Showing posts with label Bush. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bush. Show all posts

Thursday, July 03, 2008

Military abandoning support for the GOP

Early last month, a commenter without a profile named Jason left the following:

If you think the military on the whole does not support their President, you are mistaken, and therefore attempts to characterize them as some poor captive audience that would surely speak up if they could are misguided.

The comment was in response to Bush's penchant for making speeches before military audiences, where anyone who booed him would be subject to severe punishment. March was the last time Bush made an appearance to anything but hand-picked or military audiences, when he was booed and jeered at the opening pitch of the Nationals game.
Now we see:

In its annual reader surveys, the Military Times specialist news group found Bush's approval rate among the military had plummeted from 60 percent in 2005 to just 48 percent in 2007.

Gosh, Jason, it sure seems like someone in the military might want to boo the President if they could get away with it.
Now we find out that the support for McCain among the military and their families is at most 50%. Late last year we found that that support for the Iraq effort was slipping within the military community as well. The Republicans are running a war hero whose campaign mentions his service and POW status every single day, and the military isn't buying it.

McCain has long had a "problem" with veterans groups for his stinginess on vet benefits. Backing the neocon vision of Eternal War hasn't helped win over military families, either. It's somewhat ironic that, while the wingnuts froth over "military service" and re-define the word "patriotism" to mean "complete support of the Republican agenda", more than half of those people actually serving would be considered unpatriotic by the Right because they don't support Bush, McCain, or the premise of the Iraq occupation. Thus we have a complete logical breakdown on the wingnut end: criticising the troops is unpatriotic, but the troops don't support Bush, so the troops are unpatriotic, but that is criticism, so the wingnuts are unpatriotic.

The neocons and wingnuts overplayed their hand years ago when they conflated dissent on the Iraq occupation to treason. Too many people knew too many dissenters whose patriotism was not in question for that to work. Now a strong majority says that Iraq was a mistake or not worth fighting for - in other words, unpatriotic traitors, America-haters, and defeatists. With that sorry gambit, the wingnuts lost the magic talismanic power of the word "traitor", much like the words "liberal", "appeaser", and "terrorist sympathiser" no longer elicit guaranteed rage from the public. Republicans, however, have not realised this because they know that such words work on them. Thus, the GOP will continue its bizarre effort to cast 60% of Americans as treasonous, while simultaneously imagining that these 'traitors' will vote for them. And they will continue to invoke 'the troops' in attempts to stifle dissent, even though half of those troops disagree with the GOP.

full story from AFP:

Iraq undercuts Republican support among military

WASHINGTON (AFP) — Five years into an unpopular war in Iraq, many US military voters are eschewing their traditional Republican ties to support Democrat Barack Obama for president against John McCain, observers say.
...
"I think now you're going to see -- not that it's going to be overwhelming -- but a back away from the Republican Party ... At least (the military vote will) be split this year rather than overwhelmingly Republican," said Korb, a deputy defense secretary under president Ronald Reagan.
He predicted that McCain, the 71-year-old Republican senator for Arizona, will get "at most half of the military votes," instead of the three-to-one ratio that Republican President George W. Bush won in 2004.
The main reason for the defection is the Iraq war, where 4,113 US troops have died since the 2003 invasion and for which the US government has come under fire even from the military, despite recent security improvements.
...
A Los Angeles Times survey of 1,467 people, including 631 soldiers, veterans and their families, in late 2007 found that 57 percent of military respondents believed the Iraq war was not worth fighting -- nearly the same as the overall population (60 percent).
Asked which party they trusted most to handle important issues, the military families chose Democrats over Republicans 39-35 percent, compared to a 39-31 percent ratio among the general population.

And clueless Republicans are still looking backward to 2000 and 2004 for confidence, even though things have changed radically for the GOP.

Saturday, February 23, 2008

Bush hits new low in national polling

Yes, the Decider has gone into a tailspin and dropped to 19% support among the American public.

Four polls show McCain at a disadvantage to Obama if the election were held today.
Fox: McCain loses 43/47
Diageo: McCain loses 40/48
Zogby: McCain loses 40/47
Gallup: McCain loses 46/50

Of course, we still have eight months of a declining economy, McCain sucking up to Bush, the Sahwa turning on the Iraqi government, and Afghanistan sliding into failed state mode. We have eight months for Norm Coleman to do his incredible chameleon act and temporarily transform into a Democrat. We still have eight months of Republicans striking poses and the public snickering at them. And we have eight months of Administration hacks putting a flashlight under their faces and telling very scary stories that only their base believes anymore. Uh-huh, the Muslims are going to take over the country and make your daughter wear a burqa. Heard that one already.

story from ARG

February 20, 2008

Concerns over Economy Push
George W. Bush's Overall Job Approval to New Low

George W. Bush's overall job approval rating has dropped to a new low in American Research Group polling as 78% of Americans say that the national economy is getting worse according to the latest survey from the American Research Group.

Among all Americans, 19% approve of the way Bush is handling his job as president and 77% disapprove. When it comes to Bush's handling of the economy, 14% approve and 79% disapprove.

Among Americans registered to vote, 18% approve of the way Bush is handling his job as president and 78% disapprove. When it comes to the way Bush is handling the economy, 15% of registered voters approve of the way Bush is handling the economy and 79% disapprove.

A total of 78% of Americans say the national economy is getting worse and 47% say the national economy is in a recession. A total of 42% of Americans, however, say they believe the national economy will be better a year from now, which is the highest level for this question in the past year. This optimism does not spread to improvements in household financial situations as 17% of Americans say they expect their household financial situations to be better a year from now, which is the lowest for this question in the past year.

The results presented here are based on 1,100 completed telephone interviews conducted among a nationwide random sample of adults 18 years and older. The interviews were completed February 16 through 19, 2008. The theoretical margin of error for the total sample is plus or minus 2.6 percentage points, 95% of the time, on questions where opinion is evenly split.

Overall, 19% of Americans say that they approve of the way George W. Bush is handling his job as president, 77% disapprove, and 4% are undecided.

---------------------------------

Among Republicans (29% of adults registered to vote in the survey), 45% approve of the way Bush is handling his job and 50% disapprove. Among Democrats (43% of adults registered to vote in the survey), 1% approve and 99% disapprove of the way Bush is handling his job. Among independents (28% of adults registered to vote in the survey), 17% approve and 75% disapprove of the way Bush is handling his job as president.

Overall, 14% of Americans say that they approve of the way George W. Bush is handling the economy, 79% disapprove, and 7% are undecided. Among registered voters, 15% approve and 79% disapprove of the way Bush is handling the economy.

A total of 1% of Americans say that the national economy is getting better, 20% say it is staying the same, and 78% say the national economy is getting worse.


Meanwhile, the Fox News poll has Bush dropping one point since last month to 32% approval. Bush has not exceeded 38% in the Fox News poll in the past year. NBC/WSJ has seen Bush's "very favorable" ratings drop from 31% to 14% in the past year.

The last Gallup Poll early this month had 57% saying that the Iraq invasion was "a mistake".

These numbers are what the Republicans are running on. A "mistake" of a war, an economy that 1% says is improving, and continuation of policies that only 19% support. Yet, just as before the 2006 elections, we hear wildly delusional Republicans looking forward to a big victory. For fun, take a look at the predictions from those wacky folks over at Redstate.

Saturday, December 08, 2007

Indian government reading from Bush's script.

Not only does the U.S.-India nuclear deal appear to be sunk, but the aftermath of its collapse is spilling over into the Iran issue. In spite of Singh's statements that India wants no part of Bush's "warmongering" with Iran, India seems to be following Washington's script fairly closely.

In spite of the recent revelations that U.S. aid to Pakistan has mostly been spent on arming itself against India, and in spite of the ridiculous anti-Hindu outcry raised by Bush's base in denouncing Hindus as "wicked", and in spite of India's closest ally (China) becoming openly irritated with the U.S, it would seem that Mr. Singh is entirely willing to dance to the tune of a lame-duck American leader.

For a long time, Bush forbid any country from selling nuclear technology to India, even though this would be highly profitable. Then Bush changed his mind and decided it would be okay if American companies made a lot of money upgrading India's reactors, but the rest of the world (mostly our allies, by the way) should keep out. To a large degree, Bush restrained his traditional arrogance in coming up with the nuke deal, but India couldn't get the deal approved domestically due to the insistence on inspections. Since several other Western nations appear willing to step in and take America's place as India's nuclear supplier of choice, it's odd that India should become fixed on pleasing Bush, who has a bit over a year left in power and who is remarkably unpopular. If Bush is dangling something in front of Mr. Singh's eyes, then Singh should recall that Bush has done the same with Eastern European nations and he should realise that Bush's ability to deliver on the world stage is diminishing, as is his ability to get his way domestically.



US wants to convert India into subordinate ally: CPI(M)

Agencies
Posted online: Monday, December 03, 2007 at 0000 hrs IST
New Delhi, December 3:
Ahead of Tuesday's discussion in Rajya Sabha on the nuclear deal, the CPI(M) on Monday stepped up attack on the issue alleging that its "larger agenda" was to convert India into a "subordinate ally" of the US and New Delhi's "shift" in policy was visible in the Indo-Iranian relations.
"Day-to-day developments reconfirm our fears that the US wants to convert India into its subordinate ally in South Asia, even before the Indo-US nuclear deal has come into effect. This is a very ominous development," Politburo member Sitaram Yechury told reporters in New Delhi.
The CPI(M) leader said the 123 agreement, which was "firmly anchored in the Hyde Act", has fallen short "not just of our objections but of the assurances of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh himself."
Maintaining that American "pressure" was working not just on the government to "shift" its foreign policy but on Indian companies as well, Yechury said the deal was "lot more than only nuclear cooperation, it has a larger agenda ...to convert India as a subordinate ally of the US in South Asia.”
In this context, he referred to India's non-participation in a scheduled meeting with Iran and Pakistan on the gas pipeline and said "not going for the project or delaying it is not in India's interest. It is clearly succumbing to US pressures".
Yechury said the State Bank of India had "suddenly prohibited" extending their line of credit to Iranian firms and stopping Indian exports to that country.
He expressed hope that government would answer in Rajya Sabha on Tuesday these "serious" questions which came in the aftermath of India voting against Iran at the IAEA on the nuclear issue.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Iraq occupation still unpopular

I came across this war-supporter's blog and was surprised by two of his assertions about the Iraq occupation:

  • public opposition to the war is not high
  • being "opposed to the war" means you want to lose the war
So, it took me a few seconds to find the latest Gallup Poll. Surprisingly, it says the public is still opposed to the war, and have been for some time.


Only about one-third of Americans say the recent U.S. troop surge is making the situation in Iraq better, and the majority of Americans continue to say it was a mistake to send troops there in the first place. Although Americans are pessimistic about progress in the war, a slim majority still believe the United States is likely to win -- a slight improvement since mid-January, but similar to measures in early January and in 2006.

So I guess the issue is if you think that someone who says it was mistake to go into Iraq in the first place is "opposed" to the "war" (which is really an occupation at this point). However you slice the semantics of it, it sure isn't enthusiasm. People can't stop it, but they think it's a bad idea. And these people also think (by a slim majority, that is) that we will "win", so they obviously don't 'want to lose'.

Let's take a look at those numbers:


The public's assessment of the surge has not shown much change since August, but in April and July polls, Americans were slightly more negative in their assessments.

Hmmm. So 64% either think the surge isn't making much difference or think it's making things worse. But they somehow don't "oppose" it. And things have been this way for a while now.


Gallup has asked this question six times since the start of the war. Immediately after the United States invaded Baghdad in April 2003, more than 9 in 10 Americans said it was likely that the United States would win the war. When the question was next updated, in March 2006 -- three years after the start of the war -- opinions had become less positive, with just 54% saying victory was likely or certain. The results have been stable since that time.


Now, we all know that, to Republicans, any kind of rational, sober, objective assessment of the the Iraq effort is really just another way of saying that you want terrorists to kill your family and our soldiers to die in a bloodbath. Maybe that's why they are polling so low, by the way. Either way, I look at only 19% of the public being "certain we will win" as pretty lukewarm support. And that number isn't swinging upward, either.

When Petraeus made his report in September, Republicans expected a big swing in favour of the Iraq occupation and the surge. Right-wing blogs crowed that this was the proof America finally needed, and that Bush would be vindicated. The truth is that there is virtually no change at all in opinion:


28. In view of the developments since we first sent our troops to Iraq, do you think the United States made a mistake in sending troops to Iraq, or not?

Yes
No
No
opinion

%
%
%
2007 Nov 2-4
58
39
3
2007 Oct 12-14
60
37
2
2007 Sep 14-16
58
41
1
2007 Sep 7-8
54
44
2
2007 Aug 3-5
57
42
2

As you can see, the Republicans picked up a statistically-insignificant 2% who merely said that it wasn't a mistake to go into Iraq. Not that they like how it's been handled, or are happy how it's going, but just that it wasn't a mistake. A statistically-significant 19% more think that it was a mistake to go into Iraq in the first place, and that number seems stable.

The surge was supposed to disarm the militas and bring political stability to Iraq. That's what the public bought, anyway. Instead we are arming the "good" terrorists and the political situation is unchanged. Provincial elections are still unscheduled. Basra is floundering. Kurdistan is not only seeing increasing violence, but Turkey is threatening an invasion. Corpses showing signs of torture show up on Baghdad streets every day. The country is segregated into walled communities. The water, health care, and electricity infrastructres have collapsed. Malnutrition is a serious crisis. Syria is kicking out Iraqis and they are returning to become homeless. Huge amounts of oil are disappearing without being accounted for. Iraqi prisons are places where torture is common. It's not only a mess, it's an insanely expensive mess.

So we see that the right-wing blogger alluded to at the start of the post is living in his own little world.

Let's look at Bush's approval numbers. From the Washington Post/ABC News poll (11/4):


1. Do you approve or disapprove of the way George W. Bush is handling his job as president? Do you approve/disapprove strongly or somewhat?
-------- Approve --------   ------- Disapprove ------     No
           NET   Strongly   Somewhat   NET   Somewhat   Strongly   opinion
11/1/07      33       17         16      64       13         50        3
9/30/07      33       15         18      64       14         49        3
9/7/07       33       16         17      64       15         49        3 

The guy has strong disapproval from half of the country. Only half of his supporters are strong supporters. Almost four times as many strongly disapprove than "somewhat disapprove".


2. Do you think things in this country (are generally going in the right direction) or do you feel things (have gotten pretty seriously off on the wrong track)?
                 Right     Wrong     No
             direction   track   opinion
11/1/07           24        74        2
6/1/07            25        73        2
1/19/07           26        71        3 

...and Republicans are just offering to continue Bush's policies.





Friday, November 02, 2007

Cuba embargo condemned in U.N.

Once again, we see Bush's disdain for the U.N, unless it is to pressure that body into cleaning up Bush's various messes. For example, faced with grim reports of collapsed Iraqi infrastructure, child mortality and malnutrition, lack of clean water, a medical system unable to deal with cholera outbreaks, etc. Bush has glibly suggested that the U.N. should be the one to solve those problems. Apparently we are in Iraq to do the ungrateful world a great favour by chasing terrorists from one province to another, so the least the world could do is to handle all of the complications springing from the occupation.

The U.N. also has failed to rally around Bush's extremely hazy 'plan' to wage an air war against Iran. The only thing that has prevented U.N. sanctions against Israel for several years now is the U.S. veto power on the Security Council. But when the U.N. made a heavily-qualified and conditional endorsement of military action against Saddam, the U.N. was praised by Bush and it was "the world against Saddam".

Now it is the world against Bush, however. The U.S. embargo against Cuba, which the U.S. has had no hesitation to bully other nations into complying with, has now been condemned by the U.N. in a 184-4 vote with one abstention. It's hard to get the world so unified, but Bush has set his mind to it with a bully approach and his "with us or against us" mindset. Those in the "with us" camp are expected to exhaust their militaries and treasuries and back whatever crazy scheme the Decider dreams up, and also mouth increasingly-bizzare defences of Israel's actions. Do those in the "with us" camp get preferential treatment or increased aid? No, but they get photo ops with the Decider and a pat on the head. It's no wonder that the "against us" camp is growing.

In fairness, the embargo against Cuba has been backed by Democrats as well in the past. However, it's only now that the world has seen fit to stand up against U.S. foreign policy so unanimously, and that is because of Bush. The idea that a tiny island could militarily threaten the giant U.S. has long produced ridicule from the rest of the planet, but these thoughts were expressed most often in private. Slowly, countries such as Canada moved away from involvement in the embargo. So Bush, devoid of any credibility and having no political capital in the global community, once again pushed for the world to follow our lead in Cuba. And the world apparently flipped him off.

Consider that the primary "moderate" plan to get us out of Iraq is for the "international community" to increase their presence there. With the vast majority of the globe increasingly aligning itself against Bush's foreign policies, what chance does that approach have?



Cuba celebrates diplomatic victory over U.S

Cuba Wednesday hailed a new appeal made by the United Nations, which urged Washington to lift an economic and trade embargo against the Caribbean country.

"Crushing victory," "historic record" and "overwhelming support to Cuba" are some of the most repeated phrases in the media that reported Cuba's diplomatic victory Tuesday, when the world body asked the United States to lift the blockade by 184 votes in favor, four against and one abstention.

The vote also implicated an implicit condemnation of Washington as the UN suggests that the embargo has infringed the UN Charter and international law, analysts said.

Tuesday's voting at the UN General Assembly demonstrated a unanimous rejection of the embargo throughout the five continents, including all Latin America, Europe, Africa, Asia and Oceania, they said.

Washington's hostile policy toward Cuba has been rejected by an overwhelming majority of UN member countries, analysts added.

According to the Cuban government, the embargo, which was imposed in 1962 by former U.S. president John F. Kennedy, has caused an 89-billion-U.S. dollar economic loss to Cuba, as well as immeasurable damage and deaths to the country's inhabitants.

The UN has asked the United States in a number of resolutions to end the embargo, but Washington has refused to do so.

Source: Xinhua

Saturday, October 13, 2007

Afghan situation is crumbling

Bush has always run the war in Afghanistan as an afterthought. Karzai got elected, the Taliban were defeated, and the rest is "happily ever after" in his fairy tale.

However, the Taliban are making a comeback, Karzai is unpopular and holds sway over only the capital, the US is increasingly turning to air power with the attendant civilian deaths, and the economy is a shambles. Attacks in the capital itself are increasing, and Karzai is running out if money to pay the civil servants and military. When you hand out government jobs to win favour, people generally expect to be paid as part of the deal.

Yes, in another one of Bush's "successes", the electricity is only on for a few hours a day, running water and sewage services are lacking, unemployment is high, and the government is corrupt and impotent. What country does that remind you of?

Bush has done a pretty good job convincing the world that the last thing you want is to be "liberated" by the U.S. What sane nation could possibly look at Iraq and Afghanistan and see a shining beacon of hope and liberty? The nations that are aiding us are involved in an expensive, bloody, and protracted war that Bush has bungled with his characteristic optimism and refusal to plan for or consider anything but the best possible outcome. Bush sold the Afghan mission to NATO as essentially one of rebuilding and providing support for the Afghan military to take over security. The reconstruction never happened, the warlords ignored Karzai, the American commanders ignored the Afghanis, and the Afghan military turned out to be inept, abusive, and corrupt. Now the Canadians and European allies are stuck facing the hard reality rather than Bush's optimistic fantasy.

Leadership is more than planning for the best and shrugging in the face of the worst.

Why Howard continues to have faith in Bush's "leadership" is beyond logic. The NATO allies who tried to win Bush's favour by participating in the mission have gained nothing but a disastrous mess, and now Bush will be out of office and leave them holding the bag.

Make no mistake: a stable and free Afghanistan is a worthy goal, but the Decider has turned the Afghan people against us, hopelessly bungled the effort, and drawn our allies into disaster.


full story from The Australian

Afghanistan 'is going down fast'


THE bloodshed in Afghanistan has reached levels not seen since the 2001 invasion as anger at bungling by an ineffective Government in Kabul and its foreign backers stokes support for the Taliban and other extremist groups.

The death of Trooper David Pearce underlines the rising dangers for Australia's 1000 soldiers in Afghanistan, most of them deployed in the Taliban's southern heartland -- a region some of Canberra's NATO allies consider too dangerous to fight in.

"This place can only go up or down, and it's going down fast, which is something the international community simply will not understand," said a security analyst who has been working in and out of Afghanistan for 30 years.

Almost six years after the hardline Islamist Taliban were ousted, their insurgency is gaining strength, fuelled by resentment at NATO bombing of civilians, billions of dollars of wasted aid, a lack of jobs and record crops of opium, the raw material for heroin.

The fighting is spreading to places once relatively safe, including the capital and the western and northern parts of the country.

"This is a guerilla movement but it does seem to have a real momentum behind it at the moment," said Joanna Nathan, an analyst for the International Crisis Group, a Brussels-based think tank headed by former foreign minister Gareth Evans.

In Kabul, where suicide bombs have killed almost 50 people in two weeks, foreigners are increasingly ordered into "lockdown" -- barred by employers from leaving their heavily protected compounds, often behind armed guards, razor wire and concrete blast walls.

"It's all now too close -- people are jumpy," said a UN official who has lived in the dusty, chaotic city ringed by mountains for four years.

The revitalised Taliban have switched tactics back to traditional guerilla warfare after attempts to take on foreign troops under separate NATO and US commands in pitched battles last year resulted in heavy casualties.

"They never evaporated into thin air. The Taliban were there, they have been there and they are here now," said government adviser and former minister Hamidullah Tarzi, carrying his trademark silver pistol.

"One reason for their renewed strength is that the people are more or less amenable to what they are doing and maybe some of the (NATO) bombardments have not been very wisely executed.

"That has helped the people get closer to the Taliban. They are dying and they feel that they are the same (as the Talibs) from the religious point of view."

Scores, possibly hundreds, of civilians have been killed in air strikes, mainly called in to support ground troops fighting rebels. The US-led NATO force, government officials and village leaders differ over details and numbers.

The Taliban-led insurgency is also being bolstered by drugs money -- the UN reported a 50per cent jump in this year's opium crop -- local and tribal disputes, and a lack of jobs.

With the wrecked economy and the dangers of getting crops to market, being a paid fighter for the Taliban is often the only way isolated Afghans can feed their families.

"It's important to emphasise: I don't think the Taliban themselves are wildly popular," Ms Nathan said.

"I don't think people want Taliban times back. It is a broad dissatisfaction with what is happening in the country now. I think the Taliban are very clever at appealing to people or groups that are locally disenfranchised or disempowered."

The Taliban shelter and train in neighbouring Pakistan -- once the group's main sponsor -- and President Pervez Musharraf faces international pressure to do more to stop them.

But the border, a random line in the sand drawn by British colonial rulers, passes through rugged, inhospitable territory and divides fiercely loyal ethnic groups who have never been fully controlled by any government for centuries. General Musharraf and NATO generals say stemming the flow of fighters is a tough task.

While some analysts say Tehran may be supporting the Taliban, most say no firm evidence has surfaced, rejecting Defence Minister Brendan Nelson's suggestion that the bomb that killed Trooper Pearce might have been made with supplies from Iran.

"He made that comment before any proper investigation had been done," said one soldier serving with NATO.

Much of the violence in Afghanistan is rooted in ordinary crime as the conflict erodes security and the rule of law and young men desperately seek money.

"Some of my friends don't have jobs. They just walk the streets. They talk among themselves of kidnapping a foreigner just to make some money," said "Sayed", a university business student who did not want his real name used.

Guns are easy to come by and drug addiction in the country that supplies almost all the world's opium is rising.

Unemployment is near 40 per cent and many Afghans live in appalling conditions, with no running water, sewerage or electricity. Roads are poor and in the capital -- crammed with tens of thousands of squatters camped in mud brick huts -- most middle-class residents are lucky to have power a few hours a day.

"People thought democracy would give them everything -- jobs, roads, electricity, water -- but nothing of this sort has happened," Mr Tarzi said.

"In fact, it's getting worse. There is a lack of jobs, a lack of employment. Overall, nothing much has been done.

"The money that has come in has not been productive in relation to industrialisation."

Confidence in the Afghan Government, the first democratically elected administration in three decades, is fading fast.

President Hamid Karzai, 49, the philosopher and former freedom fighter who has ruled this country since 2001, faces criticism for his failure to stamp out the Taliban and raise living standards.

Dubbed "the mayor of Kabul", because he rarely leaves his palace and his Government's writ barely extends beyond the capital, Mr Karzai is battling to balance the demands of the people who elected him with those of the foreign backers who prop up his Government.

He is also undermined by the fact his administration has control over only a small share of the billions of foreign aid dollars spent in his country.

Mr Karzai is not a popular leader, his critics say, accused of being ineffective and indecisive. In Kabul and many parts of the country his public portraits and banners are dwarfed and outnumbered by those of Ahmed Shah Masood, a popular mujaheddin leader assassinated by al-Qa'ida two days before the attacks on the US of September 11, 2001.

Domestically, Mr Karzai relies on a ragtag collection of former warlords, mujaheddin freedom fighters, ex-communists and others for support and is locked in a power struggle with his parliament. The President and the legislators -- a large number of whom are illiterate -- are coming to grips with democracy as much as with each other.

Mr Karzai has been criticised for failing to sack or prosecute corrupt officials and of handing out jobs as political favours to shore up support.

His Government has also failed to make serious inroads into the $3.3billion-a-year opium industry, which is tightly intertwined with the conflict and has been breaking production records almost every year since the Taliban's fall.

"The narcotics and insurgency feed into each other," said Ms Nathan.

Trooper Pearce, 41, a father of two, was killed when his convoy was hit by a roadside bomb in southern Uruzgan province, a major opium centre where Australian and Dutch troops are working on reconstruction.

Although it is a volatile area and a centre of Taliban support, the Dutch forces had forged close links with community leaders, cutting down the fighting, until a botched poppy eradication program by a US private security firm a few months ago, analysts say.

"Uruzgan was going OK until they went in with tractors and started ripping the poppy fields up," said the Kabul-based security analyst. "The Dutch had a good relationship with the people down there, the local leaders, but when they rip up your crop, what do you do? You grab your gun. They didn't even do that much damage to the crops in the end."

Australian troops make up a fraction of the 50,000 foreign forces in Afghanistan, and opinion is divided about how effective Canberra's contribution is.

"It's more symbolic," Mr Tarzi said. "I think (John) Howard is trying his best to see what (US President George W.) Bush is thinking, and he's going along that line.

"He should concentrate more on what his people, the Australians, think. He is just following Mr Bush."

But Australia is one of a small group of countries -- along with the US, Britain, Canada and The Netherlands -- willing to send its soldiers to where most of the fighting is.

Some European countries refuse to deploy their troops to the volatile south. Several members of the NATO-led force impose tough -- and, critics say, absurd -- limits, or caveats, on how their soldiers can be used, with some barring their units from fighting in the snow, above certain altitudes or at night.

Ms Nathan said: "It is incredibly important to have nations who are prepared to go south in a robust way, to go down there not laden by caveats; to go down there to do what is needed, when it's needed, how it's needed."

Tuesday, October 09, 2007

The Way Forward? Divide the Sadrists

Once again, the White House is playing a short-term strategy in Iraq. Also, in spite of Al-Qaeda being nearly the sole focus for the past five or six months, Bush is now pulling troops off the AQ manhunt to crack down on "bad" Sadrists.

We've already seen that the strategy with Sunni terrorists has been compromised. When Bush proposed the surge in January, the plan was to have the Iraqi Army disarm or exterminate the sectarian militias with the U.S. providing a support role. Since the Iraqi Army seems to be perpetually in "training", and since the job proved far more complicated and difficult than Bush imagined it would be (big shock there, eh?), the plan was changed. And of course, this change was presented as "what we planned all along".

The "change" was to divide the Sunni terrorists into "good" and "bad" categories. The "good" terrorists were those who would join with the American troops to wipe out their rivals, while quietly being allowed to continue with their shakedowns, extortion, executions, kidnappings, and black market dealings. With the "bad" terrorists on their heels, these opportunities opened up even more as the competition thinned. One can only wonder how the Iraqi Army will deal with these entrenched "good" terrorists who oppose the government when the Army tries to regain control of the country. One also wonders about the consequences when these "good" terrorists stop co-operating or getting what they want from the arrangement. We will then have militias that know our troops' movements, weaknesses, intelligence, and locations as well as possessing the arms that we supplied them with. Since the police and military are heavily infiltrated by the militias, these forces are likely to be a liability, as well.

It should be noted that this "change" in strategy was the major feature of the surge, if not the only real one.

So what to do about the Shia insurgency, then? Let's try the same brilliant approach. What could possibly go wrong?

Yes, we'll divide the Sadrists into "good" and "bad" categories, and use them to do the job that the pathetic Iraqi military can't possibly even begin to approach. What's in it for the Sadrists? Pretty much nothing, of course. Since the Mahdi Army has "laid low" for much of the surge (with Bush taking credit for the corresponding small drop in violence), they now remain probably the strongest Iraqi force. They have no motivation to turn on their fellow Sadrists, since they have emerged as the major player and icon of resistance to the occupation. If they can wait out Bush, they will be the winners. Petraeus needs them, not the other way around. So far, all Bush is offering them is their choice of a slow death or a quick death. If Bush prevails, the Mahdi Army will be neutered and merely be an honor guard for a puppet government; the slow death. If they resist or remain "un-cooperative", then the plan will be to wipe them out; the quick death.
However, we've already seen how effective the "extermination" option was against the militias during the surge. The fact that Petraeus has to use this "good" Sadrist vs. "bad" Sadrists strategy only proves that the U.S. can't defeat them quickly and neatly. Sure, they can bomb, shell, and strafe neighbourhoods wholesale, all the while warning that withdrawal would lead to a huge civilian massacre. That would look pretty stupid, though, if we are merely there to kill off the civilians before the militias can do it.

And meanwhile, the heat will be off Al-Qaeda. Our "awakening" buddies will get slammed. The "good" terrorists will get bolder and more demanding of us. The infrastructure, economy, and political situation will continue to whimper and collapse. It will become much, much, harder to fake statistics, and Iraq certainly won't look more peaceful or stable to the domestic audience. The Iraqi government will ask us to leave, and we will lose the very last illusion of Iraqi sovereignty. And the "drawdown" of troops will have to be put on hold.

But of course, to Bush, the best possible outcome is the only likely outcome. That has been his approach for more than four years now. He's been wrong, excruciatingly wrong, for that entire time. His ill-conceived attempt for a quick fix will backfire simply because he lacks the ability to even conceive of a Plan B, much less the wisdom to see anything but a military solution to everything. In the end, the U.S. will be discredited in the Middle East as a clumsy aggressor and unreliable ally.


full story

US-IRAQ: Unable to Defeat Mahdi Army, U.S. Hopes to Divide It
Analysis by Gareth Porter*

WASHINGTON, Oct 8 (IPS) - Although the U.S. military command's frequent assertions that the primary threat to U.S. forces in Iraq comes from Iranian meddling, its real problem is that Shiite cleric Moqtada al Sadr's Mahdi army is determined to end the occupation and is simply too big and too well entrenched to be weakened by military force.

The U.S. command began trying to enter into a political dialogue with Sadr's followers in early 2006 and now claims that such a dialogue has begun, according to a Sep. 12 article by Ned Parker of the Los Angeles Times.

And Gen. David Petraeus hinted in his Congressional testimony last month at the need to negotiate a deal with the Sadrists. Petraeus said it is impossible to "kill or capture" all the "Sadr militia" and likened the problem to that of dealing with the Sunni insurgents who have now been allowed to become local security forces in Sunni neighbourhoods.

But the George W. Bush administration is not prepared to make peace with the Mahdi army. Instead it believes it can somehow divide it if it applies military pressure while wooing what it calls "moderates" in the Sadr camp. Parker quoted an anonymous administration official last month as suggesting that there were Sadrists "who we think we might be able to work with".

A U.S. commander in Baghdad, Lt. Col. Patrick Frank, told Parker last month that Sadrist representatives initiated indirect talks in late July, which were followed by Sadr's announcement at the end of August of a six-month hiatus in fighting.

But the proposal Frank made to the Mahdi army at a meeting Sep. 3 with both Sunni and Shiite community leaders suggests that Petraeus is on a short leash in negotiating local peace agreements. Frank proposed that the Mahdi army cease attacks for two weeks, and that the U.S. military would "consider reducing their raids in the district".

That was an offer that might have been expected from a newly installed occupation army rather than from one that has already admitted that it cannot prevail by using force and is bound to become weaker in the near future.

The U.S. command intends to increase the military pressure on the Mahdi army. Last week, Odierno announced that more military resources were being shifted from fighting against al Qaeda to operations against Shiite militiamen.

The idea of managing the Mahdi army problem by dividing it between "extremist" and "moderate" elements was integrated into the original "surge" strategy. Even before Petraeus took command in Baghdad last January, he and his second in command, Gen. Ray Odierno, had already decided to avoid a full-fledged military campaign against the Mahdi army.

Instead they adopted a strategy of trying to reach agreement with some of Sadr's followers -- perhaps including Sadr himself -- while targeting selected elements in the Mahdi army.

"There are some extreme elements, and we will go after them," Odierno said at a Jan. 7, 2007 news conference.

The strategy of making deals with "moderates" while attacking the "extreme elements" seemed to be given credibility when Sadr signaled in early 2007 that he was ordering the Madhi army to lie low and even to cooperate with the new U.S. Baghdad security plan.

As Sudarsan Raghavan of the Washington Post reported last May, the U.S. command even released one of Sadr's aides, Salah al-Obaidi, from Camp Cropper after five months in detention, in the belief that he was a "moderate" who could help shift the balance within the Madhi army against those determined to carry out military resistance against U.S. forces.

But contrary to the self-serving assumptions of Petraeus and Odierno, Sadr was avoiding a confrontation with U.S. forces because he believed that the occupation had entered its final phase, in which the Bush administration would be forced to negotiate a settlement prior to military withdrawal, and that he had only to keep the Madhi army intact to emerge victorious over his Shiite rivals associated with the al-Hakim family.

Sadr aides told Raghavan that the Shiite cleric viewed the Democratic takeover of Congress and the struggle over Iraq policy as evidence that the final phase of the war had begun. His expression of willingness to cooperate with U.S. forces was aimed at positioning himself to be the main Iraqi interlocutor for the United States in the transition period.

Significantly, however, Sadr refused to deal with the Bush administration, believing that the Democrats would take a less bellicose posture toward his movement.

In any case, Sadr's hopes that the U.S. command might leave the Madhi army alone were dashed by the aggressiveness of U.S. sweeps in Sadr City and other Sadr strongholds in Baghdad, which began in January even before the arrival of additional troops. By mid-March, Sadr had already begun to backtrack on cooperation with the U.S. occupation troops.

Even as Sadr was returning to open opposition to the U.S. military, the U.S. command was pushing the line that the Mahdi army was "splintering" and that attacks on U.S. troops were coming only from "rogue" Mahdi army elements.

A U.S. military official in Washington told the Associated Press in late March that some Madhi army figures were "breaking away to attempt a more conciliatory approach to the Americans and the Iraqi government", while others were "moving in a more extremist direction".

The key individual in the alleged "extremist" breakaway faction was said to be Qais al-Khazali, who was Sadr's main spokesman in 2003 and 2004. Khazali and his brother, who had just been captured a few days before, were leaders of an Iraqi network which had apparently procured armour-piercing bombs and other weapons for the Madhi army.

In July, the U.S. military spokesman, Brig. Gen. Kevin Bergner, cited Khazali's alleged testimony under interrogation as supporting the command's argument that the Iranian Quds Force was creating a "Hezbollah-like" Shiite pro-Iranian force to do its bidding in Iraq.

But Maj. Gen. Michael Barbero, deputy director for Regional Operations at the Joint Staff in Washington, had obviously not been consulted about the Khazali breakaway ploy. In a press briefing on Mar. 30, Barbero said, "[W]e assess that there are links between these brothers and Sadr's organisation."

Bergner's portrayal of the Khazali organisation as detached from Sadr's movement was an example of how the U.S. command embraces interpretations that serve its political-military objectives, even when they don't reflect its own intelligence judgments.

When the U.S. command carried out arrests of Mahdi army commanders or cell leaders last spring and summer, they invariably referred to the targets as "rogue" Mahdi army. In one such operation, U.S. and Iraqi troops captured the commander of what were called a "high-level rogue Jaysh al-Mahdi commander" of an "assassination cell" of more than 100 members.

But according to a New York Times report Jul. 28, both the head of the Sadr office in Baghdad and a Sadrist cleric preaching in nearby Kufa condemned the raid and called for the release of the detainees, indicating that they are still part of the Madhi army.

The "rogue" designation apparently referred to their resistance to the occupation, not to their relationship to the Mahdi army command.

The U.S. command's line that Iran is using Hezbollah operatives to train Shiite militias that had broken away from Sadr was further discredited when Sadr admitted in an interview with The Independent in August that his organisation has "formal links" with Hezbollah, has sent fighters to Lebanon for training and would continue to do so.

*Gareth Porter is an historian and national security policy analyst. His latest book, "Perils of Dominance: Imbalance of Power and the Road to War in Vietnam", was published in June 2005.

Thursday, October 04, 2007

Bush shuns and insults Britain

I guess it's not enough that Britain backed Bush in his ill-conceived, delusional, and disatrous invasion and occupation of Iraq from the start. Or that Britain has been by far the most reliable ally in Afghanistan. Or that they took their military to the brink of collapse in Iraq as Bush kept up the "turning the corner" masquerade. It also isn't enough that Britain squandered several billion in Iraq with nothing to show for it.

No, Britain didn't destroy their military or go bankrupt backing Bush, so now they are "unworthy".

And, of course, Bush new-found allies in France and Germany won't take this as an object lesson on the cost of following his delusional policies.

The worst part, by far, is the insult to the British military in saying that they have "performed poorly in Basra".

France has taken no part in Iraq or Afghanistan. Germany has restricted itself to safe parts of Afghanistan, and even then will only commit to training the Afghan police. Great allies, eh? However, since they back Bush's new war against Iran, they are apparently Bush's new best friends.

full story from The Daily Telegraph

Britain 'no longer closest Bush ally'


By Toby Harnden in Washington
Last Updated: 12:01am BST 03/10/2007

The White House no longer views Britain as its most loyal ally in Europe since Gordon Brown took office and is instead increasingly turning towards France and Germany, according to Bush administration sources.
"There's concern about Brown," a senior White House foreign policy official told The Daily Telegraph. "But this is compensated by the fact that Paris and Berlin are much less of a headache. The need to hinge everything on London as the guarantor of European security has gone."
With Tony Blair departed, Nicolas Sarkozy, the French president, is seen by many as the man George W Bush can best do business with in Europe. Although Angela Merkel, the German chancellor, has not lived up to initial expectations in Washington, she is still seen as far preferable to her predecessor Gerhard Schröder.

The White House official added that Britain would always be "the cornerstone" of US policy towards Europe but there was "a lot of unhappiness" about how British forces had performed in Basra and an acceptance that Mr Brown would pull the remaining 4,500 troops out of Iraq next year.
"Operationally, British forces have performed poorly in Basra," said the official. "Maybe it's best that they leave. Now we will have a clear field in southern Iraq." Another White House official described Mr Brown as "challenging" and far less close to the US than Mr Blair.
There has been a notable reduction in contact between Downing Street and the White House since Mr Blair left and US officials have remarked on how few British ministers have visited Washington in recent months.
...
Privately, White House aides accept that Mr Brown would not support military action against Iran. There is also disquiet about what US officials view as double dealing by special advisers briefing an anti-White House message in London and a more favourable one in Washington. "That sort of manoeuvring is not appreciated," said one diplomatic source.
The wariness about Mr Brown could open doors to the Conservative Party.
Owen Paterson, the shadow Northern Ireland secretary, recently met several key White House officials, including Barry Jackson, who recently took over many of Karl Rove's duties as a policy adviser to Mr Bush.
A British diplomatic source said: "In the White House there's a sense of enormous change from Blair. They used to be on the phone to Blair all the time and that's no longer the case because Brown clearly wants to be the unBlair.
"At the Pentagon, there's a feeling that Britain is letting the side down on Iraq. The new best friend is Sarkozy and that means Brown taking a step back doesn't matter as much. In White House eyes, Sarkozy is taking up the slack from Blair. "When things get tough, however, they're likely to turn to Britain again."


Saturday, September 22, 2007

Iraqi provincial control date moves back again

We now learn that 60% of the Iraqi police we have trained thus far are no longer on the job. Also, Bush promised when he proposed the surge, the Iraqis would have control of all 18 provinces by November. Now he is talking about July '08. Of course, if violence continues, it may be even later. Any wagers on the cessation of violence in Iraq over next 8 months?

In yet another example of Bush's brilliant skills in prediction and his unwarranted optimism, five months after he promised to hold the al-Maliki government to the November benchmark, he moved that date to March '08. Now he is moving that date to July '08, in spite of claims of remarkable 'progress' in the September report.

If things looked good enough in Iraq back in January to expect Iraq to take over security by November, and we've had so much "progress" from the surge since then, why does the date keep moving further away? Before all of the surge troops were even in place, he had already added four months to the handover date. And this was all while Bush was talking up the immense "success".
Bush's real plan and strategy in Iraq has been essentially to cross his fingers and hope for a miracle, while passing on the disaster to his successor. He keeps creating new scapegoats for his failure: Al-Qaeda, Iran, the "traitorous" American public, Syria, and now the corpse of Saddam Hussein.

Bush sold his surge to the American public with 18 benchmarks that he himself created. He succeeded in 3 of them. He promised to hold the Iraqi government to those benchmarks. Then he said that was unrealistic, and that nobody could possibly have seriously expected the benchmarks to be met. He said that the Iraqi military would lead the surge, with U.S. in merely a support role. Then he said it was silly to think that the Iraqi forces would ever have been able to do something like that, since there are now fewer Iraqi troops ready to operate independently than there were before the surge.

Bush keeps on making promises and then basically saying that we were stupid to actually believe that last promise, but his new promises are really, truly sincere. And every failure of his policies is really only further proof that we need to continue them.

full story

More Delays in Shift to Iraqi Control

WASHINGTON (AP) — In another sign of U.S. struggles in Iraq, the target date for putting Iraqi authorities in charge of security in all 18 provinces has slipped yet again, to at least July.

The delay, noted in a Pentagon report to Congress on progress and problems in Iraq, highlights the difficulties in developing Iraqi police forces and the slow pace of economic and political progress in some areas.

It is the second time this year the target date for completing what is known as "Provincial Iraqi Control" has been pushed back. The Pentagon report submitted to Congress on Monday hinted at the possibility of further delays.

....

The intent is to give the provincial governments control over security in their area as a step toward lessening — and eventually ending — the U.S. security role.

Thus far seven of the 18 provinces have reverted to Iraqi control.

The process has gained relatively little attention in the broader debate in Washington about when and how to get the Iraqis ready to provide their own security so that U.S. forces can begin to leave. That may be in part because some details of the provincial transition process are classified secret.

...

An independent commission that examined the issue of provincial Iraqi control this summer concluded in a report to Congress on Sept. 4 that the process is too convoluted and an impediment to the overall U.S. goals of speeding the transition to Iraqi control and supporting sovereignty.

"Our current policy of determining when a province may or may not be controlled by its own government reinforces the popular perception of the (U.S.-led) coalition as an occupation force," according to the commission, headed by retired Marine Gen. James Jones. "This may contribute to increased violence and instability."

The commission recommended that all 18 provinces return to Iraqi control immediately. U.S. forces would continue to operate in the areas they are now, in coordination with Iraqi authorities; Iraqi control would mean U.S. troops could transition to less combat-intense roles.

In an interview Wednesday, Jones said he and the other commissioners got the strong impression from Iraqi officials they met in Baghdad this summer that they want full provincial control without further delay.

"The whole process seems to be acting as more of a brake on progress than a help," Jones said. "If the Iraqi government is willing, I think we should be putting as much on them as possible. To have a sovereign government that doesn't control all of its provinces doesn't make a lot of sense to me."

In an Associated Press interview last week, Gen. David Petraeus, the top U.S. commander in Iraq, defended the transition process. It involves a series of detailed reviews and assessments by U.S. and Iraqi officials, culminating with input by Petraeus and the most senior Iraqi government leaders.

Though slow, it is helpful in sorting out problems that stand in the way of a smooth transition, he said.

"It forces people to come to grips with those issues," Petraeus said.

In January, Bush announced his new strategy for stabilizing Iraq and his decision to send an additional 21,500 U.S. combat troops to Baghdad and to Anbar province. He, said, at the time, that the Iraqi government "plans to take responsibility for security in all of Iraq's provinces by November."

In June the Pentagon informed Congress that the target had slipped to "no later than" next March.

In this month's report, the Pentagon said its "current projection" was that all 18 provinces would move to Iraqi control "as early as" July; that would be eight months later than Bush's original projection.

...

The Pentagon report cited a litany of problems with the police. For example, it said as few as 40 percent of those trained by coalition troops in recent years are still on the job. Also, due to combat loss, theft, attrition and poor maintenance, a "significant portion" of U.S.-issued equipment is now unusable.


Or, as Juan Cole summarised it:

Just to underline what is said here, 60 percent of the policemen who got even the very minimal training on offer to them have disappeared from the force; and not much is left of the weaponry ("equipment") that the US gave the Iraqi police.

The report is here (pdf).

Bush says his plans for Iraq were unrealistic

What we have now is the Decider saying that nobody could possibly have expected the restoration of democracy in Iraq or the hand off of security responsibility to Iraqis to succeed. It's just too difficult, there are too many challenges, and it's Saddam's fault, besides.

Then why did has he spent the past four years or so telling us that these things were proceeding smoothly?

full story from VOA

Bush: Saddam's Legacy Slowing Progress in Iraq

President Bush says one of the reasons for the slow pace of political progress in Baghdad is the continuing legacy of former dictator Saddam Hussein.

When President Bush announced he was sending reinforcements to Iraq earlier this year, one of his goals was to have Iraqis in charge of security in all 18 provinces by November.

That is not going to happen. And U.S. military officials say it will not until next July, at the earliest.


Yes, this was one of the promises of the surge: that Iraqis would take control of the security situation so that we could leave. It failed. Bush bought himself nine more months on Iraq by making big promises, and now he is using his failure to deliver on those promises as a bizarre justification to ask for more time. No new plan this time around, just a stall.

Acknowledging the slower than expected progress at a White House news conference Thursday, the president said while the timing has changed, his determination has not.

"The goals are the same," said President Bush. "And have we achieved them as fast? No we haven't. But, however, having not achieved them doesn't mean we ought to quit."


Perhaps it does mean that we could reasonably expect doubts on Bush's ability to predict success, however. Bush has been consistently wrong on virtually every prediction for years. Perhaps we could take this opportunity to re-assess our strategy? Bush's answer is that apparently it's Saddam's fault.


Mr. Bush said one of the reasons there is not what he called "instant democracy" in Iraq is that people there are still recovering from the former regime's violence against political opponents. President Bush said the former Iraqi ruler Saddam Hussein prevented the possible emergence of a unifying figure akin to South Africa's Nelson Mandela.
"Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas," said Mr. Bush. "He was a brutal tyrant who divided people up and split families and people are recovering from this. So there is a psychological recovery that is taking place, and it is hard work for them."


Did we not know this before the invasion?
It took over four years to figure out that Iraq is not suitable for democracy? This is hardly "instant democracy", either. And if we did know this, then why did Bush continually predict "instant democracy" and prosperity for years?

It is obvious that Bush's plan was to install Ahmed Challabi as a puppet leader who would virtually give away Iraq's oil to the 'liberators'. The Iraqis, however, would have none of it. So we had elections, which the Sunnis boycotted. Yes, despite all the "Mandelas" being wiped out by Saddam, we proceeded with elections. Now wise old Mr. Bush tells us that we shouldn't have expected this to succeed. Then why did we do it, and why was has it been presented as the major glowing achievement of the invasion?

Similarly, the Iraqi military was supposed to take the lead in the surge and restore security. That was the plan as proposed by Bush in his January 10 speech. Now we are told that this is completely unrealistic, that the Iraqi military cannot possibly be trained fast enough to have enough numbers to take over.
Then why was that the plan?

Bush is, in effect, saying that his own plans for democracy and security were ridiculous, and that nobody should ever have expected them to succeed.
He certainly didn't share that bit of wisdom with the nation, did he?


The president is trying to rebuild public support for the war, in part by announcing that progress there now allows him to bring nearly 6,000 U.S. troops home from Iraq by the end of the year.


In other words, troops that were told they would be coming home by the end of the year are now actually being allowed to come home. And this is because of the surge's "success", somehow. And there's so much 'progress' that we can now admit that this plan was fatally flawed from the outset. Sounds like a great way to "rebuild public support".

Iraq is a central issue in the race to succeed President Bush, with most opposition Democrats calling for more troop withdrawals and most Republicans backing the president.

Asked if he is an asset or a liability for his Republican Party, Mr. Bush said he is a strong asset.

"Candidates who go out and say that helping these Iraqis realize the benefits of democracy are going to do well," he said. "Candidates who go out and say that it is very important for the U.S. to have clear principles when it comes to foreign policy, they will do well."

VOA News

Those candidates had better be able to show any "benefits" from that democracy. The government the Iraqis elected is impotent and incompetent. 50,000 Iraqis each month flee the "benefits of democracy", and most of them in favour of an authoritarian police state in Syria. The health care, water delivery, and electrical delivery infrastructures have collapsed. New victims of sectarian violence show up in Baghdad nearly every day. Torture in Iraqi prisons is commonplace. People wait all day in lines for the mere chance of buying gasoline at ridiculous prices. Contractors kill innocent civilians on the street and the government's demands that they be expelled are ignored by the U.S.

As for "clear principles when it comes to foreign policy", all Bush has to offer are constantly shifting goals. The current one is that we are dividing the terrorists into 'good' and 'bad' categories. The 'good terrorists' will be used to wipe out the 'bad terrorists', since the Iraqi military is a no-show. But we're against terrorism, unless the terrorists make a temporary alliance with us to wipe out the competition. And somehow the 'good terrorists' will just fade quietly away after the 'bad terrorists' are defeated. How could this possibly fail?
In 2003 our goals were:

"We will disarm Saddam Hussein and thwart the danger posed by his weapons of mass destruction, bring stability and unity to a free Iraq, "deliver medicine to the sick," and move emergency rations to feed the hungry. "After defeating enemies, we did not leave behind occupying armies, we left constitutions and parliaments. We established an atmosphere of safety, in which responsible, reform-minded local leaders could build lasting institutions of freedom. In societies that once bred fascism and militarism, liberty found a permanent home."

And now we are reduced to merely hoping that we can keep the violence to pre-surge levels while the country whimpers in economic, social, and ethnic chaos.

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Republicans have lost the public

Republicans live in some kind of Fox News-fueled fantasy world where it is always 1994. This is how they could look at Bush's 51/49 victory in 2004 and see not only a "landslide", but a "mandate". Most people would look at those numbers and say half of the country opposes you. As Bush slipped to 40% support in the polls, then to 30%, Republicans still went into the 2006 elections believing they would win big. Now, after losing both the House and Senate, a wave of resignations among sitting Congresspeople and Cabinet members, and widespread collective yawning whenever the Decider recites his talking points, Republicans still feel, somehow, that the public supports them. In 2002, a wave of Republicans were elected largely on the basis of being associated with the Bush "team". Any idiot, with the proper evangelical Christian credentials and history of political donations, could read the script and get elected. That was then; this is now.

Those Senators and Representatives who got elected by dropping Bush's name are not in such a good position now. Bush is unpopular, for several reasons. Rather than stand on their own and explain why they are a more qualified candidate than their opponent, they apparently will still cling to the "team" model. In effect, they are asking the electorate to not look very closely at them and vote for the party's plan, of which they are on board. You don't pick up Independents with this kind of campaign, however. The "my opponent is a traitor" message only works with the people who already support you.

As for the war and occupation, all Republicans are offering is more of it, and perhaps a couple new ones. Americans do like to win, but they also like a quick, decisive win. Petraeus is saying ten more years in Iraq, on top of what will be five years when the election rolls around. The WMD, "flypaper", and liberation theses have not gained public acceptance, nor are they likely to. Bush has pushed his talking points weekly, almost daily, and nobody is buying except for the same relatively few people who bought them all along. This is why the false "critics of the war", O'Hanlon and Pollack, were such a media asset; these were people who, allegedly, changed their minds about the occupation and the surge. The truth is, however, that nobody is changing their minds about Iraq. It's virtually fixed in stone, and it's against the Republicans. O'Hanlon and Pollack were supporters of the surge all along, though one of the pair was a "critic" of its relatively small size.

The Petraeus report was going to change all of that. The public was supposed to believe that great progress was being made, and somehow also believe that there was so much progress that we would be staying in Iraq a long time. Data was fixed, statistics doctored, isolated examples were portrayed as if they were the whole story, scary predictions were made, straw men were set up and knocked down, accusations of treason were repeatedly made....but still, no minds were changed. Politically, Bush merely treaded water and held on to the support that he had before the report. All of that effort to get back to where they started, with yet another report due in six months when the same fiasco will be replayed.

Two polls (the article below) show that Bush gained nothing from the September report. And In fact, a poll taken before the report was made, showed that there was deep scepticism of the report's honesty. There was sham "news" of actually letting soldiers whose tours are up return home, and this was presented as a "withdrawal". Ending the surge, which was supposed to be temporary from the outset, was portrayed as a "drawdown". People looked back on what they had expected the surge to accomplish when it was proposed, and what actually had been accomplished. They were not impressed. Americans were again called traitors. Nobody really paid much attention. Stories of scary Islamic bogeymen were employed. America yawned.

There is very little serious consideration by Republicans as to what a post-election situation will mean for their Party. Just like the unwarranted optimism employed throughout the war and occupation, they still think the next report in March will do great things for them. They still believe they have credibility with the public, because all they hear is their own echo chamber of Fox News and talk radio, and that tells them they are on top. And, if Bush actually permits the elections to occur, they will experience a rude awakening when they lose the White House. At this point, it doesn't look as if the Democrats will win a veto-proof majority in the Senate, but who cares if the next President isn't making vetoes?

As for now, the polls are not good for Republicans:


story from CNN

Polls: Bush, Petraeus didn't change public views on Iraq


By Bill Schneider
CNN Senior Political Analyst

WASHINGTON (CNN) -- There were two high-profile media events about Iraq last week: The top U.S. commander testified before Congress and President Bush delivered a prime-time speech. What impact did they have?

Very little, according to two polls taken at the end of the week.

Before the testimony of Gen. David Petraeus and the President's speech, 26 percent of Americans polled by CBS News approved of President Bush's handling of Iraq. After the speech, 25 percent approved.

Before the testimony and the speech, 41 percent of Americans believed the United States did the right thing to take military action in Iraq. After the speech, 39 percent said it was the right thing.

The poll's margin of error was plus-or-minus 4 percent.

President Bush spoke about a "return on success.'' Drawing on General Petraeus' " . . . belief we're succeeding, his belief we will succeed,'' the president asked "the United States Congress to support the troop levels and the strategies I have embraced.''

Democrats were skeptical. "We have now set the bar so low, that modest improvement in what was a completely chaotic situation -- to the point where now we just have the levels of intolerable violence that existed in June of 2006 -- is considered a success, and it's not," said Sen. Barack Obama, D-Illinois.

Does the public believe the U.S. troop build-up is making the situation in Iraq better? Before last week, 35 percent of Americans said yes in the CBS News poll. At the end of the week, 31 percent said yes.

A poll by the Pew Research Center for the People & the Press found 54 percent of Americans want the U.S. to bring its troops home as soon as possible -- that's the same as in July.

The Pew poll's margin of error was plus-or-minus 2.5 percent.

President Bush's overall job approval hardly changed. It was 30 percent before the speech and 29 percent after. But the president's rating did jump 15 points among Republicans.

Bottom line? Nothing much changed. The public still wants out of Iraq. But the president's Republican base remains loyal.

Sunday, September 16, 2007

Bush gambles and loses on Iraq

Bush's "the way forward" non-plan is simply to go back to what we doing before the surge, only now we have categorised the sectarian militias into "good" and "bad" terrorists. The "good" terrorists are doing the job that the Iraqi military and Police were supposed to do, which only serves to prove that the Iraqi military and Police are a failure. Remember, the surge plan was to have the Iraqi military take the lead in a massive clampdown on the sectarian militias. It never happened, largely because the military and Police are thoroughly, hopelessly infiltrated by the militias themselves. So the surge plan, as it was proposed, failed miserably in one of the fundamental aspects.

The White House, along with the Iraqi government, put together 18 benchmarks for judgment of the surge's effectiveness. Congress did not put these benchmarks together. In effect, they gave Bush the chance to write his own exam. Why would the White House and the Iraqi government put together a list of benchmarks that they thought they could not meet? The answer is obviously they thought the surge would be a glorious success, the benchmarks would be met, and Iraq would be looking more or less peaceful by the time the September report came around. This is just one more example of the unwarranted optimism Bush employs in every aspect of his Administration. When asked after the surge was proposed why he thought this effort would succeed where the previous efforts had not, Bush replied, "Because now it has to". Oh, okay. So virtually any strategy could be justified under this reasoning, because now it has to work.

Republicans were convinced that the surge would yield great progress by the September report's release, and so kept deferring judgment on the surge until then. They surely were told by the White House that the Iraq strategy would be vindicated by Petraeus, and that they could take victory to the polls in November '08. Instead, it was more of the same. The public remained unconvinced of the 'progress', and the report only gave Republicans some small, dubious cover. But the die was already set. The Republicans had gone too far down the imaginary road of Bush's vision, and there is not enough time nor is there the courage for the GOP to back away from Bush now.

When you write the "exam", and have to quibble over getting 'partial credit' over the "questions" you got wrong, and make up your own definitions as you go, then one would not regard that as a sign of 'progress' on your part. When you fail the exam that you wrote, and ask for six more months before taking the "exam" again, then you are merely stalling.

It has nothing to do with wanting to "win" or "lose". I concede there was a possibility of post-invasion success, but the White House destroyed that possibility quickly in the early months of the occupation, and never really regained its balance since. They failed. Whether we want them to succeed or fail does not matter; they failed, completely and miserably. They continually made glowing predictions of imminent success, but they never came to pass. Bush certainly wanted to "win", but merely wanting to win is not enough. Bush got every dime that he asked for, and more, from the Congress. Bush boldly laid out a course and ignored public opinion, always believing that he would be rewarded with big success for his patience. He gambled and lost, but is still unwilling to accept the consequences of his failed wager. He could have succeeded, but he didn't. He failed, and we are stuck with the bill. And like a failed gambler, he is still hitting us up for more time and more money until he gets his big score. Just one more throw of the dice, and you'll see. He'll win big, because now he has to. And he really, truly expects that this approach will work on the American public, not to mention our allies. His judgment is impaired, and if you want to be the Decider, then good judgment is essential.


story from China Daily:

US report offers no solution: Arabs

DUBAI: The report by the top US general in Iraq offers no new ideas on ending bloodshed and suggests Washington has lost the war whether its troops stay in Iraq or go, according to analysts in the Arab world.

General David Petraeus, facing Democratic lawmakers and many voters demanding a quick end to the US engagement in Iraq, recommended cutting American troops by 30,000 in the next year but not fundamentally changing strategy in the war.

The reduction would return US troop strength to roughly the same level it was before an increase ordered by US President George W. Bush from February to June.

Analysts from across the Arab world were disappointed by the reports from Petraeus and US Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker, which they said seemed calculated only to shore up Bush's policy and preclude any substantial shift in approach on Iraq.

"Washington wants to bring the situation in Iraq back to square one, to the pre-surge period, which means there is no improvement. Things are not really moving forward," said Khaled al-Dakhil, a political sociology professor in Saudi Arabia.

Gulf Research Center's Sulayman Awad Ibrahim said it was worrying that Washington was relying on tribal leaders to push out Al-Qaida. "How can a few tribes, and these are really militias, in Anbar do what 160,000 US soldiers could not do? There must be something wrong. The US is, after all, the world's only superpower," he said. "When a government loses credibility, not just with the occupied people but with their own people, it is very difficult to regain the confidence that they can fulfil their mission."

With sectarian violence in Iraq raging and Washington apparently unwilling or unable to change course, some analysts said they feared Iraq would crumble into three parts - a Kurdish north, a Shi'ite south run by parties and militias close to Iran and Sunni tribes controlling the center.

Source: China Daily/agencies