How wrong they were.
In the debate, Thompson limited himself to a few snide remarks aimed at Ron Paul and some nebulously vague positions. This Hero of the punditry is now polling behind Ron Paul, who was dismissed as a nut. He rumbled and mumbled as if the whole discussion was a lot of "tomfoolery". And Giuliani, whose bold vision of war against the Islamic World was supposed to light the nation on fire with fear and hatred, is tanking and nearly broke. Somebody should tell the guy that 9/11 was six years ago, and will be seven years old by the time the election comes around. Besides, the Katrina response stands out much more vividly in people's minds as the way Republicans handle major disasters.
The major points:
- The GWOT as the pre-eminent challenge of the century. It simply isn't, and even if it were, military force cannot crush something as stateless as an idea. We cannot promote democracy and freedom in the Islamic world and simultaneously require draconian police-state suppression in those nations. Further, forcing puppet regimes to follow our dictates does not make us appear attractive or even powerful to the Islamic world; it makes appear as a foreign oppressor. We offer no hope or development to the common person beyond the freedom from radical jihadists, and that path is paved with repression and economic collapse. Immediately after 9/11 we had the support of the global community to do what needed to be done to marginalise the radical islamists. We blew it with arrogance and an invasion that had nothing to do with crushing radical Islam. We came out with a policy that said we are justified in invading any country that not only posed a threat to our security, but that had the potential to pose a threat. That covers pretty much the whole world, since any country that has a brewery can produce biological weapons, any country that has a laboratory on the level of the average high-school can produce a chemical weapon, and virtually any country can get their hands on enough radioactive material to create a dirty bomb. So we essentially told the world that if you don't play by our rules, you will get crushed.
- Private health insurance as the real solution. Yeah, this one's a winner. The way to solve the problem of so many people without health insurance and so many employers simply not offering it is to require people to buy it. We could also solve the problem of inadequate mass transit systems by requiring people to buy cars. The argument that we have the best health care in the world is like pointing to the number of Bentleys in a state and saying they have the best cars in the world. It's simply irrelevant. The number of shiny, high-tech devices in your city's hospital doesn't really matter if you can't afford the care. The vast majority of people don't need super-expensive, high-tech care, anyway. They need relatively low-tech testing, monitoring, and medication. An early diagnosis of diabetes, for example, is far better than dealing with an amputation down the road and facing catastrophic expenses and a super-high-tech artificial limb. The truth is that the private sector has dropped the ball by creating so many low-wage jobs without medical coverage, or only catastrophic coverage. For companies that do provide medical coverage, the biggest dis-incentive to hire new people is the cost of medical coverage. Universal single-payer health care would be the biggest single thing the government could do to increase employment. Medical savings accounts are also a joke. You put your own money into an account that can be used for medical expenses. Wow, why didn't we think of that before? It differs from putting your own money into a regular old savings account that can be used for anything because the MSA uses pre-tax dollars. Oooh, that makes a big difference. The more money you put in, the lower your taxable income. Or put differently, the more money you can afford to put in, the less taxes you pay. This is so out of touch with the average working family living paycheck to paycheck and drowning in debt that it is pathetic. If a family could afford to pay their own medical bills without insurance, they would not be facing bankruptcy due to catastrophic health care costs. The idea of "shopping around" is also particularly lame. Let's say you've had a sore throat for a week. It may be strep throat, but you don't know. So you spend a few hours shopping around for the cheapest office visit, mostly sitting on hold. Then you find out you need a throat culture. Start shopping around for the cheapest throat culture, and pay for another office visit that costs more than Dr. Cheapo where you went first. Then you find out that you do have strep throat, and you need penicillin. Shop around again, sitting on hold trying to quote various pharmacies. In the meantime, you've exposed your family and co-workers to strep throat over the past week. More expenses all around. The Republican idea that all of this "shopping around" could be done online is ludicrous, since you don't know what you will need beforehand, and since there are different prices at the same place for different situations.
- You are screaming for tax cuts. Nobody likes paying taxes, but people have learned that federal tax cuts just get pushed down the pipe into state and local taxes and fees. You end up paying the same either way. Even worse, you now have fragmented services and severe cuts in local budgets. The counties that have a higher tax base get good roads, the streets get plowed and cleaned on time, the schools get better teachers and facilities, the libraries are actually open, and so forth. The poorer counties get screwed. The fees for things like licence plates, building permits, birth certificates, etc. go way, way up. It's also harder to reach anyone, and the people you do reach are overwhelmed due to staff cutbacks. Besides, polls show that taxation is way down on the list of concerns for voters. Tax cuts have been great for the wealthy, but they have not done their part and invested their new money in jobs and growth. Instead, it's gone into off-shoring your job away and speculating on a real-estate bubble. Likewise, the Reagan tax cuts were squandered on forced leveraged buyouts that made companies weaker and produced mass layoffs. The rich take the money and run, and leave you to face the consequences. The Republicans try to counter this by stretching the definition of "rich". Those families making $250,000 or more are going to suffer, so you don't want the repeal of the Bush tax cuts. Again, they are in their own little world on this. That's not the average person, and someone making a quarter million can afford another thousand in taxes over a year ($84 a month - gasp!). It's those making millions a year that will see big increases. Boo-hoo.
- Send the Mexicans home. Okay, we're going to round up 12 million illegal immigrants and send them home, or so Romney says. How do we know who they are? Look in the phone directory under "illegal immigrant"? First, we require a national ID card, comrade. Fingerprints, biometric scans, background checks, the works. That won't cost any money. And considering this is the government that couldn't handle the demand for passports for people going on their winter Caribbean vacation, I wonder how something on this massive a scale would work out. But let's not get bogged down in reality. Now we have to check everyone's papers to determine if they are illegal or not. House-to-house Gestapo searches? Pre-employment checks? Prospective employers are going to hold those without proper papers? Nobody works in the underground economy, do they? It's silly. But we also have to build a Berlin Wall on the Mexican border, which somehow also is extremely cheap, and we have to keep it manned and maintained. A huge new Border Patrol won't cost any money, either, I guess. With our lax port security, somehow no immigrants will come in cargo ships or in small boats, much like drug smugglers use. And nobody in our massive Immigration Gestapo will take bribes. Short of an incredibly expensive, completely unaccountable, and supremely intrusive police state, this cannot possibly work. What none of the Republican candidates addressed was that legal immigration has ridiculously huge barriers. For example, one must own a house. It's designed to allow only those people who don't have an overwhelming need to immigrate to come here legally. Opening up the legal route to immigration is what is needed, but this doesn't play well with the fear of brown-skinned people that Republicans prey on.
- "Victory" in Iraq. This is the stupidest yet. The American people are supposedly so impressed that the violence has now come down to levels that were intolerable before the surge that they will embrace the Republican vision of Eternal War as wise and essential. Most people bought in to Iraq as a quick, easy war. We replace Saddam, a new government takes over, and everyone lives happily ever after. Sure, Bush never specifically promised that, but that was how people thought it would go down. Five years in, the majority now think going into Iraq was a mistake, and only a slim majority think we can "win", whatever that means. Petraeus is saying ten more years before Iraq is what most people would consider to be "stable". The surge was supposed to wrap things up, at least in the public's mind. It didn't. The costs are huge, and we've borrowed our way into deep debt to pay for an occupation that really has nothing to do with the GWOT. Al-Qaeda didn't bite on the idea that all of the world's terrorists would flock to Iraq and wait in line for us to kill them. Instead we got into a civil war and increased Iran's influence over the country by eliminating their greatest foe. It's actually been a great recruiting tool for the jihadists. Even worse, it's stretched our military so thin that we can't effectively deal with new threats that really do involve radical jihadists. Afghanistan is stalled, and Pakistan is unravelling. The world is chuckling at us behind our backs, and our allies are backing away from us. China and Russia are getting bolder and stronger and richer. Foreign leaders that once backed Bush have been replaced, and commitments have been cut. Our currency is declining due to the massive debts from the occupation. The GWOT is not suitable for a military solution. It's really more of a law-enforcement scenario. But you don't get to shovel obscene amounts of money into defence contractors with a law-enforcement scenario, and you don't get to play the "Bring 'Em On!" tough guy with that kind of approach, either. But when you blow it, you look worse than you did before. This issue is only a winner with those people who would have voted for the Bush agenda already. It's a lateral move at best.
So these are the thoughts that went through my mind as I came across the post on the Daily Kos below. As the Republicans splinter and fight to the death over who will be the one to lose the election in November, the Democrats essentially only differ on style and image, not policy. The Republicans have not been rewarded with large campaign contributions by the fickle wealthy who cashed in on their agenda. The Christian fundamentalists no longer "know their place". Republican legislators have literally staked their careers on a Party running on bluff and fumes. Candidates that based their positions on loyalty to the Bush agenda are being given a run for their money from "nuts" like Ron Paul. In New Hampshire, Obama attracted an overflow crowd of well over 3000, while redstate.com brags about a "packed" crowd of 750 that comes to see Romney. Democrats turned out about 2 to 1 over Republicans for the primary in Iowa. Republican candidates are skipping whole states in order to preserve precious funds, and the Right is doing its best to put a brave face on it. Just as they staked the farm on Iraq, they have staked everything on Hillary being the Democratic nominee, and at this point she doesn't seem that "inevitable". Without Clinton-hatred, the Right would have little in their arsenal. The race card and the liberal epithet just don't play like they did 1994, which is the frame that the GOP (and the media pundits) seems to be permanently frozen into. And we still have a long time for Bush to say and do stupid things, with the Republicans forced to stand by him. Since the GOP candidates are essentially offering nothing more than the continuation of the Bush Agenda, it's relevant to note that Bush's low popularity numbers among Independents are remarkably close to those among Democrats. The GOP has, for all practical purposes, driven away the moderates from their Party in favour of an ideologically "pure" base, and they cannot afford any splintering of that base whatsoever.
We still have to see how Super Tuesday turns out before any solid trend can be discerned, and the South may hold some surprises, but for now the coments below seem very insightful:
from The Daily Kos:
We've seen from the polls that independents are tending D this time around. They care more about Dem issues and reflect the same anxieties about the economy and health care, as well as agree that we need to get out of the mistake known as Iraq (surge or no surge). And we know, only too well, in a way the press does not acknowledge, that the (34%) Republican base is far from a majority in this country. In fact, we know from these numbers that conservatism as a philosophy and the Republicans as a party, have failed. This came about because of the failure in the WH known as George W Bush, the most consistently unpopular President in post-WWII polling history. The country doesn't want lock-step politicians that support that guy. The voters are just holding their breath waiting for him to go away, and not a day too soon.
3 comments:
Todd
I don't know what happened because I commented on this, this morning. People have had enough of the lying, underhanded, corruptive, repugs. From here on in it is the Democrats game unless Bush declares martial order as his wars and other excuses mount. I am still hoping there even are elections.
I just wanted to let you know I just put you on my blogroll so you will be hearing from me more often. Take care!
This is what Mcgovern had to say. He doesn't know how right he is or why!
George McGovern, the Democratic Party's 1972 nominee for president, is calling on Congress to impeach President Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney. And in an editorial in Sunday's Washington Post, McGovern writes the case for impeaching the current president is "far stronger" than the case made against former President Richard Nixon — the man who soundly defeated McGovern in the general election match up. "Bush and Cheney are clearly guilty of numerous impeachable offenses," McGovern writes. "They have repeatedly violated the Constitution. They have transgressed national and international law. They have lied to the American people time after time.
"Their conduct and their barbaric policies have reduced our beloved country to a historic low in the eyes of people around the world," he continued. McGovern, a former three-term senator who ran for president on a fiercely anti-war platform, also called the administration's policy in Iraq a "a murderous, illegal, nonsensical war" in violation of international law. "This reckless disregard for life and property, as well as constitutional law, has been accompanied by the abuse of prisoners, including systematic torture, in direct violation of the Geneva Conventions of 1949," he added. But McGovern acknowledged there is little bipartisan support for an impeachment effort, blaming "superficial partisanship" among Republicans, and a "a lack of courage and statesmanship on the part of too many Democratic politicians."
The Republicans are screwed pretty much every which way they turn and will most likely be beaten by any of the Democrats. That's my opinion. But then I never thought the American public would be dumb enough to elect Bush for a second term so what do I know.
As usual a great commentary on the current situation. Thanks
Post a Comment