Saturday, September 15, 2007

Cheer for progress if you want the troops home

Let's look at what Bush is expecting the American people to believe.
After four years of "turning the corner" and "the next six months will be crucial" statements, the surge was announced as the way to crush the sectarian militias and expel Al-Qaeda from Iraq, as well as stabilise the Iraqi government so that it would become "a strong ally in the War On Terror".

None of that happened. Instead, we divided the sectarian militias into 'good' and "bad' terrorists, moved Al-Qaeda to areas where they hadn't had a presence before, and watched the Iraqi government slide into impotence and irrelevance while they supported their own terrorist militias and let the Iraqi army and police flounder.

Now with this dubious 'success' under its belt, the surge can end. We can apparently build on this 'progress' and return to the policies that made the surge necessary in the first place. We're no longer looking for "victory", but merely "success", and success is a word that has a very malleable definition. Success is now something that can be spun out of whole cloth with suspect statistics. Questioning those statistics is treason.

On top of that, Gates now says that if 'progress' allows, we could see 30,000 more troops come home.
The subtext is simple: if you want to see the troops come home, then you had better start talking up the "success" in Iraq.
In yet another slimy, manipulative, and cynical move doomed to failure, Bush is now trying to enlist Democrats (and the nation as a whole) in a massive cheerleading effort. Like some perverse Peter Pan, if only we clap for "progress" loud enough, the troops will come home. We will still be engaged in a seemingly endless occupation of a failed state with 100,000 troops, but we will gain the return of 30,000 troops. And Bush will leave office vindicated, of course, regardless of what the conditions really are in Iraq. That will be his successor's problem.

The most obvious problem with this approach is that Bush has no credibility whatsoever with the American people beyond his base. His base will believe anything he says, no matter how fantastic it is. The public at large simply does not believe Bush would keep to his word.

The second problem is that this is not what those who marginally support the war really want. They want 'victory', and they want it soon. They don't want us there for another ten years or more, which is what Petraeus is estimating it will take to bring stability to Iraq.

The third problem with this domestic strategy is that the Republicans have tied themselves irrevocably to Iraq, and the Democrats are not going to let them slip out from under it with a wink and a nod about false 'progress'.

The fourth problem is that, far from pulling away from military involvement in the Middle east, Bush is now planning new attacks against Iran and Syria. The troops that are "withdrawn" from Iraq will merely go to Bush's new wars, and he will wring his hands that he was forced not be able to keep up his end of the bargain. If only the world would align itself with Bush's fantasies, we would have peace. Instead, we must move forward with new wars, with fewer allies, to make the Decider look like a visionary. Your patriotism is appreciated as we move through these difficult times.

The fifth problem is that Bush's Iraqi strategy of dividing terrorists into "good' and "bad" categories was a short-term one to create the illusion of progress for the September report. The 'good' terrorists are only with us as long as it serves their interests, which is to use our troops to wipe out the rival 'gangs'. Strengthening the militias only makes the Iraqi army's task more difficult in the long-term. Either the Iraqi military will have to contest the 'good' terrorists for control, or the Iraqi military will become infiltrated by the 'good' terrorists and merely serve their interests. Neither case will bring stability, no matter how much Americans cheer at home.

The bottom line is that Iraq's Shia majority will naturally align itself with Iran, and unless we topple the Iranian regime with another invasion and long occupation, Iraq will never be a strong ally in the War On Terror. Iraq, the American people, nor the world at large has the stomach for Bush's vision. And while the U.S. is tied up in the Middle East and Afghanistan, it will be unable to respond to new challenges that arise. Bush is promising nothing more than endless war that will bankrupt us and destroy our military, and subvert our democracy here at home.

The "way forward" is paved with lies and new wars, and obscene profits for military contractors. I'm not cheering for that.


Defying calls for a dramatic change of course, president says he's building long-term ties
Sep 14, 2007 04:30 AM
Tim Harper
WASHINGTON BUREAU

WASHINGTON–George W. Bush told Americans last night he is building an "enduring relationship'' with Iraq, one that may mean fewer U.S. troops in that country, but one that will extend well beyond his presidency.

The message from the U.S. president that the American troop presence, as he envisions it, will last for years to come was a major change in tone and led to suggestions here last night that he was looking at the Korean model, where Americans have been for half a century.

The last time Bush went on national television last winter, to announce his so-called "troop surge'' he said he had made it clear to Iraqi leaders that "America's commitment is not open-ended.''

But that is precisely what Bush seemed to say last night.


In a prime time address to the country – Bush's eighth direct television appeal on Iraq – the president said he would order a withdrawal of American troops beginning with 2,200 Marines already scheduled to leave Iraq this month.

The numbers would rise to 5,500 by Christmas and more than 20,000 could be home by next summer, but that would still leave more than 130,000 Americans in the country during the stretch run of the 2008 presidential campaign.

That has not only galvanized Democratic opposition to what they are now calling an "open-ended'' Bush war, but it is also causing much nervousness among Republicans facing re-election with an unpopular war still taking American lives at the rate of about 60 per month.

Never before has Bush faced such a skeptical public and the troop reduction he trumpeted last night would bring the country back only to the troop level of last November, when voters handed control of Congress to Democrats because of unhappiness with a war that showed no sign of progress.

Critics pointed out that Bush, acting on the recommendations of his top military commander in Iraq, Gen. David Petraeus, was merely returning troops from a military "surge'' he ordered last January in a last-ditch effort to secure Iraq.

Bush said Iraqi leaders support a drawdown of troops but have made it clear they want an American presence in Iraq well beyond the end of his term in January 2009.

"These Iraqi leaders have asked for an enduring relationship with America,'' Bush said. "And we are ready to begin building that relationship – in a way that protects our interests in the region and requires many fewer American troops.''

Rhode Island's Jack Reed delivered the Democratic rebuttal, saying Bush had provided for the "indefinite'' mission of 130,000 Americans, but did not provide "either a plan to successfully end the war or a convincing rationale to continue it.

"Thousands of brave Americans remain in the crosshairs of another country's civil war,'' Reed said.

He called on Republicans to work with Democrats to bring troops home. "An endless and unlimited military presence in Iraq is not an option," he added.

The war, in its fifth year, has so far killed 3,777 Americans, wounded more than 27,000 and killed tens of thousands of Iraqis.

Although Bush, like Petraeus, touted success in Iraq's Anbar province, one of the Sunni leaders who had worked closely with U.S. forces there, Abdul-Sattar Abu Reesha, was killed yesterday, 10 days after he met Bush during the president's visit to Anbar.

Before the speech, a senior administration official told reporters Bush wanted to get Iraq to "a good place'' for the next president.

But the official said a long-term relationship does not mean strictly military boots on the ground. "We have interests in this region that go beyond Iraq proper. It doesn't mean 169,000 troops.''

Bush said he believed the way forward he was describing made it possible "for the first time in years'' for people on the opposite side of the war to come together.

There was little sign of that and his speech only hardened Democratic views and provided fodder for those seeking that party's presidential nomination.

"The American people long ago lost faith in the president's leadership of the war in Iraq because his rhetoric has never matched the reality on the ground,'' House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said.

"The choice is between a Democratic plan for responsible redeployment and the president's plan for a 10-year war in Iraq."

Democratic presidential hopefuls pounced on the Bush speech as too little, too late.

"What the president told the American people (last night) is that one year from now, there will be the same number of troops in Iraq as there were one year ago,'' said New York Sen. Hillary Clinton. "That is ... unacceptable to this Congress and the American people who have made clear their strong desire to bring our brave troops home."

Illinois Sen. Barack Obama said Bush continues to hurt America's standing in the world by refusing to change course in Iraq.

"Iraq's leaders are not making the political progress that was the stated purpose of the surge, but the president wants us to keep giving him a blank check,'' Obama said.

Barbara Lee, an anti-war Democrat from California, said the speech was an exit strategy for Bush at the expense of American troops.

"It's the president's plan to run out the clock on his failed policy, to move the goal posts once again, so that he can sneak out the back door and leave the American people holding the bag,'' she said.

The battle over the future of the war will begin anew here next week, when Democrats in the Senate are expected to again try to muster enough votes to pass a bill that would lengthen the time between troop deployments.

U.S. votes against Declaration of Indigenous Rights

Is this how we support human rights? Shouldn't the U.S. be taking the lead rather than being an obstacle?

LATIN AMERICA: Native Leaders Half-Heartedly Embrace Historic Declaration
By Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Sep 14 (IPS) - While governments and the representatives of international agencies celebrated the approval of the Universal Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples after more than two decades of negotiations, some native leaders and experts in Latin America were less enthusiastic.

In their criticism of the document, indigenous leaders Manuel Castro of Ecuador and Luis Andrade of Colombia, as well as the former director of the Inter-American Indigenous Institute, Jos del Val, pointed out to IPS that it is non-binding, and that parts of it were negotiated with little participation by the representatives of its presumptive beneficiaries.

A slightly different stance was taken by the spokesman for the Rigoberto Mench Foundation, Elmer Erazo, who said the Declaration could be considered a stride forward "to the extent that indigenous people make use of it."

But, he told IPS, "it's nothing to jump up and down about."

The Declaration was adopted Thursday by majority vote in the United Nations General Assembly. Only four countries -- the United States, Canada, Australia and New Zealand -- voted against it, while Azerbaijan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Burundi, Colombia, Georgia, Kenya, Nigeria, Russia, Samoa and Ukraine abstained.

The 12-page Declaration states that indigenous peoples have the right "to autonomy or self-government in matters relating to their internal and local affairs".

It also says native peoples have the right to maintain their cultures and to not be displaced from their land, and urges states to indemnify them when their land or resources are used or damaged without their consent.

Bolivian President Evo Morales, who is himself an Aymara Indian, said he was pleased with the approval of the Declaration, and added that "These standards will help ensure that everyone has the same rights and that we will stop being marginalised."

Morales called on his indigenous sisters and brothers to take part in a world summit on Oct. 10-11 to celebrate and analyse the implications and repercussions of the Declaration.

Others, however, see less reason to celebrate.

"Twenty years of debate to produce this document, and we end up with a non-binding declaration that does not force governments to do anything; this is a disgrace," said Castro, spokesman for the influential Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador (CONAIE).

For his part, Andrade, president of the National Indigenous Organisation of Colombia (ONIC), said the new instrument "is like saying yes, but no," since it is non-binding. In his view, many governments signed the document "just for the sake of image."

With respect to the fact that Colombia abstained from voting -- the only Latin American country to do so -- Andrade said "it showed that the administration (of right-wing President lvaro Uribe) threatens the right of indigenous people and is their enemy."

Del Val, the former director of the Inter-American Indigenous Institute, said the Declaration should be taken "as an ethical and moral reference point for indigenous peoples, but nothing more than that."

"It is a non-binding, very general declaration full of vague terms and tricky wording," said del Val, who is the head of the Mexico Multicultural Nation University Programme (PUMC) at the Autonomous National University of Mexico.

"Many governments signed it as a formality, just to get it out of the way," he said.

Erazo, of the Mench Foundation, which is headed by Guatemalan indigenous leader and Nobel Peace laureate Rigoberta Mench , agrees that the Declaration has no teeth.

He recommended, however, seeing it "as a weapon to be used by the people."

According to signatory governments and U.N. authorities, including Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, the Declaration is a triumph for the world s 270 million aboriginal people. "This marks a historic moment when member states and indigenous peoples reconciled with their painful histories," said Ban.

But CONAIE s Castro saw such reactions as overblown. "In our view, there is no significant gain, if we also take into account that we were not well-represented in the negotiations and that very few indigenous people are even aware of the existence of this document."

"There are a number of laws and agreements that talk about our rights; this is just one more that is on its way to becoming dead letter," he said.

Native leaders from the region, some of whom were not widely accepted or considered highly representative, took part in the negotiations at different points.

"We participated in some debates, but we have to say truthfully that the level of representation of most indigenous peoples was extremely low," said Andrade.

According to government statistics, there are 38.5 million indigenous people in the Americas. However, that figure is seen by many experts as too low.

What there is no discrepancy over is the fact that indigenous people are the most vulnerable social group in the region, suffering the highest levels of poverty, and the most limited access to health care, education, decent housing and an adequate diet.

But in recent years, some indigenous groups in Latin America have become more organised and gained influence and political power, especially in countries like Ecuador and Bolivia.

Indigenous movements played a key role, for example, in toppling presidents Jamil Mahuad, in January 2000 in Ecuador, and Gonzalo Sanchez de Lozada, in October 2003 in Bolivia. In addition, Bolivia now has its first-ever indigenous president, who took office in early 2006. (END/2007)

Half of British troops to leave Iraq

Now that British troops have moved to an air base on the outskirts of Basra, they are set to move half of their forces to Kuwait by the end of the year. This will leave South Korea, with its 3500 troops who never leave their base, as the second-largest "ally" in Iraq. Seven other countries have less than 100 troops in Iraq and these provide no counter-insurgency role. It's rapidly becoming an American-only effort, with the rest of the world wanting nothing to do with it. Those that do stay have an agenda that has little to do with Iraq. Georgia, for example, with its 300 troops in Iraq, wants to stay on Bush's good side so that the U.S. will protect it from Russian hegemony. For the sake of 300 troops in this disaster, we are setting ourselves up for involvement in yet another conflict with Russia. The same goes for the seven or so Eastern European nations with troops in Iraq; they want our support against Russia, so they send their token forces. Latvia has two troops in Iraq, for example.

Bush is desperately trying to push the UN into Iraq, but the rest of the world doesn't seem to be taking the bait. Bush said we would "go it alone" in Iraq, if necessary. The world is apparently taking him at word.

So not only is the occupation of Iraq setting up wars against Iran and Syria, it is setting us up for long-term military confrontations with Turkey and Russia. This is at the same time as we defend Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. Then there is Venezuela, where the apparent plan seems to be to back the Zulia governor in a secessionist movement. Zulia province has oil, so we are, of course, deeply concerned about it. Since Venezuela is a democracy where its leader, Chavez, is repeatedly re-elected by higher percentages than Bush got, we can't really sell the "liberation" angle there. And Al-Qaeda is certainly not involved in the Chazez government. Any action in Venezuela will require a massive distortion of the truth, but the Bush Administration seems quite willing and able to step up to the plate in that regard. We've spent a lot of money propping up the death-squad government in Colombia, so a proxy war will most likely be in order. We simply don't have the troops for much else, but we can easily make life so miserable for Venezuelans so that they overthrow Chavez, such as we did in Nicaragua. See, that's what makes us the "good guys", so we deserve that Venezuelan oil.

Oh, and there's still the little matter of Afghanistan, where Bush is trying to push the mess off on to NATO. That's how Canada got sucked into Bush's rose-coloured world. The bungles by the Bush Administration, due to its habit of over-optimistically assessing every situation, have basically set us back to the starting point in Afghanistan. Both Canada and Britain are paying a bloody price for a pat on the back from the Decider, while Bush offers little more than "in for a penny, in for a pound" to his allies. It's not that the mission in Afghanistan is not worthwhile, but rather that Bush has completely and horribly messed it up and is abusing our allies in the process. How are we safer with fewer allies, and with the ones that we have left battered and bloodied? Does the world really need a superpower that simultaneously is unrealistically optimistic and that sees only military solutions to every problem? Does it need one that views its allies as expendable pawns to be bankrupted and bled white for domestic political cover? I don't think so.


Basra troops 'will move to Kuwait'


By Thomas Harding in Basra
Last Updated: 3:34am BST 15/09/2007

British troop numbers in Iraq are expected to be halved by December, with about 2,500 soldiers moving to Kuwait, The Daily Telegraph has learnt.


A team of officers from Permanent Joint Headquarters in Northwood has spent the past week in Basra reviewing the number of soldiers needed following the withdrawal of the last battalion from Basra Palace a fortnight ago.

It is expected that they will recommend approximately halving the force of more than 5,000 now based at Basra air station after full control of the province is passed to the Iraqis, probably in November.

The troops leaving Iraq would operate from a new base in neighbouring Kuwait, from which they would escort convoys and train Iraqi forces.

Military chiefs are negotiating with the Kuwaitis and a new barracks, called the Kuwait Support Base, should be operational by the end of the year.

However, the reduction of British troop numbers in Iraq, that will begin with 250 men from the King's Royal Hussars leaving at the end of this month, is expected to cause political problems, with America worried that a key area of Iraq is being abandoned.

The PJHQ group is expected to report before Gordon Brown meets Gen David Petraeus, the US commander in Iraq, and Ryan Crocker, the US ambassador to Baghdad, in London next week.

The Prime Minister is expected to thrash out the details of reducing the troop numbers and finding a compromise that will be acceptable to the allies. He will then make a statement to Parliament on the future of Iraq in early October.

Speaking after President George W Bush announced that more than 5,000 US troops would be withdrawn from Iraq by Christmas, Mr Brown said that decisions on the future size and strength of British forces would depend on "conditions on the ground".

"Like America, Britain will discharge our duties to the Iraqi people, to our allies and to the international community," he said.

"And as President Bush did last night, I repeat that we will meet our responsibilities and honour our obligations."

Mr Brown's spokesman said: "We have to make our decisions based on our assessment of military conditions in the south. The Americans clearly made their decisions based on their assessment of conditions elsewhere in Iraq."

With its huge oil wealth, proximity to Iran and straddling a major supply route, Basra province is a key player for the future of Iraq. Because of this, US troops are likely to be deployed there if it is felt the British force too weak.


Let's look at the other "allies". From the Daily Telegraph:

He [Bush] addressed the "international community" as well as the American people, and thanked "the 36 nations who have troops on the ground in Iraq", which surprised me somewhat because there are now only 21 nations left on the ground in Iraq, from Albania to the UK, by way of Kazakhstan, El Salvador and the Czech Republic. Apart from the Americans, only two nations have more than 1,000 troops in Iraq (South Korea and us) and seven have fewer than 100 troops who don't do any war-fighting or counter-insurgency.

South Korea never did do any war-fighting. In 2004, a brigade's worth of South Koreans was sent to Kurdistan on a "humanitarian mission": their government insisted, John Reid-style, that they were hoping to perform said mission without a shot being fired. I don't think they have fired a shot yet.

Their mission consisted of major construction works: they built a large defensive base to house their 3,500 men and only ever left it for short, pre-planned hearts and minds jobs in Erbil schools. When the Koreans do leave, there will be a nice, modern, well-built, forward operating base for American troops to continue Operation Enduring Relationship with the Iraqi People.
----

Since Prime Minister Maliki's government cannot even trust its own security forces to guard the Green Zone (now officially called the IZ or International Zone) that contains his own parliament building, he will be relieved that only 4,700 are leaving.

Security inside the zone is controlled by Kurdish peshmergas, who are reckoned to be aloof from the Shia-Sunni sectarian nightmare.

Security at the entry checkpoints is controlled by a private security company, Triple Canopy, that mans them with Peruvian peasants who speak neither Arabic nor English. Very international.



Friday, September 14, 2007

Iraq 'progress' kills 10 more police

Well, Bush said "the way forward" would be difficult, but he pretty much meant it would be difficult for everyone else. While the surge was supposed to quell violence in Baghdad, it has not only failed miserably in that regard, but has also 'succeeded' in exporting violence to the areas around Baghdad. Truck bombers blowing up a cop hangout is not a sign of "normalcy", though Bush claims normalcy is returning to Iraq.


Truck bomb kills seven police north of Baghdad

14/09/2007

BAGHDAD, (Reuters) - A suicide bomber rammed a truck laden with explosives into two police cars near the northern Iraqi town of Baiji on Friday, killing at least seven policemen, a police source said.

An official at a joint police and army coordination centre put the death toll at 10, and said he believed it could rise further because identification cards had been found at the scene which did not belong to bodies so far recovered.

The police cars were parked outside a restauraunt, 3 km (two miles) south of Baiji, the official said. He said eight civilians were wounded in the attack.

The bombing took place a day after U.S. President George W. Bush approved a limited U.S. troop withdrawal from Iraq, but said the U.S. military role will stretch beyond his presidency.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Bush gets no traction from September report

Like the surge, Republicans expected big things from the September report. Democrats were supposed to be despairing at all of the 'progress' and resigning themselves to electoral failure.

Combined with a poll taken before the report, showing a majority had dismmised the report as a sham before it was even given, the new poll shows that the same people who supported the surge in January support it now.

Giving the lie to Republican fairy tales of "lefties" opposing the occupation, the poll shows two-thirds of moderates saying that the surge is a failure and that the war was a mistake from the start. Also, about 60% of Independent voters say the surge is a failure, so this view is hardly limited to the Democratic Party. 30% of Republicans agree with the assessment of failure.

Still, the neocons brazenly shrill about treasonous, left-wing Democrats trying to destroy the country. Somehow the fact that Bush has received every cent he has asked for from Congress goes unmentioned. This huge PR exercise, in which the military, the media, and politicians have been leaned on to frame the debate in Bush's favour, has all come to naught.

Only a dismal 7% said that the war and subsequent occupation would go down in history as a success. And when necons snarl that 30% support for Bush is a significant number, they should also realise that 30% is about the proportion that believe the war in Iraq will be judged a complete failure.

Aside from tax cuts and a veritable flood of money to defence contractors, Bush's base has gained surprisingly little from his Presidency. At the same time, Bush has managed to alienate the entire world along with Hindus, Hispanics and Muslims here at home. He has virtually accused the majority of America's citizens of treason and support of terrorism for years. In 2004, Bush proclaimed his 51% electoral victory as a mandate with a straight face, and he proceeded to slide down in the polls ever since. He has stopped speaking to the American public years ago, aiming his efforts almost solely at shoring up his base's support, and giving speeches only at venues where he is guaranteed to be well-received. Ever since the '04 election, Republicans have lived in a fantasy world where they truly believe that the vast majority of the public supports them, were they not deceived by the "liberal" media and treacherous Democrats, yet Bush's repeated recitiations of their talking points has not gained the Party any traction whatsoever. It is a Party of the Doomed.


story from Xinhua

US public sees Iraq War as failure

The US public sees the Iraq War as a failure and thinks the US troop buildup there has not worked, according to an Associated Press-Ipsos poll suggesting the tough sell President George W. Bush faces in asking Congress and voters for more time.

The pessimism expressed by most people - including significant minorities of Republicans - contrasted with the brighter picture offered by General David Petraeus. The chief US commander in Iraq told Congress on Monday that the added 30,000 troops have largely achieved their military goals and could probably leave by next summer, though he conceded there has been scant political progress.

By 59 percent to 34 percent, more people said they believe history will judge the Iraq War a complete or partial failure than the number who said it would be judged a success. Those calling it a failure included eight in 10 Democrats, three in 10 Republicans and about six in 10 independents, the poll showed - ominous numbers for a president who hopes to use a nationally televized address later this week to keep Republican lawmakers from joining Democratic calls for a withdrawal.

"We cannot take any of this administration's assertions on Iraq at face value anymore," said Democratic Republican Tom Lantos, a war foe and senior member of the House Armed Services Committee. "And no amount of charts or statistics will improve its credibility."

Underscoring the public's negativity, four times as many predicted the war in Iraq would be judged as a complete US failure as the number who see a complete success, 28 percent to 7 percent.

When the Gallup Poll asked the same question in September 2006, 52 percent said the war will be judged as a partial or complete failure, seven points fewer than the AP-Ipsos survey.

"The enemy was in Afghanistan, and I believe going into Iraq we took our eye off the ball," said Ann Bock, 66, a retired teacher and Democratic-leaning voter from Edmond, Oklahoma, who participated in the survey.

In the poll - taken in the days just before Petraeus' long-awaited appearance - more people rated the troop increase a failure than a success by 58 percent to 36 percent, with three in 10 Republicans joining majorities of Democrats and independents in foreseeing failure.

Positive reviews of the troop increase were at about the same level as they were in mid-January, just after Bush announced the buildup.

People calling it a mistake to go to war in March 2003 outnumbered those calling it the right decision by 57 percent to 37 percent, numbers that have stayed about level for more than a year. About a quarter of Republicans, along with most Democrats and independents, labeled the war an error.

Among those in the poll supporting the conflict is Ronald Shaul, 62, a Republican and retired military intelligence officer.

"It was a logical outgrowth of the war on terror, started long ago by Islamic extremists," said Shaul, who lives in Hopkinsville, Kentucky.

Overall, those viewing the war and the troop buildup most negatively tended to be groups that often lean Democratic: females, minorities, those with lower incomes and those with less education.

For example, about two-thirds of women and half of men said the troop increase had not worked, while more minorities than whites said the war had been a mistake.

But the war remains unpopular with another group crucial to both political parties: moderates. Nearly two-thirds of them said the war and troop increase were failing and that the conflict was a mistake from the start.

Two groups that normally support the Bush administration - white evangelical voters and conservatives - remained largely behind its war strategy.

The poll was conducted on September 6-9 and involved telephone interviews with 1,000 adults. It had a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 3 percentage points.

Source: China Daily/agencies

Senators sceptical of surge testimony

Back in January, Bush expected big things from the surge by now. Iraqi troops would tackle and disarm the sectarian militias in a door-to-door search in which U.S. troops would merely back up. The Iraqi government would be in control of all of the provinces, and benchmarks would be met. Twice as many Iraqi police and military would be trained as currently exist. In short, Bush would be basking in the glow of success and saying "I told you so" to Democrats who had the audacity to doubt his brilliant plan.

Instead, we have phony numbers, a whole lot of corpses, the sectarian militias are as strong as ever, the Iraqi government is even weaker than it was back in January, and those troops can't seem to be trained. The 'bright' spot is that we've taken some of the terrorists and dubbed them "good guys". Meanwhile, Bush is doing his best to expand the military effort into Iran and Syria, in order to bring 'progress' to more of the Middle East. Once again, the best possible outcome is being entertained as the only possible outcome. And if it goes wrong, then it's the next President's problem. How many doubt that those Republicans who say that it's treason to criticise a sitting President in times of war will strangely have no problem blaming a Democratic President for the situation they are handed?

Meanwhile, the marginal, largely lateral moves from the surge are being inflated. This is not what Bush anticipated, and Republicans know it. By the next election we will have seen five years of Bush asking for patience, and only phony progress at the margins to show for it. Bush has had an absolutely free hand in this war and occupation. Nothing has been denied him. Yet he will blame Democrats for his failure, due to their dissent. Republican dissent against the action in Kosovo didn't seem to turn that into a major disaster, but facts don't matter to neocons.

story from Xinhua


General's account on Iraq meets skepticism in U.S. Senate

The top U.S. general in Iraq received deep bipartisan skepticism as he provided assessments on Iraq's situation at a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing Tuesday morning.

The opening statement from Sen. Richard Lugar (R-IN) set the tone for what would prove to be a heated discussion of U.S. policy in the war torn country, which Gen. David Petreaus maintained is improving.

Lugar compared the operation to a farmer risking his savings to plant on a flood plain.

"As policymakers, we should acknowledge that we are facing extraordinarily narrow margins for achieving our goals," he said, calling for a troop drawdown beyond pre-surge levels, contrary to Petreaus' recommendations.

Others, such as Sen. Joseph Biden (D-DE), questioned the disparity between Petreaus' assessments and that of the General Accounting Office (GAO), delivered to the committee last week.

Petreaus attributed the difference to his having an data collection period at least five weeks beyond that of the GAO report.

Sen. Chuck Hegel (R-NE), however, was not convinced.

"We've got too many disconnects here, general, way too many disconnects," he said.

Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) echoed Hegel's view, saying "our troops are owed a policy that is worthy of their sacrifice."

Gen. Petreaus, for his part, pointed to "signs for hope," including moves toward sharing oil revenue, progress in the Anbar Province and an overall reduction sectarian violence over the past month.

Ambassador Crocker, who accompanied him at the hearing, acknowledged that "there is an enormous amount of dysfunctionality in Iraq, and that is without question," but said that he is encouraged that "Iraqis are talking about that type of dysfunctionality."

Although some Republican senators appear to doubt about Petraeus' assessments, it remains to be seen if Democrats will gain enough Republican support to pass proposed legislation calling for the troops to come home by next spring.

Source: Xinhua

'Progress' kills 21 in Baghdad, Anbar today

I guess since Bush warned us that there would be "difficulties" ahead, Republicans can probably feel justified in brushing away today's Iraqi casualties. Yet, they are ostensibly so deeply concerned about any deaths that would occur should the U.S. withdraw its occupation forces.

Or better still, perhaps there is some secret way that these deaths can be statistically transformed into "non-deaths".

So, 11 more bodies turn up in Baghdad. Who knows if these are sectarian killings, anyway? Let's assume they dropped dead celebrating all of the 'progress'. Five more dead in bombings means we get to shake our fists and curse Al-Qaeda, though nothing in particular indicates they were involved. See, we get to assume whatever suits the Decider's case. That's what makes it patriotic.

And that "Awakening" Bush has been bragging about for almost a year now? It seems that the leader of it, and a few others as well, were killed in a roadside bomb in that peaceful Anbar province. Who could possibly have anticipated something like this? Only those who read the news reports from Iraq, apparently.


Baghdad

4 civilians were killed and 10 injured in a parked can bomb in Talbiyah neighborhood east Baghdad around 11 am.

A civilian was killed and 3 were wounded in a road side bomb in Zayuna neighborhood east Baghdad around 10,30 am.

Police found 11 unidentified bodies in Baghdad today in the following neighborhoods. & bodies were found in Karkh, the western side of Baghdad in the following neighborhoods (2 bodies in Amil, 2 bodies in Doura, 1 body in Bayaa, 1 body in Hurriyah and 1 body in Mahmoudiyah). 4 bodies were found in Rusafa, the eastern side of Baghdad in the following neighborhoods (2 bodies in Sadr city and 2 bodies in Qahira.)

Ramadi

Sheikh Sattar Abo Risha, the head of Anbar awakening council was killed in an IED explosion targeted his armed car near his house in Ramadi city today afternoon. Abo Risha's nephew, his aid and two of his guards were killed in the explosion.

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Another One Bites The Dust

Blair, Olmert, Abe, and Howard: the world leaders who have most closely associated themselves with Bush, and they all suffered politically at home.
With Blair resigning to a 'good riddance' from the British public, Olmert at 3% in the polls (considering the margin of error, it's technically possible nobody likes him), and Howard facing growing and strident opposition, now Abe calls it quits. Need we mention Musharraf?

Every year more nations withdraw from the Coalition, and Bush shakes his fist at each of them in order to ensure his isolation on the world stage. World opinion is against his hapless non-plan of occupying Iraq, and Bush continues to call on the U.N. (the organisation he and the Republicans have derided for several years now) to clean up the mess he made. With fewer allies than ever, the White House continues with policies cleverly designed to divide the world into "with us" and "against us" nations. Those "with us" are expected to stir up wars and incursions on demand, as well as pour large amounts of money they don't have into their militaries. They must also read from a script that makes it increasingly clear that they are merely pawns to a foreign power. And they also must put up a pretense of unwarranted optimism concerning any negative consequences from any of this.

Bush has gone to great lengths to establish his credentials as an asshole on the world stage. At first demanding that the world follow him into Iraq, he snarled at the world's ingratitude when it largely refused. He denounced the U.N. as ineffective and obsolete, while ignoring human rights crises that didn't fit into his Global War On Terror. He allied the U.S. with dictatorships in brazen contradiction to his stated goals of spreading democracy, and virtually guaranteed that any country that followed him wouldn't have to worry about human rights abuses being criticised by the U.S. When he finally realised that his rosy scenarios weren't going to come about, he then created scapegoats and again screeched to the world to join him in yet another ill-conceived effort in Iran, Syria, and Lebanon. And throughout all of this, he continued to depict his domestic opposition as traitors and supporters of terrorism - the very American people that the world respected, while having reservations about the American government.

And now Abe fades away into history. His replacement is the Japanese version of Cheney, so watch as his party surges into irrelevance just as the GOP will here.


full story from Washington Post
Japan's Prime Minister Resigns

By Blaine Harden
Washington Post Foreign Service
Wednesday, September 12, 2007; 4:20 PM

TOKYO, Sept. 12 -- Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who resigned abruptly on Wednesday after a year in power, has for weeks been a walking political corpse.

His party, which has dominated Japanese politics since World War II, was crushed in a July parliamentary election -- the type of humiliation that had forced previous prime ministers to quit without delay.

But that was just part of Abe's predicament. His judgment in picking a cabinet had proven faulty in the extreme, as scandals and ineptitude had pushed four ministers to resign and one to kill himself.

With poll numbers dipping below 30 percent, he became an object of ridicule, derided as a "spoiled little boy" by cultural critics and broadly criticized for a nationalist agenda that neglected a tightening economic squeeze felt by many Japanese, especially in rural areas. Public faith in his competence collapsed, polls showed, when he failed to respond aggressively last spring to revelations that 50 million pension records had been misfiled.

Yet Abe, the grandson of a prime minister, the son of a foreign minister and, at 52, the youngest prime minister since the war, had clung tenaciously to power until Wednesday afternoon, when he unexpectedly announced what has been obvious to the Japanese people since mid-summer.

"In the present situation, it is difficult to push ahead with effective policies that win the support and trust of the public," Abe said during a nationally televised news conference. "I need to change the situation to break the deadlock."

The deadlock that he referred to concerns a parliamentary fight over the extension of Japan's high-seas refueling operation in the Indian Ocean.

For the past six years, it has been the country's principal contribution to the war in Afghanistan and President Bush, along with many other world leaders, has urged Japan to continue to help out.

As recently as last weekend, Abe had said that he would do everything in his power to extend the anti-terrorism law that authorizes the floating gas station, which has pumped more than 127 million gallons of fuel, free of charge, most of it into U.S. warships.


How does free fuel equate with fighting terrorism?

Iraqi government contemplates troop cuts

If everything goes well, there could be 30,000 fewer troops than Petraeus has asked for by the time Bush is ready to leave office. Of course, this is the same Iraqi goverment that expected that it would have control of all of the provinces by November of this year. The Iraqi Government seems to hold unwarranted optimism in as high regard as Bush does.

story from Xinhua

Iraqi gov't expects cut of foreign troops to 100,000 by end 2008

An Iraqi national security advisor said Wednesday that the Iraqi government expected the number of foreign troops in the country to drop to 100,000 by the end of 2008 should its forces be ready and security situation be better.

"By the end of next year we expect the number of multinational troops could be less than 100,000," Muwafaq al-Rubaie told a news conference.

"This cut depends on the levels of the security threat that Iraq faces, whether inside or in the region, and the readiness of our security forces," Rubaie explained.

On Tuesday, Rubaie voiced the welcome of his government to the testimony made on Monday by the U.S. top commander in Iraq General David Petraeus to the U.S. Congress.

Petraeus has suggested in his testimony that the U.S. presence in Iraq should reach the pre-surge level by next July, which means a cut of about 30,000.

The top U.S. commander in Iraq also said that the U.S. force reduction would continue after next summer, but deemed that it would be premature to make recommendations now on the pace of such cuts.

Source: Xinhua

Monday, September 10, 2007

Poll says most don't trust Petraeus' report

To hear the testimony of Petraeus today, one would think that we've been in Iraq for four months instead of four years. We've had four years to train the Iraqi police and military. We've had four years to rebuild Iraq. We've been waiting for "progress" for four years now, and all we've really got is Bush asking for more patience. We hear that the surge of 30,000 additional troops has only been in 'full swing" for two months now. What about the 130,000 pre-surge troops?

Likewise, Petraeus' "drawing down" of troops is really nothing more than letting the troops whose tours are over actually go home. We don't have another 30,000 troops to replace them. Apparently, allowing soldiers to leave the military when their contract is up is now called "withdrawal".

Crocker's testimony was the most worthless: We overthrew Saddam, Iraqis voted, Al-Qaeda is bad. There was some vague talk about Iraqi politicians 'starting to work together', but mostly the civil war in Iraq seems to be regarded by Crocker as something created by Al-Qaeda, Syria, and Iran to make Bush look bad. Of all of the people to testify, why Crocker? He has no credibility as part of the Bush Administration, and he is just an ambassador who deals with the fake world of the Green Zone.

Aside from the technicial details of how Petraeus was going to doctor the numbers, it was completely what everyone expected. If you believed Bush before, then it was more of the same. If you doubted Bush before the testimony, then it was more rosy, selective cherry-picking of facts.
It was just one of Bush's press conferences, only with different people reading the script.
It looks like most people didn't expect much more than that, by the article below.
For almost three years now, 60% of Americans have said that the war is not worth fighting. Nothing that was said by Crocker or Petraeus today counters that. Just like the surge itself, Republicans expected big things from the report today, but all they got was the same familiar heads nodding and accusing the majority of the country of treason.


full story from Xinhua

Most Americans skeptical of Iraq status report: poll

Most Americans think the Bush administration's upcoming Iraq status report will exaggerate progress, and few expect it to result in a major shift in the administration's policy, a latest poll found.

The new Washington Post-ABC News poll released here Sunday, underscore the depth of public antipathy toward the Iraq war, the doubts about the administration's policies and the limited confidence in the Iraqi government to meet its commitments to restore civil order.

Most of the poll respondents expected David H. Petraeus, the top U.S. commander in Iraq, to express a rosier view when beginning to present the Iraq report to the Congress Monday.

Only about four in 10 said they expect the general to give an accurate accounting of the situation in Iraq.

A majority, 53 percent, said they think his report will try to make the situation in Iraq look better than it really is.

Two-thirds of Americans said they believe Bush will hold to his current course no matter what.

Overall, the American public's baseline judgment on the war is little changed -- more than six in 10 said the war is not worth fighting, a sentiment that has been a majority view for nearly three years.

This poll was conducted by telephone Sept. 4 to 7 among a random national sample of 1,002 adults.

Source: Xinhua

Iraqis flee to Syria: 2000 a day now

Iraqis continue to flee the miraculous "success" in their democracy in favour of an authoritarian police state. Ironically, in the democracy of Lebanon, these refugees are imprisoned. In either case, they at least will have access to electricity, clean and safe drinking water, medical care, and will have a distinct lack of people trying to torture and kill them.

full story

2000 Iraqis Cross into Syria Daily - UN Official

10/09/2007



Lebanon, Asharq Al-Awsat- Erika Feller, The UN Deputy Commissioner for International Protection Affairs at the United Nations High Commission for Refugee Affairs (UNHCR), has revealed to Asharq Al-Awsat that "Lebanon has the highest number of Iraqi detainees who are being held because of illegal entry or illegal residence and that the number is rising because of the security concerns caused by the latest events in Lebanon.

"Feller arrived in Lebanon from Syria to acquaint herself with the situation of the refugees in the country and discuss with Lebanese officials the situation of the approximately 40,000 Iraqi refugees in Lebanon.

Feller expressed her appreciation of the flexible and humanitarian approach that the Lebanese government has adopted toward the Iraqi refugees. She pointed out that "the discussions with the Lebanese officials dealt primarily with the detention of Iraqis, finding an alternative solution, and addressing the situation of the refugees.

She added that, "The Iraqi refuges have become victims twice: once in their country and once again in the countries where they have arrived."

Feller conveyed to Lebanese Interior Minister Hasan al-Sab the UNHCR's concern over the detention of refugees and asylum seekers, particularly the protracted detention for indefinite periods. She visited the Rumiyah Prison, the largest in Lebanon, where 400 inmates, mostly Iraqis, including a number of Sudanese and Somali nationals, are the object of the UNHCR's concern. She pointed to "overcrowdedness" in the Rumayih Prison and to the health and psychological conditions of these detainees and their need for care, particularly because some of them are studying at universities. She said that their detention for the only reason of being illegal residents would harm their education and professional future.

Feller's visit to Lebanon followed a three-day mission in Syria during which she met with Syrian officials and Palestinian and Iraqi refuges and UNHCR officials. She also visited the Al-Tanaf refugee camp in the no-man's land between Syria and Iraqi where 350 Palestinian refuges have been stranded since April 2006.

Feller told Asharq Al-Awsat, "They asked me for a solution," adding: "The number of Iraqis seeking to leave is on the rise because the situation is hard in view of what is happening in and outside Iraq. Approximately 2,000 Iraqis cross the border into Syria every day in search of a safe haven. So far, more than two million Iraqis have left Iraq and I think Iraqis will continue to leave because of the hard circumstances, turmoil, violence and religious persecution. I do not think anyone living in such circumstances can stay in Iraq. I was in Syria and saw the enormous numbers of Iraqis who have left Iraq. The number of Iraqis in Jordan and Lebanon may have stabilized, but not in Syria. It is difficult to determine the figures because we do no know where these Iraqis are staying."

Saturday, September 08, 2007

Four Marines killed in 'successful' Anbar

Anbar, the sparsely populated province that Bush has been bragging about almost for a year now, was the site of four more Marine's untimely deaths.

Three more dead in Nineveh, which was recently proclaimed to be "pacified".

What a sorry mess. Feel-good reports are seized upon by the neocons as gospel truth, but when the bodies pile up in contradiction, it's always someone else's fault. Four and a half years into this occupation, and we're still propping it up with doctored numbers that, at best, show only marginal improvement. Bush has had a free hand on this occupation, with Congress basically only periodically asking "are you sure this is going well?", but it's still the media's fault or Congress' fault when things don't go the way Bush thought they would.


Saturday, September 8, 2007

U.S. says 7 troops die in Iraq

Americans were killed in two separate actions, military reports


LOS ANGELES TIMES

BAGHDAD, Iraq
Seven U.S. military personnel were reported killed yesterday, and a leading Shiite Muslim cleric started a new round of finger-pointing over who is to blame for recent violence among rival factions of Shiite Muslims in Iraq.
Military officials said that four Marines died Thursday during combat in Iraq’s western Anbar province, which President Bush visited Monday and singled out as the region where the U.S. troop buildup this year has slowed the violence.
The three other American deaths occurred Thursday in the province of Nineveh when military vehicles were attacked with explosives, U.S. officials said.
The names of the dead were withheld pending notification of their families. The latest report brings the total number of U.S. military deaths to 3,760 since the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq in March 2003, according to icasualties.org, a Web site that tracks U.S. military deaths.

Friday, September 07, 2007

Israel stirring up a new war with Syria to get ready for "peace talks"

Olmert mounted the biggest defeat of the Israeli military at the bidding of Bush when Israel invaded southern Lebanon, and now he is happily proceeding with a new disaster with Syria.
With his poll numbers in single digits and his own sons dodging the military draft, Olmert clearly has placed the Israeli military in the hands of an unpopular and delusional American President.
Syria, the "bad boy", is currently supporting over a million Iraqi refugees who have left the brilliant "success" of the surge and the stunning 'triumph' of Iraqi democracy for a police state. The Bush Administration's curious show of appreciation for Syria's help is to order Olmert to invade. No doubt we'll be greeted with flowers and chocolates both by grateful Syrians and the Iraqis who fled there. What's another half a trillion dollars, anyway? The same people who said the invasion of Lebanon would go great are predicting this new war will go smoothly, so why worry?

Mystery, anxiety surrounds Syria-Israel incident

07/09/2007


JERUSALEM, (Reuters) - Mystery still shrouds Syria's complaint that Israel bombed its territory but the incident has set nerves jangling across the Middle East, with commentators urging both sides on Friday against an escalation into war.
Egypt, pioneer of Arab-Israeli detente, said Israel was fuelling tension. The Arab League said "unacceptable manoeuvres" showed Israeli bad faith toward peace talks in the region -- the United States aims to host a conference soon involving Israel and its neighbours, with a view to resolving Palestinian claims. "This is the beginning of a Syrian-Israeli conflict," said Sateh Noureddine, columnist with Lebanese newspaper as-Safir. He saw it as a follow-on from Israel's war in Lebanon a year ago.
Within Israel, there was criticism, too. An analyst wrote in the left-leaning Haaretz daily that commanders misunderstood the consequences and risked provoking a "pre-emptive strike".
A former Israeli diplomat who has worked for a resumption of long-stalled peace talks with Damascus said he was worried by a "very aggressive" Israeli message after a summer in which nervous speculation on both sides of a surprise attack by the other has mingled with public offers of renewed negotiations. But a day after Syria said its forces "confronted" Israeli aircraft in the early hours of Thursday and warned that it might respond to "aggression and treachery", the Israeli government stuck to a blanket refusal to comment, leaving analysts picking over the terse Syrian statement and guessing at what happened.
Although one Syrian official said troops "fired heavily" at Israeli planes, the state news agency spoke only of air defences "confronting" them -- a phrase that several analysts, including Jihad al-Khazen of pan-Arab newspaper al-Hayat, said could mean simply locking on radar rather than opening fire. "It leaves plenty of room for interpretation," Khazen said. The Syrian statement said Israelis "dropped munitions" that did no damage. A Western diplomat in Damascus offered what many found a plausible version of events -- that a reconnaissance mission found itself targeted by Syrian radar, or actual fire, and jettisoned its load as part of an evasive manoeuvre.
Israeli officials, speaking privately, do not deny Syrian accusations that Israel conducts such missions over Syria, which has left analysts pondering why Thursday's ended differently.
Was Syria's military response different from before or was the difference only that it protested publicly? Did it show Syria's defences have improved with Russian hardware bought since Israel's war in Lebanon? Were the Israeli pilots just careless? Or did they deliberately provoke a Syrian response?
For Lebanese commentator Noureddine, "It was no mistake ... that the Israelis reached that area. It was ... a test for Syria's military, political and psychological defences. "As for Syria's announcement, that is a warning that any other step like that can be considered as the start of a war."
Reuven Pedhatzur, an analyst and former Israeli pilot, wrote in Haaretz that, despite recent high tensions with Damascus, whoever ordered the mission failed to grasp its consequences.
Referring to Syria's part in the 1967 war that saw Israel seize the Golan Heights, he added: "Like 40 years ago, the two sides could lose control of the situation and war could break out through a misunderstanding of the other side's intentions."
Eyal Zisser, another Israeli analyst, had praise for Syria: "Any misunderstanding could lead to conflagration. However, the Syrian announcement was surprising in its moderation." Syrian President Bashar al-Assad had shown such "moderation" before, Zisser wrote in Yedioth Ahronoth newspaper, in that warnings of retaliation had not come to actual conflict.
Arguing the Lebanon war between Israel and Syria's Hezbollah allies had disturbed the status quo, however, he added: "Both sides should make more effort in future to avoid deterioration."
Retired senior Israeli diplomat Alon Liel, who has worked with Syrian representatives to promote negotiations, said Prime Minister Ehud Olmert risked giving Syria grounds for war at a time when, he believed, both sides had a chance to talk peace: "I see here an Israeli message that is very aggressive," Liel said on Friday. "And I'm worried."
Olmert himself was quoted as telling Israeli reporters, however, that all was well: "Do I not look relaxed?"
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Turkey: Israel vows swift probe of alleged airspace violation

For its part, Turkey said Monday that Israel has promised swift investigation of a possible violation of Turkish airspace.

Babacan demanded a quick explanation from Israel over the fuel tanks found near the Syrian border, calling the incident unacceptable, the Associated Press reported Monday.

"This situation is unacceptable for Turkey," he said.

Israeli officials have maintained a rare silence over the widely reported incident. At Sunday's cabinet meeting, no ministers spoke with the press and journalists were not allowed to ask questions, in a break from custom.

"This is an unacceptable development," Babacan said during the joint news conference.

"All countries in the region must show respect to all countries' sovereignty and avoid acts that lead to tensions," he said. "Otherwise, tensions would be fueled and peace and stability in the region might be harmed."

Turkey has demanded a prompt clarification from Israel and was still waiting for a response, Babacan said.

Crazy neocons shill for the surge

Behold the delusional world of the neocons! Troop morale is 'through the roof', and the reports from everyone whose job doesn't depend on the Decider's satisfaction are sheer fabrications, at least if you care to drink the Kool-Aid. Things are great in Iraq, or so these shills say, and in another ten years or so things will probably be great enough that we can even leave Iraq.

I think it's interesting to note that the false "surge critic", Michael O'Hanlon, was in on the fun.

All of these people have been continually wrong for the past 4 1/2 years and have been saying that things will turn around in another six months for the past few years. But now you can believe them for some reason. After all, it's not like they've invested their entire careers in the Iraq fiasco...well, actually they have. Sure, Republicans have been saying for the past six months that everything will depend on "Petraeus'" report, but now it seems that we can all ignore it, because these in-the-know neocons have it all figured out on their own.

As long as these bozos are making fools of themselves, why don't they just go all the way and say that we've won and it's over?


POLITICS-US: Neocons Put on a Surge-Stravaganza
By Eli Clifton

WASHINGTON, Sep 7 (IPS) - With U.S. General David Petraeus's eagerly anticipated final report on Iraq due on Sep. 15, supporters of the troop surge are busily trying to set the stage for the report that they believe will refute their opponents.

The media blitz in Washington is unfolding under the backdrop of dwindling domestic and international support for the ongoing U.S. presence in Iraq.

In a worldwide poll released Friday and conducted by the BBC World Service, GlobeScan and the Programme on International Policy Attitudes (PIPA), 67 percent of international respondents and 61 percent of U.S. citizens think the U.S. should withdraw within a year.

Progress in the troop surge has been slow and Petraeus's July interim report found mixed results, with only six of 18 congressional benchmarks for success in Iraq being met.

On Thursday, the right-leaning American Enterprise Institute (AEI) -- which has generally supported the George W. Bush administration's decisions in Iraq -- put on a marathon three-and-a-half hour series of panel discussions to promote AEI resident scholar Frederick Kagan's new report, "No Middle Way: The Challenge of Exit Strategies From Iraq".

Kagan challenges another recent report by the Centre for a New American Security, which proposes a phased withdrawal from Iraq and a shift from the current U.S. role of performing security operations to an advisory and support role for the Iraqi police and military.

"...(The CNAS) report, like most middle-way strategies, mistakes the conditions that would make such a transition successful: when basic security has been established. Instead, it suggests than an immediate transition to an advisory role -- driven by hopes for bipartisanship in Washington but irrespective of the security situation in Iraq -- would allow the United States to withdraw most of its combat forces without compromising its interests," writes Kagan. "That conclusion is false."

The "No Middle Way" kickoff included surge-heavyweights such as Senator Lindsey Graham, a South Carolina Republican, the Brookings Institution's Michael O'Hanlon, retired U.S. Army General Jack Keane and AEI's Danielle Pletka and Gary J. Schmitt.

"Middle Way" proponents, however, did get their say with James N. Miller, the co-author of the CNAS report, titled "Phased Transition: A Responsible Way Forward and Out of Iraq", defending his report in one of the two panel discussions.

The lead-up to the Petraeus report -- which, the LA Times reported, "would actually be written by the White House, with inputs from officials throughout the government" -- has fanned the flames of debate over whether the surge is actually having its desired effect.

All the speakers at the AEI event, minus Miller, painted a positive image of post-surge Iraq, citing drops in sectarian violence and the impossibility of starting an immediate phased withdrawal based on timelines instead of improvements on the ground, both political and security related, which, they claim, would only lead to a failure in Iraq.

Meanwhile, public support for the U.S. military presence in Iraq is continuously dwindling. Proponents of the surge point to statistics showing decreases in sectarian bloodshed, but serious questions have been raised about the validity of this data.

Petraeus, in his upcoming report, is expected to cite a 75 percent decrease in sectarian attacks and a 17 percent decline in civilian casualties from December 2006 to August 2007.

However, an Associated Press report last week said that 1,809 civilian deaths occurred in August, making it the highest monthly casualty count this year, with 27,564 civilians killed since the AP began its data collection in April 2005.

Furthermore, a General Accounting Office (GAO) report -- criticised at the "No Middle Way" event -- found that the "average number of daily attacks against civilians have remained unchanged from February to July 2007."

Kagan, Keen and O'Hanlon discount such dire statistics as not being representative of the Iraq they have witnessed during week-long tours of the country.

Graham summed up the situation as either continuing with the surge and emerging victorious, or choosing a middle ground and facing certain defeat.

"My last visit convinced me more than anything else that the biggest benefit from the surge is to take the men and women on the frontlines and change their attitudes about their mission," said Graham. "They've gone from riding around waiting to be shot to feel like they're kicking their ass. God bless," Graham concluded.

The LA Times suggested on Aug. 25 that morale might not be "sky high" or "through the roof", as Graham claimed in his remarks Thursday.

"The latest in a series of mental health surveys of troops in Iraq, released in May, says 45 percent of the 1,320 soldiers interviewed ranked morale in their unit as low or very low. Seven percent ranked it high or very high," said the LA Times.

(END/2007)

Iceland calls it quits in Iraq

I guess Iceland is going to leave before the imaginary "victory" parade happens. I bet they'll be sorry when Bush creates some new definition that "proves" we have "won" in Iraq.

story from Xinhua

Iceland withdraws from NATO project in Iraq
08:42, September 07, 2007

Icelandic Foreign Minister Ingibjorg Solrun Gisladottir decided this week to remove an Icelandic Crisis Response Unit (ICRU) member from a NATO training program for the Iraqi army in Baghdad, causing disappointment among NATO leaders, said reports reaching Stockholm from Reykjavik Thursday.

The ICRU member has been working in Baghdad for the last two years, primarily as a media representative, and will cease working there on Oct. 1, newspaper Morgunbladid reported.

John Craddock, the Supreme Allied Commander Europe for NATO and the U.S. European Command, said at a press conference in Iceland Wednesday that Iceland is an important and active NATO member and that he was disappointed with Gisladottir's decision.

Gisladottir was asked at the press conference whether she would withdraw ICRU members from NATO projects in Afghanistan as well. The minister said she would not, as the situation in Afghanistan is different from that in Iraq.

Gisladottir said Iceland should focus on other development programs related to Iraq, like educational programs for Iraqi refugees.

Source: Xinhua

Poll: World says withdraw troops from Iraq

The Bush Administration's Iraq policy is about as popular with the rest of the world as it is here, and that's the bad news. Only 25% of the world says that the U.S. should stick it out until 'victory", however the word is currently being defined these days. It's pretty clear that our allies' opinions don't matter to the Decider, as they are merely tools to exploit and deceive, but it is interesting to note that about 2/3 majorities in the three countries risking the most on Bush's optimism want out within a year.

Now, I can already hear the neocons sputtering on about how the world owes us, and we shouldn't care what they think anyway because they aren't as strong as us. But one of the vague "plans" on the back burner to get out of Iraq is to get the rest of the world to pitch in and help us out. You know, those weak countries that don't matter and are cowardly appeasers. It would seem by this poll that getting any new countries in on the amazing "success" in Iraq will be a tough sell. With two wars going, a third being planned with Iran, and staggering military commitments around the globe, the U.S. just can't bully like it used to. And with $12 billion a week going down the drain known as Iraq, we can't really afford to bribe like we used to, either. With Bush's State Department doing its best to push away any allies that basically won't turn their nation's military and treasury over to the U.S, we will have a hard time "persuading" countries to join the "victory train".

Another interesting point from the article: 24% of Americans want us out of Iraq immediately.

Poll says world wants troops out of Iraq

LONDON (Reuters) - More than two thirds of people around the world think American-led forces should pull out of Iraq within a year, according to a poll published on Friday by the BBC's international service.
The BBC World Service poll, which questioned 23,000 people in 22 countries, also found that only a quarter of respondents thought foreign troops should stay in Iraq until the security situation improves.
Almost two thirds (61 percent) of Americans who were asked said they thought their forces should leave Iraq within a year, with 24 percent saying they should get out immediately.
Only around a third of Americans say forces should stay until security improves, according to the poll conducted by pollsters GlobeScan and the Program on International Policy Attitudes at the University of Maryland between May 29 and July 26. The United States has around 160,000 soldiers in Iraq.
Other members of the U.S.-led coalition also had majorities wanting forces out within a year -- 65 percent of Britons, 63 percent of South Koreans and 63 percent of Australians.
U.S. President George W. Bush visited Iraq on Monday and has this week raised the possibility of reducing American troop numbers if security conditions improve.
Britain has reduced its troop numbers to around 5,000 and says its forces will remain in Iraq as long as they are needed.
But GlobeScan president Doug Miller said the poll showed most people would favour a timetable for withdrawal.
"The weight of global public opinion, and indeed American opinion, is opposed to the Bush administration's current policy of letting security conditions in Iraq dictate the timing of U.S. troop withdrawal," he said in a statement.
This article: http://news.scotsman.com/latest.cfm?id=1430082007

ACLU report says U.S. troops disregard rules of war

Regardless of how you interpret 'support the troops', this story does not make our military look much better to the rest of the world than many others that we criticise.

story from Xinhua


Documents show US troops disregard of rules for war

08:06, September 05, 2007

U.S. troops in Iraq and Afghanistan have failed to understand and observe the rules on interrogations and deadly actions when they committed crimes against local civilians, say documents released on Wednesday.

The report by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) showed it was common that U.S. soldiers believed they did not break any law when killing local citizens.

Among the killings, U.S. soldiers pushed a Iraqi man into the Tigris River because he broke curfew and a former Iraqi general suspected of helping insurgents was suffocated during interrogation, according to the documents.

Chief Warrant Officer Lewis Welshofer, who was convicted by a January 2006 court-martial of negligent homicide in the death of an Iraqi general during the interrogation, still insisted his actions were not against the rules, the documents show.

"An interrogation without stress is not an interrogation -- it is a conversation," he said in a letter to the court.


Through a federal Freedom of Information Act, ACLU requested for all documents concerning U.S troops involvement in the deaths of civilians in Iraq and Afghanistan. However, only the Army responded.

ACLU is to file a lawsuit, by which compel the military to disclose all documents on all civilian deaths incidents U.S. troops in Iraq and Afghanistan were accounted for since January 2005.

Source: Xinhua.

New poll shows Turks see U.S. as a threat

83% of Turkish citizens hold "unfavourable" opinions of the U.S, according to a new poll.
This is one of the consequences of the occupation of Iraq and the subsequent independence of Kurdistan, leading almost 66% of Turks to believe that the U.S. is the greatest threat to their country. Turkey apparently is yet another ally that the Bush Administration's foreign policy has pushed away. And all of this is an effort to secure Iraq as an ally in the War on Terror. How many reliable allies must we give up in this ill-conceived, extremely expensive attempt to gain one flimsy ally? Are we really safer with fewer allies? How long will it be until Turkey begins to look to the SCO as their new ally?

Actually, Turkey has massacred far, far more Kurds than Saddam ever did. It doesn't seem to bother Republicans that Turkey has been "killing its own people" on a massive scale for decades. Sure, they didn't use gas like Saddam did, but those people Turkey bombed, shelled and shot are just as dead. It didn't even bother Republicans when Saddam did it, either, because at the time Iraq was our "buddy" in their war against Iran. Years later, when Saddam stopped reading the script we gave him, suddenly Republicans dusted off all of the atrocities they had studiously ignored before. We simply don't criticise our allies when it comes to human rights, but when it comes to countries that aren't our client states, then we have a different standard.

Also from the article:

a February 2007 Gallup poll showed that only 15 percent of U.S. citizens believe the U.S. should take "the leading role" in solving international problems.

That seems to sharply contradict Bush's "diplomacy". It's only been in the past few weeks that Bush has called on the UN to provide humanitarian relief to the "success" in Iraq. Our other (21) allies in the Coalition are quite small in numbers, and many expressly forbid their troops to engage in combat. One such example is South Korea, which has 1200 troops sit in their base and guard themselves. Somehow this helps stabilise Iraq. Aside from Britain, which has withdrawn to the air base outside of Basra, the next 8 biggest countries' forces add up to about 4300 in total. Five countries have three dozen or less troops in Iraq currently. Latvia has two there.

So it looks like we are kind of taking the "leading role" in Iraq doesn't it?


POLITICS: U.S. Viewed as Turkey's "Greatest Threat"
By Jonathan Bell

WASHINGTON, Sep 7 (IPS) - Nearly two-thirds of the Turkish public named the United States as their country's greatest future threat, a recent Pew Global Attitudes Project survey has revealed -- the highest percentage of any Middle Eastern or Islamic country polled.

The survey, which was also conducted in Palestine, Egypt, Lebanon, Kuwait, Jordan, Morocco and Israel, asked an open ended question: "What country or groups pose the greatest threat to (survey country) in the future?" Turkey was the only country in which a majority of respondents pointed to the U.S.

Turkey, a U.S. NATO ally and recipient of U.S. and NATO security guarantees, also harbours the second most negative attitudes towards the U.S., with 83 percent holding an "unfavourable" opinion of it -- up 29 percent since 2002, the biggest drop in public opinion of the U.S. in recent years.

Eighty-six percent of Palestinians express an unfavourable opinion of the U.S., the most negative response from a Middle Eastern country.

Dr. Emre Erdogan, a political scientist and founding partner of Infakto Research Workshop, says that this is "a result of intensifying terrorist activities of the PKK" -- an armed militant group founded in the 1970s also known as the Kurdistan Workers Party -- which has found increasing support since the Iraq war began.

The Turkish people "perceive the U.S. as responsible for the worsening situation," said Erdogan in a World Public Opinion (WPO)/Programme on International Policy Attitudes (PIPA) analysis of the Pew results.

The "increasing terrorist and political activity of the PKK" is seen to be "under direct supervision of the Northern Iraq Administration and the U.S.", and the Turkish media "continuously present evidence for this [U.S.-PKK] collaboration," said Erdogan.

According to a 2005 Infakto poll, 71 percent of Turks think that "the West has helped separatist groups in Turkey gain strength", and a Pew 2007 survey found that 79 percent of Turks oppose "U.S.-led efforts to fight terrorism".

"[T]his intolerance and antipathy towards the PKK became converted to the perception of the U.S. as the major enemy of the country," Erdogan said. "Before the invasion of Iraq, the worst enemy of the country was stated as Greece or Armenia... rather than the U.S."

The 2005 Infakto poll also found that 66 percent think that "Western countries want to divide and break Turkey like they divided and broke the Ottoman Empire in the past," an idea that Steven Kull, director of PIPA and editor for WPO, found "surprising".

"[The] Turks are very concerned that the Kurds are going to leave and want to gain independence," Kull told IPS, but the suggestion that "the U.S. is intentionally seeking to divide [Turkey] surprised me...the U.S. has a commitment to protect Turkey from aggression, and has never threatened to [directly] attack Turkey, unlike Greece, which is why I find this particularly striking."

Dissatisfaction with U.S. foreign policy is not only prevalent in Turkey. A January 2007 Gallup poll of U.S. citizens found that 56 percent of respondents were dissatisfied with the current role of the U.S. in the world -- up from the 51 percent who shared that view in 2006 -- and not only do majorities of U.S. citizens see the world as more dangerous, but large numbers attribute that to the George W. Bush administration's foreign policy.

A Chicago Council on Global Affairs poll found that 69 percent of U.S. citizens support Washington's involvement in world affairs, reflecting the trend of greater support for U.S. involvement since the attacks of 9/11, but a February 2007 Gallup poll showed that only 15 percent of U.S. citizens believe the U.S. should take "the leading role" in solving international problems -- 58 percent said the U.S. should "take a major role but not the leading role."

The Pew survey found that 81 percent of Turks dislike "American ideas about democracy", 83 percent dislike "American ways of doing business", and 68 percent dislike "American music, movies and television", statistics that have all increased by at least 22 percent in the last five years.

Erdogan commented that, before, Turks might dislike the U.S. government but they still appreciated its culture, whereas now there is an "emerging antipathy" towards U.S. citizens and their life style, with 77 percent saying they held unfavourable views of U.S. citizens.

(END/2007)

U.S. leans on India over Iran

Last month, India refused to go along with the Bush Administration's warmongering with Iran. Now we are seeing the fallout from that, as the usual American suspects cast aside U.S. interests in order to create hysteria over Iran. India is now beginning to learn what State Department 'diplomacy' really is about, as they are being villified as conspirators with Iran.

Put simply, the India-U.S. nuclear deal is the best that the U.S. can get. If the U.S. doesn't play ball, there are other countries who will step in to develop India's nuclear industry, and some of those are nations we really wouldn't like to see cozying up to India. And India can always wait until Bush is out of office, if the U.S. involvement is considered critical.

With the U.S. overextended in two wars, on top of its prodigious military commitments globally, becoming more isolated as its foreign policies boil down to blackmail and bullying, and Britain backing away from self-destruction on the U.S' behalf, other countries are no longer enthusiastic about following any script the State Department might give them. Bush's reliable stooges, such as Blair, Olmert, Abe, and Howard, all are suffering politically or are out of office in disgrace.

Now is not the time to be pushing allies away from us, especially over the ill-conceived attack on Iran. The rest of the world simply is not going to cast aside its interests in an attempt to please Bush, who will be gone in 17 months anyway.

The irony of this situation is that American hypocrisy was obvious over the nuclear deal with "friendly" India and "unfriendly" Iran. Now we have 'remedied' that by putting our relations with India in jeopardy. Add to this the Republican uproar over "wicked" Hindus a few months ago, which did not play well in India or here at home with Indian-Americans. If India is smart, and it is, it will make overt moves to Russia or China to develop its nuclear industry. France, Canada, Britain and others will be frozen out of this opportunity by sticking with Bush.


Indo-Iran ties can sidetrack nuke pact

Agencies
Posted online: Friday, September 07, 2007 at 1058 hours IST
Updated: Friday, September 07, 2007 at 1102 hours IST

Nuclear Deal Washington, September 7: Observing that there was "no evidence" that India would cease its military relationship with Iran, two US Senators have warned that the "growing" ties between the two countries could "sidetrack" the Indo US nuclear agreement.

In a letter to US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, Republican Senator Jon Kyl and Richard Durbin, a Democrat, have said, "government sanctioned military-to-military working groups and joint military training exercises that India conducts with Iran" were a cause of concern.

"As supporters of the US-India Civil Nuclear Accord, we're apprehensive that the agreement could be sidetracked by what appears to be a growing relationship between Iran and India," they said in the letter dated September 5,2007.

"India apparently has helped Iran to develop more effective batteries for its submarine fleet," the lawmakers said and termed it as "disturbing".

In an attempt to alert the Indian government to this "potential problem", they said, eight US Senators wrote to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh earlier this year asking him whether India would break its military relationship with Iran.

"These Senators did not receive a response; and, of course, there has been no evidence that India will cease its military relationship with Iran," the letter said.

The lawmakers also cited reports detailing steps by India to enter into agreements to develop Iranian oil and gas resources and expressed the hope that New Delhi would deny Tehran such economic support.

"While we understand India's reliance on external sources of natural gas, we know that the Iranian economy, its energy sector in particular, is extremely fragile," the Senators wrote.

"We would hope India would not provide just the economic support to Iran that the United States has been labouring to deny through passage of legislation," Kyl and Durbin said.

The two lawmakers also cited reports of several alleged incidents of proliferation of dangerous technologies "that have their source in India".

"These are, of course, troubling matters," they said.

"We look forward to discussing these concerns with you to ensure that it is the right time for Congress to be considering the 123 agreement," they said.

The US Congress is due to give its final vote on the civilian nuclear agreement that will allow India access to nuclear material and technology to meet its power needs.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Indo-US Nuke Deal

Duty of US to convince NSG: India

Agencies
Posted online: Tuesday, September 04, 2007 at 1925 hours IST
Updated: Tuesday, September 04, 2007 at 1931 hours IST

Nuke Deal Kalpakkam, TN, September 4: India on Tuesday said it was the duty of the US to convince the Nuclear Suppliers Group under the civil nuclear deal to provide it with nuclear fuel and light water reactors and ensure clean, unconditional exemptions for trade in the atomic field with New Delhi.

India is also engaged with the 45-nation grouping to persuade it to change rules and allow the international community to have nuclear commerce with it, Atomic Energy Commission Chairman Anil Kakodkar said.

"No post and pre-conditions should be laid and there is a need for clean, unconditional exemptions from NSG guidelines on the import of nuclear reactors," he told reporters on the sidelines of a graduation function at the Indira Gandhi Centre for Academic Research at Kalpakkam, about 75 km from Chennai.

He was responding to a query on NSG guidelines that restrict the export of reactors by members of the grouping, including the US, France, Russia, Australia and Japan.

Reacting to US Under Secretary of State Nicholas Burns' remarks that it was up to India to convince NSG members to provide it nuclear fuel and light water reactors, he said, it was the duty of the US to do so in the wake of the nuclear deal recently clinched with America.

Commenting on the deal and the possible US restrictions on nuclear tests by India, Kakodkar said, "We have to look at Indian interests and should be able to carry out our strategic programmes."

The ultimate goal of the Indian nuclear programme is to move from uranium to thorium for producing energy, he said.

By 2050, nuclear energy will constitute 2,74,000 MW or 20 to 25 per cent of India's power production, he said
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

China raises fresh concerns on N-deal

Reuters
Posted online: Thursday, September 06, 2007 at 1608 hours IST
Updated: Thursday, September 06, 2007 at 1624 hours IST

N-Deal Beijing, September 6: China said on Thursday there were 'different views' about a nuclear power pact between the United States and India and called for such deals to stay in line with international safeguards -- but left its own stance ambiguous.

The agreement between New Delhi and Washington would offer India US fuel and reactors while allowing it to stay out of the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, keep nuclear arms and protect its military atomic complex from international inspections.

Even if the agreement survives opposition from Leftists, China's veto could kill it at an international level.

Indian newspapers have suggested that Beijing could block the deal at the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG), a 45-nation club that works by consensus.

Washington will need to go to the NSG, which is supposed to discourage nuclear trade with countries outside full safeguards, to ask for special leeway for India.

Noting various opinions on the deal in the NSG, China's Foreign Ministry suggested that Washington and New Delhi should address worries that it would damage safeguards against the spread of nuclear weapons.

"We have also noted that within the Nuclear Suppliers Group there are different views about relaxing the restrictions on nuclear exports to India," Ministry spokeswoman Jiang Yu told a regular news briefing.

"China believes that, with the precondition of abiding by their international responsibilities, all countries can develop cooperation in the peaceful exploitation of nuclear power."

The Leftists have demanded that New Delhi put on hold talks with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) to secure a safeguards pact needed to clinch the deal.

Jiang said any international atomic power cooperation should serve to 'protect and strengthen' barriers against the spread of nuclear arms.

She refused to say whether China itself had concerns about the deal. Some Scandinavian countries have privately expressed concerns about making exceptions for India.

Jiang's comments appeared to be China's latest step in a delicate diplomatic game of signalling concerns about the deal without sparking a stand-off with India.

Experts have said China is unlikely to stymie the nuclear deal and risk pushing Delhi closer to Washington -- just when Beijing is seeking to avoid a destabilising confrontation with its rising Asian neighbour and longtime rival.

But many have also said that Beijing worries about how the deal will affect regional security and arms controls.