Showing posts with label India. Show all posts
Showing posts with label India. Show all posts

Thursday, March 01, 2012

India holds military exercises in disputed region

China and India briefly went to war with each other in 1962, but the effort turned out to be much more difficult than anticipated for both sides. The high altitude, barren landscape, and rugged terrain are formidable challenges to a modern military.

Over the past few years, this region has once again heated up. Nothing really has changed since 1962, and both sides seem to have been expecting the other to concede.
 
From The Times of India:
NEW DELHI: India has begun major military exercises close to the Chinese border involving Special Forces of the Army and frontline fighters such as Su-30MKI as part of the endeavour to be battle ready in the inhospitable mountainous region. Code-named as 'Pralay' (devastation), the day-and-night exercises are mainly dominated by the aerial manoeuvres with support by ground forces.

The four-day exercises in the north-eastern sector, including Arunachal Pradesh, began yesterday, coinciding with the official India visit of Chinese Foreign Minister Yang Jeichi here. China has been laying claim over entire Arunachal Pradesh and voices objections whenever any senior union minister visits the state. IAF spokesman said the exercises were taking place "along the Brahmaputra river and eastern region" and "involves joint Army-Air Force operations by Eastern Air Command and Army Eastern Command."

The exercise is aimed at testing the combat potential of the IAF in various roles such as air defence, ground support operations, counter air operations and electronic warfare, he said. Besides the frontline Su-30MKI, Mirage-2000, MiG-29 and Jaguar fighter aircraft, IAF would be flying the strategic lift C-130J transport plane along with AN-32 and the AWACS.
Also, from The Washington Post: 
A visit by India’s defense minister to a border state claimed by China, accompanied by a fly-past by fighter jets recently stationed in the area, provoked some frosty advice from Beijing not to “complicate” matters. In return, the Indian defense minister, A.K. Antony, called China’s comments “most unfortunate” and “really objectionable.”
The spat, experts say, is a symptom of a deterioration in relations that began in 2005, as India drew closer to the United States and negotiated a civil nuclear cooperation agreement.
That new alignment appeared to threaten Beijing and set relations with India on a downward spiral — so much so that India’s multibillion-dollar military-modernization plans are now largely directed toward containing the growing threat from China.
“Ever since the U.S. nuclear deal in 2005, relations with China have been going through a turbulent time,” said Brahma Chellaney at the Center for Policy Research in New Delhi. “Nothing has changed in recent months to suggest that turbulence is easing or subsiding. What we are seeing actually is that Chinese state media is taking an increasingly hard line.”

Saturday, February 18, 2012

China border troubles continue

China has been making recent public remarks about the state of negotiations with India over the disputed border.
From The Hindu:
A month after India and China held the fifteenth round of border talks, a commentary in a Chinese newspaper has questioned India's claims on Kashmir and asserted that the only dispute was over the status of Arunachal Pradesh.
An article in the Communist Party-run Jiefang Daily, or Liberation Daily newspaper said the disputed western section of the border — including the Aksai Chin region which is now under China's control — was not part of the dispute, underscoring how far apart both countries' positions remained even after 15 rounds of negotiations.
The commentary said: “The Indian side believes that the border dispute between China and India covers not only the eastern region of 90,000 sq km but also the western region of 30,000 sq km and the western region is India's too. This wrong argument, which totally disregards the history, still has supporters in India.”
The article, written by an India scholar in the Shanghai Institute of International Studies, Wu Yongnian, was the first Chinese reaction to last month's border talks, and it underscored a hardening in China's position over the western section over recent years, analysts and officials said.
In New Delhi last month, National Security Adviser Shivshankar Menon and Chinese State Councillor Dai Bingguo, the two Special Representatives, discussed a framework for the settlement of disputes in all three sectors — western, middle and eastern. This was in keeping with the 2005 agreement on Political Parameters and Guiding Principles, which marked the ending of the first of three stages of negotiations.
According to Article III of the agreement, the boundary settlement would be “final, covering all sectors of the India-China boundary.”
 China appears to want to split up the various border disputes, and the talks are not going well, despite public shows of optimism.

The Times of India quotes China Daily:
"The first issue is the China-India border negotiation. China and India have held 15 meetings of special representatives for the border issue.
"Although the meetings have made many positive achievements, it is still far away from reaching a fair, just and reasonable agreement," the write up in the opinion page said.
The main barrier still comes from the Indian side as Indian media insist that the border line between China and India should be based on the " McMahon Line" left by British colonists, it said also India believes that the border dispute between the two countries covers not only the eastern region of 90,000 square km but also 30,000 sq km in the western region.
"This wrong argument, which totally disregards the history, still has supporters in India," it said.
Yet another reason that delaying the agreement was India's multi-party political system as well its society which is extremely complicated, it said.
"Various Indian political parties have different understandings on the China-India border issue, and therefore, it is hard for them to reach an agreement on the issue," it said.
It seems obvious that, in a democracy such as India, you are not going to have the consensus of opinion that you find in China.
 China has made 'concessions' with Tajikistan, Kazakhstan, and Kyrgyzstan in border talks previously. But there seems to be a pattern of China making huge (and unreasonable) demands, while settling for far less:
In the 1990s, China began negotiating settlements with these countries. Border agreements with Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan were reached in 1996 and 1998 respectively. Border talks with Tajikistan were delayed by the civil war there. However, talks gathered momentum in the late 1990s and an agreement was reached in 2002. It was this agreement that was ratified recently.

Analysts have drawn attention to the territorial concessions that China extended to resolve its many disputes. Of its 23 territorial disputes active since 1949, China offered "substantial compromises" in 17, usually agreeing "to accept less than half of the territory being disputed," M Taylor Fravel, associate professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, pointed out in the article "Regime Insecurity and International Cooperation: Explaining China's Compromises in Territorial Disputes," published in the journal International Security.

However, there is more to it than meets the eye. The territorial concessions that China is believed to have made are not quite as substantial as they appear to be. Srikanth Kondapalli, a China expert at the Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi pointed out that China's strategy of stepping up territorial claims and then settling for less has enabled it to appear to be making a major territorial concession to reach a border resolution agreement. In several disputes, "whether China actually gave up territory or made a substantial concession is a debatable question," he told Asia Times Online.
 Chinese media has built up an anti-Indian sentiment, and the media is completely State-controlled. I outlined some of this in a previous post. Much of it is jingoistic, inclined toward "teaching India a lesson". 

India, for its part, has also stirred up resentments in the media over the border conflict.
The shame of a lost border war left a long tradition of anti-Chinese slant in Indian newspapers, to the point where it doesn’t even seem like an aberration. But for some years now, the tone of a large section of the media has turned decidedly strident, a condition the country’s leading Outlook magazine once diagnosed as "Sinositis". Where once the China reportage gave the impression that for some in the media the war never quite ended, now one gets the sense that the infected are, in fact, itching for another round. Brace yourself for more malignant stuff this year, which marks the 50th anniversary of the war.

Many of the China-bashing stories doing the rounds in Indian papers are a mixture of reflexive phobia, envy, anxiety and great-game bluster, with headlines such as Wary of China moves, India, US & Japan plan talks; As China looms, US tells India to lead Asia; etc. Some are products of the occasional public spats on issues such as territorial rights, and are appropriately combative (Manmohan to Wen: Back off on South China Sea). And, when they are not openly hawkish and baying for blood (With China in mind, India tests new-generation Agni missile with high 'kill efficiency', screams a November headline), they are passive aggressive at the minimum, often betraying a degree of inferiority complex. The subheading to another November story headlined East Asia meet to have China tilt read INDIA STAND: Can't check them, will wait and watch. And that's not even an editorial!

Then there are the Chinese "incursions" stories - the most potent, and the fountainhead, of all Sinoscare media motifs in India. These stories, liberally peppered with alarmist words like "aggression", "transgression", "encroachment", and the like, follow a familiar pattern. "Sources", mostly unnamed, tell a paper or a TV channel how Chinese forces have been intruding into Indian territory; a comparison with similar intrusions in previous years establish how the Chinese menace is rising; followed by accounts of Chinese military build-up.
 The "McMahon line" is the only recognised border, and China has acceded to it in the case of Myanmar (its ally). In the cases of India and Bhutan, however, it is considered unreasonable: 

The Sino-Indian border dispute arose out of the Chinese occupation of Tibet. China's refusal to grant internal autonomy to Tibet has kept the pot boiling in Tibet and the Chinese view Indian asylum to the Dalai Lama with suspicion. This, despite the fact that India has accepted Tibet as part of China.

The Chinese have kept the border 'unsettled' so as to keep it as a ready excuse to intervene in the affairs of the Indian subcontinent. But there is a larger Chinese design at work here. 

It showed this intent in 1965 though not during the 1971 Indo-Pakistan conflict due to the erstwhile Soviet Union checkmating it on the Amur-Ussuri border.

Initially, the dispute was over the Aksai Chin area and the Chinese strategic road passing through it connecting Sinkiang with Tibet, a military necessity. Its claims over Arunachal Pradesh, initially at least, were seen as a bargaining chip.

It is noteworthy that the McMahon Line -- that China refuses to accept in Arunachal Pradesh -- has been accepted as the boundary with Myanmar. This clearly shows Chinese duplicity.
 When China talks about "securing Tibet", it means something very different than what the rest of the world considers to be "Tibet". They define Arunachal Pradesh as "South Tibet", and even include Bhutan as part of "Tibet".

Saturday, February 11, 2012

China pushes at border, India squirms and looks aside

I've dealt with this issue before, and the recent talks between China and India over their borders are turning out to be a joke. Apparently, India has made a grand 'concession' that Tibet is really a part of China, which settles everything. Except that China defines "Tibet" quite differently than India does. A part of (what everyone else recognises as) India is obstinately referred to as "South Tibet".

From Eurasia Review:
February 10, 2012
By Bhaskar Roy
There have been projections among some Indian experts and think tanks that a limited Chinese attack along the unresolved Sino-Indian border may be imminent. This view cannot be totally faulted. They are based on China’s aggressive official and semi-official postures and warning to India, especially on the sovereignty of Tawang, an important Buddhist pilgrim town in India’s north-east state of Arunachal Pradesh.
China claims officially the whole of Arunachal Pradesh as its territory. The official Chinese media, have started referring to Arunachal Pradesh as South Tibet. This is a very important shift in China’s nomenclature of Arunachal Pradesh. This is an effort to now make this Indian state a historical part of Tibet which China militarily occupied in 1950. With India among other countries in the world having acknowledged the original Tibet as a sovereign part of China, extension of Tibet to Arunachal Pradesh may give China an opening into its sovereignty claim on Arunachal Pradesh. Beijing believes it as another instrument to pressure India.


It is now common knowledge that China continues to support insurgent and separatist groups in north-east India.  If Tawang went to China it could garrison its troops there, ignite a major turbulence in north-east India, and roll down from Tawang to engage or cut off the Siliguri chicken-neck, preventing or slowing down Indian military movement. A success of this strategy would be disastrous for India. One can, therefore, understand China’s strong objection and criticism against India’s enhanced force deployment in north-east India. 

What is particularly galling for Indian observers is the fact that China is quietly building its military deployment in Tibet or Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR) that does not appear normal. The Chinese military has constructed or upgraded five airfields in close proximity of the border from the western sector to the eastern sector. There are indications that round the year air deployment is taking place or has already taken place. In the height of winter in January this year, People’s Liberation Army Air Force (PLAF) conducted live fire exercises in TAR.
The railway net work in Tibet may be projected by the Chinese as for development purposes, but its military and strategic emphasis are obvious. At least one full train load of transfer of arms and ammunitions from Golmud to Lhasa has already been conducted. The next step is bring one line to Xigaze (Shigatse) near the eastern sector border, and another to the Nepal border and then on to Kathmandu.
The road infrastructure along the border on the Tibetan side is being continually upgraded, and high altitude military exercises have also been conducted. In fact, two-dimensional military preparations in TAR can be said to be in an advanced stage.
And the Chinese public is being indoctrinated with the case for war with India:
As is well known, the Chinese Communist Party and the government have kept their people starved of information on the happenings in the world. The people have been fed by the state and party controlled media, tailored to project official views and thinking. China’s 500 million netizens’ views on different countries are shaped by official media. A study made by Simon Shen, Associate Professor in the department of social sciences, Hong Kong Institute of Education (published, China Quarterly, Sept. 2001) reveals interesting insights into the minds of these netizens. One thing that emerged from Simon Shen’s three-year research was that 90 percent were hostile to India. On territorial issues, the result was “why should China negotiate with India when it is superior and can hold off India?” India is also seen as servile to the west, and also as imperialist. Over all, the views are anti-India and based very closely if not exactly to the Chinese official propaganda.
This deliberately created mind set by the Chinese authorities can be a double edged sword. While it creates support for the party and the government, at times this can also pressure the authorities to do what they may not want to do. The Sino-India border issue is one of the questions discussed by the Chinese netizens who prefer a military strike in “South Tibet”’ Arunachal Pradesh, to teach India a lesson. These views are not of the 1950s or 1960s, they are contemporary and relevant.
But we have established agreements between the two countries about the border, and China has to honour those agreements, right? Nope:
An India-China conflict can manly be visualized along the borders. This issue is just not moving forward, and China does not want to under the current bilateral agreements. The issue is that China signed an agreement at the Prime Ministerial level in 2005 that there will be no exchange of settled population areas. Since then, they have reneged on this. The recent (Jan 16-17) Senior Representative (SR) level talks on the border and other issues not only saw little progress but rather froze such meetings for some time to come. Hence, one can safely believe that the boundary talks have gone to the mode of ‘time buying’.
So Chinese citizens are ready to go to war with India, China is building the infrastructure needed to go to war in that area, and China claims an entire province as part of India.




Also, from The Daily Mail:
India has increased its troop strength in the region and has taken several measures to improve infrastructure, including border roads.
Beijing has never acknowledged the McMohan Line separating Arunachal from Tibet as the official boundary with India. New Delhi has rejected China's claims over the state.
Sounds like it's all "settled", doesn't it?



Saturday, February 23, 2008

India waves the white flag on Chinese incursions

As I've noted before, China is creating a border conflict with India on India's NE frontier. Chinese forces are building roads, shelters, and camps both in India's Arunachal Pradesh and within Bhutan. Chinese Maoist proxies are moving into the Siliguri Corridor and the Chumba Valley to disrupt Indian and Bhutanese security forces. China openly claims ownership of Arunachal Pradesh, and India appears unwilling to go to war to defend it or Bhutan.

Remarkably, the Indian military is now saying, essentially, that it depends on how you look at it. "Maybe China really does own Arunachal Pradesh. Who are we to say who owns what?", seems to be the Indian Army's latest comment on the border incursions.

Or, as the Indian Army Chief would say, "the Chinese have a different perception" of the border than India does. Wow. Perhaps Pakistan has "a different perception of the LAC" in Jammu and Kashmir than India does, too. You have to look at from both sides, right? So if Pakistan invaded Kashmir, maybe the Indian Army would just shrug and leave. I mean, who put the Indian Army in charge of saying which country's military can or cannot come on to Indian soil? I simply have to wonder just what exactly Indian Army Chief Kapoor thinks the military is for? Parades?

If the Indian military doesn't want to go to war with China, that's one thing. Nobody likes war, especially when it marches to your doorstep. But for the Indian military to pretend this is all just some deep, dark philosophical mystery that has them baffled is just completely ridiculous. Just tell China that they can have everything east of the Siliguri Corridor. Maybe they won't go farther than that. If they do, the Indian military can always ponder some more on the artificial and ephemeral nature of borders. After all, if China is under the impression that an Indian state belongs to them, well, maybe they're right.

The issue is not the "number of incursions", but rather that these incursions now are backed up by thousands of Chinese troops encamped on the border.

story from ExpressIndia

Chinese incursions due to different perception: India

Agencies
Posted online: Saturday , February 23, 2008 at 07:25:57
Updated: Saturday , February 23, 2008 at 07:45:25


New Delhi, February 23: Noting that there were different perception of the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in Arunachal Pradesh, Army Chief Gen Deepak Kapoor has said India would be "as much blameworthy" as the Chinese side for incursions on the two sides.

He, however, said border infrastructure on Chinese side was better than that of India, giving them an "additional capability to bring additional troops", and the government here is "seriously looking" into this "disparity".

"I think a degree of misperception has been built on this issue of incursions. First and foremost, it is a matter of perception. The Chinese have a different perception of the LAC as do we. When they come up to their perception, we call it an incursion and likewise they do," Kapoor said in Karan Thapar's Devil's Advocate programme for CNN-IBN.

He said the level of total number of incursions in 2007 is "somewhat similar to what it has been in the past. So, the feeling that too many incursions have taken place into Indian territory is not right."

Asked whether Indian troops also incur into Chinese territory as often because of differences of perception about the LAC, the army chief replied: "that's right. Which they would call an incursion into their side. So, therefore, to that extent, we would be as much blameworthy for that kind of incursion up to our perceived LAC."

Kapoor dismissed media perception that Chinese incursion were a sign of muscle-flexing by Beijing indicating something worse to come.

Friday, February 22, 2008

More border troubles in Bhutan


I've posted before on the situation in Bhutan here and here.
China is moving its military forces into Bhutan, which is in the way of their effort to take the Indian frontier in a border dispute. With neighbouring Nepal already under the control of Chinese-inspired Maoist forces, and similar insurgents in the Indian state of Assam for several years, Bhutan is in a three-front low-intensity conflict. If an outright border war betwen China and India should ensue, these proxies would become an effective Fifth Column, with Bhutan becoming "liberated" by China in the same way that Tibet was "saved".

As we see in the reports below, these things are already coming to pass. Bhutan is attempting to evict Chinese proxies from bases within their country, while security forces in Assam are struggling with their own proxies and trying to prevent those in Bhutan from setting up bases in Assam. Meanwhile, China continues unhindered in its build-up, as their proxies create a diversion.

story from Calcutta News

Maoist threat: security tightened along Assam-Bhutan border

Calcutta News.Net
Friday 22nd February, 2008 (IANS)
The Assam government has tightened security along its border with Bhutan and expressed serious concern over reports that Maoist rebels from Nepal were going through the state to enter Bhutan and set up bases in the Himalayan kingdom.

'We are aware of the recent developments regarding movement of Maoist rebels and are taking the reports very seriously. We are stepping up security measures,' Asasm Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi told IANS Friday.

Bhutan's security forces have busted two Maoist militant camps and have captured at least eight Communist rebels with weapons in a crackdown that began last week.

'Our security personnel have busted two Maoist rebel camps last week, one each in the districts of Serphang and Samdrup Jongkhar, and captured eight rebels with weapons and incriminating documents,' Bhutan's Deputy Chief of Police Kipchu Namgyel told IANS by telephone from capital Thimphu.

Namgyel said the rebels belong to the Nepal-based Communist Party of Bhutan (Marxist-Leninist), a little-known group that is said to have carried out five bomb explosions in the otherwise peaceful Himalayan nation in less than a month.

The busting of the two Maoist camps in southern Bhutan districts, bordering the northeastern Indian state of Assam, has concerned authorities in the Buddhist nation of 700,000 people that is getting ready for its first parliamentary elections March 24.

Paramilitary troopers of the Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB) have stepped up vigil along Assam's 262 km unfenced border with Bhutan in view of reports of cross-border movement of Maoist rebels.

'We are taking adequate steps in view of the reports to ensure that Maoists are not able to set up any bases in Assam,' the chief minister said.

The Royal Bhutan Police (RBP) has held the Communist Party of Bhutan (Marxist-Leninist) responsible for the Feb 4 bombing in the southwestern Samtse district and four other explosions in January.

One person was injured and some government and private buildings damaged in the serial blasts. The Communist Party of Bhutan has also threatened to disrupt the March 24 elections to Bhutan's National Assembly or the lower House of Parliament that would formalize the nation's transformation from an absolute monarchy to parliamentary democracy.

Bhutan had witnessed a pro-democracy agitation in the 1990s with a section of Nepali-speaking residents in its southern parts rising in revolt against the monarchy.

The crackdown that followed led thousands of Nepali-speaking people from southern Bhutan to flee to Nepal. Now an estimated 100,000 people are sheltered in relief camps.

There are reports that the Maoists are recruiting among aggrieved refugees now based in Nepal. Recent reports say that Maoists from eastern India may have forged links with a rag-tag Assam-based rebel group called the All Adivasi National Liberation Army (AANLA), whose cadres are drawn from the state's tea workers' community.

The Assam Police have claimed to have reports about some AANLA leaders based in the state of Jharkhand, known to be a Maoist stronghold.

The Maoists' entry into Bhutan and the trend of violence has caused much concern among observers in the placid nation, currently on the fast track to experiencing democracy.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

story from The Telegraph

Bhutan purge worries Assam
- SSB alerted to passage of Maoists
OUR BUREAU

Guwahati/New Delhi, Feb. 21: The advent of democracy in Bhutan has triggered security concerns in Assam.

Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB) personnel stationed on the Indo-Bhutan border have launched an operation codenamed Night Dominance to prevent Maoists crossing over to escape a crackdown by the Royal Bhutan Army in the jungles of the Himalayan kingdom. The raids on Maoist camps is to pre-empt trouble during the March elections in Bhutan.

Sources in the SSB said that there was a danger of Maoists crossing from either side. “Maoists on the run in neighbouring Bhutan could cross over to the Indian side. Also, there is the possibility of Maoists belonging to the Communist Party of Bhutan (Marxist-Leninist-Maoist) trying to sneak into the Himalayan kingdom from the Indian side. The party is Nepal-based and there are reports that they have been using Indian border to cross over to Bhutan,” a senior official said.

Inspector-general H.C. Kharkwal confirmed that all SSB units were on maximum alert. “We have increased the level of troop deployment and arranged for modern equipment like night-vision devices and fast-moving vehicles. We need to be prepared to deal with any situation,” he said.

An intelligence official monitoring the Bhutan scene said at least three camps of the Bhutan Tiger Force — said to be the militant wing of the Communist Party of Bhutan — were busted and several Maoists arrested in the past few days. The rebels are believed to have sneaked into the Himalayan kingdom from Nepal through Assam.

Kharkwal said the SSB was focusing on the stretches through which infiltration was most likely, including the Bengal-Assam-Bhutan trijunction and Gossaigaon in Kokrajhar district.

Sources in the state home department said the increase in Maoist activity in Bhutan and along the border with Assam was discussed during a meeting on Tuesday between the king and the visiting Indian foreign secretary Shivshankar Menon and joint secretary (north) Preeti Saran.

The SSB’s special operation is likely to continue till the elections in Bhutan are over.

Militancy in Bhutan has been intrinsically linked to Assam and vice-versa ever since Ulfa and the National Democratic Front of Boroland set up camps in the Himalayan kingdom. Bhutan launched Operation All Clear in December 2003 to flush out the Assam militants.

Maoist elements in Assam, who became overly active after the episode in which a mob attacked Adivasi rallyists at Beltola in Guwahati last year, are believed to have established contact with their Nepal counterparts. “Bhutan will eventually turn into their meeting place if the situation is not handled immediately,” an intelligence official said.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

story from Kuensel


Militant camp in Samdrup Jongkhar

home 16 February, 2008 - Two members of the Communist Party of Bhutan, based in Nepal, were apprehended from a militant camp in the forest at Nunai under Samdrup Jongkhar dzongkhag, which a Royal Bhutan army patrol came across on February 15.

The RBA patrol recovered two pistols, four rifles and 15 improvised bombs from the two militants, Sanman Gurung and Aitaraj Rai. An army spokesperson said that the two apprehended militants said that there were 18 militants in the camp.
This is the third camp detected inside Bhutan since January 2008, according to the army spokesperson.

Saturday, December 08, 2007

Indian government reading from Bush's script.

Not only does the U.S.-India nuclear deal appear to be sunk, but the aftermath of its collapse is spilling over into the Iran issue. In spite of Singh's statements that India wants no part of Bush's "warmongering" with Iran, India seems to be following Washington's script fairly closely.

In spite of the recent revelations that U.S. aid to Pakistan has mostly been spent on arming itself against India, and in spite of the ridiculous anti-Hindu outcry raised by Bush's base in denouncing Hindus as "wicked", and in spite of India's closest ally (China) becoming openly irritated with the U.S, it would seem that Mr. Singh is entirely willing to dance to the tune of a lame-duck American leader.

For a long time, Bush forbid any country from selling nuclear technology to India, even though this would be highly profitable. Then Bush changed his mind and decided it would be okay if American companies made a lot of money upgrading India's reactors, but the rest of the world (mostly our allies, by the way) should keep out. To a large degree, Bush restrained his traditional arrogance in coming up with the nuke deal, but India couldn't get the deal approved domestically due to the insistence on inspections. Since several other Western nations appear willing to step in and take America's place as India's nuclear supplier of choice, it's odd that India should become fixed on pleasing Bush, who has a bit over a year left in power and who is remarkably unpopular. If Bush is dangling something in front of Mr. Singh's eyes, then Singh should recall that Bush has done the same with Eastern European nations and he should realise that Bush's ability to deliver on the world stage is diminishing, as is his ability to get his way domestically.



US wants to convert India into subordinate ally: CPI(M)

Agencies
Posted online: Monday, December 03, 2007 at 0000 hrs IST
New Delhi, December 3:
Ahead of Tuesday's discussion in Rajya Sabha on the nuclear deal, the CPI(M) on Monday stepped up attack on the issue alleging that its "larger agenda" was to convert India into a "subordinate ally" of the US and New Delhi's "shift" in policy was visible in the Indo-Iranian relations.
"Day-to-day developments reconfirm our fears that the US wants to convert India into its subordinate ally in South Asia, even before the Indo-US nuclear deal has come into effect. This is a very ominous development," Politburo member Sitaram Yechury told reporters in New Delhi.
The CPI(M) leader said the 123 agreement, which was "firmly anchored in the Hyde Act", has fallen short "not just of our objections but of the assurances of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh himself."
Maintaining that American "pressure" was working not just on the government to "shift" its foreign policy but on Indian companies as well, Yechury said the deal was "lot more than only nuclear cooperation, it has a larger agenda ...to convert India as a subordinate ally of the US in South Asia.”
In this context, he referred to India's non-participation in a scheduled meeting with Iran and Pakistan on the gas pipeline and said "not going for the project or delaying it is not in India's interest. It is clearly succumbing to US pressures".
Yechury said the State Bank of India had "suddenly prohibited" extending their line of credit to Iranian firms and stopping Indian exports to that country.
He expressed hope that government would answer in Rajya Sabha on Tuesday these "serious" questions which came in the aftermath of India voting against Iran at the IAEA on the nuclear issue.

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

U.S. aid used by Pakistan against India

In another ally-on-ally conflict reminiscent of the Turk-Kurd conflict, it now is becoming clear that much of the military aid Bush gave to Pakistan for the Global War on Terror has instead gone into arms purchases designed to prepare Pakistan for a war against India. Somehow, arming one side of two nuclear-armed nations that have fought previous wars makes us safer, though I honestly can't say how.

It's abundantly clear that whatever alliance Bush made with Pakistan was simply one of convenience on Musharraf's part. Once again, Bush got taken for a ride, to the tune of $10 billion. For years, Musharraf did little or nothing to evict the Taliban from the federal tribal areas, while they built camps and hid Bin Laden. Finally, in the past two months, the Taliban have made the federal tribal areas a de-facto independent state and the rebellion has spread beyond the frontier into Swat Valley. Then our ally, Musharraf, boldly sprung into action. He declared martial law and threw the democratic opposition into jail. Then he got some of his troops that had been taken hostage in the tribal areas released, while continuing his winning policy of doing nothing about the rebellion on the frontier. This is what we got for $10 billion. Unless, of course, Musharraf throws in a war with India as part of the deal for his "support".

Bush seems to have no other card up his sleeve but military force and huge arms shipments. Reconstruction won't take place without security, and you can't get security without reconstruction. Meanwhile, the bill just gets bigger every day, and war becomes more likely in every area Bush's magic was worked. Russia and China get more powerful as we blow huge amounts of borrowed cash on two wars that increase regional instability. If another crisis erupts, Bush has few legions left to throw at it. His base speaks glowingly of the Long War, an endless series of conflicts across the globe in which we grind our heel into the face of any nations that fail to repeat our talking points. We will be "safe" only when we can dominate the world and dictate who takes power where. Those nations friendly to us, such as Israel, can have nuclear weapons (and already do), but those who are not under our hegemony are a danger to the world. Pakistan itself was once classified by the U.S. as a rogue state for its possession of nukes and failure to sign the NPT. But when the Global War On Terror was dreamed up, all that went by the wayside. Democracy is the goal and the watchword, unless it produces governments that don't bow to our whim, such as in Palestine, Venezuela, or Russia.

Even worse, pointing out this arrogance and hypocrisy earns you the label "America Hater" from Republicans. This Long War, if it is carried out, will cost this country multiple trillions of dollars and result in a military draft and national insolvency. It will cost us our allies and create new wars which we have no control over.

In a war between India and Pakistan, the big winners will be China and Russia. Money spent on goading one side into such a war is absolutely counter to our national interests, yet this is what "patriotic" Republicans are doing. Russia controls the energy supplies for our allies in Europe, and China has the ability to create economic collapse for us at the drop of a hat, at a far cheaper cost to them than war with us. At the same time, we are committed to defending Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea, no to mention Israel. If Republicans would stop their incessant cheerleading and flag-waving for a moment and look at the big picture, they might very well put down the Kool-Aid. It has nothing to do with patriotism; it's delusion versus reality. Every nation that we defeated in the past "wanted to win", but that was not enough. Republicans seem to think that's all that is required to prevail. They are sadly deluded.


full story from ExpressIndia

Pak spent bulk of US aid on arming against India


Posted online: Wednesday, November 21, 2007 at 12:00:00
Updated: Wednesday, November 21, 2007 at 09:58:02

Silicon Valley, November 21: Pakistan has used a significant portion of the US aid since September 11 attack to arm itself for a confrontation with India instead of conducting war on terrorism, according to a strategic think tank.
Most of the USD 10 billion US aid is supposed to compensate the Pakistani government for sending its 80,000 or so soldiers to the Northwest Frontier Province and providing support to the US war in Afghanistan.
However, the money has been used for procuring high-tech weaponry to arm the military for its confrontation with India, the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) has said.
"We found that that the Pakistani military has been using that money and the majority of our direct military assistance for the purchase of high-tech weaponry such as the F-16 fighters," senior adviser in the CSIS Frederick (Rick) Barton said.
"It appears that the Pakistan military is continuing to arm more for its confrontation with India than it is for the war on terror because these weapons really don't have that much application for the kinds of low-grade persistent Taliban fighters and al-Qaeda fighters that you find in the Northwest part of Pakistan," Barton told the National Public Radio.
Urging Washington to make a more strategic use of the money it gives Pakistan, Barton said "If we had wise approach to war on terror, we would have found ways to align ourselves more with the Pakistan people. Because the only way you can deal this kind of insurgency is to have the people on your side and to not have the people harboring the insurgents."
One of the key points that the CSIS study pointed out was that the US needs to re-establish a whole new kind of relationship with Pakistan, Barton said in an interview with the public radio.
In 1990s, the US stayed away from Pakistan for 10 years, following Pakistan's nuclear weapons development.
He said Pakistan deserved a great deal of attention which the US has never done.
"We constantly flush them with money, then head for exits and none of those approaches really work."
He said only 10 per cent of the aid had gone to education and humanitarian causes and the majority of that went in response to the earthquake where tens and thousands of people were killed.
The US gave direct humanitarian assistance and military assistance and as a result the US public support in Pakistan went up from about 25 per cent to well over 50 per cent.
"None of these polls mean that much, but part of what we want to do as a country is to make it clear that we are on the side of the people, not just the powerful," said Barton.
He said America's second-largest area of humanitarian expense was in education, but there again the US is trying to do a million different things rather than focusing on particular areas where it might have higher impact.

Friday, September 07, 2007

U.S. leans on India over Iran

Last month, India refused to go along with the Bush Administration's warmongering with Iran. Now we are seeing the fallout from that, as the usual American suspects cast aside U.S. interests in order to create hysteria over Iran. India is now beginning to learn what State Department 'diplomacy' really is about, as they are being villified as conspirators with Iran.

Put simply, the India-U.S. nuclear deal is the best that the U.S. can get. If the U.S. doesn't play ball, there are other countries who will step in to develop India's nuclear industry, and some of those are nations we really wouldn't like to see cozying up to India. And India can always wait until Bush is out of office, if the U.S. involvement is considered critical.

With the U.S. overextended in two wars, on top of its prodigious military commitments globally, becoming more isolated as its foreign policies boil down to blackmail and bullying, and Britain backing away from self-destruction on the U.S' behalf, other countries are no longer enthusiastic about following any script the State Department might give them. Bush's reliable stooges, such as Blair, Olmert, Abe, and Howard, all are suffering politically or are out of office in disgrace.

Now is not the time to be pushing allies away from us, especially over the ill-conceived attack on Iran. The rest of the world simply is not going to cast aside its interests in an attempt to please Bush, who will be gone in 17 months anyway.

The irony of this situation is that American hypocrisy was obvious over the nuclear deal with "friendly" India and "unfriendly" Iran. Now we have 'remedied' that by putting our relations with India in jeopardy. Add to this the Republican uproar over "wicked" Hindus a few months ago, which did not play well in India or here at home with Indian-Americans. If India is smart, and it is, it will make overt moves to Russia or China to develop its nuclear industry. France, Canada, Britain and others will be frozen out of this opportunity by sticking with Bush.


Indo-Iran ties can sidetrack nuke pact

Agencies
Posted online: Friday, September 07, 2007 at 1058 hours IST
Updated: Friday, September 07, 2007 at 1102 hours IST

Nuclear Deal Washington, September 7: Observing that there was "no evidence" that India would cease its military relationship with Iran, two US Senators have warned that the "growing" ties between the two countries could "sidetrack" the Indo US nuclear agreement.

In a letter to US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, Republican Senator Jon Kyl and Richard Durbin, a Democrat, have said, "government sanctioned military-to-military working groups and joint military training exercises that India conducts with Iran" were a cause of concern.

"As supporters of the US-India Civil Nuclear Accord, we're apprehensive that the agreement could be sidetracked by what appears to be a growing relationship between Iran and India," they said in the letter dated September 5,2007.

"India apparently has helped Iran to develop more effective batteries for its submarine fleet," the lawmakers said and termed it as "disturbing".

In an attempt to alert the Indian government to this "potential problem", they said, eight US Senators wrote to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh earlier this year asking him whether India would break its military relationship with Iran.

"These Senators did not receive a response; and, of course, there has been no evidence that India will cease its military relationship with Iran," the letter said.

The lawmakers also cited reports detailing steps by India to enter into agreements to develop Iranian oil and gas resources and expressed the hope that New Delhi would deny Tehran such economic support.

"While we understand India's reliance on external sources of natural gas, we know that the Iranian economy, its energy sector in particular, is extremely fragile," the Senators wrote.

"We would hope India would not provide just the economic support to Iran that the United States has been labouring to deny through passage of legislation," Kyl and Durbin said.

The two lawmakers also cited reports of several alleged incidents of proliferation of dangerous technologies "that have their source in India".

"These are, of course, troubling matters," they said.

"We look forward to discussing these concerns with you to ensure that it is the right time for Congress to be considering the 123 agreement," they said.

The US Congress is due to give its final vote on the civilian nuclear agreement that will allow India access to nuclear material and technology to meet its power needs.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Indo-US Nuke Deal

Duty of US to convince NSG: India

Agencies
Posted online: Tuesday, September 04, 2007 at 1925 hours IST
Updated: Tuesday, September 04, 2007 at 1931 hours IST

Nuke Deal Kalpakkam, TN, September 4: India on Tuesday said it was the duty of the US to convince the Nuclear Suppliers Group under the civil nuclear deal to provide it with nuclear fuel and light water reactors and ensure clean, unconditional exemptions for trade in the atomic field with New Delhi.

India is also engaged with the 45-nation grouping to persuade it to change rules and allow the international community to have nuclear commerce with it, Atomic Energy Commission Chairman Anil Kakodkar said.

"No post and pre-conditions should be laid and there is a need for clean, unconditional exemptions from NSG guidelines on the import of nuclear reactors," he told reporters on the sidelines of a graduation function at the Indira Gandhi Centre for Academic Research at Kalpakkam, about 75 km from Chennai.

He was responding to a query on NSG guidelines that restrict the export of reactors by members of the grouping, including the US, France, Russia, Australia and Japan.

Reacting to US Under Secretary of State Nicholas Burns' remarks that it was up to India to convince NSG members to provide it nuclear fuel and light water reactors, he said, it was the duty of the US to do so in the wake of the nuclear deal recently clinched with America.

Commenting on the deal and the possible US restrictions on nuclear tests by India, Kakodkar said, "We have to look at Indian interests and should be able to carry out our strategic programmes."

The ultimate goal of the Indian nuclear programme is to move from uranium to thorium for producing energy, he said.

By 2050, nuclear energy will constitute 2,74,000 MW or 20 to 25 per cent of India's power production, he said
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

China raises fresh concerns on N-deal

Reuters
Posted online: Thursday, September 06, 2007 at 1608 hours IST
Updated: Thursday, September 06, 2007 at 1624 hours IST

N-Deal Beijing, September 6: China said on Thursday there were 'different views' about a nuclear power pact between the United States and India and called for such deals to stay in line with international safeguards -- but left its own stance ambiguous.

The agreement between New Delhi and Washington would offer India US fuel and reactors while allowing it to stay out of the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, keep nuclear arms and protect its military atomic complex from international inspections.

Even if the agreement survives opposition from Leftists, China's veto could kill it at an international level.

Indian newspapers have suggested that Beijing could block the deal at the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG), a 45-nation club that works by consensus.

Washington will need to go to the NSG, which is supposed to discourage nuclear trade with countries outside full safeguards, to ask for special leeway for India.

Noting various opinions on the deal in the NSG, China's Foreign Ministry suggested that Washington and New Delhi should address worries that it would damage safeguards against the spread of nuclear weapons.

"We have also noted that within the Nuclear Suppliers Group there are different views about relaxing the restrictions on nuclear exports to India," Ministry spokeswoman Jiang Yu told a regular news briefing.

"China believes that, with the precondition of abiding by their international responsibilities, all countries can develop cooperation in the peaceful exploitation of nuclear power."

The Leftists have demanded that New Delhi put on hold talks with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) to secure a safeguards pact needed to clinch the deal.

Jiang said any international atomic power cooperation should serve to 'protect and strengthen' barriers against the spread of nuclear arms.

She refused to say whether China itself had concerns about the deal. Some Scandinavian countries have privately expressed concerns about making exceptions for India.

Jiang's comments appeared to be China's latest step in a delicate diplomatic game of signalling concerns about the deal without sparking a stand-off with India.

Experts have said China is unlikely to stymie the nuclear deal and risk pushing Delhi closer to Washington -- just when Beijing is seeking to avoid a destabilising confrontation with its rising Asian neighbour and longtime rival.

But many have also said that Beijing worries about how the deal will affect regional security and arms controls.

Saturday, August 18, 2007

India says it wants no part of Bush's "warmongering"

The nations who jumped aboard the Bush Administration's plans have all either suffered or gained nothing. Britain is now bogged down in bad situations on two fronts after being conned by Bush into "peacekeeping" operations that became combat roles. Israel suffered its worst military setback when it followed the direction of the U.S. and invaded southern Lebanon. The Eastern European nations who sent their small forces to Iraq have not seen any progress on their bids to join NATO. Countries such as South Korea that merely keep their troops within their base and stay out of harm's way have gained nothing but a "pat on the back", but have not lost soldiers, either. Pakistan's Musharraf will likely lose power and our influence will evaporate with his departure.
So, in the Bush Administration's new campaign against Iran, other nations are not lining up to support another military solution. India has just announced that it wants no part of this new campaign, and it has taken a firm position on nuclear negotiations. They have received a much better deal by refusing many of the harsher demands of the Bush Administration, such as signing the NPT, and have stayed away from any 'brilliant' plans put forth by the State Department. Since India never had ambitions to be a source of nuclear terrorism, the U.S. has gained precisely nothing in its negotiations while India gets the technology to upgrade its nuclear power industry.
For decades, the U.S. led firm sanctions against India's nuclear industry after India developed the atomic bomb. For decades, we told our allies that they could not engage in the highly profitable task of bringing India's nuclear reactors up to modern standards, and the rest of the world meekly went along with that. Then one day the Bush Administration changed it's tune and decided that it's okay if American companies made a ton of money developing India's reactors, provided India signed the NPT and submitted to inspections. Our allies, who had followed our line obediently, were left out in the cold, and India politely declined to cave in to our demands. India knows that our allies will be happy to provide the technology if the U.S. hangs too tough, now that the door has been opened.
Rather than being browbeaten by Bush, India instead stood its ground as a sovereign nation and got what it wanted. Bush, by restraining the traditional arrogance of his Administration, has managed to hold on to India as a marginal ally. At best, the U.S. broke even on the deal, but by Bush's foreign policy record, this counts as a stunning success.


Agencies
Posted online: Friday, August 17, 2007 at 1804 hours IST
Updated: Friday, August 17, 2007 at 1849 hours IST

George Bush New Delhi, August 17: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has made it clear to President George W Bush during negotiations on the Indo-US nuclear deal that India could not agree to a "bilateral" NPT or Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT).

He also said that it was not in India's interest for Iran to become a nuclear weapons power, although it had the right to have nuclear energy as an NPT member.

"I told President Bush, I can't be a cheer leader or be part of a warmongering group. The nuclear dispute with Iran should be resolved through peaceful processes," he told India Today.

The Prime Minister's comments came in an interview conducted over two months back while he was returning from the G-8 Summit of Industrialsied countries in Germany. Singh had met Bush and other world leaders during his trip in June.