Saturday, October 27, 2007

Krugman on media bias

As we continue to hear the neocons shrill against the "liberal media" I thought that a few brief excerpts of an interview with Paul Krugman were in order. Also, I welcome the chance to refer people to Krugman's blog.

If you aren't aware, Mr. Krugman is an economics professor at Princeton and a columnist for the NYT.

We have a situation right now in which there are several major parts of the news media that are for all practical purposes part of "movement conservatism" -- Fox News, the New York Post, the Washington Times -- and in which other news organizations are intimidated, at least to some extent. I sometimes talk about what I call "asymmetrical intimidation." If you say a true but unflattering thing about Bush or in fact about any other prominent conservative, oh, boy! People are going to go after you. I mean, I've got people working full-time going after me, right? But if you say a false, unflattering thing about a Democrat or a progressive, no risk ... And that shapes coverage, no question about it. It's better now, but it's still very asymmetric. The other thing we should mention about the media is their addiction to the trivial. We've got the most substantive election coming up, I think, ever. We've got clear differences on policies between parties. And what are we seeing news stories about? John Edwards' hair and Hillary Clinton's laugh ... this is horrifying! And again -- it's asymmetric. I can think of lots of unflattering things to say about any of the Republican candidates -- Mitt Romney's saying his sons are serving the country by helping him get elected! -- but it doesn't get nearly as much play in the media.

-----------------------------------------

The media's bias, a large part of it is in fact right-wing bias, because they are effectively part of the right wing. Fox News ... there's nothing like Fox News on other television networks that you can look at. There is no liberal equivalent of Fox News, there is no network that, if a conservative got the Nobel Peace Prize, would have responded the way Fox News did to Al Gore's Peace Prize, by first saying nothing at all, then when they figured out the line, talking about how fat he is ... So there's no correspondence there.

Beyond that, there's two things at least; first, the hatred of substance -- they really want to talk about all that trivia -- and there's also the fetish of evenhandedness. If one candidate says something that's completely false, and the other something that's true, the media will say, "Some people believe what that guy said was false, and some people say it was true." Way back in the 2000 campaign, I wrote a piece in which I said that if Bush said the earth was flat, the headline would read: "Opinions Differ on Shape of the Planet." I was thinking specifically about what Bush was saying about taxes and Social Security, which were just out and out lies! But no one would say that, and they still won't. It's better now, a little, but they still won't say it, and that tends -- I imagine in some future environment that might work to the advantage of some dishonest candidates on the left -- but the fact of the matter is the Big Lies are all on the right right now. So it works much more to their advantage.

Iraqi political progress stalled

We keep hearing about the "lull in violence" in Iraq, but really it is marginal.

Bodies show up in Baghdad on a daily basis. It does not matter, in terms of stability and security, if it is "only" 200 instead of 300. Bombings take place nearly every day. Iraqi military and police, along with U.S. troops, continue to be killed and maimed on a regular basis. This is not "normalcy". To acheive this 'reduction', the American commanders are increasingly relying on air strikes, with its attendant civilian casualties. We have also allied ourselves with "good" terrorists in our efforts "against terrorism". If Republicans knew in January that Bush's surge would merely result in 100 fewer sectarian deaths each month, would they have so fiercely supported it? Far from Bush's vision of disarming sectarian militias with the surge, instead we have allied ourselves with them.

However, the bottom line is that this alleged "improvement" in the security situation has not brought any progress in the political situation. Progress on the political front is what will allow us to leave Iraq. Bush has consistently put the cart before the horse in stressing security over political stability. When Bush proposed the surge back in January, he expected big things by now. He expected that he would be hailed as a hero and that Iraq would be stable. The year before that we heard optimistic predictions of imminent success and "victory" in an occupation that had already dragged on too long. In September we heard of isolated improvement and questionable figures showing that fewer people were being massacred in the civil war in which we serve as a referee. As Britain withdraws and the Sadrists move toward ending their self-imposed "break", we can expect further opportunities to show how "desperate" the "enemy" is in Iraq.

Air strikes cannot end an insurgency. The "enemy" shifts from month to month. Harsh security measures only serve to give the lie to "normalcy". Refugees continue to pour into the neighbouring countries. And a new war with Iraq will only destabilise the entire region. Our Arab allies know this, and are worried. Nothing Bush promised them has come to pass. Their insecurity has only increased, as has their costs to support masses of Iraqis fleeing "democracy" and "success" in their homeland. Their counsel is routinely rejected by a delusional White House. And the U.N. is getting stuck with the bill to deal with the humanitarian disaster, while the Bush Administration derides it as being ineffective and worthless.


U.S. soldier shot dead in Salahudin north of Baghdad

An American soldier was killed by small arms fire in the Salahudin province north of Baghdad, the U.S. military said on Saturday.

The attack occurred on Thursday during U.S. troops' operations in the province, the military said in a statement.

Earlier, the military said that another soldier was killed and four others were wounded in the day when an armored piercing roadside bomb, or EFP, struck their unit in southern Baghdad.

EFP, first developed during World War II, is a special type of shaped charge designed to penetrate armor effectively.

The names of deceased soldiers are being withheld pending notification of relatives, the statements said.

The latest death brings the number of U.S. soldiers who have been killed in Iraq to more than 3,835 since the outbreak of the Iraq war in 2003, according to media count based on Pentagon figures.

Source: Xinhua
------------------------------------------------------

Four people killed in two bomb explosion in Baghdad

Two roadside bombs detonated coordinately in a parking lot in a southeastern Baghdad suburb on Wednesday, killing at least four people and wounding 25 others, a police and witness sources said.

The two blasts occurred in the morning. into a busy parking lot in the Jesr Diyala suburb, killing at least four people and wounding 25 others, including women and children, a well-informed police source told Xinhua on condition of anonymity.

However, a witness at the scene told Xinhua that he saw up to 11 bodies scattered at the scene and several civilian cars and minibuses were badly charred by the blasts that detonated in a short succession.

Iraqi security forces cordoned off the scene while ambulances were evacuating the victims to nearby hospitals and fire engines were putting out fires of nearby buildings and vehicles, the police source said.

Source: Xinhua
-----------------------------------------


15 civilians killed in U.S. raid northwest of Baghdad

U.S. troops backed by aircraft raided the al-Qaida in Iraq network northwest of Baghdad on Thursday, killing 19 suspected militants and 15 civilians, including nine children, the U.S. military said on Friday.

Actin upon intelligence reports about a meeting for al-Qaida leaders in the region of Tharthar lake, U.S. surveillance confirmed activities match to the intelligence reports, prompting the troops to call in air support and conducted a strike against the target, killing four terrorists, the military said in a statement.

The troops then tracked some of those who headed to an area south of the lake. During the tracking, the troops received small arms fire, and again the troops call in air support, it said.

After securing the area, the ground forces killed 15 terrorists, it added.

However, six women and nine children were also killed in the raid, said the statement.

Two suspects were also wounded and another was detained in the attack, along with wounding a woman and three more children, the military said.

Source:Xinhua
----------------------------------------------

Baghdad

Three bodies were found in Baghdad today in the following neighborhoods (1 body in Ur, 1 body in Bayaa and 1 body in Amil).

Kirkuk

Gunmen killed Fahima Hussein Mohammed, a nurse who works in Hawija central hospital in Hawija town west of Kirkuk. Police said that the gunmen opened fire on the nurse while while she was inside her house. Fahima was injured seriously and she died while moving her to the hospital.

Two policemen were wounded when an IED exploded targeting their patrol on Kirkuk – Mosul street north of Kirkuk around 10,30 am

Ukraine says "no thanks" to NATO

As Russia is making progress in consolidating Caspian nations in opposition to Bush's efforts to invade Iran, Ukraine is now backing away from NATO membership for the time being.

Poland and the Czech Republic are already being pressed into service as front-line cannon fodder for an "unavoidable" military confrontation with Moscow and the SCO. It must be confounding for Bush to realise that Eastern Europe is unwilling to trade one demanding foreign master for another. Aside from the opportunity for involvement in any number of exciting foreign military campaigns that are not in Ukraine's interest, and the chance to have thousands of foreign troops and mercenaries with free reign running around your nation, the Ukrainian people seem unenthuisastic.

story from naharnet
Ukraine Won't Join NATO in the Near Future

Ukraine will not be joining the NATO western military alliance in the immediate future, the country's president Viktor Yushchenko said Saturday, Interfax reported.
The country would not join in the next one or two years, but when it was ready, said Yushchenko during a wreath-laying ceremony at the grave of the Unknown Warrior in Kiev.

The pro-western president, whose rule has been bolstered by the victory of a pro-Western coalition in last month's parliamentary election, has regularly advocated joining the NATO alliance.

On Monday he told a meeting of regional defense ministers in Kiev: "Ukraine confirms its course toward membership of the European Union and NATO."

Most Ukrainians however say they are against their country, which was ruled for centuries from Moscow, joining the Western military alliance.

Russian ambassador Viktor Chernomyrdin told Saturday's edition of the daily Komsomolskaya Pravda that he did not see any reason for Ukraine joining NATO.

"Why should Ukraine join this military bloc that, by the way, possesses the nuclear weapon ? Does any threat exist?" he told the paper.

"If some menace to Ukraine exists, I'm sure that we would be the first to come to the defense of the neighbor and would not even consult anybody about this," he added. (AFP)

Afghan effort stalls

Australia's Howard, the prime Bush toady now that Blair has made his exit, is echoing the White House again. Bush apparently needs more troops in Afghanistan, though all reports and official comment from the Bush Administration somehow indicate that the Afghan effort is going swimmingly. How odd.

There are five nations, along with the Afghans, in combat roles in Afghanistan. The British press has been candid in assessing the Afghan effort and the British role. The British military has been fighting two bloody conflicts and is wearing thin. The Iraq mission, ill-conceived and ridiculously expensive, had to give in order for the Afghan mission to continue. The Afghan mission is the one concerned with terrorism, after all, which is what Britain ostensibly signed up for. Of course, this change in focus bore only contempt and insults from the Pentagon; the only reward for loyalty to the Decider. Public opinion in Canada and the Netherlands has turned against the Afghan effort, even as Bush makes further irritated demands of greater support from these nations. Australia's media has published pieces calling the Afghan situation "going down fast", and Howard is facing a tough election. U.N. reports are also hardly optimistic.

As usual, the Bush line is that apparent failure only proves that the enemy is "desperate". The Afghan people are pretty desperate, too. Unemployment is 40%, the infrastructure is a shambles, reconstruction never got off the ground, and the warlords who control the vast majority of the country refuse to give tax receipts to the puppet government in Kabul. However, girls can now to school, and this is apparently the crowning achievement of the conflict. Desperate Afghan farmers have grown a record crop of poppies, since aid has been slow or non-existent and poppies offer large profits. The military solution has been to destroy these crops, or at least to make ham-fisted attempts to do so, leaving these farmers even worse off than they were before they turned to poppies. The Afghan government barely even controls the capital and is too broke to pay the civil servants. Efforts to train the Afghan military and police are slow. Due to high troop casualties, the Coalition is increasingly turning to air power to combat the Taliban, and civilian casualties have produced outrage from Afghanis across the board, including Karzai.

Given all of this, what nation wouldn't want to get a larger piece of the Decider's 'success', knowing full well that Bush will take all of the credit and none of the blame? Seeing that the allies are now being cast as the scapegoat for the failure of the Afghan effort, how can these nations possibly resist pouring even more troops and cash into their efforts? Aware that our allies face domestic political peril in following Bush even further, surely they will step up to the plate for the mere opportunity to get a pat on the head from the Decider, which has been the kiss of death for other leaders.

Certainly all that is required is a continuation of the bullying attitude, rank condecension, arrogant demands, and unfounded optimism that got us this far. After all, the worse things look, the better they really are in Bush-land.

full story from ireland.com

Bomb kills 4 at US Afghan base

A suicide bomber detonated his explosives at the entrance to a US base in eastern Afghanistan today, killing three Afghan soldiers and one Afghan civilian.

A US spokeswoman said initial reports indicated the bomber walked up to the first security gate outside of Forward Operating Base Bermel in Paktika province.

She said three Afghan soldiers and one civilian were killed and that four Afghans were wounded.

No Americans were wounded in the attack, she said. It wasn't immediately clear if the bomber had been trying to gain entry to the base, which is near the border with Pakistan.

Taliban insurgents have set off more than 100 suicide blasts this year, a record pace, and violence in 2007 has been the deadliest since the 2001 U.S.-led invasion. More than 5,200 people have died because of the insurgency this year, according to an Associated Press count based on figures from Afghan and Western officials.

Australia's prime minister, meanwhile, said more NATO powers must directly engage the Taliban to help ease the burden on Australia, the United States, Britain, Canada and the Netherlands, which all have troops in the dangerous southern and central parts of Afghanistan.

Germany, Italy, France and Spain have troops in the safer northern sections, and Australian Prime Minister John Howard said those countries need to help ease the burden on the countries in the south.

"Some of the other countries have lots of troops in Afghanistan but they're not in some of the areas that are experiencing the heaviest fighting," he said.

The governments of the Netherlands and Canada in particular are coming under domestic pressure to pull out troops because of heavy casualties.

"I think the Dutch government has been very courageous to date," he said. "It's not for me to comment on Dutch politics but I do observe that the Dutch are making a great contribution and as are of course the Canadians."

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Afghan war pronounced "lost": Ashdown

In Iraq, we blame Iran for the Decider's continuous blunders. All of the ridiculously optimistic scenarios Rumsfeld and Cheney dreamed up would have come to pass If it weren't for Iran's "meddling", or so we are led to believe. In Afghanistan, however, we have no easy scapegoat for failure. What was supposed to be "liberation" followed by a happily-ever-after scene has turned into a quagmire where our puppet is widely ignored and powerless. The answer, of course, for Bush is that our lousy allies failed to step up to the plate.

This flies in the face of Bush's early statements that the U.S. would fight in Iraq and Afghanistan alone, if need be. Bush thumbed his nose at the U.N, world opinion, and pretty much everyone who had brains and moved ahead with his ill-conceived plans. He sold the Afghan mission to NATO as a "reconstruction" effort in a pacified nation, while bullying, bribing, and deceiving other nations to join in the Iraq mission. While most of those countries have since bailed on the Decider's "endless war" strategy in Iraq, the allies have largely stuck with Bush on Afghanistan. The problem is that the allies took Bush at his word and provided troop levels adequate for training the Afghan military and maintaining security for the "reconstruction". No, says, Bush. In for a penny, in for a pound. You were stupid enough to believe me in the first place, the Decider maintains, so send in more money and more troops, otherwise I'll look like I don't have a clue. And smile about it, too.


Afghanistan is lost, says Lord Ashdown


By Tom Coghlan
Last Updated: 3:33am BST 25/10/2007

Nato has "lost in Afghanistan" and its failure to bring stability there could provoke a regional sectarian war "on a grand scale", according to Lord Ashdown.

The former United Nations High Representative for Bosnia and Herzegovina delivered his dire prediction after being proposed as a new "super envoy" role in Afghanistan.

Lord Ashdown said: "We have lost, I think, and success is now unlikely."

The assessment will be considered extreme by some diplomats but timely by those pressing for more resources for Nato operations.

Lord Ashdown added: "I believe losing in Afghanistan is worse than losing in Iraq. It will mean that Pakistan will fall and it will have serious implications internally for the security of our own countries and will instigate a wider Shiite [Shia], Sunni regional war on a grand scale.

"Some people refer to the First and Second World Wars as European civil wars and I think a similar regional civil war could be initiated by this [failure] to match this magnitude."

Lord Ashdown, 66, the former leader of the Liberal Democrats, was speaking in advance of a Nato summit in the Dutch town of Noordwijk yesterday.

Britain and the US are infuriated by the lack of assistance granted by allies to those countries with forces operating in Afghanistan.


Monday, October 15, 2007

EU not going along with Bush on Iran

Aside from Germany and France, the EU isn't going along with Bush's rush to war with Iran. Arab states are reluctant as well, after seeing what a brilliant success Iraq was and how it impacted stability in the region. Britain has stated conditions for its participation, but the obvious question on the minds of European and Arab states regards the plan for what happens after Iran is bombed into bits. None of the American politicians, commanders, or neocons are talking about that little issue. Bush is so busy drumming up a new war, bullying countries into a "united front" against Iran, and trying to persuade the domestic audience that destroying Iran will allow us to "win" in Iraq that he hasn't really outlined that next step.

It is certainly within our ability, especially with aid from a few allies, to wage an air war against Iran. That is not the question, however. After we have bombed the industrial, political, and military infrastructure, killing civilians in the process, do we really believe that Iranians will appreciate the "favour"? If the plan is to impose a puppet government, then an occupation is necessary. If the plan is to cross our fingers and hope that an Israeli-friendly government spontaneously emerges from the rubble, then Bush is sadly deluded. The latter, however, given Bush's record, is probably the case.

A puppet government is fraught with problems, not the least being that this is exactly what the Iranians overthrew in the late '70s. The subsequent occupation would hardly be welcomed, and I think we all can see from the Iraq experience what the reconstruction would be like. We would create yet another failed state in the Middle East, put more domestic pressure on our Arab allies, and give Muslims worldwide yet another reason to hate the West. And this is the good scenario, because Israel may very well be struck itself. In any case, an occupation would leave us seriously overstretched and completely unable to respond to new threats, even with allied help. Britain is at the limit already, Germany is tied up in an increasingly-unpopular Afghan effort, and the French skills at occupation are what got us into Vietnam. We've already seen the force levels that the rest of the EU scrapes up, even under Bush's heavy pressure.

But, as I have said before, with Bush's decision-making process, the best possible outcome is the only likely outcome. It'll work out great, you'll see. They will welcome us with flowers and chocolates and eagerly give us their oil. And it won't cost hardly anything. Best of all, it will be the next president's problem.

At the very least, Turkey, Russia, and the Gulf States should be loudly inquiring what the Plan is, even if the EU is not.

Kouchner fails in bid to secure new sanctions against Tehran

Compiled by Daily Star staff
Tuesday, October 16, 2007

European Union nations failed to agree Monday on new sanctions against Iran to get Tehran to halt the part of its nuclear program that European and other nations fear could be used to make atomic weapons. An effort by French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner to get the 27-nation EU to push ahead with more sanctions - outside of the United Nations - failed to get widespread support, diplomats said.

But after an EU foreign ministers meeting, Kouchner said France might take additional punitive measures against Tehran on its own if the UN Security Council failed to take new measures before the end of the year.

"We could at that moment develop more individual, national sanctions," Kouchner said at a news conference.

It remains unclear if Russia or China will back additional economic or political sanctions at the UN.

Last month, the five permanent members of the UN Security Council - Britain, China, France, the United States and Russia - and Germany agreed with the support of the EU to hold off on a new sanctions resolution until November to allow for talks with Iran to continue.

The EU foreign ministers said in a statement that the EU "will consider what additional measures it might take" after that time.

Highlighting the division over how to get Iran to stop its uranium enrichment program, Javier Solana, the EU foreign and security affairs chief, told reporters: "It remains my mandate [from the UN] to continue working on the possibility of further sanctions. We are not thinking of sanctions right now."

The EU foreign ministers warned Iran that more sanctions would be considered if it failed to cooperate. New economic and political sanctions could include investment bans or scrapping export credit guarantees. The approach is being championed by Kouchner, who called on his EU counterparts last week to study new sanctions.

The EU, the US and others are concerned Iran's nuclear program may be geared toward creating fissile material for nuclear warheads. But Iran says its program is strictly for producing fuel for nuclear power plants.

British Foreign Secretary David Miliband said European trade with Iran had already fallen by about 37 percent in the year to May, signaling that the EU was serious about punishing Iran.

"The EU is playing its part in signaling very clearly to the Iranian regime that they need to abide by the successive UN Security Council resolutions," Miliband told reporters.

Saturday, October 13, 2007

Afghan situation is crumbling

Bush has always run the war in Afghanistan as an afterthought. Karzai got elected, the Taliban were defeated, and the rest is "happily ever after" in his fairy tale.

However, the Taliban are making a comeback, Karzai is unpopular and holds sway over only the capital, the US is increasingly turning to air power with the attendant civilian deaths, and the economy is a shambles. Attacks in the capital itself are increasing, and Karzai is running out if money to pay the civil servants and military. When you hand out government jobs to win favour, people generally expect to be paid as part of the deal.

Yes, in another one of Bush's "successes", the electricity is only on for a few hours a day, running water and sewage services are lacking, unemployment is high, and the government is corrupt and impotent. What country does that remind you of?

Bush has done a pretty good job convincing the world that the last thing you want is to be "liberated" by the U.S. What sane nation could possibly look at Iraq and Afghanistan and see a shining beacon of hope and liberty? The nations that are aiding us are involved in an expensive, bloody, and protracted war that Bush has bungled with his characteristic optimism and refusal to plan for or consider anything but the best possible outcome. Bush sold the Afghan mission to NATO as essentially one of rebuilding and providing support for the Afghan military to take over security. The reconstruction never happened, the warlords ignored Karzai, the American commanders ignored the Afghanis, and the Afghan military turned out to be inept, abusive, and corrupt. Now the Canadians and European allies are stuck facing the hard reality rather than Bush's optimistic fantasy.

Leadership is more than planning for the best and shrugging in the face of the worst.

Why Howard continues to have faith in Bush's "leadership" is beyond logic. The NATO allies who tried to win Bush's favour by participating in the mission have gained nothing but a disastrous mess, and now Bush will be out of office and leave them holding the bag.

Make no mistake: a stable and free Afghanistan is a worthy goal, but the Decider has turned the Afghan people against us, hopelessly bungled the effort, and drawn our allies into disaster.


full story from The Australian

Afghanistan 'is going down fast'


THE bloodshed in Afghanistan has reached levels not seen since the 2001 invasion as anger at bungling by an ineffective Government in Kabul and its foreign backers stokes support for the Taliban and other extremist groups.

The death of Trooper David Pearce underlines the rising dangers for Australia's 1000 soldiers in Afghanistan, most of them deployed in the Taliban's southern heartland -- a region some of Canberra's NATO allies consider too dangerous to fight in.

"This place can only go up or down, and it's going down fast, which is something the international community simply will not understand," said a security analyst who has been working in and out of Afghanistan for 30 years.

Almost six years after the hardline Islamist Taliban were ousted, their insurgency is gaining strength, fuelled by resentment at NATO bombing of civilians, billions of dollars of wasted aid, a lack of jobs and record crops of opium, the raw material for heroin.

The fighting is spreading to places once relatively safe, including the capital and the western and northern parts of the country.

"This is a guerilla movement but it does seem to have a real momentum behind it at the moment," said Joanna Nathan, an analyst for the International Crisis Group, a Brussels-based think tank headed by former foreign minister Gareth Evans.

In Kabul, where suicide bombs have killed almost 50 people in two weeks, foreigners are increasingly ordered into "lockdown" -- barred by employers from leaving their heavily protected compounds, often behind armed guards, razor wire and concrete blast walls.

"It's all now too close -- people are jumpy," said a UN official who has lived in the dusty, chaotic city ringed by mountains for four years.

The revitalised Taliban have switched tactics back to traditional guerilla warfare after attempts to take on foreign troops under separate NATO and US commands in pitched battles last year resulted in heavy casualties.

"They never evaporated into thin air. The Taliban were there, they have been there and they are here now," said government adviser and former minister Hamidullah Tarzi, carrying his trademark silver pistol.

"One reason for their renewed strength is that the people are more or less amenable to what they are doing and maybe some of the (NATO) bombardments have not been very wisely executed.

"That has helped the people get closer to the Taliban. They are dying and they feel that they are the same (as the Talibs) from the religious point of view."

Scores, possibly hundreds, of civilians have been killed in air strikes, mainly called in to support ground troops fighting rebels. The US-led NATO force, government officials and village leaders differ over details and numbers.

The Taliban-led insurgency is also being bolstered by drugs money -- the UN reported a 50per cent jump in this year's opium crop -- local and tribal disputes, and a lack of jobs.

With the wrecked economy and the dangers of getting crops to market, being a paid fighter for the Taliban is often the only way isolated Afghans can feed their families.

"It's important to emphasise: I don't think the Taliban themselves are wildly popular," Ms Nathan said.

"I don't think people want Taliban times back. It is a broad dissatisfaction with what is happening in the country now. I think the Taliban are very clever at appealing to people or groups that are locally disenfranchised or disempowered."

The Taliban shelter and train in neighbouring Pakistan -- once the group's main sponsor -- and President Pervez Musharraf faces international pressure to do more to stop them.

But the border, a random line in the sand drawn by British colonial rulers, passes through rugged, inhospitable territory and divides fiercely loyal ethnic groups who have never been fully controlled by any government for centuries. General Musharraf and NATO generals say stemming the flow of fighters is a tough task.

While some analysts say Tehran may be supporting the Taliban, most say no firm evidence has surfaced, rejecting Defence Minister Brendan Nelson's suggestion that the bomb that killed Trooper Pearce might have been made with supplies from Iran.

"He made that comment before any proper investigation had been done," said one soldier serving with NATO.

Much of the violence in Afghanistan is rooted in ordinary crime as the conflict erodes security and the rule of law and young men desperately seek money.

"Some of my friends don't have jobs. They just walk the streets. They talk among themselves of kidnapping a foreigner just to make some money," said "Sayed", a university business student who did not want his real name used.

Guns are easy to come by and drug addiction in the country that supplies almost all the world's opium is rising.

Unemployment is near 40 per cent and many Afghans live in appalling conditions, with no running water, sewerage or electricity. Roads are poor and in the capital -- crammed with tens of thousands of squatters camped in mud brick huts -- most middle-class residents are lucky to have power a few hours a day.

"People thought democracy would give them everything -- jobs, roads, electricity, water -- but nothing of this sort has happened," Mr Tarzi said.

"In fact, it's getting worse. There is a lack of jobs, a lack of employment. Overall, nothing much has been done.

"The money that has come in has not been productive in relation to industrialisation."

Confidence in the Afghan Government, the first democratically elected administration in three decades, is fading fast.

President Hamid Karzai, 49, the philosopher and former freedom fighter who has ruled this country since 2001, faces criticism for his failure to stamp out the Taliban and raise living standards.

Dubbed "the mayor of Kabul", because he rarely leaves his palace and his Government's writ barely extends beyond the capital, Mr Karzai is battling to balance the demands of the people who elected him with those of the foreign backers who prop up his Government.

He is also undermined by the fact his administration has control over only a small share of the billions of foreign aid dollars spent in his country.

Mr Karzai is not a popular leader, his critics say, accused of being ineffective and indecisive. In Kabul and many parts of the country his public portraits and banners are dwarfed and outnumbered by those of Ahmed Shah Masood, a popular mujaheddin leader assassinated by al-Qa'ida two days before the attacks on the US of September 11, 2001.

Domestically, Mr Karzai relies on a ragtag collection of former warlords, mujaheddin freedom fighters, ex-communists and others for support and is locked in a power struggle with his parliament. The President and the legislators -- a large number of whom are illiterate -- are coming to grips with democracy as much as with each other.

Mr Karzai has been criticised for failing to sack or prosecute corrupt officials and of handing out jobs as political favours to shore up support.

His Government has also failed to make serious inroads into the $3.3billion-a-year opium industry, which is tightly intertwined with the conflict and has been breaking production records almost every year since the Taliban's fall.

"The narcotics and insurgency feed into each other," said Ms Nathan.

Trooper Pearce, 41, a father of two, was killed when his convoy was hit by a roadside bomb in southern Uruzgan province, a major opium centre where Australian and Dutch troops are working on reconstruction.

Although it is a volatile area and a centre of Taliban support, the Dutch forces had forged close links with community leaders, cutting down the fighting, until a botched poppy eradication program by a US private security firm a few months ago, analysts say.

"Uruzgan was going OK until they went in with tractors and started ripping the poppy fields up," said the Kabul-based security analyst. "The Dutch had a good relationship with the people down there, the local leaders, but when they rip up your crop, what do you do? You grab your gun. They didn't even do that much damage to the crops in the end."

Australian troops make up a fraction of the 50,000 foreign forces in Afghanistan, and opinion is divided about how effective Canberra's contribution is.

"It's more symbolic," Mr Tarzi said. "I think (John) Howard is trying his best to see what (US President George W.) Bush is thinking, and he's going along that line.

"He should concentrate more on what his people, the Australians, think. He is just following Mr Bush."

But Australia is one of a small group of countries -- along with the US, Britain, Canada and The Netherlands -- willing to send its soldiers to where most of the fighting is.

Some European countries refuse to deploy their troops to the volatile south. Several members of the NATO-led force impose tough -- and, critics say, absurd -- limits, or caveats, on how their soldiers can be used, with some barring their units from fighting in the snow, above certain altitudes or at night.

Ms Nathan said: "It is incredibly important to have nations who are prepared to go south in a robust way, to go down there not laden by caveats; to go down there to do what is needed, when it's needed, how it's needed."

Thursday, October 11, 2007

U.N. tells Bush to prosecute contractors

Of course, Bush ignores the U.N. at every available opportunity, while expecting that organisation to pick up the pieces of his disaster in Iraq. Problems of child malnutrition, cholera, lack of water, etc. are all referred to the U.N, while its advice, warnings, and reports are ignored. This gives the lie to Bush's alleged "concern" over the Iraqi populace.


U.N. says prosecute Iraq contractors who commit crimes

11/10/2007

BAGHDAD (Reuters) - The United Nations called on the United States government on Thursday to ensure that any U.S. private contractors committing offences in Iraq are prosecuted.
The killing of 17 Iraqis in a shooting involving U.S. security firm Blackwater last month has created tensions between Baghdad and Washington and sparked calls for tighter controls on private contractors, who are immune from prosecution in Iraq.
In a new human rights report, the U.N. mission in Iraq urged "U.S. authorities to investigate reports of deaths caused by privately hired contractors and establish effective mechanisms for holding them accountable for where the circumstances surrounding the killings show no justifiable cause".
The report covers the April-June quarter and was not specifically referring to the September 16 incident involving Blackwater. However, it noted other reported shootings by private security contractors in the three-month period, including one by the U.S. firm on May 24.
"The U.S. government should take steps to ensure that offences committed in Iraq by all categories of U.S. contractor employees are subject to prosecution under the law," the report by the United Nations Assistance Mission for Iraq (UNAMI) said.
Many Iraqis see private security companies as little more than private armies which act with impunity. Iraqi authorities have accused Blackwater of "deliberately killing" the 17 Iraqis in last month's shooting, but the security firm says its guards responded lawfully to a threat against a convoy it was guarding.
This week, in a second reported incident involving foreign security guards, two women were shot dead when their vehicle ventured too close to an armed convoy. The Australian-owned, Dubai-based security firm Unity Resources Group said the vehicle had ignored repeated warnings to stop

Tuesday, October 09, 2007

With us or against us? Either way you die.

The War On Terror requires more than clichés and bombs. In fact, it's not really a "war" at all, but a law enforcement scenario.

Is this why our allies are deserting us? We have a buffoon for a leader who goes out of his way to divide the world into "with us" and "against us" camps, and he offers nothing but perpetual war to both sides. The nations of the world must either die fighting our wars or become the targets of our wars, and we are busily searching out new wars. Snarling Republicans demand obedience and submission from friend and foe alike; no carrots and only sticks.

Norm Coleman wrings his hands and hopes that Bush knows what he is doing, while nodding eagerly at each new war proposed. Even though Bush's policies boil down to "let's cross our fingers and hope that a miracle happens so that we don't look as incompetent as we really are", Coleman continues to back him. Yes, it's so sad that we have to bankrupt our country and destroy our military in endless war, but if we don't then we will be weak and our enemies will prevail, says Coleman. Having fewer allies and creating new enemies on a daily basis somehow makes us safer and stronger, and killing people makes them see how wonderful we are. If only we can kill enough people, the world will see that we are really looking out for their best interests. The nations of the world will thank us for bombing and occupying them, because they will get brand new puppet governments that will imprison them and torture their citizens if they don't thank us enough for "saving" them from governments that imprison and torture them.

Yes, Norm, if only the world would simply bend over and drop its pants, then we wouldn't need all of this distasteful war, would we?


War on terror seen fuelling al Qaeda

By Kate Kelland
LONDON (Reuters) - Six years after the September 11 attacks in the United States, the "war on terror" is failing and instead fuelling an increase in support for extremist Islamist movements, a British think-tank said on Monday.
A report by the Oxford Research Group (ORG) said a "fundamental re-think is required" if the global terrorist network is to be rendered ineffective.
"If the al Qaeda movement is to be countered, then the roots of its support must be understood and systematically undercut," said Paul Rogers, the report's author and professor of global peace studies at Bradford University in northern England.
"Combined with conventional policing and security measures, al Qaeda can be contained and minimised but this will require a change in policy at every level."
He described the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq as a "disastrous mistake" which had helped establish a "most valued jihadist combat training zone" for al Qaeda supporters.
The report -- Alternatives to the War on Terror -- recommended the immediate withdrawal of all foreign troops from Iraq coupled with intensive diplomatic engagement in the region, including with Iran and Syria.
In Afghanistan, Rogers also called for an immediate scaling down of military activities, an injection of more civil aid and negotiations with militia groups aimed at bringing them into the political process.
If such measures were adopted it would still take "at least 10 years to make up for the mistakes made since 9/11."
"Failure to make the necessary changes could result in the war on terror lasting decades," the report added.
Rogers also warned of a drift toward conflict with Iran.
"Going to war with Iran", he said, "will make matters far worse, playing directly into the hands of extreme elements and adding greatly to the violence across the region. Whatever the problems with Iran, war should be avoided at all costs."

All the Republicans have left is treason

I thought it relevant to point out that the right-wing in the U.S. is now completely out of ammunition.

For at least three years, Bush has called those opposed to the occupation of Iraq traitors and supporters of terrorism. The "treason card" has been badly overplayed, as we see in the MoveOn controversy and the flag lapel pin controversy. It is literally all that they have left. The right-wing has failed to convince even marginal numbers of Americans to believe in the occupation's ever-shifting rationale; now they can only insult us.

And the lapdogs of the right-wing have gone further than Bush. Dissent itself is seen by them as dangerous to our freedom. Opponents of the occupation have been routinely characterised as mentally ill, stupid, opportunistic, and cowardly. It hardly takes effort to point out that Republicans live in a delusional world where "victory" has been imminent for years and where every setback merely "proves" that the "enemy" is on the ropes. Or that isolated facts are conflated to apply to the entire situation in Iraq by little more than force of will on their part. The mere statement of an objective by senior military commanders is seen by Republicans as the accomplishment of that objective. Mixon says that his goal is to clear Al-Qaeda out of Diyala -- there, it's done. He said so, didn't he? Contorted numbers are placed in front of Republicans and they are eagerly lapped up without a hint of critical thought involved, because this is somehow "patriotic". Reports of "insurgents" being killed are celebrated as if nobody will take these people's place, much less thinking just how these people were defined as "insurgents". And Republicans are not at all opportunistic; they merely make obscene profits from the war. As far as "cowardly" goes, it is clear that so many of the architects and spinners of this occupation have never served in the military or in combat. Clinton was apaprently a "draft dodger" by virtue of his student deferment, but the vast majority of the right-wing media tools did the same thing. It's okay, though, because they are "patriotic".

So, with no solid facts to persuade anyone with, they moved to scare tactics. If we don't "win" in Iraq, then we apparently will be taken over by Muslims and forced to bow to the East, wear burquas, etc. Nobody bought that, even a little bit. Vietnam and the domino theory were paraded around, but people just chuckled. Every now and then, the "Iraqis voted" talking point gets some play, and the Republicans are reminded that the Sunnis boycotted that vote, the provincial elections aren't happening, and that those wonderful elections got the Iraqis an impotent and incompetent government.

So they are back to treason, the Swiss Army knife of political discourse. Uh-huh. The vast majority of the American people are communists who want to see America destroyed and replaced by a Sharia state....that'll play well. Let's try that one. Sure, 70% of the electorate are dirty traitors, but if they only change their minds and support Bush on everything then they will immediately become wonderful patriots. All of that treason stuff will be forgotten. Come on, we'll be your friend. Oh, and accept Jesus as your Lord and Saviour, of course. Um, and we'll need more police state powers to protect you. But other than that, it's a win-win. Trust us, you commie dirtbags... uh, I mean loyal citizen. Did we mention you should really send your kids off to Iraq, just to prove we can trust you? Well, we meant to. But then we can all be friends, and you'd like that, wouldn't you? Hey, we'll even give you this flag lapel pin.

Aside from the ability to prevent Democrats from doing anything, all Republicans can do is keep stuffing the government with droids based on their religious beliefs and political donations. Even this will come to an end in January '09, and there will be a lot of incompetent sycophants trying to fill think tank jobs. It's a suicide pact between the President and his Party. And whatever allies we have left, of course. How could this plan possibly fail?

'Progress' brings a lot more death somehow

I thought things were improving in Iraq -- at least, that's what the right-wing says.
So we surge 30,000 troops in a constantly shifting plan that is focused on Baghdad. The results for one day (today) are below. It's sad reading, and hardly seems like "normalcy", stability, or "progress". It instead seems a lot like a particularly nasty failed-state situation.

Five bombings, two mortar attacks, some shootings, and a new crop of corpses turned up on top of it all. And that's just in Baghdad. Thirteen others were killed in other parts of the occupied nation.

...and this is at least three months into the allegedly successful surge.

Baghdad

4 civilians were wounded in an IED explosion near Salahuddin square in Kadhemiyah neighborhood north Baghdad around 10,00 am.

A civilian was killed and 3 others wounded in an IED explosion near the Polish embassy in Al Arasat neighborhood downtown Baghdad around 2,00 pm.

4 civilians were killed and 10 others wounded in a parked car bomb explosion near the Technology University east Baghdad around 1,00 pm.

A civilian was killed and 5 others wounded near Al Khansaa police station in Kamaliyah neighborhood east Baghdad around 1,00 pm.

Three mortar shells targeted the buildings of the former general security agency in Baladiyat; number of casualties is unknown as Iraqi police said.

Four mortar shells slammed into the Green Zone today, Iraqi police said. No casualties were reported by the police.

A road side bomb targeted Iraqi army vehicle in Madaen today. No casualties were reported.

A road side bomb targeted an American military convoy causing no damage according to the Iraqi police.

Police found 7 dead bodies throughout Baghdad. 1 in Adhamiya, 1 in Ur, 1 in Amil, 1 in Ealam, 1 in Doura, 1 in Washash, 1 in Shuala.

Kirkuk

Gunmen killed a barber while he was in his car on the street between the villages of Ubaidyah and Hawdh 13 west of Kirkuk city today morning.

Salahuddin

A suicide car bomb exploded near a check point of the Iraqi police in Al Alam area east Tikrit city around 10,00 am. 2 civilians were killed and 4 policemen were wounded. A building for the ministry of agriculture was completely destroyed.

A suicide car bomb targeted the police station in Dijla town, 25 Kilometers south of Tikrit, today. Ten civilians were killed and 8 people were injured (including 3 policemen).

The Way Forward? Divide the Sadrists

Once again, the White House is playing a short-term strategy in Iraq. Also, in spite of Al-Qaeda being nearly the sole focus for the past five or six months, Bush is now pulling troops off the AQ manhunt to crack down on "bad" Sadrists.

We've already seen that the strategy with Sunni terrorists has been compromised. When Bush proposed the surge in January, the plan was to have the Iraqi Army disarm or exterminate the sectarian militias with the U.S. providing a support role. Since the Iraqi Army seems to be perpetually in "training", and since the job proved far more complicated and difficult than Bush imagined it would be (big shock there, eh?), the plan was changed. And of course, this change was presented as "what we planned all along".

The "change" was to divide the Sunni terrorists into "good" and "bad" categories. The "good" terrorists were those who would join with the American troops to wipe out their rivals, while quietly being allowed to continue with their shakedowns, extortion, executions, kidnappings, and black market dealings. With the "bad" terrorists on their heels, these opportunities opened up even more as the competition thinned. One can only wonder how the Iraqi Army will deal with these entrenched "good" terrorists who oppose the government when the Army tries to regain control of the country. One also wonders about the consequences when these "good" terrorists stop co-operating or getting what they want from the arrangement. We will then have militias that know our troops' movements, weaknesses, intelligence, and locations as well as possessing the arms that we supplied them with. Since the police and military are heavily infiltrated by the militias, these forces are likely to be a liability, as well.

It should be noted that this "change" in strategy was the major feature of the surge, if not the only real one.

So what to do about the Shia insurgency, then? Let's try the same brilliant approach. What could possibly go wrong?

Yes, we'll divide the Sadrists into "good" and "bad" categories, and use them to do the job that the pathetic Iraqi military can't possibly even begin to approach. What's in it for the Sadrists? Pretty much nothing, of course. Since the Mahdi Army has "laid low" for much of the surge (with Bush taking credit for the corresponding small drop in violence), they now remain probably the strongest Iraqi force. They have no motivation to turn on their fellow Sadrists, since they have emerged as the major player and icon of resistance to the occupation. If they can wait out Bush, they will be the winners. Petraeus needs them, not the other way around. So far, all Bush is offering them is their choice of a slow death or a quick death. If Bush prevails, the Mahdi Army will be neutered and merely be an honor guard for a puppet government; the slow death. If they resist or remain "un-cooperative", then the plan will be to wipe them out; the quick death.
However, we've already seen how effective the "extermination" option was against the militias during the surge. The fact that Petraeus has to use this "good" Sadrist vs. "bad" Sadrists strategy only proves that the U.S. can't defeat them quickly and neatly. Sure, they can bomb, shell, and strafe neighbourhoods wholesale, all the while warning that withdrawal would lead to a huge civilian massacre. That would look pretty stupid, though, if we are merely there to kill off the civilians before the militias can do it.

And meanwhile, the heat will be off Al-Qaeda. Our "awakening" buddies will get slammed. The "good" terrorists will get bolder and more demanding of us. The infrastructure, economy, and political situation will continue to whimper and collapse. It will become much, much, harder to fake statistics, and Iraq certainly won't look more peaceful or stable to the domestic audience. The Iraqi government will ask us to leave, and we will lose the very last illusion of Iraqi sovereignty. And the "drawdown" of troops will have to be put on hold.

But of course, to Bush, the best possible outcome is the only likely outcome. That has been his approach for more than four years now. He's been wrong, excruciatingly wrong, for that entire time. His ill-conceived attempt for a quick fix will backfire simply because he lacks the ability to even conceive of a Plan B, much less the wisdom to see anything but a military solution to everything. In the end, the U.S. will be discredited in the Middle East as a clumsy aggressor and unreliable ally.


full story

US-IRAQ: Unable to Defeat Mahdi Army, U.S. Hopes to Divide It
Analysis by Gareth Porter*

WASHINGTON, Oct 8 (IPS) - Although the U.S. military command's frequent assertions that the primary threat to U.S. forces in Iraq comes from Iranian meddling, its real problem is that Shiite cleric Moqtada al Sadr's Mahdi army is determined to end the occupation and is simply too big and too well entrenched to be weakened by military force.

The U.S. command began trying to enter into a political dialogue with Sadr's followers in early 2006 and now claims that such a dialogue has begun, according to a Sep. 12 article by Ned Parker of the Los Angeles Times.

And Gen. David Petraeus hinted in his Congressional testimony last month at the need to negotiate a deal with the Sadrists. Petraeus said it is impossible to "kill or capture" all the "Sadr militia" and likened the problem to that of dealing with the Sunni insurgents who have now been allowed to become local security forces in Sunni neighbourhoods.

But the George W. Bush administration is not prepared to make peace with the Mahdi army. Instead it believes it can somehow divide it if it applies military pressure while wooing what it calls "moderates" in the Sadr camp. Parker quoted an anonymous administration official last month as suggesting that there were Sadrists "who we think we might be able to work with".

A U.S. commander in Baghdad, Lt. Col. Patrick Frank, told Parker last month that Sadrist representatives initiated indirect talks in late July, which were followed by Sadr's announcement at the end of August of a six-month hiatus in fighting.

But the proposal Frank made to the Mahdi army at a meeting Sep. 3 with both Sunni and Shiite community leaders suggests that Petraeus is on a short leash in negotiating local peace agreements. Frank proposed that the Mahdi army cease attacks for two weeks, and that the U.S. military would "consider reducing their raids in the district".

That was an offer that might have been expected from a newly installed occupation army rather than from one that has already admitted that it cannot prevail by using force and is bound to become weaker in the near future.

The U.S. command intends to increase the military pressure on the Mahdi army. Last week, Odierno announced that more military resources were being shifted from fighting against al Qaeda to operations against Shiite militiamen.

The idea of managing the Mahdi army problem by dividing it between "extremist" and "moderate" elements was integrated into the original "surge" strategy. Even before Petraeus took command in Baghdad last January, he and his second in command, Gen. Ray Odierno, had already decided to avoid a full-fledged military campaign against the Mahdi army.

Instead they adopted a strategy of trying to reach agreement with some of Sadr's followers -- perhaps including Sadr himself -- while targeting selected elements in the Mahdi army.

"There are some extreme elements, and we will go after them," Odierno said at a Jan. 7, 2007 news conference.

The strategy of making deals with "moderates" while attacking the "extreme elements" seemed to be given credibility when Sadr signaled in early 2007 that he was ordering the Madhi army to lie low and even to cooperate with the new U.S. Baghdad security plan.

As Sudarsan Raghavan of the Washington Post reported last May, the U.S. command even released one of Sadr's aides, Salah al-Obaidi, from Camp Cropper after five months in detention, in the belief that he was a "moderate" who could help shift the balance within the Madhi army against those determined to carry out military resistance against U.S. forces.

But contrary to the self-serving assumptions of Petraeus and Odierno, Sadr was avoiding a confrontation with U.S. forces because he believed that the occupation had entered its final phase, in which the Bush administration would be forced to negotiate a settlement prior to military withdrawal, and that he had only to keep the Madhi army intact to emerge victorious over his Shiite rivals associated with the al-Hakim family.

Sadr aides told Raghavan that the Shiite cleric viewed the Democratic takeover of Congress and the struggle over Iraq policy as evidence that the final phase of the war had begun. His expression of willingness to cooperate with U.S. forces was aimed at positioning himself to be the main Iraqi interlocutor for the United States in the transition period.

Significantly, however, Sadr refused to deal with the Bush administration, believing that the Democrats would take a less bellicose posture toward his movement.

In any case, Sadr's hopes that the U.S. command might leave the Madhi army alone were dashed by the aggressiveness of U.S. sweeps in Sadr City and other Sadr strongholds in Baghdad, which began in January even before the arrival of additional troops. By mid-March, Sadr had already begun to backtrack on cooperation with the U.S. occupation troops.

Even as Sadr was returning to open opposition to the U.S. military, the U.S. command was pushing the line that the Mahdi army was "splintering" and that attacks on U.S. troops were coming only from "rogue" Mahdi army elements.

A U.S. military official in Washington told the Associated Press in late March that some Madhi army figures were "breaking away to attempt a more conciliatory approach to the Americans and the Iraqi government", while others were "moving in a more extremist direction".

The key individual in the alleged "extremist" breakaway faction was said to be Qais al-Khazali, who was Sadr's main spokesman in 2003 and 2004. Khazali and his brother, who had just been captured a few days before, were leaders of an Iraqi network which had apparently procured armour-piercing bombs and other weapons for the Madhi army.

In July, the U.S. military spokesman, Brig. Gen. Kevin Bergner, cited Khazali's alleged testimony under interrogation as supporting the command's argument that the Iranian Quds Force was creating a "Hezbollah-like" Shiite pro-Iranian force to do its bidding in Iraq.

But Maj. Gen. Michael Barbero, deputy director for Regional Operations at the Joint Staff in Washington, had obviously not been consulted about the Khazali breakaway ploy. In a press briefing on Mar. 30, Barbero said, "[W]e assess that there are links between these brothers and Sadr's organisation."

Bergner's portrayal of the Khazali organisation as detached from Sadr's movement was an example of how the U.S. command embraces interpretations that serve its political-military objectives, even when they don't reflect its own intelligence judgments.

When the U.S. command carried out arrests of Mahdi army commanders or cell leaders last spring and summer, they invariably referred to the targets as "rogue" Mahdi army. In one such operation, U.S. and Iraqi troops captured the commander of what were called a "high-level rogue Jaysh al-Mahdi commander" of an "assassination cell" of more than 100 members.

But according to a New York Times report Jul. 28, both the head of the Sadr office in Baghdad and a Sadrist cleric preaching in nearby Kufa condemned the raid and called for the release of the detainees, indicating that they are still part of the Madhi army.

The "rogue" designation apparently referred to their resistance to the occupation, not to their relationship to the Mahdi army command.

The U.S. command's line that Iran is using Hezbollah operatives to train Shiite militias that had broken away from Sadr was further discredited when Sadr admitted in an interview with The Independent in August that his organisation has "formal links" with Hezbollah, has sent fighters to Lebanon for training and would continue to do so.

*Gareth Porter is an historian and national security policy analyst. His latest book, "Perils of Dominance: Imbalance of Power and the Road to War in Vietnam", was published in June 2005.

Sunday, October 07, 2007

Canadian ministers push the Bush line on Afghanistan

Once again, decreasing stability in an occupied country is merely a sign that the insurgents are 'desperate'. The worse things look, the better they really are in Decider-speak.
Karzai basically only controls the capital, Kabul, as warlords refuse to pay tax receipts to the federal government or even enforce its dictates. Now the capital itself is being hit with suicide bombers on a regular basis and Karzai's support is evaporating. His position is maintained by foreign occupation forces, and he can't even pay the salaries of public employees.

And all of this somehow is proof that we are succeeding in Afghanistan. Certainly it has nothing to do with Bush's unwarranted optimism or the demands of the surge in Iraq. I mean, if Bush really had bungled Afghanistan, things would look bad there, wouldn't they? And all Bush sees is a 'desperate' enemy, so why worry?



Cabinet ministers trumpet Afghan mission on unannounced visit

LES PERREAUX

Canadian Press and Associated Press

October 6, 2007 at 6:07 PM EDT

KABUL, Afghanistan — Two newly shuffled Canadian cabinet ministers arrived in the Afghan capital just 30 minutes after another deadly suicide bomb attack Saturday, but that didn't daunt their persistent pitch that life is getting better for ordinary Afghans.

International Co-operation Minister Bev Oda and Foreign Affairs Minister Maxime Bernier landed in Kabul a short time after a suicide bomber struck on the main airport road, killing a U.S. soldier and four civilians. That attack came on the eve of the sixth anniversary of the U.S.-led invasion that ousted the Taliban from power.

Ms. Oda tried to reassure skeptical Afghan journalists that the shift by the insurgents to roadside and suicide bombings actually illustrated the success of the western security mission in Afghanistan.

Although such tactics have long racked southern Afghanistan, the fact that suicide bombings were now occurring in the capital showed that the Taliban were desperate because of their inability to win on the battlefield, Ms. Oda said.

Ms. Oda said she recently met senior Afghan officials and together they "identified that the difference in the challenge in Kandahar today can be seen as, to a certain extent, success."

Insurgents "are having to resort to other more desperate ways of trying to make their statements," she told a couple dozen Afghan reporters and a handful of Canadians.

Ms. Oda's reassurances come amid recent reports that the intensity of the insurgency is growing.

The United Nations' Department of Security and Safety has reported that the "security situation in Afghanistan is assessed by most analysts as having deteriorated at a constant rate through 2007."

The UN confirmed rebels were moving away from battlefield confrontations, but "the numbers of incidents are higher than comparable periods in 2006."

Instead of localized battles, bombings have been spreading across the country, the UN said.

Police have become favourite targets and civilians face mounting intimidation, the report added.

A count by The Associated Press showed about 5,100 people have died so far this year in insurgency related violence, about 1,000 more than all of 2006.

Most of the casualties have been insurgents reportedly killed in battle, according to numbers supplied by the Afghan government and western forces. The Taliban accuses the West of greatly exaggerating rebel losses.

Once relatively tranquil, Kabul has faced three major bomb attacks in a week. The bombings have claimed 37 lives, mostly civilians and police.

While Ms. Oda pointed to signs of progress like the 1,200 Canadian-sponsored wells being dug in the Kandahar region, Mr. Bernier added that "we can see the situation in Kandahar has improved."

When Ms. Oda turned the subject to record enrolment in Afghan schools, including enrolment among girls, one Afghan reporter asked about a recent Afghan human rights report that said children were beginning to stay home from school out of fear.

One more reason Afghanistan needs Canadian soldiers, Ms. Oda said, referring to the meeting she and Mr. Bernier held with Afghan President Hamid Karzai.

"He brought this up, and he explained why we have to stay in Afghanistan and we have to continue working in Afghanistan," Ms. Oda said.

Ms. Oda and Mr. Bernier also visited a restoration project in an ancient Kabul neighbourhood.

Ms. Oda announced Canada will contribute $3-million over three years to a project to dig out the neighbourhood that became a dump in the 1970s and now is buried under several metres of garbage.

But even here, the Afghans journalists indicated they were more concerned about public safety than Canadian-sponsored good works.

Mr. Bernier said he discussed the potential of negotiations between the Afghan government and the Taliban with Mr. Karzai.

"People who believe in a peaceful process will come into the discussion," Mr. Bernier said.

Mr. Karzai has said he is willing to talk to Taliban and other insurgent leaders any time.

However, Mr. Bernier said Kabul "won't discuss with people who believe in violence."

Canada's position on negotiations has not changed, Mr. Bernier added, saying the Taliban must first renounce violence.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper shuffled Ms. Oda and Mr. Bernier into their current cabinet posts in August.

Canada has some 2,500 troops in Afghanistan, the majority in the violent southern province of Kandahar. Seventy-one Canadian soldiers and one diplomat have died since the Canadian mission in Afghanistan began in 2002.

Turkey backs Syria over Israeli incursion

It's becoming increasingly clear that we will see attacks on Syria and Iran before Bush leaves office. A month ago, Israeli planes crossed over Turkish airspace in order to bomb Syria. My speculation is that Israel will carry out the Syrian part of this ill-conceived air war, with the U.S. doing its part by demolishing Iran's military and industrial infrastructure.

Now our ally, Turkey, is refusing to go along with Bush's "plan". With Islamists gaining hugely in the last Turkish elections, with Turkey's long-standing bid to join the EU perpetually stalled, and with the U.S.-created Kurd state becoming a haven for the PKK, Turkey is apparently recoiling from the possibility of an American hegemony in the Middle East.

Turkish public opinion towards the U.S. has hit a new low as Bush beats the drum for a huge regional war in the Middle East, probably in line with fundamentalist end-times philosophy.

Bush's vision for the Middle East puts Israel on top, with all other nations in the region bowing to Israel's interests. It also envisions non-democratic "client states", such as the UAE, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia, who accede to our demands promptly and submissively. There is also room for "puppet" governments in Iraq and Iran that would use fraudulent elections (along the Egyptian model) to advance U.S. (i.e. Israel's) interests. Repressive governments would eliminate opposition while the White House wrings its hands in mock concern, and Israel would continue to expand, with illegal settlements steadily gobbling up the neighbour's territory. How could this plan possibly fail?


full story

Turkey assures Syria on Israeli strike

By Khaled Yacoub Oweis
DAMASCUS (Reuters) - Turkey assured the Damascus government on Sunday it would not let Israel use its airspace to strike Syria after an Israeli raid heightened tension in the Middle East.
Diplomats said at least four Israeli planes flew in attack formation along the Syrian-Turkish border before striking deep into Syria on Sept 6. Syria and Israel have given little information on the target.
"Turkey will not let Turkish territory or airspace be used in any activity that could harm the security or safety of Syria," Foreign Minister Ali Babacan said after meeting Syrian President Bashar al-Assad in Damascus.
Babacan said he chose Syria as his first destination abroad since being named foreign minister in August to underline the importance of maintaining strong Turkish-Syrian ties. He is due to visit Israel next.
The minister, a member of the Islamist-rooted AK party, repeated Turkey's assertions that Ankara had no prior knowledge of the Israeli raid, which Assad said had targeted an unused building linked to the Syrian military.
"I hope that during my visit to Israel to be given answers and clarifications about this issue," Babacan said. "The region is at a very dangerous and sensitive stage. We always urge all parties to reach solutions through dialogue and peaceful means."
Turkey and Syria have built closer security and economic ties in recent years despite persisting water disputes and past Syrian support for Kurdish rebels.
Ankara, a member of North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, also has good ties with Israel and allows Israeli planes to train on its territory, according to diplomats in Damascus.
Israel confirmed this month that it had carried out an air strike on Syria. Syrian officials have not ruled out the possibility of another Israeli raid.
Several U.S. officials have linked the raid to apparent Israeli suspicions of secret nuclear cooperation between Damascus and North Korea. Diplomats suggested the intended target may have involved missiles supplied by North Korea, playing down reports of a nuclear link.
The raid came after speculation that Syria and Israel could resume peace talks that collapsed in 2000 over the scope of an Israeli withdrawal from the Golan Heights, a plateau which Israel occupied in 1967.
Syria has called for the Golan issue to be on the agenda of a peace conference in November sponsored by the United States, Israel's chief ally. Babacan said the Golan should be part of any Middle East settlement.
"Syria's participation is necessary to reach solutions," he said. "The peace process must proceed along all tracks, including the Syrian one."


Thursday, October 04, 2007

House requires Bush to report on withdrawal from Iraq

Republicans keep snickering that Democrats can't force Bush to withdraw from Iraq, but the joke is on them. By forcing another report in December, and another three before the elections, Bush has to keep on coming up with new "good news" to give to an increasingly sceptical Congress and a public that no longer believes anything he says.

Meanwhile, Republicans will be forced to keep defending the occupation on a regular basis right up to the election. With only one-third of the country supporting the Decider's non-plan in Iraq (and with strong support only half that number), the Republicans have been forced into making this their war.
The American public is tired of 'progress' that somehow only means we have to stay in Iraq even longer. Iraq is still a country with an impotent government (one that increasingly looks like it isn't even sovereign at all), where "only" 300 a month are being killed in sectarian violence, where our new tribal terrorist "allies" are turning up dead, where mayors are being killed, and where our British allies are throwing in the towel to fight the "other war". When the elections come around, it will have been five years that we have been there. Five years to get back to the levels of violence that 'warranted' the surge in the first place. Nearly four of those years were filled with smiley, upbeat assessments of false progress. Now we have grim assessments of false progress. This is what Republicans will bring to the '08 elections, along with snarling accusations of treason for the 70% of the electorate who have given up on the Decider's scheme. Oh, and a new war with Iran and/or Syria to keep the defence contractors happy and the bill for the mess astronomical.

The Democrats will be the primary political beneficiary of the Republican "hang tough" policy, so they can snicker all they want.

U.S. House requires Bush to present plans on eventual troop withdrawal from Iraq

The U.S. House of Representatives on Tuesday voted overwhelmingly to require President George W. Bush to present plans on eventual withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq.

By a vote of 377 to 46, the House approved the bill requiring President Bush to report to Congress in 60 days, and every 90 days thereafter, on the status of its redeployment plans in Iraq.

The Democratic-led House has passed a sheaf of bills calling for a pullback from Iraq, but without the two-thirds majority required to override a presidential veto.

As the first compromise made on the Democrats-proposed bill concerning the war policy, Republicans said they agreed to back it up because it encourages Pentagon contingency planning already under way and does not mandate troop withdrawals.

However, Congress is still about to witness another battle with the White House when it votes on the government's request for emergency Iraq funding of 190 billion U.S. dollars.

Earlier in the day, three senior House Democrats proposed a plan to raise taxes to pay for the bill of 150 billion dollars for the war in Iraq and Afghanistan in 2008.

"If this war is important enough to fight, then it ought to be important enough to pay for," said David Obey, chairman of the House Appropriations Committee who sponsored the plan.

"By putting together this bill we hope people will stop ignoring what this war is costing American taxpayers and call the president's bluff on fiscal responsibility," he said.

The tax plan requires low- and middle-income taxpayers to add 2 percent and wealthier people add a 12 to 15 percent to their tax bill, which incurred opposition from Democrat House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Republican congressmen.

"Just as I have opposed the war from the outset... I am opposed to a war surtax," she said.

The war in Iraq is costing the United States about 10 billion dollars a month, while Afghanistan and other missions run about 2 billion dollars a month, according to official statistics.

Source: Xinhua

Blackwater summary

Since this "investigation" seems to have hit a bit of dead-end, below is a summary of the salient points:

full story

Wounded Iraqis: 'No one did anything' to provoke Blackwater

BAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) -- It was last Sunday in western Baghdad. Helicopters circled overhead while armed guards, privately hired by the U.S. government, were conducting an ordinary mission to protect U.S. State Department employees.
But within minutes there was an explosion, a hail of gunfire, and bodies in the streets.
The Iraqi Interior Ministry says at least 10 Iraqis were killed and 10 wounded. Another government spokesman, Ali al-Dabbagh, told CNN that at least 20 people died, with 35 wounded.
So what happened on that day on a square in the Mansour district of Baghdad?
It depends on whom you ask.
Blackwater USA, the private security firm at the center of the controversy, says its employees simply defended themselves against armed attackers.
Two men hospitalized with gunshot wounds disagree. They say the guards fired on people for no reason.
Hasan Jaber Salman lies in Yarmouk Hospital, bandages covering gunshot wounds in his back.
Salman says he is a lawyer who was headed from a courthouse to the Ministry of Justice when he found his route blocked by four armored Blackwater SUVs.
The roadblock soon caused a traffic snarl, so armed Blackwater guards began waving at the drivers, telling them to turn around and leave the area.
"So we turned back, and as we turned back they opened fire at all cars from behind," Salman said. "All my injuries, the bullets are in my back.
"Within two minutes the security force arrived in planes -- part of the security company Blackwater. They started firing randomly at all citizens."
Blackwater, in a statement issued after the incident, denied that gunfire came from aircraft. "The helicopters providing aerial support never fired weapons," it said.
The firm also said its employees "acted lawfully and appropriately in response to a hostile attack."
But Salman claims the attack was unprovoked.
"No one fired at them, they were not attacked by gunmen, they were not targeted by an explosion," he said.
The firing continued until Salman's car crashed into a police checkpoint and flipped over, he said, adding that eight bullets struck his car and four struck him.
"My left shoulder is broken ... and my arm is broken. I had a surgery. ... They opened up my stomach," he said. "I swear to God no one did anything to them at all."
The lawyer said he intends to sue Blackwater, which he already did in 2005 after his son was involved in a similar incident outside al-Muthana Air Base near Baghdad's international airport. That lawsuit has not yet been resolved, he said.
Laborer Abul-Raheem Amir said he was on his way to a job when the minibus he was in got caught in a traffic jam caused by an explosion.
"A security company called Blackwater, they got out and kept on firing randomly at people, starting with the people walking or working the street -- even the traffic policeman, even the people who work in the area," Amir said.
"People at first thought we were safe in the minibus, but when they realized they were not, they started getting out and went to other places to save themselves," he recounted. "Unfortunately that did not work. As they got out, people were shot and killed."
He said he tried to make a run for it after the driver and two women next to him on the minibus were shot.
"I ran about 50 meters [about 55 yards] and then was shot, the first bullet. Still I kept running, but the second bullet dropped me to the ground. ... It broke my bones, and the third one made me start crawling."
Some people helped get him off the street and away from the carnage. The shooting lasted for about a half-hour, and there were some 30 bodies in the street, he said.
"I remember people strewn on the streets, children, elderly, young men, elderly women. ... The street turned into the street of the dead, a graveyard," he said.
"There was nothing I could do. Every man was for himself."
Amir wonders what the Blackwater employees were thinking.
"Is this some kind of a show of force for them to flex their muscles?" he said. "Are they doing this to us, the victims, so they can advertise and promote their abilities through the Western media? ... Is their mission to protect one person by killing 10 unarmed people? And if they are protecting two people, then they shoot 100 unarmed people. ... Is this Vietnam? ...
"Enough, enough," he said. "Enough of all that's happening. God's fury is coming. Enough of this. Enough."
CNN's Aneesh Raman and Jomana Karadsheh contributed to this report.

The shooting went on for about a half-hour. That's a long time to keep shooting, expecially if nobody is shooting back at you. Not a single Blackwater mercenary was even slightly injured, which is pretty odd if they were "fighting for their lives".

Not to worry, though. The State Department 'investigated' the matter, and issued a report:

full story

Blackwater contractor wrote government report on incident

BAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) -- The State Department's initial report of last month's incident in which Blackwater guards were accused of killing Iraqi civilians was written by a Blackwater contractor working in the embassy security detail, according to government and industry sources.

A source involved in diplomatic security at the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad said a Blackwater contractor, Darren Hanner, drafted the two-page "spot report" on the letterhead of the Bureau of Diplomatic Security for the embassy's Tactical Operations Center.
That office -- which tracks and monitors all incidents and movements involving diplomatic security missions -- has outsourced positions to Blackwater and another private firm, the embassy source said.
A highly placed industry source said that Hanner, who was listed on the report as the TOC watch officer, was working for Blackwater at the time the report was written, just after the September 16 incident occurred. He was to rotate out of Iraq this past week, the source said.
The man who approved the report was Ricardo Colon, whom the embassy source identified as the embassy's deputy regional security officer. A State Department source confirmed a Ricardo Colon Cifredo works for the State Department in Iraq.
The deadly incident produced an outcry in Iraq and raised questions about the accountability of foreign security contractors in Iraq, who, under an order laid down by the U.S.-led occupation government, are not subject to Iraqi law for actions taken within their contracts.
Anne Tyrrell, a spokeswoman for Blackwater, emphasized that the State Department is doing its own investigation into the incident.
The FBI is sending a team of agents to assist the U.S. investigation at the State Department's request, FBI spokesman Richard Kolko said Monday.
Blackwater -- which provides security to U.S. diplomats -- says its employees responded properly to an insurgent attack on a convoy. The State Department "spot report" underscores that scenario and doesn't mention civilian casualties.
However, those accounts are at odds with what the Iraqis are saying.
A senior Iraqi National Police official participating in the Iraqi governmental probe of the shooting said the Blackwater gunfire was unprovoked and the guards fired randomly, killing several civilians and wounding others.

Tom Casey, deputy State Department spokesman, noted that a spot report "is a first-blush account of those on the scene" and that the "report has no standing whatsoever."
"It was not intended to be used as an analysis, investigation, review or any detailed assessment of the situation," Casey said. "To assert that (it is) is untrue," Casey said.
The embassy source said after the spot report was completed and approved, a State Department agent took sworn statements from the participants in the shooting.
The senior Iraqi police officer said that Blackwater team members were questioned by Iraqi police immediately after the incident and initially said they opened fire in response to a mortar attack. However, he said, they then changed their story at least twice during the 90 minutes they were held.

So we outsourced the initial investigation to Blackwater? And the initial investigation didn't say a word about civilian casualties? And the mercenaries changed their story at least twice before settling on one that they were willing to swear to? And nothing seems wrong with this picture to the Bush Administration. It seems a lot like the "spot report" was the lie that Blackwater got all of their guys to agree to, which explains why the State Department waited until after Blackwater wrote it before they asked the mercenaries to swear to their version.