Two insightful posts are DailyKos regarding this are found here and here.
I would like to analyse when and why the wheels came off for the GOP, the factors that will continue to hold the Republicans back, and what this means for the Democrats and the progressives.
The first thing that must be addressed is the Republicans' disdain for reality in all its forms. When Dubya "won" election by losing the popular vote, there was no voice of reason or restraint within the GOP. Nobody in the Party leadership considered that more than half of the country opposed their agenda, their candidate, and their policies. Instead, they went full speed ahead and simply pretended that America agreed with them. After 9/11, of course, the GOP dug in to a make-believe world of their own creation. The White House bragged that they "create reality", and they removed themselves from contact with anyone who did not completely buy in to the Kool-Aid drinking world they spun out of whole cloth. The examples of this are numerous. Intelligence reports were cherry-picked and controlled to produce the "evidence" they wanted, and then this "evidence" was used to convince other Republicans of the validity of this pseudo-reality. And as Republicans moved into the sheltered confines of a Fox News/talk radio world, they were told that no other media sources could be trusted but them. The average Republican slipped into a world in which Bush was infallible, in which Bush was America, and those who disagreed with Bush must therefore "hate America". Any criticism of anything wrong in the country was dismissed as hatred of America, unless it involved blaming Democrats for whatever might putatively be "wrong". Quite simply, America was incapable of doing anything "wrong" in the Fox News-fueled world. Any facts that seemed to indicate otherwise could be rejected with a wave of the hand and the use of the magic word "America-hater".
I recall pointing out to a Republican that the U.S. actually supported Saddam during his use of chemical weapons against the Kurds, that Saddam was an ally of the U.S. for nearly a decade as a counterweight to Iran in the region, that Saddam was one of a multitude of brutal dictators that our government has backed because they are useful to our foreign policy, and that Iran was one of those dictatorships before the Shah was overthrown. All of this is well-known history for those that eschew the GOP Kool-Aid, yet it was all completely dismissed as a lie by this Republican (and several others since) based on nothing more than that my mentioning these facts proved that I "hated America", and thus was not credible. One can scarcely believe the imaginary history that Republicans carry in their heads regarding America. But I digress.
America's enchantment with the Bush Administration had already eroded substantially by 2005 when Katrina hit, but the majority still believed that Bush just had some "tough breaks" in Iraq. When the utterly inept response to New Orleans' flooding occurred, however, the spell was broken for good. Rank incompetence was revealed, gross indifference was displayed, and the country at large wondered how a guy that formerly ran a stable was put in charge of FEMA. If the GOP had taken steps then, even sham efforts, to dispel the idea that they had handed over the function of government to cronies based on ideological agreement, then we likely would be having a different conversation today. Instead, the Republicans denied any failure. They pointed the finger at the Louisiana state government, at Mayor Nagin, at the public for treasonous dissent, the treacherous media, and at the victims themselves. Eventually, "Brownie" was to become a human sacrifice and the only thing that the GOP learned was that incompetence must be covered up better. Secrecy was increased, "disloyal" elements were purged from government jobs, wagons were circled, and the Republican world view became even more firmly entrenched in a "with us or against us" mindset. No longer were we all Americans; we were either traitors or patriots. The "good news" and "progress" in Iraq flowed from the White House on a daily basis, in stark contrast to the undeniable facts that indicated a quagmire without a clear-cut triumph that Americans had truly believed would have occurred by then. And the pseudo-reality that was intravenously fed to the faithful spoke of a brilliant success in Iraq, a popular President that could do no wrong, and darkly hinted at a tiny number of domestic traitors who wanted to destroy America and that were universally reviled, except by terrorists.
The 2006 elections were merely the buzzing of a gnat within the ironclad fortress of the Republican pseudo-reality. Everyone loved them and believed in them, anything they said would be eagerly lapped up by the nation without examination, and the only "problem" was that some RINOs had been taken out of power. Prior to the 2004 election, Republicans had been locked into a perpetual time warp where it was always 1994. After the 2006 elections, they moved in lockstep to a newer false world where it is always 2002, in which they exist today.
This is why I point to polls so frequently in this blog. Republicans really, truly believe they are still wildly popular. And while Republicans dismiss polls (as they do anything that contradicts the pseudo-reality) by saying "polls go up and polls go down", the reality is that those numbers simply are not going up for them. Republican turnout in the primaries has been a pale shadow of the Democrats' numbers, and the number of people identifying themselves as Republicans has dropped while those of Democrats' is increasing to record levels. The GOP agenda has been reduced to an obstructionist campaign, Bush is ignored by world leaders and the domestic public, and elections simply aren't going their way.
For an example of the severity of this Republican disconnect with reality, see the take on McCain's recent speech shown below. McCain posited an imaginary world in 2013 in which America has "won" in Iraq, and Republicans seem to have lapped it up as if it were actually true and a foregone conclusion.
Nice move Mac. In one fell swoop, he exposes the anti-war left for what they are: Pacifist appeasers who don't believe troops should be sent anywhere, anytime, for any reason. They will be left bleating on deaf ears about bringing troops home now.
Normal Americans support military action against America's enemies as long as the cause is just and the exit strategy is known. They are patient and they can live with a date, even if it is 5 years down the road. Before today, McCain was saddled with the perception of a perpetual war combined with the scurrilous 100-years-in-Iraq lie by the left. Unaddressed, that is a deal breaker for McCain at the ballot box. No longer.
The nice part is that he can assess as he goes and decide in 2013, if he wins a second term, whether that is the prudent course at that time.
In the meantime, he has just grabbed a pile of moderate, war-weary Democrats right out of the D column.
Bill Dupray at The Patriot Room
Wow.
Yes, this is what America has been waiting for: A man who has the courage to invent an imaginary world in which Republicans are always right.
Polls show that 33% of Americans want us to withdraw from Iraq now, and the clear majority want us out in one year. However, these must not be "Normal Americans", in Mr. Dupray's view. McCain imagines that we will "win" in Iraq within five years, so it's a done deal, apparently.
Just wondering, though...what if things don't turn out like they do in McCain's imagination? Won't he keep us in Iraq? I mean, Bush had some pretty neat imaginary scenarios, too, but here we are still "surging" along. How is this supposed to appeal to "a pile of moderate war-weary Democrats"? McCain simply imagines that there will only be five more years of a war that the majority of Americans already feel was a mistake, a war that only 19% say that they're looking for a candidate that is willing to pursue until we "succeed", so obviously McCain has the election in the bag. The Decider imagined that the "surge" would put the Iraqi government in control of all the provinces by last November, but that didn't seem to induce giddiness or a massive increase in support for Republicans or the occupation. But now McCain is imagining some stuff, so it's all different, right?
By the way, take a look at this analysis of why McCain's imaginary victory is unlikely.
In the very odd world that Republicans have constructed, merely predicting something means that it will happen. I often laughed over right-wing bloggers who quoted military commanders saying that a campaign has the objective to do such-and-such, and then crowing over it as if this means it has already happened or is inevitable. To doubt such statements is the equivalent of doubting America itself in their minds.
There was a time, a relatively brief time, in which Americans felt unified by the Iraq invasion and cheered unquestioningly like football fans for the "home team", but that time has passed and the buzz has worn off. This doesn't mean that people "hate America", but it does mean that invoking 9/11 and shoving flags and eagles in our faces won't gain much traction any more. Such jingoistic, spectator-sport approaches require big, quick wins with clearly-defined "good guys" and "bad guys". The Long War model never held significant appeal to Americans, and Republicans only pulled it out as 'what they said all along' only after hopes for a big, quick win had already faded. It came off as bait and switch, and we felt deceived. Republicans only offered charges of treason to keep the restless in line. To most, the threat of being "dumped" by Republicans, of being exiled from the Cool Kids Club, of failing to make the grade as a good Decider-droid was toothless and spiteful.
Look, Republicans, it's this simple: nobody believes you any more.
Pelosi and Reid really aren't hated and reviled by the American people. Nobody but you believes that advocating withdrawal from Iraq means that they favour the destruction of America or that they oppose any war for any reason or that they want us all to become Muslims. Nobody but you thinks that the word "liberal" has magical powers to silence dissent. Nobody but you believes that the majority of the country is part of the "Far Left". Nobody but you thinks that it's more important to be loyal to the Bush Administration than it is to admit the existence of problems and deal with them. Nobody but you thinks that dissent against a Republican President is treason, but that dissent against a Democratic President is your patriotic duty.
The GOP has offered America a team of droids that back their Party over the interests of their own constituents. That's a losing proposition in politics. Nobody cares if a candidate is a good Bush Team player or is "on board" with the Party agenda. Merely stating that a candidate fails to support the GOP talking points simply does not disqualify a candidate in the eyes of the American electorate.
It would be really nice if you all continued to believe these things, however, because it will discredit your Party for a good, long time. Please, please keep on pointing to a picture of a Democrat, saying the word "liberal", and expecting to win big. Please keep on saying that Iraq is about making us safer at home. Please keep on telling us that protecting telecoms from lawsuits is the same as fighting terrorists. And please keep on portraying Bush as an infallible genius that only the "Far Left" disagrees with.
It is true that the three special elections in which Republicans have recently lost to Democrats are not astoundingly good news for progressives. These are conservative Democrats. However, those are three robots that won't be in Congress playing obstructionist games at the orders of the GOP. Those are three districts in which voters will presumably learn that casting a ballot for a Democrat doesn't mean that the world will end. Those are three examples that will be lurking in the back of every Republican Congressman's mind when the Party tells them to do something against their own electoral interests. And those are three cases that will come to mind when a Democrat in Congress thinks about caving to the GOP.
The elections in November will prove to everyone outside of the Republican pseudo-reality that the traditional "fear and smear" tactics don't work any more. Even Republicans that hold on to their seats will see the margins dwindle enough to make a bolt from the lockstep march of the Party dictates seem viable. Obstructionism will no longer be glamorous, and Republicans will have to come up with something other than hatred and a police-state fear-mongering. The Evangelical Christians are already peeling away, along with veterans and fiscal conservatives. The Party will have to stand for something more than "We Hate The Democrats". And the Republican dictate that "you're either all in or all out" will have to be abandoned.
No comments:
Post a Comment