans: 25.9%
Democrat: 30.2%

So we notice that Rasmussen sees a much more Republican country out there than other pollsters. And Rasmussen can't claim that his mysterious "likely voter" screen is making the difference, since Rasmussen's party ID figures are raw (all adults) figures. All of the figures shown for other pollsters are also an "all adult" sample.

Rasmussen is surveying a country with nearly 10% more Republicans, 10% fewer Independents, and only 4% more Democrats than other pollsters.

PPP surveys registered voters. Let's look at what their figures indicate:

Independent: 25.8%
Republicans: 35.7%
Democrat: 38.2%

All pollsters, excluding PPP, shows this:

Independent: 29.6%
Republicans: 31.2%
Democrat: 37%

This is much closer to the composite than Rasmussen was with all adults. About 4% fewer Independents for PPP, and about 4% more Republicans than the others are finding. The numbers for Democrats is about the same. So, in spite of being labeled as a "Democratic" pollster, PPP is looking at more Republicans than their peers polling registered voters.

The most current poll from GWU shows "likely" voters to break down this way:

Independent: 27%
Republicans: 34%
Democrat: 37%

In my opinion, it's still too early for any "likely voter" (LV) screen to be worthwhile. But Rasmussen's claim that his LV screen is the reason for his outlier status is not borne out by looking at another pollster that is also using an LV screen. Apparently Rasmussen just happens to consistently hit on a gold mine of unhappy Democrats in their sampling, judging by their results.

Since Rasmussen is working from a much more Republican-based sample to begin with, it's hardly surprising that they are skewed toward "unhappy Democrats" in their LV sample. We don't really know what Rasmussen means by a "nationwide" sample. My guess is that Rasmussen's "nationwide" sample includes a lot more rural areas and lot more "red" states than other pollsters.

Rasmussen's 2011 Christmas polling (12/27-12/28) showed Romney with an outlier 6 point lead for Romney over Obama (45/39). Nobody else is seeing that.

As we've seen multiple Republican candidates "flare up" with popularity, Rasmussen has always mysteriously found a 2-point edge over Obama for each person at their peak. Rasmussen said Bachmann, Cain, Perry, etc. would all beat Obama in a match-up by 2 points. Later, the numbers change as the candidate slumps. 2% is such a weasel figure: within the margin of error, and not so large that it could seem suspicious if it switched to an Obama lead.

We're at a point in the cycle where Rasmussen can publish outrageous results, and then later say that "things changed". This is what usually happens with Rasmussen polling, whether it's a national race or a Senate contest. The Republican always shows a good lead at this point, and that lead always seems to diminish or flip as we approach the actual election. Rasmussen failed to do this "reversion to the mean" in 2010, and got stuck with an 8-point Republican bias in polls close to the election. With that, pollsters are much less intimidated to publish figures contradicting Rasmussen than they used to be.

It should also be pointed out that PPP publishes the raw figures (including area codes) for all of its polling. PPP also asks each person surveyed to place themselves in one of four regions: South, Midwest, East, or West. They publish the breakdowns of the sample in every poll, so you can see if they are oversampling one region. By examining the area codes, you can see if PPP is oversampling rural areas or red districts. Both PPP and Rasmussen use automated polling and call landlines. Yet, Rasmussen sees a very conservative America where even Democrats agree that Obama is the source of all our troubles. Oddly, Rasmussen is anything but transparent about his figures.

PPP has done an immense amount of polling for free. They have established a huge amount of base-line data that will be extremely valuable going into the 2012 election. No one paid for these polls; PPP volunteered. Anyone discounting these polls due to PPP being a "Democratic" polling firm is denying themselves the facts. There is also a lot of other polling that PPP has done where it's been paid for by DailyKos/SEIU. Critics love to mix these two groups of polls together to claim a bias and taint the free polling's validity. Don't let them confuse you. Aside from that, Rasmussen makes his money from subscribers that are overwhelmingly right-wing. He also does speaking gigs where he pushes right-wing narratives, so he has a strong incentive to produce dramatically pro-Republican numbers. I'm not saying Rasmussen is dishonest. I'm saying that if you dismiss PPP based on financial bias, you would have to dismiss Rasmussen as well.

By the way, let's look at Gallup's party identification numbers.

Independent: 40%
Republicans: 27%
Democrat: 31%

These figures are an "all adults" sample, like Rasmussen. Gallup also calls cell phones in their sample and uses live interviewers (not automated polling).

There was a two-point increase in independent identification from 2010 (38%) to 2011 (40%). The increase in independent identification came at the expense of Republican identification, which dropped from 29% to 27%, while Democratic identification held steady at 31%.
Gallup also says that, if you include "leaners", that the country splits 45/45 on D/R. That leaves only 10% real "Independents" to determine the election. The scary part is that this is pretty much how things broke down in 2010. The difference is in registered voters, of course. It's ironic that the Republicans screamed about Obama "not listening" to the majority, when things were actually evenly divided among "The People".