Saturday, June 14, 2008

Republicans still short on cash

The GOP sets fund-raising quotas for House Representatives depending on their status. Those in the leadership positions are expected to raise more money than other Representatives.
It's not looking very good, either. Less than half of their "target" has been met so far.

Rep. Davis of Virginia has only raised $50,000 of the $605,000 he was expected to come up with, and he is the head of the NRCC. On the Senate side, the NRSC had $19.4 million on hand as of April 30. The Democratic counterpart had $37.6 million on hand, by comparison.

One of the reasons that we are seeing so much slander from Republicans this cycle is because it generates free media attention. A campaign can come up with any kind baseless charge or rumour, and the media will run with it without investigation, qualifying it with the cryptic "some are saying...", and the opponent's campaign will then have to spend money debunking and discrediting it.

Obviously, the Republican's cash shortfall will reduce the number and quality of ad buys. It will also, however, restrict the number and quality of promotional events and campaign workers. And with Republican enthusiasm markedly down this cycle, it will be harder to fill volunteer positions. The only upside is that Bush's economic policies have created more unemployed people with more free time to work on campaigns for free, but that's a factor working in "favour" of both Parties.

Republican House and Senate campaigns have thus far made heavy use of "cookie-cutter" ads, a generic, one-size-fits-all ad in which the candidate's name and picture merely fills in the appropriate blanks. While cheap, it fails to appeal to local issues and ties the candidate to the Bush Administration by virtue of its national nature.

The only good news for the GOP is that the RNC has raised almost double the amount the DNC has raised so far. But this money is for the convention and Presidential campaign, and the McCain ticket is unlikely to boost down-ticket races (e.g. House and Senate) significantly. Also, McCain is generally failing to gain traction against Obama in spite of recent major media buys.


story from AP:

WASHINGTON - House rank and file Republicans are tens of millions of dollars short of meeting fundraising targets set by their own campaign committee in advance of this fall's elections, according to figures circulating among the leadership, heightening concerns inside the party about major losses in November.
Most recent figures show that GOP lawmakers have brought $27 million into the coffers of the National Republican Congressional Committee in the past 17 months, far short of the target of about $58 million. Compounding the challenge, they will soon be asked to raise another $20 million or more to help candidates in selected battleground districts.
...
Republicans concede that the perception of another impending defeat makes potential donors even less inclined to contribute.

On top of this, one of the NRCC's accountants has swindled them out of a lot of money:

Compounding the problem, the committee has spent months trying to untangle the affairs of a former key staff member, Christopher Ward, who is alleged to have stolen at least $725,000 from the organization. An internal probe alleged that the former treasurer used his authority to siphon money from 2001 and 2007. The FBI is also investigating.
Ward's lawyer, Ronald Machen, declined comment on the internal probe. The NRCC said it spent $500,000 to pay for the investigation and another $300,000 to upgrade its accounting operations.

Did they really spend $800,000 chasing after $725,000? It looks that way. The money Ward is alleged to have embezzled is only 1% of the total target amount, and it was allegedly embezzled over a period of six years, so it's not as if this is the big reason for the fund-raising shortfalls.

Overall, the NRCC, which began the election cycle with a debt of more than $10 million, showed cash on hand of $6.7 million as of April 30 in its most recent report to the Federal Election Commission. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee reported cash on hand of $45.2 million.

McCain "town hall" is a staged sham

McCain's "town hall meeting" on Thursday in New Jersey was covered by a blogger.

Far from an open forum in which he tackled tough questions, it was instead a campaign rally in which the questions were provided ahead of time to selected individuals that McCain was directed to by aides. He answered a total of seven questions from the audience, and abruptly ended the "town hall" when it went off-script.

The seating for the event was arranged ahead of time, and with cameras in mind. Those cameras were also directed to be turned off by McCain's staff whenever it was convenient.

The seating was staged. There were about 20 people with Veteran's hats and all were seated directly in line with McCain's podium in the front and back. Your cameras from home would make it appear that half the people there were veterans. In reality it was about 1%. Mixed into the Veterans was one angry woman who had a sign claiming she was a Hillary supporter voting McCain. This one sign was placed directly in the spot where the cameras were most likely to pick it up. She was planted there. It also appears that there was one singular woman who pulled the same stunt Thursday night at the so called Fox News McCain town hall meeting in New York. These people aren't real Clinton supporters, this too is staged.
...
The questions and answers were not chosen among random people. 5 of the 7 questioners came from the VIP section including a woman in a wheelchair who was placed there ahead of time by a senior McCain staffer and then pointed to for a question even though she never raised her hand. They were plants. A couple of them were reading from index cards. A sixth questioner was also a plant in the bleachers about 40 feet to my right. He was a local Republican mayor whom the locals were familiar with.

So we have five questions coming from a group of pre-selected people in the "VIP section", some of which were reading from index cards. One of the two questions coming from the audience came from a known-to-be-sympathetic local Republican politician. The last question, which was from the audience, was the one that ended this charade, and was the only question that McCain was asked during the entire affair that wasn't scripted or pre-arranged.
How did this minor gamble work out?

The 7th questioner was chosen because McCain thought a 9 year old child was going to ask the question. But the father took the mike, told how his wife and child flew out of Newark on 9/11 and that could have been them. He then asked a very simple question, "Why haven't we gotten Bin Laden?"
A bunch of Obama people and others cheered. (I refrained, I was to be the next question.) McCain got pissed, started rambling about the Diamondbacks and Yankees and Rudy Giuliani on a screen, said as President Bin Laden would be caught (Guess this means Bin Laden is still safe for another few months) and people were laughing that McCain wasn't answering the question.
You could see the veins in McCain starting to burst, he got very uncomfortable that his scripted rally just got derailed by this gentleman and then he ended the rally by thanking everyone and saying God Bless America.

So this is the kind of forum that McCain expects Obama to submit to?
Seven questions, 70% of which came from people that the campaign hand-picked, vetted, and most probably handed the proper questions to beforehand, another from a known Republican politician, and the last one was intended to be from a child, and this was supposed to be some kind of open forum where "tough questions" are asked?
The moment it goes off-script with a question from a well-meaning and sympathetic audience member, the whole thing is called to an end. This unscripted question wasn't even really answered.

During the 2004 campaign, Bush also only appeared before pre-screened audiences in staged affairs like this one. He continues to only publicly speak before military audiences and hand-picked crowds, or in front of organisations known to be sympathetic in which everything is arranged beforehand. No dissent can be displayed in Republican America. A fairy-tale world in which everyone loves the Decider is all that the media is allowed to show, and McCain is emulating that practise.

Meanwhile, Democrats are criticised for refusing to appear on openly hostile outlets such as Fox News by people who think that this kind of "town hall meeting" is for real.
This might play well with the Republican Faithful, but the rest of America will not be persuaded by this North Korea-style of public discourse. Republicans, however, really believe that America - the "true" America, the Silent Majority America, the "real people"- still supports them and will swallow this kind of act.
They are in for a surprise in November. Their delusion is what is preventing them from cancelling elections altogether due to some concocted "emergency".

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

BBC: $23 BILLION disappeared in Iraq funding

A BBC investigation into the mysterious financial black hole known as the Iraq invasion has just been released. Not surprisingly, Bush's contractor buddies ripped off taxpayers for multiple billions, and the Administration has issued orders to prevent further investigation. Are we now to 'discover' that the BBC is part of the "Far Left" that no longer takes every single utterance of the Decider as gospel truth? Perhaps.
The Republicans have created a weird "rule" that allows any facts to be dismissed out of hand based on the putative and alleged association of the source with anyone who disagrees with the Administration. Perhaps some investigator's spouse once attended a conference in which someone else said something critical of the Bush Administration; obviously the entire report can then be cast as the work of "Bush haters". The only people who can say anything critical of the Administration are those within it, and in this case, they are dismissed as "traitors".

Story from the BBC:

A BBC investigation estimates that around $23bn (£11.75bn) may have been lost, stolen or just not properly accounted for in Iraq.
For the first time, the extent to which some private contractors have profited from the conflict and rebuilding has been researched by the BBC's Panorama using US and Iraqi government sources.
A US gagging order is preventing discussion of the allegations.
The order applies to 70 court cases against some of the top US companies.

War profiteering
While George Bush remains in the White House, it is unlikely the gagging orders will be lifted.
To date, no major US contractor faces trial for fraud or mismanagement in Iraq.
The president's Democrat opponents are keeping up the pressure over war profiteering in Iraq.
Henry Waxman who chairs the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform said: "The money that's gone into waste, fraud and abuse under these contracts is just so outrageous, its egregious.
"It may well turn out to be the largest war profiteering in history."

Why is the Bush Administration preventing any investigation into this? Will "the terrorists" somehow benefit by a public revelation of where these billions went? Perhaps, since the Bush Administration has continually equated those who criticise both the cost and pretext of the invasion as "terrorist sympathisers", they may make an extremely flimsy case based on 'national security'. In other words, if the public knew what went on behind the scenes, they would be opposed to the Iraq effort, and that would make us less safe as a nation. Of course, that ship has sailed, with over 2/3 of Americans now saying the whole thing was a mistake. But it doesn't have to make sense for the Administration to use it as a justification.

The truth is that the Administration is preventing the investigation of these allegations so that more evidence can disappear: hard drives erased, documents "mistakenly" discarded, suppressed audits classified as secret for decades, etc.

Again and again we have heard stories of how the Administration has actively blocked investigations of corruption within the Iraqi government as well. While promoting and crowing about the efforts of an "anti-corruption team" into Iraqi ministries, the Administration was simultaneously severely limiting what this "team" of two men could investigate. The result was that they could investigate nothing, and they sat playing computer games for months while Bush claimed credit for their "work". Several stories have also come out regarding arms purchases, where the U.S. or Iraqi government was billed for brand-new, high quality equipment only to receive used, out-dated, or broken equipment instead, with the difference going into a crony's pocket. The BBC investigation uncovers another case of just this kind of abuse:

He and his associates siphoned an estimated $1.2 billion out of the ministry.
They bought old military equipment from Poland but claimed for top class weapons.
Meanwhile they diverted money into their own accounts.

It is truly staggering that Republicans can cry shrilly about "earmarks" and "pork", while at the same time blocking investigations of over $23 billion in fraud in invasion and occupation expenditures. The justification is that there is no evidence of wrongdoing. Why is there no evidence of wrongdoing? Because the Bush Administration has continually prevented any investigations based on unprecedented secrecy. Thus, the Republicans claim this is merely an example of the "criminalisation of politics", in which poor Republican operatives are being persecuted for being on the wrong side of the Aisle.

When one starts with the premise that the Republicans and their minions can do no wrong, it is very easy to justify stonewalling investigations. And once something is investigated, it is suddenly "in the past" and it is time to "move on" and "put it behind us". Of course, this is only a last-resort position, because the first line of defence is always that the investigators are biased. In other words, the investigators did not decide at the outset that nothing wrong was done, or that the investigators had been critical of some aspect of the invasion and occupation in the past, making them obviously part of the vaguely-defined "Far Left".

The GOP had better brace itself for a steady stream of this kind of revelation for years to come once Bush leaves office. Their traditionally weak defence is only effective on the faithful, and only possible with the complicity of the Executive to conceal facts. Mid-term elections will feature Republican sound bites of unswerving loyalty to Bush contrasted with revelations of corruption that they defied anyone to investigate.

Where's all that cheap gas from Iraq?

Remember when one of the arguments in favour of invading Iraq was that gas prices would drop below the 2003 level? This was one of the populist points made repeatedly. If you opposed the invasion, then you wanted gas prices to remain at $2 per gallon, because "we would get the oil" and that meant really cheap gas somehow (though refinery capacity has been the chief bottleneck for gasoline price drops for decades now).

Remarkably, this bogus claim was also used in the First Gulf War.

And, even now, it's is being put forward as a reason for invading Iran, because this time "we" will get the oil -- or rather, the multinational oil companies will get the oil, and we all 'know' that they will act in our best interests.

Not so remarkably, the Gulf States failed to see our invasion of Iraq as a shining success that made them safer and more secure, and thus declined to increase production at the Decider's request.

GOP leader willing to settle for losing 8 Senate seats

The NRSC is the GOP organisation responsible for regaining the Republican majority in the Senate.
The leader of the NRSC, John Ensign, has availed himself of the peculiar Republican propensity to define "success" as "whatever the current situation is". Thus, the GOP is forever "succeeding" in everything that it does.

Now, the NRSC has re-defined "success" as losing no more than eight Senate seats.

From TPM:

In a further sign that Republican hopes are fading badly, the head of the Senate GOP's campaign committee has set a new goal for the party this Fall: Not to lose too many Senate seats.
NRSC chair John Ensign has moved the goal posts, according to the Savannah Morning News, saying that the GOP will have succeeded if they don't lose more than eight seats.
Ensign pointed out that if the Dems win nine seats they'll get to the filibuster-proof magic number of 60 -- at which point, Ensign warned, "they will be able to do pretty much whatever they want."
So if the Dems can't get to a 60-seat super-majority, the GOP will have won. Talk about lowering the bar.

Story from SavannahNow.com:

Democrats now have 49 seats, with two independents who vote with them.
Republicans hold 49 seats now, with 23 up for re-election this year, and five GOP senators retiring, giving away the incumbent advantage.
Democrats only have to defend 12 seats this year.
An eight-seat loss would be a very bad year for any party, even the party holding the White House at the end of a second term, when voters typically hunger for change. So, it's surprising for a party leader to speak in such frank terms about major losses.
Why would the number of seats matter if it's anything less than 51 and taking the majority, a circumstance Ensign describes as unlikely? By holding at least 41, the GOP would prevent the majority party from the 60 votes required to end filibusters and to push an unpopular bill to a vote on the floor through the cloture procedure.
"With 41 votes in the U.S. Senate, you can (1) block bad legislation, and (2) you can make the majority respect the minority's rights. And you can help craft good legislation," Ensign said. "If the Democrats were able to get to 60 votes - literally even if they get to 57-58 votes because they always seem to pick off a couple or three Republicans on a lot of votes - and if they win the White House ... they will be able to do pretty much whatever they want."

In other words, the Republicans would be unable to continue their obstructionist campaign.
In reality, however, there are a number of conservative Democrats who would putatively take some of those Senate seats, so the phrase "do pretty much whatever they want" is really just fear-mongering. Still, much of what we have seen for the past six months (at least) are straight Party-line votes by the Republican senators on issues that can easily be turned against a senator up for election. The GOP has chosen to sacrifice senators in order for Bush to prove that he's still "relevant". This also means that the next mid-term elections will see roughly the same number of Republican senators up for election, who will still presumably be running on the Bush agenda, since that's what got them elected in the first place.

Kel at The Osterley Times covers the doubts among other Republicans over McCain's campaign.
She also has video of McCain claiming that Putin is the President of Germany.
The Democrats are also making gains in fund-raising.
Al Franken has won the DFL nomination to take on Norm Coleman in Minnesota.
John McCain says that the Constitution states that America is "a Christian nation".

McCain says, "I would probably have to say yes, that the Constitution established the United States of America as a Christian nation." He continues, "I think the number one issue that is in the selection, that which people should make a selection of the president of the United States is, 'Will this person carry on in the Judeo-Christian principled tradition that has made this nation the greatest experiment in the history of mankind?'"

The United States Constitution, of course, specifically states that "no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States."

Recall that this "Christian nation" line was the basis for the right-wing freakout over a Hindu prayer being made in the Senate. Recall also that fundamentalist evangelical Christianity only came into existence in America more than a century after the Constitution was signed and ratified. McCain is now using the metaphorical corpses of the Founding Fathers as ventriloquist dummies for an argument in favour of something that they never advocated or were aware of. McCain is using the term "Christian" as interchangeable with "born-again fundamentalist Christian", which is a gross distortion and nothing near "straight talk". Indeed, in many of the former colonial states such fundamentalist views would have been punished as heresy, but now we are being led to believe that evangelical Christianity was not only in existence at the time, but also accepted and prevalent.

Republicans unfazed by "Phase Two" report

The "Phase 2" intelligence report proves exactly what so many people (like me) said in the build-up to the invasion. It wasn't that there wasn't any media pointing this out, it was that one had to dig deep and go to foreign news sources to find out about the dubious claims the Administration made.

It is completely clear that the Bush Administration, and their minions in the Pentagon, went out of their way to only look for information that supported their assertions. Iraqi exiles, many of whom had not been to Iraq in decades, were used as sources (and handsomely compensated) for reports that described the inner workings and policies of Hussein's administration. These exiles were, in fact, coached in their "evidence" by being told in advance which "facts" would be paid for and which ones wouldn't, as well as being told which "facts" would discredit them as a source. Beyond that, it appears that this propensity for gullibility allowed the Iranian intelligence services to shape the "information" provided in order to facilitate Iran's goal of seeing their greatest foe, Saddam, removed from power.

The reason that so many foreign intelligence services concluded the same thing as the Bush Administration is that these foreign services were provided the same false information that the Administration presented as fact. In one case, the Niger yellowcake "fact", the British intelligence services questioned whether this assertion relied on a known-to-be-discredited report from a few years previous. In fact, the assertion did, but the Administration had simply re-packaged the discredited report and pressured some all-too-compliant flunkies to present it as something new, so that it could be said with a straight face that this was "new intelligence". Over and over again, foreign intelligence services started with the premise that the Administration's assertions were sound, and again and again "discovered" the same phony informants providing the same phony "facts" and vouched for by the U.S. In short, the Administration misled not only America, but our allies as well.

Thus, the world was led to believe that Saddam had chemical and biological weapons and was willing to (and planning to) give them to Al-Qaeda. The world was also led to believe that Al-Qaeda was allied with Saddam, and thus the invasion would be "payback" for 9/11. Saddam was also alleged to have nuclear weapons, though we weren't exactly sure about that. But if he did, that meant he would provide them to Al-Qaeda, wouldn't it? I mean, if Botswana had nukes, they could provide them to Al-Qaeda, so hadn't we better invade Botswana, too? This line of reasoning could be used to justify the invasion of any nation on the planet. Any country that had a brewery could, conceivably, produce biological weapons. And they could, conceivably, sell them to Al-Qaeda. Any country that had a high-school chemistry lab could produce chemical weapons, and thus could make these weapons available to Al-Qaeda.

So the Administration set up a generic, one-size-fits-all case for the invasion, occupation, and installation of a "friendly" (i.e. puppet) government of any nation. Then it created a NIE that boldly proclaimed the right of the U.S. to invade any country that could be a threat, even if it was not a threat at the time. And when the President made his statement that "you are either with us or against us", it was clear what was implied: any world leader that failed to say what they supposed to say, or do what they were expected to do, was a potential target for invasion.
And then they pointed to the support of these world leaders as some kind of vindication of their case.

It was circular logic on an astounding scale, given credence by the mistaken belief that the U.S. wouldn't actually lie so boldly, so profoundly, so comprehensively about something.
But, of course, we now know that they did. The entire world knows it, too. The foreign leaders that jostled to be first on the list to crawl up Bush's rectum have now been removed from office and discredited. Their careers are over. And if a real threat were ever to emerge, the U.S. would be hard-pressed to persuade the international community of it's credibility. Thus, Bush has made us weaker, more vulnerable, and less prepared to deal with terrorism. On the plus side, we got rid of one of several dictators in the Middle East and one of dozens in the world. In doing so, we removed the primary obstacle to Iran's regional dominance and virtually created a failed state to take Saddam's place.

Kel at The Osterley Times has video of MSNBC's report on the Phase 2 report.

You may also wish to check out the DailyKos post titled "The Two Realities" for a look at how the neo-cons and their media minions are spinning this report. An excerpt:

Basically, there are two interpretations of the report. One conclusion is that Bush, Cheney, and other war proponents drastically stretched the true meaning of what intelligence they did have in order to make a case not borne out by that evidence. They took some true intelligence, and some known-to-be-untrustworthy intelligence, and some "intelligence" that consisted of nothing more than nonsense fabricated by the administration intended to heighten the perception of imminent massive threat, and presented it to the public, and Congress, and even the United Nations in an attempt to make the case for preemptive war against a secondary power with no connection to the actual terrorist attacks we were supposedly responding to.
The other interpretation, which Hiatt elucidates masterfully, is (1) Who Cares, It's Old News, and (2) Well, They Didn't Lie About Everything, So There, and (3) You'd Better Let Them Stretch Intelligence All They Want Next Time Too Or You'll Be Sorry Because The Terrorists Will Get You.

With regard to the summary of Hiatt's points, it sounds incredibly weak.
It is "old news" precisely because the Administration has stonewalled for so long. It is relevant because, as I said before, the world (and the American public) will now be deeply suspicious of any assessment of any future threat, even if it is real. It is also relevant because the neocons and the Bush Administration continue to conflate Iraq with 9/11 and continue to assert that the invasion and occupation of Iraq has made us safer at home. This is simply another case of the Republicans diverting attention from their lies and errors by asking the world to "move on" and "stop pointing fingers", while admitting nothing. Does anyone remember how the Republicans described (and some continue to describe) those who questioned the invasion and occupation as "traitors", "America-haters", and "supporters of terrorism"? One wonders where this grandiose aversion to "finger-pointing" was then. Iraq was, and still is, the primary "achievement" of the neocons, but now they are asking us to stop looking so closely at it. It is the primary justification for the Republican efforts to circumvent the Constitution, but this is now something that is "old news" and need not be examined further. Even as McCain (and most of the other Republicans that were up for their Party's nomination) contends that Iraq is the "pre-eminent challenge of our century", they still try to dismiss the basis for it as a settled issue.

Iraq is the foundation of Republican self-identification. One cannot be taken seriously in the GOP even today without acknowledging that the invasion was necessary and fully justified, and should be pursued to whatever capricious and ever-shifting definition of "success" or "victory" the Party comes up with. Thus, it is completely relevant to discuss that the rationale for the invasion and occupation was flawed, false, and distorted. As long as the GOP continues to support, defend, and take credit for the invasion of Iraq, then the examination of the underpinnings of that policy are fair game.

Some of the "facts" that the Administration presented turned out to be untrue, but the Administration contends that it was merely the victim of faulty intelligence. However, it is clear from former Administration officials that there was an eagerness to discard contrary evidence, and to prevent anything that might lead to contrary evidence from even being examined. In short, the Bush Administration created a situation that encouraged faulty intelligence to be provided to them, and penalised those who worked to provide a contrary case. Thus, if the Administration was a victim, it was a willing victim.

Let's not lose sight of what the Bush Administration's plan was: an easy invasion and a hand-off to Ahmed Chalabi's puppet government, and a happily-ever-after ending. Then bask in the glory of success and a permanent Republican majority, backed by a police state.
The Republicans gambled and lost.
However, the mere fact they could have gambled and won is now being trotted out as some kind of lame-ass excuse for the faithful.
So if anyone takes their mortgage payment and spends it on lottery tickets, then the mortgage company is just being a bunch of small-minded bastards if they move to foreclose on you, because you could have won millions. So let's not "point fingers" at people over why we are now living in a cardboard box in the alley. Let's "move on" and focus on getting a spot a the local homeless shelter. Let's "come together" and stop the "useless bickering" over who gambled away what and who ended up suffering. And, most importantly, let's not come away from this thinking that we shouldn't try to go for those millions again, because we could win next time. Don't you want to win?

Yes, the Republicans now want the world to acknowledge the brilliance of their policies, based not on the real outcome, but rather the best possible outcome. And this has been one of the primary trademarks of the Republicans, as I have said before: The best possible outcome is the only likely outcome. If you fail to believe that, then you somehow fail to believe in America. This means you that "hate America", and everything you say can be dismissed out of hand.
Nothing has changed. The circular logic of the neo-conservatives remains a fixture and staple of the GOP. The neo-cons remain eager and ready to employ this circular logic as often as is possible, because there is simply no price to be paid when they gamble and lose.

Sunday, June 01, 2008

You'll show us all!

Just a note about the fracas at the RBC.

For all of you idiots going on about voting rights, civil rights, and "count every vote", I will just remind you that we are talking about a primary election here, not a general election.

You have no 'right' to vote in a primary election. A primary is sponsored and sanctioned by the political party, and they can make whatever crazy rules they like. The Party can require that you pay $10,000 before you can cast your vote. They can require that you worship an idol, raise the dead, slay a dragon or defeat the Black Knight in mortal combat as a prerequisite to participation. The Party can say that all red-headed voters count as ten votes and blondes count as one-fourth of a vote. The Party can dismiss any delegate based on bad breath, bad hair day, body weight or insufficient breast size. They can make a corpse a delegate if they please. They can settle the nomination based on an arm-wrestling contest if they desire. It's an internal Party process to decide the nominee of the Party, not a general election. Nobody's "vote" is being taken away, because nobody that voted in the primary voted in a "real" election. It's that way for every Party, because that's our system. A Party is not government, it's a Party. If a Party chooses to be open to everyone, fine, but it's not some Constitutional requirement.

Second, all of you idiots saying that you are going to vote for McCain in the general election unless you get your way in the Party process are just dooming your own candidate. Unless Hillary plans to run on the Republican ticket in 2012, her ability to get Democrats to vote for the Republican candidate is not a real plus, is it? Destroying the Democratic Party is not going to get a woman elected President, unless you think Laura Bush might run in 2012. Perhaps you think voting for an elderly white male is going to make some kind of feminist statement. Yeah, that'll shake things up, won't it?

You're a bunch of electoral suicide bombers, and you're gonna show us all, aren't ya? Yeah, you're going to show the one Party that has a chance of nominating a woman as a Presidential candidate in the future that sticking your toe in that water is toxic. You're gonna teach us all that you won't vote for the Party nominee unless it's a woman, so what Party wouldn't want your fickle and highly conditional support? Well, the GOP, for one.
I mean, after seeing the GOP hijacked by Christian fundamentalists for all of these years, I'm sure that Democrats are looking at you fools and thinking "hey, we could get hijacked by single-issue voters, too! Cool!". You're making it abundantly clear that you could not care less about who is more "electable" by promising to vote for the Republican candidate. Do you perhaps think that you win some kind of prize if you vote for the winning candidate?

Here's the thing, idiots. You are fighting over who is going to get the privilege of defeating John McCain in November, and you morons are threatening to vote for McCain. See how stupid that is? See how counter-productive that is? You don't beat McCain by voting for him. So if you want a Party that is invested in beating John McCain to take you seriously, perhaps vowing to vote for him is not the most persuasive line of reasoning. And for all of you noble idiots standing up for voter's rights, I'm sure that voting for the Party that disenfranchised Florida in 2000 will make a bold statement about your concerns.

Yeah, you'll show us all. You'll make us all sorry Hillary ever got on the primary ballot in any state. You'll show us that you can't generate enough contributions to bail your own candidate out of her $30 million debt. You'll stand up for racists and Islamophobes everywhere and show how much power they really have in America. You'll show future generations of women that you're not afraid to vote against their interests if it involves some kind of tantrum. So strap on that electoral suicide vest and get out there and show us how worthless your support really is to our cause. Because the rest of us aren't going to stop believing in progressive candidates or issues simply because you want to hold your breath until you get your way.

Not like World War Two, Mr. Decider

Yeah, I know this is turning into a weekend blog, but the Minnesota weather is finally nice and I don't want to sit at home more than I have to.
There are however, two stories that I want to touch on, and they don't include the Democratic nomination race.

First, Australia is pulling out of Iraq.

SYDNEY, Australia (AP) - Australia, a staunch U.S. ally and one of the first countries to commit troops to the Iraq war five years ago, ended combat operations there Sunday, a Defense Department official said.
Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd was swept into office in November largely on the promise that he would bring home the country's 550 combat troops by the middle of 2008.
Rudd has said the Iraq deployment has made Australia more of a target for terrorism.
The combat troops are expected to return home over the next few weeks. Local media reports said the first of the soldiers had already landed in Australia on Sunday afternoon.

One of Bush's strongest foreign allies, Howard, was defeated in an election last November by Kevin Rudd. Howard was one of several Bush allies thrown out of office over the past few years, which is merely proof to the wingnuts that the entire planet now has BDS (Bush Derangement Syndrome).
Australia is bringing home her combat troops, however:

Several hundred other troops will remain in Iraq to act as security and headquarters liaisons and to guard diplomats. Australia will also leave behind two maritime surveillance aircraft and a warship to help patrol oil platforms in the Gulf.

Second, Bush gave another of his tedious speeches in which he repeated pretty much everything he's said a million times before. As usual, it was made to an essentially captive audience that was not allowed to express themselves. The "twist", such as it is, is that now Bush is saying that Iraq and Afghanistan are like WW2.


During a speech held at the graduating ceremony of the Air Force Academy cadets, U.S. President George W. Bush said the war waged by America in Iraq and Afghanistan is a “great struggle” and compared it with World War II, The New York Times reported.

Considering the fact that the WW II was regarded by many world leaders, military chiefs and historians as “the war of all wars” or “the war to end all wars” – let’s hope they were right at least on the first one – Bush’s assertion is in a very strong contrast with another one in which he said the U.S. military wasn’t exactly prepared for the aftermath of the first stages of the war.

...
The strategy of United States’ current enemies is to cause it to lose nerve and “retreat before the job is done”, said the President. He exemplified the situation using the experiences of Germany and Japan, which were defeated by the U.S. in WW II only to later become democratic states and allies.


This has been the primary neocon knee-jerk reflex.
Iraq and Afghanistan are counter-insurgency campaigns that are as different from WW2 as can be. There is no "terrorist capital" to overtake. There is no bunker headquarters to storm. The terrorists do not control territory as the Axis forces did, nor do they have air, naval, or armoured divisions. They do not have an industrial or economic infrastructure that can be bombed. The terrorists do not have the ability to conscript an army. In fact, their entire "command structure" is non-existent to the point of being what we termed "irregulars" in WW2.
WW2 was a completely conventional war. The Global War On Terror is much closer to a law enforcement effort (like the War On Drugs) than a conventional military conflict. But you don't get jingoistic cheer leading for law enforcement efforts like you do when you conflate something with a conventional war. It's like saying that the Highway Patrol is engaged in a 'war' on speeders. Yeah, our "boys" are moving in on the Speeders' capital city, breaking through the trenches with our tanks. Once we capture the head of the Speeders Army, we will finally be free of the terrible threat from these lunatics that want to threaten our families and destroy our way of life. Doncha wanna win?
Ironically, what Iraq has proven is that a few hundred "irregulars" can get the U.S. to squander a trillion dollars, more than 4000 lives, our civil rights and our alliances in some misguided foreign adventure. Their goal has been achieved, and it never was to cause us to lose our nerve or retreat before the job is done. There is no fixed, finite number of "terrorists" like there was a fixed number of Germans or Japanese.

We are 'fighting' a tactic, not a nation.

How is that like WW2?

Sunday, May 25, 2008

No Soup For You

The Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani has issued a new fatwa concerning the occupation troops.
See here and here for Prof. Juan Cole's take on Sistani's recent rumblings on the approval of attacks on foreign occupation troops. The latest development is that apparently Sistani has forbidden the sale of food to occupation troops.

Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani replied:

' Selling foodstuffs to the Occupying Powers is not permitted.'

He is also rumoured to be preparing public statements in opposition to the new SFA between Iraq and the U.S.

Sistani is a very important Shia leader. Although Sunnis would not consider such a fatwa binding on a Sunni, it certainly carries at least symbolic weight among all of the region's Muslims. The "Awakening" (Sahwa) forces have been getting a generally raw deal from the Iraqi government for some time, and a feeling that they are working against their own long-term interests has been growing. On top of this, Maliki is not honouring his end of the truce with the Sadrists and has arrested hundreds of them during Friday prayers. These Sadrists will be held in the torture centres known as the Iraqi prison system, likely without trial. While wingnuts may applaud such a show of "strength", such an action weakens Maliki by proving that he cannot be relied upon in future truces.

Of course, the ban on food sales shouldn't seriously impact the occupation troops, but it does leave the door open for further decrees of non-cooperation with those troops. It also symbolically bolsters the support of Shia leaders such as Sadr.

Sunday, May 18, 2008

McCain: "We've already won in Iraq"

The media honeymoon for McCain may be coming to an end.
Kel at The Osterley Times has video of an MSNBC segment in which a rather contorted defence of McCain's recent statements are met with ridicule and chuckling.

The first part concerns McCain's recent imaginary scenario of victory in Iraq by 2013. While the wingnuts have nearly wet themselves in ecstasy over a fictional future, the press has remained puzzled if this constitutes some kind of "timetable" for Iraq. Not so, says McCain in the video, who then goes on to say that we have already won in Iraq, right now in 2008. McCain's media defender dismisses the entire thing as "aspirational", but fails to take up the issue of our recent "win" beyond making a broad claim that "the surge is working".

I am at a loss to see how John McCain's ability to simply imagine a world in which all Republican talking points turn out to be true actually helps his Party in any way. It completely baffles me how we can spend $12 billion a week on a war (really an occupation) that apparently we have already won. Has anyone informed our military that it's "over"?
McCain seems to be living in his own little world, and the media is finally pointing it out.
For more chuckles, check out Oliver Willis' use of McCain's magical ability to change the future.

2013. Wow, we’re finally here. It feels like just yesterday it was 2008 and the world was so different from how it is now, in 2013. My, how things have changed! And strangely, everything changed for the better, especially for me. It’s as if I wrote a fictional account of how things would change and just wrote it from a positive point of view or something stupid like that.


It seems we could have saved ourselves a lot of lives and money if McCain had just imagined Iraq over in 2004.

The second part of the video is about McCain's flip-flop on Hamas, in which we learn that McCain was simply "giving Hamas the benefit of a doubt" back in 2006. More laughs all around.
McCain is a mother lode of comedic value given the dramatic contortions his "Straight Talk" has taken, but the far greater comedic gold will be found in the statements of those who try to explain and defend him. The media smells blood. Not the "lapel pin" type of blood, but rather the "WTF is this guy talking about?" kind of blood.

Of imaginary worlds with imaginary Eel Pouts

I'm passing on the Sunday Eel Pout this week, mostly because I failed to do my homework during the week. If I were to award an Eel Pout, however, it would go to Bush for the dismal failure of his "jawbone" effort in Saudi Arabia.

But Bush’s Saudi Arabia junkets are perhaps more symbolic than anything else. In fact, there’s evidence to suggest that even if the King had agreed to increase Saudi Arabia’s oil production, its effect on lowering gas prices in the U.S. would have been minimal to non-existent.

The Leader Of The Free World still thinks he can arrogantly demand that every country tremble at his whim. Israel's Olmert is the sole remaining world leader who still openly supports Bush's neocon agenda and methods. And Olmert is even less popular domestically than Bush is here. So he hangs his hat on an unpopular hard-line leader, praises Israel enthusiastically and uncritically, gives the Arab world a stern lecture about how they had better shape up or he'll stop liking them as much as he does... and then goes to the most powerful Arab leader in the world asking for a favour. But wait, it gets dumber. The Gulf States (Saudis included) have taken an immense financial beating by sticking with the dollar to denominate oil exports. Without this sacrifice on their part, the U.S. economy would be in a severe depression. And, by way of thanks, Bush slams them and talks down to them, followed by a request for them to engage in yet another expensive action on our behalf.
And, unbelievably, this didn't work.

This "do what we tell you to or we'll kick your ass" approach is inherently weak, but it is the only "diplomatic" tool in the neocon's bag. Whatever "carrots" we have go to three countries: Israel, Egypt, and Colombia. Oh, but we have arms sales, too - expensive weapons systems with gravy train maintenance contracts for the U.S. defence industry, complete with fail-safes that ensure that they can only be used against enemies that the U.S. wants them to be used against. And along with it comes American "advisers" ready to subvert your military or blackmail you by pulling the plug on these weapons systems if you get "uppity".

So, yeah, no Eel Pout this week, but you know who would get it if there was one.

Instead, I'm taking a look at another poll.

Just 39% of American voters now believe the U.S. and its allies are winning the War on Terror. That’s down six points from a month ago and the first time that figure has dropped below 40% since last September.
The latest Rasmussen Reports telephone survey also found that 27% now believe the terrorists are winning. That’s up three points from a month ago and up seven points over the past two months.
By a 69% to 14% margin, Republicans believe the U.S. and its allies are winning the War on Terror. Democrats are evenly divided on the question. Among unaffiliated voters, 21% say the U.S. and its allies are winning while 34% say the terrorists have the advantage.
A separate survey found that Americans now trust Democrats more than Republicans when it comes to issues of national security. Another survey has found that the number of people who consider themselves Democrats has grown to record levels.
Just 24% now expect the situation in Iraq to get better in the next six months while (39%) hold the opposite view and believe the situation will get worse. That’s the second straight month that a plurality has expected things to get worse. Prior to April, a plurality had held the more optimistic view for six consecutive months.
Just 28% of Likely Voters now say history will deem the U.S. mission in Iraq a success. That’s down four points from a month ago, six points over the past two months, and is the first time fewer than 30% have been optimistic on this point since last August. Most Americans–52%--now say history will judge the U.S. mission in Iraq to be a failure.

Yeah, polls go up and polls go down, but they sure aren't moving in the direction Republicans would like to see, are they? But delusional Republicans still think they can win by running on the GWOT, security, and Iraq. Watch for more of the "Scary Muslims want to make your daughter wear a burqa!" ads in the coming months. And undoubtedly we will all be treated to the "secret Muslim" talisman that only seems to work on the incredibly stupid and the incredibly brainwashed. And it will run alongside ads telling us that this 'secret Muslim' is also somehow simultaneously controlled by a Scary Black Christian Preacher, just to guarantee that nobody with any critical thinking skills will be included in the Republican target demographic. How could this possibly fail? The Wise Party Elders decreed it, after all.

Oh, and this little bit:

Just 22% now say that President George W. Bush has done a good or excellent job handling the situation in Iraq. That’s down six points over the past month as well. His overall job approval ratings have fallen to record lows in recent weeks. Most voters—55%--now say the President has done a poor job handling the situation in Iraq. A separate survey has consistently found that roughly six-out-of-ten Americans would like to see the troops brought home from Iraq within the year.

And Republicans are jubilant over McCain's imaginary future world in which we have only been in Iraq five more years. Never mind that 60% want us out within 2008. And with a majority saying that Bush has done a poor job in Iraq, yes, let's promise to continue those policies with a McCain Administration and no doubt win big. With 52% (of likely voters, mind you) of the opinion that Iraq will go down in history as a failure, perhaps now is a great time to throw out a fictional scenario in which it's merely a long, drawn-out, expensive marginal success. As long we're ramming icebergs here, maybe McCain should tie himself even closer to the Decider-on-the-downhill-slide. Oh, he's already doing that. Good job, GOP.

The thing that makes (and will continue to make) turning the GOP around so immensely difficult is that it's an inherently top-down organisation. Many of the primaries don't even "matter" in the GOP. They are merely staged to select which poor bozos will go to the County Convention and cast the vote they are told to cast by the Wise Party Elders. The GOP has much more in common with a military (or paramilitary) structure than it does with a modern political party. Those at the top do not deign to listen to those below. Their job is to tell the "footsoldiers" what to think, what to say, who to hate today, which contradictions to ignore, etc. Only now, when the top leaders are realising that they are in trouble, is the average Republican allowing themselves to critically assess the Party. The GOP has spent nearly a decade enforcing absolute ideological obedience within its ranks, purging itself of dissent, marginalising those who may be caught whispering that perhaps the Decider isn't a genius after all, doling out federal jobs based not on competence but ideological purity.... that there simply is no "fresh, new leadership" around to take the reigns. Beyond that, the Party has been so thoroughly infested with leeches and opportunistic sycophants that will say, do, or think anything that the Party requires of them that any fresh, new voices will be silenced and stillborn.

Just look at the chaos within the GOP over the selection of McCain to be the nominee. Someone who hasn't followed the Party line scrupulously his entire career is being put up as the saviour of the Party, and the Party is making damn sure that he toes the line and turns himself into a proper "player" with proper obedience to the Wise Party Elders that made his nomination a necessity in the first place. Tie him to Bush, tie him to the GWOT, tie him to the Scary Muslim Menace, tie him to Iraq, tie him to a shoddy GI Bill - make him fall into line, for Chrissakes! And then still spin him as a "maverick", with a straight face.
Moreover, what does this say to those in the Party that have actually "toed the line" all these years? It says that they're playing a sucker's game.

The GOP is following in the path of the Whigs, who became so "pure" that nobody was good enough to vote for them anymore.

This is just one of the reasons why the DLC is so dangerous on the Democratic side.
We don't really need a Democrat SS to keep us safe from internal dissent. We thrive on internal dissent. Republicans look at Democrats and see "disarray", but this is what keeps us from becoming the Jackboot Party that we see on the other side of the aisle.
It is a mystery to me why the DLC looks to a failing Party as the model for their own victory.

Saturday, May 17, 2008

GOP staggers into oblivion

This week has seen some interesting political developments, but perhaps the most compelling is that Republicans are finally waking up from a bender and discovering that their Party is in trouble.
Two insightful posts are DailyKos regarding this are found here and here.
I would like to analyse when and why the wheels came off for the GOP, the factors that will continue to hold the Republicans back, and what this means for the Democrats and the progressives.

The first thing that must be addressed is the Republicans' disdain for reality in all its forms. When Dubya "won" election by losing the popular vote, there was no voice of reason or restraint within the GOP. Nobody in the Party leadership considered that more than half of the country opposed their agenda, their candidate, and their policies. Instead, they went full speed ahead and simply pretended that America agreed with them. After 9/11, of course, the GOP dug in to a make-believe world of their own creation. The White House bragged that they "create reality", and they removed themselves from contact with anyone who did not completely buy in to the Kool-Aid drinking world they spun out of whole cloth. The examples of this are numerous. Intelligence reports were cherry-picked and controlled to produce the "evidence" they wanted, and then this "evidence" was used to convince other Republicans of the validity of this pseudo-reality. And as Republicans moved into the sheltered confines of a Fox News/talk radio world, they were told that no other media sources could be trusted but them. The average Republican slipped into a world in which Bush was infallible, in which Bush was America, and those who disagreed with Bush must therefore "hate America". Any criticism of anything wrong in the country was dismissed as hatred of America, unless it involved blaming Democrats for whatever might putatively be "wrong". Quite simply, America was incapable of doing anything "wrong" in the Fox News-fueled world. Any facts that seemed to indicate otherwise could be rejected with a wave of the hand and the use of the magic word "America-hater".
I recall pointing out to a Republican that the U.S. actually supported Saddam during his use of chemical weapons against the Kurds, that Saddam was an ally of the U.S. for nearly a decade as a counterweight to Iran in the region, that Saddam was one of a multitude of brutal dictators that our government has backed because they are useful to our foreign policy, and that Iran was one of those dictatorships before the Shah was overthrown. All of this is well-known history for those that eschew the GOP Kool-Aid, yet it was all completely dismissed as a lie by this Republican (and several others since) based on nothing more than that my mentioning these facts proved that I "hated America", and thus was not credible. One can scarcely believe the imaginary history that Republicans carry in their heads regarding America. But I digress.

America's enchantment with the Bush Administration had already eroded substantially by 2005 when Katrina hit, but the majority still believed that Bush just had some "tough breaks" in Iraq. When the utterly inept response to New Orleans' flooding occurred, however, the spell was broken for good. Rank incompetence was revealed, gross indifference was displayed, and the country at large wondered how a guy that formerly ran a stable was put in charge of FEMA. If the GOP had taken steps then, even sham efforts, to dispel the idea that they had handed over the function of government to cronies based on ideological agreement, then we likely would be having a different conversation today. Instead, the Republicans denied any failure. They pointed the finger at the Louisiana state government, at Mayor Nagin, at the public for treasonous dissent, the treacherous media, and at the victims themselves. Eventually, "Brownie" was to become a human sacrifice and the only thing that the GOP learned was that incompetence must be covered up better. Secrecy was increased, "disloyal" elements were purged from government jobs, wagons were circled, and the Republican world view became even more firmly entrenched in a "with us or against us" mindset. No longer were we all Americans; we were either traitors or patriots. The "good news" and "progress" in Iraq flowed from the White House on a daily basis, in stark contrast to the undeniable facts that indicated a quagmire without a clear-cut triumph that Americans had truly believed would have occurred by then. And the pseudo-reality that was intravenously fed to the faithful spoke of a brilliant success in Iraq, a popular President that could do no wrong, and darkly hinted at a tiny number of domestic traitors who wanted to destroy America and that were universally reviled, except by terrorists.

The 2006 elections were merely the buzzing of a gnat within the ironclad fortress of the Republican pseudo-reality. Everyone loved them and believed in them, anything they said would be eagerly lapped up by the nation without examination, and the only "problem" was that some RINOs had been taken out of power. Prior to the 2004 election, Republicans had been locked into a perpetual time warp where it was always 1994. After the 2006 elections, they moved in lockstep to a newer false world where it is always 2002, in which they exist today.

This is why I point to polls so frequently in this blog. Republicans really, truly believe they are still wildly popular. And while Republicans dismiss polls (as they do anything that contradicts the pseudo-reality) by saying "polls go up and polls go down", the reality is that those numbers simply are not going up for them. Republican turnout in the primaries has been a pale shadow of the Democrats' numbers, and the number of people identifying themselves as Republicans has dropped while those of Democrats' is increasing to record levels. The GOP agenda has been reduced to an obstructionist campaign, Bush is ignored by world leaders and the domestic public, and elections simply aren't going their way.

For an example of the severity of this Republican disconnect with reality, see the take on McCain's recent speech shown below. McCain posited an imaginary world in 2013 in which America has "won" in Iraq, and Republicans seem to have lapped it up as if it were actually true and a foregone conclusion.

Nice move Mac. In one fell swoop, he exposes the anti-war left for what they are: Pacifist appeasers who don't believe troops should be sent anywhere, anytime, for any reason. They will be left bleating on deaf ears about bringing troops home now.
Normal Americans support military action against America's enemies as long as the cause is just and the exit strategy is known. They are patient and they can live with a date, even if it is 5 years down the road. Before today, McCain was saddled with the perception of a perpetual war combined with the scurrilous 100-years-in-Iraq lie by the left. Unaddressed, that is a deal breaker for McCain at the ballot box. No longer.
The nice part is that he can assess as he goes and decide in 2013, if he wins a second term, whether that is the prudent course at that time.
In the meantime, he has just grabbed a pile of moderate, war-weary Democrats right out of the D column.
Bill Dupray at The Patriot Room


Wow.
Yes, this is what America has been waiting for: A man who has the courage to invent an imaginary world in which Republicans are always right.
Polls show that 33% of Americans want us to withdraw from Iraq now, and the clear majority want us out in one year. However, these must not be "Normal Americans", in Mr. Dupray's view. McCain imagines that we will "win" in Iraq within five years, so it's a done deal, apparently.
Just wondering, though...what if things don't turn out like they do in McCain's imagination? Won't he keep us in Iraq? I mean, Bush had some pretty neat imaginary scenarios, too, but here we are still "surging" along. How is this supposed to appeal to "a pile of moderate war-weary Democrats"? McCain simply imagines that there will only be five more years of a war that the majority of Americans already feel was a mistake, a war that only 19% say that they're looking for a candidate that
is willing to pursue until we "succeed", so obviously McCain has the election in the bag. The Decider imagined that the "surge" would put the Iraqi government in control of all the provinces by last November, but that didn't seem to induce giddiness or a massive increase in support for Republicans or the occupation. But now McCain is imagining some stuff, so it's all different, right?
By the way, take a look at this analysis of why McCain's imaginary victory is unlikely.

In the very odd world that Republicans have constructed, merely predicting something means that it will happen. I often laughed over right-wing bloggers who quoted military commanders saying that a campaign has the objective to do such-and-such, and then crowing over it as if this means it has already happened or is inevitable. To doubt such statements is the equivalent of doubting America itself in their minds.

There was a time, a relatively brief time, in which Americans felt unified by the Iraq invasion and cheered unquestioningly like football fans for the "home team", but that time has passed and the buzz has worn off. This doesn't mean that people "hate America", but it does mean that invoking 9/11 and shoving flags and eagles in our faces won't gain much traction any more. Such jingoistic, spectator-sport approaches require big, quick wins with clearly-defined "good guys" and "bad guys". The Long War model never held significant appeal to Americans, and Republicans only pulled it out as 'what they said all along' only after hopes for a big, quick win had already faded. It came off as bait and switch, and we felt deceived. Republicans only offered charges of treason to keep the restless in line. To most, the threat of being "dumped" by Republicans, of being exiled from the Cool Kids Club, of failing to make the grade as a good Decider-droid was toothless and spiteful.

Look, Republicans, it's this simple: nobody believes you any more.
Pelosi and Reid really aren't hated and reviled by the American people. Nobody but you believes that advocating withdrawal from Iraq means that they favour the destruction of America or that they oppose any war for any reason or that they want us all to become Muslims. Nobody but you thinks that the word "liberal" has magical powers to silence dissent. Nobody but you believes that the majority of the country is part of the "Far Left". Nobody but you thinks that it's more important to be loyal to the Bush Administration than it is to admit the existence of problems and deal with them. Nobody but you thinks that dissent against a Republican President is treason, but that dissent against a Democratic President is your patriotic duty.

The GOP has offered America a team of droids that back their Party over the interests of their own constituents. That's a losing proposition in politics. Nobody cares if a candidate is a good Bush Team player or is "on board" with the Party agenda. Merely stating that a candidate fails to support the GOP talking points simply does not disqualify a candidate in the eyes of the American electorate.
It would be really nice if you all continued to believe these things, however, because it will discredit your Party for a good, long time. Please, please keep on pointing to a picture of a Democrat, saying the word "liberal", and expecting to win big. Please keep on saying that Iraq is about making us safer at home. Please keep on telling us that protecting telecoms from lawsuits is the same as fighting terrorists. And please keep on portraying Bush as an infallible genius that only the "Far Left" disagrees with.

It is true that the three special elections in which Republicans have recently lost to Democrats are not astoundingly good news for progressives. These are conservative Democrats. However, those are three robots that won't be in Congress playing obstructionist games at the orders of the GOP. Those are three districts in which voters will presumably learn that casting a ballot for a Democrat doesn't mean that the world will end. Those are three examples that will be lurking in the back of every Republican Congressman's mind when the Party tells them to do something against their own electoral interests. And those are three cases that will come to mind when a Democrat in Congress thinks about caving to the GOP.

The elections in November will prove to everyone outside of the Republican pseudo-reality that the traditional "fear and smear" tactics don't work any more. Even Republicans that hold on to their seats will see the margins dwindle enough to make a bolt from the lockstep march of the Party dictates seem viable. Obstructionism will no longer be glamorous, and Republicans will have to come up with something other than hatred and a police-state fear-mongering. The Evangelical Christians are already peeling away, along with veterans and fiscal conservatives. The Party will have to stand for something more than "We Hate The Democrats". And the Republican dictate that "you're either all in or all out" will have to be abandoned.

Saturday, May 10, 2008

The end of the ride

For well over six months now, polls have shown that Iraq remains a millstone around the neck of the GOP. Surely, this was also the case prior to six months ago, but the Republican Noise Machine has been confident that the public opinion will "turn around" once the "facts are out" about the wonderful "progress" in Iraq. Those trend lines in the polls shown below are not encouraging, however.

The majority think the invasion of Iraq was a mistake.
The ramifications of this are profound. This means that the entire idea of Iraq being part of the Global War On Terror, the notion that we are over there to keep them from coming over here, the idea that invading Iraq has made us safer, and the assertions that only the "Far Left" holds these views have all been discredited. To deny this would mean that the majority of Americans support terrorism, are trying to militarily undermine their own country, are looking for bold new ways to make us less safe, and are part of the "Far Left". For the Republicans, the message on Iraq has essentially been reduced to "we're stuck there, so get over it".

Only 19% think it's important that their Presidential candidiate is willing to stay in Iraq until we "succeed", whatever "success" is.
Again, the ramifications of these numbers are significant. The "cut and run" talisman no longer bears weight when over 3/4 of the voters see a willingness to be flexible and leave before we have achieved "success" as desirable in Presidential candidate. McCain's "hundred years" statement, regardless of the context it is put in, clearly puts him on the 19% side. We are now in Iraq to influence whether puppet leaders or Iraqi nationalists will control the country. Nothing about that speaks of any "vital interests" for the U.S. Nothing about that inspires any desire to "kick some butt" or "bring 'em on". Nothing about that lends credence to a willingness to spend $12 billion a week on a military effort to bring about a foreign country's political reconciliation. Pictures of flags and eagles, accusations of treason, and scary stories now fail to suspend the critical thinking skills of the American electorate. The public wants an exit strategy, and the Republicans are only offering a quagmire that may or may not, at some point, become a basically "break even" scenario.

A third of the public wants to withdraw from Iraq, and only about 20% want to continue the "surge".
Apparently 33% of the nation is now part of the "Far Left", because Republicans keep telling us that only the "Far Left" wants to pull out of Iraq. The public, however, continues to see people who are clearly not traitorous nor wild-eyed leftists advocating withdrawal or drawing down force levels. Reality is not on the side of the GOP propaganda masters. Military commanders have stated that we will need to send more troops, not fewer, if we are to achieve "success", yet this option now draws only 8% support. Americans clearly no longer want to "win" in Iraq - or more accurately, no longer believe in what the Republicans consider a "win".

All three of these polls point to Iraq as a serious liability for the GOP, yet the Party has steadfastly lined up behind the most unpopular President in modern history and that Party's presumptive nominee has completely embraced that unpopular President's policies on Iraq. The GOP's traditional alliance with evangelical Christians is also highly questionable, with it being increasingly likely that these voters will choose to sit on their hands come November. A faltering economy is always bad news for the incumbent Party, and the Republicans are split between trying to come up with more and more bizarre ways to define the word "recession" or those who wish to continue to push tax cuts that have proven a failure. 80% of the public believes that the economic stimulus cheques will not make much difference. The percentages of the electorate who believe that upper-income citizens and corporations pay too much in taxes is in the single digits. People all across the country have seen the result of the Bush tax cuts: collapsing infrastructure, income inequality, offshoring jobs, and declines in the educational system. McCain only wants to continue this failed policy.

And the model of governance that the GOP has pushed has increasingly been the object of ridicule. Across the board, citizens have seen gross incompetence and total cronyism from the federal government. Turning over the government responsibilities to people based on their loyalty to the Bush agenda has turned out to be a huge failure. Staggering inefficiency and naked partisanship is the order of the day. Do you think anyone trying to get a passport really cares if the people processing it are opposed to Roe v. Wade or if they have a close personal relationship with Jesus? Do you think that anyone waiting for disaster relief is consoled by the fact the morons that bungled the job are reliable GOP donors? Does anyone who witnessed Doan's "memory problems" really think that's understandable if she was a loyal supporter of the President?
Not really. People want their tax dollars spent wisely by competent people acting in an efficient manner. Whether or not they have sworn unending loyalty to the most unpopular President in modern history is not high on the public's list of priorities. Yet McCain has said nothing in criticism of the rank incompetence Bush has cultivated. In fact, McCain is completely beholden to the Party apparatus that thrust loyalty as the primary consideration in the federal government. Morale among federal employees has plummeted, recruiting competent staff has become difficult, and retaining them even harder. At the same time, the value of having a Bush Administration position on your resume has dwindled. It marks one as an incompetent crony that was hired and retained based not on merit and skills, but rather ideological purity.

McCain has failed to say anything that he would do differently than Bush. Not one thing.

The sleeper issue, however, are House and Senate races. The Democrats can expect big gains in the House, and possibly three or four seats gained in the Senate. Republicans that do hold on to their seats will see their margins of victory dwindle alarmingly. Those not up for election until 2010 will surely see that loyalty to the Bush agenda is nothing more than a suicide pact. Already we are seeing one-size-fits-all "cookie-cutter" ads from the GOP. Just replace the face and the name, and these generic ads could run in any district. Democrats, too, are seeing the potential to be had by standing up to the Republican agenda. The next President will certainly find a Congress much less compliant to traditional Republican talking points and much less responsive to scare themes. GOP intimidation of the media will also become more difficult as it becomes readily apparent that the punditry is seriously out of touch with the reality within the country.

A smaller percentage of the public now believes in the Bush agenda than believes in the existence of magical fairies, yet we don't see pundits weighing in on how magical fairies come down on the issues of the day. No network considers how magical fairies will react to a news story or if magical fairies are sufficiently patriotic. I have yet to see a news anchor ponder over whether a national issue is "good news or not for magical fairies". We have, however, seen Republican policies that essentially rely on copious amounts of fairy dust to solve problems.

Nothing is improving for Republicans in public opinion. Jingoism now shows diminishing returns. The war that was supposed to unite America and guarantee a permanent Republican majority has now become a permanent liability for the Party that even "victory" will not mitigate. Self-identification as a Democrat has reached an all-time high. And if the Republicans lose the White House, the gravy train for right-wing think tanks, crooked contractors, and hate-mongers will come to an end.

Results from a CBS/NYT poll are shown below:

"Looking back, do you think the United States did the right thing in taking military action against Iraq, or should the U.S. have stayed out?" N=1,065 adults, MoE ± 3






.


Right Thing Stayed Out Unsure


% % %


4/25-29/08
37 57 6

3/28 - 4/2/08
34 62 4


3/15-18/08
36 59 5


2/20-24/08
38 58 4

1/9-12/08
36 58 6

12/5-9/07
41 54 5

10/12-16/07
45 51 4

9/14-16/07
39 53 8

----------------------------------------------------

"Which is more important to you in a presidential candidate: someone who commits to staying in Iraq until the U.S. succeeds, or someone who is flexible about when to withdraw U.S. troops from Iraq?" N=956 registered voters, MoE ± 3






.


Commits to
Staying
Flexible Unsure


% % %


4/25-29/08
19 77 4


Also from a CNN poll:

"Which comes closest to your view about what the U.S. should now do about the number of U.S. troops in Iraq? The U.S. should send more troops to Iraq. The U.S. should keep the number of troops as it is now. The U.S. should withdraw some troops from Iraq. OR, The U.S. should withdraw all of its troops from Iraq."





.



Send More Keep Same
Number
Withdraw
Some
Withdraw
All
Unsure


% % % % %


4/28-30/08
8 21 35 33 3


12/6-9/07
10 19 30 39 2


9/7-9/07
10 23 36 29 3


6/22-24/07
17 16 24 39 3


11/17-19/06
16 21 27 33 3


10/27-29/06
15 17 28 34 6