Saturday, August 18, 2007

Bush's credibility is blown before the surge report is issued

Despite a surge in PR that essentially consists of Republicans endlessly repeating "the surge is working" for weeks on end, most Americans have already made up their minds that the report in September, putatively to be made by Petraeus, is a sham.
Republicans have made a great show of treating the report as a critical factor in their decision regarding the surge's fate. Since it seems that people don't trust this report, where does that leave these politicians?

If they hide behind the September report, the public will see them as relying on yet more "fixed" intelligence to falsely justify the continuing occupation.
If they reject the September report, the public will wonder why Republicans put so much faith in it during the months leading up to its release.

It's become increasingly clear that the report will not even be authored by Petraeus. The Bush Administration has repeatedly referred to "Petraeus' report" and "Petraeus' plan" for at least six months now. Now, however, the word has come down that the report will be written by the Administration. The Bush Administration has credibility only with its base these days, and those people would believe Bush if he claimed the Moon was made of green cheese, so that is hardly a vote of confidence. The only reason the September report was given any more importance than one of Bush's weekly radio addresses was because it would ostensibly come from an allegedly "independent" source: Petraeus. As usual, the White House innocently claims they have no idea how people could ever have even conceived the notion that the report would be made by Petraeus. This statement, like most from the Bush Administration these days, has some serious credibility issues. The more often the White House makes statements that nobody but their base believe to be true, the more irrelevant the Administration appears. The neocons can sputter in rage about Bush being the Decider and the Commander in Chief, but the public is increasingly looking at November 2008 as relief for that situation.

Despite resetting the "clock" for the surge from February to July (no fair - one tenth of the total surge force wasn't in place until July), despite a manic frenzy of assertion of the surge's success, despite non-stop characterisation of dissent against the occupation of Iraq as treason, despite shill reports by those who falsely claimed to be "critics" of the surge, despite intense pressure on military commanders to come up with good news in large quantities and on a regular basis, despite heavy punishment and censorship of "boots on the ground" who express contrary views of the surge, and despite allying ourselves with forces who openly express disloyalty to the elected government of Iraq, the surge still has failed to gain popular acceptance or credibility beyond those who initially backed it in January.

The surge was not really even Petraeus' plan. It was handed to him by the White House and Congress confirmed him to carry it out, whether or not it was sound. Republicans have used the "in for a penny, in for a pound" approach to portray this confirmation as an endorsement of the surge by the Democrats. Nobody has bought into that besides those same few people who believe everything Bush says already.

Already we are seeing snarling epithets by the right-wing denouncing anyone who doesn't completely accept the September assessment as the gospel truth to be "traitors", "defeatists", and "terrorist supporters". Do Republicans really think that accusing the majority of Americans of treason is an effective strategy to gain their support? Or is it merely a pretense to justify Republicans ignoring the public?
How many Republicans up for election in November '08 really truly think that denouncing their own constituents as traitors is a winning tack?

I said back in May that this would be the strategy Republicans would use:
Treason. It's the last card they can play, and the one most likely to make them look crazy.


The Republicans have staked everything on the surge. They cannot possibly admit it is a failure; they can only sinuously re-define the word "success" and hope most people don't laugh in their faces. They can only lie and say that the objective of the surge all along has been to shuffle Al-Qaeda from one area to another while watching the impotent al-Maliki government go through its death throes and the tiny, useless Iraqi military stumbling around doing nothing.

story from Xinhua

Poll shows most Americans [do] not trust Sept. Iraq report

WASHINGTON, Aug. 17 (Xinhua) -- A majority of Americans do not trust the upcoming report by top U.S. commander in Iraq on the progress of the war, according to a new poll released on Friday.

U.S. President George W. Bush has frequently asked Congress and the American people to withhold judgment on his so-called "troop surge" in Iraq until David Petraeus, the top commander in Iraq, and Ryan Crocker, U.S. ambassador to Iraq, issue their progress report in September.

But according to a CNN/Opinion Research Corp. poll released on Friday, 53 percent of people polled said they suspect that the military assessment of the situation will try to make it sound better than it actually is.

The poll also indicates that most of America's mind is made up about the war -- 72 percent said the report will have no effect on their view of the war.

The survey was based on interviews of 1,029 Americans by telephone between Aug. 6 and 8.

Commenting on the poll, White House spokesman Tony Snow said on Friday that he hoped that "people do not try to engage in personal attacks on Gen. Petraeus or Ambassador Crocker."


From the CNN report:

CNN Polling Director Keating Holland said he doesn't think the mistrust is directed at Petreaus as much as it is what he represents.

Holland said, "I suspect most people are hearing the words 'general' and 'Iraq' and that's what they're basing their opinion on."

He added, "It does seem to indicate that anyone associated with the Bush administration may be a less than credible messenger for the message that there is progress being made in Iraq."


Could that be why the Bush Administration has implied for so long that the report would be Petraeus'? The White House makes "positive reports" about Iraq virtually every single day. Why would one in September be seen as particularly illuminating if it wasn't coming from Petraeus?
Just as Bush has repeatedly implied that Iraq was behind 9/11 without saying that directly, so the White House has repeatedly implied that the report would be authored by Petraeus without saying it directly. While this may be seen by right-wing bloggers as some kind of "cover", it appears completely weasel-like to those who haven't drank the Republican Kool-Aid. At some point, the Republicans will have to stop essentially waging a primary election campaign and deal with the American public at large.

The boots on the ground speak: Diyala

This is an excerpt from a post from a blog that I have noted before.
Army of Dude is a blog written a soldier named Alex currently serving in Diyala, the province that neocons wax ecstatic over as proof that the surge is "working". This particular pair of "boots on the ground", however, sees things quite differently from the press releases written by commanders trying hard not to be the next Shinseki.

I strongly encourage you to take a moment to read not only the entire post in Alex's blog, but the other entries. One point of interest is his post detailing the pressure to re-enlist.

In the excerpt that follows, Alex outlines possible nominees for the stupidest mistakes made by the military in the areas he has served. Emphases are mine.

Working with 1920s – A Sunni insurgent group we’ve been battling for months, responsible for the death of my friend and numerous attacks, agreed to fight Al Qaeda alongside us. Since then, they’ve grown into a much more organized, lethal force. They use this organization to steal cars and intimidate and torture the local population, or anyone they accuse of being linked to Al Qaeda. The Gestapo of the 21st century, sanctioned by the United States Army.

The Surge – The beefing up of ground forces in Iraq at the beginning of the year, started by the 82nd Airborne. Unit deployments were moved up several months to maintain a higher level of boots on the ground to quell the Baghdad situation. What most don’t realize is the amount of actual fighting troops in a brigade, something in the area of 2,000 soldiers in a brigade of 5,000 depending on what unit it is. So for every 2,000 fighters, there are 3,000 pencil pushers sucking up resources in every brigade that was surged. A logistical nightmare that, surprise, failed miserably. The increase of troops in Baghdad pushed the insurgents to rural areas (like Diyala), hence our move here in March. The surge was nothing more than a thorn in the side of nomadic fighters having to move thirty five miles while the generals watched Baghdad with stubborn eyes.

Two Companies Clearing Baqubah – Which brings us to the next nominee. Since Baghdad was the showcase of the war and Baqubah was brimming with super IEDs taking our Bradleys and Abrams tanks, it was decided that a unit needed to be sent there to assist the cavalry unit who averaged a death per week. But how many to send? Someone, somehow, somewhere decided that two companies of Strykers would be adequate to take down what Al Qaeda had deemed their headquarters in Iraq. What came about this oversight? Two hours into the first mission, my friend was killed in a massive IED blast that busted the hell out of the squad leader’s face, resulting in traumatic brain injury and facial reconstruction surgery. The vehicle commander tore his ACL from the concussion. Shrapnel being thrown around the inside of the truck caught one dude in the knee as a dude in the back hatch got rattled around, bruising his back as the other in the hatch was thrown completely out the vehicle. He’s been quiet since then, and was sent home soon after. Returning fire from us and the Bradleys killed an untold number of kids unlucky enough to be in the school next to our position. A wrecker sent out to pick up the destroyed Stryker was the next victim of an IED explosion, killing two men inside. Two more wreckers were sent out, one for the Stryker, one for the now totaled wrecker. As we pulled out that evening, local Iraqis, men, women and children, danced in celebration by the massive crater where the Stryker had been. At once we realized reinforcements were needed but we didn’t get any for two more months. Many more men were killed because we were stretched to our operational breaking point. But there was always more to do. Whoever made the decision to send less than an infantry battalion should be in jail right now.

The Extension – This wasn’t too much of a surprise to us, as we knew in the back of our minds that an extension was in our future. What was surprising was the fact that everyone in Iraq was extended to fifteen month deployments. It was meant to give every unit at least a year in between deployments, as some were coming back to Iraq after only ten months back in the states. Now at the end, it’s not hard to assess the achievements of our three extra months. It seems at a quick glance that we pacified the city, street by street. There was a lull in American deaths because, simply, we absorbed all the bomb blasts or found the IEDs before they could detonate on us. As deadly as they are, deep buried IEDs must take a lot of time to build and emplace. The ones used against us were meant for the cavalry unit, who didn’t have the manpower to patrol the streets like we have been. After we arrived, there were few bombs that haven’t been sitting in the ground for several months already. The enemy ran out of ways to kill us until the ingenious idea of putting bombs in houses took hold. Instead of blowing us up in armored vehicles, they thought about doing it inside an abandoned house. What kills you isn’t the bomb, but the foundation of the house that comes crashing down after the explosion. Wires and triggers are hidden behind doors or underneath rugs, so when we go out and clear blocks and blocks of houses, there’s a pressure plate waiting for you at the foot of the stairs. Only your eyes can save you at this point. That tactic has been born from our proclivity to redundantly clear neighborhoods, and the extension is guilty of claiming lives of men who are running on too little sleep, walking into house after house in the desert heat. When you’re worried about how much water you have left and the trucks are too far away to get more, you tend to miss the trip wire in the dark stairwell. Twelve month deployments are a burden on your body and mind. Asking men for three more months is not only unfair but deadly.

Seven Men Killed At The Same Time – Finally, one of the lowest, saddest points of the deployment came in May. One night, a helicopter spotted several men gathered in the road with a large object. Permission was asked to fire a Hellfire missile at them, as they were obvious IED emplacers. Permission was emphatically denied, but someone decided that a Stryker platoon should head out there anyway to check it out. In tow was a Russian reporter. On a road called Trash Alley, they hit a massive deep buried IED. Everyone in the truck except the driver, six Americans and one Russian, dead. And they didn’t need to be there at all. A helicopter could have killed the insurgents with breathtaking ease. Instead, those guys and the one with the detonator got away in the night. Justice was never done.


War supporters always tell us to "listen to the boots on the ground". What goes unsaid, however, are the consequences for those "boots" who fail to repeat the scripted lines.

As for me, I started to sign these entries with my initials long ago to avoid detection by superiors. I could and still can get in trouble for what I’ve written. Lately this blog has been passed around to dudes of every rank, and those who would be punishing me have become readers.


...and also:

In the future, I want my children to grow up with the belief that what I did here was wrong, in a society that doesn’t deem that idea unpatriotic.


This soldier's post is a heart-breaking read and I sincerely hope that nobody reading this sees this an opportunity to punish someone who has served their country but fails to squawk like a parrot when cued. The Republican's crazy "dissent is treason" mantra should be excepted in the case of the troops, but sadly it is the case where this belief is applied most stringently. "Support the troops", my ass. They mean "support the troops that say what they are told to say, and punish those who are brave enough to speak the truth".

Like most war testimonials, this one tells a story of someone fighting for their friends rather than some glorious cause. That's what makes me deeply suspicious of accounts from tools like Michael Yon, who is forever spinning tales of soldiers spouting the Party line and saying things that sound like they come from Tony Snow's mouth. Maybe officers talk like that, officers seeking quick promotion with little regard for the men under their command, that is. The "grunts", however, don't have time for that and don't see any future in it. They know better than to speak their minds around such officers, which only serves to reinforce the fantasy world of these craven toadies. This lot was still chirping away with glowing reports of 'enemy' body counts and inevitable success in Vietnam right up to the bitter end. Do we never learn?

I think that the right-wing had better brace themselves for more stories such as Alex's when the surge is over. These guys won't keep their mouths shut forever, especially once they find out to what devious lengths the Bush Administration will go to when denying them their benefits and care. Once they start to look for a job and find Republican fundies mouthing "we support your service" tonelessly while tossing their resumes in the trash, they will surely wise up to the immense fraud, lies, and hypocrisy at the foundation of the neocon's 'support' for the troops. Having built up the troops as a nearly angelic group beyond reproach or criticism, the Republicans will find it very difficult indeed to suddenly label these men and women as 'traitors' and 'defeatists'.

The major strategic "progress" of the surge has been in enlisting the sectarian militias in the effort to fight Al-Qaeda, which somehow is the most important thing.
Not only does this tactic glaringly point out the failure of the Iraqi military and police, but it also puts us directly in league with those who have tortured and killed innocent Iraqis for years in a short-term bid to tackle a relatively minor cause of the massive instability in Iraq. It was the (Iraqi) police and military who were supposed to take the lead in the surge, not our troops and certainly not the gangs that the surge was supposed to disarm. These sectarian militias are little more than street gangs, and their objectives are not nobler or more evolved than common street gangs, yet our alliance with them is the major reason behind the "pacification". In an earlier post, Alex poignantly describes an exchange with one of these militia's members:

For now, our relationship with 1920 is one of mutual distrust and hatred, a sign of the times. A conversation between a member of my platoon and a 1920 source is ripe with foreboding on the future of this partnership, and of the war to come.
“Do you want to kill me?” asked the soldier.
“Yes,” replied the source, coldly and without emotion. “But not today.
”


Does this sound like a tactic we can put our faith in? Or does it sound like a short-term move to create the illusion of long-term success while a report is due? I wish those who support the surge and claim that it's "working" would explain how it will deal the sectarian militias once the reason for this alliance of convenience disappears. It is nothing short of madness to keep on repeating that Al-Qaeda is the big problem facing Iraq, but that is exactly what we gambled the farm on. Instead, for all of this compromise with the gangs, we have merely managed to keep Al-Qaeda moving around. There is no "reconciliation"; there is only a temporary distraction that the Iraqi government, police, and military are completely squandering. And we have bought this sham of success with the extension of soldiers like Alex.

SCO begins to form as a counter to U.S. might

Beyond the announcement of Russian bomber runs, this story details the rise of the SCO (Shanghai Co-operation Organisation), which has the potential to create a powerful bloc of Central Asian states in alliance with Russia, China, India, Pakistan, and Iran. Our counter to such a bloc is Afghanistan, a country in which our puppet barely controls the capitol. Our "pull" with NATO is largely limited to Britain, and we've gone to that well far too often

Once we relied on Russia and China to keep each other in check, much as we once relied on Hussein's Iraq to keep Iran in check. With Russia and China on the Security Council, the SCO would instead prove a powerful check on PNAC's ambitions for a glorious "American Century" where the rest of the world marvels at our power and gladly bends over at our every whim. In Pakistan, it's looking like our puppet Musharraf is going to lose power due to democracy. India, while friendly, stopped meekly bowing to the U.S. long ago. And Iran, the current scapegoat for everything wrong with the world, no longer has Iraq to worry about. With the exception of China, all of these players in the SCO are at least nominal democracies, which gives the lie to Bush and other Republican's fantasy that democracy will pave the way to the easy triumph of our foreign policies across the globe. Also, with the possible exception of Iran, all of the countries in the SCO are nuclear powers.

China has rapidly developed into a strong naval power while the U.S. is still committed to the defence of Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, and to a lesser extent Australia and New Zealand. China has no such commitments on the other side of the planet from them as we do. The costs of our military efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan are kept "off the books" largely due to the sale of debt to China, ironically financing their military and industrial development with the interest. The U.S. is the only serious impediment to China's hegemony, and our financial and industrial resources are increasingly being put in China's hands. Putting financial or trade sanctions on China would be suicide for the U.S. American companies have been falling over themselves to close plants at home and move them to China. While taking a financial hit doing so, China could easily cause a collapse of the dollar by dumping their holdings on the market. Such a move would undoubtedly persuade several economies to move to the euro as the reserve currency, which would be an unmitigated catastrophe for the U.S. economy.

Russia, too, has seen a comeback due to its energy resources. Sanctions against Russia would cut off Europe's energy supplies. While not a formidible threat to take on the U.S. itself militarily, Russia remains a regional military superpower with a more advanced military than its Eastern European neighbours our its former client states to the south. They are also free of any military commitments on the other side of the globe now that Cuba is on its own. For decades, Russia has been treated to a condescending approach from the U.S. and, as a result, has failed to back American efforts and regional interests.

Meanwhile, the U.S. pours several dozens of millions into Israel every single day, mostly in the form of "loans" that are forgiven before they are due for re-payment. None of the SCO countries have commitments like this. The two other major recipients of our foreign aid, Egypt and Colombia, do nothing to enhance our economic or military interests and are among the best examples of "democracy" gone wrong.

What reason do we have to believe that a nation such as Iraq, when "stabilised", will be a strong ally of the U.S. and back our foreign policy interests? With sanctions, and later, invasion and hapless occupation, the U.S. has reduced a modern nation with a high standard of living to a disaster state without electrical or water delivery infrastructure, much less security. How many of those tortured in Iraqi prisons by a puppet government controlled from the White House will see the U.S. as a friend? How many of those forced from the "progress" in Iraq by fleeing to the "enemy" state of Syria will view the U.S. as a source for "good"? Once the dollars stop flowing from the American taxpayer into the pockets of corrupt Iraqi politicians, how many will continue to follow the script they are handed?
Or will Iraqis look to the SCO as a natural ally, an alliance free of the negative associations with the U.S?
The best possible outcome is the only likely outcome in Bush-land. The rest of us, however, had better start to look beyond slogans and flag-waving down the road at what awaits us when the world stops seeing us as the solution, and instead as the problem.


Russia to resume Cold War bomber flights

By Adrian Blomfield in Moscow and agencies
Last Updated: 5:30pm BST 17/08/2007

Russia will immediately resume long-range strategic bomber flights on a "permanent" basis, ending a 15-year suspension of the missions, President Vladimir Putin has said.

Mr Putin said a halt in long-range bombers' flights after the Soviet collapse had affected Russia's security as other nations had continued such missions - a oblique reference to the US.

"I have made a decision to resume regular flights of Russian strategic aviation," he said.

"Starting today, such tours of duty will be conducted regularly and on a strategic scale.

"Our pilots have been grounded for too long; they are happy to start a new life."

Soviet bombers routinely flew such missions to areas from which nuclear-tipped cruise missiles could be launched at the United States. But that stopped in the post-Soviet economic meltdown.

In Washington, a State Department Spokesman said the US was not troubled by the decision.

"It's interesting. We certainly are not in the kind of posture we were with what used to be the Soviet Union. It's a different era. If Russia feels as though they want to take some of these old aircraft out of mothballs and get them flying again, that's their decision."


Yes, arrogance is always the best defence. The best possible outcome is the only likely outcome. Is there any real reason to worry?

Mr Putin's comments came as he and his Chinese counterpart, Hu Jintao, attended an unprecedented show of joint military force amid fears that the Russian leader is trying to turn an increasingly powerful central Asian alliance into a second Warsaw Pact.

The United States will be anxiously watching the military manoeuvres - held under the auspices of the six-member Shanghai Co-operation Organisation (SCO) - from afar after its request to send observers was rejected.

Washington has plenty of reasons to be uneasy. Founded in 2001, the SCO, which includes the four central Asian nations of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyztan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan as well as China and Russia, is rapidly gaining a reputation as an anti-Western organisation.

That image seems to be one that Mr Putin is happy to cultivate. Analysts say that the Russian president believes the organisation is emerging as a bloc that is rapidly becoming powerful enough to stand up to the West.

Russia's most pro-government newspapers, often used by the Kremlin as propaganda vehicles, yesterday proclaimed the arrival of an "anti-Nato" alliance and a "Warsaw Pact 2". At the annual SCO summit in the Kyrgyz capital Bishkek yesterday, Mr Putin praised the alliance's growing strength. "Year after year the SCO becomes a more significant factor in strengthening security and stability in the central Asian region," he said.

In a thinly disguised swipe at Washington, which mirrored earlier attacks on American "unilateralism" and "diktat", he added: "We are convinced that any attempts to resolve global and regional problems alone are useless."

For the most part, the summit's agenda concentrated on promoting energy co-operation in central Asia, whose vast resources have elevated the region's geopolitical importance.

The West has been desperate to strengthen its presence in the area but has begun to fall behind both Russia and China in a race for influence that has been compared to the 19th century Great Game, when Britain and Russia competed for control of the region.

Yet the SCO has wider ambitions. Pakistan, India and Mongolia all want to join - as does Iran, whose president, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad, attended the summit as guest of honour, a title bound to rile Washington. Iranian membership of the SCO would pose an enormous headache for the United States. Like Nato, its treaty states that an attack on one member is regarded as an attack on all, raising the prospect that the United States could find itself aligned against both Russia and China if it invaded Iran. Yet, for all Mr Putin's posturing, most analysts believe that an underlying antagonism between the member states means that the SCO is far from cohesive, a charge that reduces its chances to be effective.

Thrown together for the moment by mutual expediency, Russia and China have historically distrusted each other. Beijing, which plays host to the Olympic Games next summer, has much less interest in antagonising the United States and would almost certainly block Iran's accession to the club.

Similarly, the central Asian nations are wary of the two regional superpowers - although, for the time being, the tolerance of Beijing and Moscow for their autocratic ways is more attractive than the demands to democratise made by the United States.

Even so, today's exercises will serve as a reminder that the global balance of power is shifting.

For the first time ever, China is deploying troops, tanks and aircraft on a combined mission abroad.

The exercises, being held in the Russian region of Chelyabinsk, involve 6,500 troops, heavy weapons and combat aircraft.

While the goal of the mission is to simulate the capture of a city held by terrorists, the sight of Russian and Chinese troops marching together will give observers in Washington pause for reflection.

British and American forces killed in Afghanistan

Success is "just around the corner" in Afghanistan, and we know that because the "terrorists" are "desperate" enough to attack British bases. And the roadside bomb that killed three U.S. soldiers doesn't "count", since including bombings would "hand
the terrorists a big victory". In fact, the mere act of counting or even reporting deaths of coalition troops only serves to 'embolden' our enemies, so please ignore the story below.


From Times Online
August 12, 2007
Four soldiers killed in Afghanistan
Times Online

A British soldier and three American soldiers have been killed in separate incidents in Afghanistan.

The British serviceman, from 1st Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, was injured when his base, north-east of Sangin in the volatile Helmand Province in southern Afghanistan, came under attack from small arms fire, rocket propelled grenades, and indirect fire, at about 1.20pm on Saturday. He was taken by helicopter to Camp Bastion, but did not survive. The soldier’s family have been informed, the Ministry of Defence said.

A roadside bomb blast killed the three American troops in eastern Afghanistan on Sunday. They were engaged in combat operations in Nangarhar province when the bomb hit their vehicle, a statement from the US-led coalition said. A civilian interpreter was also killed. The coalition did not announce the nationalities of the soldiers though the majority of troops in eastern Afghanistan are from the US.

The British soldier's death takes the number of British military fatalities in Afghanistan since the start of operations in November 2001 to 70.

Of those who have died in Afghanistan, 47 were killed in action or died as a result of injuries sustained in action, while 23 are known to have died either as a result of illness, non-combat injuries or accidents or have not yet been officially assigned a cause of death pending the outcome of an investigation. At least 61 Americans have been killed, according to Associated Press figures.

Five American soldiers were killed in Iraq on Saturday the American military said today.

Four were killed and four others were wounded by a roadside bombing during combat operations south of the Baghdad. Another soldier was killed by small-arms fire during a foot patrol southeast of Baghdad. All the soldiers were assigned to Task Force Marne, which operates in an area with a volatile mix of Sunni and Shia extremists.

Names of the dead were withheld pending notification of relatives. The deaths raised to at least 3,690 the number of US military who have died since the Iraq war started in March 2003, according to an Associated Press count.

Bush's Iranian strategy: name-calling

I feel compelled to point out that the current government of Iran came into power by overthrowing the U.S.-backed Shah. They are not likely to get their feelings hurt by the Bush Administration's name-calling; in fact, they seem to relish it.
This is a really stupid plan that even our allies are backing away from.
It's about time that we realised that our brilliant plan of bringing democracy to a nation with a Shia majority would bring Iraq closer to Iran, not further. In fact, Hussein (and the Iraqi Sunnis) was our best bet to keep Iran in check. The U.S. cheered Saddam on as he fought a bloody trench-style war against Iran in the '80s. He was on our side, so we looked the other way as he gassed the Kurds. Of course, when he stopped being useful we suddenly turned aghast at his authoritarian ways.

Now we see al-Maliki and al-Sadr looking to Iran as a friend, since their friendship with the U.S. is slowly killing them and destroying their economy. Who could have predicted that a Shia government in Iraq would want closer ties with their Shia neighbour, Iran? Isn't Iraq a sovereign government capable of making their own alliances? Why do we keep thinking that elections automatically produce pro-American governments in populations that historically have opposed our foreign policies?

I guess the Baluchi thugs we got to attack a school bus full of kids didn't really turn the Iranian people against their government like we thought it would. In the world of Bush-logic, bombing people makes them like you, so we should expect airstrikes against Iran, which will make Iraqi Shia cheer our might and rejoice at the deaths of their Shia brethren.

Remember, the best possible outcome is the only likely outcome, and we have based our entire policies in Iraq and Afghanistan on that precept. See how well that has worked out? In Republican thinking, "bravery" is going into a situation prepared for only the best results, and refusing to plan for anything less than resounding success. If things go bad, the Rapture will pull the important people out before the shit hits the fan. What could possibly go wrong?

It remains to be seen which nations will go along with these new sanctions, but so far nobody is voicing enthusiasm. Maybe if we browbeat them they'll see what a good idea it really is. That is the best possible outcome, so it's bound to "work". It may require us to re-define "work", but it's inevitable that it will "work", since it's the only likely outcome.


Iran's Guards scoff at US blacklist plan
By Agence France Presse (AFP)

Friday, August 17, 2007

TEHRAN: Iran's Revolutionary Guards on Thursday dismissed US plans to list the elite force as a terror group in order to strangle its growing economic power, warning that its "iron will" would not be deterred. A US official revealed on Wednesday that President George W. Bush was set to issue an executive order blacklisting the group in order to block the assets of what is one of the Islamic republic's key institutions.

The new move is seen by some experts as confrontational and could appease hawkish groups within the administration pushing for possible military action against Iran.

The Iranian foreign ministry called the US action "worthless" propaganda.

The Revolutionary Guards - whose influence extends well beyond the military into business and politics - would be the first national military branch included on a US list of individuals and institutions linked to terrorism.

"The identity of the Guards has terrified the enemies of this system and the revolution," the Guards replied in a defiant statement carried by the official IRNA news agency. "This has forced them to hastily find a pretext to issue superficial measures in a bid to hurt this sacred body."

In a warning to Western powers, it added, "Those who are absorbed by the world's materialism cannot understand the depth of the spiritual power and iron will of the Revolutionary Guards. The historic victory will be with the children of Islam against the world infidels."

State broadcasting also reported Guards chief Yayha Rahim Safavi as saying that his organization "will never surrender to the enemy's pressure and we will stand with a universal spirit against all domestic and foreign plots."

Washington accuses the Revolutionary Guards of stirring unrest in Iraq and supplying bombs for deadly attacks on US troops, and is seeking to cut off the force's financial lifeblood.

As well as being an elite military force with tens of thousands of troops, the Guards have also picked up billion-dollar building contracts for infrastructure.

In 2006, the Guards won a $2.09 billion contract to develop phases 15 and 16 of Iran's biggest gas field, South Pars, and a $1.3 billion deal to build a pipeline to Pakistan.

The Revolutionary Guards are also at the center of Iran's politics - President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is a former officer and has promoted several former Guards members to top posts since taking office in 2005.
http://www.dailystar.com.lb

The US has never ruled out military action against Iran over its controversial nuclear program, and a top regional commander issued a stark warning against making such a move.

"If the sworn enemy of the revolution wants to have any military provocation in the Persian Gulf against Iran's borders then the Persian Gulf will be come a hell for them," said naval commander Ali Razmjou.

The US administration's intentions were revealed late on Wednesday but have yet to be officially announced. The State Department declined to elaborate, saying it would not divulge "anything that may be actively under consideration."

The EU said it had no plans to follow Washington's lead and add the Revolutionary Guards to its list of terror organizations.

"The EU takes independent decisions on what organisations to include on the list," said European Commission spokesman Jens Mester. "Usually ... our decision follows a UN decision."

Formally no name can be added, or taken off, the EU's own terror list without the unanimous approval of all 27 EU member states, given at ministerial level.


Amid mixed US reactions to the plan, The New York Times denounced the move as clumsy and ill-conceived, in an editorial titled "Amateur hour on Iran."

"The dangers posed by Iran are serious, and America needs to respond with serious policies, not more theatrics," it wrote. Iran has already been on the US government blacklist of state sponsors of terrorism for more than two decades.

There are currently more than 40 organizations, including Al-Qaeda and its affiliates, on the State Department's list of foreign terror organizations.

The United States has so far linked the Revolutionary Guard's Quds Force - in charge of covert operations - to the growing flow of weapons to Shiite militias in Iraq and the Taliban in Afghanistan.

United States forces have also arrested five Iranian officials in northern Iraq on accusations of being in the Quds force on a mission to stir trouble in the conflict-torn country.

However, Iran vehemently rejects the charges of interference in Iraq and Afghanistan, saying the presence of US troops is the biggest obstacle to restoring security. It insists the arrested men in Iraq are diplomats. - AFP

Army says suicide rates are up among the troops

This is a story I don't think the military recruiters are sharing with prospective enlistees.



U.S. Army suicides reach quarter century high


US Army soldiers committed suicide last year at the highest rate in 26 years, and more than a quarter did so while serving in Iraq and Afghanistan, according to a new military report.

The report found there were 99 confirmed suicides among active duty soldiers during 2006, up from 88 the previous year and the highest number since the 102 suicides in 1991 at the time of the Persian Gulf War.

In a service of more than a half million troop, the 99 suicides amounted to a rate of 17.3 per 100,000 - the
highest in the past 26 years, the report said. The average rate over those years has been 12.3 per 100,000.

The suicide rate for the Army has fluctuated over the past 26 years, from last year's high to a low of 9.1 per 100,000 in 2001.

Last year, "Iraq was the most common deployment location for both (suicides) and attempts," the report said.

The 99 suicides included 28 soldiers deployed to the two wars and 71 who weren't. About twice as many women serving in Iraq and Afghanistan committed suicide as did women not sent to war, the report said.

Preliminary numbers for the first half of this year indicate the number of suicides could decline across the service in 2007 but
increase among troops serving in the wars.

The increases for 2006 came as Army officials worked to set up a number of new and stronger programs for providing mental health care to a force strained by the longer-than-expected war in Iraq and the global counterterrorism struggle.

Failed personal relationships, legal and financial problems and the stress of their jobs were factors motivating the soldiers to commit suicide, according to the report.

"In addition, there was a significant relationship between suicide attempts and number of days deployed" in Iraq, Afghanistan or nearby countries where troops are participating in the war effort, it said.

The same pattern seemed to hold true for those who attempted, and succeeded in killing themselves.

There also "was limited evidence to support the view that multiple ... deployments are a risk factor for suicide behaviors," it said.


About a quarter of those who killed themselves had a history of at least one psychiatric disorder. Of those, about 20 percent had been diagnosed with a mood disorder such as bipolar disorder and/or depression; and 8 percent had been diagnosed with an anxiety disorder, including post traumatic stress disorder - one of the signature injuries of the conflict in Iraq.

Firearms were the most common method of suicide.

Those who attempted suicide but did not succeed tended more often to take overdoses or cut themselves.

The Army said the information was compiled from reports collected as part of its suicide prevention program - reports required for all "suicide-related behaviors that result in death, hospitalization or evacuation" of the soldier. It can take considerable time to investigate a suicide and, in fact, the Army said that in addition to the 99 confirmed suicides last year, there are two other deaths suspected as suicides in which investigations were pending.

Source: China Daily/agencies

Iraq's water supply infrastructure has collapsed

Who needs water, anyway? Infrastructure is overrated. Bullets and airstrikes can solve any problem, as long as you "want to win".

More than four years into the conflict, Iraqis still do not have electricity or clean running water like many Third world countries that we haven't poured $500 billion into.

Currently, one in three Iraqis is "in dire need of emergency aid". That makes Haiti look like a country with its act together. Yet we are still told that Iraq is a remarkable success, since we have chased Al-Qaeda into new areas that were previously peaceful. Hooray. Clearly, these Iraqis getting sick and dying from unclean water are just trying to make Bush look bad, and there's no way anyone could have predicted problems from four years without electricity.

If they can just go without water or electricity for another 5 to 10 years (by Petraeus' reckoning), then we'll be able to sort all this out and provide some Republican-contributing contractor a chance to do some really shoddy work for an obscene sum. So we do have a plan, after all.

By the way, does it mean anything when this reporter is warned that visiting the Iraqi Ministry of Water Resources is a good way to get kidnapped by the security forces? Now there's a media response plan that Republicans can really get behind. Is having the security forces involved in kidnapping supposed to be a positive sign? Couldn't we find a contractor capable of handling the kidnappings so that the security forces could devote themselves to other tasks? The important thing is that this is the perception of the Iraqi people; the government is the enemy and does only bad things for you.



IRAQ: Between the Two Rivers, Lack of Water Kills
By Ali al-Fadhily*


BAGHDAD, Aug 17 (IPS) -
The collapse of Iraq's infrastructure has created a worsening water crisis that is killing untold numbers of Iraqis.

Iraq, with its famous Tigris and Euphrates rivers that run the length of the country, is now unable to provide drinking water to most of its people.

"The two rivers are still there, great as they always were, and flowing all through the year," chief engineer Ahmad Salman of the Baghdad Water Authority told IPS. "Yet Iraqis are thirsty, and we are ashamed of being engineers in the service. We have simply failed to provide our people with
half of the drinking water they need."

Much of the country is suffering severe lack of water, and the small quantities supplied are not good for human use.

"I analysed the water supplied by the water authority, and the result was shocking," Dr Ibrahim Ali, a laboratory owner in Baghdad told IPS. "It is definitely not good for human consumption, and every time we analyse it we find something new that might, in time, cause death."

The doctor added, "Various kinds of bacterial pollution and germs we are finding can be as dangerous as biological weapons."


Iraqi hospitals are full of people with illnesses due to the unsafe water. Doctors at several hospitals confirmed to IPS that water is one of the worst causes of diseases, especially among children, and that some of children had died of water-borne diseases compounded by a severe lack of medicines.

These problems are exacerbated during the summer when both the quantity and quality of water are at their lowest.

"
One of the reasons for this lack of water is lack of electric power and fuel for generators," a member of a local municipal council in Baghdad, speaking on condition of anonymity, told IPS. "We have got tired of raising our needs for the water stations because our ministers and their leaders are busy fighting over chairs so that they make as much money as possible before they are thrown away."

U.S. ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker acknowledged to reporters Jul. 19 that Baghdad residents were receiving on average only one hour of electricity a day. Before the U.S.-led invasion, Baghdad residents received 16-24 hours of electricity daily. Without electricity, water cannot be pumped to homes.

A report released Jul. 30 by the international agency Oxfam and NCCI, a network of aid organisations working in Iraq, said that eight million Iraqis, nearly one in three, were in dire need of emergency aid.

The report, 'Rising to the Humanitarian Challenge in Iraq' said that 70 percent of Iraqis are without adequate water supplies, compared to 50 percent in 2003, the year the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq was launched. About 80 percent of Iraqis lack effective sanitation, the report said.

According to the Oxfam report, "child malnutrition rates have risen from 19 percent before the U.S.-led invasion in 2003 to 28 percent now." Lack of potable water is at the root of most such conditions.

"It is corruption more than anything else," an engineer at the Baghdad Water Authority, who did not wish to be named, told IPS. "The authority is full of corruption from bottom to top, and there is no way to improve the situation unless the political situation is improved by removing these corrupt officials."

An IPS correspondent was advised not to go to the Iraqi Ministry of Water Resources in the face of a danger of being kidnapped by security men at the ministry.

"It is another weapon that the Americans are killing us with," 62-year-old Abu Mahmood, a carpenter from Baghdad told IPS.
"No water means diseases that lead to slow, but certain death. They did it to us at the time of sanctions and now it is their chance to do it again without firing bullets and making scandals."

Few Iraqis see hope under the present government. "The problem is that we do not have a government like any other country," Baghdad resident Nabhan Mukhlis told IPS. "We should just stop complaining and surrender to the death penalty that was issued the day Americans decided to invade our country."

(*Ali, our correspondent in Baghdad, works in close collaboration with Dahr Jamail, our U.S.-based specialist writer on Iraq who travels extensively in the region) (END/2007)

How much "success" can Baghdad take?

Don't worry, this is just the proof that the "terrorists" are "on the run".
Some may wonder how attacks by sectarian militias (that we have allied ourselves with) against Iraqi police in areas "secured" by the surge could be seen as "success", but these people simply don't want to "win". They lack the innate ability to turn logic on its head and see that every attack is really a sign of stability.

Snipers in Baghdad are a sign of "desperation", at least by the upside-down logic of the surge. If only it weren't for that pesky report due in September, these troublemakers would probably just sit around playing cards all day long. Instead, they have to go out and kill people to make Bush look bad. So blame Harry Reid, blame the media, and blame people like me for "emboldening" the "terrorists".

Sadly, Bush really believed when he proposed the surge back in January that we would be seeing striking success in Iraq by now. Rather than facing collapse, al-Mailki's government was supposed to have gained control over the entire country by now. Sectarian militias were supposed to have been disarmed by an Iraqi military that is six times the size of the current force, rather than being pressed into service as a paramilitary force to push Al-Qaeda around the country in a bloody game of whack-a-mole. Money would be flowing into the pockets of Iraqis from the Hydrocarbon Law, and the foreign oil companies would have an unprecedented control of a nation's oil resources. Iraqis would be returning to their homeland to rebuild their lives, instead of 50,000 a month fleeing the miraculous 'success'.

Instead we get a warped story that Iraqis are beset with BDS, that bombings don't "count" as violence, and that any bad signs are proof of the success of the surge.


story from Xinhua

Six Iraqis killed in and near Baghdad

Six Iraqis including three policemen were killed and three others injured in attacks in and near the capital on Wednesday, a well-informed police source said.

Unidentified gunmen attacked a police patrol in Baghdad's southern district of Doura, leaving three policemen killed and two others seriously injured, the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

In a separate incident, two civilians were killed by a sniper in the al-Siba'a Square in central Baghdad, the source said.

Earlier on Wednesday, one civilian was killed and another one injured when insurgents opened fire in the town of al-Madain, 30 km southeast of Baghdad, the source added.

Violence continues infesting Iraq despite the presence of tens of thousands of U.S. and Iraqi soldiers across the country in a major security crackdown on insurgency and sectarian violence.

Source: Xinhua


I guess Xinhua doesn't feel compelled to paint the surge in glowing terms.

The surge relocates violence to once-peaceful areas

New bombings in the previously-peaceful city of Kirkuk show that the surge is merely relocating violence to new areas that were once "success stories". Baghdad, where the surge was supposed to bring the most success, again was the site of more attacks. I guess that the recent killing of 13 "gunmen" there didn't prevent this.
Lastly, we are told to expect more of this violence. This is the "logic" of the surge: more violence means that we are "winning" in the struggle to bring stability to Iraq. More innocent dead mean the promise of a brighter future. Arming sectarian militias opposed to the Iraqi government means that the Iraqi government is more powerful. In short, anything that looks like a setback is really "success" in disguise.

The Bush Administration now has less than a month to come up with a novel definition of "success" that leaves out political instability, Iraqi military impotence, Iraqi police corruption and disloyalty, the continuing lack of electricity and running water, the continuing failure of the petroleum industry and the economy as a whole, the collapse of the British effort in Basra, the continuing deaths and torture of hundreds by sectarian militias, the continuing torture in Iraqi prisons by the Iraqis themselves, the failure to hold provincial elections, and a cost of $12 billion a week with only the prospect of even larger expenditures in the future.

story by ireland.com

Latest Iraq violence sees 11 dead

Bomb and mortar attacks in towns north of Baghdad have killed at least eleven people, according to reports.

Mortar shells barraged a Shia enclave north of Baghdad today killing at seven people.

An estimated 16 mortar shells fell on houses in the Sharqiya residential area in Khalis, 50 miles north of Baghdad, police said. They said 24 people were wounded in addition to the three killed.

Khalis is a mainly Shia area in the volatile Diyala province and is frequently targeted by suspected Sunni insurgents.

Farther north, storekeepers in Kirkuk swept broken glass and other debris from the bloodstained pavement hours after a series of bombs struck commercial areas in the disputed city, killing at least four people and wounding 38.

The attacks started last night when a bomb struck a mainly Turkomen open-air market in the Qoriyah district in the city center, killing two people and wounding 25, police Col. Burhan Tayeb Taha said.

Three more explosions struck the city within three hours, killing two people and wounding 13, Taha said.

Police said at least three women and five children were wounded, including 4-year-old Diyar Mohammed.

"I was there to buy a toy for him and he was injured when shrapnel hit his head," his mother Narmeen Salih said as she sat beside him in the hospital.

The apparently co-ordinated attacks came four days after a quadruple suicide truck bombing that killed hundreds of members of the minority religious Yazidi sect in northwestern Iraq.

Minority sects such as the Yazidis and Turkomen are especially vulnerable as militants seek new targets to avoid a US-Iraqi military crackdown on Baghdad and surrounding areas to stop violence among warring Sunni and Shiite factions.

The US commander overseeing the cleanup in the northwestern villages that were devastated by Tuesday's attack said al-Qaeda in Iraq fighters were taking aim at remote communities after being chased out of the larger cities such as Mosul and Tal Afar.

Authorities in Kirkuk, 180 miles north of Baghdad, said the main street had been closed to vehicles to prevent the threat of car bombs. But Maj. Gen. Jamal Tahir, the general-director of police in Kirkuk, said the explosives that struck Friday were apparently wrapped in plastic bags and hidden in the garbage, and he appealed to civilians to be alert and report anything suspicious.

"The terrorists are changing their tactics in carrying out their crimes, so police and civilians should be more aware and open-minded to ensure security," he said. "I will not say that we will put a policeman at each garbage site or any other place, but I want to say that civilians should cooperate with security personnel in preventing terrorists from committing their crimes."

The US military also has warned that militants will try to step up attacks this month in a bid to upstage a pivotal progress report on Iraq due to be delivered in September by the top commander Gen. David Petraeus and US Ambassador Ryan Crocker.
© 2007 ireland.com

India says it wants no part of Bush's "warmongering"

The nations who jumped aboard the Bush Administration's plans have all either suffered or gained nothing. Britain is now bogged down in bad situations on two fronts after being conned by Bush into "peacekeeping" operations that became combat roles. Israel suffered its worst military setback when it followed the direction of the U.S. and invaded southern Lebanon. The Eastern European nations who sent their small forces to Iraq have not seen any progress on their bids to join NATO. Countries such as South Korea that merely keep their troops within their base and stay out of harm's way have gained nothing but a "pat on the back", but have not lost soldiers, either. Pakistan's Musharraf will likely lose power and our influence will evaporate with his departure.
So, in the Bush Administration's new campaign against Iran, other nations are not lining up to support another military solution. India has just announced that it wants no part of this new campaign, and it has taken a firm position on nuclear negotiations. They have received a much better deal by refusing many of the harsher demands of the Bush Administration, such as signing the NPT, and have stayed away from any 'brilliant' plans put forth by the State Department. Since India never had ambitions to be a source of nuclear terrorism, the U.S. has gained precisely nothing in its negotiations while India gets the technology to upgrade its nuclear power industry.
For decades, the U.S. led firm sanctions against India's nuclear industry after India developed the atomic bomb. For decades, we told our allies that they could not engage in the highly profitable task of bringing India's nuclear reactors up to modern standards, and the rest of the world meekly went along with that. Then one day the Bush Administration changed it's tune and decided that it's okay if American companies made a ton of money developing India's reactors, provided India signed the NPT and submitted to inspections. Our allies, who had followed our line obediently, were left out in the cold, and India politely declined to cave in to our demands. India knows that our allies will be happy to provide the technology if the U.S. hangs too tough, now that the door has been opened.
Rather than being browbeaten by Bush, India instead stood its ground as a sovereign nation and got what it wanted. Bush, by restraining the traditional arrogance of his Administration, has managed to hold on to India as a marginal ally. At best, the U.S. broke even on the deal, but by Bush's foreign policy record, this counts as a stunning success.


Agencies
Posted online: Friday, August 17, 2007 at 1804 hours IST
Updated: Friday, August 17, 2007 at 1849 hours IST

George Bush New Delhi, August 17: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has made it clear to President George W Bush during negotiations on the Indo-US nuclear deal that India could not agree to a "bilateral" NPT or Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT).

He also said that it was not in India's interest for Iran to become a nuclear weapons power, although it had the right to have nuclear energy as an NPT member.

"I told President Bush, I can't be a cheer leader or be part of a warmongering group. The nuclear dispute with Iran should be resolved through peaceful processes," he told India Today.

The Prime Minister's comments came in an interview conducted over two months back while he was returning from the G-8 Summit of Industrialsied countries in Germany. Singh had met Bush and other world leaders during his trip in June.

Tancredo says U.S. should bomb Islamic holy sites

Taking the Republican "logic" to its natural conclusion, Tancredo suggests that another attack on the U.S. should be followed by a military strike against the Q'aaba. Just as an invasion of Iraq was the "logical" response to 9/11, this is supposed to show that we "mean business", I guess. So "the terrorists" have now learned that an attack on our soil will cause us to invade and occupy an uninvolved nation in a tremedously expensive conflict that cripples our military. That'll teach 'em. And if it doesn't, we can bomb their holy sites. Then they'll just fold and accept us as their masters...in some fantasy world.

Would the civil war in Northern Ireland have been helped by bombing the Vatican? Would Catholics all over the world have realised that going up against the Ulster government was a bad idea if the Pope was blown to bits in an air strike?

If someone cuts you off in traffic, would breaking their mother's legs bring them the clarity to see your point of view?

It's been said that if your only tool is a hammer, then pretty soon everything starts to look like a nail. Military force is the only tool in the Republicans toolbox.

Muslims believe that God resides in the Q'aaba, and all Muslims are required to make a pilgimage there at some point in their lives (the Hajj). So bombing someone's God and destroying the place they are required to visit will somehow "bring Muslims around" to accepting American domination and resigning themselves to living in peace with us.

Similarly, shooting your neighbour's dog and letting it howl in agony as it slowly bleeds to death will convince everyone on your block that you are a sensible person who merely wants them all to keep their music down and get rid of the dandelions that keep spreading to your lawn. They will look at the shooting as an opportunity to work with you on your objectives for neighbourhood improvement, such as burning crosses on selected lawns in the dead of night.

Actually, bombing the Q'aaba is the one single thing that would turn virtually all Muslims into diehard enemies of the U.S. If "the terrorists" know that this would be our reaction, that would be a big incentive for a nuclear attack on our soil. Muslims in Asia, North Africa, Europe, the Middle East and the U.S. would retaliate, and probably have the support of many governments. The U.S. would be finished as a world power, would become a pariah for at least a century, and any action would be deemed as justified against us or our allies by Muslims. The goals of "the terrorists" would be acheived.


State Department criticizes congressman for threats against Islamic sites

Washington (ANTARA News) - The US State Department criticized a US congressman and long-shot presidential candidate for saying that threatening to bomb the Islamic holy sites of Mecca and Medina could deter terrorists from carrying out a nuclear attack on the United States.

"The official position of the United States government is that those remarks are just outrageous," US State Department spokesman Sean McCormack was quoted as saying Monday.

Republican congressman Tom Tancredo during a candidate debate on Sunday defended his earlier remarks threatening to strike Islam's holiest two sites to deter al-Qaeda from hitting the United States with a nuclear weapon.

"Anybody that would suggest that we should take anything like this off the table in order to deter that kind of event in the United States isn't fit to be president of the United States," said Tancredo, a conservative from Colorado.


Other presidential candidates during the televised debate quickly criticized Tancredo's position.

"I sincerely believe that bombing religious artifacts and religious holy sites would do nothing but unify 1 billion Muslims against us. It makes no sense," said Tommy Thompson, a former member of US President George W Bush's cabinet who is also considered a long shot for the Republican party's nomination.

Tancredo's name has not been mentioned among those, like former New York mayor Rudolph Giuliani and former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney, who are considered serious contenders to win the Republican nomination.

But Tancredo grabbed some attention when iowapoltics.com published remarks he made before a small crowd.

"If it is up to me, we are going to explain that an attack on this homeland of (a nuclear) nature would be followed by an attack on the holy sites in Mecca and Medina," Tancredo said July 31.

McCormack suggested that Tancredo's remarks may be geared more toward his presidential ambitions but that it was up to him to explain "the reasoning behind the remarks."

"He will say what he will, and we'll respond as the US government that the remarks are simply outrageous," McCormack said. (*)

Thursday, August 09, 2007

Listen to the boots on the ground

Neocons say, no beg, that we should "listen to the boots on the ground". Of course, they mean certain selected "boots". I have been reading a soldier's blog, "Army of Dude", for about two months now. The latest entry is haunting. As Alex is preparing to return home, he summarises his views of the occupation and his role in Diyala.


This occupation, this money pit, this smorgasbord of superfluous aggression is getting more hopeless and dismal by the second. It’s maddening to think that more than a year’s worth of blood, sweat and tears will lead to little more than a pat on the back and a hideously redundant speech from someone who did none of the bleeding, sweating or crying.


I must remind myself not to offer any "hideously redundant speeches" if I ever meet Alex. The poor guy must not be reading enough right-wing blogs or he would 'know' that the surge is "working", not "getting more hopeless and dismal by the second". Maybe he and Michael Yon could get together. Yon is a 'real expert', while Alex is apparently just one of those 'defeatists' with 'an agenda'. Yon could regale poor Alex with reports of 'the mission'. Because having a mission to do something automatically means that success is inevitable. The best possible outcome is the only likely outcome, at least to neocons.

Despite being in a meaningless situation, my life has never had this much meaning. I watch the backs of my friends and they do the same for me. I’ve killed to protect them, and they’ve killed to protect me. For friends and family, being deployed is like being pregnant or surviving a car wreck; everyone is nice to you all of a sudden. People I don’t even know send me kind words and packages from all over. They came out of the woodwork knowing my plight and shared with me heartfelt hope and luck. The fact that you’re reading this now, dear reader, is a testament to that. Would you have cared about what I thought, felt or did two years ago? This position I’m in, shared by less than one percent of the U.S. population, has given me the distinct privilege of sharing my experiences and ruminations of this war, observations undiluted by perpetually delirious officials like General Petreaus and mainstream media sirens. I have felt every extreme of the human condition, physically, morally and emotionally. I’ve never laughed so hard, cried so long or felt more ashamed of myself in all of my life. In a matter of weeks it’ll be over, and I’ll have just the memories of enduring 130 degree heat, and poker games lasting well into the night. I’ll look back on the hysterical laughter during fifteen hour Baghdad clears, the terror of being pinned down by machine gun fire, the sight of a Stryker on it side and the unfolding of a body bag under the flames of a nearby school, unzipped tenderly to fit the body of Chevy as RPGs screamed overhead. Soon this place will all be in the past.


"perpetually delirious officials like General Petraeus"? "mainstream media sirens"? Oh, dear. It sounds like Alex "doesn't want to win". Doesn't he know that the troops will lose faith if he talks like that? Oh, wait...he is "the troops". Maybe it's not "treason", then.
It certainly sounds like he knows something about combat, and it doesn't sound as if he's been sitting behind a desk in the Green Zone, so I guess this would make him "not credible" to neocons. Does any of Alex's narrative sound like he's fighting a war against Islam for the survival of Christianity? Any mention of bringing democracy and hope to Iraqis? No. It's pretty much that he got the short straw in Bush's ill-considered gamble to look like a hero. For the neocons, who adulate "the troops" for values that these soldiers simply do not have, Alex is simply another aberration who must be punished when he returns home. Republicans who turn him down for a job will mumble that they "honor his service" while wishing him "luck". And the crude charade continues by flag-wavers dripping with hypocrisy.

And that’s how we’ve been leading our lives for the past year and two months. Going from place to place and hoping we don’t die on the way there or the way back. With our GPS tracking satellites and laser guided warheads and scientifically developed helmets for ultra comfort, we’re getting beat to the punch every day by a dude crouching behind a wall with a battery and a spool of wire. We’ve been killing the innocent with the guilty because we don’t have the luxury to tell the difference when that bomb goes off and you don’t know which of your friends are dead or alive. In essence, we’ve come here to help each other survive. It worked in most cases and sadly, not in others.


"killing the innocent with the guilty"? Say it isn't so! We're the good guys. Everyone we kill is Al-Qaeda, and the proof is that they are dead. Alex must not be reading the talking points from the White House.
All in all, not a particularly upbeat assessment of the "dramatic success" in Diyala. Surely there must be a general whose job is on the line to give us a more "balanced" view of the situation.

4 more British casualties in Basra

The important thing is not to set a timetable for withdrawal. Somehow that will help.


Iraqis exchanges greetings with British soldiers on patrol a few miles to the north of Basra July 12, 2007. Two British soldiers were killed in Iraq early on Thursday, taking the death toll to four in about 48 hours. The Irish Guards soldiers killed shortly after midnight were in a convoy hit by a roadside bomb near the Rumaila oil fields, west of Basra. Two other soldiers were seriously injured. REUTERS/Atef Hassan
Four UK troops die in Iraq in 48 hours

BASRA, Iraq (Reuters) - Two British soldiers were killed in Iraq early on Thursday, taking the death toll to four in about 48 hours.

The Irish Guards soldiers killed shortly after midnight were in a convoy hit by a roadside bomb near the Rumaila oil fields, west of Basra. Two other soldiers were seriously injured.

British-patrolled southern Iraq has become more dangerous for British troops since the government announced in February that London would cut back its force during the course of 2007.

In the April-July period, 30 British soldiers died in Iraq, making it the deadliest period since the 2003 invasion when Britain had nine times as many troops as the 5,500-strong contingent it has deployed now.

One soldier was killed during a foot patrol on Tuesday and another was shot while driving an armoured Warrior vehicle on Monday night.

The British have withdrawn from three of the four provinces they once patrolled, leaving troops only in Basra, Iraq's second-largest city.

In Basra they have pulled out of two of their three bases. They are due to abandon the last city base in coming weeks and withdraw to their heavily mortared air base outside the city.

British commanders say Shi'ite militants are stepping up attacks to create the impression they are pushing the British out. The military says it will withdraw on its own schedule.

British morale in Basra sinking fast

As the Coalition of the Willing collapses, the British control of Basra is slipping away along with the morale. Barely able to supply themselves, much less control the streets, this seems like success to some. Conned into an occupation by a thumbs-up, smiley-faced Bush, these troops are struggling to merely survive. The British version of the surge brought only short-term success in Basra, as they discovered that Al-Qaeda was only a minor problem compared to the militias and corrupt police.
This is a truly sad story of good men suffering and dying for a foreign leader's ego and the chance for his friends to make big bucks.


Fighting for pride as pressure mounts on beleaguered troops
As two more soldiers are killed in Basra, the morale among their colleagues is sinking fast
by Anthony Loyd (timesonline.co.uk)

The soldiers lead a semi-nocturnal existence between guard shifts and operations. The morning alarm is usually a salvo of incoming mortar fire. Almost every man smokes and few could tell you what day it is, let alone the date.

They have already suffered the worst casualty rate of any British unit in Iraq and yet are not even halfway into their tour.

They feel abandoned by the receding tide of British public and political support for their war. They know that if they die, their death will go barely noticed by the media at home beyond perhaps a paragraph or two in a newspaper or a few sentences at the back end of the Six O’Clock News.

Welcome to Basra Palace at the tail-end of a lost war. With only a few weeks left until the last soldier withdraws from the base, the 650 men of the Basra City battlegroup, average age 20, fight on with little but their esprit de corps and pride.
“We didn’t ask to come here,” remarked Captain Robert Basset, sitting in the back of his Bulldog armoured vehicle as it rumbled out of the palace gates into the foetid, dusty night.

“We were sent here by our country and our Government. We are making incredible efforts and sacrifices. Yet sometimes it feels like our country and Government act as though they wish we weren’t here at all.”

The pressure on the small battlegroup, who lost their first man on day 1 of their deployment, has come from every direction.

If the insurgents of al-Mahdi Army, known among the soldiers as “the Jam” after their Arabic name Jaish al-Mahdi, are the principal adversary, the climate comes a close second.

The daytime temperature can reach a brain-stewing 52C (125F). Boiling in their armoured vehicles, laden with a helmet, flak jacket, weapon, and a full load of ammunition, each rifleman is carrying between 35lb (16kg) and 50lb (23kg) , sometimes more. Night conditions can be even worse.

During one recent night-time operation a moisture-laden wind came up from the south, multiplying the humidity factor. As a result, the men’s sweat could not evaporate and their bodies’ natural cooling mechanisms failed.

In the back of the Warrior armoured fighting vehicles, notorious for their poor air-conditioning, the temperature reached 72C. Commanders began to babble and slur over the radios; some soldiers tore off their clothes, vomiting and delirious.

Over a period of several hours, much of it exchanging fire with insurgents, 15 men became heat casualties and required evacuation: wounded men can be sustained in the back of an armoured vehicle, yet keep a heat casualty inside the very environment that injured him and he may die.

The capabilities of the soldiers’ human enemy are lethal enough. Two years ago al-Mahdi Army was still considered an inept, ill-equipped and amateur force. British units who clashed with it elsewhere in southern Iraq killed its fighters in their droves, with few casualties of their own.

Yet now, with the influx of support from the Iranian Revolutionary Guard’s al-Quds division, the Jam has has been transformed. It shells Basra Palace every day with newly made mortar rounds or rockets date-marked 2007.

Hundreds of these munitions have hit the palace in the past two months alone and memories of previous units who once patrolled the city in soft hats and berets are now a world away.

Outside the palace walls, al-Mahdi Army’s ability to identify British patrols moving within the city and lay down combination ambushes using roadside bombs, rockets and small-arms fire has improved by the week.

Its bomb arsenal includes state-of-the-art explosively formed projectiles which can penetrate British armour. And the frequency of attacks has worsened. After the last Foreign and Commonwealth Office diplomat hightailed it out of the palace in February, the graph of violence against the soldiers has risen in a mounting series of spikes.

Since the Basra City battlegroup, comprising of a core element of two companies from the 4th Battalion The Rifles with a respective company each from the Royal Welsh Regiment and the Irish Guards, arrived in May, attacks have escalated even more.

The palace’s isolated location has also served the insurgents. Built by Saddam Hussein in 1990 at the southern end of the city, buttressing the Shatt al-Arab waterway, there are only three viable resupply routes for logistics convoys to reach the base from the main British camp at the airport on Basra’s outskirts. Hugely vulnerable, all three pass directly through the city.

The requirements of food, water, fuel, ammunition and spare vehicle parts ensure that these resupply convoys are vast — sometimes more than 100 vehicles. Some of the civilian lorry drivers involved in the operation get drunk to summon the courage to make the run. And al-Mahdi Army attacks the convoys from the moment they get into the city right up to the palace gates.

“Last time we did it the convoy encountered 25 IEDs [roadside bombs],” recalled Lieutenant-Colonel Patrick Sanders, 4 Rifles, the battlegroup’s commanding officer. “We were fixed. We didn’t have the intiative. The Jam see the trucks form up, they know the routes in, they know the routes out. It’s a f****** nightmare.”

More than 50 per cent of the battlegroup’s casualties have occurred as they secure the routes for these convoys — a cruel irony that has not been lost on the soldiers. “Losing blokes just to resupply ourselves is a different kind of loss,” admitted Corporal David Guntert, 36, one of 4 Rifles’ longest-serving soldiers. “Sometimes it feels like you lost them just to bring in a loaf of bread or a toilet roll.”

Under such duress, the question “Is it worth it?” inevitably haunts many of the soldiers as they rest in their accommodation blocks, stacked in bunks, up to 24 men to a room.

But there comes a moment when the questioning stops.

“The Iraqi police are corrupt,” Corporal Guntert explained. “Their army isn’t ready yet. Which leaves us. We’ve fought hard and lost some fantastic blokes. For what? We’ll probably go home questioning, ‘What was it all for?’

“As soldiers it is our right to tick. But the blokes would be gutted if we were prevented from going out on ops. As soon as we’ve got our orders, got our kit and weapons and walk over to the vehicles, the debate stops and we just get on with it.”

One Rifleman from 4 Rifles said: “We can debate it all we want but at the end of the day it’s about pride.”

The battlegroup’s commanders have been at pains to ensure that their continued operations, designed to keep up pressure on al-Mahdi Army until the moment the palace is handed over to an Iraqi military unit, are carefully balanced between what can be gained and lost. With nine dead and forty wounded, each of the battlegroup’s casualties has hit the officers as hard as the men.

Immediately after losing the soldiers for whom they are responsible, officers have struggled to maintain their composure but some commanders admitted that the private aftermath left them racked with a devastating sense of grief.

There has been more than a little weeping in Basra Palace. Among their dead the battlegroup has lost a 48-year-old major, an infantryman who had served in every rank from rifleman up; one of twin brothers, both serving with 4 Rifles, in Basra, who was killed by a bomb on their birthday; and three soldiers killed in a single bomb attack. One company alone has now suffered a 10 per cent casualty rate.

The battlegroup’s senior non-commissioned officers have dealt with the grim circumstances in their own inimitable style.

“I’ve got enough on my mind with all these f****** dead bodies without carrying another one out just because the stupid f***** wasn’t wearing his body armour and helmet,” a 4 Rifles Company Serjeant Major told his riflemen, extolling the need for them to wear flak jackets and helmets at every opportunity.

Yet even they profess to a softer side.

“We got hit by an IED which lifted up the Bulldog nose first and threw the driver through his hatch 25 metres back up the road,” recalled Company Serjeant Major Rod Poulter. “I jumped out, saw a body with British uniform on. He had burns to his face and hands, a compound fracture and dislocated foot, but he had pulled his 9mm pistol out and was lying there firing away to protect himself. We got him back.

“I spoke to him on the phone a couple of days ago. He said, ‘Hello Serjeant-Major, battle buddy’. It meant a lot to hear him call me that.”

If anything however, these losses seem only to have united the unit.

History is unlikely to record the battlegroup’s last weeks in the palace as much more than a footnote to a failed political strategy. The soldiers know that they won’t go home to public adulation or a victory parade. The word “Basra” is twinned with “Iraq”, both words that the British public now utter with a wince.

But if the soldiers feel isolated, they say that they have preserved intact their most valuable ally: pride.

“We fight for what soldiers have always fought for,” said Colonel Sanders. “For each other, for our reputation, and because we are professional soldiers. This is the life we chose. The men want to see it out. Not for a prime minister or cause, right or wrong, but for each other.”

One day in Iraq

— Two more British soldiers have died in Iraq, bringing the toll of servicemen killed this week to four. The two men, from the Irish Guards, were killed when a roadside bomb blew up next to their patrol early yesterday morning as they were travelling to the north Rumaila oil fields, west of Basra

— A serviceman killed on Tuesday night has been named as Leading Aircraftman Martin Beard, 20, of No 1 Squadron RAF Regiment. He was shot during a routine patrol north of the British base at Basra airport. The first to die was Private Craig Barber, of the 2nd Battalion The Royal Welsh, on Monday

— All charges against two US Marines — Lance Corporal Justin Sharratt and Captain Randy Stone — accused over the murder of civilians in Haditha have been dropped. Five Marines still face court martial over the alleged massacre in 2005

— Hundreds of thousands of Shia pilgrims have converged on the Baghdad shrine of the 8th-century Imam Moussa al-Kadhim amid a tight security operation. In past years the pilgrimage has been attacked by Sunni insurgents, and in 2005 about 1,000 people died in a stampede after rumours of a suicide bombing

— The goalkeeper of the Kirkuk football club, Baha Abdul Karim Darweesh, 24, was kidnapped by gunmen north of Baghdad. In a separate incident, militants blew up two bridges just outside Kirkuk

— Three people were killed in a car bombing in southern Baghdad, which also left two others injured

Monday, August 06, 2007

Sectarian forces mount a surge of their own

A truck bomb in Ninevah, where there is so much "progress" our troops are thinking about leaving. More bodies found in Baghdad, where the surge is strongest. And a mass grave found in Diyala, which is supposedly a stunning success story for the surge.

The surge is a military solution to a non-military problem. Sure, it feels good to cheer on the "good guys" against the "bad guys" and paint the complex issues in terms that can be resolved with an air strike or a bullet, but the surge has done nothing to deal with the sectarian militias or the reasons for their rise. Instead, it has made this problem worse by 'legitimising' the militias in a temporary alliance against Al-Qaeda. Once Al-Qaeda is driven out of a specific area, the militias will go back to taking us on. Only now they have our arms, and know everything about our operations as "allies".

full story from ireland.com


Last Updated: 06/08/2007 11:28
Truck bomb in northern Iraq kills at least 27

A truck bomb in northern Iraq flattened homes and killed 27 people today, police said, while Washington expressed growing impatience with a stalled political process that has failed to reconcile sectarian groups.

Rescue workers were sifting through rubble in an attempt to find survivors from the attack in the town of Tal Afar, near the Syrian border. About 30 people were injured, police said.

In eastern Baghdad, six people died and nine were wounded when street cleaners were hit by a bomb hidden in a rubbish bin.

Overnight, police in the town of Baquba -- in
Diyala province, where US and Iraqi forces have mounted an offensive against insurgents over the past several weeks -- found 60 decomposing corpses in tall grass.

In Baghdad, police said they had recovered 18 bodies.

The violence came as Iraqi politicians prepared for talks this week to restore a unity cabinet that was designed to reduce sectarian strife by including members of all communities but hit a crisis last week when the main Sunni Arab group pulled out.

Parliament went on recess last week without having passed laws, such as a bill to share Iraq's oil wealth, which Washington considers vital to ending sectarian violence by promoting national reconciliation.

Yesterday, US Defense Secretary Robert Gates criticised the parliamentary recess with some of the harshest words Washington has directed at Iraq's leaders.

"I said 'for every day that we buy you, we're buying it with American blood. The idea of you going on vacation is unacceptable'," Gates said on NBC's "Meet the Press".

Parliament cannot pass the laws unless they are first drawn up by the government, which is stalled after the Sunni Arab bloc's pullout.

US loses track of 190,000 guns in Iraq

The surge strategy is "working". All you have to do is change the definition of the word "working", which is the only patriotic thing to do, I guess. Not only are we intentionally arming the irregular forces (militias) directly as part of the new strategy, we are also arming virtually anyone else.
Arming one gang to wipe out another gang is the brilliant strategy that is bringing us the current "progress". And nothing ill can come of this, of course.


full story from ireland.com

Last Updated: 06/08/2007 13:07
US loses track of 190,000 guns in Iraq

The Pentagon cannot account for 190,000 AK-47 rifles and pistols given to Iraqi security forces in 2004 and 2005, or about half the weapons earmarked for soldiers and police, according to a government report.

The Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of the US Congress, said in a July 31 report to lawmakers that
the Defense Department also cannot account for 135,000 items of body armor and 115,000 helmets reported to be issued to Iraqi forces as of September 22, 2005.

The GAO said the Pentagon concurred with its findings and has begun a review to ensure full accountability for the program to train and equip Iraqi forces.

"However, our review of the 2007 property books found continuing problems with missing and incomplete records," the GAO report said.

The report raised concerns that weapons provided by the United States could be falling into the hands of Iraqi insurgents, just as lawmakers and policymakers in Washington await a September report on the success of US President George W. Bush's surge strategy for stabilizing Baghdad.

One senior Pentagon official told The Washington Post some weapons probably were being used against US troops. He said an Iraqi brigade created in Fallujah disintegrated in 2004 and began fighting American soldiers.

Many in Washington view the development of effective Iraqi army and police forces as a vital step toward reducing the number of US troops in Iraq.

Since 2003, the United States has provided about $19.2 billion to develop Iraqi security forces, the GAO said. The Defense Department has recently asked for another $2 billion to continue the train-and-equip program.

Congress funded the program for Iraqi security forces outside traditional security assistance programs, providing the Pentagon with a large degree of flexibility in managing the effort, the GAO said.

Wednesday, August 01, 2007

Baghdad blows up (again), Sunnis walk out of gov't

Baghdad, the focal point of the surge, suffers more high-profile bombings. As we are told of "normalcy" returning, we must assume that it is "normal" to have bombs explode in shopping districts.
And the feeble Al-Maliki government just became even more feeble.




Sunni bloc quits Iraq govt, truck bomb kills 50
Wed Aug 1, 2007 7:49 AM EDT138

By Mariam Karouny and Paul Tait

BAGHDAD (Reuters) - The main Sunni Arab political bloc quit the Iraqi government on Wednesday in a blow to Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki, while a suicide bomber driving a fuel truck killed 50 people in one of several car bombs in Baghdad.

The Sunni Accordance Front announced its pull-out from Maliki's Shi'ite-led coalition over his failure to meet a list of about a dozen demands, including a greater say in security matters.

The front's 44 members will remain in the 275-seat parliament. Its withdrawal will have little practical effect on the 15-month-old government, which is
virtually paralyzed by infighting but needs only a simple majority to keep functioning.

But the shaky coalition is under pressure from the United States and its allies to end sectarian strife between Shi'ites and Sunnis through national reconciliation.

Washington is unhappy at the slow progress towards political benchmarks meant to draw minority Sunni Arabs, dominant under Saddam Hussein, into the political process and away from an insurgency that has killed tens of thousands.

Police said the suicide bomber was driving a fuel truck packed with explosives in the attack in Mansour district of western Baghdad that wounded 60 people apart from the 50 killed.

They said the bomber lured motorists queuing for petrol to his truck after earlier saying he had rammed into the line of vehicles.

Separately, 20 people were killed and 40 wounded when a suicide bomber blew up his vehicle near a popular ice cream parlor in a bustling area full of electronics stores in Baghdad's predominantly Shi'ite district of Karrada.

In southern Baghdad, a parked car bomb killed three people and wounded five in Doura district, police said.


The U.S. military, which began a build-up of 30,000 extra troops this year in a bid to buy time for Maliki to meet his political targets, said three of its soldiers were killed by a roadside bomb in the east of the capital on Tuesday.

Success? Anbar is heating up again

Anbar province, the undisputed "success story" of the surge, is heating up. This follows attacks on Friday and Saturday.

Perhaps Al-Qaeda wasn't the major problem after all.

full story from Xinhua



U.S. marine killed in western Iraq

16:47, July 31, 2007


An American marine was killed in Iraq's volatile province of Anbar, the U.S. military said on Tuesday.

The soldier was killed on Monday during combat operations in the southwestern province, the military said in a brief statement.

An earlier military statement said that three more soldiers were killed on Thursday in fighting in the Sunni insurgent stronghold.

The names of the soldiers are being withheld pending notification of next of kin, the statements added.

Anbar province, which stretches from western Baghdad to the Syrian, Jordanian and Saudi borders, has long been the hot bed of insurgency against the American troops since the invasion in 2003.

The latest deaths bring the number of U.S. soldiers have been killed in Iraq to more than 3,650 since the Iraq war broke, according to media count based on Pentagon figures.

Source: Xinhua