Well, here we are, post-election and nearly post-holidays.
Apparently the nation has "been defeated", as McCain put it before it the election. Socialism is now to be the order of the day, if the weak and desperate spin of the McCain campaign is to be believed. Let's pause to look back at what the Republicans offered to the nation in their defeated effort.
They offered FEAR, and lots of it. Obama has something to hide, and "questions remain". The "questions" were, of course, answered, but the Republicans simply didn't like the answers or didn't believe them. Thus, these 'questions' remained. And there never really was any way to "answer" these so-called 'questions', because they weren't really questions at all; they were slanders designed to induce vague doubts that could not be proven or really disproved. All that was clear was that Republicans were completely convinced that Obama was some kind of Marxist radical who had a diabolical (but absolutely vague) scheme to destroy America. There was no evidence, merely associations backed up by an incredible amount of exaggeration, speculation, and wild leaps of logic. Republicans believed in the validity of these 'questions', largely because other Republicans believed in their validity, and that was good enough for them.
One of the biggest (and stupidest) gambles the Republicans made in the election was in believing that their Party still had credibility. Thus, if the Republicans said Obama was a Marxist radical bent on destroying America, then the electorate would believe it. The Republicans had spent so much time in their echo chamber, isolated from the rest of the world, that they had really come to believe that those outside of their artificial world agreed with them. Anyone outside of the bubble could have seen that the Republicans stopped trying to persuade anyone over to their beliefs years ago. Instead, they wrote off the non-Republicans as some tiny core of "far-leftists" who were universally despised as traitors, defeatists, and degenerates. Their messages were drenched in circular logic and the premises of those messages were only accepted by the "faithful". Apparently, everyone "knew" that the typical Democrat really longed for a Soviet-style state, cheered on terrorists, and rejoiced at our nation's every troop casualty. On top of this, the typical Democrat was "known" to have no "values", and they celebrated every abortion, engaged in promiscuous and dangerous sexual acts, were addicted to hard drugs, and would probably kill you if you didn't have several guns already.
Thus, it was inconceivable to the typical Republican that Americans would embrace a Democratic candidate. It was "obvious" that the Democratic party stood for Satanism, Stalinism, and the Sixties. The Republicans merely had to point this out, and McCain was guaranteed to win.
The truth is that Republican credibility suffered a mortal blow in 2005, and never really recovered. Katrina showed the inept and incompetent Administration lackeys, who were given jobs solely based on loyalty and their ability to parrot talking points. As Iraq became a quagmire, the Decider made wildly upbeat and optimistic statements on an almost daily basis, backed up by his Party. Expressing doubt or scepticism was clearly a sign that one was a traitor or a terrorist sympathiser who wanted America to "lose". The nation saw a Party that not only demanded blind obedience and faith, but that also put on a bizarre Tinkerbell-like performance: if we all clap loud enough and believe in the Decider, then we will win the War On Terror. In general, the nation saw an Administration that chose the outcome it wanted and then believed that the outcome was guaranteed simply because they envisioned it, with facts and arms twisted to conform with that vision. The economy began a slow slide that ended with a sharp drop off the cliff just before the election, and the Republicans continued their sunny, logically-deficient optimism until it was far too late to back-pedal.
And yet they still believed that they had credibility.
The GOP had essentially turned itself into a religion instead of a political organisation. They were the Believers, in more ways than one. No dissent was tolerated, for that would be a sign of Doubt. If one did not believe, completely and blindly, in the Party, then one did not believe in America and one wished for the nation's demise. Just as fundamentalist Christians dismiss all other religions as cults, idol-worshipping, or just a variation of good old-fashioned Satanism, so too did the Party set up a false dichotomy in the political arena. There were only Patriots and Communists, and the only way to be a good Patriot was to be a good Republican. To believe otherwise was contrary to the "religion", and since the majority of Americans did not want to see the country destroyed, then they would surely vote Republican.
This is why we see the promulgation of the "centre-right country" myth. It is a feeble and desperate attempt on the Republicans' part to preserve their "religion". The country still believes in everything that the Party believes in, per this myth, but the electorate failed to cast their votes for the Party. Thus, if a Marxist hell is avoided, it will be because the electorate firmly believes in the Republicans' ideals, not due to anything that the Obama Administration does or does not do. If Christians are not persecuted and hunted down, it will be because the vast majority believe in the GOP and will not permit the Democrats to carry out their Satanic schemes. And so forth and so on. The religion of the Republican party is thus preserved among the Faithful.
Aside from ramming fundamentalist Christianity down the nation's collective throats, what else did the Republicans offer in the McCain campaign?
War, and lots of it. There are always unfortunate situations that require military action, especially when this is the only permissible tool in the policy toolbox. Thus, the only way to be safe is to bankrupt our economy in more quagmires, which we can never disengage from lest it be seen as a sign of weakness. To do anything less is the equivalent of lining up our nation's children and shooting them - which is probably one of the Obama Administration's secret plans, anyway.
Police-state powers, and lots of them - to preserve our freedom, of course. Total, absolute secrecy is regrettably required, because the "terrorists might be listening". Scapegoats must be created and identified, with guilt presumed beforehand. Some will not confess immediately, in order to make our leaders look bad, but eventually it will become clear that we were right all along to suspect them if we are allowed to "take the gloves off". Who really knows what torture is, anyway? The Party with blinding moral clarity and simplistic answers at the ready is oddly philosophical here, isn't it? Suddenly, "moral relativism" can be embraced in this situation.
So we have fear, war, and paranoia as the primary campaign themes. The only real policy issue that was covered by the McCain campaign was health care. In reality, the Republican scheme would have caused millions to lose their coverage, since employers would drop their health plans in response. Certainly, nothing in the Republican plan requires the employer to do so, but it seems obvious that if the government is providing a deduction for individuals to buy their own health insurance that the employer can safely get out of the health care business. And somehow, simply giving people $5000 to buy insurance is not socialism, though it is a refundable tax credit. And giving everyone $5k doesn't cost any money, because it's just taxes the government wouldn't be collecting in the first place, right? Really, though, you would never even see that money. It would go straight to the insurance company. And McCain promised that his Administration would "work with" insurance companies on the issue of pre-existing conditions. What does that mean, exactly? It means nothing, except that you would not be covered for pre-existing conditions, meaning that only the healthy would have health coverage. What a step forward. Likewise, any idea that a "high-risk pool" would ensure coverage under the $5k limit was abandoned as 'regulation'.
In states where auto liability insurance is mandatory, there is a "high risk pool" mandated to be maintained by the insurance companies. This means that if you have had seven accidents in the past year and a DUI on your record, you can still obtain insurance at an astronomical cost from the "high risk pool". You cannot be denied liability coverage if you are a licensed driver.
Now, suppose you are a sick person with leukaemia and require about $15k a year in medical treatment. What insurance company will provide you with coverage for only $5k a year? None of them. Either that, or they would sell you coverage and deny all claims based on a "pre-existing condition". How would a McCain Administration persuade an insurance company to lose $10k a year when they "work with" them on coverage for pre-existing conditions? The answer is, they don't. The likely result is that our hypothetical patient would get $5k of the $20k needed to obtain health insurance, meaning they would still pay as much for health care as they did when they were 'uninsured'. This is how the insurance industry would "work with" the Administration on pre-existing conditions.
Meanwhile, the loss of $5k per taxpayer in revenue is a definite "cost", isn't it? Is there a real difference in the bottom line between the federal government paying a certain amount of money and not getting a certain amount of money to begin with? Only in ideological terms.
Republicans argue against "single-payer" not only on ideological grounds, but also on cost.
"If you think health care is expensive now, just wait until it's free", is the glib mantra. The problem is that, under the McCain proposal, more people would have coverage than they do now and costs would go up. The only way to limit cost is to deny treatment, or provide treatment in a pro-active manner. The latter method costs money up front, and saves money in the long term. The former method means that more uninsured individuals show up in the emergency room with avoidable conditions at a greater cost for treatment. It is notable that one of the McCain "advisers" on health care policy claimed that everyone is "insured" under the current scheme because they have access to emergency room care. Likewise, the idea that the average person is going to "shop around" and contest payments is absurd. Who has the time to "shop around" for the lowest price on an office visit, then "shop around" for the lowest price on a certain lab procedure, then search out the lowest price on follow-up care, and then "shop around" for the lowest price on a prescription? Is there transportation to get you to the slightly cheaper lab, doctor, or pharmacy 40 miles away? What happens to continuity of care when you spread your medical treatment out between a dozen different providers? Mistakes are made, efforts are duplicated, links are missed, and costs go up. But we manage to avoid the ideological hazard of 'socialism', so it's okay.
So we see that the McCain campaign was not only peddling very, very few actual ideas, but that these ideas were bad in practical terms. By and large, they were trying to sell fear and doubt, with a side of jingoism.
But what really killed the Republican effort was the economy.
This was not some magical mishap that befell the Party, but rather the logical result of their policies. The real collapse of the "mortgage industry" was not in making bad loans, but rather in the sale of insurance for those bad loans. Insurance on mortgages was traded by institutions that had no idea how risky those loans were, to people who had no idea that they were on the hook if those loans failed. They were merely pieces of paper that gained value every time they were traded, as if by magic. We allowed institutions to act as banks without the regulations governing banks. And the Republicans pointed to the money being made by these institutions as "proof" that regulations were bad. At the same time, those tax cuts that were supposed to be invested domestically in the creation of jobs were, once again, ploughed into offshore ventures or kept "within the family" by way of huge bonuses. Just as with Reagan's supply-side economics, the wealthy once again failed to step up to the plate and instead took the money and ran. Pointing this out, of course, is "class warfare" to Republicans. Republicans are fond of putting their shills on parade and parroting talking points, such as "I've never been employed by a poor man". You know what, though? If nobody has money to buy what the rich man is selling, that shill won't get employed in the first place. History has shown that the wealthy have repeatedly balked at employing that shill, when they can move their operations to China and employ people at less cost. Then Wal-Mart sells the wealthy person's products at a lower price, killing off local jobs. The end result is we all end up working for Wal-Mart, looking over our shoulders at some poor desperate sap who is willing to take our job for ten cents less an hour, while our government has less money to invest in infrastructure or training to improve the economy, and the wealthy get a bigger pile of cash which they refuse to risk by lending to us.
But we avoid those terrifying ideological hazards of 'socialism'. Instead, we work harder for less money and no benefits, with no job security, while every means to better ourselves is eliminated by budget cuts due to declining tax revenue. That is the economic vision the Republicans offer. We keep more of our "hard-earned money", while making it ever more unlikely that we will see it to begin with and working even harder to earn it.
I would respect the Republicans more if they were willing to take the wealthy to task for failing to hold up their end of the supply-side "bargain", but they won't. Instead, they abjure the middle class to spend more, while berating them for accumulating the consumer debt that enables them to do so. Oddly, the solution is always more tax cuts for the wealthy, because this time the wealthy will use it to our benefit. Really. We really, really mean it this time. And if that doesn't work, well, there's always more tax cuts for the wealthy. It can't fail now. And so forth and so on.
And so, the last defence for the Republicans is the Culture War.
Yes, re-fighting the Sixties is completely relevant to people who never lived through it, right?
It turns out that it really isn't. Not only that, but the people who did live through it aren't at all interested in re-visiting it. Ward and June Cleaver are dead. We aren't going back to the Fifties, which was a time of widespread poverty that is glossed over in nostalgia. Besides, a case can certainly be made that the worst excesses of the Sixties were in response to the heavy-handed repression of the Culture Warriors to begin with. The "values" that the Republicans are really pushing are bigotry, conformity, unquestioning obedience to authority, and "knowing one's place" in the social order. It doesn't matter who you are, it matters who people think you are. All of the other "values" preached by the Republicans are readily sacrificed with pride in the name of preserving the values I just mentioned. Thus, beating someone up that doesn't conform is your sacred duty, not some aberration of "values", for example. If the police arrest someone for a crime, obviously it is because they were guilty, so let's not "second-guess" authority. Any violation of the Republican's putative "values" is also acceptable if nobody finds out about it. It's an ugly paradigm that guarantees that those on the bottom will stay on the bottom, as part of God's Will, or something.
Now that a Democrat is soon to be in the White House, we can expect that the Republican concept of "criticising a sitting President during time of war is tantamount to treason" to conveniently disappear. Once again, dissent will be one's sacred duty, and not something that only whiners and traitors engage in. Republicans who presided over Bush's record debt will now be very concerned about fiscal restraint. We also will be admonished about the limits of Executive power by those who once asserted that those limits did not exist. Government "intrusion" will soon be something to be terrified of, not at all like the warrantless wiretaps, data mining, and rampant use of 'security letters' that the Bush Administration was so brave in carrying out. We can also look forward to the very odd phenomenon of criticising foreign policy as part of 'supporting the troops', when just yesterday it was 'undermining the morale of the troops'. Magically, criticising the Bush Administration and it's policies will suddenly become "divisive" by those who will showed no quarter in employing the basest of slanders against their opponents.
Because, you see, the Republicans are "the good guys", and anything that the good guys do is okay. When the bad guys do the same thing, however, it merely proves how bad they really are. For example, if Georgia attacks Russia and gets slapped down, that is disproportionate and evil. If Gaza does the same thing, anything goes in the name of self-defence. It's not so much that there are two standards as that there is one standard that is only applied in selected cases. For all of the talk about "American Exceptionalism", the bottom line is that it really means that America is excepted from the rules it applies to to other nations, and Republicans are excepted by virtue of being the voice of "true Americans".
So watch for that.
Showing posts with label McCain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label McCain. Show all posts
Monday, December 29, 2008
Saturday, October 25, 2008
Nine days out
I just had to get this McCain quote up for posterity.
If Obama wins, McCain says "the nation" will be defeated, and he's got Obama right where he wants him. Hilarious.
From the BBC:
Nine days to go.
Fivethirtyeight.com has Obama projected to win 348 electoral votes. 270 are needed to win.
McCain's "master plan" is tragic in its hopelessness. He is going "all in" in Pennsylvania to get its 27 EVs, which will serve to partially counteract some of his other expected state losses.
The problem is that McCain has never led in any reliable polling in that state. The closest he ever got was a tie on Rasmussen 9/14, which looks like an outlier in retrospect. Subsequent Rasmussen polling showed a steady increase in Obama's PA support:
On 10/22, SurveyUSA placed Obama ahead by 12%.
Yet this is where John McCain is making his final stand, and this is right where he wants Obama to be.
Even if McCain wins PA, he must win Florida or it is all over. That scenario is not supported by the polling, either. Rasmussen polled McCain ahead by 1 point 10/21, well within the margin of error. Other pollsters show Obama 3 or 4 points ahead.
Missouri is another must-win state for McCain. Rasmussen polled it in Obama's favour by five points on 10/19.
If McCain loses North Carolina, Obama moves in to the White House. Polling there is mixed, with Rasmussen giving McCain a two point lead (within the margin of error), while other pollsters show Obama with a single-digit lead in the state.
Indiana is a state that McCain cannot afford to lose, either. Like the others mentioned, if McCain loses it, there is no way he can reach 270 EVs. SurveyUSA polled Obama ahead by 4% there on 10/22.
Ohio is another must-win. Rasmussen favoured McCain by two points (again within the MOE) on 10/19.
There is also the western option: Colorado, Nevada, and New Mexico all favour Obama (19 EVs right there) , while ND and MT are toss-ups (6 more).
Georgia, with her 15 EVs, is three points away from going to Obama.
McCain now has to get very lucky multiple times in order to win. It's like flipping a coin seven times in a row and calling it correctly.
But the truth is that these polls under-estimate Obama's support. Rasmussen relies on a tight "likely voter model" that excludes a lot of Obama supporters. If you are first-time voter in this election, Rasmussen would not count you as a "likely voter". Even though statistics show that newly-registered voters turn out to vote nearly 90% of the time, Rasmussen would not consider a newly-registered voter to be "likely". Even if you voted in the primaries, but not in previous general elections, Rasmussen would not count you as a "likely voter". That hardly seems realistic. And Rasmussen is not alone in maintaining this tight model.
Consider the massive registration drives conducted during the Democratic primaries/caucuses, in which new records were set in registering new voters. Consider the massive turnouts in the primaries. Consider the truly unprecedented ground game of the Obama campaign in mobilising voters to turn out this election. None of that is being taken into account by any pollster that uses a common likely voter model. In fact, in comparisons between "registered voters", and registered voters who self-identify as likely voters, Gallup has shown very little difference (about 2%) between the two groups. And the Democrats hold a huge registration advantage in these seven crucial states.
Many of the pollsters seem to simply be assuming that Democrats won't turn out this year, despite the historic character of this election. They are far off the mark.
Republicans are looking back to 2004 for reassurances, but that was a pre-Katrina world, a world in which the Decider was still popular and Iraq was not yet judged a miserable mistake, and the economy was not in a state of disaster. Republicans have completely ignored 2006 and the mid-term elections that brought them sweeping losses. No, it's still 2004 to them, and they are relying on imaginary 2004 voters to rally and save the day.
And, in spite of Obama showing higher "favourables" than McCain, the Republicans are still pushing Obama as a scary candidate. People simply are not afraid of Obama. They have seen him at the debates, the Convention, and in campaign stops, and they have seen a reasonable, well-spoken, and intelligent man. The more McCain pushes his wild terror of Obama, the more rabid and un-hinged the Republicans appear to the public.
So Obama is leading the national tracking polls by about eight points, and he is leading in the states he needs to win 270 electoral votes, with the chance to pick up a few more.
And this is, apparently, right where McCain wants Obama to be.
Devilishly clever of him, isn't it?
My prediction is that Obama wins with 349 electoral votes. The second most likely outcome is 375 EVs, in my view.
If Obama wins, McCain says "the nation" will be defeated, and he's got Obama right where he wants him. Hilarious.
From the BBC:
"I will never allow this nation to be defeated ... my friends, we've got them just where we want them. We love being the underdog and we're going to win!"
Nine days to go.
Fivethirtyeight.com has Obama projected to win 348 electoral votes. 270 are needed to win.
McCain's "master plan" is tragic in its hopelessness. He is going "all in" in Pennsylvania to get its 27 EVs, which will serve to partially counteract some of his other expected state losses.
The problem is that McCain has never led in any reliable polling in that state. The closest he ever got was a tie on Rasmussen 9/14, which looks like an outlier in retrospect. Subsequent Rasmussen polling showed a steady increase in Obama's PA support:
- 9/21 Obama +3
- 9/24 Obama +4
- 9/28 Obama +8
- 10/6 Obama + 13
On 10/22, SurveyUSA placed Obama ahead by 12%.
Yet this is where John McCain is making his final stand, and this is right where he wants Obama to be.
Even if McCain wins PA, he must win Florida or it is all over. That scenario is not supported by the polling, either. Rasmussen polled McCain ahead by 1 point 10/21, well within the margin of error. Other pollsters show Obama 3 or 4 points ahead.
Missouri is another must-win state for McCain. Rasmussen polled it in Obama's favour by five points on 10/19.
If McCain loses North Carolina, Obama moves in to the White House. Polling there is mixed, with Rasmussen giving McCain a two point lead (within the margin of error), while other pollsters show Obama with a single-digit lead in the state.
Indiana is a state that McCain cannot afford to lose, either. Like the others mentioned, if McCain loses it, there is no way he can reach 270 EVs. SurveyUSA polled Obama ahead by 4% there on 10/22.
Ohio is another must-win. Rasmussen favoured McCain by two points (again within the MOE) on 10/19.
There is also the western option: Colorado, Nevada, and New Mexico all favour Obama (19 EVs right there) , while ND and MT are toss-ups (6 more).
Georgia, with her 15 EVs, is three points away from going to Obama.
McCain now has to get very lucky multiple times in order to win. It's like flipping a coin seven times in a row and calling it correctly.
But the truth is that these polls under-estimate Obama's support. Rasmussen relies on a tight "likely voter model" that excludes a lot of Obama supporters. If you are first-time voter in this election, Rasmussen would not count you as a "likely voter". Even though statistics show that newly-registered voters turn out to vote nearly 90% of the time, Rasmussen would not consider a newly-registered voter to be "likely". Even if you voted in the primaries, but not in previous general elections, Rasmussen would not count you as a "likely voter". That hardly seems realistic. And Rasmussen is not alone in maintaining this tight model.
Consider the massive registration drives conducted during the Democratic primaries/caucuses, in which new records were set in registering new voters. Consider the massive turnouts in the primaries. Consider the truly unprecedented ground game of the Obama campaign in mobilising voters to turn out this election. None of that is being taken into account by any pollster that uses a common likely voter model. In fact, in comparisons between "registered voters", and registered voters who self-identify as likely voters, Gallup has shown very little difference (about 2%) between the two groups. And the Democrats hold a huge registration advantage in these seven crucial states.
Many of the pollsters seem to simply be assuming that Democrats won't turn out this year, despite the historic character of this election. They are far off the mark.
Republicans are looking back to 2004 for reassurances, but that was a pre-Katrina world, a world in which the Decider was still popular and Iraq was not yet judged a miserable mistake, and the economy was not in a state of disaster. Republicans have completely ignored 2006 and the mid-term elections that brought them sweeping losses. No, it's still 2004 to them, and they are relying on imaginary 2004 voters to rally and save the day.
And, in spite of Obama showing higher "favourables" than McCain, the Republicans are still pushing Obama as a scary candidate. People simply are not afraid of Obama. They have seen him at the debates, the Convention, and in campaign stops, and they have seen a reasonable, well-spoken, and intelligent man. The more McCain pushes his wild terror of Obama, the more rabid and un-hinged the Republicans appear to the public.
So Obama is leading the national tracking polls by about eight points, and he is leading in the states he needs to win 270 electoral votes, with the chance to pick up a few more.
And this is, apparently, right where McCain wants Obama to be.
Devilishly clever of him, isn't it?
My prediction is that Obama wins with 349 electoral votes. The second most likely outcome is 375 EVs, in my view.
Saturday, August 30, 2008
The Palin Pick
Wow. The Republicans' heads are spinning around.
By picking Palin, McCain takes the "Obama is too inexperienced" issue right off the table, which was his only non-smear issue.
By picking Palin, McCain gives up on the independents. Palin is a complete 28%-er who backs Bush completely. She is also a creationist, hard-line pro-life, and evangelical Christian. You don't pick up independents with someone like that. If independents had those views, then they wouldn't be independents - they'd already be Republicans.
By picking Palin, McCain actually alienates women voters. It takes a Republican Kool-Aid drinker to believe that women will vote for McCain simply because a woman is on the ticket, especially since that woman is completely out of the mainstream political views that the strong majority of women hold.
This is a move to appeal to the Republican base, which it will. The problem is, though, that McCain already has 87% of that base locked up. And that base is a lot smaller than it was in 2004, while the number who self-identify as Democrats has increased by 10% to record highs.
Palin will definitely improve the turnout among Republican evangelicals, but their numbers have also dropped since 2004 in a generational split.
Palin will be under intense media scrutiny in the next two months to a degree that the Governor of Alaska never was. It is almost certain that she will make some gaffe, which Republicans will be forced to defend. They will cry that the media and the Democrats are "picking on a woman", while at the same time crying about "picking on a war hero". It will be the ultimate whiner's ticket, and it will sound like these two aren't ready to face 21st century challenges.
Meanwhile, all McCain has left against Obama are smears: Ayers, Rezko, secret Muslim, crazy radical, and unpatriotic. None of these have gained traction despite being given heavy play in the primary and by McCain surrogates for several months. And Biden, HRC, and Bill will be attacking McCain constantly on his weaknesses. Being a "war hero" just won't cut it.
And the big issue about this pick that makes even Republicans pause is that McCain is 72 and has recurring cancer. If McCain dies or is incapacitated in office, then Palin takes over. Can anyone imagine Palin commanding two wars (plus any new ones that McCain has started while in office), staring down Putin, handling negotiations with Iran, Venezuela, or Pakistan? Can anyone imagine Palin convincing our allies to go along with whatever crazy foreign policy McCain has left her? Telling the rest of the world not to "pick on a woman" is not going to work in those circumstances.
Palin is not a scholar along the lines of Obama. She has no foreign policy experience, whereas Obama has been to Iraq, toured Europe, been briefed extensively on military matters, and has served on the Foreign Relations Committee in the Senate. Palin would inherit all of McCain's "yes men" advisors, and be completely out of her depth on the national and international stage. If the crises the country faces in the next four years all involve attending hockey games, then she can handle it. If it's more complex than that, we are all - Republican, Independent, and Democrat alike - in big trouble.
By picking Palin, McCain takes the "Obama is too inexperienced" issue right off the table, which was his only non-smear issue.
By picking Palin, McCain gives up on the independents. Palin is a complete 28%-er who backs Bush completely. She is also a creationist, hard-line pro-life, and evangelical Christian. You don't pick up independents with someone like that. If independents had those views, then they wouldn't be independents - they'd already be Republicans.
By picking Palin, McCain actually alienates women voters. It takes a Republican Kool-Aid drinker to believe that women will vote for McCain simply because a woman is on the ticket, especially since that woman is completely out of the mainstream political views that the strong majority of women hold.
This is a move to appeal to the Republican base, which it will. The problem is, though, that McCain already has 87% of that base locked up. And that base is a lot smaller than it was in 2004, while the number who self-identify as Democrats has increased by 10% to record highs.
Palin will definitely improve the turnout among Republican evangelicals, but their numbers have also dropped since 2004 in a generational split.
Palin will be under intense media scrutiny in the next two months to a degree that the Governor of Alaska never was. It is almost certain that she will make some gaffe, which Republicans will be forced to defend. They will cry that the media and the Democrats are "picking on a woman", while at the same time crying about "picking on a war hero". It will be the ultimate whiner's ticket, and it will sound like these two aren't ready to face 21st century challenges.
Meanwhile, all McCain has left against Obama are smears: Ayers, Rezko, secret Muslim, crazy radical, and unpatriotic. None of these have gained traction despite being given heavy play in the primary and by McCain surrogates for several months. And Biden, HRC, and Bill will be attacking McCain constantly on his weaknesses. Being a "war hero" just won't cut it.
And the big issue about this pick that makes even Republicans pause is that McCain is 72 and has recurring cancer. If McCain dies or is incapacitated in office, then Palin takes over. Can anyone imagine Palin commanding two wars (plus any new ones that McCain has started while in office), staring down Putin, handling negotiations with Iran, Venezuela, or Pakistan? Can anyone imagine Palin convincing our allies to go along with whatever crazy foreign policy McCain has left her? Telling the rest of the world not to "pick on a woman" is not going to work in those circumstances.
Palin is not a scholar along the lines of Obama. She has no foreign policy experience, whereas Obama has been to Iraq, toured Europe, been briefed extensively on military matters, and has served on the Foreign Relations Committee in the Senate. Palin would inherit all of McCain's "yes men" advisors, and be completely out of her depth on the national and international stage. If the crises the country faces in the next four years all involve attending hockey games, then she can handle it. If it's more complex than that, we are all - Republican, Independent, and Democrat alike - in big trouble.
Saturday, July 05, 2008
Republicans are merely talking to themselves in GE
There seem to be two main thrusts to the aimless campaign of Sen. McCain: security and patriotism.
The "patriotism" angle is nothing more than what the GOP has trotted out for the past five or so years. The term "patriotism" is re-defined to mean "unquestioning support for the Republican agenda", with the corresponding corollary being all Democrats are traitors. Ann Coulter even took the time to document this sad meme in her book "Treason". Unfortunately for Coulter and the GOP, the public isn't buying this concept. With Bush's approval rating sinking to a new low last month, this attempt to shame the public into support for Bush (and by extension, McCain) just hasn't paid off.
As one would expect, though, this approach works well on the Republican base, so the GOP considers it a winning strategy because they believe that the vast majority of the public really, truly, deep down agrees with them. That's why we see the wingnuts constantly employing terms such as "real Americans" or "true Americans" so often. They live in a bubble world where everything that is good is due to the Republicans, and everything that is bad is the fault of the Democrats. Meanwhile, the numbers of those self-identifying as Democrats has risen to record highs. It is a startling exercise in self-delusion that deserves to be dissected and analysed by the MSM after Obama wins, which means that it will probably be overlooked and ignored. With this "patriotism" meme, the GOP is graciously offering us all a chance to love America, which apparently is considered impossible to do if you are a Democrat.
So, faced with a choice between loving America and hating America, naturally (in the mind of the wingnut) the public will come down on the side of the GOP and make the requisite embrace of torture, huge tax cuts for the wealthy to spur investment that never seems to happen, police-state surveillance that would never be abused, hatred of immigrants, hatred of Muslims, ramming fundamentalist Christianity down our throats, endless wars which are vitally necessary and which we will most certainly 'win', and a belief that America can do no wrong.
The second thrust is that of "security", in which we are supposed to be simultaneously terrified and completely confident. Shadowy, ill-defined, and incredibly malicious 'terrorists' are constantly seeking to kill us in this meme. When they aren't, they are trying to force your daughter to wear a burqa or make us all bow down to Allah at gunpoint. Only the heroic Republicans can save us, because they see through these evil schemes and have the courage to do the nasty things that are needed to 'win'...at least in the mind of the wingnut. At the same time, all is well because we are constantly getting valuable intelligence from detainees at Guantanamo and we are 'winning' in Iraq, which somehow means that we are fighting "them" over there instead of fighting them here. By fighting sectarian militias struggling for dominance in Iraq, we somehow are crushing Al-Qaeda, which has become a generic enemy which can freely be employed to describe anyone who disagrees with us regardless if they are Sunni or Shia. Extensive warrantless wiretaps are allowing us to keep tabs on these shadowy evil-doers and thwart their schemes. Brave citizens are constantly keeping their vigilant eyes on any brown-skinned people, as well as any potential lighter-skinned Quislings among us. Fear not, America, the wingnuts are on the job.
As always, though, those nasty polls have a habit of countering the wingnut bubble world, which is why they are continually dismissed out of hand as "biased" - unless they support the wingnut meme, in which case they are crowed over as "proof".
In this case, Rasmussen (an organisation that I personally consider slightly leaning to the Right) has released new results showing that the seeds of the Republican "security" meme are unlikely to fall on very fertile ground in this election campaign. Note that Republicans seem to be ones most likely to buy the "we are safer today" line, while the independent voters (the ones that are supposed to be swinging to the "maverick" candidate) are not really lapping up this meme in any convincing numbers.
Further, the issue that McCain is most relying on to win over voters is the wonderful success in Iraq. This is a tough sell, however, when half the country thinks Iraq will go down in the history books as a failure. The figures for those who think Iraq will be considered a success are eerily similar to the approval numbers for the Decider. Who would ever have thought that?
Of course, the wingnut optimist would point to this and say that these results merely show the potential for the "fear meme". If we really don't think we are safer, then Republicans can beat the drum of fear and drive the voters to the Party that offers security. The trouble with this is, of course, that the Republicans are really only offering a continuation of the policies that have made only 39% think we are safer.
Full story from Rasmussen:
Okay, but just how big an issue is "security" for the voters? If the "patriotism" meme is more or less just Republicans talking to themselves, is the "security" meme likely to gain them more traction with public in general?
Rasmussen again:
And which issue is the most important to voters? Can that offer some kind of encouragement to the McCain campaign?
Uh-oh.
These numbers support my contention that not only is the GOP living in the past and running on the winning issues of the last election, but also that the McCain general election campaign is little more than a primary campaign in which the Republicans are simply talking to themselves. Time and time again we see Fox News "analysts" looking back to the 2000 and 2004 elections and drawing conclusions from those days as if the 2006 elections never happened. The punditry class as a whole seems to similarly be living in 2004 and is basing their views on voters that simply do not exist in sufficient numbers for McCain to win on.
Thus far, very little of the attacks of the attacks the GOP has thrown at Obama have gained any traction at all: secret Muslim, secret Hindu, scary preacher, Rezko, Ayers, secret communist, traitor, scary wife, elitist, defeatist. The sole issue that has gained some traction is "inexperienced". Ironically, this is the only issue employed thus far that has a basis in truth, so the GOP has been somewhat slow in taking full advantage of it, since they seem to have a strong preference for slander. However, how experienced was the Decider in 2000? McCain has not held any executive office, either. And since all of McCain's 'experience' only leads him to be Bush's third term, how much value can be derived from it?
The "patriotism" angle is nothing more than what the GOP has trotted out for the past five or so years. The term "patriotism" is re-defined to mean "unquestioning support for the Republican agenda", with the corresponding corollary being all Democrats are traitors. Ann Coulter even took the time to document this sad meme in her book "Treason". Unfortunately for Coulter and the GOP, the public isn't buying this concept. With Bush's approval rating sinking to a new low last month, this attempt to shame the public into support for Bush (and by extension, McCain) just hasn't paid off.
As one would expect, though, this approach works well on the Republican base, so the GOP considers it a winning strategy because they believe that the vast majority of the public really, truly, deep down agrees with them. That's why we see the wingnuts constantly employing terms such as "real Americans" or "true Americans" so often. They live in a bubble world where everything that is good is due to the Republicans, and everything that is bad is the fault of the Democrats. Meanwhile, the numbers of those self-identifying as Democrats has risen to record highs. It is a startling exercise in self-delusion that deserves to be dissected and analysed by the MSM after Obama wins, which means that it will probably be overlooked and ignored. With this "patriotism" meme, the GOP is graciously offering us all a chance to love America, which apparently is considered impossible to do if you are a Democrat.
So, faced with a choice between loving America and hating America, naturally (in the mind of the wingnut) the public will come down on the side of the GOP and make the requisite embrace of torture, huge tax cuts for the wealthy to spur investment that never seems to happen, police-state surveillance that would never be abused, hatred of immigrants, hatred of Muslims, ramming fundamentalist Christianity down our throats, endless wars which are vitally necessary and which we will most certainly 'win', and a belief that America can do no wrong.
The second thrust is that of "security", in which we are supposed to be simultaneously terrified and completely confident. Shadowy, ill-defined, and incredibly malicious 'terrorists' are constantly seeking to kill us in this meme. When they aren't, they are trying to force your daughter to wear a burqa or make us all bow down to Allah at gunpoint. Only the heroic Republicans can save us, because they see through these evil schemes and have the courage to do the nasty things that are needed to 'win'...at least in the mind of the wingnut. At the same time, all is well because we are constantly getting valuable intelligence from detainees at Guantanamo and we are 'winning' in Iraq, which somehow means that we are fighting "them" over there instead of fighting them here. By fighting sectarian militias struggling for dominance in Iraq, we somehow are crushing Al-Qaeda, which has become a generic enemy which can freely be employed to describe anyone who disagrees with us regardless if they are Sunni or Shia. Extensive warrantless wiretaps are allowing us to keep tabs on these shadowy evil-doers and thwart their schemes. Brave citizens are constantly keeping their vigilant eyes on any brown-skinned people, as well as any potential lighter-skinned Quislings among us. Fear not, America, the wingnuts are on the job.
As always, though, those nasty polls have a habit of countering the wingnut bubble world, which is why they are continually dismissed out of hand as "biased" - unless they support the wingnut meme, in which case they are crowed over as "proof".
In this case, Rasmussen (an organisation that I personally consider slightly leaning to the Right) has released new results showing that the seeds of the Republican "security" meme are unlikely to fall on very fertile ground in this election campaign. Note that Republicans seem to be ones most likely to buy the "we are safer today" line, while the independent voters (the ones that are supposed to be swinging to the "maverick" candidate) are not really lapping up this meme in any convincing numbers.
Further, the issue that McCain is most relying on to win over voters is the wonderful success in Iraq. This is a tough sell, however, when half the country thinks Iraq will go down in the history books as a failure. The figures for those who think Iraq will be considered a success are eerily similar to the approval numbers for the Decider. Who would ever have thought that?
Of course, the wingnut optimist would point to this and say that these results merely show the potential for the "fear meme". If we really don't think we are safer, then Republicans can beat the drum of fear and drive the voters to the Party that offers security. The trouble with this is, of course, that the Republicans are really only offering a continuation of the policies that have made only 39% think we are safer.
Full story from Rasmussen:
Just 39% of American voters think the nation is safer today than it was before the 9/11 attacks. A larger percentage (44%) disagree. Again, there are big partisan differences on this question. Seventy-percent (70%) of Republicans believe the nation is safer, while just 18% of Democrats agree. Just over a third (34%) of unaffiliated voters believe the country is safer today.
Voters are split on the situation in Iraq in terms of the near future. While 34% think the situation in Iraq will improve in the next six months, 32% believe it will get worse. Another 25% think things will stay about the same.In the long-term, half of voters (50%) think the War in Iraq will be deemed a failure. Just 32% believe it will be go down in history as a success. Those numbers have changed little over the past month.
Okay, but just how big an issue is "security" for the voters? If the "patriotism" meme is more or less just Republicans talking to themselves, is the "security" meme likely to gain them more traction with public in general?
Rasmussen again:
However, 24% say that national security issues are most important. Among these voters, Republicans lead on the Generic Ballot 51% to 34%. Democrats also lead among the 11% who see domestic issues like Social Security and Health Care as most important. McCain leads among the 9% who say fiscal issues are tops and among the 6% whose primary interest is in cultural issues.During Election 2004, more than 40% of voters consistently rated national security issues as most important and just one-in-four thought economic issues were the key voting issue.
And which issue is the most important to voters? Can that offer some kind of encouragement to the McCain campaign?
When it comes to issues, 41% of voters consider economic issues to be the highest priority. Among these voters, Democrats lead 59% to 25%.
Uh-oh.
These numbers support my contention that not only is the GOP living in the past and running on the winning issues of the last election, but also that the McCain general election campaign is little more than a primary campaign in which the Republicans are simply talking to themselves. Time and time again we see Fox News "analysts" looking back to the 2000 and 2004 elections and drawing conclusions from those days as if the 2006 elections never happened. The punditry class as a whole seems to similarly be living in 2004 and is basing their views on voters that simply do not exist in sufficient numbers for McCain to win on.
Thus far, very little of the attacks of the attacks the GOP has thrown at Obama have gained any traction at all: secret Muslim, secret Hindu, scary preacher, Rezko, Ayers, secret communist, traitor, scary wife, elitist, defeatist. The sole issue that has gained some traction is "inexperienced". Ironically, this is the only issue employed thus far that has a basis in truth, so the GOP has been somewhat slow in taking full advantage of it, since they seem to have a strong preference for slander. However, how experienced was the Decider in 2000? McCain has not held any executive office, either. And since all of McCain's 'experience' only leads him to be Bush's third term, how much value can be derived from it?
Thursday, July 03, 2008
Military abandoning support for the GOP
Early last month, a commenter without a profile named Jason left the following:
The comment was in response to Bush's penchant for making speeches before military audiences, where anyone who booed him would be subject to severe punishment. March was the last time Bush made an appearance to anything but hand-picked or military audiences, when he was booed and jeered at the opening pitch of the Nationals game.
Now we see:
Gosh, Jason, it sure seems like someone in the military might want to boo the President if they could get away with it.
Now we find out that the support for McCain among the military and their families is at most 50%. Late last year we found that that support for the Iraq effort was slipping within the military community as well. The Republicans are running a war hero whose campaign mentions his service and POW status every single day, and the military isn't buying it.
McCain has long had a "problem" with veterans groups for his stinginess on vet benefits. Backing the neocon vision of Eternal War hasn't helped win over military families, either. It's somewhat ironic that, while the wingnuts froth over "military service" and re-define the word "patriotism" to mean "complete support of the Republican agenda", more than half of those people actually serving would be considered unpatriotic by the Right because they don't support Bush, McCain, or the premise of the Iraq occupation. Thus we have a complete logical breakdown on the wingnut end: criticising the troops is unpatriotic, but the troops don't support Bush, so the troops are unpatriotic, but that is criticism, so the wingnuts are unpatriotic.
The neocons and wingnuts overplayed their hand years ago when they conflated dissent on the Iraq occupation to treason. Too many people knew too many dissenters whose patriotism was not in question for that to work. Now a strong majority says that Iraq was a mistake or not worth fighting for - in other words, unpatriotic traitors, America-haters, and defeatists. With that sorry gambit, the wingnuts lost the magic talismanic power of the word "traitor", much like the words "liberal", "appeaser", and "terrorist sympathiser" no longer elicit guaranteed rage from the public. Republicans, however, have not realised this because they know that such words work on them. Thus, the GOP will continue its bizarre effort to cast 60% of Americans as treasonous, while simultaneously imagining that these 'traitors' will vote for them. And they will continue to invoke 'the troops' in attempts to stifle dissent, even though half of those troops disagree with the GOP.
full story from AFP:
And clueless Republicans are still looking backward to 2000 and 2004 for confidence, even though things have changed radically for the GOP.
If you think the military on the whole does not support their President, you are mistaken, and therefore attempts to characterize them as some poor captive audience that would surely speak up if they could are misguided.
The comment was in response to Bush's penchant for making speeches before military audiences, where anyone who booed him would be subject to severe punishment. March was the last time Bush made an appearance to anything but hand-picked or military audiences, when he was booed and jeered at the opening pitch of the Nationals game.
Now we see:
In its annual reader surveys, the Military Times specialist news group found Bush's approval rate among the military had plummeted from 60 percent in 2005 to just 48 percent in 2007.
Gosh, Jason, it sure seems like someone in the military might want to boo the President if they could get away with it.
Now we find out that the support for McCain among the military and their families is at most 50%. Late last year we found that that support for the Iraq effort was slipping within the military community as well. The Republicans are running a war hero whose campaign mentions his service and POW status every single day, and the military isn't buying it.
McCain has long had a "problem" with veterans groups for his stinginess on vet benefits. Backing the neocon vision of Eternal War hasn't helped win over military families, either. It's somewhat ironic that, while the wingnuts froth over "military service" and re-define the word "patriotism" to mean "complete support of the Republican agenda", more than half of those people actually serving would be considered unpatriotic by the Right because they don't support Bush, McCain, or the premise of the Iraq occupation. Thus we have a complete logical breakdown on the wingnut end: criticising the troops is unpatriotic, but the troops don't support Bush, so the troops are unpatriotic, but that is criticism, so the wingnuts are unpatriotic.
The neocons and wingnuts overplayed their hand years ago when they conflated dissent on the Iraq occupation to treason. Too many people knew too many dissenters whose patriotism was not in question for that to work. Now a strong majority says that Iraq was a mistake or not worth fighting for - in other words, unpatriotic traitors, America-haters, and defeatists. With that sorry gambit, the wingnuts lost the magic talismanic power of the word "traitor", much like the words "liberal", "appeaser", and "terrorist sympathiser" no longer elicit guaranteed rage from the public. Republicans, however, have not realised this because they know that such words work on them. Thus, the GOP will continue its bizarre effort to cast 60% of Americans as treasonous, while simultaneously imagining that these 'traitors' will vote for them. And they will continue to invoke 'the troops' in attempts to stifle dissent, even though half of those troops disagree with the GOP.
full story from AFP:
Iraq undercuts Republican support among military
WASHINGTON (AFP) — Five years into an unpopular war in Iraq, many US military voters are eschewing their traditional Republican ties to support Democrat Barack Obama for president against John McCain, observers say.
...
"I think now you're going to see -- not that it's going to be overwhelming -- but a back away from the Republican Party ... At least (the military vote will) be split this year rather than overwhelmingly Republican," said Korb, a deputy defense secretary under president Ronald Reagan.
He predicted that McCain, the 71-year-old Republican senator for Arizona, will get "at most half of the military votes," instead of the three-to-one ratio that Republican President George W. Bush won in 2004.
The main reason for the defection is the Iraq war, where 4,113 US troops have died since the 2003 invasion and for which the US government has come under fire even from the military, despite recent security improvements.
...
A Los Angeles Times survey of 1,467 people, including 631 soldiers, veterans and their families, in late 2007 found that 57 percent of military respondents believed the Iraq war was not worth fighting -- nearly the same as the overall population (60 percent).
Asked which party they trusted most to handle important issues, the military families chose Democrats over Republicans 39-35 percent, compared to a 39-31 percent ratio among the general population.
And clueless Republicans are still looking backward to 2000 and 2004 for confidence, even though things have changed radically for the GOP.
Tuesday, July 01, 2008
Qualifications?
Let's look at the comment by Gen. Wesley Clark that seems to have the wingnuts all up in arms and completely rabid:
What, exactly, is untrue about Clark's statement of opinion?
If "riding in a fighter plane and being shot down" really is a qualification to become President, then we have never had a qualified President, have we?
It's hard for me to see how the general is "attacking McCain's military service". McCain and his supporters have made a great deal about McCain's military service. Hillary even joined in with her "threshold for Commander in Chief" remark. Clark is merely stating that McCain's particular military service, however honourable, does not automatically make him qualified.
I have a very good friend who served in the Navy handling heavy construction equipment. Does this make him qualified to be President? If I say "no", am I attacking his service?
Just as it would be highly unlikely that a President would be called upon to handle heavy construction equipment, it would be highly unlikely that a President would be called upon to fly a fighter jet, even he or she weren't 70 years old. And Commander in Chief is only one of the roles the President has to play, as Clark pointed out. In the same interview, immediately previous to the remarks above, Clark specifically honoured McCain's service.
The real issue, however, is that one particular Party devoted itself to smearing a Presidential candidate's military record four years ago. One particular Party mocked that candidate's Purple Heart by handing out purple Band-Aids. One particular Party contended that non-combat service in the National Guard was far more honourable than another candidate's combat experience in the same war. How does this happen?
It happens because Republicans want us to believe that military service only matters if you are a Republican. They have no problem attacking a former four-star general who has been decorated by portraying him as a traitor and anti-military. It's perfectly "patriotic", in their view, to attack the military service of Gen. Wesley Clark, while simultaneously beating him up for putatively doing the exact same thing. This is not about military service. It's all about calling anyone who disagrees with you a traitor, and that is simply un-American.
But Obama hasn't served in the military? So what? McCain is one mentioning his time as a POW on an almost daily basis and having his surrogates tell us about how McCain's military service makes him the only qualified candidate. If Obama said that going to college in Hawaii made him the only qualified candidate, certainly the Republicans would question that premise. And would they be "attacking his educational achievements" if they did so? No, just the premise that this makes him uniquely qualified for executive office.
The President is more of a CEO than a military commander. Which candidate admits that he doesn't know how to use a computer? What corporation would hire a CEO with that lack of skills? Which candidate graduated near the bottom of his class? Shouldn't this be considered for qualification for such a position?
Unfortunately, we have one particular Party that does not have much going for it on the issues, and that Party is relying on military service as a defining qualification. Nearly eight years of practical experience has shown us, however, that a President with military experience has made a complete disaster of the military efforts he engaged in. Thus, it's not particularly abstract to consider that "riding in a fighter plane" really doesn't provide you with any critical insights needed to wage a successful military effort. Experience has, indeed, validated General Clark's opinion.
CLARK: He has been a voice on the Senate Armed Services Committee. And he has travelled all over the world. But he hasn't held executive responsibility. That large squadron in the Navy that he commanded — that wasn't a wartime squadron. He hasn't been there and ordered the bombs to fall. He hasn't seen what it's like when diplomats come in and say, "I don't know whether we're going to be able to get this point through or not, do you want to take the risk, what about your reputation, how do we handle this publicly? He hasn't made those calls, Bob.
SCHIEFFER: Can I just interrupt you? I have to say, Barack Obama hasn't had any of these experiences either, nor has he ridden in a fighter plane and gotten shot down.
CLARK: I don’t think riding in a fighter plane and getting shot down is a qualification to become president.
What, exactly, is untrue about Clark's statement of opinion?
If "riding in a fighter plane and being shot down" really is a qualification to become President, then we have never had a qualified President, have we?
It's hard for me to see how the general is "attacking McCain's military service". McCain and his supporters have made a great deal about McCain's military service. Hillary even joined in with her "threshold for Commander in Chief" remark. Clark is merely stating that McCain's particular military service, however honourable, does not automatically make him qualified.
I have a very good friend who served in the Navy handling heavy construction equipment. Does this make him qualified to be President? If I say "no", am I attacking his service?
Just as it would be highly unlikely that a President would be called upon to handle heavy construction equipment, it would be highly unlikely that a President would be called upon to fly a fighter jet, even he or she weren't 70 years old. And Commander in Chief is only one of the roles the President has to play, as Clark pointed out. In the same interview, immediately previous to the remarks above, Clark specifically honoured McCain's service.
The real issue, however, is that one particular Party devoted itself to smearing a Presidential candidate's military record four years ago. One particular Party mocked that candidate's Purple Heart by handing out purple Band-Aids. One particular Party contended that non-combat service in the National Guard was far more honourable than another candidate's combat experience in the same war. How does this happen?
It happens because Republicans want us to believe that military service only matters if you are a Republican. They have no problem attacking a former four-star general who has been decorated by portraying him as a traitor and anti-military. It's perfectly "patriotic", in their view, to attack the military service of Gen. Wesley Clark, while simultaneously beating him up for putatively doing the exact same thing. This is not about military service. It's all about calling anyone who disagrees with you a traitor, and that is simply un-American.
But Obama hasn't served in the military? So what? McCain is one mentioning his time as a POW on an almost daily basis and having his surrogates tell us about how McCain's military service makes him the only qualified candidate. If Obama said that going to college in Hawaii made him the only qualified candidate, certainly the Republicans would question that premise. And would they be "attacking his educational achievements" if they did so? No, just the premise that this makes him uniquely qualified for executive office.
The President is more of a CEO than a military commander. Which candidate admits that he doesn't know how to use a computer? What corporation would hire a CEO with that lack of skills? Which candidate graduated near the bottom of his class? Shouldn't this be considered for qualification for such a position?
It’s crucially important that we have a political debate in this country that’s at least sophisticated enough to be able to handle the following rather basic idea: Arguing that a person’s record of military service is not a qualification for the presidency does not constitute “attacking” their military credentials; nor can it be described as invoking their military service against them, or as denying their record of war heroism.
Unfortunately, we have one particular Party that does not have much going for it on the issues, and that Party is relying on military service as a defining qualification. Nearly eight years of practical experience has shown us, however, that a President with military experience has made a complete disaster of the military efforts he engaged in. Thus, it's not particularly abstract to consider that "riding in a fighter plane" really doesn't provide you with any critical insights needed to wage a successful military effort. Experience has, indeed, validated General Clark's opinion.
Saturday, June 14, 2008
McCain "town hall" is a staged sham
McCain's "town hall meeting" on Thursday in New Jersey was covered by a blogger.
Far from an open forum in which he tackled tough questions, it was instead a campaign rally in which the questions were provided ahead of time to selected individuals that McCain was directed to by aides. He answered a total of seven questions from the audience, and abruptly ended the "town hall" when it went off-script.
The seating for the event was arranged ahead of time, and with cameras in mind. Those cameras were also directed to be turned off by McCain's staff whenever it was convenient.
So we have five questions coming from a group of pre-selected people in the "VIP section", some of which were reading from index cards. One of the two questions coming from the audience came from a known-to-be-sympathetic local Republican politician. The last question, which was from the audience, was the one that ended this charade, and was the only question that McCain was asked during the entire affair that wasn't scripted or pre-arranged.
How did this minor gamble work out?
So this is the kind of forum that McCain expects Obama to submit to?
Seven questions, 70% of which came from people that the campaign hand-picked, vetted, and most probably handed the proper questions to beforehand, another from a known Republican politician, and the last one was intended to be from a child, and this was supposed to be some kind of open forum where "tough questions" are asked?
The moment it goes off-script with a question from a well-meaning and sympathetic audience member, the whole thing is called to an end. This unscripted question wasn't even really answered.
During the 2004 campaign, Bush also only appeared before pre-screened audiences in staged affairs like this one. He continues to only publicly speak before military audiences and hand-picked crowds, or in front of organisations known to be sympathetic in which everything is arranged beforehand. No dissent can be displayed in Republican America. A fairy-tale world in which everyone loves the Decider is all that the media is allowed to show, and McCain is emulating that practise.
Meanwhile, Democrats are criticised for refusing to appear on openly hostile outlets such as Fox News by people who think that this kind of "town hall meeting" is for real.
This might play well with the Republican Faithful, but the rest of America will not be persuaded by this North Korea-style of public discourse. Republicans, however, really believe that America - the "true" America, the Silent Majority America, the "real people"- still supports them and will swallow this kind of act.
They are in for a surprise in November. Their delusion is what is preventing them from cancelling elections altogether due to some concocted "emergency".
Far from an open forum in which he tackled tough questions, it was instead a campaign rally in which the questions were provided ahead of time to selected individuals that McCain was directed to by aides. He answered a total of seven questions from the audience, and abruptly ended the "town hall" when it went off-script.
The seating for the event was arranged ahead of time, and with cameras in mind. Those cameras were also directed to be turned off by McCain's staff whenever it was convenient.
The seating was staged. There were about 20 people with Veteran's hats and all were seated directly in line with McCain's podium in the front and back. Your cameras from home would make it appear that half the people there were veterans. In reality it was about 1%. Mixed into the Veterans was one angry woman who had a sign claiming she was a Hillary supporter voting McCain. This one sign was placed directly in the spot where the cameras were most likely to pick it up. She was planted there. It also appears that there was one singular woman who pulled the same stunt Thursday night at the so called Fox News McCain town hall meeting in New York. These people aren't real Clinton supporters, this too is staged.
...
The questions and answers were not chosen among random people. 5 of the 7 questioners came from the VIP section including a woman in a wheelchair who was placed there ahead of time by a senior McCain staffer and then pointed to for a question even though she never raised her hand. They were plants. A couple of them were reading from index cards. A sixth questioner was also a plant in the bleachers about 40 feet to my right. He was a local Republican mayor whom the locals were familiar with.
So we have five questions coming from a group of pre-selected people in the "VIP section", some of which were reading from index cards. One of the two questions coming from the audience came from a known-to-be-sympathetic local Republican politician. The last question, which was from the audience, was the one that ended this charade, and was the only question that McCain was asked during the entire affair that wasn't scripted or pre-arranged.
How did this minor gamble work out?
The 7th questioner was chosen because McCain thought a 9 year old child was going to ask the question. But the father took the mike, told how his wife and child flew out of Newark on 9/11 and that could have been them. He then asked a very simple question, "Why haven't we gotten Bin Laden?"
A bunch of Obama people and others cheered. (I refrained, I was to be the next question.) McCain got pissed, started rambling about the Diamondbacks and Yankees and Rudy Giuliani on a screen, said as President Bin Laden would be caught (Guess this means Bin Laden is still safe for another few months) and people were laughing that McCain wasn't answering the question.
You could see the veins in McCain starting to burst, he got very uncomfortable that his scripted rally just got derailed by this gentleman and then he ended the rally by thanking everyone and saying God Bless America.
So this is the kind of forum that McCain expects Obama to submit to?
Seven questions, 70% of which came from people that the campaign hand-picked, vetted, and most probably handed the proper questions to beforehand, another from a known Republican politician, and the last one was intended to be from a child, and this was supposed to be some kind of open forum where "tough questions" are asked?
The moment it goes off-script with a question from a well-meaning and sympathetic audience member, the whole thing is called to an end. This unscripted question wasn't even really answered.
During the 2004 campaign, Bush also only appeared before pre-screened audiences in staged affairs like this one. He continues to only publicly speak before military audiences and hand-picked crowds, or in front of organisations known to be sympathetic in which everything is arranged beforehand. No dissent can be displayed in Republican America. A fairy-tale world in which everyone loves the Decider is all that the media is allowed to show, and McCain is emulating that practise.
Meanwhile, Democrats are criticised for refusing to appear on openly hostile outlets such as Fox News by people who think that this kind of "town hall meeting" is for real.
This might play well with the Republican Faithful, but the rest of America will not be persuaded by this North Korea-style of public discourse. Republicans, however, really believe that America - the "true" America, the Silent Majority America, the "real people"- still supports them and will swallow this kind of act.
They are in for a surprise in November. Their delusion is what is preventing them from cancelling elections altogether due to some concocted "emergency".
Tuesday, June 10, 2008
GOP leader willing to settle for losing 8 Senate seats
The NRSC is the GOP organisation responsible for regaining the Republican majority in the Senate.
The leader of the NRSC, John Ensign, has availed himself of the peculiar Republican propensity to define "success" as "whatever the current situation is". Thus, the GOP is forever "succeeding" in everything that it does.
Now, the NRSC has re-defined "success" as losing no more than eight Senate seats.
From TPM:
Story from SavannahNow.com:
In other words, the Republicans would be unable to continue their obstructionist campaign.
In reality, however, there are a number of conservative Democrats who would putatively take some of those Senate seats, so the phrase "do pretty much whatever they want" is really just fear-mongering. Still, much of what we have seen for the past six months (at least) are straight Party-line votes by the Republican senators on issues that can easily be turned against a senator up for election. The GOP has chosen to sacrifice senators in order for Bush to prove that he's still "relevant". This also means that the next mid-term elections will see roughly the same number of Republican senators up for election, who will still presumably be running on the Bush agenda, since that's what got them elected in the first place.
Kel at The Osterley Times covers the doubts among other Republicans over McCain's campaign.
She also has video of McCain claiming that Putin is the President of Germany.
The Democrats are also making gains in fund-raising.
Al Franken has won the DFL nomination to take on Norm Coleman in Minnesota.
John McCain says that the Constitution states that America is "a Christian nation".
Recall that this "Christian nation" line was the basis for the right-wing freakout over a Hindu prayer being made in the Senate. Recall also that fundamentalist evangelical Christianity only came into existence in America more than a century after the Constitution was signed and ratified. McCain is now using the metaphorical corpses of the Founding Fathers as ventriloquist dummies for an argument in favour of something that they never advocated or were aware of. McCain is using the term "Christian" as interchangeable with "born-again fundamentalist Christian", which is a gross distortion and nothing near "straight talk". Indeed, in many of the former colonial states such fundamentalist views would have been punished as heresy, but now we are being led to believe that evangelical Christianity was not only in existence at the time, but also accepted and prevalent.
The leader of the NRSC, John Ensign, has availed himself of the peculiar Republican propensity to define "success" as "whatever the current situation is". Thus, the GOP is forever "succeeding" in everything that it does.
Now, the NRSC has re-defined "success" as losing no more than eight Senate seats.
From TPM:
In a further sign that Republican hopes are fading badly, the head of the Senate GOP's campaign committee has set a new goal for the party this Fall: Not to lose too many Senate seats.
NRSC chair John Ensign has moved the goal posts, according to the Savannah Morning News, saying that the GOP will have succeeded if they don't lose more than eight seats.
Ensign pointed out that if the Dems win nine seats they'll get to the filibuster-proof magic number of 60 -- at which point, Ensign warned, "they will be able to do pretty much whatever they want."
So if the Dems can't get to a 60-seat super-majority, the GOP will have won. Talk about lowering the bar.
Story from SavannahNow.com:
Democrats now have 49 seats, with two independents who vote with them.
Republicans hold 49 seats now, with 23 up for re-election this year, and five GOP senators retiring, giving away the incumbent advantage.
Democrats only have to defend 12 seats this year.
An eight-seat loss would be a very bad year for any party, even the party holding the White House at the end of a second term, when voters typically hunger for change. So, it's surprising for a party leader to speak in such frank terms about major losses.
Why would the number of seats matter if it's anything less than 51 and taking the majority, a circumstance Ensign describes as unlikely? By holding at least 41, the GOP would prevent the majority party from the 60 votes required to end filibusters and to push an unpopular bill to a vote on the floor through the cloture procedure.
"With 41 votes in the U.S. Senate, you can (1) block bad legislation, and (2) you can make the majority respect the minority's rights. And you can help craft good legislation," Ensign said. "If the Democrats were able to get to 60 votes - literally even if they get to 57-58 votes because they always seem to pick off a couple or three Republicans on a lot of votes - and if they win the White House ... they will be able to do pretty much whatever they want."
In other words, the Republicans would be unable to continue their obstructionist campaign.
In reality, however, there are a number of conservative Democrats who would putatively take some of those Senate seats, so the phrase "do pretty much whatever they want" is really just fear-mongering. Still, much of what we have seen for the past six months (at least) are straight Party-line votes by the Republican senators on issues that can easily be turned against a senator up for election. The GOP has chosen to sacrifice senators in order for Bush to prove that he's still "relevant". This also means that the next mid-term elections will see roughly the same number of Republican senators up for election, who will still presumably be running on the Bush agenda, since that's what got them elected in the first place.
Kel at The Osterley Times covers the doubts among other Republicans over McCain's campaign.
She also has video of McCain claiming that Putin is the President of Germany.
The Democrats are also making gains in fund-raising.
Al Franken has won the DFL nomination to take on Norm Coleman in Minnesota.
John McCain says that the Constitution states that America is "a Christian nation".
McCain says, "I would probably have to say yes, that the Constitution established the United States of America as a Christian nation." He continues, "I think the number one issue that is in the selection, that which people should make a selection of the president of the United States is, 'Will this person carry on in the Judeo-Christian principled tradition that has made this nation the greatest experiment in the history of mankind?'"
The United States Constitution, of course, specifically states that "no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States."
Recall that this "Christian nation" line was the basis for the right-wing freakout over a Hindu prayer being made in the Senate. Recall also that fundamentalist evangelical Christianity only came into existence in America more than a century after the Constitution was signed and ratified. McCain is now using the metaphorical corpses of the Founding Fathers as ventriloquist dummies for an argument in favour of something that they never advocated or were aware of. McCain is using the term "Christian" as interchangeable with "born-again fundamentalist Christian", which is a gross distortion and nothing near "straight talk". Indeed, in many of the former colonial states such fundamentalist views would have been punished as heresy, but now we are being led to believe that evangelical Christianity was not only in existence at the time, but also accepted and prevalent.
Sunday, May 18, 2008
McCain: "We've already won in Iraq"
The media honeymoon for McCain may be coming to an end.
Kel at The Osterley Times has video of an MSNBC segment in which a rather contorted defence of McCain's recent statements are met with ridicule and chuckling.
The first part concerns McCain's recent imaginary scenario of victory in Iraq by 2013. While the wingnuts have nearly wet themselves in ecstasy over a fictional future, the press has remained puzzled if this constitutes some kind of "timetable" for Iraq. Not so, says McCain in the video, who then goes on to say that we have already won in Iraq, right now in 2008. McCain's media defender dismisses the entire thing as "aspirational", but fails to take up the issue of our recent "win" beyond making a broad claim that "the surge is working".
I am at a loss to see how John McCain's ability to simply imagine a world in which all Republican talking points turn out to be true actually helps his Party in any way. It completely baffles me how we can spend $12 billion a week on a war (really an occupation) that apparently we have already won. Has anyone informed our military that it's "over"?
McCain seems to be living in his own little world, and the media is finally pointing it out.
For more chuckles, check out Oliver Willis' use of McCain's magical ability to change the future.
It seems we could have saved ourselves a lot of lives and money if McCain had just imagined Iraq over in 2004.
The second part of the video is about McCain's flip-flop on Hamas, in which we learn that McCain was simply "giving Hamas the benefit of a doubt" back in 2006. More laughs all around.
McCain is a mother lode of comedic value given the dramatic contortions his "Straight Talk" has taken, but the far greater comedic gold will be found in the statements of those who try to explain and defend him. The media smells blood. Not the "lapel pin" type of blood, but rather the "WTF is this guy talking about?" kind of blood.
Kel at The Osterley Times has video of an MSNBC segment in which a rather contorted defence of McCain's recent statements are met with ridicule and chuckling.
The first part concerns McCain's recent imaginary scenario of victory in Iraq by 2013. While the wingnuts have nearly wet themselves in ecstasy over a fictional future, the press has remained puzzled if this constitutes some kind of "timetable" for Iraq. Not so, says McCain in the video, who then goes on to say that we have already won in Iraq, right now in 2008. McCain's media defender dismisses the entire thing as "aspirational", but fails to take up the issue of our recent "win" beyond making a broad claim that "the surge is working".
I am at a loss to see how John McCain's ability to simply imagine a world in which all Republican talking points turn out to be true actually helps his Party in any way. It completely baffles me how we can spend $12 billion a week on a war (really an occupation) that apparently we have already won. Has anyone informed our military that it's "over"?
McCain seems to be living in his own little world, and the media is finally pointing it out.
For more chuckles, check out Oliver Willis' use of McCain's magical ability to change the future.
2013. Wow, we’re finally here. It feels like just yesterday it was 2008 and the world was so different from how it is now, in 2013. My, how things have changed! And strangely, everything changed for the better, especially for me. It’s as if I wrote a fictional account of how things would change and just wrote it from a positive point of view or something stupid like that.
It seems we could have saved ourselves a lot of lives and money if McCain had just imagined Iraq over in 2004.
The second part of the video is about McCain's flip-flop on Hamas, in which we learn that McCain was simply "giving Hamas the benefit of a doubt" back in 2006. More laughs all around.
McCain is a mother lode of comedic value given the dramatic contortions his "Straight Talk" has taken, but the far greater comedic gold will be found in the statements of those who try to explain and defend him. The media smells blood. Not the "lapel pin" type of blood, but rather the "WTF is this guy talking about?" kind of blood.
Of imaginary worlds with imaginary Eel Pouts
I'm passing on the Sunday Eel Pout this week, mostly because I failed to do my homework during the week. If I were to award an Eel Pout, however, it would go to Bush for the dismal failure of his "jawbone" effort in Saudi Arabia.
The Leader Of The Free World still thinks he can arrogantly demand that every country tremble at his whim. Israel's Olmert is the sole remaining world leader who still openly supports Bush's neocon agenda and methods. And Olmert is even less popular domestically than Bush is here. So he hangs his hat on an unpopular hard-line leader, praises Israel enthusiastically and uncritically, gives the Arab world a stern lecture about how they had better shape up or he'll stop liking them as much as he does... and then goes to the most powerful Arab leader in the world asking for a favour. But wait, it gets dumber. The Gulf States (Saudis included) have taken an immense financial beating by sticking with the dollar to denominate oil exports. Without this sacrifice on their part, the U.S. economy would be in a severe depression. And, by way of thanks, Bush slams them and talks down to them, followed by a request for them to engage in yet another expensive action on our behalf.
And, unbelievably, this didn't work.
This "do what we tell you to or we'll kick your ass" approach is inherently weak, but it is the only "diplomatic" tool in the neocon's bag. Whatever "carrots" we have go to three countries: Israel, Egypt, and Colombia. Oh, but we have arms sales, too - expensive weapons systems with gravy train maintenance contracts for the U.S. defence industry, complete with fail-safes that ensure that they can only be used against enemies that the U.S. wants them to be used against. And along with it comes American "advisers" ready to subvert your military or blackmail you by pulling the plug on these weapons systems if you get "uppity".
So, yeah, no Eel Pout this week, but you know who would get it if there was one.
Instead, I'm taking a look at another poll.
Yeah, polls go up and polls go down, but they sure aren't moving in the direction Republicans would like to see, are they? But delusional Republicans still think they can win by running on the GWOT, security, and Iraq. Watch for more of the "Scary Muslims want to make your daughter wear a burqa!" ads in the coming months. And undoubtedly we will all be treated to the "secret Muslim" talisman that only seems to work on the incredibly stupid and the incredibly brainwashed. And it will run alongside ads telling us that this 'secret Muslim' is also somehow simultaneously controlled by a Scary Black Christian Preacher, just to guarantee that nobody with any critical thinking skills will be included in the Republican target demographic. How could this possibly fail? The Wise Party Elders decreed it, after all.
Oh, and this little bit:
And Republicans are jubilant over McCain's imaginary future world in which we have only been in Iraq five more years. Never mind that 60% want us out within 2008. And with a majority saying that Bush has done a poor job in Iraq, yes, let's promise to continue those policies with a McCain Administration and no doubt win big. With 52% (of likely voters, mind you) of the opinion that Iraq will go down in history as a failure, perhaps now is a great time to throw out a fictional scenario in which it's merely a long, drawn-out, expensive marginal success. As long we're ramming icebergs here, maybe McCain should tie himself even closer to the Decider-on-the-downhill-slide. Oh, he's already doing that. Good job, GOP.
The thing that makes (and will continue to make) turning the GOP around so immensely difficult is that it's an inherently top-down organisation. Many of the primaries don't even "matter" in the GOP. They are merely staged to select which poor bozos will go to the County Convention and cast the vote they are told to cast by the Wise Party Elders. The GOP has much more in common with a military (or paramilitary) structure than it does with a modern political party. Those at the top do not deign to listen to those below. Their job is to tell the "footsoldiers" what to think, what to say, who to hate today, which contradictions to ignore, etc. Only now, when the top leaders are realising that they are in trouble, is the average Republican allowing themselves to critically assess the Party. The GOP has spent nearly a decade enforcing absolute ideological obedience within its ranks, purging itself of dissent, marginalising those who may be caught whispering that perhaps the Decider isn't a genius after all, doling out federal jobs based not on competence but ideological purity.... that there simply is no "fresh, new leadership" around to take the reigns. Beyond that, the Party has been so thoroughly infested with leeches and opportunistic sycophants that will say, do, or think anything that the Party requires of them that any fresh, new voices will be silenced and stillborn.
Just look at the chaos within the GOP over the selection of McCain to be the nominee. Someone who hasn't followed the Party line scrupulously his entire career is being put up as the saviour of the Party, and the Party is making damn sure that he toes the line and turns himself into a proper "player" with proper obedience to the Wise Party Elders that made his nomination a necessity in the first place. Tie him to Bush, tie him to the GWOT, tie him to the Scary Muslim Menace, tie him to Iraq, tie him to a shoddy GI Bill - make him fall into line, for Chrissakes! And then still spin him as a "maverick", with a straight face.
Moreover, what does this say to those in the Party that have actually "toed the line" all these years? It says that they're playing a sucker's game.
The GOP is following in the path of the Whigs, who became so "pure" that nobody was good enough to vote for them anymore.
This is just one of the reasons why the DLC is so dangerous on the Democratic side.
We don't really need a Democrat SS to keep us safe from internal dissent. We thrive on internal dissent. Republicans look at Democrats and see "disarray", but this is what keeps us from becoming the Jackboot Party that we see on the other side of the aisle.
It is a mystery to me why the DLC looks to a failing Party as the model for their own victory.
But Bush’s Saudi Arabia junkets are perhaps more symbolic than anything else. In fact, there’s evidence to suggest that even if the King had agreed to increase Saudi Arabia’s oil production, its effect on lowering gas prices in the U.S. would have been minimal to non-existent.
The Leader Of The Free World still thinks he can arrogantly demand that every country tremble at his whim. Israel's Olmert is the sole remaining world leader who still openly supports Bush's neocon agenda and methods. And Olmert is even less popular domestically than Bush is here. So he hangs his hat on an unpopular hard-line leader, praises Israel enthusiastically and uncritically, gives the Arab world a stern lecture about how they had better shape up or he'll stop liking them as much as he does... and then goes to the most powerful Arab leader in the world asking for a favour. But wait, it gets dumber. The Gulf States (Saudis included) have taken an immense financial beating by sticking with the dollar to denominate oil exports. Without this sacrifice on their part, the U.S. economy would be in a severe depression. And, by way of thanks, Bush slams them and talks down to them, followed by a request for them to engage in yet another expensive action on our behalf.
And, unbelievably, this didn't work.
This "do what we tell you to or we'll kick your ass" approach is inherently weak, but it is the only "diplomatic" tool in the neocon's bag. Whatever "carrots" we have go to three countries: Israel, Egypt, and Colombia. Oh, but we have arms sales, too - expensive weapons systems with gravy train maintenance contracts for the U.S. defence industry, complete with fail-safes that ensure that they can only be used against enemies that the U.S. wants them to be used against. And along with it comes American "advisers" ready to subvert your military or blackmail you by pulling the plug on these weapons systems if you get "uppity".
So, yeah, no Eel Pout this week, but you know who would get it if there was one.
Instead, I'm taking a look at another poll.
Just 39% of American voters now believe the U.S. and its allies are winning the War on Terror. That’s down six points from a month ago and the first time that figure has dropped below 40% since last September.
The latest Rasmussen Reports telephone survey also found that 27% now believe the terrorists are winning. That’s up three points from a month ago and up seven points over the past two months.
By a 69% to 14% margin, Republicans believe the U.S. and its allies are winning the War on Terror. Democrats are evenly divided on the question. Among unaffiliated voters, 21% say the U.S. and its allies are winning while 34% say the terrorists have the advantage.
A separate survey found that Americans now trust Democrats more than Republicans when it comes to issues of national security. Another survey has found that the number of people who consider themselves Democrats has grown to record levels.
Just 24% now expect the situation in Iraq to get better in the next six months while (39%) hold the opposite view and believe the situation will get worse. That’s the second straight month that a plurality has expected things to get worse. Prior to April, a plurality had held the more optimistic view for six consecutive months.
Just 28% of Likely Voters now say history will deem the U.S. mission in Iraq a success. That’s down four points from a month ago, six points over the past two months, and is the first time fewer than 30% have been optimistic on this point since last August. Most Americans–52%--now say history will judge the U.S. mission in Iraq to be a failure.
Yeah, polls go up and polls go down, but they sure aren't moving in the direction Republicans would like to see, are they? But delusional Republicans still think they can win by running on the GWOT, security, and Iraq. Watch for more of the "Scary Muslims want to make your daughter wear a burqa!" ads in the coming months. And undoubtedly we will all be treated to the "secret Muslim" talisman that only seems to work on the incredibly stupid and the incredibly brainwashed. And it will run alongside ads telling us that this 'secret Muslim' is also somehow simultaneously controlled by a Scary Black Christian Preacher, just to guarantee that nobody with any critical thinking skills will be included in the Republican target demographic. How could this possibly fail? The Wise Party Elders decreed it, after all.
Oh, and this little bit:
Just 22% now say that President George W. Bush has done a good or excellent job handling the situation in Iraq. That’s down six points over the past month as well. His overall job approval ratings have fallen to record lows in recent weeks. Most voters—55%--now say the President has done a poor job handling the situation in Iraq. A separate survey has consistently found that roughly six-out-of-ten Americans would like to see the troops brought home from Iraq within the year.
And Republicans are jubilant over McCain's imaginary future world in which we have only been in Iraq five more years. Never mind that 60% want us out within 2008. And with a majority saying that Bush has done a poor job in Iraq, yes, let's promise to continue those policies with a McCain Administration and no doubt win big. With 52% (of likely voters, mind you) of the opinion that Iraq will go down in history as a failure, perhaps now is a great time to throw out a fictional scenario in which it's merely a long, drawn-out, expensive marginal success. As long we're ramming icebergs here, maybe McCain should tie himself even closer to the Decider-on-the-downhill-slide. Oh, he's already doing that. Good job, GOP.
The thing that makes (and will continue to make) turning the GOP around so immensely difficult is that it's an inherently top-down organisation. Many of the primaries don't even "matter" in the GOP. They are merely staged to select which poor bozos will go to the County Convention and cast the vote they are told to cast by the Wise Party Elders. The GOP has much more in common with a military (or paramilitary) structure than it does with a modern political party. Those at the top do not deign to listen to those below. Their job is to tell the "footsoldiers" what to think, what to say, who to hate today, which contradictions to ignore, etc. Only now, when the top leaders are realising that they are in trouble, is the average Republican allowing themselves to critically assess the Party. The GOP has spent nearly a decade enforcing absolute ideological obedience within its ranks, purging itself of dissent, marginalising those who may be caught whispering that perhaps the Decider isn't a genius after all, doling out federal jobs based not on competence but ideological purity.... that there simply is no "fresh, new leadership" around to take the reigns. Beyond that, the Party has been so thoroughly infested with leeches and opportunistic sycophants that will say, do, or think anything that the Party requires of them that any fresh, new voices will be silenced and stillborn.
Just look at the chaos within the GOP over the selection of McCain to be the nominee. Someone who hasn't followed the Party line scrupulously his entire career is being put up as the saviour of the Party, and the Party is making damn sure that he toes the line and turns himself into a proper "player" with proper obedience to the Wise Party Elders that made his nomination a necessity in the first place. Tie him to Bush, tie him to the GWOT, tie him to the Scary Muslim Menace, tie him to Iraq, tie him to a shoddy GI Bill - make him fall into line, for Chrissakes! And then still spin him as a "maverick", with a straight face.
Moreover, what does this say to those in the Party that have actually "toed the line" all these years? It says that they're playing a sucker's game.
The GOP is following in the path of the Whigs, who became so "pure" that nobody was good enough to vote for them anymore.
This is just one of the reasons why the DLC is so dangerous on the Democratic side.
We don't really need a Democrat SS to keep us safe from internal dissent. We thrive on internal dissent. Republicans look at Democrats and see "disarray", but this is what keeps us from becoming the Jackboot Party that we see on the other side of the aisle.
It is a mystery to me why the DLC looks to a failing Party as the model for their own victory.
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Al-Qaeda presence in Iraq is overblown
In the vast and constantly shifting reasons why we must remain in Iraq, the old reliable standard that gets most of the play is that if we were to leave, Al-Qaeda would take over Iraq and make it a base.
The second most-employed 'reason' is that we have to stabilise the government of Iraq so that it can be "a strong ally in the War On Terror". This reason is slowly being abandoned, at least in practise, by betting everything on the "Awakening". By building a parallel military force that is not loyal to the Iraqi government, the Administration is effectively throwing the government, the National Police, and the Iraqi Army to the wolves. The idea seems to be that they can control the Sahwa more easily, rout Al-Qaeda, and then manipulate them into bringing the Iraqi government 'into line' or even overthrowing them in favour of a more puppet-like regime.
While there are a lot of problems with this approach, a stupid, risky, and expensive plan has never stopped the Administration before. But the premise of this scheme, the rout of Al-Qaeda, is profoundly weak. As John Cole notes in the post below, there are no more than a few hundred AQ. Nearly every day, the military posthumously dubs any number of corpses "Al-Qaeda". Basically, we 'know' they are AQ because we killed them, and we wouldn't have killed them unless they were AQ, or so the circular logic goes. Our "Awakening" buddies that have been killed by friendly fire have even been dubbed AQ until this little "mixup" was corrected later by the Sahwa.
In the post below, Mr. Cole is taking McCain to task over his utterly mistaken attack on Obama when he responded to a hypothetical scenario. McCain falls over himself in a knee-jerk reaction in which he adamantly speaks of a tremendous Al-Qaeda threat in Iraq.
post from John Cole's Informed Comment:
This is something that has always irked me about the neocon claims. This is the primary "link" used by wingnuts to tie Saddam to 9/11. Al-Zarqawi was in Iraq, so Al-Qaeda was allied with Saddam.
Hell, Al-Qaeda operatives were in the U.S, Britain, Spain, etc. Does that 'tie' the U.S. to Al-Qaeda? Does that mean we should invade Spain as "payback for 9/11"? Aren't we obligated to invade Britain, a country known to have WMD, to prevent it from being used by Al-Qaeda as a base?
The likely answer, if neocons were honest, to these questions is "only if the Decider says we need to".
The second most-employed 'reason' is that we have to stabilise the government of Iraq so that it can be "a strong ally in the War On Terror". This reason is slowly being abandoned, at least in practise, by betting everything on the "Awakening". By building a parallel military force that is not loyal to the Iraqi government, the Administration is effectively throwing the government, the National Police, and the Iraqi Army to the wolves. The idea seems to be that they can control the Sahwa more easily, rout Al-Qaeda, and then manipulate them into bringing the Iraqi government 'into line' or even overthrowing them in favour of a more puppet-like regime.
While there are a lot of problems with this approach, a stupid, risky, and expensive plan has never stopped the Administration before. But the premise of this scheme, the rout of Al-Qaeda, is profoundly weak. As John Cole notes in the post below, there are no more than a few hundred AQ. Nearly every day, the military posthumously dubs any number of corpses "Al-Qaeda". Basically, we 'know' they are AQ because we killed them, and we wouldn't have killed them unless they were AQ, or so the circular logic goes. Our "Awakening" buddies that have been killed by friendly fire have even been dubbed AQ until this little "mixup" was corrected later by the Sahwa.
In the post below, Mr. Cole is taking McCain to task over his utterly mistaken attack on Obama when he responded to a hypothetical scenario. McCain falls over himself in a knee-jerk reaction in which he adamantly speaks of a tremendous Al-Qaeda threat in Iraq.
post from John Cole's Informed Comment:
Moreover, the allegation that he makes about there being 'al-Qaeda in Iraq' that could well take over the country is part lie and part insanity. The Sunni Arabs are no more than 20% of the Iraqi population. How could a tiny minority from within them take over the whole?
The technical definition of al-Qaeda is operatives who have sworn fealty to Usama bin Laden. There were only a few hundred of them. I doubt whether more than a handful of such individuals are in Iraq.
So there isn't any "al-Qaeda" in Iraq in the technical sense. There are "Excommunicating Holy Warriors" (Takfiri Jihadis), i.e. devotees of political Islam who are violent and willing to deploy terror for political purposes. They declare other Muslims who disagree with them "not Muslims,"-- thus the "excommunicating" bit. But there are only a few hundred foreign fighters. A small minority of Iraqis has associated with them. They don't call themselves 'al-Qaeda in Iraq.' The major such group is "The Islamic State of Iraq." And to say that they have "bases" in Iraq is pretty grandiose. They have some safe houses and try to take and hold neighborhoods, so far with indifferent success.
The idea that this small minority of violent Muslim fundamentalists could take over Iraq is completely crazy. They haven't even been able to keep their toehold in Baghdad-- the Sunnis have been largely ethnically cleansed from the capital by Shiite militias.
So the Shiites would not allow an "al-Qaeda" takeover of Iraq. Neither would the Kurds. Nor would most Sunni Arabs (as in al-Anbar Province, where the Dulaim tribe is at daggers drawn with the Excommunicating Holy Warriors).
Moreover, the neighbors would not allow the radical Sunnis to take over. Iran would sit on its hands while Shiites were massacred in Baghdad? Secular Turkey would allow this development? Baathist Syria? Hashemite Jordan (which played a major role in tracking down and killing Abu Musab al-Zarqawi)?
McCain's assertions that "al-Qaeda" has a strong position in Iraq or has any chance of taking over the country if the US leaves are both inaccurate. One is an error, the other is a dark but insubstantial fantasy.
Obama replied:
'“I've got some news for John McCain, that is there was no such thing Al Qaeda in Iraq until George Bush and John McCain decided to invade.
“I've got some news for John McCain. I've got some news for John McCain. He took us into a war, along with George Bush that should have never been authorized, never been waged. They took their eye off the people who were responsible for 9/11 and that would be Al Qaeda in Afghanistan, that is stronger now than at any time since 2001. I've been paying attention John McCain!
“John McCain may like to say that he wants to follow Osama bin Laden to the gates of Hell. But so far all he's done is follow George Bush into a misguided war in Iraq that's cost us thousands of lives and billions of dollars and that I intend to bring to an end so that we can actually start going after Al Qaeda in Afghanistan and in the hills of Pakistan, like we should have been doing in the first place. That's the news John McCain! '
Obama is correct that there was no al-Qaeda in Iraq before Bush overthrew the Iraqi government. I haven't been able to get anyone interested in it, but there is proof positive that the Baath authorities were very scared of al-Qaeda and that when Abu Musab al-Zarqawi showed up in Iraq, they put out an APB on him and branded him dangerous. (Dick Cheney told fairy tales about how Zarqawi was put up in fancy hotels by a solicitous Saddam.)
This is something that has always irked me about the neocon claims. This is the primary "link" used by wingnuts to tie Saddam to 9/11. Al-Zarqawi was in Iraq, so Al-Qaeda was allied with Saddam.
Hell, Al-Qaeda operatives were in the U.S, Britain, Spain, etc. Does that 'tie' the U.S. to Al-Qaeda? Does that mean we should invade Spain as "payback for 9/11"? Aren't we obligated to invade Britain, a country known to have WMD, to prevent it from being used by Al-Qaeda as a base?
The likely answer, if neocons were honest, to these questions is "only if the Decider says we need to".
Sunday, February 24, 2008
The Sunday Eel Pout

Well, it's Sunday, and that means it's time to trudge out on the ice, take a seat in the fish-house, bait our hook and reel another prize for this week's Sunday Eel Pout. The week's outrages, idiocies, and facile indignations will be compiled, and the most unworthy candidates will be awarded The Sunday Eel Pout. Your candidates are as follows:
- Richard Perle, one of the primary 'architects' of the Iraq invasion, wrote an article this week in The American Interest that offers several confusing and contradictory statements about the "success" of the Iraq invasion and subsequent occupation. The title of the article is "We Won Years Ago", in which he states that we have won because "Saddam will not be sharing WMD with anyone. Judged against that measure, we have already won in Iraq". Yes, Mr. Perle, (the deceased) Saddam will no longer be "sharing" (did he ever threaten this?) his non-existent WMDs. So we've "won" then, right? Not so, says Perle: "...despite the widely, if grudgingly, acknowledged progress of the surge, the war is far from over". So which is it, Mr. Perle? He also brags, by way of a quote from the reprehensible tool named Fouad Ajami, that the invasion has established "a Pax Americana [that] anchors the order of the region". Really? If anything, Bush has shattered the order of the region.
- Reuel Marc Gerecht, from the American Enterprise Institute and a former CIA officer, who proposes that we 'pretend' to negotiate with Iran as a pretext for bombing them. Negotiations are "something that must be checked off before the next president could unleash the Air Force and the Navy". We must, however, beware that talks "could bind the United States to meaningless, stalling discussions", so these negotiations must essentially be for show. After this, of course, "the military option would likely become convincing to more Americans".
- Alberto Gonzales, former Attorney General and Bush crony, who this week compared Bush with Lincoln. Bush also has presented himself as the contemporary Lincoln. This has been a recurring theme within neocon circles, with Karl Rove, Rudy Giuliani, and Newt Gingrich saying the same thing. Gonzales received $30,000 for his little speech, in which this scholarly figure would only answer pre-approved questions. He further offered that Bush's brilliance "will be revealed in years to come". Perhaps through multiple subpoenas, one would hope.
- President Bush, who this week in Africa presented a cut in funding for AIDS, TB, and malaria as an increase in funding. Congress gave Bush $841 million for the Global Project, but Bush reduced it to $500 million since, as one his stooges said, “You don’t want to pile up money.” So cutting $341 million is now considered an increase in Bush-speak.
- Arizona Senator John McCain, who this week criticised Obama as naive for saying he would take military action in Pakistan, even without the Pakistanis' permission if they wouldn't give it. As McCain further said, " I would not broadcast to the world that I am going to bomb a sovereign nation in order to accomplish my goal." So, Mr. McCain, weren't you the guy that broke out singing a reprise of "Barbara Ann" calling for the bombing of Iran? Isn't Iran a "sovereign nation"? Is that "naive", or is it only naive if someone else does it? Of course, the Bush Administration last month did exactly what McCain is criticising Obama for proposing. When asked about this, McCain said Obama was "wrong in speaking publicly about the option". So one must wonder if it was also wrong for McCain to speak publicly about bombing Iran. So much for "straight talk". Mc Cain is also eligible for a Sunday Eel Pout for his flip-flop on "taxes for the wealthy".
“There’s one big difference between me and the others–I won’t take every last dime of the surplus and spend it on tax cuts that mostly benefit the wealthy.” [McCain campaign commercial, January 2000]
So, as we reel in another putative prize and lay it out on the Minnesota lake ice in disgust, the sense of anticipation builds. Which bozo will take this damn thing home?
The winner of Minnesota's absolutely unwanted, utterly uncoveted, dismally appropriate, shudder-inspiring, and completely ignominious Sunday Eel Pout is... John McCain for saying it's wrong to publicly talk about bombing a sovereign nation, unless he does it, but that it's okay to actually do it if you are in the Bush Administration, because it's talking about bombing a country that really bothers a sovereign nation, not the actual bombing. This is McCain's second Sunday Eel Pout.
No, you can't throw it back. It's against the law in Minnesota to throw a rough fish back in the water. You're stuck with it, like every other angler in the North Star State. Feed it to the dog, use it to symbolise what we are fighting for in Iraq, waterboard it until it "talks", but get it the hell out of my sight.
All of the idiots in this week's race were unquestionably deserving of the Sunday Eel Pout, but There Can Be Only One.
Well kids, the hissing of the eel pout can only mean one thing: this Sunday's Eel Pout award is over.
Labels:
Ajami,
Alberto Gonzales,
McCain,
Perle,
Sunday Eel Pout
Sunday, February 10, 2008
The Sunday Eel Pout

In a completely obvious hat tip to The Desert Beacon, it is with reluctance and a sinister dread that I announce the need to launch the Minnesota version of The Sunday Deck Bass. The week's outrages, idiocies, and facile indignations will be compiled, and the most unworthy candidates will be awarded The Sunday Eel Pout. Your candidates are as follows:
- John McCain's advisor, Charlie Black, called Bush a "political asset" to the McCain campaign. Former Minnesota Congressman Vin Weber was slightly more honest when he said, "I don’t think it does us any good to try to pretend Bush doesn’t exist. I just don’t think that is a strategy that works. " Translation: we're stuck with him, so let's swim with this anchor or drown.
- Mitt Romney, who bowed out of the Republican race this week not because he was thoroughly rejected by his Party, or because it had already cost him $14 million of his own money, or because his designation as the last great hope for the right-wing of the GOP was the kiss of death in a general election, but rather because that by staying in the race he would only "forestall the launch of a national campaign and frankly I'd be making it easier for Senator Clinton or Obama to win. And in this time of war, I simply cannot let my campaign be a part of aiding a surrender to terror."
- Minnesota Senator Norm Coleman, who endorsed John McCain after endorsing Rudy Giuliani earlier. Coleman, the consummate political chameleon, was voted in as part of the Bush Team. He then distanced himself from Bush before Petraeus' September report. Then he became an ardent proponent of Giuliani's war against radical Islam, embracing torture. Detecting a shift in the breeze, he backed McCain two days before the primary when polls showed McCain leading at 41%. Romney got that that 41% and won, and Coleman ended up backing the guy that got 22%. If Romney hadn't backed out, it seems certain that Coleman's dubious allegiance would have shifted to him immediately.
- Arizona Senator John McCain, who laid out his "diplomatic offensive" to get the NATO allies to expand their role in Afghanistan. This plan is exactly what the Bush Administration has been doing for the past year (at least), only now McCain will do it with "straight talk" instead. McCain brilliantly proposes to "bang heads" with our reluctant allies, who apparently simply don't understand that their militaries are at our disposal. A good shout is all that is needed to bring them 'round. I don't know why Bush never thought of this.
All of the idiots in this week's race were unquestionably deserving of the Sunday Eel Pout, but There Can Be Only One.
Well kids, the hissing of the eel pout can only mean one thing: this Sunday's Eel Pout award is over.
Labels:
Charlie Black,
McCain,
Norm Coleman,
Romney,
Sunday Eel Pout
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)