Saturday, July 21, 2007

Baghdad yields yet more signs of progress

Yet another tragedy that has nothing to do with Al-Qaeda, but rather the woeful indifference to the sectarian militias. Since tackling the militias is proving much more difficult than he laid out in his surge proposal back in January, Bush has instead shifted to the focus to "All Al-Qaeda, all the time".
Of course, Al-Qaeda simply moves to wherever the surge forces are not concentrated, and this is apparently some kind of 'success' in some circles, especially those circles involving those under the command of or in the pay of the Decider.

full story

Bodies of seven abducted Iraqi policemen found south of Baghdad


The bodies of seven abducted Iraqi policemen, including an officer, were found in an area in Babil province south of Baghdad on Thursday, a provincial police source said.

"Our police patrols found seven bodies of policemen, including the body of Lieutenant Colonel Salam Hannon, police chief of Iskandariyah town, dumped in the Mwiylha area outside the town," the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

The victims were attacked and then adducted by a group of gunmen on Wednesday evening in a rural area outside the town of Iskandariyah, some 50 km south of Baghdad, the source said.

Iskandariyah, along with several large towns in the Babil province including Yousifiyah, Mahmoudiyah, Musayyib and Latifiyah, are parts of an area known as the "Triangle of Death" inhabited by both Sunni and Shiite Muslims.

Source: Xinhua




Friday, July 20, 2007

Republican revisionist history

"Wright County Republican" blog
Below is a post from a Republican blog. The blog refused to print my comment, so I will make it public here and at considerably greater length.
The author of the Republican blog is mad about an editorial in the Star/Tribune (Minneapolis) that was critical of Bush's Iraq policies. Essentially it is a parroting of Republican talking points, so it should be easy to deal with. Emphasis in boldface is mine to separate the issues at hand from the froth.

Strib Continues Assault On Bush

Par Ridder and Susan Albright (and whoever else is left at the financially depleted Star Tribune)once again take up prime space in their Op-Ed pages today to drive home the democrat mantra of "failed strategy" in Iraq.

What used to be a credible local newspaper now can't even claim the character of Congress as the Strib blatantly supports the dem talking points by attacking the surge well in advance of the scheduled reports from military leaders in Iraq. This is nincompoopism at its height. Democrats in Congress supported the plan to increase troops in Iraq with a September report card due from General Patraeus. It's July and every liberal and their sister is calling for a cut and run policy shift sooner than later. You can't have it both ways.

The surge is working. We are turning the corner in Iraq. Al-Qaeda is deperate and knows if the democrats don't win in '08 Al-Qaeda's agenda for the Muslimification of the western world will suffer a great setback.

If Par and Susan have a better idea they should bring it forward for all to see. We're open to suggestions on how to win the war. But they only have carefully crafted political rhetoric aimed at further setting the stain of cowardice that is being put forth by the left.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Democrats in Congress did not vote for the surge. Nobody voted in support of the surge, because there was no vote taken. What the mixed-up author of the blog, Drew, seems to be referring to is the vote to confirm Petraeus. Yes, Democrats voted to confirm Petraeus. He's a fine officer. Oddly, both the blog author and Bush are trying to make it seem as if the surge was Petraeus' plan. It wasn't. It was Bush's plan, as proposed in a speech given Jan.10. This distortion is being applied to make Petraeus take the fall for the failure of the surge, and to make it seem like Bush was misled by his commander. By the way, the "report card" was Bush's idea. Also, does anyone seriously think that if the surge had somehow been a brilliant success that Republicans would have shared the credit with Democrats? No, just the blame when it all goes sour, apparently.

The text of Bush's Jan. 10 speech in which he proposed the surge
I covered this speech in an earlier post.

Okay, so in this speech Bush lays out an optimistic assessment and an optimistic plan to bring security to Iraq and quell the sectarian killings that were the primary concern at the time. Well, as optimistic as "Grim Bush " got at the time:


"Even if our new strategy works exactly as planned, deadly acts of violence will continue — and we must expect more Iraqi and American casualties. The question is whether our new strategy will bring us closer to success. I believe that it will."

Sounds like a winner, doesn't it? A close look at the speech shows he is mostly looking for success in Baghdad, but he mentions the 'success' in Anbar. Remember, in Anbar we gave up on the Iraqi military and police and allied ourselves with one armed gang to wipe out another armed gang. Of course, the goal of the surge, as stated by Bush, was to support the Iraqi military in their efforts to stabilise the country. Instead, in Anbar we do an end run around the useless Iraqi military and somehow brag about it. Of course, Anbar only holds about 1% of Iraq's population, so it's unclear how this 'success' is really so significant when looking at the big picture.
In that speech Bush was also confident about the Al-Maliki government regaining control of all the provinces by November.

"To establish its authority, the Iraqi government plans to take responsibility for security in all of Iraq's provinces by November."

How's that working out? Also, the surge was supposed to be primarily Iraqi troops with the U.S. military backing them up when they got into tough spots. Note the mention only of Baghdad, which is one city. Note also that currently the Iraqi military has only six brigades ready to work independently. Three of these are Kurdish, which means that if Turkey actually does cross the border into Kurdistan, half of the Iraqi military will be recalled from Baghdad.

"Now let me explain the main elements of this effort: The Iraqi government will appoint a military commander and two deputy commanders for their capital. The Iraqi government will deploy Iraqi Army and National Police brigades across Baghdad's nine districts. When these forces are fully deployed, there will be 18 Iraqi Army and National Police brigades committed to this effort, along with local police. These Iraqi forces will operate from local police stations — conducting patrols and setting up checkpoints, and going door-to-door to gain the trust of Baghdad residents."


And this is the only mention of using the surge to combat Al-Qaeda, and it clearly specifies Anbar province:

"Our military forces in Anbar are killing and capturing al Qaeda leaders, and they are protecting the local population. Recently, local tribal leaders have begun to show their willingness to take on al Qaeda. And as a result, our commanders believe we have an opportunity to deal a serious blow to the terrorists. So I have given orders to increase American forces in Anbar Province by 4,000 troops. These troops will work with Iraqi and tribal forces to keep up the pressure on the terrorists. America's men and women in uniform took away al Qaeda's safe haven in Afghanistan — and we will not allow them to re-establish it in Iraq."


Of course, now the plan has changed goals. Since the Iraqi forces never materialised and had been proven to be incompetent and even disloyal to Al-Maliki, Bush started claiming two months ago that the surge was all about clearing Al-Qaeda from Iraq, rather than stabilising the Al-Maliki goverment or disarming the sectarian militias as he originally had proposed. It's also about clearing Al-Qaeda out of Diyala and Baghdad, which wasn't mentioned in this speech.

Now, back to Drew's post. Bush laid out a plan to increase the number of U.S. troops in order to quell sectarian militias in Baghdad and to drive Al-Qaeda out of Anbar in that Jan. 10 speech. Unhappy with his then-current commander for not giving him sufficiently upbeat news, Bush named Petraeus as the man who would lead the surge. The confirmation vote was only to let Petraeus take the post that Bush had already assigned him so that he could execute the mission (the surge) that Bush had already laid out. It was not a vote on the surge at all, since Bush had made it clear that he was the Decider and was in command of the military. In fact, Democrats were deeply sceptical and opposed to the surge.
The first troops were deployed on Feb. 14. By June 3/4 of the total troop force was in place. Still, the murky 'success' in Anbar was the only bright spot to point to. "Wait until the other 1/4 of the troops are there", said the Republicans, as if this would make all of the difference in the world. By June it was clear that this was going to be entirely a American effort, that the Iraqi government was incapable of regaining control of the country, that sectarian militias were not going to be disarmed, and that Al-Qaeda had simply moved to wherever we weren't applying pressure with the surge.
And Republicans still kept pointing to Anbar, six months on, as the major 'success story' of the surge.
This didn't seem like much of a "success" to the public. In fact, it seemed exactly like what we had before the surge was even started.

The answer was for Bush to pretend that the surge had been about Al-Qaeda all along.

Basically he took the 'success' of Anbar, which was already in place before the surge, and claimed that this was due to the surge.
This is how shills like Drew can state:

"The surge is working. We are turning the corner in Iraq."

...when actually none of the objectives that Bush promised the surge would achieve have materialised at this point in time. As for this:

Al-Qaeda is deperate and knows if the democrats don't win in '08 Al-Qaeda's agenda for the Muslimification of the western world will suffer a great setback.

My, Drew seems to know a great deal about the schemes, motives, and inner thoughts of Al-Qaeda, doesn't he? Except that Al-Qaeda's stated goal is to get foreign infidel troops out the Middle East, not "muslimify" the Western world. They really don't seem that desperate, either. Wherever the surge concentrates, they leave that spot and move to an area where the surge isn't concentrated. In fact, as everyone who doesn't get their talking points from Bush already knows, the central focus of Al-Qaeda is in the frontier of Pakistan, not Iraq.

So five months on from the surge's start, and five years from the invasion, Iraq is no better of by almost any metric (possibly the undertaker's business has improved). The electicity is on in Baghdad for only three hours a day. The economy is a shambles. Sectarian militias are as strong as before the surge and still manage to torture and kill 300-400 a month. The government of Iraq has only now begun to make extremely feeble moves at political reconciliation. The hospitals are run by a Shia militia who denies care to Sunnis. Al-Maliki is facing a vote of no-confidence. The Iraqi military is still poorly trained and equipped and woefully undermanned. And this 'success' is costing $2 billion a week.
But all we need is another month and a half. All of this will turn around by then, see? And if doesn't, then obviously (to Drew) it will be the Democrat's fault somehow. Or Bush will simply change the definiton of "success" yet again. And as always, the Republican author of the blog under discussion feels that it's "far too early" to say the surge is a failure, but past time to say it's a success.

Thursday, July 19, 2007

Signs of progress in Diyala

More 'signs of progress' from Diyala province in Iraq. The morgue can't deal with all of the bodies piling up. The solution is mass graves for the growing numbers of unidentified and unidentifiable dead. Of course, these must be Al-Qaeda that we're killing, right? After all, they are dead.
Also note that numbers reported, which are used by U.S. military commanders to show a decrease of violence, are a fraction of the actual numbers.


IRAQ: Mass Graves Dug to Deal With Death Toll
By Ahmed Ali*

BAQUBA, Jul 17 (IPS) - The largest morgue in Diyala province is overflowing daily. Officials told IPS they have had to dig mass graves to dispose of bodies.

More and more bodies of victims of the ongoing violence are being found every day in Baquba, capital city of the province, 50km northeast of Baghdad.

"The morgue receives an average of four or five bodies everyday," Nima Jima'a, a morgue official, told IPS. "Many more are dropped in rivers and farms -- or it is sometimes the case they are buried by their killers for other reasons. The number we record here is only a fraction of those killed."

Ambulances, now able to move again after weeks of restrictions, have been removing bodies of victims from the current fighting. But they have also found skulls and bones, evidence of other killings long ago.

Dealing with these remains is becoming difficult. Like the rest of the city, the morgue suffers from continuing lack of electricity. Over the last two weeks, two of its refrigerators have been shut down. The smell of decomposing bodies hits visitors 100 metres away.

Morgue officials told IPS that a local U.S. military commander recently ordered them to bury all bodies within three days.

"We got 30 bodies out of the refrigerator on Sunday, put a number on each, and put them in plastic bags provided by U.S. troops," morgue official Kareem al-Rubaee told IPS. "We asked families to have a look at the bodies. Then, they were buried collectively."

There is expected to be a need now to bury bodies collectively every 15-20 days in order keep the capacity of the refrigerator intact, al-Rubaee said.

Families are often unable to identify and collect the bodies, morgue officials say. It is still extremely dangerous to travel around the city. Also, most bodies are never brought to the morgue at all to be identified or counted.

Many victims of U.S. air strikes have been buried under the rubble of their homes for days, sometimes weeks, residents say. The military operation has been launched to target al-Qaeda, amid local reports that the operation began after the al-Qaeda suspects had fled town.

People in the town feel targeted by killings from all sides. Foreign terror groups, like those who claim to be following the model of al-Qaeda, have kidnapped many people who are never heard from again.

Groups believed to be al-Qaeda have been known to kill and then drop the body in selected places that they call "the execution zone." This is intended to show people the power of al-Qaeda.

Police vehicles and ambulances have been moving bodies mainly from such spots to the morgue.

Baquba, never anticipating such a death toll, has only a small morgue, and limited means to carry out necessary procedures.

"When a number of bodies are brought to the morgue, we take at least two photos from different angles," Mohammed Abid, another official at the morgue told IPS. "Generally, the bodies are brought without identity cards. This is a problem for the families for whom the photographs are not enough -- faces are often deformed due to torture or shooting."

The refrigerators at the morgue are packed beyond capacity, and workers narrate grisly accounts of attempts to access the bodies for identification.

"My brother's photo is in the computer, but we couldn't get the body because it was taken by another family," 52-year-old primary schoolteacher Naser Sattar told IPS. "They thought him their son because the body was deformed."

The schoolteacher added, "I went to that family and got my brother's body and then buried it."

(*Ahmed, our correspondent in Iraq's Diyala province, works in close collaboration with Dahr Jamail, our U.S.-based specialist writer on Iraq who travels extensively in the region) (END/2007)

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Macedonia's 40 soldiers to stay on in Iraq

All 40 of Macedonia's soldiers will stay in Iraq for the forseeable future, and the world breathes a sigh of relief.
This is really about trying to get Bush's support for Macedonia's entry into NATO. After four years of stationing troops in Iraq, it hasn't got them anywhere. It will be interesting to watch how siding with the Decider plays out with the European members of NATO.
Full story

Macedonian forces to stay put in Iraq



Macedonian Defense Minister said on Monday that Macedonia will continue to participate in the U.S.-led mission in Iraq, news reaching here from Skopje reported.

Lazar Elenoviski made the pledge after meeting with Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Near East Affairs in the U.S. State Department and ex-ambassador to Macedonia, Lawrence Butler.

"Macedonia will continue its participation in the U.S.-led Freedom for Iraq operation," MIA, Macedonia's official news agency, quoted him as saying.

Butler highly praised the professional conduct of the Macedonian troops serving in Iraq, assuring Macedonia of the U.S. support for the country's NATO aspiration.

Macedonia has been longing to join NATO for years. In 2003, Macedonia joined Albania and Croatia and signed the Adriatic Treaty with the United States in a bid to facilitate their entry into the alliance.

Macedonia has been sending troops to Iraq since 2003. It now has one platoon of 40 soldiers stationed in Iraq.

The country has also contributed troops to the NATO-led mission in Afghanistan and the EU-led mission in Bosnia.

Source: Xinhua

Bush threatens financial sanctions

Since Bush has repeatedly stated that criticism of the occupation in Iraq "emboldens" Al-Qaeda, is this a way to silence opposition?
full story

U.S. to financially sanction Iraq "destabilizers"


The Bush administration announced on Tuesday that it would financially sanction any individual or organization thought to destabilize Iraq.

According to a new executive order signed by U.S. President George W. Bush, the U.S. Department of Treasury and other government agencies will freeze financial assets belong to people or groups that the United States believes to be "working to threaten stability in Iraq."

"All agencies of the United States government are hereby directed to take all appropriate measures within their authority to carry out the provisions of this order," said the order.

The order did not name any person, company or group as such " destabilizer."

But the Treasury Department said it would draw up such a list " in coming weeks and months."

White House spokesman Tony Snow said the order will be targeting terrorist and insurgent groups, including those supported by Syria and Iran.

Bush has issued similar orders to financially sanction individuals and groups the U.S. government thought to help specific groups, such as al-Qaida and Hezbollah.

Source: Xinhua

ISG says "Iraqi forces have not measured up"

Again, the issue in NOT Al-Qaeda, which is what the surge is focusing on. Instead, it is the ability of the Iraqi military and political elements to hold up their end.
War supporters quote wildly optimistic statements from military commanders who will lose their jobs if they don't show big progress real fast. But all of these optimistic statements generally revolve around fighting Al-Qaeda. The U.S. military is working feverishly to fix a leaky faucet in a house that is not only condemned, but collapsing. At this point, the best case scenario is that Petraeus will be able to point to a shiny water faucet in a rodent-and-termite infested kitchen while stepping carefully around loose floorboards to say that we have "won" and the spigot is ready to go.
The disconnect with reality when reading the right-wing blogs is astonishing. Huge progress has been made, or so they claim, and Iraq is stable and on the road to properity. Everyone killed or arrested is Al-Qaeda, and they are putatively crumbling....but somehow still an enormous threat. And we need more troops, since things are going so well.
During the Vietnam endgame, the public also heard ridiculously optimistic reports from military commanders eager to look good. Body counts of the "enemy" were rising everyday, the South Vietnamese were battling back, the people loved us and it would all wrapped up in no time.
What good will it do to rid the country of Al-Qaeda if the Iraqi military cannot hold ground or the politicians cannot even agree to disagree?
full story


Iraq Study Group co-chair paints bleak Iraq picture



Former Rep. Lee Hamilton, co- chair of the Iraq Study Group, said on Monday that the Iraqi government is far from "resolving sectarian differences" and Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki has underperformed.

In an interview with NBC's "Today Show", he said that Iraq's forces will not be able to provide the complete security for the country any time soon.

"These Iraqi forces that we have been training now for several years simply have not measured up overall," Hamilton said, adding that it would take "a remarkable bit of progress in a very short period of time for them to meet the prime minister's goals" of allowing Iraq's forces to take over security by the end of the year.

Hamilton was highly critical of Maliki, claiming that "He's known exactly what he has to do; he hasn't done it. His rhetoric is pretty good; his performance is pretty bad."

The Iraqi parliament "has been a huge disappointment all along" and is "not dealing with the fundamental problems of the country," Hamilton said.

In particular, Hamilton criticized the Bush administration for giving Iraq a satisfactory rating on the issue in last week's assessment report on the country's progress.

"What they have actually done is create a committee to look at it," Hamilton said.

"Now, creating a committee is a matter of process. It is not a matter of result. It is not close to resolving the sectarian differences that are required to bring about national reconciliation," he said.


Hamilton was making the accusation at a time when the Bush administration is under growing pressure from lawmakers of both the Republican and Democratic parties to change the Iraq policy.

Democrats said they will try again this week to set a timetable to withdraw U.S. troops from Iraq.

Source: Xinhua



Monday, July 16, 2007

UN: Iraqi children worse off than a year ago

Now we all know that Republicans are excruciatingly concerned with the poor Iraqi civilians. That's why we can't leave Iraq; a "bloodbath" will surely follow. But now the UN has said that lack of nutritionally sound food and access to health care is making life miserable for women and children in Iraq. Well, not the privileged few that are in Bush's pocket, but, you know, the others. A cholera epidemic may break out.
The right-wing has done a great job of bragging about how life has improved for the "average Iraqi" under the occupation.

Still, Bush is not above using apparently outdated data to push his case. Or forgetting to pay the agency the money he promised.
full story

Situation of Iraqi children is worse: UN


The situation for Iraqi children is getting worse and, in some respects, it was better before the war began, a senior UN official said yesterday.

"Children today are much worse off than they were a year ago, and they certainly are worse off than they were three years ago," said Dan Toole, director of emergency programs for the United Nations Children's Fund. He said Iraqis no longer have safe access to a government-funded food basket, established under Saddam Hussein to deal with international sanctions.

Toole said conditions for women and children in Iraq had worsened significantly since the February 2006 bombing of a Shi'ite shrine in Samarra, north of Baghdad, which triggered a wave of sectarian violence and displacement that continues today.

He added that gains made shortly after the US toppled Saddam's government in 2003, when people were able to move around the country freely and had access to food markets and health centers, had been lost.

"Nutritional indicators, health access indicators are all changing for the worse," Toole said. He said recently published data showing improvement referred to the situation a couple of years ago and is outdated.

The system of government-sponsored handouts - set up by Saddam's government to meet the basic needs of Iraqi citizens from 1991 to 2003, when the country was under UN sanctions - started to fall apart last year, Toole said.

Apart from shortages of items such as milk and baby milk formula, "the basic Iraqi food basket was fairly secure under the regime because there was food coming in and the government provided the food basket to its citizens," he said.

Toole could not say whether malnutrition has worsened significantly but he said UNICEF was concerned by reports it has received from refugees fleeing the country.

Toole said that, because of the violence, mothers were too afraid to send their children to school or take them to health centers to get checkups and nutritional supplements.

While efforts are being made to maintain levels of immunization, particularly against measles and polio, UNICEF is worried about the possibility of a cholera epidemic because two-thirds of Iraqis lack clean water. A couple of cases of cholera have been reported in the south of Iraq but so far there has been no major outbreak, Toole said.

He said the agency has so far received no government donations toward a $41.5 million appeal for its Iraq work through the second half of 2007.

Source: China Daily/agencies



British military: "Iraq is a lost cause"

It's an open secret that Britain has been trying to get out of Iraq for some time now, in order to devote their resources to Afghanistan. Britain tried a "surge" of it's own in Basra before Bush (or was it Petraeus) ever proposed it. It actually did have some success, but only for the short-term. It turns out, surprisingly, that there were underlying problems that military force alone could not address. Yes, problems other than Al-Qaeda. Unbelievable. But that certainly won't happen to us, will it?
With the failure of the Basra "surge", the British troops resigned themselves to hunkering down in bunkers while taking a slow death with IEDs and mortars. And Tony Blair grinned bravely.
Now, the MOD has decided, according to a 'very senior commander", that Iraq is a lost cause.
Apparently the British military has misplaced their Bush parrot trained to squawk "Al-Qaeda!" when bad news comes out. Oh, dear.
full story


More Britons killed in Iraq than Americans proportionally: report




British soldiers serving in Iraq are being killed at a proportionally greater rate than their American counterparts for the first time since the start of the war, the Sunday Telegraph reported.

As attacks surged in Basra, southern Iraq, the death rate of British troops has now surpassed that of Americans, marking a "watershed" for British involvement in the conflict, which in turn leads to calls for the government to set an immediate timetable for withdrawal from the war-torn country, said the report.

It cited an analysis by Professor Sheila Bird, vice-president of the Royal Statistical Society, on British and American fatalities from May 2006 to June 2007.

Britain has 5,500 troops serving in Iraq, and suffered 23 fatalities between February 5 and June 24, whereas the United States has 165,000, and lost 463 over the same period, according Bird's analysis.

The newspaper quoted a very senior commander from the army as saying that the war in Iraq was now regarded by political and military chiefs within the Ministry of Defense as "a lost cause".

The commander urged that both Britain and America to accept they were facing the possibility of "strategic failure" in Iraq.


A think tank on Iraq suggest Britain should cease "offensive military operations" in Iraq and concentrate on training Iraqi security forces.

But a Ministry of Defense spokesman dismissed the comparison report as "too simplistic to try to extrapolate meaningful conclusions for the future."

Source: Xinhua

More signs of progress in Baghdad

More signs of success in Baghdad:

Full story

- An American convoy was targeted by an IED explosion in Zafaraniyah district south east Baghdad around 10.00 am. The US troops closed the area. No information provided about the casualties.

- Police found today 8 anonymous bodies in Washasha neighborhood downtown Baghdad. Police say that the 8 men killed were between 20-40 years old.

- 2 civilians were injured in an IED explosion in Mahmoudiyah town south Baghdad around 12:00 pm.

- A civilian was killed and 2 others wounded in an IED explosion targeted a police commandos patrol in Jisr Diyala district south east Baghdad around 12,20 pm.

- The bodies of 2 women were found in 2 neighborhoods east Baghdad today. The first body was found in Al Ghadeer neighborhood while the other body was found in Talbiyah neighborhood.

- A police officer (lieutenant Salih Mahdi) was killed by gunmen near his house in Al Amil neighborhood south west Baghdad today morning.

- 5 civilians were killed and 15 others wounded in a parked car bomb explosion in Al Hussein square in Jadriyah neighborhood downtown Baghdad at 3:45 pm.

- One civilian was killed and one was injured after random gunfire by gunmen in Al Adel neighborhood.

- Two civilians were injured after random gunfire by gunmen in Saidiyah.

- Police found 22 dead bodies throughout the capital today. 2 in Mansour, 8 in Washash, 3 in Amil, 2 in Mahmoudiyah, 2 in Doura, 1 in Adil, 1 (woman) in Ghadeer, 1 (woman) Bunouk, 2 in Sadr

This is one day in Baghdad, where the surge is strongest and the biggest results are promised. If the Bush ventriloquist dummies are to be believed, then this will come to an abrupt halt on the last day of August.
Again , I have to ask the rhetorical question: In terms of stability and a sense of security, does it really matter if 300 instead of 400 a month are killed by sectarian forces?
Okay, right-wing, all together now: "It's AL-QAEDA!" Yup, those Shia Al-Qaeda. Very rare. But, I mean, who else could it be? The military and police forces that are thoroughly (by our commanders' reckoning) infiltrated by sectarian militias? You know, the ones that are going to "stand up" so that we can "stand down". Uh, umm...why don't you check with Fox News and get back to me on that one, okay?

Sunday, July 15, 2007

Fox says Iraqi troops not loyal to al-Maliki

Note the quote from (Rear Adm.) Fox (in bold) about how the Iraqi police and military are not loyal to the al-Maliki government.
Note that almost half of the "foreign insurgents" in Iraq are from Saudi Arabia. The Decider wants us to think the Iranians are the bad guys.
Note another car bomb in Baghdad, where the surge is strongest and where people are supposedly in love with U.S. troops.
Note once-peaceful Kurdistan is now becoming a target of Al-Qaeda. The right-wing who adore Petraeus should remember his "balloon analogy" and realise that putting pressure in one area only moves the problem to another area.
Note the "US commanders" say the Iraqi police are "often" infilitrated by Shiite militias.

These are all facts from Iraqi officials or US commanders, not the "liberal media".

From the Daily Star
Iraq announces it is holding more than 2,000 foreign suspects

Compiled by Daily Star staff
Monday, July 16, 2007


A top Iraqi official said Sunday Baghdad supports Saudi efforts to prevent cross-border infiltrations while the Interior Ministry announced having detained over 2,000 foreign suspects. In another day of violence, at least 25 Iraqis were killed in separate attacks.

In an interview with the Saudi Okaz newspaper, Iraqi National Security Adviser Muwaffaq al-Rubaie said that security in the region is inseparable from that of Iraq's.

"Whatever threatens neighboring countries, namely Saudi Arabia, constitutes a direct threat against Iraq," he said in comments carried out by the Kuwaiti official news agency. He said Iraq and Saudi Arabia face the same goal of fighting terrorism, adding that both governments have agreed to establish a "security fence" to prevent cross-border smuggling of arms and drugs and the infiltration of militants, he said.

Rubaie was part of a delegation of senior Iraqi security, defense and diplomatic officials who visited Saudi Arabia last week to seek increased cooperation in dealing with terrorism.

The Los Angeles Times reported Sunday that 45 percent of all foreign militants targeting US troops and Iraqi security forces were from Saudi Arabia, 15 percent from Syria and Lebanon, and 10 percent from North Africa, according to an unidentified senior US military officer and Iraqi lawmakers.

Fighters from Saudi Arabia are thought to have carried out more suicide bombings than those of any other nationality, the paper said.

Rubaie said about 160 Saudi militants have been tried in Iraq for taking part in its insurgency while hundreds of others are in detention.

"There are hundreds of Saudis in Iraq. Many were killed in suicide attacks," he said, claiming that foreign militants infiltrate Iraq "from a neighboring country," in an apparent reference to Syria.

"Many returned home after undergoing training on violence in Iraq, posing a threat to the kingdom's security," he said.

Meanwhile, the head of the National Command Center at the Interior Ministry, Major General Abdel-Karim Khalaf, said Iraqi authorities have recently arrested 2,489 suspected terrorists, mostly from Iran, Egypt and Afghanistan, KUNA reported. He did not specify the period the arrests were made.

He reporters that among those still being questioned, "11 were Jordanians; 64 Syrians; nine Saudis; two Algerians; six Moroccans; six Yemenis; two Libyans; 57 Palestinians; 284 Egyptians; 113 Sudanese, two Emiratis; three Lebanese and one Somali."

He added that the suspects included 461 from Iran and others came from Kenya, Eritrea, Afghanistan, Turkey, Pakistan, India, Britain, France, Holland, Tanzania, Sri Lanka and Nepal.

Meanwhile, 10 people were killed by a car bomb in central Baghdad, Iraqi police said.

Twenty-five people were wounded by the blast which ripped through shops and restaurants near Hussein Square in Baghdad's mainly Shiite Jadriyya district. Two women were among the dead.

In other violence, seven Kurdish guards were killed near the Iranian border in normally calm northern Iraq, in an attack police and a local official blamed on Al-Qaeda-linked militants.

US commanders warn that Iraqi forces are not ready to handle security alone, in part due to tensions between ordinary Iraqis and police, who the United States says have often been infiltrated by Shiite militia.

"There is a certain element of the Iraqi security forces and in particular the Iraqi police ... that have had shortfalls in terms of loyalty ... to the central government," Rear Admiral Mark Fox, the top military spokesman in Iraq, told a news conference.

A wide-ranging British report by the Iraq Commission, released Saturday evening, recommended the withdrawal of British troops from Iraq once Iraqi forces have been trained, regardless of the security situation.

Its central recommendation was for Britain to "preserve and underpin" the territorial integrity of Iraq, promote regional engagement in its reconstruction and prevent Al-Qaeda using it as a base to launch attacks.

It also urged British Premier Gordon Brown to work more with the UN and Iraq's neighbors to support and promote the country's reconstruction and build up its state infrastructure.

Maliki said Saturday that Iraqi security forces were ready to take over from the Americans at "any time," but also stressed they needed more training.

Iraq's top military spokesman, Brigadier General Qassem Atta, said at the news conference with Fox that Maliki's remark was supposed to be a "general" observation. - Agencies

Marine corporal says: "We beat people, sir"

Passed along without comment, other than it's disgusting.

Full story here
Marine: Beating of Iraqis Became Routine

15/07/2007

CAMP PENDLETON, Calif., (AP) - A Marine corporal testifying in a court-martial said Marines in his unit began routinely beating Iraqis after officers ordered them to "crank up the violence level."

Cpl. Saul H. Lopezromo testified Saturday at the murder trial of Cpl. Trent D. Thomas.

"We were told to crank up the violence level," said Lopezromo, testifying for the defense.

When a juror asked for further explanation, Lopezromo said: "We beat people, sir."

Within weeks of allegedly being scolded, seven Marines and a Navy corpsman went out late one night to find and kill a suspected insurgent in the village of Hamandiya near the Abu Ghraib prison. The Marines and corpsman were from 2nd Platoon, Kilo Company, 3rd Battalion, 5th Regiment.

Lopezromo said the suspected insurgent was known to his neighbors as the "prince of jihad," and had been arrested several times and later released by the Iraqi legal system.

Unable to find him, the Marines and corpsman dragged another man from his house, fatally shot him, and then planted an AK-47 assault rifle near the body to make it appear he had been killed in a shootout, according to court testimony.

Four Marines and the corpsman, initially charged with murder in the April 2006 killing, have pleaded guilty to reduced charges and been given jail sentences ranging from 10 months to eight years. Thomas, 25, from St. Louis, pleaded guilty but withdrew his plea and is the first defendant to go to court-martial.

Lopezromo, who was not part of the squad on its late-night mission, said he saw nothing wrong with what Thomas did.

"I don't see it as an execution, sir," he told the judge. "I see it as killing the enemy."

He said Marines consider all Iraqi men part of the insurgency.

Lopezromo and two other Marines were charged in August with assaulting an Iraqi two weeks before the killing that led to charges against Thomas and the others. Charges against all three were later dropped.

Thomas' attorneys have said he suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury from his combat duty in Fallouja in 2004. They have argued that Thomas believed he was following a lawful order to get tougher with suspected insurgents.

Prosecution witnesses testified that Thomas shot the 52-year-old man at point-blank range after he had already been shot by other Marines and was lying on the ground.

Lopezromo said a procedure called "dead-checking" was routine. If Marines entered a house where a man was wounded, instead of checking to see whether he needed medical aid, they shot him to make sure he was dead, he testified.

"If somebody is worth shooting once, they're worth shooting twice," he said.

The jury is composed of three officers and six enlisted personnel, all of whom have served in Iraq. The trial was set to resume Monday.

Saturday, July 14, 2007

Bush stands the truth on its head once again

Bush, in his weekly radio address, shows just how backwards his reasoning is. Political progress will pave the way to progress in security, not the other way around.

full story here

"Our strategy is built on the premise that progress on security will pave the way for political progress," Bush said in his weekly radio address. "This report shows that conditions can change, progress can be made, and the fight in Iraq can be won."

So, then, why are we focusing on one of the smallest sources of instability in Iraq, Al-Qaeda? People in Iraq aren't lying awake worrying about Al-Qaeda. Instead, they are concerned about who will burst into their home and make them the latest of the 650 a month to be tortured and killed. The sectarian forces who carry out these killings are doing so because of the political instability, not because of Al-Qaeda. It's a civil war, not an Al-Qaeda manhunt.
Remember, in the elections that Bush keeps bragging about the Sunni minority boycotted the vote. They felt they wouldn't get a fair shake from a Shia government, so they launched their own death squads. The Shia retaliated. Sure, Al-Qaeda stirred the pot with the Samarra bombing, but this sectarian killing was well underway by then.
In contrast, the report showed a complete political paralysis, with the surge treating one of the symptoms (Al-Qaeda) without showing any progress on the cause.

At a news conference Friday, the outgoing chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen. Peter Pace, said the number of battle-ready Iraqi battalions able to fight independently has dropped from 10 to six in recent months despite an increase in U.S. training efforts. Pace said the readiness of the Iraqi fighting units was not an issue to be "overly concerned" about because the problem was partly attributable to losses in the field.

So the shining glory of the past two years has been to get six battalions "able to fight independently"? And a few of those battalions have already been wiped out? And this is with "increased" training efforts? I guess "progress" is another one of those words that Bush gets to re-define as "whatever the situation looks like".

Bush's base says Hindus are "wicked"

Take a look at the mantra that Rajan Zed offered. It's in boldface below. It's a prayer to the "deity supreme". No Hindu god is mentioned. It's a prayer to a single deity, described as 'he". How could a reasonable person object to this, much less call it "wicked" or "an abomination"?
As for the Senate chamber being "violated", all I can say is that it's not a church, it's a glorified meeting room. As far as anyone knows, Hindus could have been silently making "wicked" prayers there for decades already. The man was invited, so it's not as if Hindus are forcing their religion down people's throats, in contrast to the Christian Right.
This is another example of Bush's 20% base and their "my God can beat up your God" mindset. These people have more in common with the Taliban than with American values.
Why doesn't the Republican Party just come out and admit that they consider all religions except Christianity to be "wicked" and "an abomination"? At least Hindu-Americans would know where they stand.

full story here
video here


Christian activists disrupt Hindu prayer in US Senate
13 Jul 2007, 0312 hrs IST,Chidanand Rajghatta,TNN



/photo.cms?msid=2199403
Hindu priest Rajan Zed was about to offer prayers when he was interrupted by three protesters ( TOI Photo)
WASHINGTON: Christian activists briefly disrupted a Hindu invocation in the U.S Senate on Thursday, marring a historic first for the chamber and showing that fundamentalism is present and shouting in the U.S too.

Invited by the Senate to offer Hindu prayers in place of the usual Christian invocation, Rajan Zed, a Hindu priest from Reno, Nevada, had just stepped up to the podium for the landmark occasion when three protesters, said to belong to the Christian Right anti-abortion group Operation Save America, interrupted him by loudly asking for God's forgiveness for allowing the ''false prayer'' of a Hindu in the Senate chamber.

"Lord Jesus, forgive us father for allowing a prayer of the wicked, which is an abomination in your sight," the first protester shouted. "This is an abomination. We shall have no other gods before You."

Democratic Senator Bob Casey, who was serving as the presiding officer for the morning, immediately asked the sergeant-at-arms to restore order. But they continued to protest as they were headed out the door by the marshals, shouting, "No Lord but Jesus Christ!" and "There's only one true God!"

Zed, sporting a saffron robe, a rudraksh mala round his neck, and a prominent tilak on his forehead, then nervously went through the invocation chosen from the Rig Veda and Bhagavad Gita.

"Let us pray," he began, "We meditate on the transcendental glory of the deity supreme, who is inside the heart of the earth, inside the life of the sky and inside the soul of heaven. May he stimulate and illuminate our minds.

"Lead us from the unreal to real, from darkness to light, and from death to immortality. May we be protected together. May we be nourished together. May we work together with great vigor. May our study be enlightening."


The sentiments were evidently lost on the fundamentalists.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
And did Operation save America distance themselves from his? Hell, no:


The organization Operation Save America later issued a statement confirming that Ante Pavkovic, Kathy Pavkovic, and Kristen Sugar were all arrested in the chambers of the United States Senate "as that chamber was violated by a false Hindu god."

"The Senate was opened with a Hindu prayer placing the false god of Hinduism on a level playing field with the One True God, Jesus Christ," the statement said, adding, "This would never have been allowed by our Founding Fathers."


Operation Save America’s Benham is quoted as saying:
“When you stand up and are arrested, and the Hindu is allowed to go free, this country has gone upside-down…”

Oh, and he also condemns Hinduism for "gross idolatry":

"Our answer is," Benham said, "When one stands up in the face of gross idolatry being allowed in the Senate, in the chamber of the United States Senate, it is incumbent on a Christian to stand up and speak the truth. No matter what, we must obey God rather than men."

There were no idols involved in the recitation of the mantra.

To his credit, Rajan Zev responded courteously to this insult:

“I believe that despite our philosophical differences, we should work together for the common objectives of human improvement, love, and respect for others,” Zed said in an e-mail to Cybercast News Service.

Well, well, that sounds pretty dangerous and "wicked", doesn't it? Yeah, not so much.


Bush misses the point, loses credibility

Judging by the questioning at Bush's recent "benchmark" press conference, nobody in the media believes he has any credibility anymore. Right-wing blogs seize on this as "liberal media bias". Yeah, it's the same "liberal media" that silently and uncritically passed along every distortion from the White House for the past four years. He might as well just bring a parrot that squawks "Al-Qaeda! Al-Qaeda!" as try to run through the same old material.
His obssession with Al-Qaeda has grown tired. He keeps repeating a standard one-note tune that can be summarised as "Al-Qaeda is bad!" Yeah, we all know Al-Qaeda is bad, Mr. Bush. Nobody's arguing with you there. This occupation was supposed to be about getting the Iraqi military up and running, standing on it's own. It also was supposed to be about stabilising the political situation and getting an Iraqi government solid enough to, maybe, have a quorum. The best way to get rid of Al-Qaeda from Iraq is to have an effective Iraqi military and an effective Iraqi government, not a few dozen armed militias and provinces looking out for themselves. Instead, it's become an Al-Qaeda manhunt, while the military and government continue to be as feeble and impotent as ever. To those who do support Al-Qaeda (hint: it's not the American public) this just makes Al-Qaeda look strong.
"Al-Qaeda is bad" simply does not translate into "endless occupation of a failed state at a cost of $2 billion a week" in the minds of the public. "Al-Qaeda is bad" does not correlate with " we accept your continuing smiley pronouncements" or "we believe whatever your ventriloquist dummies say" to the vast majority of the American people.
He also continues to hammer away on his desire to "listen to the commanders on the ground", when everyone knows what happened to Shinseki when he stopped telling the Decider good news. If Petraeus were to come out publicly and say "The Iraqi military and government are hopeless basket cases, and nothing will truly turn around until that changes", then we'd see a new "commander on the ground" in a week. The new guy would be a hand-picked toady ready and eager to parrot exactly what he's told. Bush would then continue to "listen to his commanders on the ground", as they would say exactly what he wants to hear. Petraeus knows what would happen to his men under those circumstances, so he plays the game.
Ironically, when the surge is finally admitted to be a failure, it wil be Petraeus who will take the fall. Be sure to watch for Republicans, Fox News pundits, and right-wing blogs to turn on the man who they so eagerly rely on for every bit of positive spin when this happens.
Even if Petraeus succeeds in expelling Al-Qaeda from Iraq, Iraq will still look more like Somalia for a long time to come. How can any sane person say that would be worth a trillion dollars and 4000 servicemen's lives? The public sees this, and all of Bush's crowing about how bad Al-Qaeda is won't change this. When the Shiite government of Al-Maliki tries to extend it's control over the "success" of Sunni Anbar province, the Sunni gangs that we backed will tear the Iraqi forces to shreds. The White House will simply pull a new scapegoat out of the hat in this case.
For the moment Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and Iran are waiting on the sidelines to intervene in their own interests. What will happen when they decide it's time to make their move? Screeching about Al-Qaeda won't help then. The Republicans and right-wing media, who so loudly profess concern about innocent Iraqis, will simply shrug and let the next President deal with it.
By equating critics of the occupation with supporters of Al-Qaeda, Bush has made a serious error. Polls have shown that the public does not buy his Iraqi Central Front thesis, nor his "fight them there" slogan. Even someone with low intelligence can figure out that nothing is preventing Al-Qaeda from attacking us right now, regardless of how many troops we have in Iraq. Informed people know that Al-Qaeda wasn't even in Iraq until after we invaded. Disillusionment with the occupation is so strong that even war supporters would have a hard time believing that friends, family, co-workers, etc. are actually supporters of Al-Qaeda when they dissent.
The truth is, Bush stopped talking to the American public years ago. His speeches are now exclusively geared to the 20% who will support him no matter what. As this 20% sputters in rage at reporters disrespectful enough to actually question the Decider's credibility, Republicans facing re-election will have to admit, at least to themselves, that this 20% can't save them and are just a millstone around their neck.
Just like the three protesters who denounced Hinduism as "wicked" and "an abomination", this 20% are really just hate-filled bigots who care little for democracy, much less the facts.

Pakistan moves closer to civil war

As Pakistan tries an "Anbar solution" to N. Waziristan, Al-Qaeda and the Taliban get stronger. This dictator "ally" is becoming increasingly marginalised, much like his buddy, Bush. Oddly, a "surge" in the province isn't gaining much in the way of positive results. Musharraf must be reading the same comic book that Bush, Blair, and Ohlmert are.

Jul 14, 2007 11:33 AM
Associated Press

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan – Islamic militants launched a deadly suicide attack, detonated a roadside bomb and fired rockets today as thousands of Pakistani troops deployed to the northwestern frontier to thwart the launch of a holy war, officials said.

At least 24 soldiers were killed in the suicide attack on a military convoy, an army spokesman said. The escalating violence along the rugged Afghanistan border, a haven for local and foreign extremists, follows the government's bloody attack on Islamabad's Red Mosque which sparked calls for revenge from radical groups.

"With help from local tribal elders, we are trying to ensure that militants lay down their arms and stop issuing calls for jihad against the government," a senior military official said on condition of anonymity, because he was not authorized to speak to the media.

Maulana Fazlullah, a radical cleric who has close links to the outlawed Movement for the Enforcement of Islamic Law, has told supporters to prepare for jihad against President Gen. Pervez Musharaff for the assault, the official said.

Pakistan commandos overran the mosque Wednesday, after an eight-day siege with a hard-line cleric and his militant supporters among more than 100 dead.

Fazlullah has pressed for Taliban-style rule in Pakistan – much like the leaders of the Red Mosque.

As the troop movement proceeded in at least five areas of the North West Frontier Province, a suicide bomber struck elsewhere in the border region, his explosives-laden vehicle killing at least 24 soldiers and wounding 29 others in a military convoy, said army spokesman Maj. Gen. Waheed Arshad.

Although no one claimed responsibility for the attack, Arshad said he could not rule out the possibility that it was a reaction to the assault on Islamabad's mosque.

"It could be," he said.

The attack in Waziristan, a Taliban stronghold where Washington says Al Qaeda is regrouping, was one of the most lethal suicide attacks in recent months.

Elsewhere in the northwest, suspected militants detonated a bomb that struck a vehicle carrying soldiers in the town of Bannu, wounding two, said area police official Mohammed Khan.

Two rockets were also fired at a military checkpoint. No casualties were reported.

And in what police called a "foiled terrorist attempt," two 11-pound anti-tank mines attached to a timing device and battery were found in a car in downtown Peshawar, said Abdul Majeed Marwat, police chief of the northwest's largest city.

The car was parked in a crowded area front of military-affiliated Askari Bank when a small explosion and fire in the vehicle alerted authorities. Police speculated the timing device may have been misconnected.

The region along Pakistan's border with Afghanistan has seen increased activity by both local militants, the Taliban, and – according to a recent U.S. assessment – Al Qaeda.

The mosque attack also set off peaceful protests across Pakistan Friday but they were smaller than anticipated.

In the northwest, an army brigade was heading up the Swat Valley, 75 miles northeast of Peshawar, where a suicide car bomber killed three policeman at a checkpoint Thursday, said Mohammed Javed, the valley's top administrator.

With today's suicide attack in North Waziristan, at least 53 people have been killed in bombings and shootings in the north since the Red Mosque crisis began July 3.

No new troops were sent to North Waziristan, but a spokesman for militants demanded that all existing checkpoints be removed there by Sunday.

Abdullah Farhad, who claims to speak for pro-Taliban militants, told The Associated Press the checkpoints violated a 2006 peace accord between the government and tribal elders.

The peace deal is still in effect, but militants have again started attacking government forces in the region. The government has targeted some militant hideouts.



Bush threatens veto of VA budget increases

Folks, whenever you see those right-wing blogs with the flags and eagles, brimming with enthusiastic support for the troops, just remember this story. Bush is now threatening to veto an increase in veteran's benefits. The occupation that's costing the U.S. $2 billion a week is okay with Bush, but spending a maximum of $3.8 billion to "end red tape" and "increase disability pay" is just plain wasteful to the Decider.
The pathetic Republican practise of hiding behind the troops to sustain support for the occupation has been obvious for a long time now. If we criticise the "success" of the surge, then the troops will get "mixed signals" and get discouraged, or so we are told. Just as Bush constantly tries to associate any criticism of the surge as support for Al-Qaeda, likewise the right-wing constantly tries to portray those skeptical of reaching ever-lowering goals as somehow being "against the troops".
The irony is that we got into this mess, at least partially, because the Republicans wanted to fight a war "on the cheap". Now they balk at nothing when it comes to spending ever-increasing sums of money with practically no oversight on an occupation in which the goalposts seem to be moving away from us at a rapid rate. But they draw the line when it comes to spending money on injured soldiers.

full story here

White House Against Boosting VA Budget

Moves in Congress to give the Department of Veterans Affairs as much as $3.8 billion more than the Bush administration proposed has drawn an indirect veto threat from the White House.

"If Congress increases VA funding above the president's request and does not offset this increase with spending reductions in other bills, the president will veto any of the other bills that exceed his request until Congress demonstrates a path to reach the president's top line of $933 billion," the Office of Management and Budget said in a statement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Responding to shabby outpatient treatment of wounded soldiers at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, in Washington, D.C., a group of U.S. senators moved June 13 to boost disability pay to those hurt in combat and improve care for brain injury. The measure would also expand medical care and counseling to family members and require better cooperation to end red tape for disabled service members moving from Pentagon care to that provided by the VA.

The measure would boost military severance pay for those rated with less than 30 percent disability and eliminate the current requirement that severance pay be deducted from disability pay. It would also set up Pentagon pilot programs that would give the VA a greater role in the evaluation system, a major shift in how benefits are administered.

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

Nobody knows for sure

The Administration, Petraeus, and virtually all war supporters keep on saying that the surge has only just started. This isn't exactly true. 3/4 of the troops were in place in June. It has been a phased deployment over the past 4 and a half months. During that time, there has not been a significant improvement, despite mouthings from the Administration's ventriloquist dummies about 'signs of progress'. The situation in Diyala has worsened, and the improvement in Anbar is not due to the surge, but rather to pitting one armed gang against another. Attacks on the Green Zone continue. The Iraqi military has not "stood up", sectarian deaths have increased, and Al-Qaeda is merely moving to wherever the surge isn't taking place. We call that being "on the run".
Still, we are told that it's far too early to pass judgment on the surge. Well, if we grant that, then why has the Administration seen fit to attribute any ephemeral signs of success over the past four months to the surge? Isn't it far too early to say that any 'signs of progress' are due to the surge?

In other words, it's too early to say the surge is a failure, but apparently it's been okay to say the surge is a success for the past few months, even though the troops have 'just arrived'.

Unwarranted optimism is thus okay, but sober skepticism is dangerous. "Nobody knows for sure if the surge will succeed or not", however we seem to "know for sure" there will be a bloodbath if we leave before we achieve "victory". We also "know for sure" that Al-Qaeda will "follow us home", too. How does that work? Isn't it "defeatist" to assume the worst possible outcome? Not if you support the President, but it is if you don't support the President. See how that works now?

Unwarranted optimism in military endeavours can be disatrous. Why didn't we optimistically send our entire fleet right into Japan and launch an amphibious assault immediately after Pearl Harbor? Nobody "knew for sure" that would fail, did they? The threat was certainly real to America, and failure in Japan would mean arguably worse consequnces for us. So why not employ wishful thinking and optimism in an immediate massive invasion? Because we would have been wiped out. But "nobody knows that for sure", do they? Would those opposing such a plan for an immediate invasion have been called "defeatists" and "surrenderists" who didn't want to "win"?
This entire war and occupation have been fought by only considering the best possible outcome and proceeding as if it were a forgone conclusion.

No, "nobody knows for sure" that the surge will fail. We do know that we tried a surge almost a year ago, though, and that didn't help. We do know that the surge has not had a dramatic effect over the past few months. Now, the addition of a few thousand more troops will somehow magically turn the tide, I guess.
Remember, the idea of the surge was to allow the Iraqi military to gain control by reinforcing them as the Iraqis launched a major operation to restore stability. The trouble is that Iraqi military forces are a no-show. The most important element of the surge, therefore, completely failed and has been failing for some time. Nobody knows for sure if the Iraqi military will "stand up" by next spring, either. Nobody knows for sure how shuffling Al-Qaeda from one province to another will defeat them, either. Nobody knows for sure if al-Maliki will be able to survive a no-confidence vote. Nobody knows for sure how many Iraqis have been killed in the violence. Nobody knows, but somehow it's okay to proceed as if everything will go our way and somehow it's bad to stop and ponder the minefield straight ahead of us.

One thing we can all be sure of, however, is that in September Petraeus will say that there has been 'some improvement' and that we need more time. We can be sure that Bush will give it to him. We can be sure that the sectarian militias will still be there. And we can be sure that neocons will be trotting out the same tired old arguments that they picked up from Fox News.

Back in January, Bush "believed" that al-Maliki would have control of all the provinces by November. Now Petraeus is talking about the spring of '08 as the time when we will have a "clearer picture" as to whether this will happen. Not that it will have happened, mind you, just a better idea how much more time it will take. Does this sound like a credible track record? A year ago Bush was all thumbs-up and optimistic, but things didn't work out like he thought they would. But now something has changed, this time his brilliant scheme really will work....because, in his own words, "it has to". That's so reassuring.

Crossing your fingers and hoping everything will come out okay is not leadership, and neither is it courageous.
From the Daily Telegraph

Monday, July 09, 2007

The Decider, in his own words, on the surge

Let's look at back in time seven months ago when Bush laid out the "surge" as the plan that would bring stability to Iraq. It bears re-examination, since the right-wing seems to exist in a vacuum without history and lap up each new utterance by the Decider with no consideration of what he said before. Remarks in parens are a summary of the Decider's eloquence, for brevity's sake.

The text of Bush's Jan. 10 speech in which he proposed the surge

- (Iraqis voted. Hooray. Yes, he's still hammering away on that tune. Everyone knows that elections always produce pro-U.S. governments, too. I mean, by voting they virtually agreed to be tortured, imprisoned without trial, massacred, and swindled out their oil. It's the least we can do. But I'm wondering when they voted to host an end-times battle against Good and Evil in their country. Was that on the ballot?)
- (Al-Qaeda's bad. Bad, I tell you.)
- ("Failure" in Iraq means that Al-Qaeda and Iran "win" and that would make us less safe.)

"Our past efforts to secure Baghdad failed for two principal reasons: There were not enough Iraqi and American troops to secure neighborhoods that had been cleared of terrorists and insurgents. And there were too many restrictions on the troops we did have. Our military commanders reviewed the new Iraqi plan to ensure that it addressed these mistakes. They report that it does. They also report that this plan can work."

- Hey, Iraq is more than just Baghdad, Mr. Bush. And is this remark what makes the surge Petraeus' plan?

"Now let me explain the main elements of this effort: The Iraqi government will appoint a military commander and two deputy commanders for their capital. The Iraqi government will deploy Iraqi Army and National Police brigades across Baghdad's nine districts. When these forces are fully deployed, there will be 18 Iraqi Army and National Police brigades committed to this effort, along with local police. These Iraqi forces will operate from local police stations — conducting patrols and setting up checkpoints, and going door-to-door to gain the trust of Baghdad residents."

- Again, in Baghdad. It sure is sounding like the Iraqis are going to be doing most of the work so far in the speech, doesn't it? We're just going to back them up as they clear out the bad guys, it sounds like. Currently the Sunnis don't seem to trust those Shia police, though. And those Iraqi Army and National Police turned out to be a great place to train and arm the very insurgents we are supposed to be fighting. And they seem to have a penchant for torture as well.

"Many listening tonight will ask why this effort will succeed when previous operations to secure Baghdad did not. Well, here are the differences: In earlier operations, Iraqi and American forces cleared many neighborhoods of terrorists and insurgents, but when our forces moved on to other targets, the killers returned. This time, we'll have the force levels we need to hold the areas that have been cleared. In earlier operations, political and sectarian interference prevented Iraqi and American forces from going into neighborhoods that are home to those fueling the sectarian violence. This time, Iraqi and American forces will have a green light to enter those neighborhoods — and Prime Minister Maliki has pledged that political or sectarian interference will not be tolerated."

- Well, we aren't holding the areas that have been cleared. Our commanders have admitted this. The ability no enter certain neighbourhoods of one city has not turned out to be the dramatic breakthrough that Bush thought it would be. Again, it's turned out that The Iraqi forces were compromised from the beginning by harbouring sectarian militias and warning the "bad guys" ahead of time about raids.

I've made it clear to the Prime Minister and Iraq's other leaders that America's commitment is not open-ended. If the Iraqi government does not follow through on its promises, it will lose the support of the American people

— and it will lose the support of the Iraqi people. Now is the time to act. The Prime Minister understands this. Here is what he told his people just last week: "The Baghdad security plan will not provide a safe haven for any outlaws, regardless of [their] sectarian or political affiliation."

- The support of the American public is already gone. Al-Maliki is facing a no-confidence he may not survive. And the consequences of these developments are...nothing. Just more "stay the course" talk for American public, too. 40% now want the troops to leave immediately.

"A successful strategy for Iraq goes beyond military operations. Ordinary Iraqi citizens must see that military operations are accompanied by visible improvements in their neighborhoods and communities. So America will hold the Iraqi government to the benchmarks it has announced."

- Yes, he really did say that.

"To establish its authority, the Iraqi government plans to take responsibility for security in all of Iraq's provinces by November. To give every Iraqi citizen a stake in the country's economy, Iraq will pass legislation to share oil revenues among all Iraqis. To show that it is committed to delivering a better life, the Iraqi government will spend $10 billion of its own money on reconstruction and infrastructure projects that will create new jobs. To empower local leaders, Iraqis plan to hold provincial elections later this year. And to allow more Iraqis to re-enter their nation's political life, the government will reform de-Baathification laws, and establish a fair process for considering amendments to Iraq's constitution."

- Hey, how are all those things working out, Decider dude? Al-Maliki's incompetent and impotent government is going to have control of all of the provinces by November? Or maybe one?

"Our military forces in Anbar are killing and capturing al Qaeda leaders, and they are protecting the local population. Recently, local tribal leaders have begun to show their willingness to take on al Qaeda. And as a result, our commanders believe we have an opportunity to deal a serious blow to the terrorists. So I have given orders to increase American forces in Anbar Province by 4,000 troops. These troops will work with Iraqi and tribal forces to keep up the pressure on the terrorists. America's men and women in uniform took away al Qaeda's safe haven in Afghanistan — and we will not allow them to re-establish it in Iraq."

- Okay, so now we hear something about some place other than Baghdad, and it turns out to be a province with 1% of the country's population. It turns out that we employed one sectarian gang to wipe out another gang, and the Iraqi police and military, as well as that wonderful government, are a decided non-factor in all of this.
- (Al-Qaeda's bad, and I mean bad. Really bad.)

"From Afghanistan to Lebanon to the Palestinian Territories, millions of ordinary people are sick of the violence, and want a future of peace and opportunity for their children. And they are looking at Iraq. They want to know: Will America withdraw and yield the future of that country to the extremists, or will we stand with the Iraqis who have made the choice for freedom?"

- They made the choice for freedom, right? What was the other option they were offered, again? Those people looking at Iraq as an example of "peace and opportunity" must be pretty impressed seven months on. It seems like the question they are asking is more like "When will America withdraw? Ever?"

"The changes I have outlined tonight are aimed at ensuring the survival of a young democracy that is fighting for its life in a part of the world of enormous importance to American security. Let me be clear: The terrorists and insurgents in Iraq are without conscience, and they will make the year ahead bloody and violent. Even if our new strategy works exactly as planned, deadly acts of violence will continue — and we must expect more Iraqi and American casualties. The question is whether our new strategy will bring us closer to success. I believe that it will."

- Actually, as it turns out, the question is how Mr. Bush will define the word "success". Notice the use of the term "terrorists and insurgents". We seem to have forgotten about the "insurgents" lately. And it may seem like the surge is not working, but that is just the proof that is really is working, see?

"Acting on the good advice of Senator Joe Lieberman and other key members of Congress, we will form a new, bipartisan working group that will help us come together across party lines to win the war on terror. This group will meet regularly with me and my administration; it will help strengthen our relationship with Congress. We can begin by working together to increase the size of the active Army and Marine Corps, so that America has the Armed Forces we need for the 21st century."

- Has any of this actually happened? "Working across party lines"? "Strengthen our relationship with Congress?" Wow. Which Congress would that be, Mr. President? Bush has repeatedly rejected the ISG as "handcuffing" him, even though at the time he announces the surge he said he would work with them. He isn't even meeting the benchmarks he set for himself.

"In these dangerous times, the United States is blessed to have extraordinary and selfless men and women willing to step forward and defend us. These young Americans understand that our cause in Iraq is noble and necessary — and that the advance of freedom is the calling of our time. They serve far from their families, who make the quiet sacrifices of lonely holidays and empty chairs at the dinner table. They have watched their comrades give their lives to ensure our liberty. We mourn the loss of every fallen American — and we owe it to them to build a future worthy of their sacrifice."

- In other words, stop-loss, 18 month tours, recalling the IRR for new tours for those that have already served, coercing those serving into re-enlistment, and Walter Reed Medical Center for those who can't go on. A VA woefully unable to handle an epidenic of brain injuries, and commanders that pressure the mentally ill troops to keep their damn mouths shut. We owe them that? Really?

More signs of progress in Iraq

Right in Baghdad, the focus of the surge: a car bomb, an attack on police, and another 26 sectarian killings.
"Attacks on U.S. supply convoys rise"? But how? Isn't Al-Qaeda on the run? 12 workers killed in Baghdad? Could there possibly be other groups in Iraq destabilising the situation other than Al-Qaeda? Wouldn't the Decider have mentioned this? If this were true, I'm sure the right-wing blogs would have discussed it, because they are very scrupulous about honesty and the truth. Okay, you got me; they don't care about either one at all.
Right-wing bloggers love cites, apparently, so here ya go:

Story from Xinhua


Four people killed in Iraqi violence, 26 corpses found

Attacks on U.S. supply convoys in Iraq rise: report
Iraqi FM warns of civil war if U.S. troops leave
Nine Iraqi soldiers killed in bomb attack
Another car bomb kills civilian in Baghdad
Gunmen execute 12 workers in village of southern Baghdad


Four people were killed and three others injured in two separate attacks in Baghdad on Monday, while the Iraqi police picked up 26 corpses from the streets of the Iraqi capital, an Interior Ministry source said.

A car bomb, parking in the Kendi Street where dozens of private clinics and shops located in Baghdad's western neighborhood of Harthiyah, went off near a passing police patrol in the afternoon, killing a civilian and wounding three others, the source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

Separately, gunmen opened fire on a police patrol in Baghdad's northern neighborhood of Sliekh, killing three policemen, the source said.

In addition, the source said that the police patrol collected 26 unidentified bodies in execution-style in Baghdad's neighborhoods during the past 24 hours.

Most of the bodies were handcuffed, blindfolded and showing signs of torture with bullet holes riddled in the chest and the head, he said.

Insurgency, sectarian violence and daily gruesome finding of unidentified corpses continued in the capital despite the U.S. and Iraqi security staged a security plan in the capital since Feb. 14 with an aim of putting rampant violence under control.

Source: Xinhua