Saturday, May 17, 2008

GOP staggers into oblivion

This week has seen some interesting political developments, but perhaps the most compelling is that Republicans are finally waking up from a bender and discovering that their Party is in trouble.
Two insightful posts are DailyKos regarding this are found here and here.
I would like to analyse when and why the wheels came off for the GOP, the factors that will continue to hold the Republicans back, and what this means for the Democrats and the progressives.

The first thing that must be addressed is the Republicans' disdain for reality in all its forms. When Dubya "won" election by losing the popular vote, there was no voice of reason or restraint within the GOP. Nobody in the Party leadership considered that more than half of the country opposed their agenda, their candidate, and their policies. Instead, they went full speed ahead and simply pretended that America agreed with them. After 9/11, of course, the GOP dug in to a make-believe world of their own creation. The White House bragged that they "create reality", and they removed themselves from contact with anyone who did not completely buy in to the Kool-Aid drinking world they spun out of whole cloth. The examples of this are numerous. Intelligence reports were cherry-picked and controlled to produce the "evidence" they wanted, and then this "evidence" was used to convince other Republicans of the validity of this pseudo-reality. And as Republicans moved into the sheltered confines of a Fox News/talk radio world, they were told that no other media sources could be trusted but them. The average Republican slipped into a world in which Bush was infallible, in which Bush was America, and those who disagreed with Bush must therefore "hate America". Any criticism of anything wrong in the country was dismissed as hatred of America, unless it involved blaming Democrats for whatever might putatively be "wrong". Quite simply, America was incapable of doing anything "wrong" in the Fox News-fueled world. Any facts that seemed to indicate otherwise could be rejected with a wave of the hand and the use of the magic word "America-hater".
I recall pointing out to a Republican that the U.S. actually supported Saddam during his use of chemical weapons against the Kurds, that Saddam was an ally of the U.S. for nearly a decade as a counterweight to Iran in the region, that Saddam was one of a multitude of brutal dictators that our government has backed because they are useful to our foreign policy, and that Iran was one of those dictatorships before the Shah was overthrown. All of this is well-known history for those that eschew the GOP Kool-Aid, yet it was all completely dismissed as a lie by this Republican (and several others since) based on nothing more than that my mentioning these facts proved that I "hated America", and thus was not credible. One can scarcely believe the imaginary history that Republicans carry in their heads regarding America. But I digress.

America's enchantment with the Bush Administration had already eroded substantially by 2005 when Katrina hit, but the majority still believed that Bush just had some "tough breaks" in Iraq. When the utterly inept response to New Orleans' flooding occurred, however, the spell was broken for good. Rank incompetence was revealed, gross indifference was displayed, and the country at large wondered how a guy that formerly ran a stable was put in charge of FEMA. If the GOP had taken steps then, even sham efforts, to dispel the idea that they had handed over the function of government to cronies based on ideological agreement, then we likely would be having a different conversation today. Instead, the Republicans denied any failure. They pointed the finger at the Louisiana state government, at Mayor Nagin, at the public for treasonous dissent, the treacherous media, and at the victims themselves. Eventually, "Brownie" was to become a human sacrifice and the only thing that the GOP learned was that incompetence must be covered up better. Secrecy was increased, "disloyal" elements were purged from government jobs, wagons were circled, and the Republican world view became even more firmly entrenched in a "with us or against us" mindset. No longer were we all Americans; we were either traitors or patriots. The "good news" and "progress" in Iraq flowed from the White House on a daily basis, in stark contrast to the undeniable facts that indicated a quagmire without a clear-cut triumph that Americans had truly believed would have occurred by then. And the pseudo-reality that was intravenously fed to the faithful spoke of a brilliant success in Iraq, a popular President that could do no wrong, and darkly hinted at a tiny number of domestic traitors who wanted to destroy America and that were universally reviled, except by terrorists.

The 2006 elections were merely the buzzing of a gnat within the ironclad fortress of the Republican pseudo-reality. Everyone loved them and believed in them, anything they said would be eagerly lapped up by the nation without examination, and the only "problem" was that some RINOs had been taken out of power. Prior to the 2004 election, Republicans had been locked into a perpetual time warp where it was always 1994. After the 2006 elections, they moved in lockstep to a newer false world where it is always 2002, in which they exist today.

This is why I point to polls so frequently in this blog. Republicans really, truly believe they are still wildly popular. And while Republicans dismiss polls (as they do anything that contradicts the pseudo-reality) by saying "polls go up and polls go down", the reality is that those numbers simply are not going up for them. Republican turnout in the primaries has been a pale shadow of the Democrats' numbers, and the number of people identifying themselves as Republicans has dropped while those of Democrats' is increasing to record levels. The GOP agenda has been reduced to an obstructionist campaign, Bush is ignored by world leaders and the domestic public, and elections simply aren't going their way.

For an example of the severity of this Republican disconnect with reality, see the take on McCain's recent speech shown below. McCain posited an imaginary world in 2013 in which America has "won" in Iraq, and Republicans seem to have lapped it up as if it were actually true and a foregone conclusion.

Nice move Mac. In one fell swoop, he exposes the anti-war left for what they are: Pacifist appeasers who don't believe troops should be sent anywhere, anytime, for any reason. They will be left bleating on deaf ears about bringing troops home now.
Normal Americans support military action against America's enemies as long as the cause is just and the exit strategy is known. They are patient and they can live with a date, even if it is 5 years down the road. Before today, McCain was saddled with the perception of a perpetual war combined with the scurrilous 100-years-in-Iraq lie by the left. Unaddressed, that is a deal breaker for McCain at the ballot box. No longer.
The nice part is that he can assess as he goes and decide in 2013, if he wins a second term, whether that is the prudent course at that time.
In the meantime, he has just grabbed a pile of moderate, war-weary Democrats right out of the D column.
Bill Dupray at The Patriot Room


Wow.
Yes, this is what America has been waiting for: A man who has the courage to invent an imaginary world in which Republicans are always right.
Polls show that 33% of Americans want us to withdraw from Iraq now, and the clear majority want us out in one year. However, these must not be "Normal Americans", in Mr. Dupray's view. McCain imagines that we will "win" in Iraq within five years, so it's a done deal, apparently.
Just wondering, though...what if things don't turn out like they do in McCain's imagination? Won't he keep us in Iraq? I mean, Bush had some pretty neat imaginary scenarios, too, but here we are still "surging" along. How is this supposed to appeal to "a pile of moderate war-weary Democrats"? McCain simply imagines that there will only be five more years of a war that the majority of Americans already feel was a mistake, a war that only 19% say that they're looking for a candidate that
is willing to pursue until we "succeed", so obviously McCain has the election in the bag. The Decider imagined that the "surge" would put the Iraqi government in control of all the provinces by last November, but that didn't seem to induce giddiness or a massive increase in support for Republicans or the occupation. But now McCain is imagining some stuff, so it's all different, right?
By the way, take a look at this analysis of why McCain's imaginary victory is unlikely.

In the very odd world that Republicans have constructed, merely predicting something means that it will happen. I often laughed over right-wing bloggers who quoted military commanders saying that a campaign has the objective to do such-and-such, and then crowing over it as if this means it has already happened or is inevitable. To doubt such statements is the equivalent of doubting America itself in their minds.

There was a time, a relatively brief time, in which Americans felt unified by the Iraq invasion and cheered unquestioningly like football fans for the "home team", but that time has passed and the buzz has worn off. This doesn't mean that people "hate America", but it does mean that invoking 9/11 and shoving flags and eagles in our faces won't gain much traction any more. Such jingoistic, spectator-sport approaches require big, quick wins with clearly-defined "good guys" and "bad guys". The Long War model never held significant appeal to Americans, and Republicans only pulled it out as 'what they said all along' only after hopes for a big, quick win had already faded. It came off as bait and switch, and we felt deceived. Republicans only offered charges of treason to keep the restless in line. To most, the threat of being "dumped" by Republicans, of being exiled from the Cool Kids Club, of failing to make the grade as a good Decider-droid was toothless and spiteful.

Look, Republicans, it's this simple: nobody believes you any more.
Pelosi and Reid really aren't hated and reviled by the American people. Nobody but you believes that advocating withdrawal from Iraq means that they favour the destruction of America or that they oppose any war for any reason or that they want us all to become Muslims. Nobody but you thinks that the word "liberal" has magical powers to silence dissent. Nobody but you believes that the majority of the country is part of the "Far Left". Nobody but you thinks that it's more important to be loyal to the Bush Administration than it is to admit the existence of problems and deal with them. Nobody but you thinks that dissent against a Republican President is treason, but that dissent against a Democratic President is your patriotic duty.

The GOP has offered America a team of droids that back their Party over the interests of their own constituents. That's a losing proposition in politics. Nobody cares if a candidate is a good Bush Team player or is "on board" with the Party agenda. Merely stating that a candidate fails to support the GOP talking points simply does not disqualify a candidate in the eyes of the American electorate.
It would be really nice if you all continued to believe these things, however, because it will discredit your Party for a good, long time. Please, please keep on pointing to a picture of a Democrat, saying the word "liberal", and expecting to win big. Please keep on saying that Iraq is about making us safer at home. Please keep on telling us that protecting telecoms from lawsuits is the same as fighting terrorists. And please keep on portraying Bush as an infallible genius that only the "Far Left" disagrees with.

It is true that the three special elections in which Republicans have recently lost to Democrats are not astoundingly good news for progressives. These are conservative Democrats. However, those are three robots that won't be in Congress playing obstructionist games at the orders of the GOP. Those are three districts in which voters will presumably learn that casting a ballot for a Democrat doesn't mean that the world will end. Those are three examples that will be lurking in the back of every Republican Congressman's mind when the Party tells them to do something against their own electoral interests. And those are three cases that will come to mind when a Democrat in Congress thinks about caving to the GOP.

The elections in November will prove to everyone outside of the Republican pseudo-reality that the traditional "fear and smear" tactics don't work any more. Even Republicans that hold on to their seats will see the margins dwindle enough to make a bolt from the lockstep march of the Party dictates seem viable. Obstructionism will no longer be glamorous, and Republicans will have to come up with something other than hatred and a police-state fear-mongering. The Evangelical Christians are already peeling away, along with veterans and fiscal conservatives. The Party will have to stand for something more than "We Hate The Democrats". And the Republican dictate that "you're either all in or all out" will have to be abandoned.

Saturday, May 10, 2008

The end of the ride

For well over six months now, polls have shown that Iraq remains a millstone around the neck of the GOP. Surely, this was also the case prior to six months ago, but the Republican Noise Machine has been confident that the public opinion will "turn around" once the "facts are out" about the wonderful "progress" in Iraq. Those trend lines in the polls shown below are not encouraging, however.

The majority think the invasion of Iraq was a mistake.
The ramifications of this are profound. This means that the entire idea of Iraq being part of the Global War On Terror, the notion that we are over there to keep them from coming over here, the idea that invading Iraq has made us safer, and the assertions that only the "Far Left" holds these views have all been discredited. To deny this would mean that the majority of Americans support terrorism, are trying to militarily undermine their own country, are looking for bold new ways to make us less safe, and are part of the "Far Left". For the Republicans, the message on Iraq has essentially been reduced to "we're stuck there, so get over it".

Only 19% think it's important that their Presidential candidiate is willing to stay in Iraq until we "succeed", whatever "success" is.
Again, the ramifications of these numbers are significant. The "cut and run" talisman no longer bears weight when over 3/4 of the voters see a willingness to be flexible and leave before we have achieved "success" as desirable in Presidential candidate. McCain's "hundred years" statement, regardless of the context it is put in, clearly puts him on the 19% side. We are now in Iraq to influence whether puppet leaders or Iraqi nationalists will control the country. Nothing about that speaks of any "vital interests" for the U.S. Nothing about that inspires any desire to "kick some butt" or "bring 'em on". Nothing about that lends credence to a willingness to spend $12 billion a week on a military effort to bring about a foreign country's political reconciliation. Pictures of flags and eagles, accusations of treason, and scary stories now fail to suspend the critical thinking skills of the American electorate. The public wants an exit strategy, and the Republicans are only offering a quagmire that may or may not, at some point, become a basically "break even" scenario.

A third of the public wants to withdraw from Iraq, and only about 20% want to continue the "surge".
Apparently 33% of the nation is now part of the "Far Left", because Republicans keep telling us that only the "Far Left" wants to pull out of Iraq. The public, however, continues to see people who are clearly not traitorous nor wild-eyed leftists advocating withdrawal or drawing down force levels. Reality is not on the side of the GOP propaganda masters. Military commanders have stated that we will need to send more troops, not fewer, if we are to achieve "success", yet this option now draws only 8% support. Americans clearly no longer want to "win" in Iraq - or more accurately, no longer believe in what the Republicans consider a "win".

All three of these polls point to Iraq as a serious liability for the GOP, yet the Party has steadfastly lined up behind the most unpopular President in modern history and that Party's presumptive nominee has completely embraced that unpopular President's policies on Iraq. The GOP's traditional alliance with evangelical Christians is also highly questionable, with it being increasingly likely that these voters will choose to sit on their hands come November. A faltering economy is always bad news for the incumbent Party, and the Republicans are split between trying to come up with more and more bizarre ways to define the word "recession" or those who wish to continue to push tax cuts that have proven a failure. 80% of the public believes that the economic stimulus cheques will not make much difference. The percentages of the electorate who believe that upper-income citizens and corporations pay too much in taxes is in the single digits. People all across the country have seen the result of the Bush tax cuts: collapsing infrastructure, income inequality, offshoring jobs, and declines in the educational system. McCain only wants to continue this failed policy.

And the model of governance that the GOP has pushed has increasingly been the object of ridicule. Across the board, citizens have seen gross incompetence and total cronyism from the federal government. Turning over the government responsibilities to people based on their loyalty to the Bush agenda has turned out to be a huge failure. Staggering inefficiency and naked partisanship is the order of the day. Do you think anyone trying to get a passport really cares if the people processing it are opposed to Roe v. Wade or if they have a close personal relationship with Jesus? Do you think that anyone waiting for disaster relief is consoled by the fact the morons that bungled the job are reliable GOP donors? Does anyone who witnessed Doan's "memory problems" really think that's understandable if she was a loyal supporter of the President?
Not really. People want their tax dollars spent wisely by competent people acting in an efficient manner. Whether or not they have sworn unending loyalty to the most unpopular President in modern history is not high on the public's list of priorities. Yet McCain has said nothing in criticism of the rank incompetence Bush has cultivated. In fact, McCain is completely beholden to the Party apparatus that thrust loyalty as the primary consideration in the federal government. Morale among federal employees has plummeted, recruiting competent staff has become difficult, and retaining them even harder. At the same time, the value of having a Bush Administration position on your resume has dwindled. It marks one as an incompetent crony that was hired and retained based not on merit and skills, but rather ideological purity.

McCain has failed to say anything that he would do differently than Bush. Not one thing.

The sleeper issue, however, are House and Senate races. The Democrats can expect big gains in the House, and possibly three or four seats gained in the Senate. Republicans that do hold on to their seats will see their margins of victory dwindle alarmingly. Those not up for election until 2010 will surely see that loyalty to the Bush agenda is nothing more than a suicide pact. Already we are seeing one-size-fits-all "cookie-cutter" ads from the GOP. Just replace the face and the name, and these generic ads could run in any district. Democrats, too, are seeing the potential to be had by standing up to the Republican agenda. The next President will certainly find a Congress much less compliant to traditional Republican talking points and much less responsive to scare themes. GOP intimidation of the media will also become more difficult as it becomes readily apparent that the punditry is seriously out of touch with the reality within the country.

A smaller percentage of the public now believes in the Bush agenda than believes in the existence of magical fairies, yet we don't see pundits weighing in on how magical fairies come down on the issues of the day. No network considers how magical fairies will react to a news story or if magical fairies are sufficiently patriotic. I have yet to see a news anchor ponder over whether a national issue is "good news or not for magical fairies". We have, however, seen Republican policies that essentially rely on copious amounts of fairy dust to solve problems.

Nothing is improving for Republicans in public opinion. Jingoism now shows diminishing returns. The war that was supposed to unite America and guarantee a permanent Republican majority has now become a permanent liability for the Party that even "victory" will not mitigate. Self-identification as a Democrat has reached an all-time high. And if the Republicans lose the White House, the gravy train for right-wing think tanks, crooked contractors, and hate-mongers will come to an end.

Results from a CBS/NYT poll are shown below:

"Looking back, do you think the United States did the right thing in taking military action against Iraq, or should the U.S. have stayed out?" N=1,065 adults, MoE ± 3






.


Right Thing Stayed Out Unsure


% % %


4/25-29/08
37 57 6

3/28 - 4/2/08
34 62 4


3/15-18/08
36 59 5


2/20-24/08
38 58 4

1/9-12/08
36 58 6

12/5-9/07
41 54 5

10/12-16/07
45 51 4

9/14-16/07
39 53 8

----------------------------------------------------

"Which is more important to you in a presidential candidate: someone who commits to staying in Iraq until the U.S. succeeds, or someone who is flexible about when to withdraw U.S. troops from Iraq?" N=956 registered voters, MoE ± 3






.


Commits to
Staying
Flexible Unsure


% % %


4/25-29/08
19 77 4


Also from a CNN poll:

"Which comes closest to your view about what the U.S. should now do about the number of U.S. troops in Iraq? The U.S. should send more troops to Iraq. The U.S. should keep the number of troops as it is now. The U.S. should withdraw some troops from Iraq. OR, The U.S. should withdraw all of its troops from Iraq."





.



Send More Keep Same
Number
Withdraw
Some
Withdraw
All
Unsure


% % % % %


4/28-30/08
8 21 35 33 3


12/6-9/07
10 19 30 39 2


9/7-9/07
10 23 36 29 3


6/22-24/07
17 16 24 39 3


11/17-19/06
16 21 27 33 3


10/27-29/06
15 17 28 34 6

Thursday, May 01, 2008

The Decider is decidely unpopular

Yet another data point in the past few years demonstrating the "buyer's remorse" of Bush's election; he's now the most unpopular President in modern history. More unpopular than Nixon.

Narrowly re-elected (49/51) largely due to the public's perceived "success" in Iraq, Bush steadily declined in popularity throughout his second term. Despite achieving record high approval numbers after 9/11, his numbers also slid fitfully downward in his first term. Of those who approve of him, previous polls have shown those who strongly support him are few; his support his soft. While Bush has stagnated in the low 30's to high 20's for well over a year now, what has changed now is the numbers of those who disapprove of him. Apparently fewer people are taking the "no opinion" option in polls and have moved into the "disapprove" column.

Certainly a good deal of this recent decline has had to do with the economy. While Bush may or may not be able to do anything instantly to improve things, it's highly doubtful that his recent optimistic remarks are reassuring to those facing economic troubles. Spending $12 billion per week in Iraq hasn't seemed to help things, either. And playing semantics with the definition of "recession" hardly encourages confidence. The Administration clearly thought that the house of cards created by the housing bubble would hold up until Bush left office, and the downturn could be blamed on the Democrats. Chalk this up as yet another of Bush's overly-optimistic assessments that was not borne out by reality.

I am sometimes asked, "What is wrong with optimism?". Nothing, per se. The question is the context it is in. If you are on the sinking Titanic and the captain is smiling and making assurances that everything is okay while the chilly water swirls around your ankles, then that is a case where optimism is unwarranted and even dangerous. If, after Pearl Harbour, the U.S. had sent it's entire (depleted) fleet into an invasion of the Japanese homeland by a President optimistic that everything would go our way, the loss to our country would have been staggering. It is not really leadership to consider only the best possible outcome in every scenario and simply assume that the best possible outcome will be the actual outcome. Any idiot can cross their fingers, twirl a rabbit's foot, and knock on wood, hoping for the best. Any moron can "double down", confident that a big win is due. Yet this is more or less what the Administration has done in regards to Iraq, Afghanistan, the economy, Katrina, global warming, and an array of other problems. And when things don't work out to be the best possible outcome, the Administration has simply blamed the critics for not believing in America. Clapping for Peter Pan may have been a good option in a children's fictional tale, but it simply is not sound policy for running a country.

What is striking, however, is that the major media has completely failed to grasp that Bush has lost the confidence of the American people. His optimistic pronouncements of Middle East peace, "victory" in Iraq, and imminent economic improvement are breathlessly gushed over by the media as ironclad guarantees that we can take to the bank. Even now we see a Republican presidential candidate that merely promises more of Bush's policies, and this is portrayed as sound, new, and visionary by the media. The voters have already come to the realisation that one can believe in America while refusing to believe in Bush, but the media seems to have failed to make this logical connection.

Bush's only "plan", such as it is, to deal with the economic downturn is to offer more tax cuts. This has failed miserably. The economic day of reckoning has been put off for years by the housing bubble, which has nothing to do with tax cuts. The money from the tax cuts simply has not been invested in America, simply has not created jobs, simply has not "trickled down". Instead, it's gone into overseas investments, offshoring jobs, companies that exist only on paper and employ no one, or just tossed on to the pile with the rest of the money. Once again, the best possible outcome has not turned out to be the actual outcome.


story from CNN:

May 1, 2008
Poll: Bush most unpopular in modern history
Posted: 02:30 PM ET

WASHINGTON (CNN) — A new poll suggests that George W. Bush is the most unpopular president in modern American history.

A CNN/Opinion Research Corporation survey released Thursday indicates that 71 percent of the American public disapprove of how Bush his handling his job as president.

"No president has ever had a higher disapproval rating in any CNN or Gallup poll; in fact, this is the first time that any president's disapproval rating has cracked the 70 percent mark," said CNN Polling Director Keating Holland.

"Bush's approval rating, which stands at 28 percent in our new poll, remains better than the all-time lows set by Harry Truman and Richard Nixon (22 percent and 24 percent, respectively) but even those two presidents never got a disapproval rating in the 70s," Holland added. "The previous all-time record in CNN or Gallup polling was set by Truman, 66 percent disapproval in January 1952."

CNN Senior Political Analyst Bill Schneider adds, "He is more unpopular than Richard Nixon was just before he resigned from the presidency in August 1974." President Nixon's disapproval rating in August 1974 stood at 67 percent.

The poll also indicates that support for the war in Iraq has never been lower. Thirty percent of those questioned favored the war while 68 percent opposed the conflict.

"Americans are growing more pessimistic about the war," Holland said. "In January, nearly half believed that things were going well for the U.S. in Iraq; now that figure has dropped to 39 percent."

The numbers on the Iraq war come on the five-year anniversary of President Bush's "mission accomplished" moment onboard the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln, when Bush proclaimed that "major combat operations in Iraq have ended."

The record low support for the war in a CNN poll could be one reason behind the president's unpopularity, but it probably is not the only one.

"Support for the war, the assessment of the economy and approval of Mr. Bush are all about the same — bad," Schneider said.

The CNN/Opinion Research Corporation poll was conducted by telephone from Monday through Wednesday, with 1,008 adult Americans questioned. The poll's sampling error is plus or minus 3 percentage points.

Sunday, March 30, 2008

The Sunday Eel Pout


Here in Minnesota, the ice is now too thin to risk one's life for a fish, and too thick to get a boat out, so it's fortunate that I can take one of my reserve eel pouts from the deep-freeze for this week's award. My wonderful revamped PC is still in a local shop, so I am using a borrowed laptop to briefly and hurriedly bestow a reconstituted eel pout on some hapless but deserving victim.

This week's candidates are as follows:

  • Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina proved once again this week that the Republican leadership is completely and hopelessly clueless when it comes to Iraq. As he explained on Fox News regarding the battle over Basra, "Now we have a battle with militias who are operating outside the government. … We must win this fight. The militias that we are fighting are backed by Iran. So this is an effort by Iran to destabilize Iraq." Sen. Graham must not have read his scorecard. The facts are that the Iraqi government's biggest ally is the Badr Corps, the militia of the Supreme Islamic Council (ISCI), which is the most pro-Iranian of all of the militias in Iraq. The Sadrists are the least Iranian-influenced major Shia militia in Iraq. If the Iraqi government succeeds in crushing the Mahdi Army, it will be a major boost for Iranian interests in the country. Nearly everything that the Administration has done in Iraq, from removing the secular Hussein regime that was absolutely hostile to Iran, to pushing elections despite a Sunni boycott that resulted in an overwhelming Shia win, to failing at economic reconstruction that left Iranian religious charities as a lifeline for poor Iraqis, has only increased the profile of Iran within Iraq and within the region. Now Sen. Graham is essentially proposing, as ThinkProgress puts it, "we must defeat militias backed by Iran by siding with a militia backed by Iran". Such idiocy deserves a fresh eel pout.

  • Karl Rove, in an interview on Fox News, with O'Reilly explains what's at stake in Iraq. Victory in Iraq "will rally the Muslim world to us. It will also create a huge influence in the Middle East. Think about the creation of the democracy in the historic center of the Middle East with the third-largest oil reserves in the world. If we have a functioning democracy in Iraq, that's an ally in the war on terror, a counterweight to mullahs Iran and to Assad in Syria, this will create a very hopeful center of reform and energy for reform throughout the Middle East." Oh Karl, stop. Democracy in the Middle East would be a terrible thing for our foreign policy, as sad as that may sound. I realise that the conventional wisdom is that democracy always creates pro-American governments, but that really is not the case, especially in the Middle East. The governments in the Middle East, whether monarchs or dictators, are far more sympathetic to our interests and far more pliable to our will than the people of those countries. Democracy in Iraq has created a pro-Iranian state in what once was Iran's greatest nemesis. Democracy in Iran, however limited it is, brought Ahmedinejad to power. The royalty in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States are the lid on radical Islam, not the engine. Public opinion throughout the Arab and Persian world toward Israel is much more negative than the governments in those countries. What would really "rally the Muslim world to us" would be to stop shoveling $12 million each day into Israel, stop using them as our regional proxy, and stop defending everything they do.
  • President Bush, who called the violent breakdown in Basra a "byproduct of the success" of the surge, and a "very positive moment". Al-Maliki's now-stalled effort in Basra also apparently "shows the progress the Iraqi security forces have made during the surge." That's why American special forces, along with the British, are helping on the ground and in the air: because the Iraqi Army has made so much progress that they still need our help. And as usual, any development only serves to confirm that we must maintain the surge. Iraqi government "standing up"? We have to maintain the surge to support them. Violence from the Basra conflict spreading to other areas of Iraq? We have to maintain the surge because security is so bad. Casualties up? Maintain the surge or things will get worse. Casualties down? Maintain the surge or the security gains will disappear. Notice also that the Administration isn't talking about Al-Qaeda anymore, which has been the big threat in Bush's mind for a year now. Before the surge, the militias were the big threat, and the surge would disarm them. When the surge failed at that, it was Al-Qaeda that was the big threat, and militias were benign. Now we're in Iraq to stop the militias, but only certain militias, because that's the problem like they said all along.
Ah, such idiocy. They all deserve eel pouts, at least. But there can be only one.
The winner of Minnesota's absolutely unwanted, utterly uncoveted, dismally appropriate, shudder-inspiring, and completely ignominious Sunday Eel Pout is... Karl Rove for his dimwitted claim that victory in Iraq will spread democracy, and that that would mean a pro-U.S. Middle East. If you think it's disgusting now, just wait until it thaws out. Perhaps the awarding of this eel pout can finally bring the Arab world together in agreement that Karl Rove is a jackass.

That's all for this Sunday's Eel Pout Award. Thanks to my neighbour for the laptop loan. I am fairly confident that my new machine will running in the week ahead, and this blog will be restored.

Saturday, March 29, 2008

Stunning "progress" in Iraq

Just a quick take on the Iraqi situation before I have to return my neighbour's laptop.

Al-Maliki is becoming the Iraqi version of Bush. He threw his Army into Basra with almost no planning and no intelligence. Who could have predicted that armoured vehicles couldn't penetrate the narrow streets of Basra? Who knew that the Basra police would desert and mutiny when it's been clear for years that they are infiltrated by the militias? Who could have possibly anticipated that the conflict would spread to other cities, or that the Army's supply lines would be harried?

Months after announcing a "decisive" battle against a nebulously-defined enemy in the northern part of the country, nothing has taken place that is any different than the routine 'indecisive' efforts of the past. Days after personally overseeing the Basra operation and making a three-day ultimatum (without mentioning the ensuing consequences), Al-Maliki then withdrew far away from the fighting and announced an additional week before the ultimatum would expire and he would then...do what, exactly?

Far from proving the Iraqi Army's "readiness", the week's unfolding scenario only illustrates Al-Maliki's readiness to follow the Administration's orders. American troops have already begun participating, and we have been providing air support for the Basra operation nearly from the start. With discontent growing among the Sunni Sahwa ("Awakening") forces, some of the Sahwa forces are going on strike to protest not being paid. If the continuation of this conflict weakens the Iraqi government's hold on other areas, we could very see our "Awakening" buddies take advantage of the situation and reject the Shia government's control of predominantly Sunni districts. The Sahwa are in this to wipe out the rival gangs, not to bolster the Iraqi government, and the government has not only failed to pay them, but it has actively moved against Sunni interests. And the longer this expensive operation continues, the longer the government loses crucial oil revenue from Basra. This could turn out to be major financial setback on top of a potentially demoralising defeat for the Iraqi government.

How can this be considered any less than a civil war? The Shia government of Al-Maliki has as its strongest ally the (Iranian-inspired) Badr Corps, and the Iraqi Army (along with the Badr Corps) are taking out their primary domestic opposition. The potential ascendance of ISCI can only increase the profile of Iran within Iraq. Just as the removal of Saddam from power took away the strongest check on Iran's regional power, this action by the Iraqi government will, if successful, only reinforce Iran's influence in the region.

Baghdad is also coming apart, and the mortar attacks on the Green Zone are not only much more intense, but have also resulted in casualties. 31 districts within Baghdad are now seeing clashes with Sadrist forces.

The Iraqi minister of defense, Abdul Qadir Jasim, admitted in a news conference in Basra that the militiamen had taken the Iraqi security forces off guard. He added that the Iraqi government had expected this operation to be routine, but was surprised at the level of resistance, and was forced to change its plans and tactics.

Does the above sound familiar? All that we need now is for Al-Maliki to start using terms like "turning the corner" and we'll know for sure that Cheney left his script there. We now have Turkish troops in Kurdistan, the Diyala "pacification is stalled, as is the Anbar reconstruction, progress in Baghdad has been set back, and the Basra conflict has spread to four new cities; this is "good news" to the Decider.

McCain really intends to campaign on the "progress" in Iraq?

Drink up, lads! The GOP is coming to town!

Now that the St. Paul Police Dept. has stocked up on hundreds of new tasers in anticipation of the GOP National Convention here this summer, the next step is too loosen up the liquor laws. Now the Legislature is looking at 4 AM as the last call, and allowing liquor stores to stay open on Sunday, but only during the Convention.

Currently, selected bars are allowed to sell until 2 AM, and all liquor stores across the State are closed on Sunday. Extensive empirical research that I have conducted shows that both Republicans and Democrats have managed to get drunk just fine under the current law. Ironically, it is the Republican legislators that have always fought to restrict bar hours and liquor store sales. Now, the Party of family values needs to be able to drink until 4 AM and pick up a bottle on Sunday to keep that buzz going. That's what "sophisticated" people do, after all.

Perhaps Garrison Keillor was correct when he surmised that, "Republicans seem to need alcohol to maintain their beliefs".

The Twin Cities hosts hundreds of conventions each year, and one must think that these include 'sophisticated' people. Why does this particular convention need special liquor laws? And a ten mile radius from the convention is really quite broad. Are there really that many delegates that will need to drink between 2 and 4 AM that we need hundreds of places for them to do it in? Even all of the way out to Bloomington? And if so, don't the local Republicans deserve the same opportunity to be 'sophisticated' year-round? It should be interesting how many of the neighbourhood working-class bars that Republican delegates would be unlikely to frequent will take advantage of this temporary relaxation of the laws.


story from The Minnesota Monitor

Under an amendment proposed by Rep. Phyllis Kahn, bars in St. Paul and parts of Minneapolis and Bloomington would remain open until 4 a.m. between Aug. 29 and Sept. 8 to accommodate the Republican National Convention.
The amendment to a state appropriations bill would allow late night bar sales within a ten mile radius of the RNC, and would allow for liquor stores to stay open on Sunday throughout the period. Kahn says the amendment is offered to make Minneapolis-St. Paul more "sophisticated" while the Republicans, media and protesters are in town.
The bill would also provide local liquor licensing boards to reject the later bar hours and extended liquor store operations.
The bill was passed by the State Government Finance Division Committee on Wednesday.
A similar Senate bill was withdrawn shortly after being offered earlier this month.

Sunday, March 23, 2008

disaster

It is with great frustration that I once again announce that this blog is still on hold, with a special shout out to Microsoft "support" this week. After struggling with the rebuild of my PC myself, then a clueless, incompetent local tech shop that moved at a glacial pace, my machine was actually up and running for a little more than a day on Friday. I was far too busy re-installing apps to blog, but a completely minor issue came up and I decided to take advantage of Microsoft technical support, since the previously mentioned tech shop was mysteriously closed for the holiday weekend.

Three hours later, the Microsoft bozo had managed to turn a minor irritant into a full-blown disaster, wiping out weeks of progress before abandoning me to my own devices. Microsoft's ever-dubious technical support has two priorities, by my experience. The first is to make absolutely sure that the person they are dealing with does not have a pirated copy of Windows. Since they cannot be absolutely sure of this over the phone, they are perpetually suspicious. A full 20 minutes was spent grilling me over the details of my installation in order to determine if I was trying to pull a "fast one" on them. None of these details were passed on the hapless bozo designated to "help" me. The second priority is to come with some kind of pretext to dismiss the support request altogether. I was required to list all of the applications I had installed, spelling out most of them, and each of these were completely unfamiliar to my support bozo. "Winamp?", the clown repeated again and again, as if the name somehow translated into "disaster" in his native tongue. Somehow, the implication is that, if you install anything else beyond the OS, then you are some kind of "wise guy". After uninstalling everything except Firefox, which mysteriously would not uninstall (but worked perfectly), and wiping out everything (including the OS) in a "repair" effort, I was told that my new hard drive (two weeks old, high-end, and the least likely thing to cause a problem) was trash. Until I replaced it, Microsoft technical support could not "help" me any further.

A mistaken attempt to modify a Windows component in a working, stable system had brought me into the clutches of Microsoft technical support, which had left me with a useless machine and a preposterous pretext.

So, I post this from a neighbour's machine. I will take my newly-rebuilt PC back to the clueless and glacially-slow shop, and they will restore it at a snail's pace. And Extemporaneous Discourse will once again rise from the digital ashes. Eel pouts will be awarded, Republican idiocy will be exposed, and all will be well again.

Sunday, March 09, 2008

Down but not out

I still haven't managed to get my new PC up and running, so Extemporaneous Discourse will remain in stasis for several more days.

Monday, March 03, 2008

downtime

I am rebuilding/upgrading my PC this week, so there will be no new posts.

Saturday, March 01, 2008

Violence up in Iraq

As Senate Republicans prepare to shill for the surge again, this doesn't come as good news: more Iraqis are getting killed.

Combined with the "setback" over provincial elections, it could get tougher for those eager to crow about "progress" in Iraq. The Iraqi occupation has actually made the terrorism threat worse.

On top of that, the surge cannot really be credited with any "improvement", as John Cole points out:

McCain argues that violence is down in 17 of 18 provinces. That argument itself suggests the irrelevancy of the US to Iraq. There are no US troops to speak of in the 3 northern Kurdish provinces, or in the southern 4 provinces from which the British have largely withdrawn. There are few US troops in most of the 8 provinces where Shiites predominate. There was no troop escalation or "surge" in the Sunni al-Anbar province. So if violence has declined in 17 of 18 provinces, US policy cannot possibly have anything to do with most of that. General Petraeus has had significant successes in Baghdad, though at the unfortunate (an unintentional) cost of further turning it into a Shiite city from which most Sunnis have been ethnically cleansed.

So the areas that are the most stable are the areas where we have no or very few troops, but an increase in troops is supposed to have produced a decline in violence. Baghdad is a walled city that has been ethnically cleansed, so secatrian conflict naturally has gone down. Fallujah has banned all motor vehicles in the city for over a year, so no car bombings. This is "progress"? It's like banning cars and then taking credit for safer driving habits by pointing to a decline in car accidents.

Of course, Turkey is currently in the process of invading Kurdistan, which is hardly a sign of a stable Iraq. Basra, too, is controlled by the militias, not the Iraqi government. But it's stable, so that supposedly is a mark in favour of the surge. How is that?

The American public thought that by now the surge would be over and we would be talking about withdrawal. Instead, the surge will likely continue for the remainder of Bush's term. The Republicans are setting themselves up by presenting a rosy picture in Iraq, especially since the tensions between the "Awakening" forces and the Iraqi government are building. It's a dangerous bid, and senators up for re-election will be forced into making supportive statements that could turn against them in the months approaching the election.

story from AFP
Iraq violence surges in February

by Salam Faraj Sat Mar 1, 4:55 AM ET

BAGHDAD (AFP) - The number of Iraqis killed in February rose by 33 percent over January, reversing a six-month trend of reduced violence, in a setback to the US military plan to curb the bloodshed ravaging the country.

The combined figures obtained by AFP from the interior, defence and health ministries showed that the total number of Iraqis killed in February was 721, including 636 civilians, compared with 541 dead in January.

It reverses the six-month trend of a steady fall in casualties across the country on the back of a massive US and Iraqi military assault, mainly targeting Al-Qaeda in Iraq.

The February death toll is up after a steady fall in the preceding six months. The monthly tolls were 541 in January, 568 in December, 606 in November, 887 in October, 917 in September and 1,856 in August.

The number of people wounded in February was 847.

January's death toll reached a 23-month low, with US commanders saying that all types of attacks were down to levels not seen before the February 2006 bombing of a Shiite shrine in the town of Samarra that triggered a wave of violence.

The bloodshed that erupted after the shrine attack peaked in January 2007 with 1,992 deaths reported by the three ministries.

The jump in February's toll seems to have been caused by two major attacks during the month.

On February 1, at least 98 people were slaughtered when a female suicide bomber blew herself up amid a crowd of pet lovers in Baghdad's popular al-Ghazl animal market.

And in another brazen attack last Sunday, at least 48 people were killed when a suicide bomber blew himself up in a crowd of pilgrims at a rest stop in the town of Iskandiriyah, south of Baghdad.

Coleman continues to slide in polls

Norm Coleman, the incumbent Republican Senator for Minnesota and extraordinary political chameleon, is again riding low in the polls. A little over four years ago, Coleman was at a 52% favourablity level. Since then, he's been struggling to keep his head above the crucial 50% mark. The latest poll puts him at 49%.

The results fall pretty much along partisan lines: 70% of those who feel terrorism is the top issue support Coleman, 69% of Republicans like him, 67% of evangelicals give him the thumbs-up, and he wins over 72% of those who call themselves conservative. Those would be nice numbers for a Republican primary, but for a general election it looks less sunny. Norm never won a majority in the 2002 election that brought him to power, only a plurality. He has weak support (44%) from Independents and those who call themselves moderates (46%).

At first the classic Bush Team crony, Coleman voted with the Administration 98% of the time in his first year. As the shine began to come off Bush later on, Coleman struck poses to show some space between himself and Bush. He voted against the surge, but has completely fallen into line with the GOP on every vote to change the policies on Iraq. Formerly a pot-smoking, anti-war liberal Democrat, Coleman changed his stripes and jumped ship in 1996. Since then, his positions have shifted with the political wind. He endorsed Giuliani and bought in to all of the crazy, hyper-fear, eternal war, Muslim-hating rhetoric of that campaign. Then the breeze shifted, and he was all about McCain. He is now irrevocably tied to the Bush agenda, and as McCain increasingly embraces Bush in order to manufacture some kind of GOP consensus, Coleman will be forced to return to his role as a Bush crony with all of the attendant unpopularity that such a designation brings. Norm isn't an idiot; he knows that the tide has turned against him. He now has no choice, however, but to make another shift into a diehard GOP stalwart.

Meanwhile, the more-recently (2006) elected Democratic Senator, Amy Klobuchar, enjoys a strong 61% approval rating. She has strong support from moderates (71%) and wins over 58% of Independents. She also has strong support in outstate Minnesota, while Norm has barely a majority there. The message to take away from this is that the senator who rejects the Bush agenda is considerably more popular than the senator that has bound himself, hand and foot, to that GOP agenda. So while Norm is not exactly reviled, he is pushing a weaker message than the Democrats.

As I said before, Coleman gets his strong support from Republicans and those that call themselves conservatives. However, Republicans are only 27% of the state and conservatives are only 26%. Evangelicals are only one-third of the state, and those who consider terrorism as the most important issue are only 7% of those polled. Coleman's strong support comes from the margins of the electorate. Any sane candidate in Coleman's position would make a sharp shift to the centre, but instead conditions have forced Coleman to move even farther to the right. This also does not bode well for this seat to remain in Reublican hands.

Thursday, February 28, 2008

Iraqi "breakthroughs" now broken right through

The reversal of the de-Baathification law actually made it more difficult on former Baathists, but that didn't stop Bush from taking credit for the "progress". Now the law to set up provincial elections has been vetoed, and Bush can't claim that as "progress" on his benchmarks.

Let's look at the Decider's own words, when he proposed the surge back on Jan. 10:

I've made it clear to the Prime Minister and Iraq's other leaders that America's commitment is not open-ended. If the Iraqi government does not follow through on its promises, it will lose the support of the American people
— and it will lose the support of the Iraqi people. Now is the time to act. The Prime Minister understands this. Here is what he told his people just last week: "The Baghdad security plan will not provide a safe haven for any outlaws, regardless of [their] sectarian or political affiliation."

These benchmarks were set by the Bush Administration
back when the Decider was making public statements every day about all of the outstanding progress in Iraq and how corners were being turned and so forth. Soon after the 11/06 elections, however, the Decider turned into Grim Bush. Iraq was hard, it would take huge sacrifice, we needed a surge...blah, blah, blah. And even though Bush never specifically promised "success" by a particular date, it seems obvious that he expected great progress by September if the Iraqi government was to regain control of all of the provinces by November.


"To establish its authority, the Iraqi government plans to take responsibility for security in all of Iraq's provinces by November." (1/10/07)

Now more than a year has passed, and nobody expects the promise of the surge to be realised before Bush leaves office. The only thing left is for neocons to re-define "stability" as "whatever the situation is". The benchmarks won't be met, and the Pentagon will once again call the benchmarks "unreasonable", even though the Administration essentially wrote its own own test and failed.


story from McClatchy

Iraqi leaders veto law Bush administration hailed as political breakthrough

  • Posted on Wednesday, February 27, 2008
BAGHDAD — Iraq's three-man presidency council Wednesday announced that it's vetoed legislation that U.S. officials two weeks ago hailed as significant political progress.
Also Wednesday, U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates said he hoped that Turkey's incursion into northern Iraq to fight Kurdish rebels would last a "week or two" but "not months."
Turkish news agencies reported that as many as 77 guerrillas were killed the night before in the most violent night of the week-old incursion on Iraq's northern border. A rebel spokesman said fighters for the Kurdish Workers Party, known as the PKK, had killed 18 Turkish soldiers.
The rejected bill, which sets out the political structure for Iraq's provincial governments and establishes a basis for elections in October, was only the second of 18 U.S.-set political benchmarks that the war-torn nation needs to reach.
Parliament considered it in a bundle with two other bills, a general amnesty and a budget, and approved it on Feb. 12 in what was welcomed in Washington as an example of good government, compromise and progress toward national unity.
Now the question is whether parliament is willing to revise the measure.
"It was a package deal. Now that package is broken," said Joost Hiltermann, an Iraq expert at the International Crisis Group in Amman, Jordan.
At the heart of the rejection of the provincial law is the question of whether Iraq will have strong provincial governors who answer only to their elected executive councils or if the federal prime minister will have a voice in their appointment and removal.
The presidency council vetoed the bill, challenging the role it gave both the prime minister and the governor.
Anthony Cordesman, a Middle East expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C., said the law is needed to define the roles of Iraq's provinces and of the central government and to set ground rules for any future discussion of creating a federation of Sunni and Shiite Muslim and Kurdish regions.
"The key issue is whether the presidency council sent the law back for the right reasons and if parliament will improve the law rather than oppose further delays," he said.
A spokesman declined to say which member or members of the presidency council, which is composed of a Kurd, a Shiite and a Sunni, refused to sign the legislation, sending it back to parliament.
He said the Oct. 1 elections aren't compromised.
However, Hiltermann expressed doubt that the elections would take place as scheduled in October. "It's all up for grabs," he said. "Everything is set back."
Political groupings that oppose extreme government centralization, such as Sunnis, Shiite nationalists and Shiite followers of radical cleric Moqtada al Sadr, could see an uphill battle in parliament, Hiltermann said.
Hassan al Sneid, a Dawa Party member in the large Iraqi Alliance, supports the idea of a prime minister wielding control over governors. Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki is also a Dawa member.
"If the prime minister doesn't have the authority to depose a governor, we will have a president in each governorate," he said.

Al-Qaeda presence in Iraq is overblown

In the vast and constantly shifting reasons why we must remain in Iraq, the old reliable standard that gets most of the play is that if we were to leave, Al-Qaeda would take over Iraq and make it a base.

The second most-employed 'reason' is that we have to stabilise the government of Iraq so that it can be "a strong ally in the War On Terror". This reason is slowly being abandoned, at least in practise, by betting everything on the "Awakening". By building a parallel military force that is not loyal to the Iraqi government, the Administration is effectively throwing the government, the National Police, and the Iraqi Army to the wolves. The idea seems to be that they can control the Sahwa more easily, rout Al-Qaeda, and then manipulate them into bringing the Iraqi government 'into line' or even overthrowing them in favour of a more puppet-like regime.

While there are a lot of problems with this approach, a stupid, risky, and expensive plan has never stopped the Administration before. But the premise of this scheme, the rout of Al-Qaeda, is profoundly weak. As John Cole notes in the post below, there are no more than a few hundred AQ. Nearly every day, the military posthumously dubs any number of corpses "Al-Qaeda". Basically, we 'know' they are AQ because we killed them, and we wouldn't have killed them unless they were AQ, or so the circular logic goes. Our "Awakening" buddies that have been killed by friendly fire have even been dubbed AQ until this little "mixup" was corrected later by the Sahwa.

In the post below, Mr. Cole is taking McCain to task over his utterly mistaken attack on Obama when he responded to a hypothetical scenario. McCain falls over himself in a knee-jerk reaction in which he adamantly speaks of a tremendous Al-Qaeda threat in Iraq.

post from John Cole's Informed Comment:

Moreover, the allegation that he makes about there being 'al-Qaeda in Iraq' that could well take over the country is part lie and part insanity. The Sunni Arabs are no more than 20% of the Iraqi population. How could a tiny minority from within them take over the whole?

The technical definition of al-Qaeda is operatives who have sworn fealty to Usama bin Laden. There were only a few hundred of them. I doubt whether more than a handful of such individuals are in Iraq.

So there isn't any "al-Qaeda" in Iraq in the technical sense. There are "Excommunicating Holy Warriors" (Takfiri Jihadis), i.e. devotees of political Islam who are violent and willing to deploy terror for political purposes. They declare other Muslims who disagree with them "not Muslims,"-- thus the "excommunicating" bit. But there are only a few hundred foreign fighters. A small minority of Iraqis has associated with them. They don't call themselves 'al-Qaeda in Iraq.' The major such group is "The Islamic State of Iraq." And to say that they have "bases" in Iraq is pretty grandiose. They have some safe houses and try to take and hold neighborhoods, so far with indifferent success.

The idea that this small minority of violent Muslim fundamentalists could take over Iraq is completely crazy. They haven't even been able to keep their toehold in Baghdad-- the Sunnis have been largely ethnically cleansed from the capital by Shiite militias.

So the Shiites would not allow an "al-Qaeda" takeover of Iraq. Neither would the Kurds. Nor would most Sunni Arabs (as in al-Anbar Province, where the Dulaim tribe is at daggers drawn with the Excommunicating Holy Warriors).

Moreover, the neighbors would not allow the radical Sunnis to take over. Iran would sit on its hands while Shiites were massacred in Baghdad? Secular Turkey would allow this development? Baathist Syria? Hashemite Jordan (which played a major role in tracking down and killing Abu Musab al-Zarqawi)?

McCain's assertions that "al-Qaeda" has a strong position in Iraq or has any chance of taking over the country if the US leaves are both inaccurate. One is an error, the other is a dark but insubstantial fantasy.

Obama replied:

'“I've got some news for John McCain, that is there was no such thing Al Qaeda in Iraq until George Bush and John McCain decided to invade.

“I've got some news for John McCain. I've got some news for John McCain. He took us into a war, along with George Bush that should have never been authorized, never been waged. They took their eye off the people who were responsible for 9/11 and that would be Al Qaeda in Afghanistan, that is stronger now than at any time since 2001. I've been paying attention John McCain!

“John McCain may like to say that he wants to follow Osama bin Laden to the gates of Hell. But so far all he's done is follow George Bush into a misguided war in Iraq that's cost us thousands of lives and billions of dollars and that I intend to bring to an end so that we can actually start going after Al Qaeda in Afghanistan and in the hills of Pakistan, like we should have been doing in the first place. That's the news John McCain! '


Obama is correct that there was no al-Qaeda in Iraq before Bush overthrew the Iraqi government. I haven't been able to get anyone interested in it, but there is proof positive that the Baath authorities were very scared of al-Qaeda and that when Abu Musab al-Zarqawi showed up in Iraq, they put out an APB on him and branded him dangerous. (Dick Cheney told fairy tales about how Zarqawi was put up in fancy hotels by a solicitous Saddam.)

This is something that has always irked me about the neocon claims. This is the primary "link" used by wingnuts to tie Saddam to 9/11. Al-Zarqawi was in Iraq, so Al-Qaeda was allied with Saddam.
Hell, Al-Qaeda operatives were in the U.S, Britain, Spain, etc. Does that 'tie' the U.S. to Al-Qaeda? Does that mean we should invade Spain as "payback for 9/11"? Aren't we obligated to invade Britain, a country known to have WMD, to prevent it from being used by Al-Qaeda as a base?

The likely answer, if neocons were honest, to these questions is "only if the Decider says we need to".

Sunday, February 24, 2008

Democrat ranks swell, Republican ranks dip

I know that, since the polls have all turned against them, Republicans dismiss any polling out of hand. The exception is any poll that shows Congress has low approval numbers, and even then they leave out the fact that the Republican members of Congress are considerably more unpopular than the Democratic members.

The tide has turned against Republicans so profoundly, yet since they live in a delusional world fueled by Fox News and talk radio, they still really believe that the public supports Bush. The Main Stream Media (MSM) is merely twisting the facts, or so they believe. Others are slightly more candid, and opine that the public has turned against them, but that people have simply been "misled" by the MSM, and that all it will take is exposure to 'the truth' and the public will rub their eyes and come out of their hypnotic state. The 'truth' is generally defined as talk about the "success" in Iraq, scary stories about an Islamic takeover of America, soldiers reading from scripts they rehearsed with their CO, and lots of flags and eagles. The unsaid 'truth' involves a copious amount of hatred, charges of treason, and bragging about torture. Another invasion (or possibly two) is also bandied about as a good way to bring the public around to the Republican view of things.

With the Decider slipping to 19% in polls, and national polls showing McCain losing to Obama at this stage, the usual dose of Republican Kool-Aid has been increased to alarming levels in order to fend off reality. Now, with the Gallup Poll shown below, they will need an IV for the stuff.

Despite the snarling neocon assertion that Americans despise the Democrats and everything they stand for (with those "things they stand for" being selectively defined by the aforementioned snarling neocon), the numbers of Americans describing themselves as Republicans has dropped over the past two months. This isn't the MSM defining people as Republicans, it's people themselves describing themselves as Republicans. On top of that, more than half of the country now has an unfavourable view of the GOP.

While the numbers of those who call themselves Independents have dropped substantially over the past few months, the major beneficiary has been the Democrats - or more precisely, those who call themselves Democrats.

40% of the American public now describe themselves as Democrats.
More than half of the country has a favourable view of the Democratic Party,
Likewise, more than half of the country feels that the Democrats "can bring about the changes this country needs", that they are "able to manage the federal government effectively", and that they have "mostly honest and ethical members in Congress".

The Presidential election, however, is not determined by popular vote. It is determined by the Electoral College (or by the Supreme Court, in Bush's case). The Republicans, by virtue of being the Party in power, still hold substantial sway over the MSM and the "punditocracy", but their message is having a declining effect. The divisions within the GOP, at the current time, also send "mixed signals" to the sheep. The vast majority of Democrats, however, would be happy with either candidate, at least according to exit polling in several primaries. Democratic turnout for the primaries has exceeded Republican turnout, even in the South. This is good news for Congressional elections, since they are not affected by the Electoral College. It is not outrageous to assume that nearly all of those who voted in the primary are likely to vote in the general election. As of right now, the Democrats hold the lead in potential electoral votes if the election were held today.

In one sense, at least, the continuing fight for the Democratic nomination is an advantage for the Democrats. By not having a single person to target, Republicans are forced to delay their slander campaigns. On the Republican side, McCain is increasingly associating himself with the stained and odious Bush legacy, which should hurt him over the coming months. The other sleeper factor is the economy. A declining economy virtually always works against the incumbent Party.

from the Gallup Poll

February 21, 2008

Democrats Have Significant Identification, Image Advantage

Percentage identifying as Democrats near Gallup high

by Frank Newport

PRINCETON, NJ -- Americans are now more likely to identify themselves as Democrats than at any time since 2000.

Forty percent of Americans in the Feb. 11-14 Gallup Poll -- in response to the question, "In politics, as of today, do you consider yourself a Republican, a Democrat, or an independent?" -- said they identified with the Democratic Party, while 26% identified with the Republican Party and 34% with neither (most of these considered themselves independents).

The 40% Democratic identification figure is unusually high. The last time 40% of Americans identified as Democrats was August 2000. Before that, there have been just a handful of Gallup Poll telephone surveys -- going back to 1985 -- in which 40% or more of Americans identified as Democrats. The highest Democratic identification in a Gallup telephone poll was 42% in July 1987.

The gap between Democratic and Republican identification -- now at 14 percentage points -- is also almost a record high. The gap was higher only in December 1998 -- immediately after President Bill Clinton had been impeached by the Republican-controlled House of Representatives -- when 41% of Americans identified as Democrats and only 20% as Republicans.

The highest level of identification with the Republican Party, 39%, has been reached at three points: in May 1991 (a few months after the first Persian Gulf War), December 2003 (in a poll in the field at the time of Saddam Hussein's capture), and September 2004 (after a successful Republican convention at which George W. Bush was nominated for a second term in office).

Last year, as often happens in a year in which there is no national election, Americans were increasingly likely to identify as independents. This year, as presidential election voting has begun in primaries and caucuses, the Democrats have been the beneficiary as Americans have become more likely to express identification with a party. As 2007 ended, an average of two Gallup Polls conducted in December showed 32.5% of Americans identifying as Democrats, 37.5% as independents, and 28.5% as Republicans. Now, the shift is evident. Identification with the Republican Party and with no party have slipped slightly, while identification with the Democratic Party has gained.

There are several other indications that the Democratic Party is riding high at the moment. First, the percentage of Americans with a favorable image of the Democratic Party (56%) is significantly higher than is the case for the Republican Party (41%).

In addition, a Feb. 8-10 USA Today/Gallup poll asked Americans to say whether three specific dimensions applied or did not apply to the two parties. The dimensions were: 1) can bring about the changes this country needs; 2) is able to manage the federal government effectively, and 3) has mostly honest and ethical members in Congress.

In each instance, the American public was more likely to say the characteristic applies to the Democratic Party than to the Republican Party. The biggest difference -- almost 20 points -- is on the dimension of bringing about change, perhaps not surprising given the strong emphasis on change in Barack Obama's campaign (and, to some degree, that of Hillary Clinton). Also, because there has been a Republican administration in the White House since 2001, it may be natural for Americans to say the Democratic Party would be most able to bring about change were its standard-bearer to move into the White House.

Bottom Line

The data reviewed here underscore the strong position of the Democratic Party at this point in the election year. A near-record number of Americans indicate that they currently identify as Democrats; the image of Democratic Party is much more favorable than that of the Republican Party; and Americans say the Democratic Party is better positioned to bring about change and is more likely to be able to manage the government effectively.

The Sunday Eel Pout


Well, it's Sunday, and that means it's time to trudge out on the ice, take a seat in the fish-house, bait our hook and reel another prize for this week's Sunday Eel Pout. The week's outrages, idiocies, and facile indignations will be compiled, and the most unworthy candidates will be awarded The Sunday Eel Pout. Your candidates are as follows:
  • Richard Perle, one of the primary 'architects' of the Iraq invasion, wrote an article this week in The American Interest that offers several confusing and contradictory statements about the "success" of the Iraq invasion and subsequent occupation. The title of the article is "We Won Years Ago", in which he states that we have won because "Saddam will not be sharing WMD with anyone. Judged against that measure, we have already won in Iraq". Yes, Mr. Perle, (the deceased) Saddam will no longer be "sharing" (did he ever threaten this?) his non-existent WMDs. So we've "won" then, right? Not so, says Perle: "...despite the widely, if grudgingly, acknowledged progress of the surge, the war is far from over". So which is it, Mr. Perle? He also brags, by way of a quote from the reprehensible tool named Fouad Ajami, that the invasion has established "a Pax Americana [that] anchors the order of the region". Really? If anything, Bush has shattered the order of the region.
  • Reuel Marc Gerecht, from the American Enterprise Institute and a former CIA officer, who proposes that we 'pretend' to negotiate with Iran as a pretext for bombing them. Negotiations are "something that must be checked off before the next president could unleash the Air Force and the Navy". We must, however, beware that talks "could bind the United States to meaningless, stalling discussions", so these negotiations must essentially be for show. After this, of course, "the military option would likely become convincing to more Americans".
  • Alberto Gonzales, former Attorney General and Bush crony, who this week compared Bush with Lincoln. Bush also has presented himself as the contemporary Lincoln. This has been a recurring theme within neocon circles, with Karl Rove, Rudy Giuliani, and Newt Gingrich saying the same thing. Gonzales received $30,000 for his little speech, in which this scholarly figure would only answer pre-approved questions. He further offered that Bush's brilliance "will be revealed in years to come". Perhaps through multiple subpoenas, one would hope.
  • President Bush, who this week in Africa presented a cut in funding for AIDS, TB, and malaria as an increase in funding. Congress gave Bush $841 million for the Global Project, but Bush reduced it to $500 million since, as one his stooges said, “You don’t want to pile up money.” So cutting $341 million is now considered an increase in Bush-speak.
  • Arizona Senator John McCain, who this week criticised Obama as naive for saying he would take military action in Pakistan, even without the Pakistanis' permission if they wouldn't give it. As McCain further said, " I would not broadcast to the world that I am going to bomb a sovereign nation in order to accomplish my goal." So, Mr. McCain, weren't you the guy that broke out singing a reprise of "Barbara Ann" calling for the bombing of Iran? Isn't Iran a "sovereign nation"? Is that "naive", or is it only naive if someone else does it? Of course, the Bush Administration last month did exactly what McCain is criticising Obama for proposing. When asked about this, McCain said Obama was "wrong in speaking publicly about the option". So one must wonder if it was also wrong for McCain to speak publicly about bombing Iran. So much for "straight talk". Mc Cain is also eligible for a Sunday Eel Pout for his flip-flop on "taxes for the wealthy".
    “There’s one big difference between me and the others–I won’t take every last dime of the surplus and spend it on tax cuts that mostly benefit the wealthy.” [McCain campaign commercial, January 2000]

So, as we reel in another putative prize and lay it out on the Minnesota lake ice in disgust, the sense of anticipation builds. Which bozo will take this damn thing home?

The winner of Minnesota's absolutely unwanted, utterly uncoveted, dismally appropriate, shudder-inspiring, and completely ignominious Sunday Eel Pout is... John McCain for saying it's wrong to publicly talk about bombing a sovereign nation, unless he does it, but that it's okay to actually do it if you are in the Bush Administration, because it's talking about bombing a country that really bothers a sovereign nation, not the actual bombing. This is McCain's second Sunday Eel Pout.
No, you can't throw it back. It's against the law in Minnesota to throw a rough fish back in the water. You're stuck with it, like every other angler in the North Star State. Feed it to the dog, use it to symbolise what we are fighting for in Iraq, waterboard it until it "talks", but get it the hell out of my sight.

All of the idiots in this week's race were unquestionably deserving of the Sunday Eel Pout, but There Can Be Only One.

Well kids, the hissing of the eel pout can only mean one thing: this Sunday's Eel Pout award is over.

Saturday, February 23, 2008

India waves the white flag on Chinese incursions

As I've noted before, China is creating a border conflict with India on India's NE frontier. Chinese forces are building roads, shelters, and camps both in India's Arunachal Pradesh and within Bhutan. Chinese Maoist proxies are moving into the Siliguri Corridor and the Chumba Valley to disrupt Indian and Bhutanese security forces. China openly claims ownership of Arunachal Pradesh, and India appears unwilling to go to war to defend it or Bhutan.

Remarkably, the Indian military is now saying, essentially, that it depends on how you look at it. "Maybe China really does own Arunachal Pradesh. Who are we to say who owns what?", seems to be the Indian Army's latest comment on the border incursions.

Or, as the Indian Army Chief would say, "the Chinese have a different perception" of the border than India does. Wow. Perhaps Pakistan has "a different perception of the LAC" in Jammu and Kashmir than India does, too. You have to look at from both sides, right? So if Pakistan invaded Kashmir, maybe the Indian Army would just shrug and leave. I mean, who put the Indian Army in charge of saying which country's military can or cannot come on to Indian soil? I simply have to wonder just what exactly Indian Army Chief Kapoor thinks the military is for? Parades?

If the Indian military doesn't want to go to war with China, that's one thing. Nobody likes war, especially when it marches to your doorstep. But for the Indian military to pretend this is all just some deep, dark philosophical mystery that has them baffled is just completely ridiculous. Just tell China that they can have everything east of the Siliguri Corridor. Maybe they won't go farther than that. If they do, the Indian military can always ponder some more on the artificial and ephemeral nature of borders. After all, if China is under the impression that an Indian state belongs to them, well, maybe they're right.

The issue is not the "number of incursions", but rather that these incursions now are backed up by thousands of Chinese troops encamped on the border.

story from ExpressIndia

Chinese incursions due to different perception: India

Agencies
Posted online: Saturday , February 23, 2008 at 07:25:57
Updated: Saturday , February 23, 2008 at 07:45:25


New Delhi, February 23: Noting that there were different perception of the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in Arunachal Pradesh, Army Chief Gen Deepak Kapoor has said India would be "as much blameworthy" as the Chinese side for incursions on the two sides.

He, however, said border infrastructure on Chinese side was better than that of India, giving them an "additional capability to bring additional troops", and the government here is "seriously looking" into this "disparity".

"I think a degree of misperception has been built on this issue of incursions. First and foremost, it is a matter of perception. The Chinese have a different perception of the LAC as do we. When they come up to their perception, we call it an incursion and likewise they do," Kapoor said in Karan Thapar's Devil's Advocate programme for CNN-IBN.

He said the level of total number of incursions in 2007 is "somewhat similar to what it has been in the past. So, the feeling that too many incursions have taken place into Indian territory is not right."

Asked whether Indian troops also incur into Chinese territory as often because of differences of perception about the LAC, the army chief replied: "that's right. Which they would call an incursion into their side. So, therefore, to that extent, we would be as much blameworthy for that kind of incursion up to our perceived LAC."

Kapoor dismissed media perception that Chinese incursion were a sign of muscle-flexing by Beijing indicating something worse to come.