Showing posts with label British. Show all posts
Showing posts with label British. Show all posts

Friday, November 23, 2007

British Army facing "manpower crisis"

A few days ago we saw a report saying that the British military was running out money. Now we see they are running out of troops, as well. The U.S. military, already forced to use stop-loss and lower its recruiting standards, is depending more and more on the allies to pick up the slack.

Meanwhile, Bush's ally in Australia, Howard, may not survive the next election. Australia may very well join the list of nations that have abandoned the Decider's quest for endless war.

Could it be that that the world, along with the U.S. public, has turned its back on Bush's vision of a decades-long conflict known as the Long War? Or has it merely found it impossible to sustain?

Army crisis as number of troops leaving soars


By Thomas Harding, Defence Correspondent
Last Updated: 2:37am GMT 23/11/2007

The Army is facing a major shortfall in manpower after the latest figures released today showed that the number of troops leaving had increased by 50 per cent in the last year.

The difficulty in finding troops for the frontline has become evident after the Ministry of Defence admitted it was short of 4,500 soldiers - the equivalent of almost an entire brigade.

With most of the Army on continuous operations for the last four years in Iraq and Afghanistan the strain on soldiers and their families has been immense.

In the last two years the manning shortage of soldiers excluding officers has more than quadrupled from 1,000 to the most recent figure making the Army short of nine battalions in manpower.

The MoD's requirement for soldiers is 88,450 but yesterday the figure stood at 83,860 which includes almost 7,000 men recruited from Commonwealth countries.

More worryingly the number of people resigning from the Army has increased by 10 per cent in the last year to 12,500.

The figures come after former head of the Army Gen Sir Mike Jackson warned that the Armed Forces are facing a cash "crisis" raising doubts over whether the military will be able to pay for future operations.

Bernard Jenkin, a Tory member of the Commons Defence Committee, said the latest figures were "absolutely appalling".

"The problem of retaining soldiers in the Army is not just about very modest pay and conditions this is about the strain of operations and the stress on family life caused by long periods of separation.

"There comes a point where people feel forced to choose and the family inevitably comes first – after all, what we are fighting for is for our families and children."

Derek Twigg, the defence minister, said the MoD was "addressing manning challenges" by adjusting policies and "using long-term strategies" to recruit and retain people.

There was positive news that, perhaps attracted by media reports of fighting on the front in Afghanistan, there has been a 25-per-cent increase in young men signing up for the infantry in the last year.

But overall the Armed Forces are now lacking almost 7,000 personnel out of a total required force of 181,000.

The MoD said it hoped to improve the manning figures under its Service Personnel Plan which will take into account the demands of family life.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Liberal Democrats' acting leader Vincent Cable said criticism had been "personalised" against Gordon Brown because, as chancellor: "He signed the cheque for 5bn for the war in Iraq at a time when the armed forces were already overstretched.

"That is why the troops are under-equipped, they are not properly housed, they are not cared for when they are injured - and they are very angry."

Organisations like the Royal British Legion say the armed forces are over-stretched and under-funded, and say that while 4.4% of GDP was spent on defence in the early 1980s, today it is about 2.3%.

The BBC's defence correspondent Caroline Wyatt said the real question, was whether the armed forces were being asked to do too much on the available resources.

Long-term defence planning failed to predict that Britain would be fighting two medium-sized campaigns on two fronts simultaneously, and facing lengthy ongoing commitments as a result.

The last full review, which tried to match the armed forces to the threats they expected to counter, was carried out in 1998.

"The overstretch in the budget has led to calls from some for a new strategic defence review, which would outline exactly what military role and aims Britain wants to pursue - and how much it's prepared to pay for that," she said.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

British Army running out of money

It would seem that senior British military leaders have realised, and are starting to voice, the costs of following Bush's trail on the War On Terror. The War On Terror seems to be little more than a war on nations that don't kiss Bush's ass sincerely enough, and it's only diminishing America's respect in the world.

In Iraq, we essentially went after a loudmouth dictator and implied he was responsible for 9/11. Despite the majority of the hijackers of the 9/11 attacks being Saudis, we instead cozied up to Saudi Arabia. Now another loudmouth, albeit elected, is being portrayed as dangerous and an invasion is being scheduled.

Meanwhile, the federal tribal areas of Pakistan (where Bin Laden is believed to be - remember him?) is even more chaotic and more sympathetic to the Taliban than it was before Bush launched his overly-optimistic effort there. The man continually plans for only the best outcomes, and never thinks of formulating a "Plan B", because everything always goes our way in the movies, I guess.

Now the British public is going to have to come up with the cash to finance the endless wars. Unlike the dollar, the pound is not the world's reserve currency and borrowing money to finance wars is very expensive. None of these wars promise to make any money for the participants. In fact, in Iraq the plan was to let the multinational oil companies buy the oil for cheap and sell it back to us at huge profits. These aren't 'American" or British" companies; they are huge conglomerates with no loyalty to any nation. How much are Britons willing to pay to keep the Decider from having to admit his incompetence?


Armed forces 'are running out of money'


By Thomas Harding Defence Correspondent
Last Updated: 1:48pm GMT 20/11/2007

The former head of the Army has warned that the Forces are facing a cash crisis with it becoming unlikely that the military will be able to pay for future operations.
Gen Sir Mike Jackson said recent spending commitments by the Chancellor Alistair Darling were likely to prove insufficient to pay for future operations.
The officer, who has been critical of the Government since retiring as Chief of the General Staff, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "I fear there is some sort of crunch on the horizon."
He added: "I detect, I fear, some crisis ahead in defence spending, if things go on as they are in terms of what we do, what we might have to do and the money allocated."
Despite the Government announcing an extra £400 million for operations in last month’s pre budget report on top of a 1.5 per cent increase in the defence budget, Gen Jackson said this was still not enough.
The MoD is currently battling with the Treasury over funding of equipment projects and payment for vehicles being used in Iraq and Afghanistan.
There are significant worries that without proper funding the military are going to continue to lose substantial numbers of troops fed up with poor pay, accommodation and constant operations.
The Treasury’s offer of extra funding was still unlikely to prove enough for the fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan or for potential future engagements.
Gen Jackson suggested that what people “never really grasped” was there would not be enough funding “to do the things which we do now and the things which we may have to do in the future".
The officer, who was replaced by Gen Sir Richard Dannatt after he retired last year, acknowledged British defence spending was already above the European average.
But he insisted such a comparison risked ignoring Britain’s "strategic" needs and suggested that Britain's influence in the world could wane.
"The analysis must start in logic from what it is that the UK thinks is its part to play in a very uncertain and difficult world," he went on.
"You've got to get that analysis right because from that then flows the tools you need... to do the job."
Since resigning, Gen Jackson has criticised the M0D's treatment of soldiers, particularly in the standards of pay and living accommodation.
He said today there was a widespread recognition that the conditions of service for army personnel were "not how they should be".

Sunday, November 04, 2007

British Army report says Iraq war was badly planned

Not a big surprise, in total, but the specifics are interesting. Following Bush's example, the reports from the British "boots on the ground" were "hopelessly optimistic". As I've said before, military campaigns are not football matches; cheerleading cannot take the place of sober analysis. You simply cannot make decisions based on intelligence that has been shaped to put a positive spin on the situation.

Also, as has been widely suspected for years, the U.S. drove the operation with its own agenda with little or no regard for the British situation. Everything was planned for a quick victory scenario, with no clear planning for the occupation beyond victory speeches and heroic claims. Plan "B" was simply more of the same. Thus, despite the boundless optimism, the peace was lost within 100 days. Plan "B" turned into a snarling campaign of treason accusations against critics who noticed that things weren't going as well as expected.

And, of course, the infamous Decider secrecy was imposed on the British, which worked against the planning by excluding anyone who wasn't "hopelessly optimistic". This is what happens when loyalty is your primary consideration; you only hear what you want to hear and only plan for the best possible outcome.

While this was a secret report that was leaked from British Army, one can only wonder if the American military is engaging in similar introspection. Perhaps the Bush Administration "yes men" and minders have prevented our military from learning from this debacle.

story from the Daily Telegraph:

Iraq war was badly planned, says Army


Sean Rayment, Defence Correspondent
Last Updated: 2:16am GMT 04/11/2007

A leaked internal Army report has delivered an unprecedented attack on the planning and execution of the war in Iraq.
The document, which openly condemns British and US foreign policy, says that "leaders should not start an operation without thinking through the options and implications of their plans".

It claims that widespread planning failures in the post-war phase led to the peace in Iraq being lost by September 2003, within the first 100 days of the occupation.
The report, marked "restricted", adds that many senior officers now believe that the Government has developed a "bureaucratic approach to problem solving" and is "no longer capable" of running large scale military operations such as the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The 16-page document describes how the Iraq campaign was undermined by a lack of planning, resources, funding and intelligence.
"The evidence shows that too little planning was done for Operation Telic [the codename for the war in Iraq] particularly on the non-military side, and that too few resources, both human and financial were allocated to the post-war situation," it says.
The report, drawn up in late 2006, suggests that Britain and the US may have breeched the Geneva Convention by failing properly to conduct their duties as "occupying powers".
It also says that assessments by British commanders on the success of their reconstruction efforts were "hopelessly optimistic". The secrecy surrounding the operation, the report claims, meant that government departments were unable to plan for the post-war phase until December 2002 - just three months before the start of the invasion.
The report, entitled An Analysis of Operation Telic, makes no apology for the stark criticisms contained within it nor for the embarrassment it will cause the Government.
Instead, the document, which is part of a wider study called Theme Zero, says that the "Army has a duty to learn from experience". The report states:
• The British headquarters suffered from a lack of good quality officers
• Lack of planning put Britain and the US, as occupying powers, in "breach" of the Geneva Convention
• Lack of planning resulted in delays before essential reconstruction could begin
• Not enough funding was requested by senior commanders or approved by the Treasury
• British commanders were forced to work to an ideologically driven US timetable
• Restrictive operational security meant that few people in Government were involved in planning.
The report also says that the main focus of US commanders was the stabilisation of Baghdad and that they were "unresponsive" to the concerns of their British counter-parts for the worsening situation in southern Iraq.
One officer wrote that the Britain was committed to an ideologically driven US timetable, adding: "The train was on Grand Central station, and was leaving at a time which we did not control."
The report says "the multinational headquarters suffered from a lack of good quality British officers with formal staff training", a situation which persisted until the military secretary, who advises the secretary of state for defence, intervened to ensure that officers of the correct calibre- were posted to Iraq.
Crucially, the document claims that the British were unable to win the "hearts and minds" of the Iraqis because they failed to understand Arab culture. One officer wrote: "We may be able to influence their minds but we will never win the (Islamic) heart.

Saturday, September 15, 2007

Half of British troops to leave Iraq

Now that British troops have moved to an air base on the outskirts of Basra, they are set to move half of their forces to Kuwait by the end of the year. This will leave South Korea, with its 3500 troops who never leave their base, as the second-largest "ally" in Iraq. Seven other countries have less than 100 troops in Iraq and these provide no counter-insurgency role. It's rapidly becoming an American-only effort, with the rest of the world wanting nothing to do with it. Those that do stay have an agenda that has little to do with Iraq. Georgia, for example, with its 300 troops in Iraq, wants to stay on Bush's good side so that the U.S. will protect it from Russian hegemony. For the sake of 300 troops in this disaster, we are setting ourselves up for involvement in yet another conflict with Russia. The same goes for the seven or so Eastern European nations with troops in Iraq; they want our support against Russia, so they send their token forces. Latvia has two troops in Iraq, for example.

Bush is desperately trying to push the UN into Iraq, but the rest of the world doesn't seem to be taking the bait. Bush said we would "go it alone" in Iraq, if necessary. The world is apparently taking him at word.

So not only is the occupation of Iraq setting up wars against Iran and Syria, it is setting us up for long-term military confrontations with Turkey and Russia. This is at the same time as we defend Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. Then there is Venezuela, where the apparent plan seems to be to back the Zulia governor in a secessionist movement. Zulia province has oil, so we are, of course, deeply concerned about it. Since Venezuela is a democracy where its leader, Chavez, is repeatedly re-elected by higher percentages than Bush got, we can't really sell the "liberation" angle there. And Al-Qaeda is certainly not involved in the Chazez government. Any action in Venezuela will require a massive distortion of the truth, but the Bush Administration seems quite willing and able to step up to the plate in that regard. We've spent a lot of money propping up the death-squad government in Colombia, so a proxy war will most likely be in order. We simply don't have the troops for much else, but we can easily make life so miserable for Venezuelans so that they overthrow Chavez, such as we did in Nicaragua. See, that's what makes us the "good guys", so we deserve that Venezuelan oil.

Oh, and there's still the little matter of Afghanistan, where Bush is trying to push the mess off on to NATO. That's how Canada got sucked into Bush's rose-coloured world. The bungles by the Bush Administration, due to its habit of over-optimistically assessing every situation, have basically set us back to the starting point in Afghanistan. Both Canada and Britain are paying a bloody price for a pat on the back from the Decider, while Bush offers little more than "in for a penny, in for a pound" to his allies. It's not that the mission in Afghanistan is not worthwhile, but rather that Bush has completely and horribly messed it up and is abusing our allies in the process. How are we safer with fewer allies, and with the ones that we have left battered and bloodied? Does the world really need a superpower that simultaneously is unrealistically optimistic and that sees only military solutions to every problem? Does it need one that views its allies as expendable pawns to be bankrupted and bled white for domestic political cover? I don't think so.


Basra troops 'will move to Kuwait'


By Thomas Harding in Basra
Last Updated: 3:34am BST 15/09/2007

British troop numbers in Iraq are expected to be halved by December, with about 2,500 soldiers moving to Kuwait, The Daily Telegraph has learnt.


A team of officers from Permanent Joint Headquarters in Northwood has spent the past week in Basra reviewing the number of soldiers needed following the withdrawal of the last battalion from Basra Palace a fortnight ago.

It is expected that they will recommend approximately halving the force of more than 5,000 now based at Basra air station after full control of the province is passed to the Iraqis, probably in November.

The troops leaving Iraq would operate from a new base in neighbouring Kuwait, from which they would escort convoys and train Iraqi forces.

Military chiefs are negotiating with the Kuwaitis and a new barracks, called the Kuwait Support Base, should be operational by the end of the year.

However, the reduction of British troop numbers in Iraq, that will begin with 250 men from the King's Royal Hussars leaving at the end of this month, is expected to cause political problems, with America worried that a key area of Iraq is being abandoned.

The PJHQ group is expected to report before Gordon Brown meets Gen David Petraeus, the US commander in Iraq, and Ryan Crocker, the US ambassador to Baghdad, in London next week.

The Prime Minister is expected to thrash out the details of reducing the troop numbers and finding a compromise that will be acceptable to the allies. He will then make a statement to Parliament on the future of Iraq in early October.

Speaking after President George W Bush announced that more than 5,000 US troops would be withdrawn from Iraq by Christmas, Mr Brown said that decisions on the future size and strength of British forces would depend on "conditions on the ground".

"Like America, Britain will discharge our duties to the Iraqi people, to our allies and to the international community," he said.

"And as President Bush did last night, I repeat that we will meet our responsibilities and honour our obligations."

Mr Brown's spokesman said: "We have to make our decisions based on our assessment of military conditions in the south. The Americans clearly made their decisions based on their assessment of conditions elsewhere in Iraq."

With its huge oil wealth, proximity to Iran and straddling a major supply route, Basra province is a key player for the future of Iraq. Because of this, US troops are likely to be deployed there if it is felt the British force too weak.


Let's look at the other "allies". From the Daily Telegraph:

He [Bush] addressed the "international community" as well as the American people, and thanked "the 36 nations who have troops on the ground in Iraq", which surprised me somewhat because there are now only 21 nations left on the ground in Iraq, from Albania to the UK, by way of Kazakhstan, El Salvador and the Czech Republic. Apart from the Americans, only two nations have more than 1,000 troops in Iraq (South Korea and us) and seven have fewer than 100 troops who don't do any war-fighting or counter-insurgency.

South Korea never did do any war-fighting. In 2004, a brigade's worth of South Koreans was sent to Kurdistan on a "humanitarian mission": their government insisted, John Reid-style, that they were hoping to perform said mission without a shot being fired. I don't think they have fired a shot yet.

Their mission consisted of major construction works: they built a large defensive base to house their 3,500 men and only ever left it for short, pre-planned hearts and minds jobs in Erbil schools. When the Koreans do leave, there will be a nice, modern, well-built, forward operating base for American troops to continue Operation Enduring Relationship with the Iraqi People.
----

Since Prime Minister Maliki's government cannot even trust its own security forces to guard the Green Zone (now officially called the IZ or International Zone) that contains his own parliament building, he will be relieved that only 4,700 are leaving.

Security inside the zone is controlled by Kurdish peshmergas, who are reckoned to be aloof from the Shia-Sunni sectarian nightmare.

Security at the entry checkpoints is controlled by a private security company, Triple Canopy, that mans them with Peruvian peasants who speak neither Arabic nor English. Very international.



Sunday, September 02, 2007

British troops withdraw to air base

British troops, despite insults and mockery from the Bush Administration, have withdrawn from Basra. By the end of the year they will be completely withdrawn so that they can focus on Bush's other miracle: Afghanistan.


British Troops Leave Basra Base in Iraq

Sep 2, 5:36 PM (ET)
By DAVID STRINGER
LONDON (AP) - British soldiers began withdrawing Sunday from their final remaining base inside the southern Iraqi city of Basra, a move likely to prompt a further reduction in troop numbers, lawmakers and officials said.
Around 550 soldiers stationed in Basra Palace were leaving the downtown site to join 5,000 other personnel at an air base camp on the fringes of the city - ending their permanent presence in Iraq's second largest city.
The Iraqi military sent hundreds of reinforcements to the city to prevent Shiite militias and criminal gangs from expanding their influence now that the British have gone.
The decision to leave the palace compound - targeted with daily mortar and rocker attack in recent months - will hand military commanders an option of pulling around 550 troops out of Iraq in the autumn, lawmakers said.

"We're withdrawing personnel," said a British defense ministry spokesman, on customary condition of anonymity. "It's been our long planned intention to leave the palace."
Prime Minister Gordon Brown, who is due to set out future strategy for British operations in Iraq in a speech to parliament next month, was aware of the operation, a government official said.
Decisions made by ex-leader Tony Blair to reduce Britain's troops numbers in Iraq from 7,000 to 5,500 earlier this year left an option of pulling out around 500 more personnel once the Basra Palace base was handed back to Iraqis.
"It has always been our intention to draw down troops in Basra" as Iraqi army and police become ready to handle security duties, said a spokesman for Brown's Downing Street office, speaking on condition of anonymity.
In Basra, Major Mike Shearer, Britain's military spokesman, told reporters he could not disclose precise details of the withdrawal. "I can confirm that an operation is ongoing, but we will not give any further details," Shearer said.
The base has been used by Britain to house soldiers and diplomatic staff since the 2003 U.S.-led invasion.
With the British drawdown, U.S. and Iraqi authorities have expressed concern about the land supply line from Kuwait to Baghdad and beyond and security of the oil fields - until now under the eye of British troops.
The withdrawal occurred in the midst of a power struggle between rival Shiite groups throughout southern Iraq, and some analysts fear violence will continue as the British continue to draw down their forces.
Last week, the head of the security committee on the Basra city council, Hakim al-Miyahi, predicted "some disorder" after the British pullout from the city because he feared that Iraqi forces were incapable of maintaining order.
After the election in January 2005 that brought Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki to power, the city fell under the influence of Shiite religious parties and militias, some with ties to Iran.
The police force is heavily infiltrated by militias. Political rivals, liquor dealers, DVD shop owners and anyone who violated different groups' interpretations of Islam was subject to assassination by death squads.
With additional Iraqi soldiers in the streets, residents say things have quieted in recent weeks.
"This is not an unexpected move, but the families of the service personnel involved will want to know that every possible precaution has been taken to maximize their safety during this period," opposition Conservative party lawmaker Liam Fox said.
Britain's Sunday Times newspaper reported Sunday British forces could hand over responsibility for Basra as early as next month.
The defense ministry has previously said it hopes to hand security responsibility for Basra, the last remaining province under its command, to Iraqi forces sometime this autumn.
"This is a thoroughly sensible military decision," said opposition Conservative lawmaker Patrick Mercer. "It will allow more troops to be withdrawn from Iraq in the autumn, just as Britain increases its numbers of troops in Afghanistan."

British general: U.S. Iraq policy "intellectually bankrupt"

Here we see a military opinion from our strongest ally, Britain, that parallels the one domestic critics of the Iraq occupation have been making for years. Bush and Rumsfeld completely bungled post-war Iraq, directly leading to a prolonged and extremely expensive occupation with thousands of military casualties. They then bungled that occupation for years while continually claiming progress that was nothing more than imaginary. Then, after creating an unfathomable mess, the U.S. tried the surge in an effort to correct four years of ineptitude in nine months time. Other than buying Bush nine months to postpone judgment on his failed occupation, the surge has produced only modest progress, and then only in isolated areas. Sectarian killings are up, when compared to last year's levels, Al-Qaeda is merely "off-balance", the Iraqi Police are incompetent, corrupt and disloyal to the Iraqi government, and the Iraqi miltary is in perpetual "training" while also being more loyal to the sectarian militias than the government. The Iraqi government itself has been impotent and incompetent since its inception, and now is on the verge of collapse.

This is what we have waited so long for: a marginally-improved disaster at a cost of $12 billion a week.

Britain tried a surge of their own one year ago, and it brought only short-term results. The MOD was wise enough to see the handwriting on the wall and handed over control to the Iraqis. Now they are besieged on their bases and control has shifted to the Iraqis, for better or worse. Bush's response has been to apply the not-so-dreaded "surrenderist" label to their ally.

The surge cannot last much longer than April, since the tours of duty will be over by then for most of the surge troops. Recruiting is down, re-enlistments are down, the junior officers are deserting the military in droves, and the senior officers have staked their careers on pleasing an Administration that their peers in Britain describe as "incompetent". After the surge, then what? Are we then back to the pre-surge non-plan of crossing our fingers and hoping for a miracle? No, the plan at that point is to create another false hope (e.g. Allawi-led government, militia truce, another Iraqi brigade, etc.) that will buy Bush more "wait and see" time until his term expires. And the war supporters will eagerly lap up the next "solution" as the key to "victory", just as they did the surge.


UK general attacks US Iraq policy

The head of the British army during the Iraq invasion has said US post-war policy was "intellectually bankrupt".

In a Daily Telegraph interview, former chief of the general staff, Gen Sir Mike Jackson, added that US strategy had been "short-sighted".

He said former US defence secretary Donald Rumsfeld was "one of the most responsible for the current situation".

The Ministry of Defence said Sir Mike was a private citizen who was entitled to express his views.

The US Department of Defense said: "Divergent viewpoints are a hallmark of open, democratic societies."

Sir Mike told the Daily Telegraph that Mr Rumsfeld's claim that US forces "don't do nation-building" was "nonsensical".

He criticised the decision to hand control of planning the administration of Iraq after the war to the Pentagon.

He also described the disbanding of the Iraqi army and security forces after the overthrow of Saddam Hussein as "very short-sighted".

"We should have kept the Iraqi security services in being and put them under the command of the coalition," he said.

Mehdi army

The Telegraph reports that in Sir Mike's autobiography Soldier, which is being serialised in the paper, he said the US approach to fighting global terrorism was "inadequate" as it focused on military power rather than diplomacy and nation-building.

In the book, Sir Mike also said Mr Rumsfeld had refused to deploy enough troops to uphold law and order in Iraq and had rejected plans for administering Iraq drawn up by the US State Department, the paper says.

The criticism comes as the US military said an order from radical Iraqi Shia cleric Moqtada al-Sadr to his Mehdi army militia to freeze operations for six months would allow coalition forces to concentrate their attentions on al-Qaeda.

A US statement said the instruction would mean fewer kidnappings, killings and attacks.

Sir Mike, who is now retired, also defended the record of British troops in Iraq after claims by US officials that UK forces had failed.

He said: "What has happened in the south, as throughout the rest of Iraq, was that primary responsibility for security would be handed to the Iraqis once the Iraqi authorities and the coalition were satisfied that their state of training and development was appropriate.

"In the south we had responsibility for four provinces. Three of these have been handed over in accordance with that strategy. It remains just in Basra for that to happen."

His comments follow a series of critical remarks from US officials about the British attitude towards Iraq.

'Strain on operation'

US military adviser Gen Jack Keane said last week that American commanders had expressed "frustration" over the prospect of UK withdrawal.

BBC defence correspondent Paul Wood said Sir Mike's comments may put further strain on the British-US operation in Iraq.

Sir Mike's criticisms were backed by Sir Malcolm Rifkind, former Conservative foreign secretary and defence secretary.

Sir Malcolm told the BBC: "I think one of the most fundamental criticisms is not just that Rumsfeld was incompetent - which he was - but it was actually his boss, George Bush, who actually made the extraordinary decision to put the Pentagon and Rumsfeld in control of political nation-building after the actual war ended."

A spokeswoman for the US State Department said she would not comment on Sir Mike's views.

Liberal Democrat leader Sir Menzies Campbell said Sir Mike's remarks reinforced his view that British troops should leave Iraq as soon as is practically possible.

He told BBC News 24 that Sir Mike was "a man well known for speaking his mind and not afraid to ruffle American feathers".

Last week, Prime Minister Gordon Brown wrote to Mr Campbell, rejecting the Lib Dem leader's call for a timetable for withdrawing UK troops.

Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/uk/6973618.stm

Published: 2007/09/01 14:58:43 GMT

Saturday, August 18, 2007

British generals tell Brown to withdraw from Basra

I'd like to point out the remark from a "senior British military commander":
“That’s to miss the point. It was never that kind of battle, in which we set out to defeat an enemy.”

also: it was never the role of occupation troops to intervene in a “turf war” among factions from the same community, all of which have links to the government coalition in Baghdad.

You see, our forces in Iraq are engaged in an OCCUPATION, not a BATTLE. You can only referee an occupation, you can't win it, because you have already won when you defeated the country's military that you are occupying. When neocons say that they want to "win" in Iraq, they miss the point; we already won. Now we're just hanging around acting as a police force in the middle of a civil war, trying to use military force to solve political, economic and social problems.

Sadly, the rest of the world is looking at how the White House is treating it's staunchest ally, and its not getting a pretty picture. Those who criticise Britain for failing to follow Bush to the bitter end are only saying to our allies (and those considering strengthening their alliance with us) that the U.S. does not consider their allies as anything more than proxies for American foreign policy. Is this our appreciation for Britain's support - to throw them to the wolves and denounce them as something akin to cowards for falling for Bush's thumbs-up, smiley-faced assertions and taking their military to the brink of collapse to save Bush's ego? This is the essence of Bush's supreme arrogance: the rest of the world exists only to serve our interests and those elements that cease to be useful to our interests will be discarded with contempt. That approach will win over a lot of governments to our side, won't it? It's the arrogant politics of a bully nation, not a world superpower trying to bring peace and democracy to the downtrodden and victimised.

The British people should be outraged at this shoddy treatment.

Those other nations in the coalition should take it as an object lesson.

The American people should reject the Bush Administration's callous assessment of the British military and voice their appreciation of Britain's courage.


Military commanders tell Brown to withdraw from Iraq without delay

By Raymond Whitaker and Robert Fox

Senior military commanders have told the Government that Britain can achieve “nothing more” in south-east Iraq, and that the 5,500 British troops still deployed there should move towards withdrawal without further delay.

Last month Gordon Brown said after meeting George Bush at Camp David that the decision to hand over security in Basra province – the last of the four held by the British – “will be made on the military advice of our commanders on the ground”. He added: “Whatever happens, we will make a full statement to Parliament when it returns [in October].”

Two generals told The Independent on Sunday last week that the military advice given to the Prime Minister was, “We’ve done what we can in the south [of Iraq]”. Commanders want to hand over Basra Palace – where 500 British troops are subjected to up to 60 rocket and mortar strikes a day, and resupply convoys have been described as “nightly suicide missions” – by the end of August. The withdrawal of 500 soldiers has already been announced by the Government. The Army is drawing up plans to “reposture” the 5,000 that will be left at Basra airport, and aims to bring the bulk of them home in the next few months.

Before the invasion in 2003, officers were told that the Army’s war aims were to bring stability and democracy to Iraq and to the Middle East as a whole. Those ambitions have been drastically revised, the IoS understands. The priorities now are an orderly withdrawal, with the reputation and capability of the Army “reasonably intact”, and for Britain to remain a “credible ally”. The final phrase appears to refer to tensions with the US, which has more troops in Iraq than at any other time, including the invasion, as it seeks to impose order in Baghdad and neighbouring provinces.

American criticism of Britain’s desire to pull back in southern Iraq has recently become public, with a US intelligence official telling The Washington Post this month that “the British have basically been defeated in the south”. A senior British commander countered, “That’s to miss the point. It was never that kind of battle, in which we set out to defeat an enemy.” Other officers said the British force was never configured to “clear and hold” Basra in the way the Americans are seeking to do in Baghdad.

Immediate American discontent is said to centre on the CIA’s reluctance to leave Basra Palace, an important base for watching Iran, which may explain why Britain has held on to the complex until now. But last week it was reported that US intelligence operatives were in the process of pulling out. Further ahead, the US is concerned over the security of its vital supply line from Kuwait, with some American commanders saying that if the British withdraw, American troops will have to be sent south to replace them. As the hub of Iraq’s oil industry, Basra is also a tempting prize for the Shia militias battling each other for control.

There are fears that the bloody power struggle in Basra will escalate sharply if and when British troops depart, but commanders point out that up to 90 per cent of the violence is directed against their forces. They are understood to believe it was never the role of occupation troops to intervene in a “turf war” among factions from the same community, all of which have links to the government coalition in Baghdad.

Mr Brown will have to take these wider concerns into account, in reaching a decision that has political as well as military implications. At Camp David he stressed that “we have duties to discharge and responsibilities to keep” in support of the Iraqi government and “the explicit will” of the international community. The 15 September report on the progress of the security “surge” by the US commander in Iraq, General David Petraeus, and the American ambassador to Baghdad, Ryan Crocker, will be crucial to British as well as US military plans.

General Petraeus is expected to report mixed results, and to plead for more time for the surge to work. But the White House, under pressure from Republicans facing disaster in the 2008 elections, is likely to announce at least some troop reductions. British commanders, and some US commentators, believe that will enable the Prime Minister to spell out plans for a British withdrawal when MPs return in October, although the process may last well into next year.

British and American forces killed in Afghanistan

Success is "just around the corner" in Afghanistan, and we know that because the "terrorists" are "desperate" enough to attack British bases. And the roadside bomb that killed three U.S. soldiers doesn't "count", since including bombings would "hand
the terrorists a big victory". In fact, the mere act of counting or even reporting deaths of coalition troops only serves to 'embolden' our enemies, so please ignore the story below.


From Times Online
August 12, 2007
Four soldiers killed in Afghanistan
Times Online

A British soldier and three American soldiers have been killed in separate incidents in Afghanistan.

The British serviceman, from 1st Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, was injured when his base, north-east of Sangin in the volatile Helmand Province in southern Afghanistan, came under attack from small arms fire, rocket propelled grenades, and indirect fire, at about 1.20pm on Saturday. He was taken by helicopter to Camp Bastion, but did not survive. The soldier’s family have been informed, the Ministry of Defence said.

A roadside bomb blast killed the three American troops in eastern Afghanistan on Sunday. They were engaged in combat operations in Nangarhar province when the bomb hit their vehicle, a statement from the US-led coalition said. A civilian interpreter was also killed. The coalition did not announce the nationalities of the soldiers though the majority of troops in eastern Afghanistan are from the US.

The British soldier's death takes the number of British military fatalities in Afghanistan since the start of operations in November 2001 to 70.

Of those who have died in Afghanistan, 47 were killed in action or died as a result of injuries sustained in action, while 23 are known to have died either as a result of illness, non-combat injuries or accidents or have not yet been officially assigned a cause of death pending the outcome of an investigation. At least 61 Americans have been killed, according to Associated Press figures.

Five American soldiers were killed in Iraq on Saturday the American military said today.

Four were killed and four others were wounded by a roadside bombing during combat operations south of the Baghdad. Another soldier was killed by small-arms fire during a foot patrol southeast of Baghdad. All the soldiers were assigned to Task Force Marne, which operates in an area with a volatile mix of Sunni and Shia extremists.

Names of the dead were withheld pending notification of relatives. The deaths raised to at least 3,690 the number of US military who have died since the Iraq war started in March 2003, according to an Associated Press count.

Thursday, August 09, 2007

4 more British casualties in Basra

The important thing is not to set a timetable for withdrawal. Somehow that will help.


Iraqis exchanges greetings with British soldiers on patrol a few miles to the north of Basra July 12, 2007. Two British soldiers were killed in Iraq early on Thursday, taking the death toll to four in about 48 hours. The Irish Guards soldiers killed shortly after midnight were in a convoy hit by a roadside bomb near the Rumaila oil fields, west of Basra. Two other soldiers were seriously injured. REUTERS/Atef Hassan
Four UK troops die in Iraq in 48 hours

BASRA, Iraq (Reuters) - Two British soldiers were killed in Iraq early on Thursday, taking the death toll to four in about 48 hours.

The Irish Guards soldiers killed shortly after midnight were in a convoy hit by a roadside bomb near the Rumaila oil fields, west of Basra. Two other soldiers were seriously injured.

British-patrolled southern Iraq has become more dangerous for British troops since the government announced in February that London would cut back its force during the course of 2007.

In the April-July period, 30 British soldiers died in Iraq, making it the deadliest period since the 2003 invasion when Britain had nine times as many troops as the 5,500-strong contingent it has deployed now.

One soldier was killed during a foot patrol on Tuesday and another was shot while driving an armoured Warrior vehicle on Monday night.

The British have withdrawn from three of the four provinces they once patrolled, leaving troops only in Basra, Iraq's second-largest city.

In Basra they have pulled out of two of their three bases. They are due to abandon the last city base in coming weeks and withdraw to their heavily mortared air base outside the city.

British commanders say Shi'ite militants are stepping up attacks to create the impression they are pushing the British out. The military says it will withdraw on its own schedule.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

British preparing to exit Basra

For U.S. and Britain, opposite directions in Iraq

BASRA, Iraq: As U.S. troop levels are rising in Baghdad, British force levels are heading in the opposite direction, with the troops preparing to withdraw completely from the city center of Basra.

The British intend to pull back to an airport headquarters well out of the city, which is 480 kilometers, or 300 miles, south of Baghdad. It is a symbolic move widely taken by Iraqis as the beginning of the end of the British military presence in southern Iraq.

The scaling down by America's largest coalition partner foreshadows many of the political and military challenges certain to face American commanders when their troops begin withdrawing.

Skepticism is widespread in Basra, as in Baghdad, about whether Iraqi forces are ready to take over. Both the British and Americans will have to assuage the fears of Iraqis that they are being abandoned to gunmen and religious extremists. And both are likely to face intensified attacks from propaganda-conscious enemies trying to claim credit for driving out the Westerners.

As the British prepare for the withdrawal from the city center - and the wider transition of handing over Basra Province to Iraqi security forces during the coming months - Brigadier James Bashall, commander of the 1st Mechanized Brigade, conceded that his troops would almost certainly "get a lot of indirect fire as we go backward."

It is no coincidence that he is reading up on Britain's withdrawal from Aden, its former crown colony in what is now Yemen, and lessons from other wars, with the American experience in Vietnam what Bashall calls the "obvious parallel."

Rear Admiral Mark Fox, a U.S. military spokesman in Baghdad, parried any suggestion that Basra was a model for the Americans.

"I think that our focus right now is on the operations that we are conducting," he said. "Certainly that's the thing that is in front of us right now, and I wouldn't characterize us as necessarily peeking over the shoulders of somebody else to see how they are doing it."

The British commanders studiously avoid talk of dates for the same reason U.S. commanders are resisting such pressure in Congress - they fear it would embolden insurgents.

But it has escaped no one's notice that Britain's new prime minister, Gordon Brown, could score political points by withdrawing from an unpopular war. Brown headed to Washington on Sunday for a get-acquainted meeting with President George W. Bush.

The British pullback, and British commanders' talk of moving toward "overwatch" and intervening "in a limited sense" if requested by the Iraqis, is viewed with dismay by many Iraqis in the city.

Mustapha Wali, a teacher, was blunt. "If they withdraw, we will live in a jungle, like the early days," he said.

"The parties control the government, and the aim of officials is to fill their pockets with money - millions of dollars inside their pockets and nothing to the city."

The educated and secular middle classes fear that the Iraqi security forces - particularly the police - are hopelessly infiltrated by the extremist Shiite militias and Iranian-backed Islamist parties competing, often murderously, for control of Basra's huge oil wealth.

An overwhelmingly Shiite port city that controls Iraq's gateway to the Gulf, Basra is much less affected by the Sunni-Shiite sectarian violence plaguing Baghdad. But, as a report by the International Crisis Group concluded June 25, it is virtually controlled by Shiite militias.

Since the 2003 invasion, the British-led forces in Basra have adopted a far less aggressive and interventionist stance than U.S. troops have farther north. Some contend that this was the only realistic approach, with far fewer troops at their disposal and a more benign environment.

But critics accuse the British of simply allowing the Shiite militias free rein to carry out their intolerant Islamist agenda, which involved killing merchants who sell alcohol, driving out Christians and infiltrating state institutions and the security forces.

"The British are very patient. They didn't know how to deal with the militias," said an Assyrian Christian who would identify herself only as Mrs. Mansour. "Some people think it would be better if the Americans came instead of the British. They would be harder on the militias."

The report by the International Crisis Group, an organization that seeks to prevent or resolve deadly conflicts, concedes that a recent British-led crackdown was a qualified success in reducing criminality, political assassinations and sectarian killings, but nevertheless concludes that Basra "is an example of what to avoid."

It said the British had been driven into "increasingly secluded compounds," a result, the report said, that was viewed by Basra's residents and militia as an "ignominious defeat."

Saturday, July 21, 2007

Memo says British military is at the breaking point

This is the second "secret" memo from the British military this week. The earlier memo included remarks from senior MOD officials that Iraq was "a lost cause".
Bush's ill-considered invasion and long occupation has now broken the world's two most powerful militaries, but we still "need more time" before results wil be apparent, or so the talking points say.

full story

We're running out of troops, warns army chief



· Defence memo leak says virtually no reserves left
· 'Intense tempo of life' due to Iraq and Afghan fighting


Richard Norton-Taylor
Saturday July 21, 2007
The Guardian


The head of the army has warned that Britain is almost running out of troops to defend the country or fight in military operations abroad.

The warning by General Sir Richard Dannatt, chief of the general staff, to fellow defence chiefs comes at a time when the army is asking for a big increase in reservists to be deployed in Afghanistan, reflecting a crisis in Britain's armed forces.

In a secret memorandum he says: "We now have almost no capability to react to the unexpected." Reinforcements for emergencies or for operations in Iraq or Afghanistan were "now almost non-existent".
He adds: "The enduring nature and scale of current operations continues to stretch people". Gen Dannatt warns the army had to "augment" 2,500 troops from other units for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan to bring up the total force to the 13,000 needed there. This remained "far higher than we ever assumed", he says.

He continues: "When this is combined with the effects of under-manning (principally in the infantry and Royal Artillery) and the pace of training support needed to prepare units for operations, the tempo of life in the Field Army is intense." While the current situation was "manageable", Gen Dannatt said he was "concerned about the longer term implications of the impact of this level of operations on our people, equipment and future operational capability".

The general's warnings, in a document leaked to the Daily Telegraph, come at a time when the Ministry of Defence and the Treasury are finalising spending plans for the next three years in the comprehensive spending review expected to be revealed in October. The three service chiefs are arguing among themselves about how the money should be spent. The navy is expected next week to be told it will get two new aircraft carriers at a cost of between £2bn and £3bn and fewer destroyers and frigates than it wants.

Gordon Brown, the prime minister who as chancellor fought regularly with the MoD, has told defence chiefs to sort out a deal among themselves, according to defence sources.

As the army has been forced to call up 600 reservists for Afghanistan there is only one Spearhead battalion of 500 troops, available for an emergency.

Gen Dannatt's memo says Britain's other rapid deployment unit, the Airborne Task Force, made up mainly of Paras, was unable to fully deploy "due to shortages in manpower, equipment and stocks".

It is not the first time Gen Dannatt has expressed concern about pressure on the army. Soon after he took up his post last August he told the Guardian that the army was "running hot" and called for a national debate on defence.



This is the price paid for handing over the British military to a delusional American President. Any other countries want to get in on this "success"? I thought not. Let's at least hope that the British military has learned a crucial lesson from this.


Monday, July 16, 2007

British military: "Iraq is a lost cause"

It's an open secret that Britain has been trying to get out of Iraq for some time now, in order to devote their resources to Afghanistan. Britain tried a "surge" of it's own in Basra before Bush (or was it Petraeus) ever proposed it. It actually did have some success, but only for the short-term. It turns out, surprisingly, that there were underlying problems that military force alone could not address. Yes, problems other than Al-Qaeda. Unbelievable. But that certainly won't happen to us, will it?
With the failure of the Basra "surge", the British troops resigned themselves to hunkering down in bunkers while taking a slow death with IEDs and mortars. And Tony Blair grinned bravely.
Now, the MOD has decided, according to a 'very senior commander", that Iraq is a lost cause.
Apparently the British military has misplaced their Bush parrot trained to squawk "Al-Qaeda!" when bad news comes out. Oh, dear.
full story


More Britons killed in Iraq than Americans proportionally: report




British soldiers serving in Iraq are being killed at a proportionally greater rate than their American counterparts for the first time since the start of the war, the Sunday Telegraph reported.

As attacks surged in Basra, southern Iraq, the death rate of British troops has now surpassed that of Americans, marking a "watershed" for British involvement in the conflict, which in turn leads to calls for the government to set an immediate timetable for withdrawal from the war-torn country, said the report.

It cited an analysis by Professor Sheila Bird, vice-president of the Royal Statistical Society, on British and American fatalities from May 2006 to June 2007.

Britain has 5,500 troops serving in Iraq, and suffered 23 fatalities between February 5 and June 24, whereas the United States has 165,000, and lost 463 over the same period, according Bird's analysis.

The newspaper quoted a very senior commander from the army as saying that the war in Iraq was now regarded by political and military chiefs within the Ministry of Defense as "a lost cause".

The commander urged that both Britain and America to accept they were facing the possibility of "strategic failure" in Iraq.


A think tank on Iraq suggest Britain should cease "offensive military operations" in Iraq and concentrate on training Iraqi security forces.

But a Ministry of Defense spokesman dismissed the comparison report as "too simplistic to try to extrapolate meaningful conclusions for the future."

Source: Xinhua