Thursday, August 23, 2007

Except for the failures, the surge succeeds

Was the purpose of the surge to make marginal security improvements that leaves the level of violence "high"? No, it wasn't.

The major "success" of the surge has come in Al-Anbar province. There are two problems with this position however:

- Al-Anbar holds only about 1% of Iraq's population. It is also not ethnically mixed, so it has been relatively free of sectarian violence, which the surge was intended to quell.
- The success in Al-Anbar was already well underway when Bush announced the surge in January. Since Republicans insist that the surge only began in July, then it's clear that the surge was not a major improvement in Al-Anbar over the situation in, say, June when 3/4 of the troops were in place. Remember, we can only consider progress since the surge was in full force, according to Republicans.

The other "success" story was in Diyala, which is more of a question mark. The surge proposal did not envision massive air strikes, such as were employed in Diyala and which killed many civilians. The proposed surge also did not include arming, feeding, and housing Shia terrorist militias. Rather, it envisioned an Iraqi military three times the size of the current one taking the lead with the U.S. troops in a support role. It did not speak of throughly corrupt and disloyal Iraqi police force passing along intelligence to militias and taking bribes.

The surge also was supposed to allow Al-Maliki to control all of the provinces by November. Instead, two provincial governors have been killed in the south and the Al-Maliki government is facing collapse.

Don't believe it? See the transcript of the speech here from Jan. 10

The surge Bush proposed has failed. Any" success" has come either from improvements that were already in place before the surge or in strategies that Bush did not propose for the surge.

Even in Baghdad, where the surge is most heavily concentrated and where the biggest results were promised from the surge, roadside bombs strike almost daily and multiple corpses turn up showing the handiwork of our allies, the "good terrorists".

It is obvious that the current situation was not what Bush had in mind when he proposed the surge. Once again, he chose optimism over reality. He was wrong and now he will ask for more time, just as he has several times before when he was wrong in his assessments.

In addition, his credibility only exists in any useful sense among his base. The public in general has not embraced his "Central Front on the War On Terror" thesis, nor has it been persuaded in his "follow us home" contentions. He continues to falsely cast the occupation as a "war" in which social, ethnic, and political problems can be solved with the right amount of bullets and air strikes. His "Long War" against Islam does not have any support beyond his base, either. The imminent departure of the British from Basra promises only a fresh challenge to overstretched troops, and our own troop levels cannot be maintained at surge levels beyond April. Tremendous pressure has been brought to bear on the military and media to create a positive spin, but this is not sustainable for long. Bush's political capital has been badly exhausted and the Republicans' domestic agenda is in a shambles. The NIE promises only "modest" success in the next year, which is when the election will be hitting its stride. Week after $12 billion week, Bush will only have the same old lines to rely on, and those are worn threadbare.


POLITICS-US/IRAQ: Still No Light at Tunnel's End
By Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Aug 23 (IPS) - While there have been some improvements in Iraq's security situation over the past seven months, the level of overall violence remains "high" with only modest improvements possible over the next six to 12 months, according to a new study by the U.S. intelligence community released here Thursday.

At the same time, prospects for a political settlement to Iraq's multiple internal conflicts -- particularly between the Shi'a majority and the Sunni minority -- appear bleak. The Shi'a-led government of Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki is likely to "become more precarious over the next six to 12 months," according to the latest National Intelligence Estimate (NIE), which reflects the consensus view of Washington's 16 intelligence agencies.

"Iraq's sectarian groups remain unreconciled; AQI (Al Qaeda in Iraq) retains the ability to conduct high-profile attacks; and to date, Iraqi political leaders remain unable to govern effectively," according to the report's 10-page "Key Judgments', the only section of the report that was declassified.

"We assess, to the extent that Coalition forces continue to conduct robust counter-insurgency operations and mentor and support the Iraqi Security Forces (ISF), that Iraq's security will continue to improve modestly during the next six to 12 months, but that levels of insurgent and sectarian violence will remain high and the Iraqi Government will continue to struggle to achieve national-level political reconciliation and improved governance," it added.

The NIE, entitled "Prospects for Iraq's Stability: Some Security Progress But Political Reconciliation Elusive", comes as the administration is preparing its own report on how well its "surge" strategy -- which added 30,000 U.S. troops to the 135,000 who were already in Iraq in January -- has been working.

The surge, which also included the application of more aggressive counter-insurgency techniques, was designed to reduce sectarian violence and improve security conditions, particularly in Baghdad, in order to encourage political leaders on all sides in Iraq to make the compromises necessary to achieve national reconciliation.

The administration's report, which will be presented to Congress in mid-September by Washington's overall commander in Iraq, Gen. David Petraeus, and its ambassador there, Ryan Crocker, will re-launch the Congressional debate over Washington's next steps in its four-and-a-half-year-old occupation.

Democratic lawmakers, most of whom opposed the surge, have been pushing for Congress to adopt a timetable for the withdrawal of all U.S. combat forces from Iraq.

They have also called for changing the mission of the remaining troops to training Iraqi forces, protecting U.S. installations and personnel, and mounting Special Forces operations against AQI and other terrorist targets.

President George W. Bush, who has vowed to veto any legislation that includes a mandatory timetable for withdrawal, has indicated -- most recently in an uncompromising speech to the Veterans of Foreign Wars Convention -- that he believes the surge has shifted the balance of forces in Iraq and should continue well into next year if not beyond.

At the moment, he appears to have the support of most Republican lawmakers. However, Sen. John Warner, the influential ranking Republican member and former chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, broke ranks with his party's leadership Thursday by calling on Bush to begin withdrawing troops no later than the end of this year.

Warner, who just returned from his latest trip to Iraq, joined Democrats in suggesting that withdrawing U.S. troops would help persuade the various Iraqi factions that national reconciliation was urgent.

"I really, firmly believe the Iraqi government, under the leadership of Prime Minister al-Maliki, let our troops down," he said after meeting with Lt. Gen. Douglas Lute, the White House's so-called "Iraq Czar".

The latest NIE, which follows one released just before the surge took effect in February, is likely to be used as ammunition by both sides of the impending debate.

Despite its dour tone, the administration will likely seize on a number of passages in the document that supports its view -- that the six-month-old surge strategy designed to curb violence in Baghdad has brought results and should continue well into next year.

In particular, the NIE notes that the more aggressive counter-insurgency tactics deployed under the surge has checked the "steep escalation of rates of violence" and led to "measurable but uneven improvements" in the overall security situation.

In addition, the NIE warns that "changing the mission of Coalition forces from a primarily counterinsurgency and stabilisation role to a primary combat support role for Iraqi forces and counter terrorist operations to prevent AQI from establishing a safe haven would erode security gains achieved thus far."

That assessment will likely be used by Bush and his Republican supporters to argue against Democratic efforts to redefine the U.S. military mission in Iraq, let alone to begin drawing down its combat forces.

But the NIE's bleak assessment of the political situation in Iraq is likely to fuel Democratic arguments that, despite improvements in the security situation, prospects for national reconciliation remain as distant as ever.

"Political and security trajectories in Iraq continue to be driven primarily by Shia insecurity about retaining political dominance, widespread Sunni unwillingness to accept a diminished political status, factional rivalries within the sectarian communities resulting in armed conflict, and the actions of extremists such as AQI and elements of the Sadrist Jaysh al-Mahdi (JAM) militia that try to fuel sectarian violence," according to the NIE.

"Broadly accepted political compromises required for sustained security, long-term political progress, and economic development are unlikely to emerge unless there is a fundamental shift in the factors driving Iraqi political and security developments," it noted, suggesting implicitly that such a shift was not in view.

Indeed, those passages were seized on by several other Democratic presidential candidates virtually as soon as the report was released as evidence that the surge has failed.

"With no progress on political reconciliation between the various sects in Iraq, it is clear that President Bush's tactic of troop escalation has failed to achieve its goal of convincing Iraqi leaders that they must take bold steps to promote stability and reconciliation in Iraq," said Sen. Christopher Dodd.

Sen. Barack Obama's campaign released a statement asserting that the NIE "underscores the fundamental truth that we cannot continue to substitute the bravery of our troops for a true commitment from the Iraqi government to resolve the grievances at the heart of their civil war..."

The NIE also noted that expectations both within Iraq and among its neighbours that U.S. troops will indeed begin to draw down at some point in the next six to 12 months will likely fuel sectarian violence and intra-sectarian conflict as all of the various forces in play will jockey to fill the resulting power vacuum.

While the ISF has improved its performance over the last six months, according to the report, it still depends on U.S. forces for "important aspects of logistics and combat support." While the government is expanding the Iraqi Army to fill critical gaps, "...we judge that significant security gains from those programmes will take at least six to 12 months, and probably longer, to materialise," it said.

Growing Sunni resistance to AQI -- much ballyhooed as a major strategic success by the administration and its supporters -- offers, according to the report, "the best prospect for improved security over the next six to 12 months, but we judge these initiatives will only translate into widespread political accommodation and enduring stability if the Iraqi Government accepts and supports them".

That appears unlikely, the NIE suggests, due to fears by the government's Shi'a leaders that "these (Sunni) groups will ultimately side with armed opponents of the government."

(END/2007)

Success means the killers don't stick around

Operation Arrowhead Ripper "cleared out Al-Qaeda" and got them "on the run" and "desperate". It also flattened Diyala and nobody has any idea how many civilians are buried in the rubble, but the morgue overflowed with civilian casualties , forcing mass graves to be employed. A lot of the bodies were posthumously dubbed "Al-Qaeda", based on mysterious criteria that the military won't share. Likewise, in Vietnam it was common to turn any corpse into "VietCong" to boost the 'body count' and show we were 'winning'.

Now "Operation Lightning Hammer" is also "successful", because Al-Qaeda is again "on the run". It's also "successful" because we have employed terrorist groups to wipe out terrorists. Yes, it seems odd that, in our virtuous battle to free Iraq from terrorists, we have joined up with groups which not only have attacked and killed our troops, but also have abducted, tortured, executed, and held many, many innocents for ransom. But these are "good terrorists". I don't remember Bush mentioning this distinction in his Jan. 10 speech proposing the surge. Actually, he has pretty much blurred the terms "terrorists", "insurgents", and "Al-Qaeda" together non-stop, so nobody really knows what he means:

The violence in Iraq — particularly in Baghdad — overwhelmed the political gains the Iraqis had made. Al Qaeda terrorists and Sunni insurgents recognized the mortal danger that Iraq's elections posed for their cause, and they responded with outrageous acts of murder aimed at innocent Iraqis. They blew up one of the holiest shrines in Shia Islam — the Golden Mosque of Samarra — in a calculated effort to provoke Iraq's Shia population to retaliate. Their strategy worked. Radical Shia elements, some supported by Iran, formed death squads. And the result was a vicious cycle of sectarian violence that continues today.

So it sounds like "insurgents" are the bad guys, doesn't it? Well, that's only those "insurgents" who haven't vowed to "unite in their fight against terrorists and become one tribe of Diyala", as the article quotes the military as saying. So these people that Bush called terrorists are going to fight against terrorists. And they took a vow, after all.

Al-Qaeda is so "desperate" and "on the run", in fact, that 200 of their number killed one of the "good terrorist" leaders, along with his sons on Friday. And since they didn't stick around and wait to be killed, Col. Sutherland counts this as a success. They're "on the run" again.

I would hazard a guess that if a mugger beat you bloody and took your week's pay, that you would not consider it a "success" because he failed to hang around and take on the police. You would probably not consider the mugger moving on to victimise others somewhere else as a positive sign that the mugger is now "desperate", either. Yet, in the case of Iraq the Bush Administration feels free to make up definitions as they go along, and if you don't accept them unquestioningly then you "support the terrorists". The bad terrorists, not the "good terrorists". Please try to keep up.

So now that we know we are "winning", you can easily see that yet another attack on the Green Zone is also something positive. The attackers didn't mill about waiting for our troops to arrive, did they? See, they are "on the run".

Likewise,
the assassination of
Khalid Othman is another "success" because his killers didn't make camp on the crime scene, but instead ran away. They were "desperate". Another roadside bomb in Baghdad, where the surge is focused, killed a civilian. Iraqis now know they are secure, because they will only be killed by people who run away afterward. The day before, one our soldiers was killed by a roadside bomb in Baghdad, which is not sounding very "pacified", is it? But surely you see that as long as these "bad terrorists" (or were they the "good terrorists"?) don't establish a base and control territory like a conventional military that we are "winning". Of course, we can ignore those who point out that the nature of an insurgency is that it does not fight like a conventional military force and control territory. Isn't this what the British did when they fought against American colonists? As long as the colonists fought in ambushes and ran away, they were not a "serious" force.

I must point out, however, that the surge was supposed to be all about providing enough security for the Al-Maliki government to bring stability to Iraq. Bush said:

Yet over time, we can expect to see Iraqi troops chasing down murderers, fewer brazen acts of terror, and growing trust and cooperation from Baghdad's residents. When this happens, daily life will improve, Iraqis will gain confidence in their leaders, and the government will have the breathing space it needs to make progress in other critical areas.

Notice how those "Iraqi troops" are doing all of the work? Does it seem to you that Iraqis have confidence in their leaders? Has anyone seen progress "in other critical areas"? In fact, we are allying ourselves with "murderers", the Iraqi troops are loyal to the sectarian militias more than they are loyal to the government, and, as the article points out, Al-Maliki is big trouble politically.

Apparently the plan all along was to divide the terrorists into "good" and "bad" groupings, keep them from settling down so they are forced to kill nomadically, and allow political paralysis to induce a collapse in the government, which is now defined as "breathing space". If so, things are moving according to plan. And as long as we can point to heavily-patrolled areas where people aren't dying, then we are winning. Except in Baghdad, of course. And Diyala. Aside from the failures, the surge is succeeding.


200 Al-Qaeda fighters assault Iraqi town
By Agence France Presse (AFP)

Friday, August 24, 2007


BAQOUBA, Iraq: Scores of Al-Qaeda fighters raided an Iraqi town Thursday, clashing with rival militants and police after killing a tribal sheikh in fighting that left 23 people dead and 15 others kidnapped. Brigadier General Ali Dalayan, police chief of Diyala's provincial capital of Baquba, said over 200 fighters from Al-Qaeda's Iraq affiliate attacked a mosque and the homes of tribal Sunni sheikhs in the town of Kanan.

"The first attack was against a mosque," he told AFP. "They blew up the mosque, then they bombed houses crowded with family members."

Three houses were attacked, including those of two sheikhs who support Iraqi police and US troops in their fight against Al-Qaeda, he said.

"Sheikh Yunis al-Tae was killed in the attack" along with an unknown number of his sons in one of the homes, he added.

Police countered with the support of gunmen from the Brigades of the 1920 Revolution, a Sunni insurgent group once allied with Al-Qaeda but now one of its fiercest rivals.

He was not immediately able to say how many people died in the raids and how many in the ensuing gun battle. At least one policeman was among the dead.

Dalayan said police had chased the attackers but had had a "difficult time as they planted roadside bombs around the town before escaping. We have arrested 22 Al-Qaeda suspects," he said. They were detained south of Kanan, 50 kilometers from Baghdad, in an area known to be a stronghold of Al-Qaeda in Iraq.

He said the attackers managed to abduct eight women and seven children.

The raid on Kanan came despite a massive military crackdown in Diyala by some 16,000 US and Iraqi troops who claimed success in their assault.

The US military said that the 12-day "Operation Lightning Hammer" ended Thursday successfully, with around 26 Al-Qaeda fighters killed and 50 villages cleared.

It said more than "80 tribal leaders and representatives" vowed to "unite in their fight against terrorists and become one tribe of Diyala. We have continued to diminish their [Al-Qaeda] supplies and disable Al-Qaeda's abilities to disrupt the population," the statement quoted Colonel David Sutherland, commander of US forces in Diyala, as saying.

He said that while not many militants were nabbed, the operation "proved to be a great success because we disrupted Al-Qaeda, causing them to run. Their fear of facing our forces proves the terrorists know there is no safe haven for them in Diyala. And though this specific operation is over, our fight is not over," he said in a statement.
http://www.dailystar.com.lb


The US military blames the group for much of the violence besetting Iraq. In recent months Al-Qaeda has been attacking the increasing number of Sunni Arab tribesmen who support US-led forces in fighting the militants.

Meanwhile, gunmen shot dead Khalid Othman, media spokesman for the Sunni Iraqi Islamic Party of Vice President Tareq al-Hashemi, in the northern Iraqi city of Mosul.

The attackers riddled Othman's car with bullets which also wounded his driver, said Brigadier General Abdel-Karim Khalaf al-Juburi of Mosul police.

In another incident, a roadside bomb killed one civilian in Baghdad's Jadida neighborhood, security officials said.

Also in Baghdad, an explosion rocked the heavily fortified Green Zone early Thursday but there were no casualties, a US Embassy official said.

The Green Zone, a walled-in city district, houses the Iraqi Parliament, the US and British embassies and several other foreign missions.

The US military announced Thursday that one of its soldiers was killed and four wounded in a roadside bomb explosion west of Baghdad the previous day.

The latest fatality took the military's losses in Iraq since the March 2003 invasion to 3,721, according to an AFP count based on Pentagon figures.

Meanwhile, a new US intelligence estimate warned Thursday Premier Nuri al-Maliki's government will become "more precarious" in the coming months.

"The IC [intelligence community] assesses that the Iraqi government will become more precarious over the next six to 12 months because of criticism by other members of the major Shiite coalition" as well as Sunni and Kurdish parties, the US intelligence estimate said. US politicians have lashed out against Maliki this week, expressing impatience with his government's progress in Iraq. President George W. Bush defended the Shiite premier Wednesday, calling him "a good guy." - AFP

Monday, August 20, 2007

Surge's "success" destroys Diyala

According the article from IPS shown below, it appears that things aren't so wonderful in Diyala after all. See also the previous post about a soldier's view of the Diyala 'success'.


IRAQ:
Caught Between the U.S. and Al-Qaeda

By Ahmed Ali*

BAQUBA,
Aug 20 (IPS) - The major U.S. military operation in Baquba city north
of Baghdad has ended, but it has left continuing suffering for
residents in its wake.


The U.S. military launched Operation
Arrowhead Ripper in Baquba, 50 km northeast of Baghdad, on Jun. 18.
Baquba is the capital city of Iraq's Diyala province.

The stated goal of the operation was to eradicate al-Qaeda from the
city and other areas in the province. The region has seen some of the
highest number of attacks on U.S. troops.


Shortly after launching the operation, the U.S. military
admitted that nearly 80 percent of al-Qaeda militants had fled the
area.


Residents had been looking for an end to raids and abductions
by criminal gangs and sectarian death squads, but the U.S. military
operation brought no relief.

"People here feel afraid because the coalition forces always push
al-Qaeda out of the cities, but unfortunately they return when the
troops retreat," resident Mohammed Hulail told IPS. "So the coalition
forces can provide no solution."


A Baquba city official, speaking on condition of anonymity,
told IPS that al-Qaeda militants had already returned to parts of the
city. "We are now sure that Iraqi police and army cannot defeat
al-Qaeda who are well fortified in the streets and buildings."

Residents have learnt to fear enemies on all sides. "People are the
victims of this war because they are in the middle point between the
American forces and the fighters of al-Qaeda," Jabbar Ibrahim, a
secondary school teacher in the city told IPS. "The fighters of
al-Qaeda came to control the city, but when the U.S. troops came to
fight them, they ran away, leaving civilians to face the shells the
bombs."

Many residents complain of indiscriminate arrests through the U.S.
forces' search for al-Qaeda suspects. "Arrests are sometimes made
wrongly; simple people who have nothing to do with fighting and
violence were arrested, and those who were the real fighters ran away,"
a resident who declined to give his name told IPS.


The Iraqi Islamic Party has accused the Multi-National Forces operating
in the area of killing many people in Baquba in the early weeks of the
operation.

"The operations led by the U.S. forces in western Baquba led to the
death of more than 350 people, most of whom are still under the
rubble," the party said in a statement.


Many residents in this city of 300,000 say that operation
Arrowhead Ripper has made living conditions worse. "We spent 12 days
without water, electricity and food," Hamid Shaaban, a 51-year-old
retired city official told IPS. And U.S. forces were of little help.


"I have seven children," said Shaaban. "I went to ask U.S.
troops for food and water." All he got, he said, was some bottled
water. He was then sent away.

The shortage of water hit the city at the worst time of the year. "The
temperature was between 45 and 51 degrees C," an elderly woman said.
"We have had very long days, it has been terrible."

Most residents IPS spoke to said they would leave if they could, but
they either lacked funds or simply did not know where to go.


"We do not have another place to go in order to leave this
miserable place," resident Kamil Abid told IPS. "All places are the
same, and we have no money to start again."

The U.S. military has often detained people who have stayed home during
the attacks and searches. Several residents say a decision to stay on
was often seen as a gesture of defiance.


Now almost everyone seems fed up with the violence and
intimidation from all sides. "What people want is security in order to
get back again to their jobs to earn their living," said the owner of a
local food store. "Providing this is the responsibility of the
coalition forces and the Iraqi government."


Suspicions abound that the U.S. forces do not really want to
solve the problem. "U.S. governments always tend to create an enemy,
and then fight him in order to show weak governments, like this one in
Iraq, that they cannot do without the support of U.S. power," said a
retired army officer.

(*Ahmed, our correspondent in Iraq's Diyala province, works in close
collaboration with Dahr Jamail, our U.S.-based specialist writer on
Iraq who travels extensively in the region) (END/200
7

Surge only works where troops are surging

Yet another provincial governor killed in an area where the surge isn't focused.

If nobody robs you at gunpoint when you are in the company of three police officers, do you simply overlook it when you are robbed three blocks away and those officers aren't around? Do you say that the police have robbers in general "on the run" because robbers are now "forced" to only go after people who don't have three police officers standing near them? Do you feel that, over time, robbery will disappear because these criminals will no longer want to prey on a populace if they are limited only to those that do not have three police officers in their vicinity at all times? Do you criticise those who point to the high rates of robbery everywhere else in the city and dismiss them as "supporters of robbery" who want robbers to kill your family and force you into robbery against your will? Would you support housing, feeding, and arming with high-powered weaponry various burglars, drug addicts, dope dealers, car thieves, and rapists if they agree to join the police in their efforts to drive the robbers to the next town over, while letting them continue with their crimes because now they are "good" criminals?

If so, then you probably support the surge, because this is the underlying logic that you must accept for the surge to be credible.





Roadside bomb kills Iraqi governor



An Iraqi provincial governor was blown up
by a roadside bomb today in what appeared to be an escalation of a
power struggle between rival Shi'ite factions that threatens to
destabilise the oil-producing south.



Mohammed Ali al-Hassani, governor of Muthanna province, was on his way
from his home in the city of Rumaitha to Samawa, the provincial
capital, when his convoy of nine cars was hit by a powerful roadside
bomb, provincial officials said.



One bodyguard was also killed and two others wounded.



Prime minister Nuri al-Maliki called for Iraqis to exercise restraint,
saying the perpetrators were seeking to "drown the province in chaos".





© 2007 ireland.com

Iraqis continue to flee the surge's success

So you think the surge is a "success"? If so, why are the best and brightest of that "liberated" nation fleeing that "stabilisation" and "pacification"? I have to wonder, as I've mentioned before, why so many of these Iraqis flee their homeland and its democracy, giving up everything, to seek refuge in an authoritarian police state that the Bush Administration says is a haven for terrorism, where they have nothing.

One war-supporting blogger explained it to me: They flee to Syria because Syria is mad at Bush. That makes very little sense in the larger picture, however. Yes, they give up their homes and businesses, their car and their neighbourhood to make a political statement about a foreign President. They are even willing to push their daughters into prostitution, as the article points out, just because Syria is "mad at Bush". I'm not buying that.

As the article mentions, these people that are fleeing are the very sort that Iraq needs if it is going to rebuild and "stand up". These are the professionals who have left: the doctors, engineers, technicians, lawyers, etc. that a civil society needs to exist.

Since Petraeus says it will likely take five to ten years for Iraq to "really" stabilise, who is going to fill these positions in the meantime?

And why should Jordan, Egypt, and Syria bear the cost of caring for these millions who are fleeing Bush's dream of a "beacon of prosperity, democracy, and peace"? As the article states, these were among the very nations that warned against an invasion, yet they have to pay the costs for Bush's mistakes (which Republicans don't even freely admit really were even mistakes).

The Bush Administration's answer: "it's the U.N.'s problem".
From the article: "Meanwhile, Washington has been more than generous in seeking to transfer its Iraq responsibilities to the UN." Already we are seeing Bush trying to push increasing responsibilty on the United Nations to rebuild the country that Bush destroyed, and also to send troops to pacify the "pacification" that allegedly is going so well. This is yet another group that warned Bush about the consequences of an invasion, and one that Bush derided as irrelevant. Four years ago, Bush said we didn't need the U.N. We could go it alone, if need be, and take all of the credit and glory for the success ourselves. Now we are trying to bully the U.N. into helping to clean up our mess and whining about those traitorous British who are running out on us. Yes, the arrogance remains as strong as ever.

Okay, kids, now what have we learned to do when things don't go the way The Decider said they surely would? That's right, say it with me now..."It's Al-Qaeda!" Al-Qaeda is bad! If you disagree with Bush, then you support Al-Qaeda!" Remember, it's not a scapegoat or a strawman if Bush relies on Al-Qaeda to take the blame for everything. Jesus whispers in Bush's ear every day, so if Bush says something, it comes direct from God Himself. But not Allah. This is the mentality of Bush's base, and when Bush gives an address, these are the people he is really speaking to.

And last of all, why do we have to get this kind of analysis from a German media outlet? Why has our own media failed to cover this critical issue that impacts the rebuilding of Iraq?


full story from Der Spiegel

LOSING IT'S BEST AND BRIGHTEST
Iraq's Elite Fleeing in Droves


By Amira El Ahl, Volkhard Windfuhr and Bernhard Zand

One in ten Iraqis has left the country. Baghdad's elite are trying to make ends meet in neighboring Jordan and Syria. Washington wants the United Nations to address the refugee crisis. In the meantime, the country is losing its best minds -- the very people needed to rebuild Iraq.

The first stage on the road to safety is a $20 taxi ride. It takes the future refugee past nervous soldiers, through dangerous checkpoints and along streets with nicknames -- like "Grenade Alley" and "Sniper Boulevard" -- that bespeak the perils of travel in Iraq.

Stage one ends at the curb in front of Samarra Terminal at Baghdad Airport, where travelers are so overcome with relief that they hardly even notice the gruff way guards treat them. Before they are even allowed to enter the terminal, security officers order them to deposit their suitcases and carry-on bags next to a yellow line painted on the asphalt and flanked by two sets of six-foot-tall concrete barriers. While police dogs sniff the luggage for explosives, the travelers -- men, women, grandparents and grandchildren -- stand to the side in the heat, parents wearing stiff-looking travel clothes and a few children in brightly colored wind-breakers.

"We are flying to Amman," says one mother, smiling as she hands her whining son his stocking cap, "and then to Prague and on to Stockholm. The children think it's snowing there."

The first flight, a charter flight operated by Flying Carpet, isn't scheduled for departure until the afternoon, but the airport is already crowded at 9 a.m. Three doctors -- old friends from their university days, who haven't seen each other in years -- are reunited in the terminal. One of them, a child psychologist named Khaldun Fahmy, was kidnapped a week earlier when he returned to take one last look at his abandoned villa. After three terrifying days, in which he was tortured, the $50,000 ransom money was paid and Fahmy was released and taken to the hospital. "Am I talking too much?" he asks his friends. "It's all therapy, all self-therapy."

Four flights are departing from Baghdad Airport on this particular afternoon, bound for Amman, Damascus, Beirut and Dubai. Few are shedding tears. Most of the travelers have already said their goodbyes, and their farewells are well considered and long planned. Some expect to return, while others are leaving "for good," says Fahmy.

Mass Flight

Iraq, a country still shaken by daily violence, is currently the scene of what is likely the biggest refugee disaster since the displacement of Palestinians in the Arab-Israeli War in 1948. On the eve of the Iraq war, the United States, the United Nations and neighboring countries had expected refugees to number in the tens of thousands. Four years later, more than 2 million Iraqis have already left the country. Jordan has accepted close to 750,000, the Gulf states 200,000, Egypt 100,000 and Syria at least 1,400,000. Roughly one in 10 Iraqis has fled the country, and about the same number are now internal refugees.

They are not just the country's poor and desperate. Many are the elites of a nation that already lost many of its best and brightest during decades of tyranny and economic embargos. Ironically, those choosing to leave the country today are precisely the doctors, lawyers, judges, engineers and government bureaucrats the country will desperately need to rebuild itself.

The West -- especially the two leading coalition nations, the United States and Great Britain -- has opened itself up to severe criticism for its unwillingness to step up to the plate. Since the 2003 invasion, Britain has accepted a mere 115 and the United States only about 500 of a total of more than 14,000 seeking asylum in the West. The Bush administration has promised to process 7,000 applications for political asylum this year and has made a commitment to accept 3,000. Former senior US diplomat Richard Holbrooke calls the Bush administration's efforts "pathetic" and the American public's indifference "shameful."

Meanwhile, Washington has been more than generous in seeking to transfer its Iraq responsibilities to the UN. The organization, says Zalmay Khalilzad, the former US Ambassador to Iraq, should focus more of its attention in the future on the political process in Baghdad, security issues, the country's oil law -- and the refugee crisis. But this is a tall order, with the UN High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) not even in a position to get the most vulnerable Iraqis -- the interpreters and reconstruction workers being hunted down by terrorists, who accuse them of collaborating with the occupiers -- out of the country. US authorities in Iraq do not accept asylum applications, and those Iraqis who do manage to make it abroad are better off not mentioning any ransom money they may have paid for kidnapped relatives, especially not in the United States. US immigration authorities define such payments as "material support" for terrorist organizations.

The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation recently contributed $5 million to a fellowship fund for Iraqi academics. The purpose of the fund, says a foundation spokeswoman, is to "protect Iraq's intellectual capital." The foundation currently receives about 40 applications a week, but the program's funds are only enough to pay for about 150 academics and will have been used up within a few months.

Staggering Costs

Meanwhile, the cost to Syria and Jordan, whose governments warned against an invasion and are now being left to deal with the humanitarian consequences, is running into the billions. Jordan has now virtually closed its borders to Iraq, while up to 2,000 Iraqis cross the border into Syria every day. Syrian Interior Minister Bassam Abdul-Majid says that Damascus will likely follow Jordan's lead before long.

No one knows precisely how many Iraqis there are in Syria today. The demand for subsidized goods like bread and gasoline has increased by one-fifth, at an additional cost to the government of several hundred million dollars. Apartment rents in some neighborhoods have skyrocketed, government-run schools are overflowing with students and unemployment and inflation are on the rise.

The growing crisis has also affected the UN. At the beginning of the year, two employees at the UNHCR office in Damascus were sufficient to register Iraqi refugees. But within weeks, the situation spun out of control. Suddenly UNHCR officials saw thousands of people lining up outside their office every morning.

Today, only half a year later, 30 clerks sit at desks in a warehouse in eastern Damascus, recording personal data and translating it into English. "It's the largest operation of its kind that we're running worldwide," says British UNHCR official Sybella Wilkes.

Before the building opens in the morning, employees walk through the crowd with megaphones, warning the refugees about con artists. No one from the UNHCR will ask for money, they say, adding that while the process will be time-consuming and inconvenient, it is free. Then health experts arrive on the scene to scan the crowd for the sick and fatigued. "We have to fish out the most vulnerable ones first," says Wilkes, "otherwise they won't make it through the waiting period in the heat." The disabled, old men in wheelchairs and chemotherapy patients are taken to the front of the line.

Huda Sibawi, 33, a grief-stricken young woman, is carrying six death certificates: those of her mother, her father, two uncles, her brother and her brother-in-law. The father, a wealthy Sunni from New Baghdad, had donated money to a mosque and, at the end of Ramadan, broke the fast a day earlier than is customary among the Shiites. He paid dearly for his infraction. Fighters from the Shiite Mahdi militia exterminated most of his family in a two-week murdering spree.

The killers seized the Sibawis' assets, which included 11 apartment buildings and a small chain of supermarkets. Neighbors from Baghdad occasionally call Huda to tell her that members of the Mahdi militia are now driving the family's company cars around the city.

Some of the Iraqi refugees are so desperate that mothers have been known to take their daughters to nightclubs, where they offer them to Western and Arab tourists from the Gulf as if they were exotic fruits. "Diana, for example," says a driver who works for the limousine service of a large, Western hotel, "just arrived from Mosul. You can meet her in our disco after 1 a.m."



Yeah, these people are just trying to make Bush look bad. Sure.

Sunday, August 19, 2007

NYT: "Boots on the Ground" say surge is a failure

It's odd that right-wing bloggers who cited the "success" story (put forward by a pair masquerading as 'critics' of Bush's handling of Iraq) in the New York Times, could pass up another editorial in that same paper giving the opposite assessment. This one, however, was not written by phony critics being led by the nose around scenes the military has picked as "proof" that the surge is showing success.
No, these are actual servicemen, the "boots on the ground" that Bush and Republicans allegedly listen to rather than "politicians". Rather than being escorted on a well-guarded Magical Mystery Tour with military spokespeople telling them exactly what they want to hear, these guys have been risking their necks carrying out the policies that the right-wing bloggers cheer. They offer an assessment that markedly contrasts with Pollack and O'Hanlon, mainly by telling the truth of their experiences.
Now you won't see these guys on Fox News, because they don't sit in an air-conditioned office in the Green Zone reading scripts their superiors have handed them. They don't play some kind of brown-nose game to get their rank; they are NCOs. They actually have to go out in the heat and dust with their men and carry out the dirty work while the officer corps thinks up clever new ways to call the latest batch of corpses that turn up a 'sign of victory'.
One of the "surprising" elements of their assessment is that (gasp) Al-Qaeda is not the number one obstacle to stability in Iraq. It seems to the sectarian militias and the political situation that drive them that occupies that spot. The Iraqi military and police force are not seen as a capable and professional force on the verge of "taking over" or "standing up", but rather as a profoundly corrupt, disloyal, and dangerous element thoroughly infiltrated by the militias. They offer a "routine" example of Iraqi civilians being threatened with death and torture by the Iraqi military and police if they co-operate with the U.S. military. They offer the "common" scenario of Iraqi troops being loyal to their own miitias rather than their commanders or even the al-Maliki government. They reveal the consequences of our new policy of arming Sunnis to wipe out Al-Qaeda, which is the shining star of the surge effort. It seems we are simply arming groups that want to take on the government, which just postpones the day we can withdraw.

Of course, the right-wing will dismiss this all with shrill squawks of "Al-Qaeda!". They don't really care about the Iraqis at all, except as a tool to be abandoned if the day ever comes where Al-Qaeda is actually driven out of Iraq. This talk of Iraqi politics and multiple factors and social unrest is not nearly black-and-white enough for their tastes, so they get bored by it and go back to the Big Battle Between Good and Evil That We Must Win. Wake them up when "we" get the oil, okay? If you mention withdrawal, however, you will hear a crazed scenario of massive bloodshed where those poor Iraqi civilians will suffer, and they really care about those innocent peoples' lives, and after all, they voted. Yes, they care deeply about Iraqis if it suits the talking points.

The neocons are real "defeatists" here. They have given up on Iraq completely and have focused on Al-Qaeda to the exclusion of all else.

How is it that a sectarian militia that tortures, abducts, and executes innocent people based on their religion or ethnicity is suddenly considered "good" and "non-terrorist" simply because they temporarily agree to join with us in our Al-Qaeda extermination campaign? How does arming, feeding, housing and providing intelligence to groups that seek the violent overthrow of the elected government of Iraq bring us any closer to "stability"? How does looking the other way as the Iraqi Interior Ministry runs torture centres in the prisons square with our criticism of Saddam's abuses?

The answer is simple: we don't give a damn about anything but Al-Qaeda and Iraq can go to hell in a handbasket as long as Al-Qaeda goes with it. When the commanders talk of "success" and "pacification", they mean success against Al-Qaeda and the pacification of specific isolated areas by letting the militias run the show while the military and police stay on the sidelines taking bribes and passing along information to the armed gangs that are now our buddies.

In the hypocrisy we have all come to expect from Republicans, the NYT is a credible source when they say what the right-wing wants to hear, but when they print something that contradicts their Fox News-fueled fantasy world, then it's just another "liberal media outlet" that is peddling "defeatism". And when the "boots on the ground" say things that aren't cleared by Ryan Crocker or Tony Snow first, well, that's just traitorous propaganda and those guys will suffer the consequences as those brave folks in the Green Zone spring into action to silence and punish them. It's the only way to spare us from the evil schemes of sergeants who want to see America fail and put your daughter in a burqa. They apparently have forfeited their right to our support by failing to parrot the words of the "politicians" that we aren't supposed to listen to in the first place.


story at NYT

The War as We Saw It


Article Tools Sponsored By
By BUDDHIKA JAYAMAHA, WESLEY D. SMITH, JEREMY ROEBUCK, OMAR MORA, EDWARD SANDMEIER, YANCE T. GRAY and JEREMY A. MURPHY
Published: August 19, 2007

Baghdad

VIEWED from Iraq at the tail end of a 15-month deployment, the political debate in Washington is indeed surreal. Counterinsurgency is, by definition, a competition between insurgents and counterinsurgents for the control and support of a population. To believe that Americans, with an occupying force that long ago outlived its reluctant welcome, can win over a recalcitrant local population and win this counterinsurgency is far-fetched. As responsible infantrymen and noncommissioned officers with the 82nd Airborne Division soon heading back home, we are skeptical of recent press coverage portraying the conflict as increasingly manageable and feel it has neglected the mounting civil, political and social unrest we see every day. (Obviously, these are our personal views and should not be seen as official within our chain of command.)

The claim that we are increasingly in control of the battlefields in Iraq is an assessment arrived at through a flawed, American-centered framework. Yes, we are militarily superior, but our successes are offset by failures elsewhere. What soldiers call the “battle space” remains the same, with changes only at the margins. It is crowded with actors who do not fit neatly into boxes: Sunni extremists, Al Qaeda terrorists, Shiite militiamen, criminals and armed tribes. This situation is made more complex by the questionable loyalties and Janus-faced role of the Iraqi police and Iraqi Army, which have been trained and armed at United States taxpayers’ expense.

A few nights ago, for example, we witnessed the death of one American soldier and the critical wounding of two others when a lethal armor-piercing explosive was detonated between an Iraqi Army checkpoint and a police one. Local Iraqis readily testified to American investigators that Iraqi police and Army officers escorted the triggermen and helped plant the bomb. These civilians highlighted their own predicament: had they informed the Americans of the bomb before the incident, the Iraqi Army, the police or the local Shiite militia would have killed their families.

As many grunts will tell you, this is a near-routine event. Reports that a majority of Iraqi Army commanders are now reliable partners can be considered only misleading rhetoric. The truth is that battalion commanders, even if well meaning, have little to no influence over the thousands of obstinate men under them, in an incoherent chain of command, who are really loyal only to their militias.

Similarly, Sunnis, who have been underrepresented in the new Iraqi armed forces, now find themselves forming militias, sometimes with our tacit support. Sunnis recognize that the best guarantee they may have against Shiite militias and the Shiite-dominated government is to form their own armed bands. We arm them to aid in our fight against Al Qaeda.

However, while creating proxies is essential in winning a counterinsurgency, it requires that the proxies are loyal to the center that we claim to support. Armed Sunni tribes have indeed become effective surrogates, but the enduring question is where their loyalties would lie in our absence. The Iraqi government finds itself working at cross purposes with us on this issue because it is justifiably fearful that Sunni militias will turn on it should the Americans leave.

In short, we operate in a bewildering context of determined enemies and questionable allies, one where the balance of forces on the ground remains entirely unclear. (In the course of writing this article, this fact became all too clear: one of us, Staff Sergeant Murphy, an Army Ranger and reconnaissance team leader, was shot in the head during a “time-sensitive target acquisition mission” on Aug. 12; he is expected to survive and is being flown to a military hospital in the United States.) While we have the will and the resources to fight in this context, we are effectively hamstrung because realities on the ground require measures we will always refuse — namely, the widespread use of lethal and brutal force.

Given the situation, it is important not to assess security from an American-centered perspective. The ability of, say, American observers to safely walk down the streets of formerly violent towns is not a resounding indicator of security. What matters is the experience of the local citizenry and the future of our counterinsurgency. When we take this view, we see that a vast majority of Iraqis feel increasingly insecure and view us as an occupation force that has failed to produce normalcy after four years and is increasingly unlikely to do so as we continue to arm each warring side.

Coupling our military strategy to an insistence that the Iraqis meet political benchmarks for reconciliation is also unhelpful. The morass in the government has fueled impatience and confusion while providing no semblance of security to average Iraqis. Leaders are far from arriving at a lasting political settlement. This should not be surprising, since a lasting political solution will not be possible while the military situation remains in constant flux.

The Iraqi government is run by the main coalition partners of the Shiite-dominated United Iraqi Alliance, with Kurds as minority members. The Shiite clerical establishment formed the alliance to make sure its people did not succumb to the same mistake as in 1920: rebelling against the occupying Western force (then the British) and losing what they believed was their inherent right to rule Iraq as the majority. The qualified and reluctant welcome we received from the Shiites since the invasion has to be seen in that historical context. They saw in us something useful for the moment.

Saturday, August 18, 2007

British generals tell Brown to withdraw from Basra

I'd like to point out the remark from a "senior British military commander":
“That’s to miss the point. It was never that kind of battle, in which we set out to defeat an enemy.”

also: it was never the role of occupation troops to intervene in a “turf war” among factions from the same community, all of which have links to the government coalition in Baghdad.

You see, our forces in Iraq are engaged in an OCCUPATION, not a BATTLE. You can only referee an occupation, you can't win it, because you have already won when you defeated the country's military that you are occupying. When neocons say that they want to "win" in Iraq, they miss the point; we already won. Now we're just hanging around acting as a police force in the middle of a civil war, trying to use military force to solve political, economic and social problems.

Sadly, the rest of the world is looking at how the White House is treating it's staunchest ally, and its not getting a pretty picture. Those who criticise Britain for failing to follow Bush to the bitter end are only saying to our allies (and those considering strengthening their alliance with us) that the U.S. does not consider their allies as anything more than proxies for American foreign policy. Is this our appreciation for Britain's support - to throw them to the wolves and denounce them as something akin to cowards for falling for Bush's thumbs-up, smiley-faced assertions and taking their military to the brink of collapse to save Bush's ego? This is the essence of Bush's supreme arrogance: the rest of the world exists only to serve our interests and those elements that cease to be useful to our interests will be discarded with contempt. That approach will win over a lot of governments to our side, won't it? It's the arrogant politics of a bully nation, not a world superpower trying to bring peace and democracy to the downtrodden and victimised.

The British people should be outraged at this shoddy treatment.

Those other nations in the coalition should take it as an object lesson.

The American people should reject the Bush Administration's callous assessment of the British military and voice their appreciation of Britain's courage.


Military commanders tell Brown to withdraw from Iraq without delay

By Raymond Whitaker and Robert Fox

Senior military commanders have told the Government that Britain can achieve “nothing more” in south-east Iraq, and that the 5,500 British troops still deployed there should move towards withdrawal without further delay.

Last month Gordon Brown said after meeting George Bush at Camp David that the decision to hand over security in Basra province – the last of the four held by the British – “will be made on the military advice of our commanders on the ground”. He added: “Whatever happens, we will make a full statement to Parliament when it returns [in October].”

Two generals told The Independent on Sunday last week that the military advice given to the Prime Minister was, “We’ve done what we can in the south [of Iraq]”. Commanders want to hand over Basra Palace – where 500 British troops are subjected to up to 60 rocket and mortar strikes a day, and resupply convoys have been described as “nightly suicide missions” – by the end of August. The withdrawal of 500 soldiers has already been announced by the Government. The Army is drawing up plans to “reposture” the 5,000 that will be left at Basra airport, and aims to bring the bulk of them home in the next few months.

Before the invasion in 2003, officers were told that the Army’s war aims were to bring stability and democracy to Iraq and to the Middle East as a whole. Those ambitions have been drastically revised, the IoS understands. The priorities now are an orderly withdrawal, with the reputation and capability of the Army “reasonably intact”, and for Britain to remain a “credible ally”. The final phrase appears to refer to tensions with the US, which has more troops in Iraq than at any other time, including the invasion, as it seeks to impose order in Baghdad and neighbouring provinces.

American criticism of Britain’s desire to pull back in southern Iraq has recently become public, with a US intelligence official telling The Washington Post this month that “the British have basically been defeated in the south”. A senior British commander countered, “That’s to miss the point. It was never that kind of battle, in which we set out to defeat an enemy.” Other officers said the British force was never configured to “clear and hold” Basra in the way the Americans are seeking to do in Baghdad.

Immediate American discontent is said to centre on the CIA’s reluctance to leave Basra Palace, an important base for watching Iran, which may explain why Britain has held on to the complex until now. But last week it was reported that US intelligence operatives were in the process of pulling out. Further ahead, the US is concerned over the security of its vital supply line from Kuwait, with some American commanders saying that if the British withdraw, American troops will have to be sent south to replace them. As the hub of Iraq’s oil industry, Basra is also a tempting prize for the Shia militias battling each other for control.

There are fears that the bloody power struggle in Basra will escalate sharply if and when British troops depart, but commanders point out that up to 90 per cent of the violence is directed against their forces. They are understood to believe it was never the role of occupation troops to intervene in a “turf war” among factions from the same community, all of which have links to the government coalition in Baghdad.

Mr Brown will have to take these wider concerns into account, in reaching a decision that has political as well as military implications. At Camp David he stressed that “we have duties to discharge and responsibilities to keep” in support of the Iraqi government and “the explicit will” of the international community. The 15 September report on the progress of the security “surge” by the US commander in Iraq, General David Petraeus, and the American ambassador to Baghdad, Ryan Crocker, will be crucial to British as well as US military plans.

General Petraeus is expected to report mixed results, and to plead for more time for the surge to work. But the White House, under pressure from Republicans facing disaster in the 2008 elections, is likely to announce at least some troop reductions. British commanders, and some US commentators, believe that will enable the Prime Minister to spell out plans for a British withdrawal when MPs return in October, although the process may last well into next year.

Bush's credibility is blown before the surge report is issued

Despite a surge in PR that essentially consists of Republicans endlessly repeating "the surge is working" for weeks on end, most Americans have already made up their minds that the report in September, putatively to be made by Petraeus, is a sham.
Republicans have made a great show of treating the report as a critical factor in their decision regarding the surge's fate. Since it seems that people don't trust this report, where does that leave these politicians?

If they hide behind the September report, the public will see them as relying on yet more "fixed" intelligence to falsely justify the continuing occupation.
If they reject the September report, the public will wonder why Republicans put so much faith in it during the months leading up to its release.

It's become increasingly clear that the report will not even be authored by Petraeus. The Bush Administration has repeatedly referred to "Petraeus' report" and "Petraeus' plan" for at least six months now. Now, however, the word has come down that the report will be written by the Administration. The Bush Administration has credibility only with its base these days, and those people would believe Bush if he claimed the Moon was made of green cheese, so that is hardly a vote of confidence. The only reason the September report was given any more importance than one of Bush's weekly radio addresses was because it would ostensibly come from an allegedly "independent" source: Petraeus. As usual, the White House innocently claims they have no idea how people could ever have even conceived the notion that the report would be made by Petraeus. This statement, like most from the Bush Administration these days, has some serious credibility issues. The more often the White House makes statements that nobody but their base believe to be true, the more irrelevant the Administration appears. The neocons can sputter in rage about Bush being the Decider and the Commander in Chief, but the public is increasingly looking at November 2008 as relief for that situation.

Despite resetting the "clock" for the surge from February to July (no fair - one tenth of the total surge force wasn't in place until July), despite a manic frenzy of assertion of the surge's success, despite non-stop characterisation of dissent against the occupation of Iraq as treason, despite shill reports by those who falsely claimed to be "critics" of the surge, despite intense pressure on military commanders to come up with good news in large quantities and on a regular basis, despite heavy punishment and censorship of "boots on the ground" who express contrary views of the surge, and despite allying ourselves with forces who openly express disloyalty to the elected government of Iraq, the surge still has failed to gain popular acceptance or credibility beyond those who initially backed it in January.

The surge was not really even Petraeus' plan. It was handed to him by the White House and Congress confirmed him to carry it out, whether or not it was sound. Republicans have used the "in for a penny, in for a pound" approach to portray this confirmation as an endorsement of the surge by the Democrats. Nobody has bought into that besides those same few people who believe everything Bush says already.

Already we are seeing snarling epithets by the right-wing denouncing anyone who doesn't completely accept the September assessment as the gospel truth to be "traitors", "defeatists", and "terrorist supporters". Do Republicans really think that accusing the majority of Americans of treason is an effective strategy to gain their support? Or is it merely a pretense to justify Republicans ignoring the public?
How many Republicans up for election in November '08 really truly think that denouncing their own constituents as traitors is a winning tack?

I said back in May that this would be the strategy Republicans would use:
Treason. It's the last card they can play, and the one most likely to make them look crazy.


The Republicans have staked everything on the surge. They cannot possibly admit it is a failure; they can only sinuously re-define the word "success" and hope most people don't laugh in their faces. They can only lie and say that the objective of the surge all along has been to shuffle Al-Qaeda from one area to another while watching the impotent al-Maliki government go through its death throes and the tiny, useless Iraqi military stumbling around doing nothing.

story from Xinhua

Poll shows most Americans [do] not trust Sept. Iraq report

WASHINGTON, Aug. 17 (Xinhua) -- A majority of Americans do not trust the upcoming report by top U.S. commander in Iraq on the progress of the war, according to a new poll released on Friday.

U.S. President George W. Bush has frequently asked Congress and the American people to withhold judgment on his so-called "troop surge" in Iraq until David Petraeus, the top commander in Iraq, and Ryan Crocker, U.S. ambassador to Iraq, issue their progress report in September.

But according to a CNN/Opinion Research Corp. poll released on Friday, 53 percent of people polled said they suspect that the military assessment of the situation will try to make it sound better than it actually is.

The poll also indicates that most of America's mind is made up about the war -- 72 percent said the report will have no effect on their view of the war.

The survey was based on interviews of 1,029 Americans by telephone between Aug. 6 and 8.

Commenting on the poll, White House spokesman Tony Snow said on Friday that he hoped that "people do not try to engage in personal attacks on Gen. Petraeus or Ambassador Crocker."


From the CNN report:

CNN Polling Director Keating Holland said he doesn't think the mistrust is directed at Petreaus as much as it is what he represents.

Holland said, "I suspect most people are hearing the words 'general' and 'Iraq' and that's what they're basing their opinion on."

He added, "It does seem to indicate that anyone associated with the Bush administration may be a less than credible messenger for the message that there is progress being made in Iraq."


Could that be why the Bush Administration has implied for so long that the report would be Petraeus'? The White House makes "positive reports" about Iraq virtually every single day. Why would one in September be seen as particularly illuminating if it wasn't coming from Petraeus?
Just as Bush has repeatedly implied that Iraq was behind 9/11 without saying that directly, so the White House has repeatedly implied that the report would be authored by Petraeus without saying it directly. While this may be seen by right-wing bloggers as some kind of "cover", it appears completely weasel-like to those who haven't drank the Republican Kool-Aid. At some point, the Republicans will have to stop essentially waging a primary election campaign and deal with the American public at large.

The boots on the ground speak: Diyala

This is an excerpt from a post from a blog that I have noted before.
Army of Dude is a blog written a soldier named Alex currently serving in Diyala, the province that neocons wax ecstatic over as proof that the surge is "working". This particular pair of "boots on the ground", however, sees things quite differently from the press releases written by commanders trying hard not to be the next Shinseki.

I strongly encourage you to take a moment to read not only the entire post in Alex's blog, but the other entries. One point of interest is his post detailing the pressure to re-enlist.

In the excerpt that follows, Alex outlines possible nominees for the stupidest mistakes made by the military in the areas he has served. Emphases are mine.

Working with 1920s – A Sunni insurgent group we’ve been battling for months, responsible for the death of my friend and numerous attacks, agreed to fight Al Qaeda alongside us. Since then, they’ve grown into a much more organized, lethal force. They use this organization to steal cars and intimidate and torture the local population, or anyone they accuse of being linked to Al Qaeda. The Gestapo of the 21st century, sanctioned by the United States Army.

The Surge – The beefing up of ground forces in Iraq at the beginning of the year, started by the 82nd Airborne. Unit deployments were moved up several months to maintain a higher level of boots on the ground to quell the Baghdad situation. What most don’t realize is the amount of actual fighting troops in a brigade, something in the area of 2,000 soldiers in a brigade of 5,000 depending on what unit it is. So for every 2,000 fighters, there are 3,000 pencil pushers sucking up resources in every brigade that was surged. A logistical nightmare that, surprise, failed miserably. The increase of troops in Baghdad pushed the insurgents to rural areas (like Diyala), hence our move here in March. The surge was nothing more than a thorn in the side of nomadic fighters having to move thirty five miles while the generals watched Baghdad with stubborn eyes.

Two Companies Clearing Baqubah – Which brings us to the next nominee. Since Baghdad was the showcase of the war and Baqubah was brimming with super IEDs taking our Bradleys and Abrams tanks, it was decided that a unit needed to be sent there to assist the cavalry unit who averaged a death per week. But how many to send? Someone, somehow, somewhere decided that two companies of Strykers would be adequate to take down what Al Qaeda had deemed their headquarters in Iraq. What came about this oversight? Two hours into the first mission, my friend was killed in a massive IED blast that busted the hell out of the squad leader’s face, resulting in traumatic brain injury and facial reconstruction surgery. The vehicle commander tore his ACL from the concussion. Shrapnel being thrown around the inside of the truck caught one dude in the knee as a dude in the back hatch got rattled around, bruising his back as the other in the hatch was thrown completely out the vehicle. He’s been quiet since then, and was sent home soon after. Returning fire from us and the Bradleys killed an untold number of kids unlucky enough to be in the school next to our position. A wrecker sent out to pick up the destroyed Stryker was the next victim of an IED explosion, killing two men inside. Two more wreckers were sent out, one for the Stryker, one for the now totaled wrecker. As we pulled out that evening, local Iraqis, men, women and children, danced in celebration by the massive crater where the Stryker had been. At once we realized reinforcements were needed but we didn’t get any for two more months. Many more men were killed because we were stretched to our operational breaking point. But there was always more to do. Whoever made the decision to send less than an infantry battalion should be in jail right now.

The Extension – This wasn’t too much of a surprise to us, as we knew in the back of our minds that an extension was in our future. What was surprising was the fact that everyone in Iraq was extended to fifteen month deployments. It was meant to give every unit at least a year in between deployments, as some were coming back to Iraq after only ten months back in the states. Now at the end, it’s not hard to assess the achievements of our three extra months. It seems at a quick glance that we pacified the city, street by street. There was a lull in American deaths because, simply, we absorbed all the bomb blasts or found the IEDs before they could detonate on us. As deadly as they are, deep buried IEDs must take a lot of time to build and emplace. The ones used against us were meant for the cavalry unit, who didn’t have the manpower to patrol the streets like we have been. After we arrived, there were few bombs that haven’t been sitting in the ground for several months already. The enemy ran out of ways to kill us until the ingenious idea of putting bombs in houses took hold. Instead of blowing us up in armored vehicles, they thought about doing it inside an abandoned house. What kills you isn’t the bomb, but the foundation of the house that comes crashing down after the explosion. Wires and triggers are hidden behind doors or underneath rugs, so when we go out and clear blocks and blocks of houses, there’s a pressure plate waiting for you at the foot of the stairs. Only your eyes can save you at this point. That tactic has been born from our proclivity to redundantly clear neighborhoods, and the extension is guilty of claiming lives of men who are running on too little sleep, walking into house after house in the desert heat. When you’re worried about how much water you have left and the trucks are too far away to get more, you tend to miss the trip wire in the dark stairwell. Twelve month deployments are a burden on your body and mind. Asking men for three more months is not only unfair but deadly.

Seven Men Killed At The Same Time – Finally, one of the lowest, saddest points of the deployment came in May. One night, a helicopter spotted several men gathered in the road with a large object. Permission was asked to fire a Hellfire missile at them, as they were obvious IED emplacers. Permission was emphatically denied, but someone decided that a Stryker platoon should head out there anyway to check it out. In tow was a Russian reporter. On a road called Trash Alley, they hit a massive deep buried IED. Everyone in the truck except the driver, six Americans and one Russian, dead. And they didn’t need to be there at all. A helicopter could have killed the insurgents with breathtaking ease. Instead, those guys and the one with the detonator got away in the night. Justice was never done.


War supporters always tell us to "listen to the boots on the ground". What goes unsaid, however, are the consequences for those "boots" who fail to repeat the scripted lines.

As for me, I started to sign these entries with my initials long ago to avoid detection by superiors. I could and still can get in trouble for what I’ve written. Lately this blog has been passed around to dudes of every rank, and those who would be punishing me have become readers.


...and also:

In the future, I want my children to grow up with the belief that what I did here was wrong, in a society that doesn’t deem that idea unpatriotic.


This soldier's post is a heart-breaking read and I sincerely hope that nobody reading this sees this an opportunity to punish someone who has served their country but fails to squawk like a parrot when cued. The Republican's crazy "dissent is treason" mantra should be excepted in the case of the troops, but sadly it is the case where this belief is applied most stringently. "Support the troops", my ass. They mean "support the troops that say what they are told to say, and punish those who are brave enough to speak the truth".

Like most war testimonials, this one tells a story of someone fighting for their friends rather than some glorious cause. That's what makes me deeply suspicious of accounts from tools like Michael Yon, who is forever spinning tales of soldiers spouting the Party line and saying things that sound like they come from Tony Snow's mouth. Maybe officers talk like that, officers seeking quick promotion with little regard for the men under their command, that is. The "grunts", however, don't have time for that and don't see any future in it. They know better than to speak their minds around such officers, which only serves to reinforce the fantasy world of these craven toadies. This lot was still chirping away with glowing reports of 'enemy' body counts and inevitable success in Vietnam right up to the bitter end. Do we never learn?

I think that the right-wing had better brace themselves for more stories such as Alex's when the surge is over. These guys won't keep their mouths shut forever, especially once they find out to what devious lengths the Bush Administration will go to when denying them their benefits and care. Once they start to look for a job and find Republican fundies mouthing "we support your service" tonelessly while tossing their resumes in the trash, they will surely wise up to the immense fraud, lies, and hypocrisy at the foundation of the neocon's 'support' for the troops. Having built up the troops as a nearly angelic group beyond reproach or criticism, the Republicans will find it very difficult indeed to suddenly label these men and women as 'traitors' and 'defeatists'.

The major strategic "progress" of the surge has been in enlisting the sectarian militias in the effort to fight Al-Qaeda, which somehow is the most important thing.
Not only does this tactic glaringly point out the failure of the Iraqi military and police, but it also puts us directly in league with those who have tortured and killed innocent Iraqis for years in a short-term bid to tackle a relatively minor cause of the massive instability in Iraq. It was the (Iraqi) police and military who were supposed to take the lead in the surge, not our troops and certainly not the gangs that the surge was supposed to disarm. These sectarian militias are little more than street gangs, and their objectives are not nobler or more evolved than common street gangs, yet our alliance with them is the major reason behind the "pacification". In an earlier post, Alex poignantly describes an exchange with one of these militia's members:

For now, our relationship with 1920 is one of mutual distrust and hatred, a sign of the times. A conversation between a member of my platoon and a 1920 source is ripe with foreboding on the future of this partnership, and of the war to come.
“Do you want to kill me?” asked the soldier.
“Yes,” replied the source, coldly and without emotion. “But not today.
”


Does this sound like a tactic we can put our faith in? Or does it sound like a short-term move to create the illusion of long-term success while a report is due? I wish those who support the surge and claim that it's "working" would explain how it will deal the sectarian militias once the reason for this alliance of convenience disappears. It is nothing short of madness to keep on repeating that Al-Qaeda is the big problem facing Iraq, but that is exactly what we gambled the farm on. Instead, for all of this compromise with the gangs, we have merely managed to keep Al-Qaeda moving around. There is no "reconciliation"; there is only a temporary distraction that the Iraqi government, police, and military are completely squandering. And we have bought this sham of success with the extension of soldiers like Alex.

SCO begins to form as a counter to U.S. might

Beyond the announcement of Russian bomber runs, this story details the rise of the SCO (Shanghai Co-operation Organisation), which has the potential to create a powerful bloc of Central Asian states in alliance with Russia, China, India, Pakistan, and Iran. Our counter to such a bloc is Afghanistan, a country in which our puppet barely controls the capitol. Our "pull" with NATO is largely limited to Britain, and we've gone to that well far too often

Once we relied on Russia and China to keep each other in check, much as we once relied on Hussein's Iraq to keep Iran in check. With Russia and China on the Security Council, the SCO would instead prove a powerful check on PNAC's ambitions for a glorious "American Century" where the rest of the world marvels at our power and gladly bends over at our every whim. In Pakistan, it's looking like our puppet Musharraf is going to lose power due to democracy. India, while friendly, stopped meekly bowing to the U.S. long ago. And Iran, the current scapegoat for everything wrong with the world, no longer has Iraq to worry about. With the exception of China, all of these players in the SCO are at least nominal democracies, which gives the lie to Bush and other Republican's fantasy that democracy will pave the way to the easy triumph of our foreign policies across the globe. Also, with the possible exception of Iran, all of the countries in the SCO are nuclear powers.

China has rapidly developed into a strong naval power while the U.S. is still committed to the defence of Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, and to a lesser extent Australia and New Zealand. China has no such commitments on the other side of the planet from them as we do. The costs of our military efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan are kept "off the books" largely due to the sale of debt to China, ironically financing their military and industrial development with the interest. The U.S. is the only serious impediment to China's hegemony, and our financial and industrial resources are increasingly being put in China's hands. Putting financial or trade sanctions on China would be suicide for the U.S. American companies have been falling over themselves to close plants at home and move them to China. While taking a financial hit doing so, China could easily cause a collapse of the dollar by dumping their holdings on the market. Such a move would undoubtedly persuade several economies to move to the euro as the reserve currency, which would be an unmitigated catastrophe for the U.S. economy.

Russia, too, has seen a comeback due to its energy resources. Sanctions against Russia would cut off Europe's energy supplies. While not a formidible threat to take on the U.S. itself militarily, Russia remains a regional military superpower with a more advanced military than its Eastern European neighbours our its former client states to the south. They are also free of any military commitments on the other side of the globe now that Cuba is on its own. For decades, Russia has been treated to a condescending approach from the U.S. and, as a result, has failed to back American efforts and regional interests.

Meanwhile, the U.S. pours several dozens of millions into Israel every single day, mostly in the form of "loans" that are forgiven before they are due for re-payment. None of the SCO countries have commitments like this. The two other major recipients of our foreign aid, Egypt and Colombia, do nothing to enhance our economic or military interests and are among the best examples of "democracy" gone wrong.

What reason do we have to believe that a nation such as Iraq, when "stabilised", will be a strong ally of the U.S. and back our foreign policy interests? With sanctions, and later, invasion and hapless occupation, the U.S. has reduced a modern nation with a high standard of living to a disaster state without electrical or water delivery infrastructure, much less security. How many of those tortured in Iraqi prisons by a puppet government controlled from the White House will see the U.S. as a friend? How many of those forced from the "progress" in Iraq by fleeing to the "enemy" state of Syria will view the U.S. as a source for "good"? Once the dollars stop flowing from the American taxpayer into the pockets of corrupt Iraqi politicians, how many will continue to follow the script they are handed?
Or will Iraqis look to the SCO as a natural ally, an alliance free of the negative associations with the U.S?
The best possible outcome is the only likely outcome in Bush-land. The rest of us, however, had better start to look beyond slogans and flag-waving down the road at what awaits us when the world stops seeing us as the solution, and instead as the problem.


Russia to resume Cold War bomber flights

By Adrian Blomfield in Moscow and agencies
Last Updated: 5:30pm BST 17/08/2007

Russia will immediately resume long-range strategic bomber flights on a "permanent" basis, ending a 15-year suspension of the missions, President Vladimir Putin has said.

Mr Putin said a halt in long-range bombers' flights after the Soviet collapse had affected Russia's security as other nations had continued such missions - a oblique reference to the US.

"I have made a decision to resume regular flights of Russian strategic aviation," he said.

"Starting today, such tours of duty will be conducted regularly and on a strategic scale.

"Our pilots have been grounded for too long; they are happy to start a new life."

Soviet bombers routinely flew such missions to areas from which nuclear-tipped cruise missiles could be launched at the United States. But that stopped in the post-Soviet economic meltdown.

In Washington, a State Department Spokesman said the US was not troubled by the decision.

"It's interesting. We certainly are not in the kind of posture we were with what used to be the Soviet Union. It's a different era. If Russia feels as though they want to take some of these old aircraft out of mothballs and get them flying again, that's their decision."


Yes, arrogance is always the best defence. The best possible outcome is the only likely outcome. Is there any real reason to worry?

Mr Putin's comments came as he and his Chinese counterpart, Hu Jintao, attended an unprecedented show of joint military force amid fears that the Russian leader is trying to turn an increasingly powerful central Asian alliance into a second Warsaw Pact.

The United States will be anxiously watching the military manoeuvres - held under the auspices of the six-member Shanghai Co-operation Organisation (SCO) - from afar after its request to send observers was rejected.

Washington has plenty of reasons to be uneasy. Founded in 2001, the SCO, which includes the four central Asian nations of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyztan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan as well as China and Russia, is rapidly gaining a reputation as an anti-Western organisation.

That image seems to be one that Mr Putin is happy to cultivate. Analysts say that the Russian president believes the organisation is emerging as a bloc that is rapidly becoming powerful enough to stand up to the West.

Russia's most pro-government newspapers, often used by the Kremlin as propaganda vehicles, yesterday proclaimed the arrival of an "anti-Nato" alliance and a "Warsaw Pact 2". At the annual SCO summit in the Kyrgyz capital Bishkek yesterday, Mr Putin praised the alliance's growing strength. "Year after year the SCO becomes a more significant factor in strengthening security and stability in the central Asian region," he said.

In a thinly disguised swipe at Washington, which mirrored earlier attacks on American "unilateralism" and "diktat", he added: "We are convinced that any attempts to resolve global and regional problems alone are useless."

For the most part, the summit's agenda concentrated on promoting energy co-operation in central Asia, whose vast resources have elevated the region's geopolitical importance.

The West has been desperate to strengthen its presence in the area but has begun to fall behind both Russia and China in a race for influence that has been compared to the 19th century Great Game, when Britain and Russia competed for control of the region.

Yet the SCO has wider ambitions. Pakistan, India and Mongolia all want to join - as does Iran, whose president, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad, attended the summit as guest of honour, a title bound to rile Washington. Iranian membership of the SCO would pose an enormous headache for the United States. Like Nato, its treaty states that an attack on one member is regarded as an attack on all, raising the prospect that the United States could find itself aligned against both Russia and China if it invaded Iran. Yet, for all Mr Putin's posturing, most analysts believe that an underlying antagonism between the member states means that the SCO is far from cohesive, a charge that reduces its chances to be effective.

Thrown together for the moment by mutual expediency, Russia and China have historically distrusted each other. Beijing, which plays host to the Olympic Games next summer, has much less interest in antagonising the United States and would almost certainly block Iran's accession to the club.

Similarly, the central Asian nations are wary of the two regional superpowers - although, for the time being, the tolerance of Beijing and Moscow for their autocratic ways is more attractive than the demands to democratise made by the United States.

Even so, today's exercises will serve as a reminder that the global balance of power is shifting.

For the first time ever, China is deploying troops, tanks and aircraft on a combined mission abroad.

The exercises, being held in the Russian region of Chelyabinsk, involve 6,500 troops, heavy weapons and combat aircraft.

While the goal of the mission is to simulate the capture of a city held by terrorists, the sight of Russian and Chinese troops marching together will give observers in Washington pause for reflection.