Showing posts with label improvement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label improvement. Show all posts

Thursday, September 06, 2007

Bush continues to lie about surge's success

So it seems that violence against Iraqi civilians isn't down, that Iraqis continue both to flee the country and also to become internally displaced, that the military is providing questionable figures to "prove success", and that the Iraqi military, aside from its low numbers, continues to have loyalties to sectarian militias.

The surge was supposed to be about quelling the sectarian militias and promoting political stability, not about chasing Al-Qaeda from one city to another and dubbing certain terrorists "good" and others "bad".

The surge has merely produced marginal security improvements in isolated areas that is not even likely to continue after the surge ends. At $12 billion a week, this is not a great value. Add to that, however, that the infrastructure and economy is not improving either and both are continuing disasters. And also consider that the political situation is close to a "failed state" scenario. Anyone besides a Bush cheerleader or in the pay of the Decider can see that the surge is a failure.

story from Mc Clatchy

Report: Surge hasn't cut attacks on Iraqi civilians


WASHINGTON — The surge of additional U.S. troops in Iraq has failed to curtail violence against Iraqi civilians, an independent government agency reported Tuesday.
Citing data from the Pentagon and other U.S. agencies, the Government Accountability Office found that daily attacks against civilians in Iraq have remained "about the same" since February, when the United States began sending nearly 30,000 additional troops to improve security in Iraq.
The GAO also found that the number of Iraqis fleeing violence in their neighborhoods is increasing, with as many as 100,000 Iraqis a month leaving their homes in search of safety.
The GAO's conclusions contradict repeated assertions by the White House and the Pentagon in advance of the coming congressional debate on whether to stay the course in Iraq or to begin some withdrawal of U.S. troops.
Neither a July report from the White House nor a report last month from 16 U.S. intelligence agencies, however, provided any statistics to support their claims that the surge has improved security. The GAO report, in contrast, includes charts showing the number of attacks against Iraqi civilians, Iraqi security forces and U.S. troops. Only attacks against U.S. troops have declined in recent weeks.
In testimony before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee Tuesday, U.S. comptroller general David S. Walker, who heads the GAO, said he couldn't vouch for charts that Sen. Norm Coleman, R-Minn., said Army Gen. David Petraeus, the U.S. commander in Iraq, had shown him during a recent congressional visit to Iraq. Coleman said those charts showed a decrease in violence.
"Let's just say that there are several different sources within the administration on violence, and those sources do not agree. So I don't know what Gen. Petraeus is giving you," Walker said.
When President Bush announced in January that he'd dispatch more troops, he said the goal was to cut sectarian violence so the government of Prime Minister Nouri al Maliki could work out political compromises on key issues among Iraq's rival religious and ethnic groups.
Supporters and opponents of the surge now agree on at least one thing: Maliki has been unable to bring about those agreements. So does the GAO. Its report found that of the 18 benchmarks Iraq's government set for itself, three have been met, four have been partially met and 11 haven't been met.
"Overall, key legislation has not been passed, violence remains high, and it is unclear whether the Iraqi government will spend $10 billion in reconstruction funds," the report said.
The GAO said it couldn't determine whether sectarian violence in Iraq is down "because measuring such violence requires understanding the perpetrator's intent, which may not be known."
But the report said it was possible to assess the overall daily number of attacks against civilians. A chart showed that those attacks have remained relatively constant throughout 2007, despite the additional U.S. troops. The GAO referred a request for precise numbers to the Defense Intelligence Agency.
Army Lt. Gen. Raymond Odierno, the No. 2 U.S. commander in Iraq, acknowledged the controversy over the numbers in comments to reporters in Baghdad on Tuesday. But he said that violent incidents in Iraq are at their lowest point in 15 months this week.
"There's been some controversies about civilian casualties," Odierno said. "Ours still see it as below what it was. We think we're making progress."
The GAO said that the Pentagon disagreed with its conclusion that there was no discernable trend in sectarian violence and provided the agency with additional data. But the GAO said it wasn't persuaded and didn't change its conclusion.
The GAO said it did change its assessment of two benchmarks from "not met" in a draft report to "partially met" after it received additional information. Those were whether the Iraqi government had provided three trained and ready brigades to join in Baghdad security operations and whether it had ensured that there were no safe havens for outlaws, regardless of sectarian affiliation.
Walker said that Iraqi forces have made progress in providing some security in Baghdad, but that it's unclear whether they can sustain those gains alone.
"I think there's a serious question whether they on their own will be able to hold these neighborhoods for an extended period of time . . . absent direct U.S. troop involvement," Walker said. "That's probably the $64,000 question."
The report found that many Iraqi military units include fighters with strong sectarian and tribal loyalties, and therefore are unwilling to confront extremist militias.
Walker said it was important to determine not just whether Iraqi forces were ready to fight, but also whether they were "committed to a unified Iraq and committed to fight on that basis."
That kind of loyalty will be hard to achieve until Iraqi politicians reach political reconciliation, Walker said. Currently, he said, the Maliki government is "dysfunctional".
The GAO report also provided evidence to support some analysts' belief that U.S. combat deaths have declined in the past few months because some Iraqi groups have chosen not to face American troops on the battlefield.
U.S. officials had predicted that combat deaths would rise when the surge was at full strength and the U.S. began a series of military offensives. Instead, U.S. combat deaths declined from a high of 120 in May to 55 in August, according to the icasualties.com Web site.
Citing a June 2007 Pentagon document, the GAO report said that many fighters from the Mahdi Army militia of Shiite cleric Muqtada al Sadr left Baghdad as the number of U.S. and Iraqi troops there increased. However, it said, "they now engage in ethnic and sectarian violence in northern and central Iraq" and are battling another Shiite militia, the Badr Organization, for control of southern Iraq.
(Leila Fadel in Baghdad contributed.)
McClatchy Newspapers 2007

Sunday, August 26, 2007

The 'progress machine'

Baghdad is where the surge is concentrated and where the biggest (positive) results were expected from the surge. Just yesterday in Baghdad, reports show a car bombing, an attack on Iraqi troops, and another crop of bodies turning up to demonstrate that sectarian killings continue right under the noses of the surging troops.

However, the surge has also served to re-locate violence to previously stable areas, such as Kurdistan. Mosul and Kirkuk are two of those Kurdish cities that have seen previously unheard-of kidnappings, roadside bombs, car bombs, drive-by shootings, and brazen attacks on troops.

The events show below are just a typical day. Usually none of these tragedies merits a mention on the American media, yet for the people who live in these areas it represents anything but "normalcy" or "stability". It instead creates a fearful environment that induces people to turn to their sectarian militia for protection - at a price, of course. The more that communities are defined as one militia's "turf", the harder it is "reconcile" those communities with the rest of the area. But until the "gang war" breaks out, the surface appears stable and relatively calm.

That is what the "bottom-up reconciliation" really is; the staking of turf so that inter-militia conflict can be obviated. As long as the militias co-operate with U.S. troops against Al-Qaeda, or just simply label their competitors as "Al-Qaeda" in order to have the U.S. troops wipe them out, then the commanders can call this "progress". This "progress" can then be packaged and sold wholesale to the American media as 'proof' that the surge is "working".

This is the 'progress machine' that allows Republicans to live their delusional vision that we are always "winning". Senior officers are happy to avoid a "Shinseki Treatment" by passing along this illusion of "progress", because it makes the Bush Administration happy, and that means promotion, or at least the continuation of one's career. They can always create another "Operation Whatever" to push the violence someplace else. This proves our military superiority over the "insurgents". But the "insurgents" do not have be militarily superior; they just have to be tenacious. They certainly are tenacious, having survived for 4 1/2 years so far.

Have you ever really heard a definition of the term "insurgent" before, as it applies to Iraq?
Are they Al-Qaeda? Does the term include sectarian militias, or only those militias that continue their terrorist activites while allied with us? Is an Iraqi "insurgent" anyone who opposes the Al-Maliki government, or just someone who opposes the U.S. occupation? Does the term "insurgent" include those who engage in kidnapping, extortion, protection rackets, black market arms dealing, and ethnic cleansing or does it merely refer to those who carry out bombings and attacks on military and police?

Yes, let's keep it vague so that we can refer to anyone killed or arrested as an "insurgent". That way we can show inflated progress with a straight face. Just as in Vietnam, anyone who was killed in bombardments, artillery fire or just "got in the way" was labeled "VietCong", so too is the label "insurgent" being sloppiliy applied in the case of Iraq. We don't ask questions, because we want to "win", and anything that makes it look like we are winning is fair game. This is what we get for $12 billion a week: shifty "accounting" that keeps the "shareholders" from asking questions.


reports from Reuters

* BAGHDAD - A parked car bomb killed seven people and wounded 30 others in the Kadhimiya district in northwestern Baghdad, police said.

* MOSUL - The body of a university lecturer was found in the southeast of the northern city of Mosul, five days after he was abducted, police said.

* MOSUL - Five people were wounded including three policemen by three separate roadside bombs in Mosul, police said.

* ARAB JABOUR - U.S. forces said they discovered an execution site containing human skulls and decomposing bodies in Arab Jabour, an agricultural area on the southern outskirts of Baghdad.

* BAGHDAD - Police said they found nine bodies in different districts in Baghdad on Friday.

* BAGHDAD - Gunmen attacked an Iraqi army patrol, killing one soldier and wounding two others in Mansour district in western Baghdad on Friday, police said.

*NAJAF - Gunmen killed a man in a drive-by shooting in Najaf, 160 km (100 miles) south of Baghdad, on Friday, police said.

* KIRKUK - Gunmen killed a man in a drive-by shooting in southern Kirkuk, 250 km (155 miles) north of Baghdad, on Friday, police said.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

Let's look on the bright side

The right-wing blithely ignores the deteriorating situation in Kurdistan, once an area of prosperity and security in a war-torn nation. They prefer instead to point to numbers of putative "Al-Qaeda" killed in areas where U.S. troops are the most concentrated. They also live in a delusional scenario where Al-Qaeda is the major cause of everything wrong in Iraq, so by extension killing these putative "Al-Qaeda" will create the stability the surge was ostensibly supposed to secure. More and more clearly we are instead finding out that these "problems" are merely being pushed to other areas, such as Kurdistan. And this is called "progress", apparently.

Oh, and let's not forget that another car bomb just went off in the most heavily-patrolled city of the surge, Baghdad. Does this have any bearing on the "security situation" in Baghdad? Not to the right-wing. These bombings "tell us nothing" except that we must stay the course. It may say to Iraqis, however, that if you trust in the surge and decide to go shopping (as the current victims did) that you may very well get killed or injured. But then, how many on the right really care about the Iraqi civilians anyway? It's all about Al-Qaeda.


Car bomb kills eight people in northern Iraq's Kirkuk


Related News
Five U.S. soldiers killed in Iraq
Danish withdrawal from Iraq going quickly: officer
Gunmen storm police checkpoint in northern Iraq, kill 6
Five security members killed in northern Iraqi clash
U.S. House passes bill barring permanent bases in Iraq


Eight people were killed and more than 40 others injured in a car bomb attack in a popular market in northern Iraq's city of Kirkuk on Thursday, local police source said.

"A car bomb parking near the Abdullah Restaurant in a busy popular market in central Kirkuk detonated at about 6:00 p.m. ( 1400 GMT), killing eight people and wounded more than 40 others," the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

The blast damaged several nearby shops and buildings, the source said.

In Baghdad, another car bomb went off in the afternoon in a crowded commercial area in Karradah neighborhood, killing 20 people and wounding up to 60 others, according to the police.

The powerful blast set a nearby building on fire and destroyed several civilian cars and shops, said the police.

Source: Xinhua

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Green Zone hit by mortars again

The Green Zone is the most heavily fortified area in the country, but despite years of occupation including the current surge, it still gets attacked by mortars almost weekly. Baghdad is the ostensible focus of the surge, as well as the home of several sectarian militias that manange to torture and kill hundreds a month in the middle of a huge troop presence. So this is what $2 billion a week gets us. I think one real "sign of improvement" would be if our "embassy" would stop getting hit by mortars.

Mortar barrage hits Baghdad Green Zone



Mortar rounds landed on the heavily fortified Green Zone in Baghdad on Tuesday while the U.S. and Iranian delegations were holding a second landmark meeting over Iraq's worsening security situation, a well-informed police source said.

"Several mortar rounds landed on the Green Zone shortly after 11:00 a.m. (0800 GMT)," the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

It was not known whether there was any casualty or where exactly the rounds landed, the source said.

The attack occurred about an hour and a half after the start of the meeting of U.S. Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker and his Iranian counterpart Hassan Kazemi Qomi in the office of Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki.

The U.S. military did not confirm the incident yet.

The U.S.-controlled Green Zone is a vast area on the west bank of the Tigris River, which houses the Iraqi government offices and foreign embassies, including the U.S. embassy.

Source: Xinhua

Thursday, July 19, 2007

Signs of progress in Diyala

More 'signs of progress' from Diyala province in Iraq. The morgue can't deal with all of the bodies piling up. The solution is mass graves for the growing numbers of unidentified and unidentifiable dead. Of course, these must be Al-Qaeda that we're killing, right? After all, they are dead.
Also note that numbers reported, which are used by U.S. military commanders to show a decrease of violence, are a fraction of the actual numbers.


IRAQ: Mass Graves Dug to Deal With Death Toll
By Ahmed Ali*

BAQUBA, Jul 17 (IPS) - The largest morgue in Diyala province is overflowing daily. Officials told IPS they have had to dig mass graves to dispose of bodies.

More and more bodies of victims of the ongoing violence are being found every day in Baquba, capital city of the province, 50km northeast of Baghdad.

"The morgue receives an average of four or five bodies everyday," Nima Jima'a, a morgue official, told IPS. "Many more are dropped in rivers and farms -- or it is sometimes the case they are buried by their killers for other reasons. The number we record here is only a fraction of those killed."

Ambulances, now able to move again after weeks of restrictions, have been removing bodies of victims from the current fighting. But they have also found skulls and bones, evidence of other killings long ago.

Dealing with these remains is becoming difficult. Like the rest of the city, the morgue suffers from continuing lack of electricity. Over the last two weeks, two of its refrigerators have been shut down. The smell of decomposing bodies hits visitors 100 metres away.

Morgue officials told IPS that a local U.S. military commander recently ordered them to bury all bodies within three days.

"We got 30 bodies out of the refrigerator on Sunday, put a number on each, and put them in plastic bags provided by U.S. troops," morgue official Kareem al-Rubaee told IPS. "We asked families to have a look at the bodies. Then, they were buried collectively."

There is expected to be a need now to bury bodies collectively every 15-20 days in order keep the capacity of the refrigerator intact, al-Rubaee said.

Families are often unable to identify and collect the bodies, morgue officials say. It is still extremely dangerous to travel around the city. Also, most bodies are never brought to the morgue at all to be identified or counted.

Many victims of U.S. air strikes have been buried under the rubble of their homes for days, sometimes weeks, residents say. The military operation has been launched to target al-Qaeda, amid local reports that the operation began after the al-Qaeda suspects had fled town.

People in the town feel targeted by killings from all sides. Foreign terror groups, like those who claim to be following the model of al-Qaeda, have kidnapped many people who are never heard from again.

Groups believed to be al-Qaeda have been known to kill and then drop the body in selected places that they call "the execution zone." This is intended to show people the power of al-Qaeda.

Police vehicles and ambulances have been moving bodies mainly from such spots to the morgue.

Baquba, never anticipating such a death toll, has only a small morgue, and limited means to carry out necessary procedures.

"When a number of bodies are brought to the morgue, we take at least two photos from different angles," Mohammed Abid, another official at the morgue told IPS. "Generally, the bodies are brought without identity cards. This is a problem for the families for whom the photographs are not enough -- faces are often deformed due to torture or shooting."

The refrigerators at the morgue are packed beyond capacity, and workers narrate grisly accounts of attempts to access the bodies for identification.

"My brother's photo is in the computer, but we couldn't get the body because it was taken by another family," 52-year-old primary schoolteacher Naser Sattar told IPS. "They thought him their son because the body was deformed."

The schoolteacher added, "I went to that family and got my brother's body and then buried it."

(*Ahmed, our correspondent in Iraq's Diyala province, works in close collaboration with Dahr Jamail, our U.S.-based specialist writer on Iraq who travels extensively in the region) (END/2007)

Monday, July 16, 2007

UN: Iraqi children worse off than a year ago

Now we all know that Republicans are excruciatingly concerned with the poor Iraqi civilians. That's why we can't leave Iraq; a "bloodbath" will surely follow. But now the UN has said that lack of nutritionally sound food and access to health care is making life miserable for women and children in Iraq. Well, not the privileged few that are in Bush's pocket, but, you know, the others. A cholera epidemic may break out.
The right-wing has done a great job of bragging about how life has improved for the "average Iraqi" under the occupation.

Still, Bush is not above using apparently outdated data to push his case. Or forgetting to pay the agency the money he promised.
full story

Situation of Iraqi children is worse: UN


The situation for Iraqi children is getting worse and, in some respects, it was better before the war began, a senior UN official said yesterday.

"Children today are much worse off than they were a year ago, and they certainly are worse off than they were three years ago," said Dan Toole, director of emergency programs for the United Nations Children's Fund. He said Iraqis no longer have safe access to a government-funded food basket, established under Saddam Hussein to deal with international sanctions.

Toole said conditions for women and children in Iraq had worsened significantly since the February 2006 bombing of a Shi'ite shrine in Samarra, north of Baghdad, which triggered a wave of sectarian violence and displacement that continues today.

He added that gains made shortly after the US toppled Saddam's government in 2003, when people were able to move around the country freely and had access to food markets and health centers, had been lost.

"Nutritional indicators, health access indicators are all changing for the worse," Toole said. He said recently published data showing improvement referred to the situation a couple of years ago and is outdated.

The system of government-sponsored handouts - set up by Saddam's government to meet the basic needs of Iraqi citizens from 1991 to 2003, when the country was under UN sanctions - started to fall apart last year, Toole said.

Apart from shortages of items such as milk and baby milk formula, "the basic Iraqi food basket was fairly secure under the regime because there was food coming in and the government provided the food basket to its citizens," he said.

Toole could not say whether malnutrition has worsened significantly but he said UNICEF was concerned by reports it has received from refugees fleeing the country.

Toole said that, because of the violence, mothers were too afraid to send their children to school or take them to health centers to get checkups and nutritional supplements.

While efforts are being made to maintain levels of immunization, particularly against measles and polio, UNICEF is worried about the possibility of a cholera epidemic because two-thirds of Iraqis lack clean water. A couple of cases of cholera have been reported in the south of Iraq but so far there has been no major outbreak, Toole said.

He said the agency has so far received no government donations toward a $41.5 million appeal for its Iraq work through the second half of 2007.

Source: China Daily/agencies