Monday, July 30, 2007

Anbar not as quiet as Petraeus says

I seem to recall this being the big success story. Anbar, where peace reigns thanks to the surge. Police are the new targets, apparently.

story from Xinhua


Seven people killed in two bomb attacks in western Iraq

16:12, July 28, 2007

Seven people, including two policemen were killed and at least 11 others injured in two bomb attacks in the restive city of Fallujah, a local police source said on Saturday.

A roadside bomb detonated on Saturday morning near a passing police patrol in the Hay Nazzal neighborhood in the city and damaged a police vehicle, killing two policemen and wounding another on board, the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

Earlier on Friday night, five civilians were killed and at least ten others were injured when an explosive-charge went off inside a minibus carrying passengers in central Fallujah, according to the source.

Fallujah, some 50 km west of Baghdad, is part of the volatile province of Anbar and has long been the hot bed of insurgency against U.S. troops and Iraqi security forces since 2003.

Source: Xinhua

Turkmen party leader killed

Yeah, well, sectarian violence is down, except for the assassinations.

story from Xinhua

Gunmen kill 6 in northern Iraq

07:59, July 30, 2007

Gunmen killed six persons and seriously injured a local leader of an Iraqi Turkmen party after storming his house in a town in Salahudin Province in northern Iraq, a provincial police source said on Sunday.

"Eight gunmen stormed the house of the local head of the Turkmen Front late on Saturday in the town of Yangcha near the city of Toz Khurmato, 90 km east of Tikrit," the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

The gunmen shot dead six people and seriously wounded the local head of the Front, the source said, adding that two sons of the Turkmen official were among the dead.

The incident is under investigation, as the attackers crossed several checkpoints manned by the Kurdish Peshmerga militia, which fought the former Iraqi regime under Saddam Hussein and joined the Iraqi army after the U.S.-led war on Iraq.

Source: Xinhua

Oxfam report says Iraq is in a "humanitarian crisis"

I guess insignificant things like having food to eat or water to drink hasn't improved at all in the past four years, but at least Al-Qaeda is being shuffled from province to province, so all of this should go away real soon. I mean, if the Iraqis have put up with this for this long, they can surely wait another ten years for the country to stabilise, right?

full story


Iraq faces deepening "humanitarian crisis"

BAGHDAD (Reuters) - Hunger and disease are spreading in Iraq as violence masks a deepening humanitarian crisis, Oxfam said in a report on Monday.

The charity said 28 percent of Iraqi children are malnourished, 15 percent of Iraqis regularly cannot afford enough to eat and 70 percent lack clean drinking water, all sharp increases since 2003.

"The terrible violence in Iraq has masked the ongoing humanitarian crisis. Malnutrition amongst children has dramatically increased and basic services, ruined by years of war and sanctions, cannot meet the needs of the Iraqi people," Oxfam director Jeremy Hobbs said.

"The fighting and weak Iraqi institutions mean there are severe limits on what humanitarian work can be carried out. Nevertheless more can and should be done to help the Iraqi people," he said.

Two million Iraqis have been forced to flee the country since 2003, and at least as many have been displaced within Iraq.

Oxfam, which pulled out of Iraq along with most other aid agencies because of deteriorating security in 2003, said there are local charities within Iraq that are working to help the poorest Iraqis. But most are under-funded.

Some are afraid to accept aid from countries with troops in Iraq for security reasons, and Oxfam called on countries that have not sent troops to send more money for aid.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

British preparing to exit Basra

For U.S. and Britain, opposite directions in Iraq

BASRA, Iraq: As U.S. troop levels are rising in Baghdad, British force levels are heading in the opposite direction, with the troops preparing to withdraw completely from the city center of Basra.

The British intend to pull back to an airport headquarters well out of the city, which is 480 kilometers, or 300 miles, south of Baghdad. It is a symbolic move widely taken by Iraqis as the beginning of the end of the British military presence in southern Iraq.

The scaling down by America's largest coalition partner foreshadows many of the political and military challenges certain to face American commanders when their troops begin withdrawing.

Skepticism is widespread in Basra, as in Baghdad, about whether Iraqi forces are ready to take over. Both the British and Americans will have to assuage the fears of Iraqis that they are being abandoned to gunmen and religious extremists. And both are likely to face intensified attacks from propaganda-conscious enemies trying to claim credit for driving out the Westerners.

As the British prepare for the withdrawal from the city center - and the wider transition of handing over Basra Province to Iraqi security forces during the coming months - Brigadier James Bashall, commander of the 1st Mechanized Brigade, conceded that his troops would almost certainly "get a lot of indirect fire as we go backward."

It is no coincidence that he is reading up on Britain's withdrawal from Aden, its former crown colony in what is now Yemen, and lessons from other wars, with the American experience in Vietnam what Bashall calls the "obvious parallel."

Rear Admiral Mark Fox, a U.S. military spokesman in Baghdad, parried any suggestion that Basra was a model for the Americans.

"I think that our focus right now is on the operations that we are conducting," he said. "Certainly that's the thing that is in front of us right now, and I wouldn't characterize us as necessarily peeking over the shoulders of somebody else to see how they are doing it."

The British commanders studiously avoid talk of dates for the same reason U.S. commanders are resisting such pressure in Congress - they fear it would embolden insurgents.

But it has escaped no one's notice that Britain's new prime minister, Gordon Brown, could score political points by withdrawing from an unpopular war. Brown headed to Washington on Sunday for a get-acquainted meeting with President George W. Bush.

The British pullback, and British commanders' talk of moving toward "overwatch" and intervening "in a limited sense" if requested by the Iraqis, is viewed with dismay by many Iraqis in the city.

Mustapha Wali, a teacher, was blunt. "If they withdraw, we will live in a jungle, like the early days," he said.

"The parties control the government, and the aim of officials is to fill their pockets with money - millions of dollars inside their pockets and nothing to the city."

The educated and secular middle classes fear that the Iraqi security forces - particularly the police - are hopelessly infiltrated by the extremist Shiite militias and Iranian-backed Islamist parties competing, often murderously, for control of Basra's huge oil wealth.

An overwhelmingly Shiite port city that controls Iraq's gateway to the Gulf, Basra is much less affected by the Sunni-Shiite sectarian violence plaguing Baghdad. But, as a report by the International Crisis Group concluded June 25, it is virtually controlled by Shiite militias.

Since the 2003 invasion, the British-led forces in Basra have adopted a far less aggressive and interventionist stance than U.S. troops have farther north. Some contend that this was the only realistic approach, with far fewer troops at their disposal and a more benign environment.

But critics accuse the British of simply allowing the Shiite militias free rein to carry out their intolerant Islamist agenda, which involved killing merchants who sell alcohol, driving out Christians and infiltrating state institutions and the security forces.

"The British are very patient. They didn't know how to deal with the militias," said an Assyrian Christian who would identify herself only as Mrs. Mansour. "Some people think it would be better if the Americans came instead of the British. They would be harder on the militias."

The report by the International Crisis Group, an organization that seeks to prevent or resolve deadly conflicts, concedes that a recent British-led crackdown was a qualified success in reducing criminality, political assassinations and sectarian killings, but nevertheless concludes that Basra "is an example of what to avoid."

It said the British had been driven into "increasingly secluded compounds," a result, the report said, that was viewed by Basra's residents and militia as an "ignominious defeat."

The Iraqi military: our last hope

The only hope to getting out of Iraq with anything that looks like success is to have an Iraqi Army and Police that is capable of taking over when we leave. Even if Al-Qaeda is actually expelled from Iraq, dozens of sectarian militias threaten the stability of the country. Other commanders have noted a distinct lack of loyalty to the Iraqi government among the Iraqi military. Again we see confirmation of this, as Gen. Dubik says the troops he is attempting to train seem to be more loyal to their sectarian militias than to Al-Maliki.

It takes 9 weeks to train a U.S. marine. We've had more than four years to train the Iraqi Army and Police. But this pace is apparently too fast.

And this is our only hope to getting out of Iraq with anything that looks like success.
Connect the dots.


Story from NYT

General Training Iraqis Cites Problem of Sectarian Loyalty



Published: July 29, 2007

BAGHDAD, July 28 — The new American general in charge of training and equipping Iraq’s security forces said the hardest challenge was finding good leaders free of sectarian loyalties.

Reach of War

“You can’t grow a force this fast and have the right number of qualified leaders,” Lt. Gen. James M. Dubik told The Associated Press on Saturday. “You can’t do it. This is a problem now, and it will be a problem for a good number of years.”

General Dubik said nonsectarianism was “much harder” to instill than teaching soldiers how to fight.

The Iraqi police on Saturday more than doubled the estimated death toll of a truck bombing on Thursday in the central Baghdad district of Karrada, to around 60 from 25. Two days after the explosion, rescuers were still searching for human remains in the rubble of a dozen apartments and houses that were destroyed or badly damaged by the blast.

Nearby, relatives of missing people watched miserably as Iraqi security forces removed the debris. Funeral corteges passed, with mourners carrying coffins and chanting.

Insurgents dressed as women attacked an Iraqi Army checkpoint near the northern town of Kirkuk on Saturday, killing three soldiers and wounding one, said Col. Sadr al-Din Abdullah, an Iraqi Army commander.

The governor of Kirkuk announced a three-hour curfew before the Asia Cup soccer final on Sunday between Iraq and Saudi Arabia, as security forces across the country prepared to tighten security, fearing that insurgents would attack celebrating crowds.

Diyala: So this is a success?

So we have destroyed Diyala in an attempt to "save" it from Al-Qaeda.
Note that a U.S. commander said that 80% of Al-Qaeda fled Baquba before the surge even started.
Where do we imagine they fled to? Let's not worry about that; it's a "victory", okay? Sure, the bodies of civilians killed in the attacks are piling up and being buried in mass graves without identification, but you have to break a few eggs and all that.
The important thing is that we are winning hearts and minds. Uh...wait a minute. I guess we're not.

You may wish to check out one soldier's account of Operation Arrowhead Ripper and who we are allying ourselves with in Diyala. He also offers an assessment of the Iraqi military that will "stand up so that we can stand down".


story from IPS

IRAQ: 'Arrowhead' Becomes Fountainhead of Anger
By Ali al-Fadhily*

BAQUBA, Jul 10 (IPS) - Ongoing U.S. military operations in Diyala province have brought normal life to an end, and fuelled support for the national resistance.

Baquba, 50km northeast of Baghdad, and capital city of the volatile Diyala province, has born the brunt of violence during the U.S. military Operation 'Arrowhead Ripper'.

Conflicting reports are on offer on the number of houses destroyed and numbers of civilians killed, but everyone agrees that the destruction is vast and the casualties numerous.

The operation was launched Jun. 18 "to destroy the al-Qaeda influences in this province and eliminate their threat against the people," according to Brig. Gen. Mick Bednarek, deputy commanding officer of the 25th Infantry Division.

But most Iraqis IPS interviewed in the area say the operation seeks more to break the national Iraqi resistance and those who support it. Adding credibility to this belief is the fact that the U.S. operational commander of troops involved in the operation told reporters Jun. 22 that 80 percent of the top al-Qaeda leaders in Baquba fled before the offensive began.

"Americans want Sunni people to leave Diyala or else they face death," Salman Shakir from the Gatoon district in Baquba told IPS outside the U.S. military cordon around the besieged city. "They warned al-Qaeda days or maybe weeks before they attacked the province and so only us, the citizens, stayed to face the massacre."

Shakir said many of his relatives and neighbours were killed by the military while attempting to leave the area. "I cannot tell you how many people were killed, but bodies of civilians were left in the streets."

"We all know now that the U.S. military is using the name of al-Qaeda to cover attacks against our national resistance fighters and civilians who wish immediate or scheduled withdrawal of foreign troops from Iraq," Hilmi Saed, an Iraqi journalist from Baghdad told IPS on the outskirts of Baquba.

The Iraqi Islamic Party, a Sunni political group in the Iraqi cabinet, issued a statement Jul. 1 alleging that more than 350 people had been killed in the U.S. military operation in Baquba.

The group called the operation "collective punishment" and said "neighbourhoods in western Baquba have witnessed, since last week, fierce attacks by occupation forces within Operation Arrowhead Ripper."

The statement added, "The forces shelled these neighbourhoods with helicopters, destroying more than 150 houses and killing more than 350 citizens. Their bodies are still under the wreckage. And they have arrested scores of citizens."

The U.S. military does not keep count of the number of civilian casualties caused by their operations.

Animosity towards the United States appears to be rising throughout the area as a result of the military action.

"Americans are pushing us to the corner of extremity by these massive crimes," Abbas al-Zaydi, a teacher from Baquba told IPS. "They simply want us to sell cheap our religion, history, tradition and faith or else they would call us terrorists."

Al-Zaydi added, "My son was not a fighter, but he was killed by a militia leader who is at the same time an Iraqi army division commander. Our great fault is only that we are Sunnis, and Americans do not like that."

"It is clear now that any Iraqi who refuses to serve the American plan is considered an enemy of the United States," a community leader in the city who did not want to give his name told IPS.

He said some people are angrier with other leaders supporting the U.S. forces. "The whole world is responsible for these murders, and a day will come that we say to the world, 'you supported Americans who killed us'."

A man wearing a mask, who appeared to be a resistance fighter, spoke with IPS just outside Baquba on condition of anonymity.

"Hundreds were killed and thousands evicted from the city while the so-called al-Qaeda fighters survived," he said. "Americans must be told that we will never stop killing their sons who came to kill us unless they leave our country in peace."

(*Ali, our correspondent in Baghdad, works in close collaboration with Dahr Jamail, our U.S.-based specialist writer on Iraq who travels extensively in the region) (END/2007)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Let's look on the bright side

The right-wing blithely ignores the deteriorating situation in Kurdistan, once an area of prosperity and security in a war-torn nation. They prefer instead to point to numbers of putative "Al-Qaeda" killed in areas where U.S. troops are the most concentrated. They also live in a delusional scenario where Al-Qaeda is the major cause of everything wrong in Iraq, so by extension killing these putative "Al-Qaeda" will create the stability the surge was ostensibly supposed to secure. More and more clearly we are instead finding out that these "problems" are merely being pushed to other areas, such as Kurdistan. And this is called "progress", apparently.

Oh, and let's not forget that another car bomb just went off in the most heavily-patrolled city of the surge, Baghdad. Does this have any bearing on the "security situation" in Baghdad? Not to the right-wing. These bombings "tell us nothing" except that we must stay the course. It may say to Iraqis, however, that if you trust in the surge and decide to go shopping (as the current victims did) that you may very well get killed or injured. But then, how many on the right really care about the Iraqi civilians anyway? It's all about Al-Qaeda.


Car bomb kills eight people in northern Iraq's Kirkuk


Related News
Five U.S. soldiers killed in Iraq
Danish withdrawal from Iraq going quickly: officer
Gunmen storm police checkpoint in northern Iraq, kill 6
Five security members killed in northern Iraqi clash
U.S. House passes bill barring permanent bases in Iraq


Eight people were killed and more than 40 others injured in a car bomb attack in a popular market in northern Iraq's city of Kirkuk on Thursday, local police source said.

"A car bomb parking near the Abdullah Restaurant in a busy popular market in central Kirkuk detonated at about 6:00 p.m. ( 1400 GMT), killing eight people and wounded more than 40 others," the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

The blast damaged several nearby shops and buildings, the source said.

In Baghdad, another car bomb went off in the afternoon in a crowded commercial area in Karradah neighborhood, killing 20 people and wounding up to 60 others, according to the police.

The powerful blast set a nearby building on fire and destroyed several civilian cars and shops, said the police.

Source: Xinhua

Saturday, July 28, 2007

50,000 flee Iraq's "success" each month

If the surge is such a big "success" and Iraq is "steadily improving", one must wonder why 50,000 Iraqis flee the country each month to join the more than 2 million others in Jordan, Syria, and Egypt.
It's certainly interesting that "bad boy" Syria has been forced to support an increasing share of refugees from the shining success in Iraq. 30,000 Iraqis each month flee their native land into a repressive dictatorship. Iraqis seem to be voting indeed, only it's with their feet.

Meanwhile, Iraq asks these already strained countries to do more to help those who flee, while failing to pay the money they promised.

This is one of the major signs that Iraq is not improving, as the Decider and his ventriloquist dummies continously say. The surge was instituted to improve the security situation, and "The security situation is what is driving Iraqis to leave their country", according to this report. If things truly were improving, then Iraqis would be returning, not continuing to flee.

Let's see what the Decider does in response to this mammoth problem that his fictionally-premised, ill-conceived, and massively expensive war has caused. My guess is that he'll do exactly what he does with everyone else disillusioned with the occupation: ask for patience. Or tell them to "shut up".

What message does this send to our allies, not only in the Middle East, when it's obvious the U.S. does not care what problems it causes with its actions? When Bush talks about how the invasion of Iraq will do "great things" for the region, those countries in the region must be thinking about these huge costs. Far from a shining positive example of democracy and prosperity, Iraq is looking like a complete disaster and people are fleeing that disaster in droves. How many people in the Middle East are looking to Iraq and thinking, "maybe we can get some of that democracy stuff here"? It's obvious that the repressive stability of Syria is a huge draw, even to those with purple-stained fingers.


Jordan reiterates call for assistance to Iraqi Refugees

(MENAFN - Jordan Times) AMMAN Jordan on Thursday called on the international community to issue "immediate and direct assistance" to help it maintain services to hundreds of thousands of Iraqis residing in the country.

The call was made during a one-day meeting in Amman for Iraqi-hosting countries, particularly Jordan and Syria.

"Iraqi-hosting countries are currently under immense pressure in services offered, infrastructure, natural resource strain, security, and particularly the health and educational sectors, as a result of the huge number of Iraqi guests," Interior Ministry secretary general and head of the Jordanian delegation, Mkhaimar Abu Jamous, told the gathering.

The Jordanian official reiterated a plea made in April during a UN conference in Geneva when it was revealed that Iraqi guests are costing the Kingdom $1 billion a year.

Abu Jamous stressed that the mounting pressure adds to the intensity of problems related to the country's meagre resources, particularly water. Jordan, he noted, is already one of the world's thirstiest countries in the world.

He also highlighted the security challenge posed by the consequences of the war in Iraq.

"The security situation is what is driving Iraqis to leave their country. The increase of Iraqis in the Kingdom has amounted to a higher cost on the budget to provide security," Abu Jamous said.

The United Nations estimates that over two million Iraqis have fled from violence in Iraq to neighbouring countries with around 50,000 more who continue to do so each month.

Jordan, in respect to its population of nearly 5.5 million, has absorbed around 750,000, according to UN estimates. This means that around one in every eight persons living in the Kingdom is an Iraqi national.

Jordan's unemployment rate is around 15 per cent which leaves the government unable to give preferential treatment to Iraqis with respect to issuing large number of residency permits allowing them to work.

Syria, with a population of around three times the size of Jordan's, has also taken in around 1.5 million Iraqis and its government estimates it is allowing an additional 30,000 a month to enter.

The Syrian head of delegation raised much of the same concerns as Jordan, adding the US must shoulder its responsibilities and extend direct assistance to hosts.

UN officials have repeatedly warned the international community that Jordan and Syria are under severe strain "particularly in the health and education sectors" and must not be ignored.

Director of the Jordan Information Centre Bisher Khasawneh noted that Jordan's educational system, already strained because of natural growth, struggles to stand up to the challenge posed by the Iraqi community.

He explained that the ratio between students to teacher has become a problem and that some schools are being forced to return to the infamous double shift system because of extra number of Iraqi students who are attending public schools.

The government, upon directives by King Abdullah, admits all Iraqi school-age children into public and private schools, even if they do not hold residency permits.

A government source told The Jordan Times that around 50,000 Iraqi children are receiving education in some of Jordan's 3,200 schools.

Iraqis are also ensured open access to public health services that are "heavily subsidised" at around 65 per cent, Khasawneh said.

In his address at yesterday's meeting, secretary general of Iraq's foreign ministry, Mohammad Al Hajj Al Hmoud, called on host countries to facilitate more residency permits, allow Iraqis holding non-G series passports to continue to enter borders and provide better health and educational facilities until conditions are suitable for their return.

"It is the duty of the international community and in particular neighbouring countries to provide assistance to displaced Iraqis," Hmoud said.

On the eve of the meeting that was attended by members representing Iraq, Syria, Egypt, the UN, the EU and the Arab League, Amnesty International (AI) released a statement urging the international community to support Jordan and Syria both financially and by establishing generous resettlement programmes for the Iraqis in greatest need of protection.

"It is vital that states who pledged funds to help at a previous conference last April to honour their commitments, which all too few have done to date."

AI said that $25 million pledged by Iraq's government had still not materialised.

A list of recommendations was released at the conclusion of the meeting, in which participants collectively agreed that all parties should work towards the return of security and stability in Iraq since it is the deteriorating security situation that is forcing Iraqis to leave their country.

They recommended Iraqi nationals of all ethnic backgrounds to return to their country to participate in its political recovery.

The meeting was also attended by supervisors from Iran, Turkey, Russia, US, UK and Japan.


Yep, the Democrats are afraid of the surge's "success". That's what it all boils down to. Apparently a lot of Iraqis are afraid of the surge's "success", too.

Thursday, July 26, 2007

"Signs of Improvement": Sectarian killings sharply rise

In yet another rebuke to neocon claims that "the surge is working", reports show a sharp increase in sectarian killings in the past month. Recall that this was the problem the surge was ostensibly proposed to deal with, not Al-Qaeda's presence. Many of the recent bombings in Baghdad appear to be indiscriminate, rather than being targeted at Shia to provoke a Sunni uprising. The neocon talking point is that Al-Qaeda is at the root of the sectarian violence, by killing Shia in spectacular bombings designed to encourage their fellow Sunnis to exterminate Shias. Thus, by this logic, Bush's concentration on Al-Qaeda will (eventually) calm the sectarian violence by removing the impetus. The latest bombing in Baghdad, the soccer massacre, killed both Sunni and Shia; how would this serve Al-Qaeda's aims?
Could it possibly be that the current manhunt focus of the surge is simply an attempt to ignore the intractable problem of sectarian violence while concentrating on a purely military solution? This certainly takes the focus off of the civil war, which is unpopular and difficult to solve with a military confrontation scenario. The numbers of dead bodies piling up seems to indicate that the link between Al-Qaeda and sectarian violence is weak. Again, it appears the American and Iraqi military are simply playing games with the numbers and the war supporters are eager to lap this up.
Complete story

Up to 592 unidentified bodies were found dumped in different parts of Baghdad in the period between June 18 and July 18, 2007, according to figures based on media reports compiled by Iraq Slogger. Most of the bodies found by the police – an average of 20 a day – are bound, blindfolded and shot execution style, victims of sectarian violence carried out by both Sunni and Shi’ite death squads. Many also bear signs of torture or mutilation, according to medical sources in Baghdad. Despite official Iraqi and U.S. statements to the contrary, the reports indicate that the number of unidentified bodies in the capital has risen again to pre-surge levels over the last two months.

Shia/Sunni tensions existed long before Al-Qaeda arrived in Iraq. The "nation" of Iraq is an artifical construct, held together up until recently by Saddam's authoritarian rule. Our current approach is similar to trying to end the American Civil War by going after the Undergound Railroad and telling ourselves that this will relieve the tensions between North and South. Sadly, military force is the only card the Bush Administration knows how to play: more troops or less troops, take your pick. The profound political chasms that Iraq faces are seemingly left to the feeble and incompetent Iraqi government, which seems constantly on the verge of collapse or implosion. It is completely unclear how an Oil Law that gives the vast majority of Iraq's oil wealth away to multinational oil companies will help the political situation. These oil companies are allowed to "keep the books" and determine how much they will claim is due the Iraqis. Such mysterious accounting practises are familiar to anyone who has ever had an agent representing them, but somehow in this case, the benign oil companies will "play fair" with the Iraqis. And the money that goes to the government will not be siphoned off by multiple levels of Iraqi corruption, either. And upon receiving a check for their part of whatever is left over, the Iraqis will see that their multi-generational dispute is pointless and bad for business. Once again, the best-case scenario is being presented by the Bush Administration as the only likely outcome, and once again it is the only plan. This is the land of long memories and blood feuds, where the majority of Iraqis have seen their families tortured and massacred by the "other side" for years, where corruption is part of the cost of doing business, and where political tensions have been allowed to simmer (but never boil over) for decades. Five years of occupation have taught us nothing; it is the alien American culture trying impose it's foreign logic on a land and people who do not share it. But thirty pieces of silver will solve it all, at least in Bush's mind.
But, oh yes, let's not forget: the Iraqi government has established a commission to examine possible solutions to the political chasm. This is yet another of the "great successes" the "liberal media" wants to keep us from hearing about. If only the American public knew that a commission of Iraqi politicians was trying to come up with solutions to an intractable mess, they would certainly support Bush's 'plan', wouldn't they?

The only plan that the surge really rests on is throwing enough troops at Iraq until some kind of un-anticipated miracle occurs that will produce reconciliation. Getting Sunni and Shia militias to join against the "common enemy" of Al-Qaeda is only effective when Al-Qaeda is in that particular area. Once the surge "succeeds" in pushing A-Qaeda someplace else where the military isn't concentrated, the entire reason for the "reconciliation" vanishes, and we are back to the starting point. This is essentially what has happened in Basra with the British forces. But it won't happen to us because..... um, well, because the best possible outcome is the only likely outcome, remember? So cross your fingers and dig out those rabbit's feet, because the Decider has a big plan.

Thus spake the Decider

Take a look back in time and muse upon the thoughts of the Decider, in his ever-changing parade of goals and definitions:
From the July 12 speech by Bush

Our top priority is to help the Iraqis protect their population. So we have launched an offensive in and around Baghdad to go after extremists, to buy more time for Iraqi forces to develop, and to help normal life and civil society take root in communities and neighborhoods throughout the country. We're helping enhance the size, capabilities and effectiveness of the Iraqi security forces so the Iraqis can take over the defense of their own country. We're helping the Iraqis take back their neighborhoods from the extremists.

Of course, that was only last month. In that time, we have instead switched over to a course entirely devoted to pushing Al-Qaeda out of one area and into another. Training for the Iraqi military has been put on hold. "Normal life and civil society" has come to an abrupt halt in "successful" Diyala province. Only one-third of the Iraqi army force levels Bush "believed" would be ready to operate independently are actually there. We are allying ourselves with extremists, rather than "helping the Iraqis take back their neighborhoods from extremists".

In short, not one element of our "top priority" has worked, and it appears as if these elements are no longer our "top priority".

Neocons seem to have decided that Sunnis are the "bad guys", because you must have clearly-defined "bad guys" when you are in a war in which our very civilisation is at stake. If this is the new course, then neocons should be advised that the Shia are quite sympathetic to Iran. Are we really saying that after $500 billion spent, we are now working to establish a government in Iraq that is a firm ally of Iran?

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Bush speaks, the nation yawns

Bush simply has no credibility anymore. He has "fixed" intelligence repeatedly and puts enormous pressure on his commanders to come up with "good news" as it becomes increasingly obvious that the surge will have to continue far longer than he proposed in January.
Remember, Bush said in his January 10 speech (in which he proposed the surge) that the Iraqi government would have control of the country by November. He said 18 Iraqi brigades would take the lead in the surge, with the U.S. troops merely backing them up. So far only six brigades are established and working independently, and our own commanders say the Iraqi forces are not only infilitrated by militias, but not loyal to Al-Maliki. U.S. military strategists have said that "only" 800 sectarian killings a month would be considered "success", and the definition of "victory" has changed from a stable, prosperous democracy that would serve as a positive example to the entire Middle East to an essentially failed state in which large numbers of U.S. troops chase Al-Qaeda from one province to another in a bloody whack-a-mole surge.
Bush continually lowers the bar for "success", and each time he says "it's what we've said all along". Does he not realise that his speeches are public and recorded? Or does he feel he still has credibility with the American people?
This is not "Bush Derangement Syndrome", as the neocons term anyone guilty of not unquestioningly lapping up each new distortion the Decider speaks, but rather a simple credibility gap. We have heard all of this before, and it never gets better in "another six months". Each time that he asks for another six months he is optimistic about success, and each time the threat of failure is "grave". Years and years go by, but that last optimistic promise is as bad as the next. Bush is trying to referee a football game with baseball umpires, and we just have to give him "more time", or so he says.
In the meantime, his shills insult the vast majority of Americans by implying that lack of support for Bush is equivalent to supporting Al-Qaeda. They speak of nebulous "good news" that the media doesn't want us to hear. They point at specific bright spots and ignore the previously bright spots, such as Kurdistan and Basra, that are steadily growing dark. They ignore the current civilian casualties, while claiming concern for potential civilian casualties should we withdraw. They ignore the desperate situation this conflict has placed our allies in, and call for even greater sacrifices from those nations that have already aided us. To these shills, the only thing that is important is that "their guy" doesn't go down in disgrace, but he already has. These shills constantly say that it is "far too early" to evaluate the surge, but then proceed in the same virtual breath to evaluate it in a positive light. And they sincerely believe that nobody will notice this contradiction.


Bush tries to portray Iraq war linked to al-Qaida


Related News
U.S. command in Iraq foresees significant U.S. role for next two years: report
U.S. Democrat candidates call for withdrawal from Iraq in first official debate
Wave of violence kills at least 24 people in Iraq on Monday
No cancer found in polyps removed during Bush's medical exam
Wave of violence kills at least 24 people in Iraq on Monday

Amid low public support for his handling of the Iraq war, U.S. President George W. Bush on Tuesday tried to link the rampant violence in Iraq to the al-Qaida terrorist organization.

"Al-Qaida in Iraq is a group founded by foreign terrorists, led largely by foreign terrorists and loyal to a foreign terrorist leader: Osama bin Laden," Bush said at the Charleston Air Force Base, South Carolina, one day after Democratic presidential candidates called at a debate in the city for withdrawal from Iraq.

"The merger between al-Qaida and its Iraqi affiliate is an alliance of killers and that is why the finest military in the world is on their trail," Bush said.

In his speech, Bush cited declassified intelligence to demonstrate that al-Qaida's operation in Iraq was a direct threat to the United States, and criticized lawmakers for calling for pulling American troops out of Iraq.

"I've presented intelligence that clearly establishes this connection" (between Iraq violence and al-Qaida), Bush said.

"Some say that Iraq is not a part of the broader war on terror ... They claim that the organization called al-Qaida in Iraq is an Iraqi phenomenon, that it's independent of Osama bin Laden and that it's not interested in attacking America," he said.

"That would be news to Osama bin Laden," Bush said.

U.S. intelligence has showed that al-Qaida had no active cells in Iraq when the United States launched war against Iraq in March 2003, and that the group's operation in Iraq is much larger now than before the war.

Despite efforts to rally support for his war policy, the U.S. public see Bush as intransigent on Iraq and prefer that the Democratic-controlled Congress make decisions about a possible withdrawal of U.S. forces, a new poll showed.

The Washington Post-ABC News poll published on Tuesday found 55 percent of those surveyed said they trust congressional Democrats on the war, compared with 32 percent who said they trust Bush. And by 2 to 1, Americans said Congress, rather than the president, should make the final decision about when to withdraw U.S. forces from Iraq.

Overall attitudes about the war in Iraq continue to be decidedly negative, with more than six in 10 saying that given the costs, the war was not worth fighting, and 55 percent said they support legislation that would set a deadline of next spring for the withdrawal of U.S. forces from Iraq, according to the poll.


Source: Xinhua

Green Zone hit by mortars again

The Green Zone is the most heavily fortified area in the country, but despite years of occupation including the current surge, it still gets attacked by mortars almost weekly. Baghdad is the ostensible focus of the surge, as well as the home of several sectarian militias that manange to torture and kill hundreds a month in the middle of a huge troop presence. So this is what $2 billion a week gets us. I think one real "sign of improvement" would be if our "embassy" would stop getting hit by mortars.

Mortar barrage hits Baghdad Green Zone



Mortar rounds landed on the heavily fortified Green Zone in Baghdad on Tuesday while the U.S. and Iranian delegations were holding a second landmark meeting over Iraq's worsening security situation, a well-informed police source said.

"Several mortar rounds landed on the Green Zone shortly after 11:00 a.m. (0800 GMT)," the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

It was not known whether there was any casualty or where exactly the rounds landed, the source said.

The attack occurred about an hour and a half after the start of the meeting of U.S. Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker and his Iranian counterpart Hassan Kazemi Qomi in the office of Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki.

The U.S. military did not confirm the incident yet.

The U.S.-controlled Green Zone is a vast area on the west bank of the Tigris River, which houses the Iraqi government offices and foreign embassies, including the U.S. embassy.

Source: Xinhua

Baghdad blows up; the surge 'succeeds' again

More 'signs of improvement' in Baghdad as two car bombs explode. Yes, the surge is "working", we are told daily by neocons. What these shameless shills mean by "improvement" is that we kill people and then arbitrary dub the corpses "Al-Qaeda", which means that things are improving because (based on nothing) it has been decided that Al-Qaeda is the source of all instability and violence in Iraq. Of course, when things like this happen, we are supposed to put on our smiley faces and think about how wonderful Iraq will be when the surge finally solves all of Iraq's problems. Again, I point out the bizarre disconnect of 'concern' for innocent Iraqis should we withdraw and apathy towards those innocents killed while the surge is underway.

At least 50 dead after car bombs target celebrating Iraqis
Jul 25, 2007 02:47 PM
Associated Press
BAGHDAD — Officials in Iraq say two suicide car bombings struck soccer fans in Baghdad today as they were celebrating Iraq’s victory in the Asian Cup semifinal.

At least 50 people are dead and more than 100 wounded.

The victims were among the thousands of revellers who took to the streets of the capital after Iraq’s soccer team beat South Korea to reach the tournament’s final against Saudi Arabia on Sunday in Jakarta, Indonesia.

Police and hospital officials say the first attack took place about 6:30 p.m. when a bomb exploded in a crowd of people cheering near a popular ice cream parlour in Baghdad’s western neighbourhood of Mansour.

Interior Ministry officials say at least 30 people were killed and 75 wounded in that attack.

Another suicide car bomber detonated his payload about 45 minutes later in the midst of dozens of vehicles filled with revellers near an Iraqi army checkpoint in the eastern district of Ghadeer.

The second attack killed at least 20 people, including two soldiers, and wounded 61.

Progress in Diyala

More signs of progress from the surge in Diyala: hospitals have stopped working. As the bodies pile up in (and outside) the morgue Diyala has opted for mass graves. The large numbers of civilian casualties from Operation Arrowhead Ripper now have a broken hospital system to turn to. The surge, originally put forward by Bush as a way to end sectarian fighting, has now become exclusively focused on Al-Qaeda. If you happen to be a Sunni Iraqi injured in one of the many airstrikes in Diyala, you would find yourself unwelcome in the Shia-run hospitals. The lack of security, which is what OAR was ostensibly to provide, has produced a situation worse than that under Saddam.
Note that this one of major "success stories" that war supporters cite regarding the surge.


IRAQ: Baquba Denied the Healing Touch
By Ahmed Ali*

BAQUBA, Jul 25 (IPS) - Diyala General Hospital in the provincial capital Baquba has been hit by severe lack of supplies amid ongoing attacks by militants.

Located 50km northeast of Baghdad, the city of Baquba has become known now for both the huge U.S. military operations and the presence of al-Qaeda.

The shortages coupled with a lack of basic infrastructure have left the largest hospital in Diyala province short of supplies, and staffed by terrorised doctors often unable to do their job.

Diyala General Hospital, built in the 1970's, was never adequately resourced since the devastating Iran-Iraq war of the 1980s and the dozen years of economic sanctions since the early 1990s.

When the U.S.-led occupation began in April 2003, administrators promised reconstruction and rehabilitation of Iraq's healthcare system. It never came. This hospital, like countless others in Iraq, is in a far worse condition today than even during the sanctions period when more than half a million Iraqi children died from malnutrition, disease and lack of adequate healthcare.

The problems appear to begin and end with lack of security.

"One day, a number of Iraqi army casualties caused by a suicide car bomb were brought to the hospital by a military patrol," Mohammed Ali, a 39-year-old orthopaedic surgeon told IPS. "The soldiers began to insult the staff, and hit two physicians after ordering them to leave other patients and treat the wounded soldiers first."

Doctors announced a strike, Ali said. "A few days later the head of the physicians syndicate called an end to the strike after intervention by the mayor."

But doctors have continued to face abuse, Nasseer Adil, a 42-year-old pathologist told IPS. "It has become very normal that any person can come and insult anyone in the hospital."

Over time, the abuse and threats have driven many doctors to leave their job, and when they can, the country.

"The staff members began to come to work intermittently, and sometimes we could hardly see one physician in the whole hospital," Haleem Kareem, a 46-year-old receptionist at the hospital told IPS.

Dr Ahmed Shibad, a 30-year-old orthopaedic surgeon, fled the hospital for Syria four months ago after he said he received death threats from Iraqi soldiers backed by U.S. forces.

During an interview with IPS in Damascus in May he said, "The Iraqi forces who regularly came into the hospital to order us around and abuse us were supported by the American military. The American soldiers watched the Iraqis do this to us, and this is another reason why I left."

By October 2006, 18,000 Iraqi doctors, over half of all doctors in Iraq, had fled the country, according to a report by Radio Free Europe.

Now many people in Baquba go to private clinics in hope of better treatment and security. But while the main hospital offers free treatment, private clinics can be expensive.

Violence continues to plague the Baquba hospital. "The fighters used to attack Iraqi army soldiers who used to bring their casualties and bodies to the hospital," Hadi Sadeq, a 40-year-old official in the emergency unit told IPS. "For this reason staff quit, and people in need of treatment stopped to come."

Complicating matters further has been corruption within Iraq's Ministry of Health in Baghdad.

The ministry, which has been run by officials loyal to Shia cleric Muqtada al-Sadr, has been accused of favouring Shia areas in Iraq. Baquba, a mixed area, has been considered a Sunni area by the ministry.

Doctors at Diyala General Hospital told IPS they believe that the Heath Ministry has hindered the supply of medical equipment and supplies to their hospital for sectarian reasons.

"The Diyala director-general of health was kidnapped in the building of the Health Ministry itself, and was later killed in Sadr city," Majid Ibrahim, a 48-year-old ophthalmologist told IPS. "It is a well-known incident, admitted even by the health minister, Dr Ali al-Shamary."

A hospital worker, speaking on condition of anonymity, told IPS that lately the government has been trying to increase protection for the hospital but that "unfortunately, the guards are all Shia."

(*Ahmed, our correspondent in Iraq's Diyala province, works in close collaboration with Dahr Jamail, our U.S.-based specialist writer on Iraq who travels extensively in the region.) (END/2007)

Monday, July 23, 2007

The success of Diyala

This is the result of one of the shining success stories of the surge, Operation Arrowhead Ripper (OAR) in Diyala province. Yesterday I read one of Michael Yon's reports about how wonderful and successful OAR was, with a crossposter saying it was" more bad news for the Defeaticrats". In it, Mr. Yon detailed how the U.S. troops had held a meeting with some selected militias and proposed that they take an oath. The militia leaders objected to the majority of the oath. And that, apparently, is a major success story that the media is ignoring and that those opposed the occupation are going to be worrying over.
Aside from the fact that this is simply the "Anbar solution" applied in Diyala, where the Iraqi military has been circumvented and where we enlist various armed gangs to attack other armed gangs, the result of OAR has been heavy civilian casualties.

Full story from IPS

IRAQ: Living Becomes Hard in a Dead City
By Ahmed Ali*

BAQUBA, Jul 23 (IPS) - Life in the violence-plagued capital city of Iraq's Diyala province has become a struggle for day-to-day survival.

Heavy U.S military operations, sectarian death squads and al-Qaeda militants have combined to make normal life in Baquba, 50 km northeast of Baghdad, all but impossible.

Movement from the city to another destination is extremely dangerous. Kidnappings have become rampant in a lawless city where government control is only a mirage.

Lack of security and mobility have meant severe shortages of fuel, food, medical supplies and other necessities.

The central market in the city of about 325,000 has vanished. It is not just the shopping that is gone. People used to meet acquaintances in the market to socialise and sometimes do business.

The ongoing violence has ended all that. The market has become scattered around city districts. Many shop owners have reopened smaller shops within their houses, and abandoned their business locations.

About two or three persons have been killed or abducted in the market daily on average in recent weeks. This had started to happen even before the U.S. military operation Arrowhead Ripper was launched last month with the intention of targeting al-Qaeda forces. Now residents say it is much worse.

"The troops have closed all the outlets from the city, and never allow cars to move," Amir Ayad, a 51-year-old assistant professor in the sciences college at Diyala University told IPS. "To get my college, I have to get a cart as other people do. It is five kilometres, and it is better than walking."

"For the final examinations which were held unfortunately during this period of military operations, students had to walk hours to get to the exam centre," Prof. Majeed Abid told IPS. "They were exhausted and sweating."

Animal-drawn carts have now become a new business in Baquba. Most of these are drawn by donkeys, and each cart carries 10-15 passengers who pay two to three dollars a journey.

"Every day I bring vegetables four kilometres by cart and pay 25-35 dollars for this," 29-year-old Adil Omran told IPS. "For this reason, the prices have increased tremendously."

"A tomato, which is grown commonly in Iraq, is usually around six cents," said Mahmood Ali, a retired teacher. "Nowadays, we buy it for 1.25 dollar. Families now tend to buy one or two bags of potatoes (30 kilos each) because they cannot afford the increasing prices of other vegetables."

Complicating matters is the already unsteady disbursement of salaries due to the volatile security situation.

"Officials used to receive their salaries every month, but for a year and a half now we receive our salaries only every 50-70 days," Kadhim Raad, a 44-year-old official in the municipality of Baquba told IPS.

"The staff at the Ministry of Education have not received their salaries for three months because no money is available in the banks," Sara Latif, an official in the finance department of the Directorate General of Education told IPS.

People are now looking for ways to leave this city of continuing violence, delayed salaries, lack of jobs, lack of open markets, closed factories, no functioning municipal work, and very little farming due to lack of water and electricity.

The average house in Baquba gets one or two hours of electricity a day. It is not uncommon for three or four days to pass without a minute of electricity.

Most people have bought small generators, but lack of fuel often makes it impossible to run these. Before the U.S.-led invasion, a litre of petrol in Iraq cost five cents; today in Baquba it is nearly two dollars.

There are no functioning fuel stations. Instead, people buy 20-litre jugs.


"People have forgotten there is something called a petrol station," Hamid Alwan, a 46-year-old taxi driver told IPS. "The owners of petrol stations sell the tankers of petrol before they are brought to Baquba to make more money."

And all this is less than the biggest concern – to find a way just to stay safe.

(*Ahmed, our correspondent in Iraq's Diyala province, works in close collaboration with Dahr Jamail, our U.S.-based specialist writer on Iraq who travels extensively in the region) (END/2007)



Sunday, July 22, 2007

Poll results on Iraq situation

The latest Newsweek poll on Iraq:

14. Which of the following do you blame most for the current situation in Iraq?

Total


Republicans Democrats Independents

2

The U.S. military 2 3 1

40

The White House 13 54 46

13

Congress 20 7 13

33

Iraqi leaders 52 25 29

4

Same/All equal 3 4 5

8

Don't know 10 7 6


The Neocons have been shrilling for months about how Harry Reid is responsible for "defeatism". Hell, they have pretty much gone so far as to say the man is hated by the public. However, only 13% see Congress as responsible for "the current situation in Iraq". It also affirms that, in the minds of the public, this war is definitely "Bush's war". And if, as 33% say, the Iraqi leaders are to blame, how are we ever going to get a stable Iraqi government and military that will "stand up so we can stand down"? And only 20% of Republicans blame Congress for the Iraq situation. It really shows that the Pelosi/Reid haters are seriously out of touch with everyone but their little clique.

Also, roughly half of the country doesn't want to wait until September for an assessment of the surge:

8. The Bush Administration says there will be an assessment of how the "surge" plan is working in September. Do you think this timing is reasonable, or that it is too long to wait for an assessment?

Total


Republicans Democrats Independents

48

Timing is reasonable 74 31 49

47

Too long to wait 20 64 47

5

Don't know 6 5 4

With that in mind, the next results are really quite telling:

4. Do you think President Bush's "surge" plan increasing U.S. troops in Iraq has been a success or a failure?

Total


Republicans Democrats Independents

22

Success 47 7 21

64

Failure 31 84 66

14

Don't know 22 9 13


So, about half of the country doesn't even want to wait until September's report from Petraeus, 64% say the surge is a failure, and 40% blame the Bush Administration for it.
Look at those numbers for independent voters as well. They are the swing votes in the next election.
Recently right-wing blogs ahve been bragging about the "booming economy" that bush has brought about. It turns out 59% disapprove of his Handling of the economy.
It is truly stunning that Republicans have bet the farm on this unpopular man and his unpopular war. Sadly, they still keep predicting a Republican win in 2008 because "Americans like to win" and "the surge will turn out to be a success". The polls say otherwise, and the polls reflect elections. Sure, Bush will make some ridiculous pronouncement where he re-defines the word "success" and his faithful will lap it up, but the American public at large won't if these numbers are any indication.

Surge allies killed in Baghdad

This is again in Baghdad, where the surge is strongest and al-Qaeda is supposed to be "on the run". You won't see this news story on right-wing blogs.


Minivan bomber kills Sunni tribal leaders

BAGHDAD Five Sunni tribal leaders opposed to al-Qaeda were killed when a suicide bomber drove a minivan packed with about half a tonne of explosives into a house outside Baghdad yesterday. Another 12 people were wounded, and police said the death toll could rise.

The men were meeting near Taji, about 20 kilometres (12miles) north of the Iraqi capital, to discuss joining US and Iraqi forces in fighting al-Qaeda in their mainly Sunni Arab area. The US military wants to recruit Sunnis tired of indiscriminate al-Qaeda violence into provincial police units. (Reuters)

Saturday, July 21, 2007

March poll says that almost half of Iraqis think life was better under Saddam

While this poll was taken five months ago, nothing has changed regarding the quality of life for Iraqis in that time. I doubt that Iraqis are particularly concened or buoyed by the reports of Al-Qaeda being "on the run". That's the least of their problems.

From military.com, hardly a liberal media outlet.
link
Poll: Iraqis Losing Hope
Associated Press | March 20, 2007
WASHINGTON - The optimism that helped sustain Iraqis during the first few years of the war has dissolved into widespread fear, anger and distress amid unrelenting violence, a survey found.

The poll - the third in Iraq since early 2004 by ABC News and media partners - draws a stark portrait of an increasingly pessimistic population under great emotional stress. Among the findings of this survey for ABC News, USA Today, the BBC and ARD German TV:

Poll: Is Iraq better off today than it was before the war?

-The number of Iraqis who say their own life is going well has dipped from 71 percent in November 2005 to 39 percent now.

-About three-fourths of Iraqis report feelings of anger, depression and difficulty concentrating.

-More than half of Iraqis have curtailed activities like going out of their homes, going to markets or other crowded places and traveling through police checkpoints.

-Only 18 percent of Iraqis have confidence in U.S. and coalition troops, and 86 percent are concerned that someone in their household will be a victim of violence.

-Slightly more than half of Iraqis - 51 percent - now say that violence against U.S. forces is acceptable - up from 17 percent who felt that way in early 2004. More than nine in 10 Sunni Arabs in Iraq now feel this way.

-While 63 percent said they felt very safe in their neighborhoods in late 2005, only 26 percent feel that way now.

The major cause for this sharp reversal in Iraqi attitudes is the continuing violence - bombings, attacks by roving gunmen and kidnappings - that has overwhelmed the country since the U.S. invasion four years ago this week.

Eighty percent of Iraqis surveyed reported some kind of violence nearby, according to the nationally representative survey conducted Feb. 25 to March 5 among 2,212 Iraqis, including oversamples in Anbar province, the Sadr City section of Baghdad, Basra and Kirkuk. Results were subject to a sampling error margin of plus or minus 2.5 percentage points. The survey was done by D3 Systems, a pollster specializing in conflict countries

Iraqi civilian deaths are estimated at more than 54,000, possibly much higher. More than half of Iraqis surveyed said a friend or relative has been hurt or killed in the violence, while almost nine in 10 worried that a loved one will be hurt.

The levels of stress soar outside relatively peaceful Kurdistan, especially in Baghdad and the Sunni-dominated Anbar province, the poll found.

Fewer than half in the country, 42 percent, said that life in Iraq now is better than it was under Saddam Hussein, the late dictator accused of murdering tens of thousands during a brutal regime.

Iraqis pessimism about safety spills over into their views of most aspects of life - the economy, basic needs like power and clean water, even the risks of sending their children to school.

But views of the U.S. military presence are contradictory among Iraqis - just as they are in this country.

About four in five Iraqis oppose the presence of U.S. troops but only a third want those U.S. troops to leave Iraq immediately.

Conducting the face-to-face poll was a difficult ordeal in such a violent country. More than 100 Iraqi interviewers conducted the poll and some reported seeing bombings, beatings and even a mass kidnapping. Several teams of interviewers were detained by police - but every interviewer made it home safely.




Blast from the past

In September 2006, during an interview on Meet The Press, the Vice-President said the following regarding the invasion of Iraq:

The U.S. invasion “was the right thing to do, and if we had to do it again, we would do exactly the same thing,” he said.

I just had to dig that one up.

Memo says British military is at the breaking point

This is the second "secret" memo from the British military this week. The earlier memo included remarks from senior MOD officials that Iraq was "a lost cause".
Bush's ill-considered invasion and long occupation has now broken the world's two most powerful militaries, but we still "need more time" before results wil be apparent, or so the talking points say.

full story

We're running out of troops, warns army chief



· Defence memo leak says virtually no reserves left
· 'Intense tempo of life' due to Iraq and Afghan fighting


Richard Norton-Taylor
Saturday July 21, 2007
The Guardian


The head of the army has warned that Britain is almost running out of troops to defend the country or fight in military operations abroad.

The warning by General Sir Richard Dannatt, chief of the general staff, to fellow defence chiefs comes at a time when the army is asking for a big increase in reservists to be deployed in Afghanistan, reflecting a crisis in Britain's armed forces.

In a secret memorandum he says: "We now have almost no capability to react to the unexpected." Reinforcements for emergencies or for operations in Iraq or Afghanistan were "now almost non-existent".
He adds: "The enduring nature and scale of current operations continues to stretch people". Gen Dannatt warns the army had to "augment" 2,500 troops from other units for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan to bring up the total force to the 13,000 needed there. This remained "far higher than we ever assumed", he says.

He continues: "When this is combined with the effects of under-manning (principally in the infantry and Royal Artillery) and the pace of training support needed to prepare units for operations, the tempo of life in the Field Army is intense." While the current situation was "manageable", Gen Dannatt said he was "concerned about the longer term implications of the impact of this level of operations on our people, equipment and future operational capability".

The general's warnings, in a document leaked to the Daily Telegraph, come at a time when the Ministry of Defence and the Treasury are finalising spending plans for the next three years in the comprehensive spending review expected to be revealed in October. The three service chiefs are arguing among themselves about how the money should be spent. The navy is expected next week to be told it will get two new aircraft carriers at a cost of between £2bn and £3bn and fewer destroyers and frigates than it wants.

Gordon Brown, the prime minister who as chancellor fought regularly with the MoD, has told defence chiefs to sort out a deal among themselves, according to defence sources.

As the army has been forced to call up 600 reservists for Afghanistan there is only one Spearhead battalion of 500 troops, available for an emergency.

Gen Dannatt's memo says Britain's other rapid deployment unit, the Airborne Task Force, made up mainly of Paras, was unable to fully deploy "due to shortages in manpower, equipment and stocks".

It is not the first time Gen Dannatt has expressed concern about pressure on the army. Soon after he took up his post last August he told the Guardian that the army was "running hot" and called for a national debate on defence.



This is the price paid for handing over the British military to a delusional American President. Any other countries want to get in on this "success"? I thought not. Let's at least hope that the British military has learned a crucial lesson from this.


Why we will win in Iraq

While I generally try to avoid cross-posting from other blogs, I am making an exception today.
I check out Joy Tomme's Ratbang Diary most every day, and her latest post, entitled "Here's the Thing" is succint and to-the-point. I encourage readers to examine it. An excerpt follows:


No matter what deadline dates the Bush administration sets for itself regarding the war in Iraq, the dates will be pushed ahead, fudged and lied about ad infinitum. The criteria used for progress or success in Iraq will be lowered and changed ad infinitum. The definition of Al Qaeda, where it is and how effective it is will be changed according to the whim of the Bush administration ad infinitum. The standard used to gauge the effectiveness of the insurgents against US troops will be changed according to the Bush administration’s latest lies about the war in Iraq ad infinitum.


This is precisely why Bush has no credibility, and also why those who continue to support the occupation can always believe we are "winning" and just need more time. The attacks against are troops are up? Well, the "enemy" is obviously "desperate". The attacks against our troops are down? See, we're "winning". Militias killed a dozen more people today? Silly, it's Al-Qaeda that matters. Let those crazy Muslims kill each other off and good riddance. More talk of withdrawal? No! If we leave then those poor innocent Iraqis will perish in a bloodbath. They voted, after all!

And so it goes, year after year. We are always "winning", always on the verge of "victory", though "the fight is hard". And Muslims are always trying to get you to bow down to Allah and make your daughter wear a burqa, so we can't "lose". Criticising the occupation only "emboldens the enemy", so support Bush unless you want your family blown up in a terrorist attack. Treason! Treason, I say! No matter what the cost, we must "win" in Iraq, but don't ask me to pay taxes to cover the cost. We have to bring democracy to Iraq, but those damn Iraqi politicians had better do what Bush says. The media is biased against Bush! And here's a media report that proves we are turning the corner in Iraq! So there!

It's hardly surprising, but once Bush is finally out of office, these same supporters will suddenly be all about the failure of whomever takes over in Iraq. Dissent will once again be a sacred right, and not an insult to the troops. Every death will be heralded as proof of incompetence, rather than as proof that we need to "stay the course". And these people will simply never recognise the disconnect.