The majority think the invasion of Iraq was a mistake.
The ramifications of this are profound. This means that the entire idea of Iraq being part of the Global War On Terror, the notion that we are over there to keep them from coming over here, the idea that invading Iraq has made us safer, and the assertions that only the "Far Left" holds these views have all been discredited. To deny this would mean that the majority of Americans support terrorism, are trying to militarily undermine their own country, are looking for bold new ways to make us less safe, and are part of the "Far Left". For the Republicans, the message on Iraq has essentially been reduced to "we're stuck there, so get over it".
Only 19% think it's important that their Presidential candidiate is willing to stay in Iraq until we "succeed", whatever "success" is.
Again, the ramifications of these numbers are significant. The "cut and run" talisman no longer bears weight when over 3/4 of the voters see a willingness to be flexible and leave before we have achieved "success" as desirable in Presidential candidate. McCain's "hundred years" statement, regardless of the context it is put in, clearly puts him on the 19% side. We are now in Iraq to influence whether puppet leaders or Iraqi nationalists will control the country. Nothing about that speaks of any "vital interests" for the U.S. Nothing about that inspires any desire to "kick some butt" or "bring 'em on". Nothing about that lends credence to a willingness to spend $12 billion a week on a military effort to bring about a foreign country's political reconciliation. Pictures of flags and eagles, accusations of treason, and scary stories now fail to suspend the critical thinking skills of the American electorate. The public wants an exit strategy, and the Republicans are only offering a quagmire that may or may not, at some point, become a basically "break even" scenario.
A third of the public wants to withdraw from Iraq, and only about 20% want to continue the "surge".
Apparently 33% of the nation is now part of the "Far Left", because Republicans keep telling us that only the "Far Left" wants to pull out of Iraq. The public, however, continues to see people who are clearly not traitorous nor wild-eyed leftists advocating withdrawal or drawing down force levels. Reality is not on the side of the GOP propaganda masters. Military commanders have stated that we will need to send more troops, not fewer, if we are to achieve "success", yet this option now draws only 8% support. Americans clearly no longer want to "win" in Iraq - or more accurately, no longer believe in what the Republicans consider a "win".
All three of these polls point to Iraq as a serious liability for the GOP, yet the Party has steadfastly lined up behind the most unpopular President in modern history and that Party's presumptive nominee has completely embraced that unpopular President's policies on Iraq. The GOP's traditional alliance with evangelical Christians is also highly questionable, with it being increasingly likely that these voters will choose to sit on their hands come November. A faltering economy is always bad news for the incumbent Party, and the Republicans are split between trying to come up with more and more bizarre ways to define the word "recession" or those who wish to continue to push tax cuts that have proven a failure. 80% of the public believes that the economic stimulus cheques will not make much difference. The percentages of the electorate who believe that upper-income citizens and corporations pay too much in taxes is in the single digits. People all across the country have seen the result of the Bush tax cuts: collapsing infrastructure, income inequality, offshoring jobs, and declines in the educational system. McCain only wants to continue this failed policy.
And the model of governance that the GOP has pushed has increasingly been the object of ridicule. Across the board, citizens have seen gross incompetence and total cronyism from the federal government. Turning over the government responsibilities to people based on their loyalty to the Bush agenda has turned out to be a huge failure. Staggering inefficiency and naked partisanship is the order of the day. Do you think anyone trying to get a passport really cares if the people processing it are opposed to Roe v. Wade or if they have a close personal relationship with Jesus? Do you think that anyone waiting for disaster relief is consoled by the fact the morons that bungled the job are reliable GOP donors? Does anyone who witnessed Doan's "memory problems" really think that's understandable if she was a loyal supporter of the President?
Not really. People want their tax dollars spent wisely by competent people acting in an efficient manner. Whether or not they have sworn unending loyalty to the most unpopular President in modern history is not high on the public's list of priorities. Yet McCain has said nothing in criticism of the rank incompetence Bush has cultivated. In fact, McCain is completely beholden to the Party apparatus that thrust loyalty as the primary consideration in the federal government. Morale among federal employees has plummeted, recruiting competent staff has become difficult, and retaining them even harder. At the same time, the value of having a Bush Administration position on your resume has dwindled. It marks one as an incompetent crony that was hired and retained based not on merit and skills, but rather ideological purity.
McCain has failed to say anything that he would do differently than Bush. Not one thing.
The sleeper issue, however, are House and Senate races. The Democrats can expect big gains in the House, and possibly three or four seats gained in the Senate. Republicans that do hold on to their seats will see their margins of victory dwindle alarmingly. Those not up for election until 2010 will surely see that loyalty to the Bush agenda is nothing more than a suicide pact. Already we are seeing one-size-fits-all "cookie-cutter" ads from the GOP. Just replace the face and the name, and these generic ads could run in any district. Democrats, too, are seeing the potential to be had by standing up to the Republican agenda. The next President will certainly find a Congress much less compliant to traditional Republican talking points and much less responsive to scare themes. GOP intimidation of the media will also become more difficult as it becomes readily apparent that the punditry is seriously out of touch with the reality within the country.
A smaller percentage of the public now believes in the Bush agenda than believes in the existence of magical fairies, yet we don't see pundits weighing in on how magical fairies come down on the issues of the day. No network considers how magical fairies will react to a news story or if magical fairies are sufficiently patriotic. I have yet to see a news anchor ponder over whether a national issue is "good news or not for magical fairies". We have, however, seen Republican policies that essentially rely on copious amounts of fairy dust to solve problems.
Nothing is improving for Republicans in public opinion. Jingoism now shows diminishing returns. The war that was supposed to unite America and guarantee a permanent Republican majority has now become a permanent liability for the Party that even "victory" will not mitigate. Self-identification as a Democrat has reached an all-time high. And if the Republicans lose the White House, the gravy train for right-wing think tanks, crooked contractors, and hate-mongers will come to an end.
Results from a CBS/NYT poll are shown below:
"Looking back, do you think the United States did the right thing in taking military action against Iraq, or should the U.S. have stayed out?" N=1,065 adults, MoE ± 3
| ||||||
.
| ||||||
| Right Thing | Stayed Out | Unsure | ||||
| % | % | % | ||||
|
4/25-29/08
| 37 | 57 | 6 | |||
3/28 - 4/2/08
| 34 | 62 | 4 | |||
|
3/15-18/08
| 36 | 59 | 5 | |||
|
2/20-24/08
| 38 | 58 | 4 | |||
1/9-12/08
| 36 | 58 | 6 | |||
12/5-9/07
| 41 | 54 | 5 | |||
10/12-16/07
| 45 | 51 | 4 | |||
9/14-16/07
| 39 | 53 | 8 | |||
----------------------------------------------------
"Which is more important to you in a presidential candidate: someone who commits to staying in Iraq until the U.S. succeeds, or someone who is flexible about when to withdraw U.S. troops from Iraq?" N=956 registered voters, MoE ± 3
| ||||||
.
| ||||||
| Commits to Staying | Flexible | Unsure | ||||
| % | % | % | ||||
|
4/25-29/08
| 19 | 77 | 4 | |||
Also from a CNN poll:
"Which comes closest to your view about what the U.S. should now do about the number of U.S. troops in Iraq? The U.S. should send more troops to Iraq. The U.S. should keep the number of troops as it is now. The U.S. should withdraw some troops from Iraq. OR, The U.S. should withdraw all of its troops from Iraq."
| ||||||
.
| ||||||
| Send More | Keep Same Number | Withdraw Some | Withdraw All | Unsure | ||
| % | % | % | % | % | ||
|
4/28-30/08
| 8 | 21 | 35 | 33 | 3 | |
|
12/6-9/07
| 10 | 19 | 30 | 39 | 2 | |
|
9/7-9/07
| 10 | 23 | 36 | 29 | 3 | |
|
6/22-24/07
| 17 | 16 | 24 | 39 | 3 | |
|
11/17-19/06
| 16 | 21 | 27 | 33 | 3 | |
|
10/27-29/06
| 15 | 17 | 28 | 34 | 6 | |
1 comment:
I wish to hell right or wrong or what we thought mattered but as you know it does not! You did a good job on that. It's almost funny but I guess the reason Bush supposedly does not care what polls say or look at them is because they are always negative.
Iraq's failure that was a given day one is just beginning but I am afraid it will not derail McGoon as it should. The more he tries to distance himself from Bush the more like him he gets.
I posted on it a couple of times but Bush has resorted to peace Israeli style by building a wall right through the success in Sadr City!
Post a Comment